Since I moved here, I have sen people break into cars (numerous times), fill suitcases with products from Target and Walgreens and leave without paying, casually smoke meth in a crowded bus, empty their bladder and bowels in the middle of the sidewalk, etc. all of this brazenly and in broad daylight. In other cities, this type of behavior usually earns you at least a good beating and a night in jail. The negative feedback is very important for conditioning antisocial people to behave in a civilized community, but for some reason, SF has decided to not bother with it.
Some other comments conflate this with the "homeless problem". This is not a "homeless problem". Homeless people living in a shelter or pitching a tent under a bridge are not the problem in SF. Criminal antisocial nutcases getting no consequences for their actions are the problem.
In what cities does any of this earn you a good beating?
I've been wondering what cops are using these days since phonebooks aren't a thing any more.
Guess a lot of people are 'falling down stairs' instead (outside SF).
For extremely serious crimes, not his list of public indecency. For instance:
* Under the Environmental Public Health Act, it is an offence to urinate or defecate "in or upon any street, arcade, vacant land, river, canal, ditch, drain or watercourse or in any place to which the public has access except in any sanitary convenience provided for such purpose." The penalty is a fine of up to $1,000 for a first offence, and up to $2,000 and $5,000 for the second and third offence respectively. [1] [2]
[1] https://www.asiaone.com/singapore/totally-unacceptable-man-p...
[2] https://www.todayonline.com/singapore/nea-issues-warning-wom...
We know that the rich are allowed to do what they want. I’m more interested in the people likely to actually do it.
The GP was talking about an informal punishment though, not canning.
Without a police force dense societies usually can not function.
Defund the police does have a certain legitimate point in the US, where police are basically the catch all for dealing with any kind of social problem. (In fact I think if it were phrased differently, most cops would rather there be another type of department that responded to sticky social situations).
But yes, the overall issue is really a lack of law and order in the law enforcement ranks, which decreases the public trust and increases adversarialism. The average person seeing a cop and reflexively thinking how to avoid getting their attention and avoid getting hassled for some bullshit is an indicator of a deep set problem. The cancer was fueled by drug criminalization and other crushing nanny statism (eg the draconian way traffic laws are enforced), but it would take a lot more than simply rolling those back to regain the public trust.
I would prefer that criminals were not beaten and that we find a better solution. I don’t think we have to choose between police brutality and crime.
For example, it’s not possible for me to solve the systemic issue of drugs and mental health in order to stop public defecating. It is possible for me to arrest the person for pooping in the street.
I think we should do both at the same time. But we certainly shouldn’t arrest people for pooping because they have a systemic issue invisible handsing them toward public pooping.
People can be trash for different reasons. And if a systemic issue makes someone do trashy behavior, then they are still trashy.
It seems to be missing the point to point out lack of empathy for arresting poopers.
The societal dysfunctions are because tech ppl, the ones who ask the laypeople of the world to allow them to fix all their problems, have built a literal dystopia of social problems in the place where they have the most actual wealth and power to build something else. There is no greater argument for the myopia of VC-tainted tech solutionism than SF itself.
In what way does using harsh language to describe harsh people cause DAs to not enforce crimes? How does one thing directly cause the other?
"Harsh language" isn't the problem, it's the framing and lack of empathy for these people.
15 years in and no one in my family has been a victim to any crime.
> 15 years in and no one in my family has been a victim to any crime.
The reason provided above is as anecdotal as the one provided by GGP, and cannot be solely used to build any arguments/conclusions from.
There's also an axiomatic conflict between this & GP: The general neighborhoods that glerk and random314 live in may not be the same neighborhoods, resulting in the conflicting self-reports written above. It is possible that random314 lives in one of the nicer neighborhoods that glerk mentions offhandedly, and unless shown otherwise, has not been to FiDi or SOMA:
> > > I think a lot of people live in their nice neighborhood bubble and have never stepped foot in FiDi or SOMA.
Just went to SF for the first time in 5 years. So much worse. Wasn’t great in 18, but back then I walked across Golden Gate Park alone during the day and it was beautiful. I cannot imagine now. Market st is hell.
Crime was pretty crazy during dot com days, just tolerated more. Maritime Park next to the Hyatt / Embarcadero was always hip deep in homeless people at night. Very scary. Even worse when the freeway was still there. Market always had overly bright lights at night and looked like a sci fi dystopia. Absolutely no one wanted to be in SOMA at night which is a real problem for a startup working late hours. Hence small startups preferred renting private homes in Menlo Park etc. (Silicon Valley HBO)
Got to the airport and the taxi driver said "Do you really want to go there?" - which was a bad sign and things just got worse when I got to the hotel and noticed that my room had 3 huge sliding bolts on the door.... I was told by the receptionist NOT to walk directly along Geary (I think) to get to the hotel but go two blocks north first and then cut back down.
Being an idiot I ignored this advice one night and got the fright of my life!
This was in a hotel that was a fairly short walk from Union Square.
> Because you need me, Springfield. Your guilty conscience may force you to vote Democratic, but deep down inside, you secretly long for a cold-hearted Republican to lower taxes, brutalise criminals and rule you like a king!
That's almost 30 years old now.
We have similar problems here in the UK. A lot of people are disconnected by class which leads to misunderstands and bad politics. I personally think this class disconnect contributed far more to events like Brexit and Trump in recent years than social media.
Most of family are working class and things like mass 3rd world migration, homelessness, drug use, etc has caused huge problems in working class communities here in the UK. But when you try to raise these issues (as a working class person) you always get accused by some progressive middle-class person of racism, intolerance, or being anti-progress, etc.
You basically have to wait for things to get so bad that middle class people are also impacted, then they'll stop slandering you and let you have an opinion.
As an outsider it would seem San Francisco is reaching that tipping point now – it's not just poor people being impacted by these bad political decisions, but also the wealthy progressives responsible for them.
Although from what I've seen in the case of SF it seems the progressives who caused the issues rather just flee than fix the problems they created.
So let's take a look at the other list item...
Poland and Romania are not the third world, nor are Spain, Italy or Ireland.
India is borderline third world, but Indians are one of the most successful migrant groups in the UK.
Nigerians, too, are seeing success in education, business, politics and sport. My partner works for a YC-funded startup founded by two Nigerian Londoners.
So, by process of elimination, are you are saying that Pakistanis and Bengalis are a major source of problems? Hardly surprising that people accuse you of intolerance in that case.
Would you like to be more specific?
(And before you start up about class again: my dad drove a van for a living)
This doesn't get acknowledged in the West too much, that is that we (meaning countries that used to be East of the Wall) have outsourced many of our social problems to the West (which had created many of them in the first place in the '90s by ideologically imposing the Shock Doctrine therapies on us, but that's another discussion).
The thing is that this situation also affects people from those countries/societies who are not inclined to crime, such as a close friend of mine who's now having to go through lots of procedures and loops before being allowed to sign for a rental contract (she's Romanian, her SO is Polish, they've just moved from London to Manchester). All those procedures and loops are applied by the real estate agency, so not by the British State itself, I presume because the people from agency have to financially secure their back based on previous negative (from a financial pov) interactions with people from Romania and Poland (I'm also from Romania, if it matters).
Not sure what the best route going forward might be, because when you try to put yourself in each person's shoes you can understand why and how things are done in a certain way, no need to resort to "he/she is doing that because of racism/xenophobia".
In the case I mentioned, most probably that real estate agency lost money by dealing with Romanians and Poles in the past in a different way than it's used to lose money by dealing with local British people, that's why it put in place more complicated procedures for Romanians/Poles than it has for the locals. Yes, it is discrimination, but, again, in many cases it is based on pure material reasons, i.e. people not wanting to lose more money than they have to.
I feel like that's an open-and-shut case if "Oh, you need application form A1234-v-Romanian/Polish" is the case.
Again, that seems to be specific to that big agency, she also told me that in the past when she and her SO had found rental arrangements through smaller agencies things were a lot more straight-forward.
Yes. Sorry but while it's unpleasant to say, that's just indisputable.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rochdale_child_sex_abuse_ring
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rotherham_child_sexual_exploit...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Telford_child_sexual_exploitat...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oxford_child_sex_abuse_ring
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peterborough_sex_abuse_case
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Newcastle_sex_abuse_ring
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Keighley_child_sex_abuse_ring
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Huddersfield_grooming_gang
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Halifax_child_sex_abuse_ring
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Derby_child_sex_abuse_ring
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bristol_child_sex_abuse_ring
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Banbury_child_sex_abuse_ring
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aylesbury_child_sex_abuse_ring
Towns all over England have seen thousands of young girls be systematically raped while the police, councils and MPs have almost all turned a deliberate blind eye. Spurred on by the same misplaced sense of righteousness and/or guilt that presumably led you to write your comment full of obfuscation and finger-pointing, rather than sitting down like grownups and having a discussion that acknowledges the serious problems that have been caused by the UK's immigration policy that has resulted in whole parts of towns and cities being replaced by a foreign culture, instead of dispersing and integrating people carefully into the country. This is to say nothing of terrorist attacks, widespread intimidation against non-muslim practices, ethnic ghettos, parallel court systems, hymen inspection clinics, massive over-representation of genetic disorders due to traditions of inbreeding, etc.
Excuse me?
A gang of your beloved Englishmen were in court just yesterday for systematically raping young girls. Must be because of the Pakistanis.
https://www.itv.com/news/granada/2023-04-04/men-appear-charg...
Somewhere along the line this term was misunderstood and repurposed into a euphemism for "underdeveloped" or worse, with racial undertones. Best to just drop the term from your vocabulary unless you're talking about the cold war.
I suppose the issue is more that it's hard to agree on what the problem is or how to solve it. Eg, is it drug use that's the issue or mental health? And how do you fix that?
For example, a lot of people in my family abuse drugs – cocaine, ketamine, NO2, etc... But I also know a lot of middle class people who use these same drugs "responsibly". If you use a little cocaine every now then and you have the money for it then understandably you might see it as harmless. But then I also see the other side of this coin because I have family who spend all of their benefits money on drugs like cocaine and abuse it daily.
This makes it really difficult to take a zero tolerance approach to things like drug use because you end up pissing off all the middle class liberals who like using drugs on the weekend and see banning drugs and regressive. They also simply don't understand the problem either. They commonly think bizarre things like people who failed school and who are probably < 80 IQ just need a bit of mental health support and they'll stop abusing drugs and get their lives on track...
