News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by wffurr on Friday February 17, 2023 @07:27AM (#34833841)
There's 138 trains per day between Amsterdam and The Hague. It's faster to take the train than to drive on that trip. Driving in either city in an exercise in frustration. Why would anyone in a rich country with a high functioning rail system like The Netherlands want to drive?

I don't know how many rich countries that describes, but I lived happily for years in Boston in the USA without a car. I have one now but only because I have an off-street parking space for it. Otherwise I'd go back to renting one on the ~monthly occasions I want to use one. The main benefit of Zipcar to me versus owning is that the car had a parking space that it went back into.

Now if only the mass transit system in the area wasn't falling apart and the rail connections to other cities were even half as good as the ones in the Netherlands.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by fruit2020 on Friday February 17, 2023 @07:37AM (#34833931)
It’s faster if you live next to the train station and your work is next to the destination station. Anyway, for some people is better one way than the other
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by mcv on Friday February 17, 2023 @08:23AM (#34834328)
A lot of business parks are close to a station for that very reason.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by moffkalast on Friday February 17, 2023 @07:46AM (#34833993)
The problem with that is the part where you need to get to and from the train station to your actual destination, which could be on the very other side of town. It can be solved with shuttles or taxis, but that adds even more complexity and annoyance than just driving directly, especially with luggage.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by david-gpu on Friday February 17, 2023 @07:54AM (#34834064)
Bike sharing services are great in those situations. You don't even need to carry your bike in the train. There is also public transit like trams and buses.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by pc86 on Friday February 17, 2023 @08:35AM (#34834467)
I didn't see many bikes in Amsterdam capable of conveying luggage.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by david-gpu on Friday February 17, 2023 @08:55AM (#34834658)
How frequently do people need to carry luggage? The space afforded by a backpack or panniers on a regular bike suffices for most people most of the time.

We can all conjure circumstances when it is difficult or inconvenient to use public transit, but deep down we all know most people most of the time are driving their cars alone with minimal cargo and the reason they are driving is because our towns are designed to make it as convenient as possible.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by bluGill on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:45AM (#34835210)
It is hard to get groceries for a family into panniers. I did it while I was single, but now that there is a family to feed things don't fit. Even if you go shopping daily, a lot of things don't fit at all.

I've used my bike trailer for groceries. You have to be careful that you don't buy more than fits, but it works.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by oefnak on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:08AM (#34834792)
There's plenty of 'bakfietsen' in Amsterdam.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by mcv on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:24AM (#34834965)
People carry entire families on their bikes in Amsterdam. There's been a massive boom in cargo bikes of every sort. But even regular bikes often have a small crate.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by runako on Friday February 17, 2023 @08:04AM (#34834160)
Gentle reminder that a significant portion of society is not able to carry out trips on bikes due to infirmity, disability, or needing to convey someone who cannot bike (e.g. small children).
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by ryukafalz on Friday February 17, 2023 @08:18AM (#34834296)
A significant portion of society is also not able to drive for similar reasons, but they mostly go ignored in our car-centric society. Nobody's saying that we should completely eliminate the ability to drive, certainly some people will need to, but we need to also provide viable options for those who can't.

Additionally, bike infrastructure works great for mobility scooters too: https://youtu.be/xSGx3HSjKDo

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by mcv on Friday February 17, 2023 @08:37AM (#34834484)
This exactly. Different people have different needs and abilities, and we all get better options if more options become available. This is why investing in more bike infrastructure is ultimately good for everybody, even for the people who absolutely need a car; more people in public transit or on bikes means less cars on the load, less stress on infrastructure, less traffic jams, etc.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by nostromo123 on Friday February 17, 2023 @08:09AM (#34834203)
I agree, but in a short time someone will reply here to tell you how they brought their kids to kindergarten in subzero temperatures with a bike, or how they bike half an hour in rain to buy groceries...

For my family it's not even about the physical aspect, but about time. I don't want to waste my free time going to and from places in 2x/3x the time it takes by car.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by runako on Friday February 17, 2023 @08:13AM (#34834242)
> in a short time someone will reply here to tell you how they brought their kids to kindergarten in subzero temperatures with a bike, or how they bike half an hour in rain to buy groceries...

Fully expecting that comment, and I look forward to that person describing how they take an elderly parent to the doctor on a bike…

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by rexpress on Friday February 17, 2023 @08:35AM (#34834471)
The 'elderly parent to the doctor' case is still an argument for bike infrastructure. The more people choose to travel by bike instead of by car, the more space is available on the roads for those that need motor vehicles.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by lnsru on Friday February 17, 2023 @08:23AM (#34834330)
That’s perfect case for a taxi. However I love cars and just playing devil’s advocate here.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by bluGill on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:39AM (#34835145)
The cost of a taxi ride is not affordable if you need to make that type of trip often. Paying $40 for a ride once or twice a year is okay, but if you need to make a weekly trip to the doctor, plus get groceries and go to church on Sunday - a brand new car is now cheaper (a brand new car is very expensive, most people drive older used cars that are a lot cheaper)
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by mantas on Friday February 17, 2023 @08:20AM (#34834309)
CARGO BIKE /s
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by Xylakant on Friday February 17, 2023 @08:42AM (#34834524)
You’re being sarcastic, but I’ve been there and done that. For $reasons. Under other circumstances, the answer would be “take a cab.”
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by mantas on Friday February 17, 2023 @08:48AM (#34834587)
„Take a cab“ is always an option. But at some point, if using it frequently enough, it becomes cheaper and more convenient to just own the damn thing.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by Xylakant on Friday February 17, 2023 @08:54AM (#34834646)
If you take into account the current costs for cars, you can do a lot of kilometer per cab every month. I‘ve done the math for me - I could take the cab around 20-30 times a month for an average distance, for the costs associated with a VW Golf size car.

There are also options that cover the middle ground: Mixed mode (cab, train, cab) or car sharing. Certainly not available for all of us, but just as certainly available to many of us.

The primary issue is that the math only works out if you don’t buy/own a car, otherwise you‘ll have the majority of the costs of car ownership anyways. On a pure mile by mile replacement, the math doesn‘t work out.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by mantas on Friday February 17, 2023 @10:52AM (#34836041)
If you MUST lease a brand new car and replace it every few years - probably. But driving a slightly older car is perfectly fine.

There're a lot of other variables. Family/life situation, hobbies, health situation, visual (fuck video ads on public transit) and audio noise tolerance...

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by Xylakant on Friday February 17, 2023 @11:08AM (#34836346)
People upthread ran the numbers and arrived at 600 USD/month for a used car. Seems high to me, but I don't know how the math works out in the US. For Germany, this is a pretty good modeling of the costs https://financer.com/de/blog/was-kostet-ein-auto-im-monat/ and it still arrives at 240 EUR/month for a used car. That's maybe not 20 cab rides, but still a significant number.

Obviously, the math I did for me works out for me. It likely will look different for you. However, I never pretended that the math works out for everyone - it doesn't. But it would work out for a lot of people if they were honest.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by mantas on Friday February 17, 2023 @12:13PM (#34837373)
I've no idea for US either, but 600 USD/mo looks weird. For me here in Lithuania it was cheaper than that even while I was paying off my car. Now driving a paid-off-but-well-maintained car is more like €150/month for ~ 1k km a month with occasional maintenance, insurance and rare downtown parking. Obviously it is higher than that when including previous lease payments, but historical price is going down every month. So it could be pretty close to €240 after all, but buying a new car and then keeping it is not exactly a „used car“ budget...

„If they were honest“ is a bad argument to be honest. If everybody would change their preferences, they may have similar math to yours :)

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by Xylakant on Friday February 17, 2023 @12:24PM (#34837521)
By "were honest" I mostly mean "honest with themselves". There are a lot of costs that are easy to forget or ignore. The cost of parking in the city. The occasional repair. Having to tow your car, because it broke. Deprecation of a valuable asset. Very few people take stock of what they actually spend on their car, because it's hard and it's constantly shifting. Some costs are annually and (mostly) independent of your annual mileage - insurance and tax, for example. Others are constant and directly associated with your mileage - fuel. Yet, others again are directly associated but come in lumps - maintenance, tires, ... Deprecation is fuzzy and partially outside of any factor you can control, etc.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by mantas on Saturday February 18, 2023 @12:48PM (#34849076)
That feels like a strawman because most people do knowledge those costs. But they are negligible in the long run. €300 for a tire set over 5 years (but probably longer) literally €5/month. Occasional oil change works out to similar costs.

Of course, someone may run 20" wheels and then prices skyrocket. But then it’a no longer pure transit costs and more like an expensive hobby.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by Steltek on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:04AM (#34834758)
Don't be silly. The elderly parent with bad reflexes and even worse eyesight will drive themselves to the doctor in their equally decrepit car. That's what really happens when you reinforce the belief that cars are a necessity because bikes are some extreme hardship.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by UncleEntity on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:56AM (#34835351)
You’re joking but I once took an elderly man from the front entrance of his building to the parking lot in my cab because he couldn’t walk that far with his walker (which wasn’t all that far from the back door) and had to help him get behind the wheel to drive off.

Needless to say I waited a bit for him to clear the neighborhood before driving off.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by Steltek on Friday February 17, 2023 @10:20AM (#34835622)
Oh I'm very much NOT joking! I was stopped at a red light on my bike when I was rear ended by an 83yo. He couldn't judge how far his car was from my bike. He was super angry that I insisted he had to stick around to exchange information because he was going to be late for a doctor's appointment in Brookline. Thankfully it was low speed (he was stopping, he just didn't know where to stop) so all he did was knock me forwards.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by UncleEntity on Friday February 17, 2023 @11:23AM (#34836631)
83 must be the magic year…

Had one back into me at a traffic light, with me honking, and then put it into drive and take off when the light changed. Had to have the cops drag him out of a medical building to get a report and his story went from “no accident” (at the scene) to me rear ending him (on the witness stand contesting his ticket), luckily I was hauling around a passenger who confirmed my side of the story.

