It's transparently gross if music SOLD to me that I'm supposed to be able to listen to in perpetuity is DRM'd so I can't shift platforms or devices or whatever. That's shitty, and I'm glad we're done with that.
However, the deal with a streaming service is that for the price we used to pay to "own" a single CD or album, we get access to an enormous body of music we can listen to at will. That, to me, is a service that I'm paying for. I'm not troubled by the music being locked in, because what I'm paying for is access to that library.
It's definitely a shift in how music works, and it's not without its downsides (especially as I understand it for artists), but in a world where most people don't have access to great record stores I think it's overall better.
We never "won" with video purchases at all, which was predictable (we only got free-access formats on music because it happened outside the industry), but also less of a problem for me personally. I might "buy" something from Apple or whatever, but I understand it as a long-term rental. If I really want to own a film, I buy the BluRay.
As for Linux, man, that's an unalloyed victory. Does anyone even SELL commercial Unix anymore? When I was younger there was still AIX and HP/UX and obviously Solaris, but I never heard of any of those anymore.
Apple.
And before anyone says yes well but it runs a proprietary application layer so it doesn't count, it also runs all the open ones too just fine. The fact it's barely used for that despite a massive user base (by Unix standards) is hardly Apple's problem, or fault even. It just goes to show how deeply and thoroughly the open source software community has failed in getting the vast majority of ordinary people to care about open source desktop software. Even when all the barriers to access are completely eliminated.
Rarely have there been such obvious and one-sided manipulation of public source repos on strictly licensed code, as have been published by Apple Inc. It appears that they go out of their way to insult and dismiss any "power" over the code itself, like a steering committee especially, but as simple as an open repo maintainer.
There is simply no profit in making current, working source code available in the same way as a published book at a public library is.. and so there is infinite Chutzpah at Apple Inc to say, not our affair. There is no way that current active source code works the way it is supposed to, if you cannot find it, build it, change it and thereby learn it and apply it.
Emperor Apple has no clothes here
Also, Apple's kernel (XNU) is somewhat open-source. Apple isn't really interested in contributions, but you can build it yourself and install it, and macOS will boot and run from it (the main exception being iOS apps on Apple Silicon, maybe Apple Pay, and FileVault gets disabled to make the modification and inability to fully secure your system obvious, those parts are closed source kernel extensions, but they aren't dealbreakers).
Precisely. For those attempting to deny this, He's right you know.
macOS is a commercial and certified Unix and is still sold as part of their Macs. So that is still true to this day.
[1] https://www.opengroup.org/openbrand/register/brand3673.htm
[2] https://www.opengroup.org/openbrand/register/brand3678.htm
AT&T Unix -> BSD -> FreeBSD -> NeXTSTEP -> macOS. (This is overly simplified, as everything is a mess and macOS contains code from both FreeBSD and original BSD which FreeBSD was based on, among other places.)
macOS is ironically a more authentic Unix than Linux is, Linux having been a clone while macOS being a great grandchild.
Diagram of Unix History: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/7/77/Unix_his...
what I meant, though, was "for the datacenter" or "for server applications."
I don't think the film industry gets as much from me as before with physical copies. But I don't accept discs anymore. Give me a digital download or go away. I use some streaming services but just consume far less now.
I am not much troubled by DRM, but the industry mostly regresses to past behavior.
I held off on the subscription services for a long time, but I eventually pulled the trigger for two reasons.
First, OTA access to everything was simpler and easier than cable sync from my (enormous) library. This may or may not be a unique feature of Apple Music, but I'm in the world so it works for me. By signing up to AM, I can get everything on my phone on demand, including weird or esoteric things that aren't actually available on Apple Music because AM will read my actual library and upload anything it doesn't have to facilitate easy access. (Now, YOU can't get access to the weird stuff I have, but that's fine.)
The second reason, which I admit is actually the first forcing function, is that while I understood perfectly well how to go to the music server and plug in my phone and sync music, it was just a Bridge Too Far for my nontechnical wife. She wanted it simpler, and so rather than complain was just not listening to music on her phone. :(
So I signed up for AM, and holy crap it's been pretty much an unalloyed boon. I still buy stuff (mostly local, since I live in a place with a record store), but I sample FAR more widely than I did before because the incremental cost to trying something because I read an article about this-or-that artist is zero. That aspect is pretty great.