Similar things are true with homelessness. Everyone agrees people being homeless isn't good, but then what do you do about it? If you think people agree on this then why don't you try arguing for a zero tolerance approach to homelessness and see what people say? My guess is that people will start accusing you of not caring and arguing that it's not something that should be treated as a crime because these people really just need mental health support. But the truth is you're not going to fix homelessness by giving people mental health support. And again, this is so hard to explain to middle class people because they won't accept that not everyone is like them and that some people will just end up back on the street no matter what you do.
And I think this is really the core of problem. Middle class people assume (perhaps reasonably) that everyone is like them and their middle class friends and that they will make good decisions with a bit of support. In my experience this just isn't true.
As for 3rd world migration it's hard to know where to start... There are so many issues and this is such a complicated topic. To summerise:
- Cultural incapability issues. Again, middle class people struggle to understand that not every muslim is like their friend Mo from university. And as you brought it up, yes, Pakistanis are obviously one of groups which are less culturally compatible with British communities.
- Economic issues. I'm happy to expand on this if you like, but 3rd world migration in the UK has just been bad economic policy which disproportionately impacts the working class.
- Crime. Again, very hard to talk about this because people don't like the statistics here... There are groups which are significantly over represented in certain crimes and calling working class people in communities which have to deal with these crimes intolerant doesn't solve the issue.
To your point though, I think Indian migration has been great for the country – this is basically indisputable if you look at the statistics. I also agree that there are lots of great migrants from the 3rd world, which is what's even more frustrating about this... Instead of bringing over people that would have a net-positive impact on working class communities, we instead have an immigration system which selects for stupid stuff like being fit enough survive crossing the channel on inflatable raft, or lying about your country origin.
The problem is that almost no one tries to "raise these issues". Instead you get:
> Migrants take ALL new jobs in Britain
> The swarm on our streets
> Migrants swarm to Britain
> 3.8Million EU migrants allowed to stay here
> Send in army to halt migrant invasion
> 4,000 foreign murderers and rapists we can't through out
> Illegals have landed
That's after it's been sanitised for front page news. The fact is that those ideas were seeded by a right wing press, fire-hosing propaganda about how subhuman migrants are raping your daughters. The result was open racism and bigotry, not an expression of concern for job stability or integration.
First, that addressing the core causes behind most crime (poverty, drugs, mental health, etc.) implies not enforcing the laws. We could address the root causes while also enforcing laws.
Second, that enforcing the laws requires extreme punishment like beatings.
But there was also a lot of good stuff.
If we go with this, let's apply it equally. SBF should get 50 lashes in a town square and any employer stealing wages or landlord failing to maintain their property gets a beating and thrown in jail for a night. Why limit this punishment to petty crimes like pooping in the street?
First, it's not a single reason but several going hand in hand. The main one, as far as I understand, is the sky-rocketing price of housing, coupled with little social safety net for which the US is well-known, produced a lot of homelessness that has not been addressed and ballooned. With that also came crime and drug abuse (that's not new: I've been there 10 years ago and was shocked by the amount of homeless people in the streets, and I live in Paris, which has its fair share of homeless people, so that's saying something)
The second main one is that racism, which has always been a thing, especially in the police force, produced some very high profile events (George Floyd) and high backlash against the police, perceived as racist and not being on the side of "the people".
There has been a big "defund the police", which resulted in less policing, police force demoralization, a lot of officers quitting. Coupled with the previous issue, a lot of small crimes happened, mainly perpetuated by poor people. It's important to note that due to the US history, being poor correlate strongly with skin color.
I don't really know if it's the fact that the people appearing the court were black and it was deemed racist or if the court were overloaded (probably an unhealthy mix of both), but at some point, shoplifting under a certain amount (was it $950? Somewhere in the $1000 ballpark) was changed from a felony to a misdemeanor. In practice, that means you could do that without fear of retribution, which predictably had awful results, and might be the disturbing videos you are talking about.
There you go, hopefully I didn't misrepresent the situation and didn't forget any other important factor, though I'm sure someone will correct me if I did.
I don't really know if it's the fact that the people appearing the court
were black and it was deemed racist or if the court were overloaded (probably
an unhealthy mix of both), but at some point, shoplifting under a certain
amount (was it $950? Somewhere in the $1000 ballpark) was changed from a felony
to a misdemeanor. In practice, that means you could do that without fear of
retribution, which predictably had awful results, and might be the disturbing
videos you are talking about.
In most states the felony threshold gets adjusted periodically if for no other reason than to keep up with inflation. Texas bumped theirs to $2,500 and Alabama to $1,500 back in 2015.The felony limit could be $1 or $1000. If the DA's office refuses to prosecute, it doesn't matter.
I'm also from Europe. I'll probably be flagged to hell for this but you should be aware that this claim isn't actually true despite how often it's repeated.
When BLM kicked off the WSJ ran an article that looked at the actual statistics around police shootings in the USA. There are apparently databases of such things. They show no evidence of police racism. The original article is paywalled,
https://www.wsj.com/articles/the-myth-of-systemic-police-rac...
but it seems some US politician put up a copy here:
https://grothman.house.gov/news/documentsingle.aspx?Document...
a police officer is 18½ times more likely to be killed by a black male than an unarmed black male is to be killed by a police officer.
A 2015 Justice Department analysis of the Philadelphia Police Department found that white police officers were less likely than black or Hispanic officers to shoot unarmed black suspects. Research by Harvard economist Roland G. Fryer Jr. also found no evidence of racial discrimination in shootings. Any evidence to the contrary fails to take into account crime rates and civilian behavior before and during interactions with police.
The latest in a series of studies undercutting the claim of systemic police bias was published in August 2019 in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. The researchers found that the more frequently officers encounter violent suspects from any given racial group, the greater the chance that a member of that group will be fatally shot by a police officer. There is “no significant evidence of antiblack disparity in the likelihood of being fatally shot by police,” they concluded.
In 2019 police officers fatally shot 1,004 people, most of whom were armed or otherwise dangerous. African-Americans were about a quarter of those killed by cops last year (235), a ratio that has remained stable since 2015. That share of black victims is less than what the black crime rate would predict, since police shootings are a function of how often officers encounter armed and violent suspects. In 2018, the latest year for which such data have been published, African-Americans made up 53% of known homicide offenders in the U.S. and commit about 60% of robberies, though they are 13% of the population.
etc. You believe otherwise because the issue became the central organizing rallying cry of the left, so they systematically attack any discussion of the underlying data.
This is why so many shootings that get saturation media coverage as evidence of police racism end up containing bizarre details like the police doing the shooting being black, or the victim being high on drugs.
That's an extremely bold statement to make.
The study the WSJ article was based on was retracted: https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2014148117
Directly from the authors themselves:
> Despite this correction, our work has continued to be cited as providing support for the idea that there are no racial biases in fatal shootings, or policing in general. To be clear, our work does not speak to these issues and should not be used to support such statements. We take full responsibility for not being careful enough with the inferences made in our original report, as this directly led to the misunderstanding of our research.
And there are articles that go into how exactly they got it wrong: https://www.washingtonpost.com/outlook/2020/07/15/police-sho....
On top of this, police shootings are just one aspect of policing. You can find various research that supports, for example, that you're way more likely to be pulled over while driving if you are black than if you are white. And that relative proportion drops at night because it's harder for them to see. They're then more likely to be searched after the stop, and more likely to be handcuffed.
And police brutality is much more than just shooting - I don't think we keep track of how often police officers use _any_ kind of force, but that's another thing that would also need to be evaluated.
There are just... so, so many things you'd need to consider and refute in order to make that statement.
https://www.wsj.com/articles/i-cited-their-study-so-they-dis...
My June 3 Journal op-ed quoted the PNAS article’s conclusion verbatim. It set off a firestorm at Michigan State. The university’s Graduate Employees Union pressured the MSU press office to apologize for the “harm it caused” by mentioning my article in a newsletter. The union targeted physicist Steve Hsu, who had approved funding for Mr. Cesario’s research. MSU sacked Mr. Hsu from his administrative position. PNAS editorialized that Messrs. Cesario and Johnson had “poorly framed” their article—the one that got through the journal’s three levels of editorial and peer review.
Read the correction they issued:
https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2004734117
"As we estimated Pr(race|shot, X), this sentence should read: ‘As the proportion of White officers in a fatal officer-involved shooting increased, a person fatally shot was not more likely to be of a racial minority.’ This is consistent with our framing of the results in the abstract and main text."
In other words, the thing being fought over was the wording of a single sentence that didn't change their actual conclusions, which are consistent with the other evidence. But then later:
"Despite this correction, our work has continued to be cited as providing support for the idea that there are no racial biases in fatal shootings, or policing in general."
Yes, because their correction in their own words "is consistent with our framing of the results".
This whole incident is just proof of what I'm saying - the American left systematically attacks anyone who tries to point out the actual data here, which is why people don't hear about it. This particular paper led to a Twitter mob and someone got fired, but it wasn't due to bad methods, it was because student activists were upset about the "harm" it caused:
https://www.wsj.com/articles/a-twitter-mob-takes-down-an-adm...
>> you're way more likely to be pulled over while driving if you are black than if you are white.
Aren't you now doing the things you're claiming these Michigan researchers did? Where's your control for actual crime rates?
And you're systematically ignoring literally everything else I've said, including an article pointing out the multitude of errors included in the study, references to other unexplained disparities, and I might also just add:
> Cesario and Johnson write that their "decision had nothing to do with political considerations, ‘mob’ pressure, threats to the authors, or distaste for the political views of people citing the work approvingly."
Even if police shootings aren't evidence of racial disparities in policing, there are a _lot_ of other disparities.. which are certainly worth considering if you actually care about the data.
But if your evidence consists entirely of vacuously parroting Oped pieces by a right wing political commentator who "claimed that 95% of outstanding homicide warrants in Los Angeles were for undocumented immigrants and that 75% of L.A.'s most wanted list comprised undocumented immigrants", then.. I don't know what to tell you.
Indeed. The chronology is important:
1. Cesario et al [1] received some criticism [2], but they stood by their findings [3] 2. A student union / twitter mob was not happy with the findings of the study [4] 3. The resulting political pressure led to the ousting of Stephen Hsu from MSU, who had approved the funding for the study [5] 4. Only then retracted Cesario et al their study, while still standing by their findings [6]
There is a similar study done by economist Roland Fryer [7], while at Harvard.
