I think if you would choose Java or Python or C#, then Rust might not be the right choice.
I've done a bit of Rust in my job, and there are some basic things that Rust doesn't have going for it:
- steep learning curve (this means for the first 6 months, you or your colleagues are unproductive, write bad Rust which your company then builds upon over time).
- bad error messages (even though that was a focus for the rust team!)
- frustratingly complex for setting up test coverage
- Slow analyzer speed (*super laggy* on Clion, though this might be a jetbrains issue)
- Slow compilation times (I heard somewhere that "Go just goes". I've also written some Go in my free time, and compilation is fast. Well IMHO, "rust will rust" - it's very slow. Generics can make compilation event slower.)
- Verbose. I've seen a just few lines of JS get replaced with hundreds and thousands of Rust.
I would love to hear more! (If you have the time.)
I recognize this is not entirely on rustc though.
Just recently I am making a comeback to rewriting a tokio 0.1 library to the latest version so I'll likely have a few examples that I can post... where? In GitHub issues?
Even if it is an "it hurts when I do this" without more context it can be useful to bring the problem to our attention (but the more context you provide the higher the change we'll fix the problem).
pub async fn foo() -> i32 {
unimplemented();
}
pub async fn bar() {
let f = await foo();
}
gives error: incorrect use of `await`
--> src/lib.rs:6:13
|
6 | let f = await foo();
| ^^^^^^^^^ help: `await` is a postfix operation: `foo().await`
It isn't on rustc to understand this either, but it helps a bunch of people, so the team does it anyway.I'll definitely do so going forward.
The problem is with that is the impostor syndrome: I legitimately can't tell if I am an idiot and skipped some basic Rust training, or the error messages are truly confusing and unproductive.
But your messages help. I'll just write those down and send them to GitHub's issue list.
> I legitimately can't tell if I am an idiot and skipped some basic Rust training, or the error messages are truly confusing and unproductive.
It doesn't make a difference. The compiler can't assume any level of proficiency. If a topic requires you to read the docs, it should tell you so. There are some "basic" things it relies on, but for anyone with any level of experience programming should be able to read a diagnostic and either understand it outright or have enough clues about what to search for. So "this error is confusing because I didn't read chapter N of The Book" can be simplified to "this error is confusing."
Please, more detail (=
new HTMLDivElement()
Rust: struct WebBrowser {
...The verbosity and complexity of `wasm_bindgen`/serialization between JS and Wasm (written in Rust) is primarily the thing I am frustrated at here when I see hundreds and thousands of Rust code. A concrete example: creating a Websocket client in Javascript/Typescript vs in Rust/Wasm.
In general though (outside of Wasm), Rust is less readable.
And with regards to Rust errors, I've found Rust errors related to Tonic and Diesel to be quite annoying/unreadable. The Diesel docs seem to blame Rust for this (can't find the docs for it right now).
eg Browsers provide JS functions that are intended for JS, which are not directly exposed to Wasm. So when your Wasm wants to access DOM things, access DOM functions, (etc) it needs to go through a JS shim layer instead of being able to call them directly.
If the browser dev's (or some W3C type of body?) introduced those same functions, but had them be directly accessible from wasm, then the JS shims wouldn't be needed.
The JS dev's for each of the browsers though would probably try and stop it ("security risk!" excuses, etc) though, as that would potentially cut into "their territory" and allow other languages to compete. :(
Btw, my impression that it would be blocked by JS people involved in the process, was from a conversation some time ago with one of the JS people themselves.
They said (from their point of view) there's no need for WASM to directly access things instead of going through JS, and they'd block it themselves if things went that direction. Security was the lever they mentioned they'd probably be able to use.
I'm curious to see those few lines of JS!
Rust lives in this interesting spot where, on paper, it should be superior to anything... but in practice, it's not a good choice in most cases.
It's very easy to ramp up someone in Go that's had a standard CS education and written C/C++ before. It's also simple enough syntax-wise for someone who knows python well enough to understand references, etc. Its stylistic restrictions and not being OOP-first also mean that codebases are generally readable. Compilation is also extremely straight forward.
With Rust, I've found even very experienced C++ folks have a long ramp-up period, the development toolchain is slow, and the ecosystem is limited.
Sure, for example there are projects to enable Rust usage with CUDA. But few are inclined to actually bother implementing a new BLAS and GPU accelerated tensor library with Rust.
I do think 10 years from now Rust will start getting more adoption as the ecosystem and tooling improve.
But it's hard to argue with Go where you'll typically get results that are faster or at worst comparable to Java without the OOP design pattern gobbledygook, simple concurrency model, and simple build process. It's "good enough" for 99% of use cases.
I've found C++ folks especially have the hardest time with Rust, because they approach it using C++ idioms and habits, then get frustrated when they can't do things the way they're used to.
