I would love to hear more! (If you have the time.)
I recognize this is not entirely on rustc though.
Just recently I am making a comeback to rewriting a tokio 0.1 library to the latest version so I'll likely have a few examples that I can post... where? In GitHub issues?
Even if it is an "it hurts when I do this" without more context it can be useful to bring the problem to our attention (but the more context you provide the higher the change we'll fix the problem).
pub async fn foo() -> i32 {
unimplemented();
}
pub async fn bar() {
let f = await foo();
}
gives error: incorrect use of `await`
--> src/lib.rs:6:13
|
6 | let f = await foo();
| ^^^^^^^^^ help: `await` is a postfix operation: `foo().await`
It isn't on rustc to understand this either, but it helps a bunch of people, so the team does it anyway.I'll definitely do so going forward.
The problem is with that is the impostor syndrome: I legitimately can't tell if I am an idiot and skipped some basic Rust training, or the error messages are truly confusing and unproductive.
But your messages help. I'll just write those down and send them to GitHub's issue list.
> I legitimately can't tell if I am an idiot and skipped some basic Rust training, or the error messages are truly confusing and unproductive.
It doesn't make a difference. The compiler can't assume any level of proficiency. If a topic requires you to read the docs, it should tell you so. There are some "basic" things it relies on, but for anyone with any level of experience programming should be able to read a diagnostic and either understand it outright or have enough clues about what to search for. So "this error is confusing because I didn't read chapter N of The Book" can be simplified to "this error is confusing."
Please, more detail (=
new HTMLDivElement()
Rust: struct WebBrowser {
...The verbosity and complexity of `wasm_bindgen`/serialization between JS and Wasm (written in Rust) is primarily the thing I am frustrated at here when I see hundreds and thousands of Rust code. A concrete example: creating a Websocket client in Javascript/Typescript vs in Rust/Wasm.
In general though (outside of Wasm), Rust is less readable.
And with regards to Rust errors, I've found Rust errors related to Tonic and Diesel to be quite annoying/unreadable. The Diesel docs seem to blame Rust for this (can't find the docs for it right now).
eg Browsers provide JS functions that are intended for JS, which are not directly exposed to Wasm. So when your Wasm wants to access DOM things, access DOM functions, (etc) it needs to go through a JS shim layer instead of being able to call them directly.
If the browser dev's (or some W3C type of body?) introduced those same functions, but had them be directly accessible from wasm, then the JS shims wouldn't be needed.
The JS dev's for each of the browsers though would probably try and stop it ("security risk!" excuses, etc) though, as that would potentially cut into "their territory" and allow other languages to compete. :(
Btw, my impression that it would be blocked by JS people involved in the process, was from a conversation some time ago with one of the JS people themselves.
They said (from their point of view) there's no need for WASM to directly access things instead of going through JS, and they'd block it themselves if things went that direction. Security was the lever they mentioned they'd probably be able to use.
I'm curious to see those few lines of JS!
Rust lives in this interesting spot where, on paper, it should be superior to anything... but in practice, it's not a good choice in most cases.
It's very easy to ramp up someone in Go that's had a standard CS education and written C/C++ before. It's also simple enough syntax-wise for someone who knows python well enough to understand references, etc. Its stylistic restrictions and not being OOP-first also mean that codebases are generally readable. Compilation is also extremely straight forward.
With Rust, I've found even very experienced C++ folks have a long ramp-up period, the development toolchain is slow, and the ecosystem is limited.
Sure, for example there are projects to enable Rust usage with CUDA. But few are inclined to actually bother implementing a new BLAS and GPU accelerated tensor library with Rust.
I do think 10 years from now Rust will start getting more adoption as the ecosystem and tooling improve.
But it's hard to argue with Go where you'll typically get results that are faster or at worst comparable to Java without the OOP design pattern gobbledygook, simple concurrency model, and simple build process. It's "good enough" for 99% of use cases.
I've found C++ folks especially have the hardest time with Rust, because they approach it using C++ idioms and habits, then get frustrated when they can't do things the way they're used to.
I've had better success teaching Java people Rust. They find it much easier to learn than C++, and I can get them writing idiomatic Rust code quickly, while C++ devs are still trying to get their coding habits past the borrow checker.
Even when you get confident it is still a longer process writing code than C/C++. It makes you think very hard about what you do carelessly in C.
But having spent the last few years debugging a lot of Swift code, and a bit of Rust code, that time is worth it I say.
Where Rust shines is in the debug cycle. Less of it.
Once you learn to surrender to the compiler, you will find true bliss,....
I've done a bit of Rust in my job, and there are some basic things that Rust doesn't have going for it:
- steep learning curve (this means for the first 6 months, you or your colleagues are unproductive, write bad Rust which your company then builds upon over time).
- bad error messages (even though that was a focus for the rust team!)
- frustratingly complex for setting up test coverage
- Slow analyzer speed (*super laggy* on Clion, though this might be a jetbrains issue)
- Slow compilation times (I heard somewhere that "Go just goes". I've also written some Go in my free time, and compilation is fast. Well IMHO, "rust will rust" - it's very slow. Generics can make compilation event slower.)
- Verbose. I've seen a just few lines of JS get replaced with hundreds and thousands of Rust.