Summarized, the two studies find the following:
Cesario et al:
Per interaction with the police, civilians have roughly the same risk of being killed by police gunfire, regardless of their ethnicity.
Fryer:
- Per interaction with the police, civilians have roughly the same risk of being the target of police gunfire, regardless of their ethnicity. - Per interaction with the police, a black civilian is 1.5x more at risk to receive slight use of force by the police than a white civilian. This disparity gets smaller at higher levels of force. (See [7], Figure 1) - Per interaction with the police, a perfectly compliant black civilian is 1.2x more at risk to receive slight use of force by the police than a perfectly compliant white civilian. This disparity gets smaller at higher levels of force. (See [7], Figure 5)
[1] https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.1903856116 [2] https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.1919418117 [3] https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.1920184117 [4] https://twitter.com/gradempunion/status/1270829004157849600 [5] https://lansingstatejournal.com/story/news/2020/06/19/msu-vp... [6] https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2004734117 [7] https://scholar.harvard.edu/sites/scholar.harvard.edu/files/...
Here, have a morsel from my old hometown.
https://www.wbrz.com/news/brpd-narcotics-officer-exposes-wro...
> "At least three to four nights a week they would have us riding through the neighborhoods," Ardoin said. "If you saw a random black person walking around the street and hasn't done anything, they would tell us just to jump out the vehicle, grab them and pat them down without probable cause. I voiced my opinions several times, and I didn't agree with that."
Many of my black friends used to call the local police the "jump out boys". My friends had to grow up worried that they would be randomly planted with drugs. Unfortunately of all the people I know, I'm the one who actually ended up getting planted with drugs by a deranged cop, despite being white.
The full story is much longer and so insane that I don't even want to open the full can of worms here at the moment, but I should do a write-up and talk to a lawyer now that I have the time/money, despite the statute of limitations which probably protects them.
I mean I've literally watched this officer with my own eyes procure meth ingredients, I have footage of her distributing, some people I know murdered her brother and there was a giant meth lab found at his house, it's just a total unbelievable shit show from start to finish. But I was the one who got railed. The FBI refuses to get involved despite numerous tips.
mistrial, in law, a trial that has been terminated and declared void before the tribunal can hand down a decision or render a verdict. The termination of a trial prematurely nullifies the preceding proceedings as if they had not taken place.
Other than that it’s a totally credible story about a meth-cooking police officer…
As for the mistrial, it's only in spirit because my public defender flat out refused to take my case seriously and refused to appeal on grounds that it would make her life difficult.
It's hard to make people believe or understand what small town corruption is like unless they've seen it for themselves. The mayor himself showed up at the place I was crashing at after I got arrested just to further make things more difficult for me... what kind of psychotic town allows for such behavior?
I thought about calling the police and getting them to review the footage, but it was a crapshoot who showed up and if I would only get into more trouble.
My arresting officer has been kicked off of the local force before and reinstated. Until a few years ago, the father of the local district attorney was the the town's mayor. The same mayor was the town bail bondsman. When I was processed, the town's mayor himself visited the parents of the friend I was staying with at the time in a play to get me kicked out and back on the street.
It's an insane town and it's ruled by a few wealthy families. The corruption in that town was unimaginable and I myself was subject to an abusive power figure as my guardian while growing up, that same man is great friends with the same prosecutor who conspired to press charges and conduct a mistrial. I can't get away from it.
My second lawyer didn't know my name after two years, prepared no defense and refused to file a motion to quash (the town dragged on proceedings for years and it turned out they'd never sent the "evidence" to the lab).
I had half a dozen cops approach the stand, sequestered, and each of them told a totally different story. My only witness then got slapped with a charge for "lying to the police", whatever that was in legalese, and the judge ignored all of the inconsistencies. I should also mention that my right to a trial by jury was taken away from me in an act of deceit, where I, a minor without a lawyer or guardian present, was made to sign a document upon bail which gave up that right. I was told at the time that they would not release me on bail unless I signed the document.
My lawyer then refused to file an appeal because it would, and I quote, "make [her] job miserable", because her de facto boss was the judge, who happened to be the only presiding judge across two parishes.
My original public defender, who had been removed from my case, was so upset by the outcome that he came to visit me in jail, promised me he'd fight for me... he had a private screaming match with the judge in his office, but the best he could do was get me a reduced sentence on good behavior. I still had to pay thousands in fees and endure all of the other issues that come with the state having a vice grip around you.
So in any situation where a black male and a police officer encounger each other, the police officer is more likely to kill.
Racism *and* base rate fallacy. Fancy that.
Everything I have studied suggests that, yes, homelessness is directly related to a lack of affordable housing.
Until very recently, there were condos and houses available in that exact price range in downtown Austin. Yet ask anyone who lives there, there are and were tons of homeless everywhere you went in the city.
There are other cities that are way more affordable than SF, with the same homelessness problem. The thing they share in common with SF are the "compassionate" policing policies.
These are stereotypes but in the midwest you either are driven/make the trip to California or your freeze to death in the winter.
In the south, you either are driven/make the trip to california or you are eventually shot or locked up.
On the coasts that is now considered horrible tyranny. So you gotta deal with the downsides of that.
I travel to many off the beaten path neighborhoods (mostly) all over the west coast and the homeless encampments I see in places like LA and the Bay Area are just people who can’t afford housing but have cars and RVs to live in.
Kind of annoying because the places where 20 years ago you could park a truck are full of urban campers. Last week I was driving around in Fremont, a couple miles from where I grew up, and every square foot of road around the place I was delivering to was occupied by people living on the streets. When I last lived there in the 80s Fremont was just your average boring suburban hell where there’s no way they wouldn’t have cleared out these encampments. Pretty sure that’s where they had a bunch of signs basically saying “no camping” which they obviously don’t bother enforcing.
Your most certainly can, if you can prove to a judge that they are mentally ill, and unable to make decisions for themselves.
What you describe is technically possible, but extremely rare. Even when someone is involuntarily admitted, the stay is typically capped.
Generally, as long as an individual isn't harming other people, "the system" doesn't have a reason to pursue a judgement. Many of these people are isolated from family/support systems or have nobody to actually care or advocate for them.
Further, many of them have complex cases. While treatment may be effective temporarily, it's hard to sustain the level of care after an admission.
Back in the day the police would beat the crap out of the lowlifes and drop them off outside of town.
And then the liberal guilt peddlers made noise and the men got weak.
Must just be some essential part of their character. /s
That's because abusive families are one of the primary drivers of substance abuse and mental illness.
Way to absolve tech of any blame and blame those dirty poor homeless addicts. Clearly there's absolutely no reason for these people to exist! They just do!
The dirty poor homeless addicts aside, what exactly did tech do? Tech didn't come up with the truly brain-dead housing policy that makes it so difficult to build new housing, so that supply can catch up with demand. Tech isn't handing out drugs on the street.
I'm not a tech worker in SF so I'm not taking anything personally. But I struggle to establish a causal relationship between tech and what's happening in SF. Usually, it's a good thing for a community when there's a local high-income cash cow.
People are talking as if this is the city's problem, but it's our industry that caused the problem. We have to acknowledge that so we don't keep causing problems.
And as the cash cow, our industry has the ability to influence policy to prevent these issues from happening.
Policy has kept housing expensive in SF by not building enough supply, by not regulating rents, but not building better public transit infrastructure.
And it's the rich advocating against affordable housing. And they made their money through tech.
If that means being a landlord isn't lucrative enough, that's fine, the government can absorb that capacity and build social housing instead. There's no reason the private market should be allowed to monopolize rental housing.
You could easily massively increase density by simply building more 4-8 story apartment complexes in the style of several cities around the world like Paris.
SF isn't an island. It's not landlocked. Just build up.
Land is usually not the issue unless you're at Tokyo, Hong Kong or Singapore levels of dense.
People are slowly realizing that it was a mistake, but its gonna take some time to fix the situation.
Ok, but apparently it was shit even before that, so this can't be full answer.
Compare San Francisco to somewhere like Singapore, and ask yourself where would you rather live - and if the freedoms available in SF are worth the trade offs. BTW I'm not taking a stance here as I live in neither location.
The cities you mention have a different culture. It's ingrained into you as a kid. It's "less liberal" in the sense that the wider society doesn't accept these values. The media, your family and friends and other parts of the environment are a lot more effective than the law.
On the other hand, I also know that in general in any of those countries, the consequences for something like shoplifting are a lot stronger than they would be in most western countries.
As an island nation, Taiwan also has a somewhat easier time preventing narcotics smuggling. Whereas the mainland Chinese Communist Party has covertly targeted the USA for "Opium War 2" by tacitly allowing the smuggling of fentanyl precursor chemicals to Mexican drug cartels.
(In the 70s they also once bombed the mayor's house when they didn't like him.)
" SF’s police department has 335 fewer full-duty police officers than it did in 2017, with a total of 1,537 officers as of January, according to Supervisor Matt Dorsey, a former police communications staffer.
A police staffing analysis indicated that the department needs upward of 2,100 sworn officers to satisfy city demands. As fewer officers are available to patrol streets or respond to incidents, the department says it has been forced to ask staff to work longer hours or pick up extra shifts. "
When the force is at 75% capacity, officers are overworked and deprioritizing non-emergency responses. It's a recipe for more George Floyds, not less.
The article the poster linked to does not show the overall department budget, rather that was spent on employees' wages. I don't see you or the other poster mentioning this at all though. Here is an article you can see the overall budget of numerous police departments including SF
https://abc7news.com/sfpd-budget-defund-the-police-departmen...
18-19: 629.8M 19-20: 692.3M 20-21: 667.9M 21-22: 657.4M
I believe I see one increase and two decreases. Between 18-19 to 19-20 the departments funding increased. While the department had funding decreased from 19-20 to 20-21 and again from 20-21 to 21-22. Now whether or not this defunding (funding decrease) was due to "defund the police" or some other factor I cannot say. However I can say for a fact that the narrative police were NOT defunded is wrong. I have provided 2 overall budgets that show they were defunded for two separate time periods.
Its also worth noting we are not adjusting for inflation or cost of living increases.
https://missionlocal.org/2023/03/sf-mayor-27m-police-overtim...
https://sfbos.org/sites/default/files/BLA.SF_Police_Dept._Bu...