I've had better success teaching Java people Rust. They find it much easier to learn than C++, and I can get them writing idiomatic Rust code quickly, while C++ devs are still trying to get their coding habits past the borrow checker.
Even when you get confident it is still a longer process writing code than C/C++. It makes you think very hard about what you do carelessly in C.
But having spent the last few years debugging a lot of Swift code, and a bit of Rust code, that time is worth it I say.
Where Rust shines is in the debug cycle. Less of it.
Once you learn to surrender to the compiler, you will find true bliss,....
Java is slow(er) to to startup, but once it's going, it's pretty good.
You may not have seen this if you haven't used Scala...
The most recent example was a Scala monolith. It had to use JVM 1.8 because <reasons> prevented migration to 11 (tried quite hard, but never succeeded). GC tuning doesn't really apply when considering start up delay, but yes it had been tuned over the years. Memory was not limited. The application, mainly due to Scala, had tens of thousands of classes. They all seemed to get JIT'ed on start up, which was the primary reason for the slow start up. People involved (who had come from heavy Scala shops like Twitter) seemed to think it was normal.
Stop -> deploy code -> start is simpler and less likely to go wrong.
I’d love to use C# without having to deal with distributing the runtime, so I’d like to hear more!
In the later versions of DotNet there are a couple of common ways to distribute (I'd suggest either DotNet 6 [LTS] or preferably DotNet 7 [current]).
You'd usually use the dotnet publish command, which ideally produces one of three things, all of which are self-contained and can be deployed to a clean server without any framework. Ordered by worst-first (in relation to your requirement):
1. The halfway house from dotnet publish is a folder with your app/site/api alongside all the dlls needed from the standard library and/or nuget. This is a standalone folder, though messy.
2. With an extra couple of options on the dotnet publish command you get it all as a single binary which is exactly what you say: a big executable.
3. There is another option available on the dotnet publish command which will use magic (probably tree-shaking but I can't remember) to produce a smaller single binary by removing unused code.
As an aside, it's also worth noting a couple of extra points:
* The dotnet publish command can cross-compile ready-to-deploy outputs for any supported platform (eg Mac or Linux, using x86, AMD64, or ARM64) just by specifying the combination of platform and CPU as command line options.
* Within C# you can mark your assets as embedded resources (like an embed FS in Go) and they will also be included in your output.
The final result varies in size depending upon what your code does (and hence included libraries), and some code (eg reflection) may interfere with the tree-shaking (or whatever) of option 3 - but it warns you whilst it generates the output, and you can either ignore it or use option 2.
Generally speaking the option 3 builds are between 1.5 and 2 times the size of a Go one, but you're looking about 20MB to 30MB for useful stuff. Not tiny, but still quite small these days. Option 2 builds probably double.
In use (and this is subjective) they consume a bit more memory than Go, but seem more consistent/stable in that usage.
Also note that within that 20MB-30MB build, for an api or a website you get a built-in web server that can sit behind nginx etc as usual, but is also good enough to expose directly.
I can't quite tell from the .NET SDK repository -- any idea if this stuff works on Linux (i.e. building on Linux, perhaps for Windows)? I see mention of MSBuild, so I'm guessing maybe not.
I love C#, but I abandoned it a while ago because I wanted to only rely on open source tools (just to ensure my code is usable in the future). Then, of course, they open-sourced a bunch of stuff (including the compiler). If I at least had the option to develop C# on Linux (with support for cross-compiling to Windows), that would be great (and honestly something I would have never expected 10 years ago).
Here's a link to the commands I use to generate my cross-platform builds [1]. They are easy enough to stick in a shell script or batch file so you get all the builds with one command. These produce single executables, trimmed for size.
[1] https://github.com/kcartlidge/Newt#generating-stand-alone-bu...
For CLI tools whilst a single binary can be convenient, native-image lets you get those for JVM programs too these days. But it's not always the case that it's enough. In practice you will often hit the need for:
a. Cross platform / cross builds.
b. A way to easily update them for your users (that isn't "everyone mount this NFS/SMB drive")
c. Ability to ship other files e.g. third party libraries written in other languages, config files, data files, readmes ...
d. Possibly, avoiding virus scanners and Gatekeeper if you have users on Windows/macOS.
Conveyor [1] does support distributing CLI tools (in any language) that can then be updated via apt-get, the Windows package manager or Sparkle on macOS. If your language/runtime supports cross-building then it can do it all from your developer laptop, you don't need each OS to build for. The resulting artifacts are single files (deb, msix/exe, zip) and it supports both self-signing and regular signing if you want that.
It provides a few other neat features on Windows:
• One click install that immediately adds new tools to every single terminal session without needing restarts.
• If you want, silent background updates Chrome-style. If you don't, manually triggered updates.
• For JVM apps specifically it automatically configures the Windows terminal to support ANSI escapes, Unicode and other modern features so you can use all the same stuff as on UNIX without needing to futz around with win32 or wrappers.