Still don’t have a clue why he thought it was a good idea to put it into reverse and barely creep backward at a red light with cars all around him.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by robin_reala on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:28AM (#34835012)
If you need to convey kids then you buy a bike that conveys kids easily. Copenhagen is full of these sort of box bikes[1] (well, trikes I guess) that at their larger side will happily fit three to four small children.

[1] https://christianiabikesamerica.com/collections/all-models

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by ianburrell on Friday February 17, 2023 @11:40AM (#34836890)
Taking cars off the roads means more space for the people who do need the roads. Few people are saying get rid of cars entirely, they have important uses. The roads already exist, tearing them out would be stupid. But we shouldn’t design our cities around them and require everyone have one. This has advantages for those who need to drive, reducing traffic.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by bluecalm on Friday February 17, 2023 @12:25PM (#34837534)
Those people can still ride mobility scooters, e-bikes, small electric vehicles (like golf carts) but often can't drive. Car centric world means exclusion for those groups.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by _dain_ on Friday February 17, 2023 @07:51AM (#34834040)
Those cities have extensive networks of local rail, subway, trams, and buses. So "the other side of town" is easily reachable.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by moffkalast on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:34AM (#34835089)
And you again need to figure out and get whatever local card or ticket or app they decided to use to pay for all that, because there is zero standardization, which adds even more financial overhead assuming you're only visiting once, plus figuring out the timetable and route plan so you don't end up on the completely opposite end. Lots of "Oh wait, you were supposed to take the #15 bus, but this is a #15B which doesn't go to your station because fuck you" moments.

Remember, this mess is trying to directly compete with just looking at a satnav and driving where it says with no extra charge, lost time, or mental effort.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by bluGill on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:48AM (#34835267)
Transit agencies should come up with a reciprocity plan. You don't live here, but you have have a monthly pass for the city you live in so I'll let you ride my system for a week - or if system prices are too different pro-rate your time so you get a great discount.

Note that a large part of the above is I think transit agencies should try to get as many people as possible on unlimited ride family passes. Anyone with such a pass must find transit useful enough to use often anyway, and the pass means they don't worry about making one additional trip they just go.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by johnwalkr on Friday February 17, 2023 @12:03PM (#34837226)
Large cities don’t usually have one unlimited monthly plan, you pay for your specific route or zone(s).
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by bluGill on Friday February 17, 2023 @07:28PM (#34842539)
I'm fine with zones, though I think cites get them wrong. The lowest cost zone should include your house, no matter where you live, with additional zones for getting farther away. When traveling your hotel should be how your zone is defined (or where ever you stay).

But you should always strive to have everyone on an unlimited rides pass for their home zone. Anything else encourages getting a car for trips that could go either way and that in turn justifies a car for everything.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by Telluur on Friday February 17, 2023 @10:49AM (#34836003)
> because there is zero standardization For the Netherlands, you could not be more wrong. By law, all public transport companies for Trains, Metro, Tram, Bus, Watertaxies are hooked into the exact same NFC payment platform, the OV-chipkaart. Recently, they rolled out debit/credit card payments on these readers nation-wide.

Additionally, all public transportation companies provide standardized service information including live updates (often required by the law). Any journey can be fully planned on 9292.nl.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by moffkalast on Friday February 17, 2023 @11:21AM (#34836599)
Good thing the only country that exists is the Netherlands and nobody ever ventures outside of it.

I do hope there is an eventual push for an EU-wide NFC system for public transport, that would be pretty dope.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by cjfd on Friday February 17, 2023 @07:49AM (#34834018)
"Why would anyone in a rich country with a high functioning rail system like The Netherlands want to drive?"

Well, I live in The Netherlands and the place where I work is not very reachable by public transport. The 138 trains per day between Amsterdam and The Hague is all very nice and so on but even in the Netherlands people who live in a village will in many cases be somewhat isolated if they don't own a car.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by seydor on Friday February 17, 2023 @07:50AM (#34834029)
Why would so many people need to move between Amsterdam and Hague in the first place
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by mcv on Friday February 17, 2023 @08:39AM (#34834499)
They're both important cities. Sometimes people need to be in a specific city.

But you're absolutely right that it's better to work in the same city where you live, so you can simply ride a bike to work.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by stouset on Friday February 17, 2023 @07:53AM (#34834057)
They’re 37 miles apart.

Do you have idea how many Americans commute 37 miles each way, every single day?

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by yourusername on Friday February 17, 2023 @08:13AM (#34834237)
The job market in the Netherlands is very flexible and the housing market is very inflexible. It's not financially feasible for most people to move for a job every few years. Especially to the Amsterdam region where you would need to be on a waiting list for a decade for social housing or make ~2x national average to even think of moving there.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by olddustytrail on Friday February 17, 2023 @11:21AM (#34836581)
It's not that odd. There are a similar number from Glasgow to Edinburgh daily.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by Ekaros on Friday February 17, 2023 @07:59AM (#34834105)
That is optimal situation.

But it does breakdown or be worse with slightly more complicated routes. Like I used to travel from smaller city to bigger city to other big city. And in the end public transport was probably 50% if not longer in time. First 15-20 minutes to station, then 45 minutes with local train. Wait for intercity, ~2 hours and 30 minutes or get lift to destination. Compared to straight 2 hours from door to door with car.

And this is with perfectly serviceable train network with plenty enough trains. Or at max capacity.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by mcv on Friday February 17, 2023 @08:32AM (#34834435)
25% longer is not that bad, especially if you consider that you can't work while driving, but for many kinds of work, you can do some work in a train (if you have a seat, at least). Or read a book.

I don't consider train travel to be lost time in the way car travel is.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by Retric on Friday February 17, 2023 @08:26AM (#34834361)
Swapping trains can take a while, but until self driving works you can’t do much while driving. And even with self driving simply up and stretching, grabbing a bite to eat, or even just going to the bathroom requires you to stop making progress for a while.

Driving has several advantages, but getting stuck in traffic is extremely unpleasant in ways that similar delays on other forms of travel don’t really replicate.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by robertlagrant on Friday February 17, 2023 @08:38AM (#34834493)
> getting stuck in traffic is extremely unpleasant in ways that similar delays on other forms of travel don’t really replicate

But you also don't have to take a 3 hour coach ride because the driver or other staff's union is striking. It's just you and your car.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by mcv on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:22AM (#34834943)
But that's again because these trains are run for profit, cutting every corner they can, and underpaying their employees. I'd prefer to see trains nationalised and run as national infrastructure with the goal of luring more commuters into mass transit. Because that will mean enormous savings in pollution, traffic jams, noise, and road maintenance.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by robertlagrant on Saturday February 18, 2023 @01:42PM (#34849713)
Even when they were nationalised they were terrible. The biggest problem isn't whether it's for profit or not. The biggest problem is the relatively vast value for money, and value in general, of cars, even with extremely large fuel taxes imposed. People don't want to pay a lot of money for transport because they've seen how much value a car gives, and so having the cost and large numbers of people required to operate a really high quality train would require more than anything raising ticket prices significantly.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by Retric on Saturday February 18, 2023 @09:39PM (#34853660)
Car travel is only “cheap” per trip because people have already sunk the costs into owning, insuring, and parking their car and paying for roads.

Fuel taxes don’t even come close to paying for our road networks while rail is lumping all these costs together on a per trip basis.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by robertlagrant on Sunday February 19, 2023 @07:06AM (#34856894)
It's still cheap compared to that.

If you want an emergency services vehicles to get to your house you need a road anyway.

If you want buses and coaches to function, you need roads.

If you want to transport a bootload of stuff more than three times a year you're financially better off paying for a car than renting.

If yor kids have school anywhere that isn't walking/cycling distance from your house, then you need a car, or two.

If you have a job, and don't want to be beholden to a very local employer, you likely need a car. Except if you live close to a train station and your job is close to another one. And except in the last five years, when some jobs can now be remote.

If you want to go anywhere that a train doesn't go, you need a car, probably. Which is everywhere outside of extremely high density urban areas that can afford an underground rail system.

You need any of those things to be true for a road to be needed. You likely need a car for all but the first two. Cars and roads are valuable. I don't see how that's debatable.

Trains are now location-specific optimisations where we know we have hotspots of usefulness, where it's worth laying track and having massive investment as enough people will use that route.

Just as a circuit-switched phone call is a better connection, but packet-switched is better overall, and cheaper, so are trains and cars.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by Retric on Monday February 20, 2023 @04:05PM (#34872895)
A public road network for cars needs a great deal of infrastructure that a public network for busses and ambulances would. Literally every single street in NYC could be single lane, one way, without any street level parking if you’re not building for cars. Further, the demands of traffic directly relate to the kinds of roads, bridges etc you can get away with building.

You have several objectively false statements here such as:

“If yor kids have school anywhere that isn't walking/cycling distance from your house, then you need a car, or two.” Except 100’s of millions of people currently live live further than cycling distance from their kids school and don’t own a car.

Frankly cars didn’t exist until very recently and society was fine without them.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by Retric on Friday February 17, 2023 @10:29AM (#34835721)
Just you and your car + the guys bumper 3 feet in front of you that’s moved 5 feet in the last minute because of a traffic accident or something. Luckily you can just look at waze and holly shit you’re going to be in this mess for another 4 hours, but you can’t even take a nap or something because traffic is still inching along…

Now that’s not universal, but I really do budget 3-4 hours extra for some trips because holiday traffic is just that bad in my area.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by HardlyCurious on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:13AM (#34834848)
This is really the selling point of mass transit for me.

But I have a problem. I'm an introvert and I get fatigued by constant human interaction. I also get fatigued by constant distractions. I really benefit from having some breathing space where I can zone out.

Saying it out load makes it sound reckless and inconsistent, doesn't driving require constant attention? But no, somehow I can zone out drive and drive to my destination completely subconsciously, at least if it's a route I know we'll, like on a commute.