Also based on the timeline for 21-22 they defunded, then recognized the need more money because you know they defunded from the previous year so then allocated more funding.
The article I linked didn't have 22-23.
You're also saying that 3 out of 4 isn't consistent. Fine. Does that make me a liar, or are you picking nits?
> The article I linked didn't have 22-23.
That's what I said.
I responded to you, you responded to someone claiming "The police aren't defunded in San Francisco. They have consistently gotten budget increases."
I pointed out the police have been defunded depending on the time span you look at. I also pointed both of you misrepresenting the data pretending it was the overall budget when it was in fact the employees wages.
>>You're also saying that 3 out of 4 isn't consistent.
I disagree with you. You claimed a link said there was a "$27.5 million to fund police overtime in 21-22". Could you point specifically to where that is?
One does reference a 27.5 million proposal and says "The Budget and Appropriations Committee of the Board of Supervisors approved a $25 million budget supplemental Wednesday to fund police overtime in San Francisco. It next goes to the full Board of Supervisors on March 21st." No where does this say that this is being added to last years budget. In fact the article is from March 2023.
Even if it was for 21-22, if original budget allocated less money than the previous year, they defunded the police that year. Rushing to add in extra funding AFTER the budget was done so people can pretend it never happened does not erase the original budget that defunded them.
So I still see it as 2-2 even with your added 22-23 data which is not consistent in my eyes.
And what does "have been" have to do with "are?" You seem to be having some difficulty understanding tense. That explains it.
As for not making arrests, isn't that self reinforcing? Of course police will slow down arrests if the other end is not completing the process.
I find your view of this unusual and puzzling.
If these people don't want to do policing, they should not collect a police officer salary.
[1] https://abc7news.com/san-francisco-budget-announcement-defun...
Also worth quoting this section of the article you linked to:
> That means over the two year budget period, the city reduced law enforcement spending to the tune of $110 million. As the budget process continues, supervisors will have the opportunity to propose further cuts that could get closer to $120 million, like they did last year.
[1] https://abc7news.com/sfpd-budget-defund-the-police-departmen...
$692.3 million in 2019-2020
$667.9 million in 2020-2021
$657.4 million in 2021-2022
Source: your link.
The article's headline says it's up 4.4% but that's compared to 2019.
It refers top the whole department, not what individual officers make.
"Oh look, Ricky is stealing again, should we bother arresting his aggressive angry ass again for the 7th time this year? Nah."
An la times article said: “ San Francisco police officers Kevin Lyons and Kevin Sien have been temporarily suspended after they were arrested last year in connection with the destruction of evidence. They’re accused of destroying credit cards, identification records and suspected methamphetamine discovered in the luggage of a person staying in a hotel.
Lyons and Sien allegedly told staff that cataloging the evidence would take too long and instead disposed of the credit cards and IDs in a shred bin and flushed the drugs down a hotel toilet, according to state court criminal complaints.”
It’s a story mentioned here https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2023-04-03/twenty-p...
In civilized society, you make a pact with the state. They have a 'monopoly on violence' and in exchange, you and your property are protected. That pact seems to be broken in SF, and to a lesser extent in CA at large. People should do what they need to in order to keep themselves safe. If that means a gun? So be it.
One can fire non-lethal rounds, and aim around a person (or into the ground), instead of at them. I'm not a believer in urban gun ownership. But there are ways to responsibly be one and benefit from it without putting others' lives or your own freedom at risk. (Counterfactual: pulling a gun on a criminal is a good way to have a criminal pull a gun on you.)
i pray i never need it but i'm glad to live in a place that's not without its problems, but where i can at least defend myself and my property.
also @JumpCriscross since his comment is dead: that's silly, you shouldn't make a threat you aren't willing to follow up on. more importantly "warning shots" are a really good way to cause collateral damage. might be you shoot through a wall. plus your eye is on the threat so it's irresponsible to shoot elsewhere bc you aren't actually evaluating what's there and what's behind it.
Thankfully, the US and California are still Democracies for the moment.
Anyone who tries to hold up Singapore as a beacon of "good governance" simply isn't working in reality ...
It's dumb to jail homeless and mentally ill people, but it's just as dumb to just stop jailing them without providing them the help they need.
The most liberal cities in the world don't have big homeless and crime problems because help and housing is provided.
I don't know, I'm not the judge of that, but it sounds a bit like a very mobile goal post. Usually, "liberal policies" are removing or weakening penalties and enforcement. A liberal drug policy will decriminalize drug use. liberal = tolerant, so liberal policies tolerate a lot more things.
And SF is in many regards more liberal than European cities. Whether it's your preferred kind of liberal politics, or whether it's combined with other effective policies etc, is a different question.
To me that looks like a society that has completely abdicated its responsibility of using legal force to protect the rights and safety of its inhabitants, rather than just an honest disagreement on what variation in values and lifestyles that are accepted.
> To me that looks like a society that has completely abdicated its responsibility of using legal force to protect the rights and safety of its inhabitants, rather than just an honest disagreement on what variation in values and lifestyles that are accepted.
It does to me, too, that's one of the reasons I moved to the suburbs, and it wasn't anywhere as bad as in SF and other US cities. But I felt that the priorities were backwards and I understood that the majority of people wanted them pushed further in the direction I considered wrong. So I moved, because why stay and suffer if you don't believe in those policies but most of your neighbors do?
In a sense it’s closer to the original Christian ideal than most, but I don’t see how that can lead to peace, joy and prosperity long-term in a society where a minority abuses it.
Are they? In the US "liberal policies" are also associated with higher taxation and government regulation. So which is it?
Statements like this seem to be exactly why people are frustrated with SF's policies. What is the "help they need" that will be sufficient to keep them from being a problem? I've known addicts and schizophrenics, and it's near impossible to fix them, even with an affluent and caring family to support them the whole way. What will an incompetent state actor possibly do that is better, other than just lock them up to keep them from harming others?
> Since I moved [to SF], I have seen people break into cars (numerous times), fill suitcases with products from Target and Walgreens and leave without paying, casually smoke meth in a crowded bus, empty their bladder and bowels in the middle of the sidewalk, etc. all of this brazenly and in broad daylight.
I'm not aware of any major European city where this kind of behaviour is tolerated, much less common.
As for smaller cities in Europe like London or Berlin, they're also still reasonably safe (I didn't like night buses in London but that's about it) and the crazy stuff is mostly contained.
I guess a huge part of this is that most countries over here at least have something resembling a working social system.
Liberalism in the US heavily resists the usage of asylums and actually helping people in general. In Europe that's not really the case.
Singapore
But hasn't the hue and cry been "defund the police"? We heard it as far back as the mostly peaceful protests that ravaged major US cities across the US in 2020-21. And it's been the chant of mostly left-leaning politicians and organizations.
2. "Defund the Police" usually means diverting money away from reactive policies (policing) to proactive policies (community initiatives that prevent people from falling into abject poverty to begin with). You can claim that "defund the police" is bad optics, but honestly the US is such a far gone police state that "liberals" could have picked any rallying cry and it would have been weaponized.
3. The reason you see police forces doing less even though they have more funding is because they are using the narrative that they were "defunded" (recall this never happened) as a bargaining chip for police unions to negotiate with lawmakers for less oversight and more funding.
4. There is no correlation between police funding and crime rates. Police only show up AFTER a crime has been committed, and anyone who has dealt with police firsthand knows how much they love to drag their feet:
https://www.brookings.edu/blog/how-we-rise/2022/03/31/preven....
5. This one might be a bit philosophical but when you have a police force you aren't reducing violence, you're just shifting the violence that is done to the state. While the crazy homeless people and crack addicts might be "out of sight out of mind", you can guarantee they are getting stabbed and beaten up in prison, or shot in the street by the cops.
If your goal is to simply remove "undesirables" from the view of the public then police are a great tool, but if our conception of justice is that crude then we might as well return to the code of Hammurabi.
If the goal is to reduce violence and crime overall, then police are not the best tool for the job. Preventative measures must be taken to keep people from getting to the mental state that causes them to commit crimes.
This link [2] says police headcount is down 25% from 2017.
https://californiaglobe.com/articles/new-report-sfpd-short-8...
https://missionlocal.org/2023/03/police-staffing-crisis-san-...
Police budget was lowered in 2020, that's from a decrease in tax revenue though, not ideological.
https://www.sfexaminer.com/archives/breed-orders-departments...
It was also increased back to normal levels in 2022.
Well, quite frankly, they deserve that outcome a lot more than guys like Bob Lee. I don’t understand how one could care so much about protecting dangerous, crazy homeless people from harm. It’s like worrying about making sure Osama bin Laden doesn’t get hit by any hijacked planes
This is some Hammurabi thinking. It's not about protecting "Osama Bin Laden" (although justice should be blind and not paywalled), it's about ensuring that our system produces fewer Osama Bin Ladens.
To steelman your point, let's say that police are 100% necessary in society and the more police the better. In this universe the police never cause collateral damage and are always 100% in the right.
In this world, even if you lock up every "Osama Bin Laden" you are still putting the police officers in harm's way. They are using their bodies to ensure that the Bob Lee's of the world can keep on innovating.
To prevent harm to officers, we should figure out how to reduce the number of encounters they have, which means reducing the number of criminals through other means. If society is a machine that produces Osama Bin Laden's as a byproduct, isn't it in everyone's best interest to reduce the rate at which we produce Osama Bin Laden's? Especially the police who put themselves in harms way?
Conversely, increase the number of officers. This will cause the incidence per officer to fall.
There are places in the world that have done this. For example [0], where the populous has been deputized in order to quell violent crime.
[0] https://www.breitbart.com/latin-america/2023/04/03/ecuadors-...
If there was a way to solve these issues while also being really nice and compassionate then I’d be all for it, but if you’re getting bullied sometimes the best thing to do is to just sock the bully in the mouth.
>I don’t understand how one could care so much about protecting dangerous, crazy homeless people from harm. It’s like worrying about making sure Osama bin Laden doesn’t get hit by any hijacked planes.
Controversial take incoming, brace yourself. Bin Laden was the son of a construction magnate who was radicalized in a war where he fought for the US by proxy, only to be abandoned (except where Western meddling was advantageous for Western interests) when it was over. His picture is the illustration for the proverb, "The child who is not embraced by the village will burn it down to feel its warmth."