And the way I have AM configured, everything I listen to gets downloaded, so if I'm in a place with no coverage (or an airplane) I still have everything I want.
Well, yeah. Streaming services wouldn't exist without DRM. The existence of infinite accessible libraries of content for flat-fee monthly-subscription prices, is built upon IP licenses which were granted conditional to the consumer's inability to leverage that access into piracy. If we deleted DRM, streaming services would cease to exist overnight — all their license grants being revoked, leaving them with nothing to serve — and we'd go back to just relying upon the iTunes Music Store / Netflix DVD rental model. (Which, to be clear, has still also existed alongside streaming this whole time.)
> But, guess what? increasingly all of that is in a cloud data center where your control is ... limited.
But with almost every stack deployed to those data centers just using one or another portable open standard (Terraform, Docker, Kubernetes, etc.) for deployment, commodifying the IaaS provider, such that the moment the IaaS provider attempts to assert any constraints developers aren't uncomfortable with, the developer can just move away in an instant.
(IaaS providers try their best to offer technologies with actual lock-in, but either no significant fraction of users takes them up on them; or a new open-standard abstraction layer is created that re-commodifies the offering by making it something portable to other IaaS providers + open implementations. The "S3-compatible" object-storage API is one good example of such re-commodification.)
Why is that? You can download everything for free. I don't think people use Netflix to access otherwise inaccessible content but rather because it's more convenient than searching for the right torrent link.
It is just far easier to just watch Netflix etc; if it had no drm, the vast majority would not change anything I would think, especially because the GP already said: no-one cares about drm. If they don’t care it doesn’t matter either way for most people (not the handful of Hn readers). It is like privacy; the vast majority of people don’t care; just the few that worry about dystopia.
However many if not most people still use Netflix even thought they have no real reason to.
Streaming from a „offensichtlich rechtswidrige Vorlage“ (§ 53 UrhG.) is not legal. That has been clarified by a decision from the EuGH in 2017.
I'm not a lawyer though and this isn't legal advice. Let me know if there have been verdicts and legal proceedings stating the contrary.
Anyway; what adblocker? I use adblock plus and it works for most sites, but not these type of sites; they seem to use every trick in the book.
As an additional warning, some kodi addons are torrent based and thus potentially risky in germany without using an anonymisation service like a vpn
So that private use can quickly become public for those less technically inclined.
I've never had fakes nor malware in ~10 years of downloading stuff.
Ultimately, it should be easy. If using Netflix and Disney+ is easier than using the Pirate Bay, then I gladly pay for Netflix and Disney+. If it becomes harder, more frustrating, fragmented, ad-riddled, or I need additional subscriptions to access the stuff I want, at some point the Pirate Bay becomes more convenient again.
There are plenty of fakes and mislabelings. some malware (especially on the download software)
And before anyone complains, nobody needs a movie to take more than 700MB ;)
See also: the 30-year-long campaign by the RIAA to stop any kind of non-DRMed digital high-fidelity consumer recordable media from being marketed. They finally lost it with the advent of the CD-R, but it's the reason that MiniDisc had DRM, Digital Compact Cassette was never "a thing", etc.
Convenient, but also relatively affordable to do things the legal way. Back in the day when torrenting was popular, even among the general population, most new albums would cost 15-20 Euro, getting a movie season was 30-40 Euro. Now you can get as much music is you need for 10 Euro per month. The situation with video streaming is a bit more complex, because the market is fragmented, but regardless you can pick your service and watch quite a lot of material for 10 Euro per month.
If you have to spend 50 Euro per month to get fresh music, torrenting looks far more attractive than when it's 10 Euro per month.
I would like to see a cultural shift away from the idea, that one must go through some middleman to make and publish anything, towards the idea, that if you have a great project and you put yourself out there and people believe in your idea, they will support you and all of society reaps the benefits. We would become more a society of choice and self-informing, than a society of maximized consumption.
At the same time, I think in many areas there is still a long way to go, to achieve that cultural shift.
These middleman, as all, come from a practical need, not cultural one. The people creating the content usually have no interest or skill in making marketing material, setting up meetings with venues, handle IP infringement/lawsuits, and all the other mind numbing boring stuff that these publishing studies handle that takes time away from their actual skill. I think the obvious outcome is that this middleman is automated, and split, but again, that's not a cultural shift, that's a practical one.