I'm 39 now and I have never caused an accident for what that anecdotle evidence means.

My commutes are my decompress time. I can't do anything during them, and if I could, I wouldn't benefit the same way.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by dublinben on Friday February 17, 2023 @11:30AM (#34836743)
With safe, separated infrastructure, a commute of the same duration via bicycling or walking would be even better for your physical and mental health. We all live in a prison of car supremacy, whether we realize it or not.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by HardlyCurious on Friday February 17, 2023 @11:37AM (#34836854)
I lived very close to my work for a period and tried bike commuting. I don't disagree with the benefits of doing it, but it's not very realistic for most people in most places.

I was having a hard time NOT getting sweaty on my ride into work because humidity is the highest in the morning. And when I wasnt sweating I was getting rained on, or my hands were freezing, or I got chain grease on my pants.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by toshredsyousay on Friday February 17, 2023 @02:12PM (#34838966)
If you got an electric bike, that could help with the sweat. The breeze with the extra speed and the reduction in effort really reduce the of sweat dramatically. Or just bring a change of clothes and maybe a towel if that is tolerable. For the rain, a bike poncho works pretty well, especially if you pair it with rubber boots (maybe have a change of shoes ready). For the cold, gloves or bar mitts work pretty well. For the chain grease, you can get a full chain guard to house the entire chain if you want, or just tuck your pants into long socks, or get a pant clip. Given how much maintenance people often have to do on cars, a little care to have the right gear for biking is often easily well worth the effort and cost.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by HardlyCurious on Friday February 17, 2023 @02:26PM (#34839133)
Yes, there are solutions or work arounds for these issues. It just makes commuting on a bike inconvenient for many people.

Electric bikes are great, but other than price, it starts to blur between having an electric motorcycle. Especially after you need to don appropriate gear for the commute to stay dry / comfortable. And the motorcycle would have greater range and more use cases.

And at the end of the day, while riding a bike to work is great and I would encourage everyone to try it if they can, do you really think it works without a backup plan? Even people I know who have taking bike commuting pretty seriously didn't do it literally every single day.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by Retric on Friday February 17, 2023 @03:04PM (#34839756)
Bike specific trails make a huge difference here. An electric motorcycle is less flexible, costs more, and doesn’t provide exercise. Pedal assist going in + a workout on the way back is hard to beat.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by smaudet on Friday February 17, 2023 @08:18AM (#34834292)
Sure in the case of long commutes or exploration of different areas there are certain advantaged to autonomous vehicles - however the car is by no means king. Helicopter is even better for getting from random distant location to distant location.

But this is not the majority of travel, and in those cases car travel is indeed overkill, and a hassle to boot, as anyone who has ever had to daily wrangle with parking lots and rush hour traffic can attest.

There are different concerns with public transport, but the advantages tend to outweigh the disadvantages, and it appears this is borne out by the data.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by yourusername on Friday February 17, 2023 @08:09AM (#34834201)
>There's 138 trains per day between Amsterdam and The Hague. It's faster to take the train than to drive on that trip

If you're going from the Hague central station to Amsterdam central station, sure. Now plan a more typical commute from say the Hague Wateringen to the over Amstel industrial estate (It takes two times as as driving) Play around with real life scenarios. Say you're going from Amsterdam Osdorp to your work in Utrecht Lageweide. It takes twice with transit as if you were to drive even with traffic. Most Dutch people drive, especially those that can afford to.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by mcv on Friday February 17, 2023 @08:22AM (#34834324)
> It takes two times as as driving

That really depends on the amount of traffic jam you end up in.

It's true that not every route has a direct train connection, and there are definitely trips where cars are faster, but during rush hour around big cities, cars become a lot less reliable. On top of that, cars are only fast if you have access to parking on each end of the trip. Otherwise you still need to park somewhere else and take local transit for the final leg (which is definitely the preferred way to visit Amsterdam by car).

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by yourusername on Friday February 17, 2023 @08:28AM (#34834394)
>That really depends on the amount of traffic jam you end up in.

And on the ammount of leaves/snow/rain/wind/heat/strikes impeding rail traffic. Terrible traffic jams happen but let's not pretend the NS doesn't have a long list of excuses to run less or no trains or massively delayed trains. I can't count the number of times NS announced that they would stop running trains because of some weather where i had no issue driving home. On average driving is going to be twice as fast for most typical commutes.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by mcv on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:17AM (#34834889)
No, I agree. Trains have gotten unreasonably unreliable too. They didn't always have this much trouble with leaves, rain and cold, as far as I recall. I think trains everywhere, and not just in Pennsylvania, suffer from being run for profit on narrow safety/reliability margins.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by jononomo on Friday February 17, 2023 @08:52AM (#34834628)
Imagine how many more cars would have to be on the road if there were only 20 trains per day between Amsterdam and The Hague!
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by CalRobert on Friday February 17, 2023 @08:54AM (#34834648)
35 minute drive without traffic, or a 20 minute bike ride to Utrecht Centraal, 40 minute train ride to Lelylaan, and a 15 minute bike ride from Lelylaan. (so 75 minutes predictably-ish, though NS had a lot of delayed/late trains when I visited last).

But the kicker, I suppose, is that in my version you drive 35+ minutes and then need to work out, while the train version means I don't need to go to the gym. When I lived in LA I rode my bike and it meant being in great shape without ever having to work out, and I miss it, but of course it depends on the situation.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by WeylandYutani on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:16AM (#34834881)
They did research on this: people actually ENJOY being stuck in traffic. So it doesn't really matter if mass transit is fast, cheap, reliable.

You have to make owning a car impossible. Take away parking spaces, block roads into the city, increase taxation.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by mcv on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:18AM (#34834903)
Well I don't. I strongly prefer travelling by train, even if it takes longer, because that's more time I can read or do something else productive. Cars are terrible for that.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by sva_ on Friday February 17, 2023 @08:14AM (#34834246)
There's also a nice section of the beach in that general area where you can drive your car all the way to the beach with ocean view at no parking fee.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by BrandonS113 on Friday February 17, 2023 @08:26AM (#34834369)
I had to spend a few months in Holland for work. We we left with the problem of what do do on the weekends. You can't rent bikes if you are not Dutch, and visiting the lovely villages and other places Holland is full of is a time consuming exercise in futility unless one has a car.

A train is great for Rotterdam-Hague-Amsterdam, not so good for visiting the Bosch museum in 's-Hertogenbosch.

Holland has a great road system and parking everywhere. The perfect place for a car owner.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by rexpress on Friday February 17, 2023 @08:32AM (#34834436)
I've rented bikes in the Netherlands several times as a UK citizen, but perhaps in different areas.

Part of the reason the Netherlands is the perfect place for a car owner is that so many people are able to go by bike instead, freeing up space on the roads.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by BrandonS113 on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:18AM (#34834905)
Yes, private bike rental firms are happy to take my money. But they are not common. But the public OV are ubiquitous and more strict.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by imiric on Friday February 17, 2023 @08:51AM (#34834611)
> You can't rent bikes if you are not Dutch

Huh? There's a bike rental place on practically every other corner in most Dutch cities, and most of their profit is from tourists. You only need to show some ID and leave a deposit. Dutch people usually have a cheap old bike, or use the public OV bikes, for which you do need to register and get a card, but even that is possible as a foreigner, it just takes some days to process.

> visiting the lovely villages and other places Holland is full of is a time consuming exercise in futility unless one has a car.

I'm not sure where you're getting this from either. Intercity transport by train works great, and there are many organized bus tours that take you to smaller villages. You can easily see most of the country without owning a car, though it's a personal preference whether you enjoy using public transport or not.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by BrandonS113 on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:15AM (#34834871)
One needs iDEAL for many things in Holland, and needs to be a resident for that. My colleague tried to get a personal OV-chipkaart, https://www.ov-chipkaart.nl/en/apply-for-personal-ov-chipcar..., needed for bikes, he went though the process, and got nowhere. It was 2 years ago, so may have changed. But he said it stranded on need for a local bank account.

I know you can get anywhere by public transport, much better than where I live. But going though tram-train-train (+even bus or a 3rd train) to visit some village that is less than an hour away by car, will multiply the transport time.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by mcv on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:34AM (#34835091)
The accessibility of OV-kaarten is indeed not great for tourists, which is ridiculous. There's been a lot of criticism of the OV-kaart system. But most things can be paid with a simple bank card transaction. I doubt buying or renting a car would be that much easier.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by BrandonS113 on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:46AM (#34835231)
yes. I dont want to make much out of this. One of the team came from a country close by and he brought his car. Problem solved.

But just about every Dutch person we worked with had a car. They would meet us on weekends in villages, and most drove. Public transport is great in Holland, but cars have their place too. And unlike some countries close by, Holland has a well maintain and well designed road system. Its great for car travel.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by mcv on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:59AM (#34835391)
This is true. You can really feel by the road surface that you've crossed the border with Belgium or Germany. Netherland isn't just about bikes; it tries to make sure all forms of transport all well-served. Public transport could be better, though.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by mcv on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:31AM (#34835060)
> You can't rent bikes if you are not Dutch

Why not? Where are you trying to rent? There's bike rentals specifically aimed at tourists, and most people speak English reasonably well.

> A train is great for Rotterdam-Hague-Amsterdam, not so good for visiting the Bosch museum in 's-Hertogenbosch.

I just checked, and from Amsterdam, the train to that museum is actually slightly faster than a car. Though you do have a 15 minute walk at the end. Perhaps Den Bosch should run a bus line there.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by BrandonS113 on Friday February 17, 2023 @11:10AM (#34836380)
Yes, unfortunately were not exactly working in Amsterdam, and needed a tram to the local station and then a train to, perhaps Amsterdam.

That said, I would love to know why 's-Hertogenbosch is spelled that way. I asked a few locals, and none knew.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by mcv on Friday February 17, 2023 @07:10PM (#34842391)
It's one of those cities that has two names: Den Bosch and 's Hertogenbosch.