Bob Lee sounds like a great guy. He is among a class who benefited enormously from federal and state policy that subsidized suburban communities at the expense of cities, arguably in a way that shifted, rather than eliminated, the social ills that are endemic to most human societies above a certain population threshold. The policies that gave Bob Lee et al. their advantageous start created the dangerous, crazy people, when different policies might have diluted the circumstances which shaped them to the point where they might have been treatable, without necessarily cramping Mr. Lee's style.
There but for the grace of housing/economic policy advantageous to my intersectional identity go I.
(Note that we've ended up with the worst of both worlds.)
See my point #5 in the parent comment:
> This one might be a bit philosophical but when you have a police force you aren't reducing violence, you're just shifting the violence that is done to the state.
When you give the police overwhelming power to punish dangerous people, you have created a new class of very dangerous people. In my theoretical universe where cops are infallible this is not a problem, in the real world if you give an institution that much power what do you think would happen when they "solve crime". Would they willingly relinquish that power? Or would they aim to extend their influence onto larger swaths of the population with more draconian laws?
> If there was a way to solve these issues while also being really nice and compassionate then I’d be all for it, but if you’re getting bullied sometimes the best thing to do is to just sock the bully in the mouth.
I think you're missing the point. I am not saying there should be zero accountability for criminals and zero police. I am saying we should also attack the root causes of criminality instead of just using punitive measures. Right now we are treating the symptom and not the cause.
The West Coast cities, LA, SF, Portland, and Seattle are much more liberal than most "blue" cities.
Regardless, I live in SF, and love it here, for way more reasons than the tech scene (it's actually a coincidence I live here as far as my job goes). I really hope we can improve this situation, regardless of the relative scale compared to other cities. It seems like part of a national problem.
Your impressions are, bluntly, wrong.
LA and San Francisco have the 32nd and 37th highest violent crime rates out of the top 100 largest cities in the US, and the 72nd and 7th in overall crime rates. Homelessness, driven by lack of development combined with the the attraction and generation of concentrated wealth is a real California statewide problem (though there are plenty of non-California cities with serious problems, NYC is nearly as bad as LA, and far worse than San Francisco, in terms of population share that is homeless.)
SF is 4th highest in the United States for larceny rates. Note that larceny is the most frequent type of property crime per the FBI.
I think initially it started as "being poor is not a crime" with the good thought that you can't arrest people for not having a house. I think this escalated toward a lax attitude toward drugs and many "petty" crimes (e.g. public urination, stealing a case of beer).
The interesting thing was that when I lived there sometimes I'd ask or joke about it (bicycle theft was a huge problem, car windows being smashed, etc). People would mostly pretend they didn't see it and have no idea what to say to my joke for fear that somebody around them had a very strong opinion and they would offend.
Also, I remember once my improv class was chatting outside the theater and a homeless man asked for a cigarette and then started berating my classmates when they ignored him, and they actually felt bad. I know their sympathy came from a good place. Many of these people are damaged mentally and jail will only get them out of your face. But in my opinion something more proactive needed to be done.
I don't even think it needs to be traditional jail. Heck, I wouldn't be surprised if some of these people would be happier/healthier working outside in the sun getting some exercise instead of being in a cell. I think that's not boolean enough for most people though.
Jail alternatives are more expensive in the short term, and that is all that matters to this faction.
To get approval to build new housing is essentially impossible.
When aggressive crimes are enforced less strictly than code violations or regulatory approvals, SF is the result.
The full, uncomfortable answer, is people who wear liberalism/equality as a fashion accessory - instead of really caring about it. The "don't criminalize homelessness" line is towed to the degree of mandating homelessness. There is a culture of blocking solutions, while offering no alternative solutions. This makes it almost impossible for the homeless who want to be uplifted (by far the majority) to make progress. Even something as simple as having a mailing address and a shower can make a huge difference (especially for finding employment and government aid), but such progress is blocked by faux-liberalism.
He did offend the Asian community with insensitive comments on attacks on them, which might've been enough for a recall.
I’m not from the US, but I’ve been to SF a number on times (>5). The first time was in 2006 for apple WWDC, as a student, and back then I already witnessed a number of people wandering in the streets, mostly passed out or wandering, but I also saw peopoe shouting at the air, and defecating and throwing stuff.
At the time I was told this was a legacy from the post-Vietnam era, where many veterans flocked there due to the dem leaning of the city which provided an expectation of help, and also mostly the nice weather, but ultimately they did not get support.
From that point on things developed. Veterans from other wars, and then generally any people with life issues, were attracted to that location which fits their unfortunate, crazy situation - drugs, a barebones support network that provides food (?), and the fact no one bothers them anymore..
At least that’s what I was told.
In recent years I’ve noticed more of the situation, but tbh nothing that surprises me from the earlier observations. I didn’t see ANY numbers so that may or may not be the case.
I am interested in someone validating or correcting my perception
Have things gotten worse, recently? The addict population definitely has grown over the past 20 years; even the older addicts will tell you that. But the city has also greatly gentrified over that time and has seen significant demographic shifts, including decreases in communities which historically saw most of the violent crime. There are plenty of statistics to throw around to support whatever claim you want.
[1] She works for IHSS, a combined Federal and State program that provides elderly requiring living assistance (e.g. cleaning, grocery shopping, accompanying on medical appointments, etc) with an allowance to pay care workers--it works both as assistance for poorer elderly, and as a work program for everybody else. There are IHSS-like programs across the country. But in San Francisco the vast majority of people receiving IHSS allowances seem to be former or often current drug users. I think she's only had one client who wasn't an addict.
The bay area has the lowest rate of homeless shelters per capita of any major metro in the united states. Whether you're talking Atlanta, Miami, or Boston (regardless of weather), every other city has more homeless shelters and programs to house people. This gets people off of the streets and, at a minimum, gets them in a place where they can take advantage of other programs to deal with health and addiction problems.
In the bay area these people stay on the streets while hundreds of charities get small amounts of money to help, but with no real central coordination or group that's in charge of spending that money effectively. As a result you've got a ton of people on the streets, as well as all the consequences of that.
People- both on the streets and in control politically, don't have much urgency in providing shelters as a result.
Even East PA was the hood. Oakland was famous for riots
SF governance has always been terrible. Real estate has gotten so expensive that startups anxious to conserve runway are pushing deeper into bad neighborhoods that were once unthinkable
The Facebook / Sun campus is there because it was cheap land
If the cost of office space were a concern, it'd be difficult to explain why they're anywhere near the Bay Area at all.
> San Franciscans face about a 1-in-16 chance each year of being a victim of property or violent crime, which makes the city more dangerous than 98 percent of US cities, both small and large.
https://www.hoover.org/research/why-san-francisco-nearly-mos...
People who want to sort major US cities by homicide, assault, or other crimes can look here:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_States_cities_b...
But, its non-violent crime and property crime numbers are through the roof which makes it feel incredibly unsafe.
Miami, on the other hand, actually has a higher homicide rate than SF but because the streets are clean and property crime is much much lower it feels far safer than SF. Also, to be honest, for people reading hacker news, homicides are an incredibly rare black swan event, unlike property crime which you experience almost daily in SF. So, it makes sense for this crowd to have a place higher utility on low property crime than on low homicides. And I'm not judging, I moved to Miami and couldn't be happier with that decision.
The murders that happen in my part of town are usually drug-related, like an OD or, in the case of my neighbor, a drunk and jealous girlfriend with access to a firearm.
Parts of Miami are definitely cleaner, and some parts of Miami are pretty bad too, if not worse (parts of Wynwood, particularly south of the Wynwood Arcade used to be filled with homeless tents; and that's to say nothing of Liberty City, Little Haiti, etc.. ). However, Miami looks nicer but in many aspects there's some real trash beyond the facade. My building is under 5 years old, in a great (and growing) part of town, yet has had multiple murders in it. I used to live at Icon Bay, which had a literal drug lord living in one of the penthouses until there was a large-scale raid that forced him out. The FBI literally has a unit in my complex because they are here all the time - drug rings, prostitution rings, kidnapping, etc... are all happening right under your nose, but since the perps drive a Benz and walk around in a $250 pair of sneakers, it's less in-your-face (and more socially accepted) than some homeless dude in the Tenderloin shooting up heroin and taking a shit on the sidewalk. One guy in my elevator line was moving weed by the pound on a regular basis like it was nothing, and I had no idea until the property manager pointed out that they had recently been arrested on felony drug charges. Another in my building wears an ankle monitor yet owns a fleet of exotic cars. It's so much harder to tell here than anywhere else I've lived....until you know what to look for.
And that's to say nothing of the outrageous amount of scams here, particularly medicare/medicaid fraud. I'd take the homeless guy who shits on the sidewalk any day over the guy who stole millions from medicare and drives around in a Ferrari.
At least in SF/Bay Area, you can tell who the trashy folks are, and who the mentally ill people are. In Florida, they are allowed to scam the government, drive around in flashy cars, and better yet - they can buy guns and carry them around, loaded, without a permit.
But, personally, I'd rather have the medicare-fraud-guy than the shits-on-the-street guy in my neighborhood. The former hurts me a little no matter where they live, the latter hurts me a lot but only if they are nearby.
Just in 2014, the national average was 4.5 per 100,000.
And these numbers are several times that of large European cities.
Still, this is not as bad as Oakland, with a homicide rate several times that.
[1] https://abc7news.com/feature/san-francisco-bay-area-safety-t...
[2] https://ucr.fbi.gov/crime-in-the-u.s/2014/crime-in-the-u.s.-...
There were 10 more in 2022 than in 2014[0], which was the low point for homicide rates nationally[1]. The absolute number is fairly flat and per-capita rates are well down on 2000s levels[2].
[0] https://sfgov.org/scorecards/public-safety/violent-crime-rat...
[1] https://www.macrotrends.net/countries/USA/united-states/murd...
[2] https://www.city-data.com/crime/crime-San-Francisco-Californ...
That is in of itself not alarming. An average city would have an average homicide rate: That's what averages are. It's only alarming if the city has (a) one of the lowest homicide rates nationally, or (b) one of the highest homicide rates nationally. Being average just means that it's the middle of the pack.
- If it's genuine: There's nothing to worry about. Extreme paranoia about (a) is in this case a false positive.
