News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by InsideOutSanta on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @03:51AM (#43702653)
One of the benefits a working democracy conveys to its citizens is that they largely don't have to care about politics. They can trust that government action is relatively consistent over time, that laws will be enforced fairly enough, that their property will be protected to a reasonable degree, that the currency will be reasonably stable, that the roads will be maintained, that some public transport will be available, that sudden wars won't erupt around them, and so on.

That's what makes working democracies successful. But it seems that it also makes democracies vulnerable because people don't realize they have these benefits because they live in a working democracy. They start to think these benefits have nothing to do with politics and are just the way things are, like the laws of nature.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by demosito666 on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @04:20AM (#43702876)
Interestingly, I believe that the reality is exactly the opposite: on the political regimes' spectrum of democratic -> authoritarian -> totalitarian only the middle one doesn't require people's participation. Both democracy and totalitarism need to be actively maintained by significant part of the population, otherwise they converge to the "natural" state of things - authoritarian order. None of the stuff you listed (fair laws, property rights, etc.) occur naturally once it has been set up at some point in past. That's why they talk about "checks and balances" all the time, and they are impossible without active participation.
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by InsideOutSanta on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @05:51AM (#43703420)
Yeah, I should have phrased this better. When I said that

>citizens (...) largely don't have to care about politics

I didn't mean that it wasn't harmful if they didn't care; I meant that there was no clear, immediate incentive.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by Braxton1980 on Thursday April 17, 2025 @08:34AM (#43715883)
>I meant that there was no clear, immediate incentive.

What about tariffs, that causes price increased. What about changes to the law, like congestion pricing in NYC

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by pjc50 on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @04:28AM (#43702925)
What distinction are you making between authoritarian and totalitarian here?
Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by demosito666 on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @05:01AM (#43703138)
I think the most significant distinction is exactly that:

Authoritarian - leaves people alone in general as long as they stay out of politics. Examples: 90% of regimes throughout human history. Almost all post-soviet countries, almost all of Middle East and Africa, Singapore, etc.

Totalitarian - forces people into actively participating in leader's political goals and penetrates the daily life. North Korea, USSR, Nazi Germany, Fascist Italy.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by Braxton1980 on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @08:30AM (#43704554)
>Authoritarian - leaves people alone in general as long as they stay out of politics.

Directly, yes, but their policies still affect people.

For example, if an authoritarian leaders enacts economic decisions that damage the economy everyone is affected.

If I pay more for goods and services due to Tariffs aren't I being forced to participate in the leader's political goals?

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by jowea on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @10:06AM (#43705771)
The distinction is fuzzy, but I think what is meant here is more directly political. In a totalitarian system, it is considered important for everyone to know and openly and regularly support state ideology with words and deeds. In the least totalitarian but authoritarian system, the state just wants apathy and obedience from its citizenry.

So it would be totalitarian leaning for a leader to make a speech (watching is mandatory btw) saying that buying foreign is anti-patriotic and generating social censure, in addition to the tariffs, for people seen with foreign goods.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by Braxton1980 on Thursday April 17, 2025 @08:08AM (#43715608)
>it is considered important for everyone to know and openly and regularly support state ideology with words and deeds.

People literally do this on social media and they aren't even being forced.

As for the remainder, I do see the forced part but I'm not sure of how meaningful that is. If I don't agree with Trump but I'm forced to watch his speeches what does this do?

As for supporting state ideology, while not forced, there are hats, bumper stickers, flags to identify yourself

Imagine Trump forced everyone to wear his MAGA hat. What effect does it have? I don't think being forced to do this and that has much value

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by jowea on Thursday April 17, 2025 @02:45PM (#43720662)
> People literally do this on social media and they aren't even being forced.

I think applying the authoritarian-totalitarian distinction in a democracy gets weird because democracies like totalitarian systems but unlike the archetypal authoritarian system expect the average person to engage in politics. So it's not a straight spectrum from democracy to totalitarian with autocracy in the middle.

And if someone forces everyone to wear their symbols, then it becomes obvious who the open dissenters are, and it becomes hard to tell who is neutral, who is enthusiastic, and who is silently dissenting, everyone looks like a supporter and people may start becoming more supporting simply because of apparent social consensus.

Anyway, here's what Wikipedia has to say. Maybe it clears up

> In exercising the power of government upon society, the application of an official dominant ideology differentiates the worldview of the totalitarian régime from the worldview of the authoritarian régime, which is "only concerned with political power, and, as long as [government power] is not contested, [the authoritarian government] gives society a certain degree of liberty."[6] Having no ideology to propagate, the politically secular authoritarian government "does not attempt to change the world and human nature",[6] whereas the "totalitarian government seeks to completely control the thoughts and actions of its citizens",[5] by way of an official "totalist ideology, a [political] party reinforced by a secret police, and monopolistic control of industrial mass society."[6]

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Totalitarianism#Definitions

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by Braxton1980 on Sunday April 20, 2025 @08:13AM (#43743291)
> the archetypal authoritarian system expect the average person to engage in politics

I still disagree with this, maybe what defines politics is different for you.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by Braxton1980 on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @04:32AM (#43702953)
>One of the benefits a working democracy conveys to its citizens is that they largely don't have to care about politics

The citizens elect the government so how can you not care about poltiics?