The first simply means "the forest", in slightly archaic spelling. The second is short for "des hertogenbosch", which is archaic for "the duke's forest". "Des" is archaic genitive that's barely used any more in Dutch except in a few phrases and place names.

's ochtends => des ochtends => of the morning

's avonds => des avonds => of the evening

's Hertogenbosch => the duke's forest

's Gravenhave => des graven hage => the count's hedge (also known as Den Haag / The Hague)

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by electrosphere on Friday February 17, 2023 @11:51AM (#34837037)
I've rented bikes very easily as a UK tourist. All you need is cash in Euros or a credit card.

Disagree about parking, at least what I've seen in Amsterdam city area. You have to use an app and pay for parking. There are patrol cars that will dish out fines if you are caught. There are blue zones in suburbs which are free but it's mainly for visitors/residents.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by wffurr on Saturday February 18, 2023 @11:59AM (#34848452)
I rented a bike in Holland no problem. Weird that you weren't able to do so.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by fleddr on Friday February 17, 2023 @08:29AM (#34834399)
The US anti-car narrative often refers to the Netherlands as some kind of beacon of proper public infrastructure, whilst not knowing a damn thing about it.

First, let's establish that the Netherlands is a car country. We have 11 million cars on a population of 17 million. On a typical day, 1 million people use public transport. Cars are the norm, not trains or bicycles.

Public transport is rarely faster, not even in the most idyllic example that you give where you go from big city to big city. The thing you conveniently forget to consider is that nobody lives near the station of city A and then also works very closely to the station of city B. It almost always includes additional travel towards A and from B. Cycling, trams, buses, multiple stops in both directions. It adds up.

To illustrate how absurdly slow public transport can be, a personal example. I used to live directly behind a train station in a mid-sized city. Doesn't get much better than that, right?

Let's explore the commute to work, some 60km away...

I have to get up early and be there some 10 mins before departure to secure somewhat of a reasonable spot. Next, I'm on route to the first big city station. This route is slow, it stops 5 times along the way as everybody needs to connect to a big hub to get where they need to be.

I arrive at the hub, where there's a 20 minute connection wait to take the train to the big city destination. This route is longer but fast, no stops along the way.

I get out and have a 10 minute connection wait for the bus to take me to the place closest to work, after which there's a 5-10 minute work.

Total commute time: 2.5 hours single way. To move 60km. And that's living behind a train station and working at one of the countries' largest employers.

What works really well in the Netherlands is living within a cycling radius from work, every other option sucks.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by speeder on Friday February 17, 2023 @08:37AM (#34834483)
That is not a car country.

São Paulo has more car than population, and has so many cars that their area summed is bigger than the area of all streets in the city.

It is so many cars that sometimes walking 1 hour to your workplace is faster than a car route where you can spend 2, 3 hours to go to a neighborhood next to yours during rush hour.

So many cars that the city became also the city with most helicopters, because as ludicrously expensive they are, for people that need to reach their workplace really fast (CEO, firemen, medics...) helicopters are good idea.

Situation got so bad that the government wants to heavily restrict the use of helicopters because private helicopters were causing literally airborne traffic jams along the normal traffic jam, blocking public services like police from moving to emergency sites.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by jononomo on Friday February 17, 2023 @08:51AM (#34834616)
Does São Paulo have more cars than people even if you include children? Surely there must also be an underclass of very poor or homeless people who do not own cars. What accounts for the fact that there are more cars than people? Is it common for a household of four (mother, father, son, daughter) to own five or six cars?
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by bluGill on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:22AM (#34834935)
I don't know Brazil, but based on what I know of the US I wouldn't be surprised. A couple will often own 3 cars, 2 daily drivers and one for some other odd task (truck, or the sports car) that is used as a backup. It will be one car per kid of driving age, though most kids are not old enough to drive. Then there are work cars, which for tax/legal reasons can't be used for personal trips so those who have them will also have a personal car for non-work trips. There are people who keep a car at their vacation house. Rental cars also add a fair number of cars. Plus collectors who have a dozen cars that they only drive to shows. It all adds up.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by jononomo on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:30AM (#34835048)
Ok, but in the US there are forty five million fewer registered vehicles than there are people, even after accounting for all the factors you listed.

There are 286 million registered vehicles for a population of 331 million people.

And the US is the wealthiest nation in the world.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by dghlsakjg on Friday February 17, 2023 @01:23PM (#34838337)
The more important metric is that there are only 238 million licensed drivers in the US.

So if every single licensed driver went for a drive, they could invite all 26 million licensed Canadians to come down and use a spare car, and still have 22 million registered cars left over.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by EL_Loco on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:25AM (#34834982)
No, São Paulo doesn't have more cars than people. I don't know where the parent got their data. I'll stand corrected if shown data supporting it, but the numbers I found were more like 7 cars for ever 10 inhabitants, and I don't even know if children taken into account. I lived in São Paulo for many years, and I sold my car before I moved there. Living downtown, one is better off without one. However, more cars than inhabitants seems and exaggeration.

Edit: Did some quick checking. According to the national institute of statistics, São Paulo's fleet is about 8.8 million (this includes over 1 million motorcycles, plus all the busses, tractors, trucks, etc. Regular cars are 6 million). Population is 12.3 million.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by fleddr on Friday February 17, 2023 @08:52AM (#34834630)
We have an office in São Paulo which I visited, so I'm familiar with it. It's a ridiculous city. It's so complicated that even people working in the office regularly get lost in the city. A true concrete jungle. We were in a 3 hour traffic jam just to go to a place for lunch.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by cesarb on Friday February 17, 2023 @08:56AM (#34834667)
You forgot to mention the rodízio. Depending on the final digit of your car plate, there's one day of the week in which it is forbidden from being used in the rush hour within the central part of that huge city.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by HardlyCurious on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:01AM (#34834719)
If that is your standard for being a 'car country'. What is your standard for being a 'public transport country' or 'train country'?
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by aardvarkr on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:10AM (#34834808)
That’s not a car country, that’s a traffic country.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by EL_Loco on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:35AM (#34835102)
I just checked the Detran and IBGE's numbers. There aren't more cars than people in São Paulo. It's a traffic hell, for sure, but still less cars than people.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by hgomersall on Friday February 17, 2023 @08:36AM (#34834472)
I think the question that anyone that rejects cars would ask is why do you choose to live 60km from your work?
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by davidMC1982 on Friday February 17, 2023 @08:44AM (#34834552)
Because his partner works 60km in the opposite direction?
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by hgomersall on Friday February 17, 2023 @08:51AM (#34834619)
I think you're missing the point... If you reject car ownership and the associated commute etc, you structure your life around that. You get a job and a house that are compatible with that philosophy. As a couple, neither of you would have a job that requires you to commute such distances.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by hn_throwaway_99 on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:03AM (#34834749)
Couldn't think of a better argument for why most people do not reject cars. Restricting your employment options to a small, say cyclable area around where you live can be extremely limiting for your employment opportunities, especially if you have a partner that also works. Especially considering the point another commenter said that oftentimes central business districts where the best jobs are can be prohibitively expensive for housing.

I'm not one to discount the cost of a long commute, and I'm hopeful that more remote and flexible work options will make it so people have less time commuting. But people like to own cars because in most cases they can be incredibly useful, and ignoring that fact won't help people transition off them.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by hgomersall on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:14AM (#34834861)
But that's precisely the point. Many people (and arguably the young people in the OP), value life over "employment opportunities". That's the philosophy behind why many of us reject cars in our daily lives. Those hours of commuting I don't have to do I spend with my children. Equally, the commuting I do do is free exercise.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by Aunche on Friday February 17, 2023 @11:01AM (#34836228)
>Restricting your employment options to a small, say cyclable area around where you live can be extremely limiting for your employment opportunities

You're missing the forest for the trees. If you live in a mid-sized city in the Netherlands and want to limit yourself to a 1 hour commute by public transit, there are just as many, if not more opportunities than if you live in a mid sized city in the US like Richmond because the Netherlands is that much denser, and transit optimizes for commercial centers. The difference that in the Netherlands, you still have the option of commuting by car, whereas, in the US you'd have to move.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by davidMC1982 on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:16AM (#34834879)
That only holds true when your basic needs to survive are met such that you're able to entertain a philosophy such as "reject car ownership". I suspect most people are going to abandon such a philosophy as soon as "putting food on the table" is no longer possible.

Conflicting ideas such as these crop up all the time. For instance, "commuting in a car is dead time, at least I can read/work on the train". A reasonable position at face value, but entirely useless to the person who finishes work at 17:00 and must pick the kids up from school at 17:30. The 30 mins car ride may be "dead time", but the 60 mins by public transport obviously doesn't work for them.

I would guess that the "rejecting car ownership" types probably have this as a subset of a broader philosophy where they've somewhat rejected wealth in favour of something else, or already have the economic freedom to make such a choice.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by hgomersall on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:46AM (#34835233)
Yes absolutely it's about choices. I would argue the debate is more worthwhile than that because it's good to think in terms of "what would be ideal" so that as a society we can plan for that. Too often, such public debate become bogged down with a view that those that oppose car usage as part of a daily routine are fundamentally opposed to car usage. In fact, typically we can see a better world and want it for everyone. Since improving things for drivers generally necessarily makes things worse for everyone that isn't in a car, the practicalities of reducing car usage are actually a reduction in existing privilege (which people will always fight tooth and nail).
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by bluecalm on Friday February 17, 2023 @10:45AM (#34835952)
It's true you often need a car but it shouldn't be the case. Cars are terribly inefficienct way to get around. They are more expensive and slower (once there are enough of them) than alternatives. The anti-car sentiment is about changing the infrastructure so the cheaper/greener and faster alternatives get a chance.

