News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by foldr on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @08:18AM (#35452829)
I'm mentioning homophobia because you've suggested that being LGBTQ is often caused by an underlying mental illness (doubling down on this claim here: https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=4gotunameagain), and because you've suggested that anyone who claims that homophobia is prevalent (in the 'coastal US', at least) is acting in bad faith and 'deliberately victimizing' themselves. Now you seem to be playing semantic games regarding the meaning of 'homophobia'. I won't try to change your mind here, but I think the majority of HNers will easily be able to see what I'm referring to.

On top of all that, this whole discussion resulted from one bullet point in a comment on an article that literally has nothing to do with LGBTQ people or homophobia. And yet you feel the need to argue all of these points here.

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by greatDEBONKER on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @11:44AM (#35456063)
You're arguing in bad faith here. As the poster you are replying to mentioned, you started claiming they were being 'homophobic' the moment they mentioned a viewpoint that you do not agree with. Name calling or labeling individuals into negative categorizations is a common tactic used by individuals whose world views are challenged by individuals who do not agree with them. Like mentioned above, hacker news contains viewpoints of individuals from a diverse community of individuals, that includes individuals who believe that LGBTQ is caused by mental illness. There is nothing wrong with having this viewpoint, and one cannot claim without any certainty that LGBTQ is not caused by mental illness as most scientific research is politically driven so no one will risk studying said topic and putting out a publication that asserts a viewpoint that is not within the accepted range of the societies current overton window.

> LGBTQ is often caused by an underlying mental illness Is not a homophobic statement. Nothing in this statement or assertion meets the definition of homophobia.

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by foldr on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @11:55AM (#35456233)
I disagree on this point. The idea that being gay or trans is a form of (or consequence of) mental illness is inherently homophobic. So is the idea that LGBTQ people 'deliberately victimize' themselves.

There is no bad faith here. Remember that you my also be exposed to points of view that you don't like – such as the one I just expressed.

Edit: I'd ask one question in response to your comment. You say that due to limitations of current scientific knowledge, 'one cannot claim without any certainty that LGBTQ is not caused by mental illness'. Ok, then can we be certain that being straight is not caused by mental illness? Which scientific studies could one cite to support or refute that claim?