- If it's fraudulent: They're moving the sources of homicide out of their jurisdiction and onto somewhere else. Or they're increasing enforcement, in which case there may be increased false positives as a consequence.
I remember in the 90's that oakland and east palo alto were basically murder capitals, and SF wasn't too far off.
To be fair though, I've lived in areas that were next door to top 5 murder/capita rates throughout the 90s-00s and they were all heavy drug and gang areas you knew to avoid. Most of those have also been cleaned up as property values have sky rocketed triggering development.
I tend to refer to what's happening in SF as SF-Stockholm syndrome. I grew up in Texas, spent time on the east coast, with a reasonable stint in NYC, and spent just over a year Scotland. I really have never seen the openness and acceptance of severe substance abuse like I have on the west coast of the United States (not just in SF.
Portland, SF, LA, pretty much every major city here, there are areas of the city where crime is effectively just tolerated. SF is particularly unique, because, by a wide margin, it's the smallest and most walkable. Other cities tend to be automobile-centric, so non-organized crime tends to stay in small areas of the city (though, from my understanding, this is changing in Portland).
This is combine with a fairly strong anti-police culture. I don't know the veracity or history, but people here, even perfectly law abiding people, tend to think the police forces are generally corrupt-and-racist, or have a history of corruption and racism.
Combine this with the out-of-control opiate epidemic, and what this seems to have created is a pretty nuts, but not actually abnormally dangerous, environment in San Francisco in particular. There is little enforcement of any laws, except parking enforcement. When my friends from Germany visited, they were very curious about this "opiate and crime thing" after reading about book about Fentanyl, so as part of their visit, I showed them the open drug markets around midnight at UN Plaza, at Civic Center BART station. They were horrified.
I call it Stockholm Syndrome because people here legitimately believe that leaving anything in your car, in any major city in America, will likely lead to a break in. Obviously this is incredibly untrue, and SF is an outlier in theft (to the point that the stats are laughably inaccurate because nobody even reports car break-ins to the police anymore), but people have acclimated to the culture, and just assume it's normal, if they don't leave the region on a regular basis.
Ironically, the city is actually fairly safe with regards to violent crime. Not especially safe, but the homicide figures show that things aren't "out of control" in the violent crime aspect.
The thing that's shocking is how in-your-face it all is. The signs of severe substance abuse, are ever-present in a shockingly large amount of the commercial districts of the city (though most of the city is perfectly safe, quite and residential). The city does absolutely nothing about it. Primarily, because the court system cannot handle the case load. My roommate is a Public Defender, so I'm acutely aware of the backlog of cases that are genuinely violent crime. Not that it matters, because in election-after-election, the candidates tend to be pretty much on the same page that nothing really will be done. Again, much of the populous has a very strong distaste for any policing action.
This tragedy did not happen in a bad part of town, and I regularly walk in worse areas at similar hours regularly, and it's generally fine.
All this to say that based on my reads of online forums, I think SF is ahead of the curve of Seattle in terms of near universal frustration with homelessness/drugs/etc (even if it’s not confirmed whether they are related to this case), but somehow no progress or change in elected officials have been made.
I’m watching this to see if there’s hope for some of the problems in Seattle, since online forums here aren’t pissed off to the same degree yet.
Basic "supply and demand" also applies to crime, playground needles and sidewalk turds: if you lower the "price" (punishment) at constant demand (people who want to steal or shoot up in public), the supply increases.
Also EU, agree with this.
If it's the latter then I assume that social services are just overwhelmed?
I'm pretty sure that if I was made homeless tomorrow, and knew I had no prospect of pulling myself out of that situation, I'd migrate to somewhere with a climate like that of SF.
So the statistics say "most homeless lived in SF prior to becoming homeless", but if you actually check local school records you know they didn't grow up here.
Such an approach keeps problems alive.
Looks to me that the logical alternatives to means-tested aid are either no resources for anybody, which seems undesirable, or resources for everybody, no matter how well-off they are already, which seems wasteful. What do you suggest instead?
Family-friendly policies that help parents raise their children.
Universal healthcare coverage.
Walkable neighborhoods.
Good public transit.
Etc.
2) These abuses started to be caught on cell phone videos, starting with Eric Garner in New York, and Michael Brown in Ferguson which was not on video. After the videotaped murder of George Floyd in 2020, some activists saw an opportunity to raise their public profiles significantly with the slogan "DEFUND THE POLICE", indicating that the very concept of policing was racist. In particular, the idea of being a "tough on crime" politician was seen as a version of the N-word
3) This caught on because of people's increasingly race-addled brains in the last 5 years, and that people were on lockdown in the pandemic and were happy to join large outdoor protests
4) Most cities did not defund the police but overall mayors, politicians, and leaders, who used to speak glowingly of the police, started saying that policing is racist, making policing a less respectable profession, causing high labor attrition and "quiet quitting" for those who didn't formally retire or quit
5) In parallel with all of the above, District Attorneys were elected like Chesa Boudin in San Francisco and Larry Krasner in Philadelphia who advocated for "restorative" justice, which can be appropriate for people with consciences but for your repeat offender psychopath effectively meant zero consequence for crime
6) Due to a lack of policing, crime, especially among Black Americans, skyrocketed in 2020 and 2021. Large of areas of San Francisco and other cities were essentially handed to the criminals. In San Francisco in particular, these are mostly Honduran fentanyl traffickers, Black robbery gangs, and White and Asian car break-in rings.
TLDR: there are far fewer consequences for crime now in large cities like SF, NY, LA. The results are as expected.
Due to the absolute dominance of voters with this mentality, and the practice of electing prosecutorial positions that in other parts of the world would be professional appointees, they have repeatedly ended up with prosecutors that ran on a campaign of refusing to prosecute. This isn't specific to SF, it can also be seen in LA and New York. In fact one of the criticisms levelled at the Trump inditement is that the prosecutor in question campaigned specifically on prosecuting Trump (for whatever) and has now upgraded what would normally be a misdemeanor, whilst simultaneously downgrading many other types of crime.
In other words: politics, ideology, the usual suspects.
“While the violent crime rate has fluctuated year-over-year, it has remained relatively stable this past decade—between 428 and 466, hovering near its 2010 level (440), when California embarked on major criminal justice reforms.”
“While violent and property crime rates increased in 2021, both remain relatively low”
https://www.ppic.org/publication/crime-trends-in-california/
I guess ChatGPT thinks it does not hold personal opinions, but fails to realize that it is biased. I used to live in the Bay Area, and it's clearly not "like any other major city." These problems are indeed much higher than in other major American city, and completely off the shorts compared to other major cities worldwide.
Where I kind of agree with the "let's not blame SF entirely" is that it's probably not necessarily only a SF governance problem, but a general problem in American society, and a lot of these people who are profoundly lost come from all around to SF because it's known to be permissive. Now, an argument could be made that maybe being so permissive actually enables these people to fall even lower - than if they weren't able to "centralize" in that way.
But the real question is probably: how is it that people can become so mentally ill in the USA? Elements of answers could be:
- low family cohesion: whereas in most of Europe, families eat every meal at a table together, it's more rare in the US. Parents often work a lot, from birth, as parental leave is pretty much inexistent. The hustle culture and obsession with money takes focus away from family and promotes severe dysfunctions in the attachment systems of future adults.
- an overall excessive and more reckless culture: it's what makes America so innovative, but also what can make it so dark. Always bigger, always faster leads to big companies, but it also leads to people losing sight of what matters in life and engaging in extreme vices.
I think it's mostly point 2, and it's a tough one because it's deep in the culture.
2. On top of that, California has additional broken tax policies and other policies that deepen the shortage of affordable housing.
3. Big cities are where the services are, such as soup kitchens. If you are homeless in the US and have nothing, going to the nearest big city is your best bet for trying to eat regularly.
4. California and big cities are both expensive. Once you go to California as a homeless person or the big city as a homeless person, it's quite hard to get off the street because housing is so expensive.
5. Being LGBTQ puts one at high risk of being homeless due to homophobia. San Francisco has a reputation for being more LGBTQ-friendly than average even for a big city.
So you have desperate people hearing high-minded nonsense that lures them into a bad situation and we aren't really dealing effectively with such issues generally, so we aren't giving people real solutions. Desperate, hopeless people with no options is not a good population type to foster the growth of if you value a civilized social climate.
/2 cents
https://sfstandard.com/public-health/latino-homelessness-sur...
if we didn't have such a huge issue with out of state people swelling our homeless population, we wouldn't have such programs as these to repatriate them: https://www.sfexaminer.com/news/housing/homeward-bound-reloc...
If you're homeless and moved to a particular city because you believe you'll have a better time there, then you might feel incentivized to claim that you originally lived there before becoming homeless.
Unfortunately there's no good way to confirm or refute this data.
There are also lots of reasons to question exactly how such numbers are determined and what they really mean, which is a long discussion I don't care to have.
Due to the temperate weather, California has largely become the dumping ground for America's chronic homeless.
Not all homeless are chronic homeless.
You don't need all your homeless to be chronic homeless to dramatically and negatively impact the scale of the issue for one state that has, iirc, 12 percent of the US population and 25 percent of the US homeless population.
...Or, being LGBTQ puts you in a higher risk of being homeless due to underlying mental issues. We can never know.
There was also a recent article on HN about the Catholic church -- which expects all priests to be celibate -- investigating gay dating but not straight dating priests to get rid of them.
Any claim that homophobia is prevalent in the coastal US is laughable, and deliberate victimisation.
Also, you yourself are expressing a number of homophobic ideas in this thread. Could you please stop? It sucks that every HN thread that mentions LGBTQ people even in passing seems always to have to attract homophobic comments.
Finally, you should read the comment that DoreenMichele linked to to see what she was getting at.
And I did read the comment.
Other people chiming in to suggest you are homophobic or your comments are homophobic is not something I have control over. Acting like I am playing the victim card based on that is ridiculous.
On top of all that, this whole discussion resulted from one bullet point in a comment on an article that literally has nothing to do with LGBTQ people or homophobia. And yet you feel the need to argue all of these points here.
> LGBTQ is often caused by an underlying mental illness Is not a homophobic statement. Nothing in this statement or assertion meets the definition of homophobia.
There is no bad faith here. Remember that you my also be exposed to points of view that you don't like – such as the one I just expressed.