Unfortunately the little default GUI that lets you trigger updates and add CLI tools to your path on macOS isn't officially launched yet, because it only works for JVM apps and not other types of program. But if anyone wants to try it just let me know, it's easy to activate.
If you don't need any such features then yes, a single binary can be a bit more convenient than a zip. But the number of situations where it breaks down is pretty high and it's not so hard to handle multiple files.
Your comment is super interesting, don't let me sound like I'm trying to shoot it down. I'm being deliberately terse to avoid creating receptors for language war antigens to bind to.
My feelings on this changed over time. About 10-15 years ago I thought single executable output was a critical feature for a language, because everywhere I went I saw people saying how important it was for them, how much simpler it made deployment. I figured, OK, people know what they want so that's what they should get.
Then Docker came along. Docker images aren't single files, they're the polar opposite. They aren't even things you directly manipulate using the filesystem at all. Yet people loved it and it took over the world. Clearly what all those people demanding single-file executables were actually wanting in 95% of cases was simpler deployment, and they were phrasing it as single executable because that was concrete and understandable whereas simpler deployment is a very vague concept so who knows what you'd get if you asked for it.
For people who are selecting Go or Rust or Graal native images primarily because of single-file output, I'd actually really appreciate a chance to ask a few questions or interview them quickly to learn more about the deployment context. Conveyor is all about deployment and it's good to understand more about how people are doing things and what could be better.
I like go, but I wouldn't prototype in it, I'd pick julia or python. And if I'm familiar with the problem and want to code for production, rust really doesn't seem any slower to develop in than go to me and perhaps a bit less verbose. But in retrospect I think that is because of the direction I came at rust from means my habitual coding style lined up more closely with what rust expects. Its not a harder coding mindset, just a different one than someone who came from java would be used to.
I recently wrote an asynchronous microservice in C++, because it needed to use a C++ library I'd already written. Took about two weeks of effort, and clocked in at 1500 loc, not counting tests or the half-dozen external dependencies. I rewrote it in 100 lines of idiomatic Go using nothing except the standard library a few days ago. That's a 10x reduction in both lines of code and development time, although it's a bit unfair because I had already done the C++ version first. That is after giving up on a Rust version that was already weighing in at ~1000 LOC in an unfinished state.
After this experience, I don't think I'd ever use C++ or Rust again for a concurrent web service, unless there was hard real-time latency requirements. Golang is just so much better streamlined for that application, and the standard library is batteries included.
But yeah, if I was writing an embedded firmware or something I would absolutely prefer Rust.
I think Rust will see a lot of adoption in web services that are glorified CRUD APIs. It would have been a poor choice to do many of these workloads in this in C or C++ (despite the data point of Amazon 1.0 LOLz).
Time to iterate is also only much faster in certain situations, e.g. local development; if you have to e.g. build a container image, push to a registry, and redeploy to a k8s cluster somewhere, those savings become somewhere between less significant and nonexistent.
Can you expand on what you mean here? I know you're not implying Rust is faster to move thru a CICD pipeline, so can you tell me what you do mean? I seem to be unable to make a different reading
If Rust is helping you make prototypes and iterate quickly, I’d love to hear how you’re using the language.
I suspect it has to do with how familiar you are with type systems, and the way that you use them. I find that Rust's constraints help guide me towards a solution more quickly, and I spend less time chasing down strange edge cases. Not eliminate! But reduce.
I really don't see how anyone choses nodejs/deno to anything.
Java imo gives you much less trouble, is more stable, has a working (!!!) Unit testing setup and exceptional runtime.
Next on my list is to give rust a go, since I'm intrigued by its features, but if I was to go fast I'd go with java any day.
I went back and prototyped a slightly similar app in Python w/ a gui toolkit and I felt like I was driving through exception city. I have made my career writing in dynamic languages so I forgot just how pleasant it was to write in a static one!
Sorry, this is always the wrong choice, which is why it felt so bad.
Writing a UI in TypeScript with any of the major frontend frameworks will not require you to wade through run-time exceptions
Java native GUI toolkits are also far more mature
Python and TKinter and similar stuff is always just awful, I've never seen someone put together anything half decent with that stack
Theres another app that I use for renaming downloaded video files that uses a GUI toolkit.
I've written GUIs in pyGTK for industrial apps and it was a wonderful experience. The only reason I couldn't get it to work now because I can't get pygobject to compile on Windows (the offered solution of MSYS2... wasnt)
Unfortunately this project was working with Stable Diffusion, so I had to use something in Python
In any case I don't like this idea of a right or wrong answer here. LIke way too many people think Electron is a right answer and I think that's just dumb
This is going to sound mean but I don't really know how to phrase it more nicely. People building backends in js/ts are doing so because either they, or a critical mass of the people they expect to code in it, don't know any better backend languages.