This is not true. Many if not most artists create art because they enjoy it.
What is true is that middle men like publishers and record labels wouldn’t exist if nobody paid for content. Coincidentally, they are also the ones who push the lie that nobody would make content if they weren’t paid.
Why is it so common to assume that no artist who is compensated for their work creates art because they enjoy it? You're presenting a false dichotomy.
Quality content takes time, effort and money, even when you love what you're doing. Every creative industry is littered with the corpses of the careers of brilliant, passionate artists who couldn't afford to live on goodwill alone. Compensation is what allows artists the freedom and capability to do what they love.
I don't think many people will deny that compensation encourages more creation. That is in fact the basis for copyright (at least in the US) - to romote the progress of science and useful arts, by securing for limited times to authors and inventors the exclusive right to their respective writings and discoveries. But that does not mean that the current copyright scheme is the best way of achieving more creation. In many ways it stifles creation as much as it encourages it.
Yes, we need to make it so that those who create can afford to live. But why do we need to so heavily restrict everyone elses rights to share and then throw public funds into enforcement of that insanity in order to achieve that? Really, we should make it so that everyone can affort to live instead and encourage creation via public and community funding or private patronage directly instead of doing this copyright dance where middlemen profit off our shared culture.
The sci-fi author Charlie Stross has a series of blog posts on their site about all the work that goes into publishing a book and how much of it is done by employees of the publisher (and how that is not work that Stross can do / would like to do).
> Also, lots of people, including many artists, like the stability of a steady pay check
I'm sure many plumbers would like recurring royalties from their work too. That doesn't mean that that is a good way for society to function. Any discussion of copyright that just looks at the needs of the creators without considering the effects on everyone else is fundamentally flawed.
History shows otherwise but even if that was true: Free (re)distribution does not inherently mean that the creator is not compensated in some way.
Some people aren't comfortable doing illegal, potentially immoral, things like torrents of copyrighted works.
Disney originally wanted VHS tapes to lock so you had to pay them to rewind them.
You may be affected by propaganda from very influential copyright holders with massive marketing power.
The moral/ethical side is more murky depending on how you want to look at things. For example, for me personally there is a big difference between things like libraries (a copy was purchased and allows one showing at a time), a rewind lock (interference with how you use something you purchased), and duplication (streaming included). The previous ones required someone to purchase. Does it cut into sales? Sure. But someone still paid money for a true copy and they copy is a single instance. With duplication the scale is different. It can affect sales drastically and hurt the workers (not just the stars and greedy companies). Some people may feel the latter is unethical/immoral. I tend to buy used stuff. I also just don't buy stuff if I think it's too expensive. I haven run into any issues with Netflix either.
There was a presentation by Lawerence Lessig everyone should watch from years ago. There was a time when by default _everything_ was public domain, unless explicitly copyrighted.
This has flip-flopped to now where almost nothing is public domain. How did this happen? Money bought enforcement of made up rules and then laws were bought (lobbied?) to take everything out of the public domain.
A simple legal test. Can you make a backup copy of your own data? Yes. Of your own movies? (still just data) Yes. But people still seem to think, maybe it's illegal when it is not.
Can you give your backup copies of _your_ data to your friend? Yes. Even if it includes your movies? Yes.
Why? Because under copyright laws it doesn't cause harm, it's not fraud, etc... I've been to court over copyright infringement, it's a civil issue in almost _every_ single case normal people would be involved in.
Here's what it takes to be "criminal" where you are in trouble with the _law_. (Civil is a contract violation between people, _not_ with the government)
* Done so for private or commercial financial gain;
* Over 180 days, reproduced or distributed 1 or more copyrighted works with a total retail value of over $1,000; or
* Released over a publicly accessible computer network material that was intended for commercial distribution
[source: https://www.draskovich.com/blog/2019/december/is-copyright-i... ]
Now, do you even know a _single_ person that has committed a _crime_ of copyright infringement? I would argue very, very likely no.
Therefore, you making copies of your movies and giving them to friends (even over the internet) for _fun_ or whatever, constitutes civil copyright infringement, _not_ criminal.
If you cross the street without using the crosswalk you are breaking a criminal law. If you drink booze under 21, criminal. If you smoke weed, criminal.