Edit: I'd ask one question in response to your comment. You say that due to limitations of current scientific knowledge, 'one cannot claim without any certainty that LGBTQ is not caused by mental illness'. Ok, then can we be certain that being straight is not caused by mental illness? Which scientific studies could one cite to support or refute that claim?
I'm quite confident her mental health issues were due to the extreme abuse she suffered and not due to being trans per se.
Makes perfect sense.
You n=1 could also very well be interpreted as the extreme abuse being the source for the transexualism as well. Anyway with all the respect I will stop replying now.
No, that isn't my position at all.
You want to cite some research so I can look at it, feel free. So far, you have not cited anything, just made general assertions and shared your opinion.
My opinion differs from yours and I'm telling you part of why -- but only part of why.
10.1111/j.1440-1819.2010.02118.x
10.1155/2014/463757
10.1111/j.1600-0447.1993.tb03467.x
10.1023/A:1024517302481
10.1023/A:1019724712983
The correlation between GID and depression was modest, but significant (r = .20; P < .05), whereas the correlation between GID and separation anxiety was nonsignificant (P > .05).
10.1111/j.1440-1819.2010.02118.x
Comparison with previous reports on the psychiatric comorbidity among GID patients revealed that the majority of GID patients had no psychiatric comorbidity. GID is a diagnostic entity in its own right, not necessarily associated with severe comorbid psychological findings.
10.1155/2014/463757
Clinical evidence suggests that schizophrenia occurs in patients with GID at rates higher than in the general population and that patients with GID may have schizophrenia-like personality traits. Conversely, patients with schizophrenia may experience alterations in gender identity and gender role perception.
10.1111/j.1600-0447.1993.tb03467.x
Personality disorders, mainly within cluster B, were identified among 5 of 19 transsexuals, and a majority had multiple personality disorders. Among controls, no personality disorder was identified. Personality traits as measured by the SCID screen revealed significantly more subthreshold pathology among transsexuals than controls in 8 of 12 personality categories.
I will note that there were only 19 trans individuals in the above study.
10.1023/A:1024517302481
(One quarter had had problems with substance abuse prior to entering treatment, but less than 10% evidenced problems associated with mental illness, genital mutilation, or suicide attempts. Those completing the MMPI (93 female and 44 male) demonstrated profiles that were notably free of psychopathology (e.g., Axis I or Axis II criteria).
This last study supports what I and other people are saying here: That when allowed to be themselves, their psychological issues largely disappear.
Your second study also asserts "no comorbodity" of GID and major psychiatric issues. Your first study shows only a small effect of increased depression and separation anxiety, issues not usually viewed as "crazy" like "crazy homeless people committing violence" levels of crazy.
The only study you cited that seems to meaningfully support your position is the correlation with increased rates of schizophrenia. Someone taking master's level classes in psychology once said to me something like "Schizophrenia is known to get worse due to social factors. You put schizophrenics in residential treatment, they get better. You send them home to their crazy-making families, they get worse again."
How does this accord with outcomes being better for them in less developed countries? I had a friend with paranoid schizophrenia and he spent the last few months of his life mostly getting outpatient treatment at home.
It isn't an assertion that schizophrenia is solely due to the family being crazy-making, just that such people are vulnerable to negative social influences. Such vulnerability does not mean that all families of all schizophrenics are equally crazy-making.
Is there a study that proves this? I did a brief literature scan and it seems to me that researchers are unclear about the causation direction of things like trauma, psychological disorders, and GID/gender dissatisfaction. I think this is a pretty important part of the ongoing debate.
I don't want to be the "citations needed" guy, but I do have a tremendous respect for science and I don't want to just have to go with my gut on something like this.
I'm not an expert on Trans issues. However, I'm recovered from childhood sexual trauma and I had unusual levels of support.
So it's clear in my mind that a lot of what you see in the LGBTQ community is really due to the effects of trauma and not due to being LGBTQ per se.
But, I mean, most people would dismiss that as just my opinion. So it probably isn't something you would want to cite.
Do you have a source for this? Because I’ve seen other conflicting claims that transitioning and trans acceptance doesn’t show much effect on suicide outcomes.
(2022) “ In this prospective cohort of 104 TNB youths aged 13 to 20 years, receipt of gender-affirming care, including puberty blockers and gender-affirming hormones, was associated with 60% lower odds of moderate or severe depression and 73% lower odds of suicidality over a 12-month follow-up.” https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamanetworkopen/fullarticle...
(2021) “ Data were collected as part of a 2020 survey of 34,759 lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, queer, and questioning youth aged 13–24, including 11,914 transgender or nonbinary youth… Use of GAHT was associated with lower odds of recent depression (adjusted odds ratio [aOR] = .73, p < .001) and seriously considering suicide (aOR = .74, p < .001) compared to those who wanted GAHT but did not receive it. For youth under age 18, GAHT was associated with lower odds of recent depression (aOR = .61, p < .01) and of a past-year suicide attempt (aOR = .62, p < .05).” https://www.jahonline.org/article/S1054-139X(21)00568-1/full...
The statistics might bear out that being LGBTQ puts one at high risk of being homeless, but homelessness being due to homophobia is an unclear and unproven assertion.
This will receive howls of disapproval. It's so obvious, like climate change being fake and Trump secretly battling a cabal of pedo vaccine-peddling warmongers. How could you possibly believe something different?
But I've heard similar about Chicago, Paris and Bradford.
https://www.politico.com/amp/news/2020/07/29/trump-chicago-g...
> Conservative media for decades have painted America’s third-largest city as a national hub of gun violence and gang activity, crippled by what they see as political correctness thwarting real solutions.
https://blog.geographydirections.com/2015/02/02/fox-news-no-...
> Emerson stated, “In Britain, it’s not just no-go zones, there are actual cities like Birmingham that are totally Muslim where non-Muslims just simply don’t go… In parts of London, there are actually Muslim religious police that actually beat and actually wound seriously anyone who doesn’t dress according to religious Muslim attire.”
>These segments were widely mocked across social media and the station eventually issued an apology, stating that there was “no credible information to support the assertion”.
As a European you just have to look at all the claims of how "communist" California is to get an idea how detached from reality these people are.
Why are there so many people on unlicensed dirt bikes doing wheelies down the street?
The rich can usually avoid the stench and filth of the poor so they don't invest their money in solving it. Now the poorness is festering.
This is a problem that will not get solved without taxes, and it probably won't get solved without taxes at the federal level. Americans will not let themselves be taxed more and so the consequences are more of this for the foreseeable future.
This is simply untrue. There are cities with more wealth inequality (Singapore, Shanghai, Dubai..) that have no such crime or filth, because the police deal with it aggressively.
Despite having control of every layer of government they still somehow are blaming someone else.
San Francisco wasn't always like this.
It's not that anything specific has changed in SF - it's more a case of, the political machine has been running very smoothly in a way that does little to help anyone in particular, and occasionally it manifests as an "oopsie we let someone die".
The designated narrative role of SF since the 70's, as a Democratic Party stronghold, is to be praised from the left for progressive policies, and pilloried from the right for being a failing dystopia. And the narrative has simply intensified both ways over time, while the actual ground level conditions are way more varied. There used to be more overt violence, gang shootings and the like. Now it's mostly drug use and property crime. Mostly. After all, someone did just get stabbed. But in any case, the existence of the narrative allows every concrete fact to be shouted over by paid advocates for some cause.
To get at the truth you have to dig into the details neighborhood by neighborhood, department by department, year by year. The problems are not something that manifests from electing one wrong leader or voting yes on one wrong ballot proposition, but from the city openly allowing itself to court a menagerie of institutions that do no good other than to allow money to be shuffled between bank accounts. There are nice neighborhoods, mostly on the west side of the city, where if anything bad is happening, it's kept tucked out of sight. But go downtown and you get the apocalyptic scenes, which are supported by this "NGO industrial complex".
For one example, I present Urban Alchemy. Urban Alchemy describes itself like this:
We’re a social enterprise that engages with situations where extreme poverty meets homelessness, mental illness and addiction.
When a neighborhood, street or intersection earns a reputation as a place to avoid, we turn it around. Urban Alchemy is a peaceful and supportive presence, inviting communities to rebuild and restore a sense of pride and respect in urban spaces.
UA has a logo that looks like a cult symbol, and they hire former prisoners as "ambassadors"(i.e. they beat up and harass people, mostly homeless). This does nothing to fix the visible drug use problem next door to their building, of course. It would not surprise me to learn that UA itself has drug addicts in its ranks.
In essence, they seem to be doing the kind of thing you would expect the police to be doing, but the police aren't doing it, so they're going to do it very badly and say it is helping. What are the police doing? Not a whole lot, it seems. They were very happy to say it was the progressive district attorney making things unsafe. But even if that were the case, they just haven't been enforcing, not even traffic. They weren't defunded at all. After Covid, people started speeding around the empty streets and they didn't stop even after traffic picked up again. They need to fire the department and start over, like what happened in Georgia in 2004.
Tech actually did a measure of good for the city, at the expense of making it a really expensive place to live and bringing in a highly transient population of tech workers who "put in a few years" for a career launchpad. The tech companies threw their weight around and got some things built. However, a lot of the surplus funds that went into the government went into "programs" of the Urban Alchemy sort, and tech workers weren't in it for the long term and voted with the national narratives, not for direct investment in the neighborhoods. So, mostly, measures that favored landowners under progressive guises passed.
And that brings us to today, where it might actually come to pass that the city has to cut something for once. But they've made so many things in the budget earmarked that it'll probably be the wrong things that get cut first.
“Stabbed” here being a euphemism for “murdered.” Carefully softened word choice is a key tactic used by the people in power in SF who have allowed things to get this bad in the first place.
In general, the US has a major crime/homlessness problem due to the lack of a social safety net, poor drug & mental health policy, and homophobia.
California has much nicer weather than much of the US so homeless people move their or are just able to survive there. In some cases, right wing states purposely relocate their homeless to California.
America is currently experiencing a backlash against a broken justice system that tolerates police brutality, favors the rich, and is often racist. Unfortunately, this has probably resulted in an overcorrection in many places.
The previous point is exasperated by the fact that the Republican party, which in recent decades has been more oriented around "law and order", has become a far right party. Therefore, even if someone agrees with their candidate on crime, they may disagree with them on economics, LGBTQ rights, etc.