I don't mean for this to be judge-y. People have different skillsets. A nodejs backend can be the right choice if you're a full-stack dev or a solo dev and you mainly know js and you get a lot of agility and correctness by using what you know instead of trying to use a "better" choice but one that you yourself are less likely to use correctly or quickly in your own use case.
It can also be the right choice if you're a big backend java/etc guru but you know you want to set this thing up but then just monitor/oversee frontend/fullstack devs being the ones who do incremental modifications to it.
But yeah - without additional outside constraints and everything else being equal, it doesn't make a lot of sense to use nodejs as opposed to basically anything more boring - be it java, rails, etc.
The thing that surprises me the most about node based backends is that they forego both the platform maturity and static-safety of java AND the ridiculous amount of batteries included into django and rails, just to be able to use javascript, of all things. What you could rails-g in a minute you could instead spend a day looking for an npm package that won't be abandoned in a month or spend eternity rolling your own everything and then maintaining it.
They accomplish things like built-time code generation, static server-side rendering, and other kinds of code transformation that are difficult and flaky without a back end that can understand JS.
I have looked for non-tinkertoy solutions in Java and Go. There aren't any, and senior people in those communities are hostile to the very idea. (Maybe remembering Java Nashorn?) Maybe the only people friendly to the idea of interoperable back ends are Rust people (where you have libraries like Yew/Sycamore/Dioxus/Leptos that actively imitate JS frameworks).
But yes, your claim is that the only reason to write JS back ends is ignorance and enfeeblement is ignorant and repugnant.
But for business logic, database interactions, calculations, etc, I really think the language construct is to clumsy and does not scale nicely.
You can ingest and emit JSON in any language. You can even compile backend-friendly code to run in JS on the frontend, via emscripten (and increasingly, Wasm), which will output very lean and JIT-friendly code. The usual "isomorphic" case for backend.js is no less 'presumptuous' or 'dismissive' than the comment you're pointing to and criticizing here.
> You can ingest and emit JSON in any language.
How is this relevant? Serving a JS application to a client is not like serving a JSON API. > You can even compile backend-friendly code to run in JS on the frontend, via emscripten (and increasingly, Wasm), which will output very lean and JIT-friendly code.
Not in my experience. Compared to front-to-back JS, shipping your applications as WASM ends up with downloads and memory footprints that are several times larger than the same application in ordinary JS, and this matters a lot for slower networks and mobile clients.Edit: not to mention that Go has a very limited WASM story, so your "realistic" choices for shipping back end code to the front end are C++ and Rust.
In some JS applications, the way the frontend code communicates with the backend is via JSON API endpoints. I believe GP was just pointing out that you can write that JSON API in any language you want.
> not to mention that Go has a very limited WASM story, so your "realistic" choices for shipping back end code to the front end are C++ and Rust.
Can you elaborate on this? How is it limited in comparison to say, Rust.
As far as file sizes go, you're right. It might be possible to get better results deploying a brotli'd or gzipped file instead[1].
[0]:https://tinygo.org/docs/reference/lang-support/stdlib/ [1]:https://github.com/golang/go/wiki/WebAssembly#reducing-the-s...
> You can even compile backend-friendly code to run in JS on the frontend, via emscripten (and increasingly, Wasm)
Lol, you can't be serious
If you are referring to something similar to Blazor (client side), yeah no imo it's pretty awful for anything other than internal enterprise apps. I couldn't imagine running a public facing product on that.
All languages come with tradeoffs in terms of performance, development/maintenance cost and ease of hiring. Most businesses only care superficially about performance, which leaves developer productivity and ease of hiring. Node/typescript isn't terrible in terms of developer productivity, and it's got the best hiring story of any language. Python is good in both those ways too, but since you already need a javascript hiring pipeline for the client it's easier just to use node and hire full stack devs.
It is not Node V. Python, but Node V Java
Python is a terrible choice as a backend, too.
It has a place as a scripting language, but so often it is used to build complete systems. They suck.
handlebars, terra, askama, and maud are examples I recognize from high up on that list.
Maud example: (chosen because it's the most "native Rust" in a sense and is designed for HTML specifically so I believe it's the closest to what you're asking for)
html! {
h1 { "Hello, world!" }
p.intro {
"This is an example of the "
a href="https://github.com/lambda-fairy/maud" { "Maud" }
" template language."
}
}
https://maud.lambda.xyz/I hate configuring typescript and having to deal with bundlers, package.json, esbuild, etc.
But Deno and Bun are just around the corner. What we need is to get rid of this a la carte mentality around tooling and just give everyone Typescript, batteries included, and make it fast.
Then Node really isn’t that bad anymore.
And for all of its faults, NodeJS can be fun compared to something like Java which feels more like doing taxes. Maybe it's the danger. Maybe it's the fact there are so many packages and libraries out there - everyone can contribute! Who knows, but I won't waste my time learning say Rails just to use a "better" backend framework. It's good enough even though I know better. There are way more important things.