Public transport is one alternative but I think small personal transport devices are more promising.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by johnwalkr on Friday February 17, 2023 @11:54AM (#34837088)
“Rejecting car ownership” types will probably live walking distance to schools. This doesn’t even have to mean living in a city centre somewhere, if anything schools are the one thing in America designed for local people as opposed being designed for cars.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by fleddr on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:05AM (#34834770)
And you're missing the point that these types of jobs are in or around the big cities, where people cannot afford housing. Well, maybe 5% can, the rest of us will commute.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by mcv on Friday February 17, 2023 @08:53AM (#34834639)
It's generally better to live close to one person's workplace than right in between the two.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by iso1631 on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:18AM (#34834904)
Modern advice is to move jobs every 2-3 years. You want to move house every 2-3 years? Move the kids schools every 2-3 years?
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by MarceColl on Friday February 17, 2023 @10:15AM (#34835563)
I've moved between jobs every 1-2 years for the past 10. I've never been more than an hour away (and that was one job that was particularly far away). In most cases, because we have a good public transit system, I'm within 10-15 minutes by subway or 30/40 minutes walking. I don't even consider it too much. Never moved house.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by HardlyCurious on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:04AM (#34834751)
Why?
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by mcv on Friday February 17, 2023 @10:07AM (#34835489)
So only one person instead of two has to suffer through a dreadful commute, you need only one car instead of two, one parent works close to where the kids go to school, etc. If you live in the middle, everything is far away for everybody.

That doesn't mean it's not viable to live in the middle, but I think these are some pretty good arguments why it's often preferable to live close to at least one partner's workplace. Obviously it's not going to work for everybody, but if you're thinking about where to buy your house, this may be worth taking into consideration.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by HardlyCurious on Friday February 17, 2023 @10:51AM (#34836037)
Would you volunteer to have twice the dreadful commute for the benefit of your partner, or do you see yourself being the beneficiary of this configuration?
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by mcv on Friday February 17, 2023 @07:13PM (#34842413)
My wife and I seem to disagree who is the beneficiary of this configuration. She seems to like driving. And she likes that I live close to home.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by Tade0 on Friday February 17, 2023 @08:51AM (#34834617)
Perhaps because real estate/rent is simply too expensive anywhere closer.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by hgomersall on Friday February 17, 2023 @08:58AM (#34834688)
Whenever I've heard people make that argument, what they actually mean is "The huge house I want to live in I can afford if I spend an hour a day in the car, oh and people that live in the cities should not make it harder for me to pursue such a path by restricting car usage. Externalities be damned, won't someone think of my being unable to afford a 5 bedroom house with a big garden in the city".
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by bluGill on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:29AM (#34835025)
Humans have always been that way. Adam Smith observed in his "wealth of the nations" that once someone has enough to eat and other basics, increases in income are mostly used to make their house better (mostly meaning larger). If your plan for bettering the world doesn't account for this, then you have lost.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by lotsofpulp on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:18AM (#34834901)
It is both the desire to not live in an apartment, but rather have a detached single family house with a garage and backyard, and also a desire to live away from people below your socioeconomic level and near people at or above your socioeconomic level (referred to as “good schools”).

If Americans were okay with living in Tokyo sized abodes, then there would be sufficient density for sufficient housing and job opportunities to exist in a region that could support sufficient public transit.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by johnwalkr on Friday February 17, 2023 @11:44AM (#34836950)
There’s plenty of detached houses in Tokyo (even in the 23 wards) and they cost 1/4 of what they cost in a major American city. Tokyo is denser than any American city but less dense than Paris, and greater Tokyo, which is even cheaper for housing, still has great transit/no need for a car for most people and has a density of only 1000/km^2. Also available in Tokyo is small apartments for single people. A minimum wage worker there will live in a small apartment, yes, but can survive without 5 roommates in a moldy basement suite.

Americans would be okay living in “Tokyo sized abodes” if they knew what that actually meant and didn’t assume all of Tokyo looks like Shibuya. One thing I’ll grant is that garages are rare, because they count as finished space for property tax purposes.

Tokyo is actually a great example of what a city without car-centric planning and free parking everywhere can be like and a perfect example of a “15 minute city”. It’s not only about transit, but what transit and walkability encourages. I lived there for 6 years in a very residential neighborhood, but I was still within 10 minutes walking of virtually any daily necessity, 5 or so grocery stores, dozens if not hundreds of restaurants, 3 public baths, one of which was a legit onsen, a few furniture stores, and even 2 aquarium shops. I’m trying to think of a counter example and I can only think of one thing that wasn’t a ten minute walk away: a movie theatre, although there were multiple within a 15 minute train ride.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by dghlsakjg on Friday February 17, 2023 @01:29PM (#34838439)
Tokyo style abodes are illegal in a huge part of many urban areas.

Given the choice between a some of the shitty living situations I dealt with while living in the US, and an affordable, compact efficient apartment. I'll take the latter

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by WarOnPrivacy on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:17AM (#34834891)
>> Perhaps because real estate/rent is simply too expensive anywhere closer.

> Whenever I've heard people make that argument, what they actually mean is "The huge house I want to live in I can afford if I spend an hour a day in the car...."

Or it's because it would require 3x-6x their income to afford to live anyplace closer. A major factor of employee shortages is exactly that. There are no homes within 50 mi (often much further) of that job that can be afforded with those wages.

We live 45mi out from a (until recently, inexpensive) US metro area and we require 4 incomes to cover basic expenses.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by Tade0 on Friday February 17, 2023 @10:16AM (#34835573)
That might have been the case a decade ago, but with the uptick in real estate prices it's not even that any more.

I have friends who bought an apartment in a small town next to the city where the jobs are because they didn't have the credit score for anything closer to work.

This is the reality (and realty) people in the market for living space are currently facing.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by fleddr on Friday February 17, 2023 @08:55AM (#34834659)
Because I can't afford to move to the city where I work.

Because even if I could, work is unstable, I can't keep moving.

Because I have a girlfriend, any move closer to work is further away for her.

Because my family and friends are here, and I need to take care of my parents.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by maxsilver on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:03AM (#34834737)
Because most people don't have the luxury of choosing those things.

- I don't have any meaningful control over where I'm allowed to work

- I don't have any meaningful control over where my spouse is allowed to work

- I only have a tiny amount of control over where I'm allowed to live (most of it prices us out, despite being above-average income)

- even if I do exercise some control, it can be changed or stripped from me by others at any time. (You may get laid off and have to find a new office. Or your office may move away from you -- when you are hired, the office might only have been 12 miles away, but later they moved the office so it's now 25 miles away)

- You may not always be allowed to move in response to those changes (you might not be able to afford to move your whole house every two years, when job situations for you/your spouse change. And if you have kids, doing this super disrupts any chance they may have at a social life via school)

- You may not even be allowed to change home or school locations. (Divorced people exist, shared-custody children exist and are in some places, the most common form of parenting in 2023, you might not be allowed to relocate your kids schools ever)

A lot of anti-transportation "15 minute city" idealists like to handwave away how incredibly complicated it is, to magically get your entire life to line up such that you don't ever have to travel medium-sized distances. That is an extreme luxury that most people will never have.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by nextaccountic on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:39AM (#34835141)
> I don't have any meaningful control over where I'm allowed to work

And that's exactly why remote work should be the norm (for the professions where it is at all possible)

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by bluGill on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:26AM (#34834997)
The 15 minute city isn't one you never leave, it is one where basic tasks of life are within 15 minutes. Most people will leave it for work, but they will stop and play within 15 minutes of home.

Otherwise you are spot on. If your company moves offices within the same city's MSA they assume you can get there. If they move office to a different city they will pay to move you.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by balfirevic on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:43AM (#34835189)
> Most people will leave it for work, but they will stop and play within 15 minutes of home.

Even that assumes you don't have relatively specific hobbies. Which I guess is true for many people, but it's highly unlikely that (for example) my preferred martial arts instructor and my preferred dance instructor are going to be within 15 minutes of where I live.

And of course, your girlfriend/boyfriend, if you don't live together.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by thesuitonym on Friday February 17, 2023 @10:03AM (#34835446)
What are you getting at? Are you incapable of nuance? It was already stated that a 15 minute city isn't a place you never leave, it's a place where you can meet your daily needs within 15 minutes. If you want to go to a specific martial arts instructor, then yes, you probably have to leave. But if you just want a place to work out, that will be around. If you want to go to a specific grocer, you will probably have to leave, but there will be a place where you can get your milk and veggies within 15 minutes. If you meet someone from outside your neighborhood, you'll have to visit them, but if you spend more time in your neighborhood, you'll likely make stronger bonds there.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by balfirevic on Friday February 17, 2023 @11:31AM (#34836761)
> What are you getting at? Are you incapable of nuance?

Your rudeness aside, what I'm getting at is that I'll likely have to leave once or twice a day even not accounting for work. I live in a European city and get everywhere by car BTW.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by harvey9 on Friday February 17, 2023 @11:25AM (#34836672)
Don't assume most people will leave it for work. Oxford, England intends to charge people who drive across a 15 minute zone boundary more than a few times a week. https://www.oxfordmail.co.uk/news/23073992.traffic-filters-w...
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by WeylandYutani on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:07AM (#34834785)
The average in the Netherlands is 20 kilometers if anyone is wondering.

I think public transport is pretty good if you live in the Den Haag-Rotterdam-Amsterdam area. Which in America would be considered a single metro area. Something like 5 million people.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by aenis on Friday February 17, 2023 @10:31AM (#34835755)
Ebikes also tend to change the equation. I live 37km from where I work. By bike its 1hr20 when its not too windy. By ebike its 1hr flat (ok, its a speed pedalec, requires a license). By car its 45 min. By train its 1hr10. Despite having the means to own a car I sold it a few years ago and never looked back. I rent one every few weeks I need one.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by throwaway894345 on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:23AM (#34834952)
I lived 5 miles away from my downtown office in Chicago. My apartment was 5 minutes from the train and my office was 1 minute on the other side. There were no connections, so this is an ideal public transit situation. It still took 40+ minutes each way versus 20 minutes by car during rush hour or ~10-15 outside of rush hour.