I don't know if this is true, but I've been told that unlike most other cities, much of SF's resources for helping homeless people is located in their downtown. That then results in the homeless problem being much more visible there.
The truth is tech ruined the city. SF used to be a city of misfits, who don't usually have high income. Tech workers started flooding the city, drove up rents, and these misfits ended up homeless. Once you're homeless it's a struggle, some get back on their feet but some start abusing drugs. Government support programs are terribly run, so nobody uses them. Let the situation go on for a few years and you get SF.
It's not just SF though, it's any city in North America that has had booming rents the past couple decades. Vancouver, Seattle, Portland, SF.
If you look at Tokyo, rents are low and jobs are plentiful. The biggest city in the world has less than 4000 homeless people living in it.
I hope this serves as a wake up call to you that your biases are preventing you from seeing the whole picture.
This is called post hoc reasoning, or, in tech, decision-based data-making.
The left decided that regulating society's behavior was racist so they stopped doing it since 2014.
a) They cut officers and drive them away. They had 2,160 officers and needed them. They are down to 1,651 officers (Sept 2022) Source: abc7news.com
b) The San Francisco DA allows many arrested to allowed to go free. They elected a special DA to allow people to go free. Not for all crimes, but many. This emboldens people because they see so many people released without trial or sentencing for their crimes, so they are emboldened to commit crimes.
The number of murders is very sad to see increased to such high levels.
Why just make things up? The absolute number of murders is basically flat over the last decade and per-capita it's decreased[1].
[0] https://sfgov.org/scorecards/public-safety/violent-crime-rat...
[1] https://www.city-data.com/crime/crime-San-Francisco-Californ...
- Sf closed schools for one year and half during the COVID causing large number of families to move out. And these are people who are contrablance to ultra liberals.
- Housing crisis: Corruption within the city's permit process has resulted in the need to hire "accelerators," which exacerbates the housing crisis.
- Public education: The public school system is facing significant difficulties and is in desperate need of improvement.
- Drug policy: The implementation of safe drug consumption sites has inadvertently worsened the city's drug problem.
- Street closures: Restricting vehicle access on certain streets has negatively impacted businesses and inadvertently facilitated the spread of homeless encampments.
- Small business challenges: Overly stringent regulations, often driven by the "virtue signaling" of the super wealthy, have created a hostile environment for small businesses.
- Progressive District Attorney: The DA's policies have led to policing issues, resulting in a surge of crimes such as robberies.
- Homelessness: Despite significant spending on homelessness, inefficiencies and corruption have hindered progress. Furthermore, "virtue signaling" has taken precedence over effective solutions.
- BART safety: Following a police shooting on BART several years ago, a reduction in policing has made the transit system less safe, deterring people from using it to visit San Francisco.
These issues may be interrelated or independent, but each contributes to the city's current struggles.
- Drug Crisis: Fentanyl crisis which is a US-made drug, widely accessible, and is affecting all America, exacerbating the homeless problem.
- SFO subsidizing addiction: On average $336 in grants given to homeless [2], many of whom are addicts, plus policies that allow crime for retail goods that are then fenced to support addiction.
i'd add 2 citations under " Homelessness [1] "
[1] https://www.nytimes.com/2021/11/23/books/review/san-fransick...
[2] According to the San Francisco Department of Homelessness and Supportive Housing, as of 2021, the average amount of General Assistance (GA) provided to individuals experiencing homelessness in San Francisco was $336 per month.
"Inadvertently." Nice one.
> These issues may be interrelated or independent, but each contributes to the city's current struggles.
I don't see how any reasonable person could not see that these things are all closely related. The inequality, due to the unaffordable housing, leading to rampant homelessness, drug use, and crime, to an almost-complete abdication of prosecution for these crimes, in an effort to be "equitable," and now... considering paying reparations for slavery!? You really don't see a thread here? Really!?
There are some really really strong forces preventing change in SF.
San Francisco has tended to view aggressive law enforcement against poor or homeless people as immoral (they don't want to criminalize being poor) which has had an unintended affect of making it a good place to be a homeless person or criminal.
while simultaneously staying heavily invested in economics that nobody but some quiet, far off yacht owner seems to be happy about
As someone from the general northeast US, it's amazing how local views of california have changed as they continue to kind of...drag their feet along and keep up this "highly based" outward appearance.
In 2000, there was observably more crime everywhere, but rents were cheap and as a young person I enjoyed the relative lawlessness. Market St used to be nothing but adult theaters and shady import shops. Things are 1000% NICER in ALL areas of the city. The transformation of China Basin has been incredible.
But you have to put all the down-and-out people somewhere. We squeezed them out of many central refuge areas (Tenderloin, 6th St., Fillmore, Mission) and then expected instant gentrification.
TL;DR... SF: far from perfect, but definitely not on a downward slope.
1. Rent has become insanely expensive such that a lot of people end up no the streets. This is the cause of the tent cities popping up, and really are a small part of what people have a problem with. The "invisible" homeless.
2. We do not have any resources for people who are too mentally ill or too sick to be of any "use" to society. A lot of those people end up on the street, where they are vulnerable to manipulation to start using heroin. A lot of them have mental disabilities. No, we do not have mental hospitals, and the ones that do exist are full, and they are not hurrying to build more.
3. We have a massive heroin addiction epidemic. These are the people who are crawling all over the place trying to get their fix, mugging people in the fugue states between scraping enough money together to get their next fix. The "highly visible" homeless.
So. Something like 0.17% of our population is homeless. That is like 600k people.
Imagine what it will take get these people off the streets and reintegrated into society, if that is even possible.
They need:
1. Shelter.
2. Food.
3. Medical professionals to help them come down from the high, and help them get on a better path to stop using drugs.
4. Security to prevent re-victimization.
5. Legal authority to detain them without their consent ( a lot of homeless people have schizophrenia and are extremely paranoid and do not trust anyone ).
Imagine how much that will cost.
The US government is extremely austere around funding this stuff, so it has been left up to the cities and states, which do not have the resources to tackle the problem.
So that is really it. It's too expensive, and all the money is pooled into the top .1% of the population, and we don't tax them, and they are busy building rocket ships, so we don't have any money to fix the issue.
Some people want the cops to arrest them but that is actually MORE expensive and MORE prone to failure, other ethical issues aside. ( of which there are many )
There may be more impactful things for the likes of Bezos to invest in than rocketships, but the idea that more wealth redistribution via taxation here would help things needs evidence to back it up.
In 2021, when the stock market was at its peak and therefore the net worths of billionaires were the most inflated (for which you can blame government policy, anyway), the wealth of all billionaires in the US were around $4T. Even if you confiscated it all and were magically able to sell all of their interests in various holdings without affecting the price, it would pay for two, maybe three years of Social Security and Medicare; forget the rest of the federal government, let alone all the other levels of government.
It's been pointed out elsewhere that San Francisco already spends over a billion dollars a year on programs related to homelessness, or around $57k per homeless person. To put it in context, if the whole country spent the same amount on welfare per capita, it would be $19T, which is 3x the current federal budget and over 80% of the GDP. It's a mind-boggling amount of money which would be completely untenable to sustain over time.
You would have to rely on a lot of faith to think that lack of money is what is preventing these problems from being fixed.
Since then, I have relocated to Austin, where homelessness has always been more prevalent than in other southern cities but never to the same extent as in LA or SF. However, a few years ago, our mayor chose not to penalize public camping, and as a result, homeless camps began to spring up throughout the city, including a tent city beneath a highway near my home. This led to a host of issues, including campfires, public defecation, and needles, necessitating constant intervention by EMS.
Fortunately, a proposition to make public camping illegal again passed with ease. While the city council was initially slow to enforce the ban, they eventually did so, and one by one, the tent cities disappeared. Occasionally, a tent pile of belongings still appears, but these are also cleared out promptly.
It's unclear where the former residents of these tent cities have gone. Some may have relocated to the creeks or woods out of sight, while others may have taken a bus to SF or LA. Alternatively, perhaps the change in policy inspired some of them to reach out to family members or other support networks to try and get back on their feet.
Ultimately, all I know is that enforcing basic laws had a positive impact on the non-homeless population, and I hope that those experiencing homelessness can find a way to improve their situation without making the city worse for everyone else.
1) Various US policies have driven up rates of destructive drug use (i.e. it's easier to get truly toxic drugs like Meth and Fent than it is to get lower harm, but equally potent drugs)
2) Various US policies have made life miserable for people who fall victim to that drug use
3) SF has nice weather and is generally more tolerant of people on drugs (California is the capital of working professionals with hard-drug habits)
4) Given the above, if you're down on your luck and drug addicted in the US, SF, Seattle, and LA are the only logical places to live in
5) For political reasons (SF is the home of leading progressives like Nancy Pelosi, Gavin Newsom, Kamala, etc.), there is a well-funded cultural apparatus trying to label SF as a failed state due to its own policies
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/San_Fransicko
by Michael Shellenberger
Id be really careful of taking anything people here say seriously. Its a politically divisive topic and the stuff ive seen in the comments are people getting riled up. The right wing loves to hate san francisco, the media loves to hate it too. Please consider there are multiple sides, people are being manipulated by media and outrage
In short, nothing happened to make SF this way, it's always been this way. The idea that SF is some left-wing exemplar is just as foolish as the idea that is was a good place to start start-ups. It's all hype. SF is kinda nasty. (Go check out what was going down here a few decades ago. But be warned, it's pretty fucked up. It's a story that culminates in the events at Jonestown. If you don't already know what that is, then you probably should not look it up.)
- SF has policies that encourages homeless to emigrate there, one of which is being pretty lenient to anyone who sets up camp on the streets
- SF allows open drug markets that has become a hotbed of criminal activity
- Police aren't fully empowered, and many people because of their ideology tend to hate police
- Lots of catch and release going on, both anecdotally and on news
- They offer drug kits (think needles, pipes, and other tools). The kit looked to be worth around $100
- They gave free alcohol/marijuana to homeless during lockdown
- A large subset of the population seem to give no shits about the city or other people: public urination, defecation, harassment, drug use, property theft, vandalism is common. The lack of enforcement has allowed these activities to increase
I only ever read that it's "because of the policies" and there are lots of rather disturbing videos about SF making its rounds on YouTube.
But what exactly happened? Did they just remove all the police? Did they gave out free drugs to everybody?
I'm not interested in blaming political parties, I just want to get a quick grasp of what exactly has happened.