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by InsideOutSanta on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @04:50AM (#43703072)
>The citizens elect the government so how can you not care about poltiics?

I don't think there's a direct correlation between the ability to vote and caring about politics. People usually care about politics when it affects them negatively. I would guess that most people in most democratic systems don't have strong negative experiences with their governments and, thus, are not incentivized to care about politics.

Note that I'm not making an argument that they should not care. I think they should, but the very system that allows participation probably also decreases the incentive for most people to participate.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by Braxton1980 on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @08:32AM (#43704584)
>. I would guess that most people in most democratic systems don't have strong negative experiences with their governments

Opinion polls about political parties and leaders seem to always hover near the bottom end, at least in the US [1]

[1] there are always bumps after elections (change), war (nationalism), and tragedy (group sympathy)

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by jowea on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @10:11AM (#43705818)
Well, a bit. A part of liberal democracy is that elections don't matter that much. The losers can trust that they aren't going to be arrested, have their property confiscated etc. The established system like the courts, constitutions separation of powers and other anti-majoritarian things will prevent most extreme measures. And in at least some political systems, it is expect that no matter what some minimally competent people will win and govern not that differently from what the election loser was going to do.

And remember voting is not mandatory and a lot of people don't vote. Those people are ultimately letting others decide, and a lot of them are hoping the voters are going to pick well, or at least decently.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by Braxton1980 on Thursday April 17, 2025 @01:35PM (#43719921)
>The losers can trust that they aren't going to be arrested, have their property confiscated etc.

Is that what people are worried about? What about the economy, civil rights, wars, etc.

I'm very confused about your argument. Is it that who you vote for doesn't matter because they won't personally attack you and the policies of whatever politician won't harm you?

>lot of them are hoping the voters are going to pick well, or at least decently.

Considering how the popular vote is almost always close to being split (you know like +10/-10) why would a non voter have that trust when from their view it's a coinflip

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by jowea on Thursday April 17, 2025 @03:07PM (#43720894)
> Is that what people are worried about? What about the economy, civil rights, wars, etc.

I meant this more like what people could be worried about. In a functioning liberal democracy, there are things people usually don't worry about, which allows some people to just ignore politics. Sure the economy is an issue, but there isn't a serious communist contender in the election or a candidate wanting to start wars of conquest.

Imagine this election. Candidate A you think will deliver GDP growth of 2+-0.5%. Candidate B you expect to deliver GDP growth of 3+-2% growth. No other big difference between them. Maybe you prefer A, maybe you don't, but in the end you'll probably be relatively fine either way.

Now imagine this other election. Candidate A hates your ethnic group and you are likely going to be fired from your government job or worse if he wins. Candidate B is from your ethnic group and will do reverse Candidate A. Now the point is that this sort of election isn't supposed to happen in a functional liberal democracy.

Consequences are rarely this extreme, and even when they are it's not a product of personal or group targeting just a general policy like "ban fracking", which means even affected people can still carry on with their lives.

And also this is one of the reasons elections "work" at all. If the losers think they will be chased by the state after losing, there's no reason to participate in the election, might as well arm up before the polls and take your chances in the battlefield and/or negotiate directly with the other side's elites.

> I'm very confused about your argument. Is it that who you vote for doesn't matter because they won't personally attack you and the policies of whatever politician won't harm you?

> Considering how the popular vote is almost always close to being split (you know like +10/-10) why would a non voter have that trust when from their view it's a coinflip

My point is that it's a coinflip between two acceptable choices. Some of those nonvoters would be literally undecided if asked who they prefer. It may matter, but not that much. And even if it does, it may matter in a way where the consequences are hard to predict or not obvious.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by fc417fc802 on Thursday April 17, 2025 @04:40PM (#43721993)
You had asked "how can you not care about poltiics?" which implies there's some force driving people to care about the outcome. Similarly "why would a non voter have that trust when from their view it's a coinflip" is effectively the same question.

If someone doesn't particularly care about the outcome given the available options then it follows that how close or far the odds are isn't going to matter to them.

> Is that what people are worried about? What about the economy, civil rights, wars, etc.

It's important to be clear about the context. There's the thing, and then there's the thing relative to the election where only a few outcomes are possible once the ballot has been set. It is possible to care deeply about the former but not particularly about the latter, either because all options are either good enough or pointlessly bad from your perspective. And of course it is also possible to simple not care (ie be emotionally invested in and go about broadcasting your opinion to others) about the things you listed to begin with.

It's also important to keep in mind that "not caring" can be at odds with "ought to care", although that is obviously a subjective third party judgment.

Re:CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew cont... by silverquiet on Wednesday April 16, 2025 @07:23AM (#43703982)
And yet the Republicans have campaigned on tearing down government for my entire life. And people treated me like a fool for believing them.