This is the third largest US city and one with comparably few major thoroughfares (compared to many other large US cities). It seems that it’s just really hard for public transit to beat cars at any distance.

Moreover, lots of people are constrained on where they can work and live. I think a lot of the anti-car rhetoric in America seems to assume everyone is a healthy, childless, young urban professional who aspires to live in the densest habitat he can find, and this is a very unrealistic portrait of Americans.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by hgomersall on Saturday February 18, 2023 @01:49AM (#34844621)
In truth, an environment built for people over cars is better for everyone. Including those that can't drive (which is all children, and many with disabilities) or can't afford to drive. Your case sounds like a perfect situation where a bike with proper cycling infrastructure would be the best option.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by throwaway894345 on Sunday February 19, 2023 @02:58PM (#34861218)
Not really. Chicago is pretty damn cold in the winter and hot in the summer and very wet in between. Of course, a Sufficiently Committed Cyclist can and will cope, but that's an unrealistic expectation for the majority of the population. Moreover, my example was an idyllic case for public transit (or as idyllic as it gets in the US). Most places are far less dense than Chicago and traveling by car is easier.

To be clear though, I would like to see more walkable places, and while "people over cars" is hopelessly vague and verging on ideology, I probably agree with some of what people envision when they make this statement. I think it would be great if our urban and semiurban environments had more, smaller shops and more safe infrastructure for bikes and cars. More separation of fast moving car traffic from side streets. Etc. But we have a loooong way to go before bikes or public transit are more practical than cars, and as others have pointed out even the most bike-friendly countries in the world still have high (and growing) rates of car ownership.

Cars are undeniably handy for all but some people in the densest environments, but we still need to take care not to overfit to cars.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by ddevault on Friday February 17, 2023 @08:34AM (#34834459)
This is a pretty unusual situation, where you presumably live in the sticks and commute to the city, or vice versa? In the cities, particularly Amsterdam, cars are not the favored option. In Amsterdam 38% of travel is by bike, Zwolle is 46%. Across the whole country the averages break down at 45% by car, 36% by bike, and 11% by transit. That is to say, a very slight majority prefers modes other than a car across the country as a whole, and within cities the difference is presumably more significant. These figures, even in their most conservative interpretation, are wildly different from the United States, where travel by bike is a rounding error and the public transit options are abysmal.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by refurb on Friday February 17, 2023 @08:33AM (#34834441)
It's similar in Singapore which arguably, because of its size has amazing public transport. But what do a lot of people do if they can afford it? Buy a car, especially if you want to live away from the city center and have kids.

They even pay the $100,000 fee for a 10 year permit to have a car, on top of 100% import tax. That's close to $175,000 just to own some tiny 3-cylinder car for 10 years.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by iso1631 on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:25AM (#34834979)
I spent a month in Singapore in 2015, staying at an apartment in Haugong, 10km from my office.

Public transport took an hour to get to the office. A taxi was 20 minutes. I'd agree public transport isn't great by a long way. Riding a bike if I lived there permanently might have been better, even with the 32 degree heat.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by noobermin on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:32AM (#34835071)
Singapore was literally rebuilt for cars very much like America. It's not because cars are better, and even so drivers are miserable here they rank low on waze's rankings of happy drivers, with Netherlands much further up the pack. All new developments (HDB as well) are even more car centric. If you can drive, you are afforded privilege in some respects, and so that's why people do it.

Also, "live away from the city center and have kids" ignores that still 89% of people in singapore don't own cars, and no, 89% of people in sg do not "live near the city center" or "don't have kids."

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by refurb on Friday February 17, 2023 @07:52PM (#34842695)
You kinda prove my point. 11% own cars because thats the government cap (no more cars allowed), but even middle class people are willing to spend hundreds of thousands for the benefits of driving.

And to say Singapore was built for cars is kinda funny. It has one of the best public transit systems in the world.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by vel0city on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:33AM (#34835083)
When you make it incredibly expensive to own a car, few people own cars. Who would have guessed?

I wonder what car ownership would look like if there was no fee and taxes were much lower?

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by bluecalm on Friday February 17, 2023 @11:14AM (#34836468)
Maybe wonder how it would look like if car owners actually paid for the cost (environmental, killing pedestrians and cyclists, huge areas of valuable land dedicated to parking, cost of road maintenance). Cars are the most subsidized mean of transportation, no wonder there are so many of them.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by refurb on Friday February 17, 2023 @08:38PM (#34842970)
You missed the point entirely.

It's incredibly expensive to owns cars and people still pay.

That tells you how valuable they find owning a car.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by goodpoint on Friday February 17, 2023 @08:46AM (#34834566)
> The US anti-car narrative often refers to the Netherlands as some kind of beacon of proper public infrastructure

No, you are confusing the Netherlands an a whole with cities like Amsterdam.

People refer to the latter as an example of walkable cities.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by rexpress on Friday February 17, 2023 @08:49AM (#34834590)
>First, let's establish that the Netherlands is a car country...On a typical day, 1 million people use public transport. Cars are the norm, not trains or bicycles.

Anyone visiting a Dutch city can see what a distortion this comment is. The sheer volume of bike traffic on largely safe infrastructure is phenomenal. Imagine if even half of these people took to cars instead, it would be gridlock. Life may be good for Dutch drivers, but only because so many others leave their cars at home.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by macNchz on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:26AM (#34834992)
> The sheer volume of bike traffic on largely safe infrastructure is phenomenal. Imagine if even half of these people took to cars instead, it would be gridlock.

Having visited Amsterdam by chance after missing a flight to London due to NYC gridlock traffic, this was one of my first thoughts on arrival.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by throwaway894345 on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:11AM (#34834823)
How is that a distortion? It seems like you’re violently agreeing with the parent that many people bike to work but far, far fewer than the majority (which is essentially what the American anti-car rhetoric suggests).

> Imagine if even half of these people took to cars instead, it would be gridlock.

There are 10 million employed Dutch (Statistica) of whom 65% drive (Statistica), so an additional half a million would be a 10% traffic increase, which is probably not “gridlock”, but in any case I don’t see how this refutes the original claim that Netherlands is a car country.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by nirimda on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:37AM (#34835124)
I think the problem is that American anti-car rhetoric doesn't speak with one voice. There are people who know what they're talking about, who are mostly saying "If we follow some of the Dutch practices, we can get a city where people can get to a local destination by bike safely. But we should also take note that even in the Netherlands, the need to engineer roads for bike safety is something they continually forget". But there's others who say "The US is a hell-hole, Americans are evil and dumb, cars are evil, they will destroy the earth, we must all copy the enlightened Europeans who are good and wise people".

It is like that for so many reform proposals. Heterodox economists (MMT or gold standard or anything really) will say "we ought to consider this evidence in making our economic decisions", and their acolytes on forums like this will say "If we adopt this reform, we will be able to solve all our problems, but it's just corruption and self-interested politicians who stop us". Voting system reform people say "The US is screwed by FPTP, if we adopted proportional representation we will depolarise and have a nice consensual politics", but people who study the politics of countries that use proportional representation don't really indicate that (I think in this case there are some political scientists who get close, but only by circularly defining perfection in politics as exhibiting the consequences of proportional representation).

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by throwaway894345 on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:59AM (#34835395)
I agree that it’s hard to represent groups accurately, but I don’t think your “person who knows what they’re talking about” falls reasonably within bounds of anyone’s “anti-car” definition. For one, it’s not actually an anti-car argument, it’s a pro-cycling argument and lots of Americans favor safer cycling without getting anywhere near anti-car. Moreover, every identifiably anti-car community I’m aware of (e.g., r/fuckcars) has a tone that is more akin to your “Americans are evil” example—are there identifiably anti-car communities that embody your former example?
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by resfirestar on Friday February 17, 2023 @11:51AM (#34837039)
I don't know of any such communities online, but in real world local politics the first example is more common. People who support things like bike lanes, bus lanes, and light rail don't describe themselves as "anti-car", but their opponents call them that among less polite names, so I'd argue it's the more mainstream definition of anti-car.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by throwaway894345 on Friday February 17, 2023 @12:44PM (#34837798)
Yeah, I think we're talking about different groups. I'm talking about people who self-identify as "anti-car". I've never heard of anyone who uses "anti-car" as a derogatory term for others, but I wouldn't be surprised if they exist somewhere. Personally, it seems unreasonable to me to define "anti-car" as "supports other modes of transit"; "anti-car" by my definition (which I think is the main definition) requires emphatic opposition to cars.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by tablespoon on Friday February 17, 2023 @11:20AM (#34836574)
> ...but only by circularly defining perfection in politics as exhibiting the consequences of proportional representation

Oh, I love "logic" like that. Another common example is: "the free market is the best economic system because the perfect allocation of goods in society is how the market does it."

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by CydeWeys on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:37AM (#34835125)
You need fine-grained statistics. It certainly isn't true that 65% of the people living or working in big dense Dutch cities like Amsterdam drive to work. That statistic more reflects how much the population of the Netherlands is spread out as a whole, not concentrated in its biggest cities as is more common in many other European countries.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by ikesau on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:45AM (#34835222)
Do you mean Statistica or Statista?
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by throwaway894345 on Friday February 17, 2023 @10:00AM (#34835412)
Statista. I’m on mobile and autocorrect is getting me. I edited my post, thanks for the correction.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by tromp on Friday February 17, 2023 @10:02AM (#34835429)
> There are 10 million employed Dutch (Statistica) of whom 65% drive

People don't just commute to work. Millions of Dutch students commute to school and I expect a large majority of those will bike.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by rexpress on Friday February 17, 2023 @10:28AM (#34835703)
The original poster claimed that car usage is the norm in the Netherlands, which implies that anything else is outside the norm, or unusual. This is obviously incorrectly.

There are various other posts in this thread that also give statistics, and the number of car vs bike journeys is not so far apart.