If you copy a movie and even share it on the internet, NOT criminal, it's civil offense.
This doesn't even get into the issues with consciences objections to insane laws.
Last argument: If your core argument is loss of money if copyright was put back to 14 years instead of the bonkers length it is now, I argue patent law proves otherwise. And the rampant file sharing has not hurt any jobs I've heard of so far. (artificial scarcity/supply/demand)
/rant
"There was a time when by default _everything_ was public domain, unless explicitly copyrighted."
That wouldn't really change rhis issue because the producers would still copyright.
"Now, do you even know a _single_ person that has committed a _crime_ of copyright infringement?"
Given this:
"Released over a publically accessible computer network material that was intended for commercial distribution"
Yes, a fair amount. The reason they focus on the civil side is that the company can recover damages that way. They likely could go after many individuals criminally if people are distributing over publiclly accessible torrents or download a lot of new movies (not released on DVD digital) in 180 days. Either civilly or criminally, it can be a terrible time, and many people don't want to risk that.
"If you copy a movie and even share it on the internet, NOT criminal, it's civil offense."
As long as the movie is not theaters-only.
"If you cross the street without using the crosswalk you are breaking a criminal law."
Not quite. Jaywalking also requires that you impede the travel of a vehicle.
"If your core argument is loss of money if copyright was put back to 14 years instead of the bonkers length it is now"
I'd be fine with shorter lengths. I believe Disney was one that lobbied for the longer length. That doesn't really address people circumventing copyright during that 14 years.
This is really the crux. How many lawsuits have there been where someone used a patent for personal use, shared their use on the internet and was sued for millions of dollars and lost in court? (even 1?)
I feel it's an absurdity that I can spend _millions_ making a widget and after 15 (or 14?) years anyone can use my design for free, and somehow people support this limitation for patents but not for copyrights. (and we still have a vibrant economy based on patents)
Huh. Now that's an interesting claim I have never heard before. Google doesn't seem to turn up anything on it. Do you have any supporting info? If there's really anything to the claim, I'd love to read more.
Also, a favorite: https://gizmodo.com/amazon-secretly-removes-1984-from-the-ki...
Where I live, you'll be fined if you download a movie torrent.
Edit: you don't get fined on the first download, you have to repeat the infraction. First download only gets a warning.
Edit again: Here's the warning you receive first:
Madame, Monsieur,
Vous avez souscrit un abonnement à internet auprès du fournisseur d’accès à internet <insert provider here>.
Votre connexion internet a été utilisée pour télécharger et/ou mettre à disposition une ou plusieurs oeuvres protégées par le droit d'auteur : * Date et heure des faits : <insert datetime of infraction here> (Horaire GMT : l’heure de Paris correspond à l’heure GMT +1h en hiver et +2h en été) * Adresse IP: adresse IP <insert IP here>) * Logiciel(s)/protocole(s) : <insert torrent software used here>. Conséquences :
Le téléchargement illégal, appelé couramment « piratage », prive les créateurs de leur rétribution et représente un danger pour l’économie du secteur culturel. Il vous expose en outre, vous et votre entourage, a des contenus inappropriés (pornographie, violence...) et/ou malveillants (virus, spams…).
En l'absence d'autorisation des détenteurs des droits sur ces œuvres, les faits constatés peuvent constituer une infraction pénale et entraîner des poursuites devant le tribunal de police pour contravention de négligence caractérisée (punie d'une peine maximale de 1500 euros d'amende ou 7500 euros pour les personnes morales).
L'utilisation qui est faite d'un accès à internet engageant la responsabilité personnelle du titulaire de l'abonnement, c'est donc vous qui êtes exposé(e) aux sanctions prévues par la loi.
Le présent courriel constitue un premier avertissement.
Si votre accès à internet est à nouveau utilisé pour des téléchargements illégaux ou des mises en partage d'œuvres protégées, l'Hadopi sera amenée à réexaminer votre dossier en vue de son éventuelle transmission à l'autorité judiciaire.