Spring boot is great but it does have its quirks. Config and plumbing for instance compare to Nest or Rails doesn’t makes it the best and fastest dev experience. And all the Java extra stuff and it’s ecosystem makes it solid but also old compare to what you can see happening in other languages.
I have Quarkus in my mind though. It looks amazing in dev experience with lib like panache, resteasy etc… and performance are amazing too which comes as a bonus. But there is no dev out there. And I feel that in Java people want to work on Spring Boot because spending X years working on Spring Boot are more valuable in their career than X years on something else that is not really the de facto standard of the industry. So ya not great for hiring talented people…
But NestJS with the JS/TS ecosystem start to be very close to what Rails was in the past. Stuff like Prisma for instance makes everything a breeze. There is almost always a package for the thing you want. Great at websocket too. Can do GraphQL if it’s your thing. Same language as the front end, Nextjs, etc. One of the most performant dynamic languages. And interesting things happening like Deno or using Rust with it. So there are quite some perks to it.
Can’t speak about Django though. But I am wondering how is the dev experience like when we use it for real projects.
I am starting a new project/startup and wondering which one to start it with between all these technologies. And after looking for a long time I can see that they really all comes with their pros and cons.
That could be a sign of “stability”.
I’m personally using Django since two years ago and have the same feeling as yours, there are nothing exciting happening in this area, but after two years of use I came to the conclusion that it’s features are too stable, so nothing new need to happen in the first place.
It’s a common myth that software should be always updating and introducing new features. No, it’s not, if it can solve the problem great it doesn’t need to change at all.
JS/TS/Rust are still in their exploration phase, new ideas, new exprimentations, new frameworks come and go everyday, and that’ the reason they look vibrant.
Before settle down with Django, for years I’ve used bleeding edge tech like Meteorjs/React/Nextjs/Vue/Nuxtjs/Svelte/SvelteKit/… in real world, or try to rewrite real world app with them, and the biggest problem of all of them is that they all have their quirks and things in JavaScript area are changing too often and too much, I’m so tired to chase all these fancy new ideas.
For 90% web apps Django+Htmx+AlpineJS can serve me good and do all the things that new tech can do easily, at the same time keep incredible stability.
I believe Rails or Laraval are same here, you don’t need to switch in 90% cases, just relex and appreciate the stability they bring.
For Rails the thing is that it’s not just one lib among a huge ecosystem like Python but more or less Ruby = Ruby on Rails. Sure you have Sinatra which is the Flask of Ruby but that’s it. While in Python you can do so many other things from devops to ML to eBPF…
Hotwire is an exciting technology coming out of Ruby/Rails ecosystem. Rails 7 was an important release bringing a lot of great features and Rails 7.1 looks even better.
Ruby has a lot of nice advances as language starting with 2.7 and continuing to the recent release of 3.2. Check the recent changes at https://rubyreferences.github.io
IMHO Ruby and its eco-system is the perfect mix of tech that works while trying to get right some of the most important modern approaches.
Specifically regarding the
> But realistically unless if you plan to do a rewrite, which is never a good idea, it may not be the best option out there
This is not directed to you but more a general rant :)
I hate with passion (and yes I am biased) this line of thinking because it is not true in maybe 90% of the cases. And it is not true when one says that about almost any established language that should be used where it fits (or where it is used the most).
What I write below applies to an average company mostly doing Saas/CRUD/web apps. If you are working at FAANG or FAANG-like companies maybe this does not apply to you.
Be sincere:
- Say that you want to pick something that will increase your hiring skills if you are a developer, or that you want to brag to your friends that you are using what Amazon/Google is using or that you want to speak to conferences about the latest big tech
- Or say that you don't like Ruby and just want to choose something else. That is fine.
- Or if you are a director of engineering/leader/manager say that you can hire JS developers cheaper or that offering a cool/hype technology is the only way to attract new people or that you want to feel safe in front of board members/GM/CEO by saying we failed to solve this even if we use everything that FAANG uses.
But please don't say that you don't choose Rails because you might grow so much that you will need to rewrite.
I don't know one single example where a company died because they choose Rails. Just the decision to rewrite a product on its own is a high risk of failing. It does not matter the from:, to: parameters.
And again I need to say to anyone thinking to start a project in Ruby/Rails but thinking they need to choose otherwise: You are not Google, nor Netflix, Amazon, .... You (probably) don't need anything from their tools or architecture that makes them offer concurrent services to hundred of millions of users.
Try to have 10k users first and then I think you will probably have the mindset + management experience to hire Ruby devs or to help a new hire to learn Ruby.
The total number of job offers in Rails have been going down for quite a long time now.
If you look at the Stackoverflow surveys and compare the professional respondents for Ruby and RoR between 2021 and then 2022. It’s a 20% decrease. It’s a lot.