In a country that famously has more bikes then people, the idea that if half the bike journeys converted to cars there would only be a ten percent increase in traffic is quite clearly ridiculous. Especially within cities bikes carry volumes of people that would overwhelm roads if those people used space-inefficient cars.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by throwaway894345 on Friday February 17, 2023 @12:48PM (#34837870)
> The original poster claimed that car usage is the norm in the Netherlands, which implies that anything else is outside the norm, or unusual

This isn't a reasonable interpretation. "the norm" only implies that it's the majority mode of transportation (in contrast with the anti-car rhetoric). This implies that other modes are not the majority, but it does not imply that those other modes are particularly rare.

> In a country that famously has more bikes then people, the idea that if half the bike journeys converted to cars there would only be a ten percent increase in traffic is quite clearly ridiculous.

I mean, I showed my math--feel free to point out where I erred, but just stating "it's quite clearly ridiculous" is like putting your fingers in your ears and shouting, "I can't hear you".

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by twic on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:52AM (#34835296)
Generalising from the centre of a city to the whole country is a distortion. Last time i was in the Netherlands, i arrived in Amsterdam, then went out to the countryside, somewhere near Dedemsvaart. I looked at doing the trip by public transport, but it would have taken forever. Instead, we rented a car and drove there, along wide, fast, busy roads. The Netherlands is indeed a heavily motorised country.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by rexpress on Friday February 17, 2023 @10:41AM (#34835892)
Dutch cycling infrastructure is close to ubiquitous, extending practically the length and breadth of the country. The idea that bikes are used only in city centres is another distortion. But of course the bike tends to be used for shorter, local trips.

Your (roughly 130 km) journey would have been less fast had those people making their shorter distance journeys by bike got into their cars instead.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by xputer on Saturday February 18, 2023 @02:21PM (#34850127)
You'll find plenty of people cycling in Dedemsvaart itself though. Nobody is claiming cars don't have their place. It just shouldn't be the default mode - or even worse, the only viable option - for every single trip.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by kamaal on Friday February 17, 2023 @10:21AM (#34835630)
>>Anyone visiting a Dutch city can see what a distortion this comment is.

Your parent comment is saying the same thing. Stay inside the city, close enough to your office that you can reach it by a bicycle. Of course in that case you could say the rent you would be pay would be equally higher. Plus not every one can afford to do that(given school availability, and your spouse office has to be close by too).

On a net basis, its again the same thing. You just pay for your time with higher rents.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by cscurmudgeon on Friday February 17, 2023 @10:36AM (#34835811)
What fraction of Netherlands lives in a city vs the rural areas?
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by yourusername on Friday February 17, 2023 @11:07AM (#34836320)
Even in the most urbanised part of the country most people still drive for most distances over ~5km. If you have to get from one side of Rotterdam to the other side a car is much faster than a bike or public transportation.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by nayuki on Friday February 17, 2023 @12:34PM (#34837645)
Rotterdam is much more car-friendly than Amsterdam.

Not Just Bikes: "Rotterdam: the City Rebuilt for Cars": https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=22ovt1EMULY

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by tablespoon on Friday February 17, 2023 @11:16AM (#34836499)
> Anyone visiting a Dutch city can see what a distortion this comment is. The sheer volume of bike traffic on largely safe infrastructure is phenomenal. Imagine if even half of these people took to cars instead, it would be gridlock. Life may be good for Dutch drivers, but only because so many others leave their cars at home.

I was actually considering making the same point, but sarcastically: "B b but, when I was a tourist visiting the walkable tourist areas Amsterdam where tourists go, I didn't passively observe any locals needing a car!"

It's a mistake to think tourist/visitor experiences give you a good idea what it's like to live anywhere.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by rexpress on Friday February 17, 2023 @11:38AM (#34836862)
That assumes that the tourists and visitors confine themselves to the major tourist areas. If you bother to cycle outside the major tourist areas of the Netherlands, whether to minor cities or villages, you'll still notice many people cycling for local journeys.

The mistake is people used to car dependence being unable to imagine any alternative, thus refusing to believe that it can be true.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by tablespoon on Friday February 17, 2023 @03:59PM (#34840491)
> That assumes that the tourists and visitors confine themselves to the major tourist areas.

Which is a valid default assumption, unless it's made clear the speaker didn't do that.

Especially in this case, where you have an actual Dutch person who lives in the actual Netherlands getting told they were wrong by someone who cites visitor experiences.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by xputer on Saturday February 18, 2023 @02:09PM (#34849998)
Cycling is ubiquitous in the Netherlands though. Even in small towns. The only place where it's not convenient is if you're living out in the fields in say Flevoland.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by hintymad on Friday February 17, 2023 @04:23PM (#34840754)
It seems you're assuming that majority of the people live in the city or would love in a city? Many people, me included, do not want to live in a city, at least not in an American city. What a city boasts to offer are not relevant to my life: bars, shops, boutique stores, fancy restaurants, active social circles, loud parties, fashion shows, you name it. All those activities are just either too noisy or too crowded. On the other hand, there's not enough outdoor activities in a city. Things are so small in a city too. I want to stay in a spacious coffee shop talking to my friends without raising my voice. I want to have a huge gym instead of those crammed multi-floor ones in a city. I want to have a house that has large enough backyard and front yard and quiet streets for my kids to play around. I want to be able to play drum on my front yard and my neighbors won't hear a thing (I'm exaggerating but you get the idea). I want to be able to hop on a vehicle to ski in a place no more than 30 minutes away from my home whenever I want to. And I certainly don't want to take a bus for grocery shopping for a family of 6. The only thing in a city that I miss is those amazing huge libraries. God I enjoy spending my whole day there.

And if I can afford such life without a car, I'm all for it. But I don't know how.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by mcv on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:01AM (#34834717)
> We have 11 million cars on a population of 17 million.

Yeah, but we have 23 million bikes.

It's true that our public transport has been neglected. The privatisation of the 1990s was a bad idea in my opinion, and public transport should be run for the public good, not for profit. Like roads, it's part of the nation's infrastructure. And better public transport means less people on the road, which means less traffic jams, which will also mean better travel times for people who really do need cars.

The number of bike trips and car trips aren't that far apart (25% and 32%). Public transport still lags way behind at 3%.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by nextaccountic on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:36AM (#34835104)
> > We have 11 million cars on a population of 17 million.

> Yeah, but we have 23 million bikes.

> (...)

> The number of bike trips and car trips aren't that far apart (25% and 32%).

Wow, that's a good point. But, is the number of bike trips compared to car trips growing, shrinking, or staying the same?

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by throwaway894345 on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:14AM (#34834862)
All of that is true but it doesn’t seem to refute the parent’s claim that the American anti-car rhetoric envisions a nation where cycling and taking public transit to work is the norm because the Dutch have figured out how to make cycling and public transit faster than driving.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by dashundchen on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:54AM (#34835314)
It doesn't refute it because I think it's a mischaracterization of what "anti-car" or bike/transit/pedestrians advocates are typically asking for

What I and many other advocates in the US want is for anything besides cars to be even considered in public infrastructure and urban design. Living without access to a car is near impossible in lots of US cities.

The default is to design around the car, if bikes or pedestrians are mentioned it's tacked on as an afterthought.

An example I had just last night was my US city presented their first phase of the "bike master plan". Essentially the engineers told us they didn't want to maintain protected bike infrastructure or interfere with traffic. About half of the "improvements" they listed out were "sharrows", bike symbols painted in the travel lane. The other half were striped bike lanes with no protection from vehicles.

And this is in a city that's inherited some bike/ped/transit friendliness by the nature of it being built pre-war.

Good luck in the exurban sprawl, South and Sunbelt - you'll be lucky to even have a sidewalk, nevermind a bike lane on the 8 lane road. The car is default in the US.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by mcv on Friday February 17, 2023 @10:03AM (#34835449)
Not Just Bikes on youtube (strongly recommended) loves to point out that Netherland is not just better for bikes, but also for cars, exactly because so many people travel by bike, leaving the road available for those who really do need a car. And the roads here are far better maintained than in any of our neighbouring countries.

For some trips, cycling or public transport really is faster than driving, but for others obviously not. The most important thing is that all three are viable options. Forcing everybody into only one of those three will hurt everybody.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by toshredsyousay on Friday February 17, 2023 @12:45PM (#34837823)
Isn't the hype more about the relative difference (I don't think most people are claiming NL is a utopia)? The amount of miles driven per capita in the US is twice as much as that of the NL. The percent of trips on bike is 25% in the NL vs 2% in the US. About half of all trips made in the NL are on bike, transit or walking. The other half of trips are made with cars. If the US suddenly had half the amount of driving per capita that it does now that would mean dramatic lifestyle differences on average.

Japan seems to have the least driving per capita of any wealthy nation (at least from the data I see), so maybe people should be using that as an example more, but I think a lot of people in the US really appreciate the physical protection that people on bikes often get in the NL (even if it isn't everywhere). It sends a different message about priorities.

In the US, even if you don't want to drive, that is often your only choice for most trips, whereas in the NL you can drive if you want, but it is easier to find an alternative. That is a 'car-oriented' mindset versus 'multi-modal transit' mindset. However, I am sure that the NL could still make many changes to reduce car ownership if it really wanted to.

https://internationalcomparisons.org/environmental/transport...

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by weberc2 on Friday February 17, 2023 @01:26PM (#34838394)
> Isn't the hype more about the relative difference (I don't think most people are claiming NL is a utopia)?

We're talking specifically about self-designated "anti-car" people. I doubt there are any surveys, so we're all just conjecturing, but the rhetoric I see definitely holds NL and Europe generally up as a car-less utopia. For example, the first post on r/anticar is titled "cities built for people rather than cars are so beautiful" and it shows an idyllic picture of a German street. https://www.reddit.com/r/Anticar/comments/mp6t4p/cities_buil...

