News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by Ekaros on Friday February 17, 2023 @07:59AM (#34834105)
That is optimal situation.

But it does breakdown or be worse with slightly more complicated routes. Like I used to travel from smaller city to bigger city to other big city. And in the end public transport was probably 50% if not longer in time. First 15-20 minutes to station, then 45 minutes with local train. Wait for intercity, ~2 hours and 30 minutes or get lift to destination. Compared to straight 2 hours from door to door with car.

And this is with perfectly serviceable train network with plenty enough trains. Or at max capacity.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by mcv on Friday February 17, 2023 @08:32AM (#34834435)
25% longer is not that bad, especially if you consider that you can't work while driving, but for many kinds of work, you can do some work in a train (if you have a seat, at least). Or read a book.

I don't consider train travel to be lost time in the way car travel is.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by Retric on Friday February 17, 2023 @08:26AM (#34834361)
Swapping trains can take a while, but until self driving works you can’t do much while driving. And even with self driving simply up and stretching, grabbing a bite to eat, or even just going to the bathroom requires you to stop making progress for a while.

Driving has several advantages, but getting stuck in traffic is extremely unpleasant in ways that similar delays on other forms of travel don’t really replicate.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by robertlagrant on Friday February 17, 2023 @08:38AM (#34834493)
> getting stuck in traffic is extremely unpleasant in ways that similar delays on other forms of travel don’t really replicate

But you also don't have to take a 3 hour coach ride because the driver or other staff's union is striking. It's just you and your car.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by mcv on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:22AM (#34834943)
But that's again because these trains are run for profit, cutting every corner they can, and underpaying their employees. I'd prefer to see trains nationalised and run as national infrastructure with the goal of luring more commuters into mass transit. Because that will mean enormous savings in pollution, traffic jams, noise, and road maintenance.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by robertlagrant on Saturday February 18, 2023 @01:42PM (#34849713)
Even when they were nationalised they were terrible. The biggest problem isn't whether it's for profit or not. The biggest problem is the relatively vast value for money, and value in general, of cars, even with extremely large fuel taxes imposed. People don't want to pay a lot of money for transport because they've seen how much value a car gives, and so having the cost and large numbers of people required to operate a really high quality train would require more than anything raising ticket prices significantly.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by Retric on Saturday February 18, 2023 @09:39PM (#34853660)
Car travel is only “cheap” per trip because people have already sunk the costs into owning, insuring, and parking their car and paying for roads.

Fuel taxes don’t even come close to paying for our road networks while rail is lumping all these costs together on a per trip basis.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by robertlagrant on Sunday February 19, 2023 @07:06AM (#34856894)
It's still cheap compared to that.

If you want an emergency services vehicles to get to your house you need a road anyway.

If you want buses and coaches to function, you need roads.

If you want to transport a bootload of stuff more than three times a year you're financially better off paying for a car than renting.

If yor kids have school anywhere that isn't walking/cycling distance from your house, then you need a car, or two.

If you have a job, and don't want to be beholden to a very local employer, you likely need a car. Except if you live close to a train station and your job is close to another one. And except in the last five years, when some jobs can now be remote.

If you want to go anywhere that a train doesn't go, you need a car, probably. Which is everywhere outside of extremely high density urban areas that can afford an underground rail system.

You need any of those things to be true for a road to be needed. You likely need a car for all but the first two. Cars and roads are valuable. I don't see how that's debatable.

Trains are now location-specific optimisations where we know we have hotspots of usefulness, where it's worth laying track and having massive investment as enough people will use that route.

Just as a circuit-switched phone call is a better connection, but packet-switched is better overall, and cheaper, so are trains and cars.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by Retric on Monday February 20, 2023 @04:05PM (#34872895)
A public road network for cars needs a great deal of infrastructure that a public network for busses and ambulances would. Literally every single street in NYC could be single lane, one way, without any street level parking if you’re not building for cars. Further, the demands of traffic directly relate to the kinds of roads, bridges etc you can get away with building.