Critical contributors of Rails and its ecosystem left for Rust, Elixir, etc. For instance the guy that was behind Active Record went to Rust. Or the creator of Elixir itself and many other followed. On the other hand I don’t see prohiminent open source contributors coming to Ruby to at least replace them… I have been doing Rails myself for almost a decade now and I can tell you that many Rails devs want or already switched to Phoenix or other languages. It’s not going up.
Many gems are mature for sure and don’t really need anymore commits. But also many are abandoned with PRs and issues stacking up. The ecosystem is not really increasing anymore even more vibrant.
Now with all that said: is it impossible to find a job in Rails today? No. Is it impossible to find some devs? No. Is it going to disappear in 4 years? No. Are you going to make a big mistake using it today? No. But there are now so many other options out there without any of these cons and some other pros that it starts to be more and more difficult to chose Rails as a solution today to start a company. Unless you want to use Rails for a side project you can’t ignore these issues and all the other options we now have out there.
About rewrites. It’s not just about the technical part. It’s also the human part. Let’s say I hire you and we grow and there is also 3-10 more Rail devs. But a rewrite has to happen. Are you going to be so exited to jeopardize all your experience in Rails to switch to something new? Even if you are the other 2-9 devs may not. And let’s say more or less everybody agrees that a rewrite has to happen, now you still have to agree on which language and which framework you are going to use! Some may really want to do Go, some Elxir, some other TS…
Whatever the solution that will be chosen there will be a lot of frustrations. Plus there will be frustrations on the tech part of the rewrite and they have to start to be slowly getting more and more productive to the new tech where something that could have taken 1 day can take 5 now. All this, particularly the frustrations from switching to a tech where some won’t really like, will slow down a lot the company. When you check postmortems of startups that failed, so many times in the reasons why they failed there will be this “and we decided to do a rewrite…”. But I never saw a company failed and they will still say that the rewrite was a great idea.
With all that said: better pick the right solution today and look at all the options. Not the Google one, not the one that decrease but one that is at least solid to vibrant, not the last hyped one either, but the best one.
I truly love Rails. But I can’t just chose it because I love it. There are now better options out there for the long term future.
To do the same in java means making a billion model files with a billion transformation functions on them
I've been saying that for a while. If you're building web backends, Rust is not a good choice. Go is so much easier. The green thread system gets rid of the thread/async distinction, garbage collection means you don't have to obsess over memory management, and the libraries for web backend stuff are the same things Google uses internally, so they're well-tested.
A big problem with Rust, long-term, is that the kind of programs that really need it are somewhat out of today's mainstream. It's not that useful for webcrap. It's not that useful for phone apps. The AI people use Jupyter notebooks and Python to drive code on GPUs.
Where do you really need Rust? Heavy-duty multi-threaded programming. Operating systems. Compilers. Routers and network infrastructure. Robotics, maybe. Hard real time. It ought to be used more for high-performance games, but the game infrastructure isn't there yet. Unreal Engine is C++ and Unity is C#. Rust has Bevy and Rend3, but they're not AAA title ready.
Perhaps Rust is fighting the last war - the mess inside C++.
In any case, if you are trying to optimize microsecond usage in AWS lambda I hope you have a truly gargantuan amount of traffic and/or have incredibly cheap engineers or the money saved will barely match up to the cost of the engineering hours sunk into them.
https://andre.arko.net/2018/10/25/parsing-logs-230x-faster-w...
two minor follow-ups on that as well:
* https://andre.arko.net/2019/01/11/parsing-logs-faster-with-r...
* https://andre.arko.net/2022/03/13/parsing-logs-faster-with-r...
Additionally for the case mentioned, the log parsing apparently already fit quite comfortably in the free tier of AWS lambda. Rubygems.org seems to get its developer time for free, so Andre can keep tuning this log parser as a hobby experiment (in the best sense of the word, nothing wrong with having fun). But TFA was about building a startup and most of those definitely don't manage to get their devs to work for free.
Rust async support was only released in late 2018. Not very long at all, especially if compared to Golang.
One thing this is missing is that Rust is useful for libraries callable by many different languages. You may or may not want to use it to build an actual Web app (I personally think it's a solid choice, but reasonable people can disagree). But for building, say, the Python cryptography library [1], which is used as a part of "webcrap", Jupyter notebooks, and in many other domains, Rust is clearly an excellent option. Nobody is going to build core Python infrastructure in Go or Node, and without the plumbing libraries none of the higher-level applications can function.
Adding another language in the middle will only complicate our toolchain.
Regarding Python, with the pressure from Ruby, PHP, JS and Julia JIT compilers, they will eventually get more serious about JIT adoption, and then there is ctypes of OS APIs.
[0]: https://www.usenix.org/system/files/1311_05-08_mickens.pdf
You may be underestimating the amount of need there is for performant code though. Its everywhere.
This heuristic wouldn't work for my department because we build web backends in C++. I keep telling the most senior devs here that nobody does this and for good reasons (velocity etc), and their response is "who cares what the rest of the world does."