Actions à mener :
Je vous engage donc à prendre, sans délai, toute mesure utile pour éviter une nouvelle infraction. Vous pouvez consulter le site internet de l’Hadopi qui vous propose des fiches pratiques et des vidéos pédagogiques qui vous permettront notamment de :
* Sécuriser votre accès à internet en paramétrant votre box. Vous pouvez également vous rapprocher de votre fournisseur d’accès à internet sur ce sujet : https://hadopi.fr/outils-usages/parametrer-sa-box * Désinstaller les logiciels pair à pair de vos équipements : https://hadopi.fr/outils-usages/desinstaller-un-logiciel-pai... Par ailleurs, il existe sur internet de nombreuses offres légales disponibles. Pour vous aider :
* L’Hadopi référence les offres légales labellisées par l’institution et celles apparaissant comme respectueuses des droits de propriété intellectuelle : https://hadopi.fr/outils-usages/rechercher-un-site-ou-un-ser... * L’Hadopi vous donne également des indices pour identifier les sites illégaux. * Si l'œuvre que vous cherchez n’est pas disponible sur l’un des sites référencés par l’Hadopi, vous pouvez le signaler sur la page dédiée du site de l’Hadopi. L’ensemble de ces actions est disponible sur https://hadopi.fr/outils-usages. Vous avez également la possibilité de formuler des observations et d'obtenir des renseignements, en contactant l’Hadopi :
* Par voie électronique, en utilisant le formulaire suivant :https://cpdform.hadopi.fr/ notamment si vous souhaitez obtenir des précisions sur le titre des œuvres qui ont été téléchargées ou mises à disposition depuis votre connexion à internet ; * Par voie postale: Hadopi - Commission de protection des droits, 4 rue du Texel, 75014 Paris ; * Par téléphone au 09.69.32.90.90 (Appel non surtaxé de 9h à 12h30 et de 13h30 à 17h). Retrouvez toutes les informations utiles sur www.hadopi.fr/outils-usages/reagir-a-la-reception-dune-recommandation.
For anyone else wondering what a "personne morale" is:
En droit français, une personne morale est un groupement doté de la personnalité juridique. Généralement une personne morale se compose d'un groupe de personnes physiques réunies pour accomplir quelque chose en commun. Ce groupe peut aussi réunir des personnes physiques et des personnes morales. Il peut aussi n'être constitué que d'un seul élément.
La personnalité juridique donne à la personne morale des droits et des devoirs. Le droit français distingue :
les personnes morales de droit public : l'État, les collectivités territoriales, les établissements publics... ;
les personnes morales de droit privé : les plus courantes étant les sociétés privées, les sociétés civiles, les groupements d'intérêt économique, les associations. Certaines personnes morales de droit privé sont chargées de la gestion d'un service public.As for the cloud point, "in an instant" is definitely not how I'd describe the process of moving between cloud providers. There wouldn't be whole series of blog posts coming out every month or so talking about how some company moved from provider X to Y, spending 100s of engineer hours just to find themselves in another semi-closed ecosystem, but for half the price.
Why? You can always rip a video stream.
> [...] If we deleted DRM, streaming services would cease to exist overnight
And yet GOG exists and sells games all DRM free. To disprove a theory, one only needs to provide 1 counter example.
Maybe some streaming services would cease to exist. Maybe some of them are not needed. I highly doubt though, that it is an impossibility to have streaming services without DRM. I don't see how DRM helps at all. If I were a Netflix user, which I am not because of DRM and because it is shitty built to not work on Firefox on GNU/Linux and without installing shit on my machine, I could simply record my screen copying the content. Even if there was some software limiting this ability, I could use a hardware before the monitor to grab the video signal. DRM doesn't protect anything properly.
It is worth noting that GOG exists only because CDPR want it to and subsidise its costs from their other businesses due to their political beliefs.
As a standalone entity GOG would have ceased to exist overnight a long time ago. It's lack of DRM is definitely an argument to why it loses so much money.
The closer analogy would be to Xbox Game Pass, which has no marginal costs per title, but indeed does have DRM.
Then why there is a ton of Netflix and Amazon Prime owned content on the torrents? It seems the content is very pirateable, DRM or not.
This process loses a lot — for example, this signal is very likely post-HDR-color-processing, and so the result won't look very good on any other screen than the one it was originally told it was going to be played on.
Most people won't care, and will just watch the torrent anyway; but the fact that there's this very slight loss of fidelity, makes the IP rights-holders feel warm and happy inside that they still have this "perfect fidelity master copy" that they can show in theatres that nobody else has access to.