You have several objectively false statements here such as:

“If yor kids have school anywhere that isn't walking/cycling distance from your house, then you need a car, or two.” Except 100’s of millions of people currently live live further than cycling distance from their kids school and don’t own a car.

Frankly cars didn’t exist until very recently and society was fine without them.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by Retric on Friday February 17, 2023 @10:29AM (#34835721)
Just you and your car + the guys bumper 3 feet in front of you that’s moved 5 feet in the last minute because of a traffic accident or something. Luckily you can just look at waze and holly shit you’re going to be in this mess for another 4 hours, but you can’t even take a nap or something because traffic is still inching along…

Now that’s not universal, but I really do budget 3-4 hours extra for some trips because holiday traffic is just that bad in my area.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by HardlyCurious on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:13AM (#34834848)
This is really the selling point of mass transit for me.

But I have a problem. I'm an introvert and I get fatigued by constant human interaction. I also get fatigued by constant distractions. I really benefit from having some breathing space where I can zone out.

Saying it out load makes it sound reckless and inconsistent, doesn't driving require constant attention? But no, somehow I can zone out drive and drive to my destination completely subconsciously, at least if it's a route I know we'll, like on a commute.

I'm 39 now and I have never caused an accident for what that anecdotle evidence means.

My commutes are my decompress time. I can't do anything during them, and if I could, I wouldn't benefit the same way.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by dublinben on Friday February 17, 2023 @11:30AM (#34836743)
With safe, separated infrastructure, a commute of the same duration via bicycling or walking would be even better for your physical and mental health. We all live in a prison of car supremacy, whether we realize it or not.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by HardlyCurious on Friday February 17, 2023 @11:37AM (#34836854)
I lived very close to my work for a period and tried bike commuting. I don't disagree with the benefits of doing it, but it's not very realistic for most people in most places.

I was having a hard time NOT getting sweaty on my ride into work because humidity is the highest in the morning. And when I wasnt sweating I was getting rained on, or my hands were freezing, or I got chain grease on my pants.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by toshredsyousay on Friday February 17, 2023 @02:12PM (#34838966)
If you got an electric bike, that could help with the sweat. The breeze with the extra speed and the reduction in effort really reduce the of sweat dramatically. Or just bring a change of clothes and maybe a towel if that is tolerable. For the rain, a bike poncho works pretty well, especially if you pair it with rubber boots (maybe have a change of shoes ready). For the cold, gloves or bar mitts work pretty well. For the chain grease, you can get a full chain guard to house the entire chain if you want, or just tuck your pants into long socks, or get a pant clip. Given how much maintenance people often have to do on cars, a little care to have the right gear for biking is often easily well worth the effort and cost.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by HardlyCurious on Friday February 17, 2023 @02:26PM (#34839133)
Yes, there are solutions or work arounds for these issues. It just makes commuting on a bike inconvenient for many people.

Electric bikes are great, but other than price, it starts to blur between having an electric motorcycle. Especially after you need to don appropriate gear for the commute to stay dry / comfortable. And the motorcycle would have greater range and more use cases.

And at the end of the day, while riding a bike to work is great and I would encourage everyone to try it if they can, do you really think it works without a backup plan? Even people I know who have taking bike commuting pretty seriously didn't do it literally every single day.

Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by Retric on Friday February 17, 2023 @03:04PM (#34839756)
Bike specific trails make a huge difference here. An electric motorcycle is less flexible, costs more, and doesn’t provide exercise. Pedal assist going in + a workout on the way back is hard to beat.
Re:Throughout the rich world, the young are falling out of l... by smaudet on Friday February 17, 2023 @08:18AM (#34834292)
Sure in the case of long commutes or exploration of different areas there are certain advantaged to autonomous vehicles - however the car is by no means king. Helicopter is even better for getting from random distant location to distant location.

But this is not the majority of travel, and in those cases car travel is indeed overkill, and a hassle to boot, as anyone who has ever had to daily wrangle with parking lots and rush hour traffic can attest.

There are different concerns with public transport, but the advantages tend to outweigh the disadvantages, and it appears this is borne out by the data.