Yeah, it matters to have something new hires can use, which is one of the big flaws in not caring about the outside world. Our team lost three people recently because they took the job expecting low-to-mid level C++ type work and instead got this web stuff and got bored. It's either that or they get web people who struggle not to create segfaults.
Go authors always disliked C++, and got a manager that allowed them to work on their toy language, which eventually became Go.
The thing here is that most web backends are basic CRUD bullshit, and you fundamentally will not hit the thread/async distinction, nor need to care about whether there's garbage collection or not. Microsoft has used actix-web in production as far as I know, it's not like the Rust web stack isn't battle tested.
>Where do you really need Rust? Heavy-duty multi-threaded programming. Operating systems. Compilers. Routers and network infrastructure. Robotics, maybe. Hard real time.
These are all the things that sit adjacent to a web framework, and once you step outside that CRUD happy path, Rust fits very well - and in this case just "bolts on".
>It's not that useful for phone apps.
This is more tangential but I know of more than a few companies who have written or are writing their cross-platform logic in Rust instead of C++. This is really akin to how some projects back Python modules with Rust: it's easy to have it backing things and it beats the hell out of dealing with C++.
And look, I'm not even saying don't use Go/Python/JS/<insert your preferred language here>. You do you, your startup will live or die by so many other things than choice of programming language.
Most of my data, cost and performance requirements aren’t suited to the likes of FiveTran/etc, and whilst I could theoretically use Python, it’s far too slow, and the propensity to crash unexpectedly (meaning I have to spend extra time debugging) means the development velocity is actually worse than just writing it in Rust. Plus, most of the libs and tooling I’d use from Python are available in Rust.
I’ve also written Rest and GRPC API’s in Rust (mostly for serving up data and being a query layer), and found it a far more pleasant experience than Python/Typescript/C#. Admittedly a somewhat ”smaller” use-case than a lot of what people would consider web-API’s but still.
Internally Google uses no web and most of the backends are in C++.
If you’re building a large complex app that needs to be shared across multiple platforms, C++ is a common choice. Not talking about games here, think Office, Facebook, Zoom, WebEx etc. It easy to see Rust replacing C++ in that stack.
But as Rust is so much nicer that C++, I could see it becoming popular for smaller projects that want to share common logic, with a native UI on top.
One strength of C++ is that it is far more established than rust - and that comes with a lot of advantages:
* It has a larger number of people who know how to work with it
* It has a huge catalog of established, fully functional libraries for everything you could imagine from UI to game development to embedded systems to simulation to anything else
* It has broad support in developer toolsets in general like editors and IDEs, static analysis tools, formatters, pre-commit hooks, etc
If I'm starting a new project with C++, I can immediately know that there's a huge landscape of programming already carved up and ready to work with. I can't do that as easily in Rust. The language, the libraries, the tools are all younger. Some of it isn't as fully featured, some of it isn't nearly as stable.
That will improve with time, but it's a huge advantage to C++ right now.
They didn't say Rust is almost always better than C/C++.
There's perhaps the implication there, but it's certainly not explicit in the GP's comments.
I'm painfully aware of this. Typical Rust problem, from a reply I made to a posting on Reddit:
* WebGPU dev: WGPU updated to 0.15!
* Me: Might want to hold off on upgrading for a bit. See (bug report on related package)
* WebGPU dev: Good to know. I'll keep this in mind if someone has any issues when following my tutorial
* Me: I'm using Egui/rend3/wgpu/winit/vulkan cross platform on Linux and Windows, with cross-compiling. Getting all those crates to play well together is not easy. Every time something in that stack changes, it's days or weeks of trouble.
Sadly, it's not really an advantage anywhere that hasn't already eaten the grief and doesn't already use C++.
Both C and C++ infrastructure are so horribly terrible that Zig is gaining traction simply by creating a better compiling infastructure totally indepdent of whether the language is better or not.
That's one hell of a downvote.
One the one hand, Go/Node/Python/etc doesn't scratch my itch for the strong type system (sum types/tagged enums mostly) and on the other hand even though I like prototyping in Rust I really miss things like a REPL, more terse syntax, and a bit more expressiveness.
I think O'Caml is closer to my ideal but the ecosystem isn't quite there. Maybe all it needs is time.
This might help with cleanup: https://github.com/tc39/proposal-explicit-resource-managemen...
But I'm not sure anything will help with the type system. For example, this drives me absolutely insane: https://www.typescriptlang.org/play#code/MYewdgziA2CmB00QHMA...
I've never really had a problem with it, but I isolate such resources behind a wrapper, which makes cleanup easy. I just create a little higher-order function:
function doSomethingThatNeedsCleanup(fn) {
const thing = createTheThing();
try {
return fn(thing);
}
finally {
cleanUpTheThing(thing);
}
}
> this drives me absolutely insane (console.log(["10", "10", "10"].map(parseInt) outputs [10, NaN, 2])That's not really an issue with the type system, that's just coincidence and bad luck.