> The amount of miles driven per capita in the US is twice as much as that of the NL. The percent of trips on bike is 25% in the NL vs 2% in the US. About half of all trips made in the NL are on bike, transit or walking. The other half of trips are made with cars.

I don't see how this is relevant? I don't think anyone in this thread disputes that cycling is more prevalent in NL versus US, and none of this refutes the toplevel claim that NL is a car country nor supports the anti-car rhetoric which suggests that NL is a car-free utopia. Like many "non-anti-car" Americans, I would like to see American transit become more multi-modal, but that's not what we're debating at present.

> However, I am sure that the NL could still make many changes to reduce car ownership if it really wanted to.

Sure (the obvious/extreme example is banning cars by legislation), but this seems circular, because we're implicitly interested in why doesn't the NL public want fewer cars (on the contrary, car ownership was increasing as of 2016)? Like in the US we can plausibly argue that Americans haven't experienced the Dutch cycling/pubtransit system and thus doesn't know what they're missing out on, but that's a much harder argument to make about the Dutch. :)

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by vel0city on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:10AM (#34834806)
Traveling 60km, even in traffic near me, would take like 45 minutes by car.

It's a bit of a long commute by US norms (I think average is 20mi, 32km) but not too crazy compared to what some people do.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by chasely on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:20AM (#34834925)
The Netherlands ranks 36th on the list of cars per capita [0]. This is higher than I thought it would be but it's still quite a ways away from the countries I would consider to be car-centric like the US and Canada (ranked 6th and 8th, respectively).

I also found this plot interesting relating vehicles and GDP [1], though the data seems outdated compared to the first link.

I'd also guess, though I can't find the data, that the US is one the highest cars per capita rates in its cities. Outside of NYC and Chicago, there is a real lack of public transport infrastructure in most US cities.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_vehicles_... [1]

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by thesuitonym on Friday February 17, 2023 @10:16AM (#34835577)
My guy, nobody thinks the Netherlands is a perfect beacon of transit, but you just can't understand what it's like living in the US. Even if you live in a large metro, unless it's NYC or you live and work in the right parts of Chicago, public transit just isn't even an option--unless an hour and a half commute on a bus is worth it to you.

Let's compare your commute to work to a commute in the US:

>I have to get up early and be there some 10 mins before departure to secure somewhat of a reasonable spot. In the US, you have to be there at least 30 minutes early, because the parking lot will be absolutely packed, and the busses don't run on time, so it might get there too soon.

>Next, I'm on route to the first big city station. We don't even have this in the US. You would have had to already be in the city to get on the bus.

>This route is slow, it stops 5 times along the way as everybody needs to connect to a big hub to get where they need to be. In the US, this route stops the same five times, but also gets stuck in rush hour traffic, because we rarely have dedicated transit lanes.

I arrive at the hub, where there's a 20 minute connection wait to take the train to the big city destination. The connection in the US would be at least 30 minutes, if you're lucky it will be scheduled at 20 during rush hour, but the bus is probably late. Also, again, it's not going into the city, you were already there, you just need to get on a different route.

>I get out and have a 10 minute connection wait for the bus to take me to the place closest to work, after which there's a 5-10 minute work.

If you have to make another connection outside the hub, you're probably waiting at least 45 minutes, in addition to the bus being late. The closest bus stop to where you work is another 30 minute walk away, along a 45 mph highway with no bike lanes and a sidewalk that just randomly ends occasionally.

>Total commute time: 2.5 hours single way. To move 60km. And that's living behind a train station and working at one of the countries' largest employers.

In the US, this was actually entire hypothetical. The route just doesn't actually exist.

Hope this helps you see why we place NL on a pedestal. We know it's not perfect, but it's so much better than what we have. Unless you live in an incredibly small portion of the country, it's just not an option.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by dsfyu404ed on Friday February 17, 2023 @10:34AM (#34835785)
>In the US, this was actually entire hypothetical. The route just doesn't actually exist.

Drag your butt over to Google maps and punch in a route from Lowell, Leominster, Worcester or Taunton Massachusetts (outlying cities in the Boston area people many commute in from) to any portion of the Boston area just inside I95 but not downtown and eyeball the times.

The route exists in the US and the times are in line with his estimates.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by thesuitonym on Friday February 17, 2023 @10:48AM (#34835986)
Oh boy, you found one outlier! That negates my entire argument!
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by ghaff on Friday February 17, 2023 @10:56AM (#34836131)
I live about a 7 minute drive from the North Leominster commuter rail. I'm about 90 minutes door to door to Boston/Cambridge depending upon where I'm going--which is better than driving at rush hour.

That said, it's only useful for commuting. There are far too few trains after evening rush hour to use it if attending an evening event.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by fleddr on Friday February 17, 2023 @11:14AM (#34836456)
My guy, dude...I didn't contradict the idea that the Netherlands has superior transit options compared to the US. I was giving push-back against the idea that the Dutch situation is utopian as if some kind of paradise. It isn't.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by cscurmudgeon on Friday February 17, 2023 @10:35AM (#34835808)
Well said. The pro-EU narrative hypes up everything in the EU or Europe zone ignoring data. For e.g., US rail infra is more than that of Netherlands per capita:

https://www.nationmaster.com/country-info/stats/Transport/Ra...

Usage (totals):

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_rail_usag...

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by tmnvix on Friday February 17, 2023 @03:43PM (#34840275)
> Let's explore the commute to work, some 60km away...

Well. There's your problem.

The idea of travelling 60km to work is a very modern phenomenon. Like a lot of people you've built your life around car travel. It's hard to get back from that.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by xputer on Saturday February 18, 2023 @02:05PM (#34849954)
Well it seems you're criticizing Americans' rosy view of Dutch public infrastructure without realizing how absurd the US is in terms of infrastructure. I challenge you to visit the US and not use a car at all. In many cities you wouldn't even be able to get out of the airport. Yet Schiphol has a massive station underneath it with trains that can take you, not only to Amsterdam, but to virtually any city and even small town in the country.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by fragmede on Saturday February 18, 2023 @02:17PM (#34850087)
Not just in the county, but to other countries, which thanks to Shengen, means it's viable to live in one country and work in another. High speed rail ftw.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by devoutsalsa on Friday February 17, 2023 @08:29AM (#34834405)
Because trains don’t go everywhere.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by t0bia_s on Friday February 17, 2023 @11:25AM (#34836669)
But with combination of bus you are able to go almost everywhere in Czechia.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by nerdchum on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:21AM (#34834932)
Are dogs allowed on the trains?
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by wkat4242 on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:41AM (#34835169)
The problem in the Netherlands is the peripheral connections. Transport between the cities is great. Inside them also. Suburban areas are crap though. In my town my house 15km from the city center of Amsterdam had a bus one time per hour. And really unreliable, often wouldn't appear etc. Walking to the train station was possible but 20 minutes.

This makes any trip much more difficult. Anyway I had to have the car for work. I hated that thing and the consultancy job.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by tobyhinloopen on Friday February 17, 2023 @10:01AM (#34835417)
> Why would anyone in a rich country with a high functioning rail system like The Netherlands want to drive?

Because some people don’t live in Amsterdam or The Hague.

Taking public transportation will take me over twice the time, and that’s when there’s no outage or delay.

“But traffic jams!” I hear you say. Well, the % time in traffic jams is drastically less for me than the % time lost due to missing a transfer, a delayed train or a canceled train.

Traffic jams are annoying but not very common or large, and will only rarely cause me to miss an appointment. Also, you just use cruise control and wait.

Experiencing a delay, cancelation or missing a transfer is almost guaranteed for any trip I make, and this usually means waiting another 30 mins for the next train or bus, and trying to figure out what I need to do to get to my destination (finding alternative trains)

All while being more expensive and less comfortable than just driving somewhere. If it were (drastically) cheaper, I could convince myself to take the time loss. But it is not, it is literally more expensive to take the train or bus than to drive if you already own a car.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by evanelias on Friday February 17, 2023 @10:46AM (#34835969)
> The main benefit of Zipcar to me versus owning is that the car had a parking space that it went back into.

I used to wholeheartedly agree with this. I lived in a very parking-constrained area. Zipcar had cars with dedicated spots on random corners throughout town, which was extremely convenient! At least prior to 2020...

Then the pandemic hit, and the number of package delivery trucks skyrocketed, along with doordash, uber eats, etc. And also just a general decrease in people's willingness to follow parking rules and signs. In the final year of my Zipcar membership before cancellation, literally 100% of my rentals involved dealing with a blocked parking spot when trying to return the car. I just don't think Zipcar's concept is viable anymore.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by 83 on Friday February 17, 2023 @11:09AM (#34836372)
Not everyone want to spend their whole life in an urban environment. Perhaps there is not much opportunity for this in the Netherlands, but I can't imagine not having a vehicle to go camping/rock climbing/kayaking/mountain biking/hiking which requires going to remote areas not typically serviced by public transport.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by t0bia_s on Friday February 17, 2023 @11:22AM (#34836603)
Depnds on country. In Czech Republic public transport is common and take you in almost every village. It is actually more comfortable to go hiking by public transport, because you can plan route from place A to place B. You do not have to go from A to B and back to A bcause of car.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by stronglikedan on Friday February 17, 2023 @11:56AM (#34837129)
> Why would anyone in a rich country with a high functioning rail system like The Netherlands want to drive?

Because some people, like me, find driving to be blissful and elating, and I will never not take the opportunity to do it.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by tdiff on Friday February 17, 2023 @12:07PM (#34837280)
Because number of trains per day makes little sense if you have to plan the trip months in advance to get affordable prices, and the ticket binds you to a specific train.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by wffurr on Monday February 20, 2023 @07:24AM (#34867447)
One line of thought that hadn't occurred to me until this thread is that The Netherlands car infrastructure is also probably quite good, in keeping with their general high quality of infrastructure all around.

Although as many of the other commenters noted, one reason that driving in some places in the country is doable is that many others choose alternatives, themselves made attractive by high quality infrastructure.