The signature of parseInt is:
parseInt(string: string, radix?: number | undefined): number
And Array<string>.map(fn) takes a function with the signature: fn(element: string, index?: number | undefined, array?: string[] | undefined): any
So parseInt coincidentally matches the signature Array<string>.map() is looking for.I'm not sure what you expect the type system to do here. It works just fine at catching an actual type error, such as this:
console.log([10, 10, 10].map(parseInt)
...which correctly complains: Argument of type '(string: string, radix?: number | undefined) => number' is not assignable to parameter of type '(value: number, index: number, array: number[]) => number'.
Types of parameters 'string' and 'value' are incompatible.
Type 'number' is not assignable to type 'string'.
(As I'm sure you know, this is the correct code: `console.log(["10", "10", "10"].map(s => parseInt(s))` .)If that were true I'd not mind quite as much... but actually, parseInt takes two parameters and map passes three.
Again, this isn’t a type system issue. It’s both an API design issue and a poor programming hygiene issue. (Don’t pass bare functions if you don’t know what the parameters are.)
I mean, map always passes them in, so in that sense they aren't optional. Mixing that with functions that take in optional parameters, but aren't usually called with them, gives you a ticking time bomb, IMO. And double that danger when the language's type system allows you to call a function with more parameters than it could ever take.
> Don’t pass bare functions if you don’t know what the parameters are.
This is exactly the kind of thing I want my programming language's type system to catch for me, if I'm working in a language with a static type system like TS.
And even in dynamic languages, this is exactly the kind of thing I want my programming language to catch for me at runtime. Python does, for example.
Stuff like this - while it might fit JS and TS and make sense to some - makes absolutely no sense to me, and is why I simply look to other languages to fit my needs.
>> Don’t pass bare functions if you don’t know what the parameters are.
> This is exactly the kind of thing I want my programming language's type system to catch for me, if I'm working in a language with a static type system like TS.
Hows your compiler supposed to know you don't know what the parameters are?
In TS you really can't (that's my point and why I prefer to avoid the language) because of JS and API baggage. But just about every other static language that I've worked in can complain for this kind of thing.
> Hows your compiler supposed to know you don't know what the parameters are?
Why does the compiler care about what I know? The compiler itself knows what the function's parameters are and it can tell me that something seems wrong because I'm asking it to call a function that maxes out at 2 parameters with 3 parameters.
TS does catch this kind of thing in a lot of places. It just intentionally decides not to do it for these kinds of callbacks because of the same JS and API baggage.
> But I'm not sure anything will help with the type system. For example, this drives me absolutely insane: https://www.typescriptlang.org/play#code/MYewdgziA2CmB00QHMA...
You just gave me CPTSD, thank you. This motivated me enough so that I will leave JavaScript and TypeScript for good now.I've found that the basic NodeJS or Python works for most problems I've chosen. Not even with strong typing.
But if Rust exists, suddenly you have a nicer-to-use high performance language, and you have a choice to use it.
I’m currently rewriting what I wrote in Rust to see how the prototypes compare and… I just feel so much at peace knowing that the type system and the borrow checker have my back and that I won’t encounter unexpected nil pointers or zero values. And I write this quickly as well.
(Yes, I do have experience with both languages, so none of these exercises were new to me. But I’ve been favoring Rust over the last couple of years.)
In Go you have a garbage collector, no need for the borrow checker or reference counting on your side. What unexpected nil pointers or zeros? It’s all easy and straightforward in Go. If you’re referring to the handling of materialized interfaces, which one may encounter in form of concrete error types, and which is one of Go’s idiosyncrasies, then it might help to look deeper into learning how to handle Go’s interfaces.
Maybe compared to C, Go is quite concise, but Go is nowhere near Rust's level of expressiveness, especially with poor generics support, much more verbose error handling etc.
> no need for the borrow checker or reference counting on your side.
I think that people that mention borrow checker in context of backend dev haven't done much backend dev in Rust. The nature of a web backend is to (most of the time) get data from the client, process, return a response. In this context you very rarely have to think about borrow checker and almost never use explicit lifetimes.
> What unexpected nil pointers or zeros? It’s all easy and straightforward in Go
If you forget to initialize a struct, you may end up with a nil pointer and you might not catch it until runtime.
Seeing Rust as a system programming language only is missing the bigger picture (IMO).
"What kind of startup would fail because it uses Rust ?"
Then check if said startup matches that description.
If your answer is something like Go or Node.js, then Rust is probably not the right choice.
If your answer is C or C++ or something similar, then Rust is very likely the right choice.
Obv, there are always exceptions here, but this helps you work through things a bit more objectively. Rust can be a fantastic language for many purposes, but it has a very high development cost.