Take that away from them, and they really do withdraw their licenses. (See also: Apple being able to license effectively-perfect-fidelity 256kbit AAC versions of songs from certain parties, but being unable to convince those same parties to license Apple Lossless encodings of those songs.)
I'll just say this: sailing the high seas (well, kinda: I only pirate the movie which I have access to anyway and I'm subscribed to Netflix/Disney+/Amazon Prime Video/etc. + 140 channels as part of my Internet subscription) gives a better picture than streaming.
People underestimate the quality of streaming movies locally and playing FLAC files locally vs streaming.
I don't know anything about the other services firsthand because I jus-- uh, actually, never mind
[0] https://www.vdocipher.com/blog/widevine-drm-hollywood-video/...
Because Netflix is conserving bandwidth by sending you a lower-bitrate stream, while the pirated copy is — for movies at least — very likely a pirated copy of some offline release, e.g. BluRay, which comes with higher bitrate.
Is this really true? I would expect the post-processing to happen in the TV.
For me personally quality outside of Netflix is usually always better. Likely because of DRM
Why? Is DRM stopping piracy? Like what do you think would happen if DRM didn't exist, would the pirate bay be even bigger?
People don't pay for netflix because it's hard to pirate stuff, they pay for netflix because it's easier to do so than to pirate stuff, and it would be the same even if the laws of the universe changed one night and all DRM ceased to function.
If only that were true, I'd be actually be happy to subscribe to them. I've realized that streaming services are only useful if your problem is "I need entertainment, find me something nice to watch", but mostly useless if you have a specific title to watch. Majority of the time there is no streaming service that offers the titles I want to watch.
Always start with a conversation...
"you have never seen that movie ? let's play it"
"wait I don't see it on netflix, neither on prime or disney or...I should have bought the vhs/DVD/blueray at the time."
Not sure if you can find most +2y old movies on torrent platforms, last time I checked I couldn't find what I was looking for. I lament the death of local videoclubs where you could rent movies from any decade.
I can find torrents for anything I like, it's really easy. I guess if you don't do it often, you don't know where to look. But piratebay is still up and a good start.
In fact I am always disappointed how small they libraries actually are as I am used to something else.
Not exactly a model I wish to be followed by other countries.
You absolutely can. Just maybe not on the public trackers.
It's not like radio or TV have any DRM. I used to copy to tape movies and songs I liked all the time. Later we had TiVo &c to automate the process. The push for DRM just makes piracy stronger.
Or as a contemporary example, Steam's DRM is about as effective as a sticky note saying "please do not copy", lots of games on the platform don't even have any DRM. Some of the most financially successful games launched without DRM, e.g. Sekiro and Elden Ring. Stores like itch.io, humble bundle, gog don't have DRM either.
The only ones actually profiting from DRM are the DRM makers.
Why? Libraries loan you books and paper does not have any DRM. Works fine. The only difference is you might get some rate limit, e.g. 30 movies per month, or more watermarks instead of digital restrictions.
On the flip side getting Netflix in high quality has annoying hoops because of DRM (No, nobody wants to use Edge, thank you very much).
> If we deleted DRM, streaming services would cease to exist overnight — all their license grants being revoked, leaving them with nothing to serve
No, only if single stores do that. If lots of stores do that, you simply get the same content but without DRM. That literally happened for music, so you would at least need to argue why not here as well.
And even then, libraries have a different rights model, involving the fact that they legally own each copy they lend out as a distinct purchase of an IP license, placing a distribution concurrency limit on each work of “however many copies they’ve purchased”. They aren’t legally allowed to just make more copies to serve more users; they have to buy those additional copies.
And yes, this applies to both physical books and e-books lent out by libraries. (It also applied to the DVDs Netflix used to be about loaning out.)
Because books are physical objects, copying them is expensive. Digital data doesn't have that problem.
I have never tried it my self for anything other than A4 compendia books though.
you answered yourself why the scan approach is impractical.
I don't think that's true. But assuming it is true, then yeah, I'm in! I'm sure people would find other enjoyable activities that would be DRM-free, we would be fine.
There would not be this social pressure / expectation to use or subscribe to these DRM encumbered platforms (or that you, at least, have access to all movies or series at any time) when you invite people over.
That's completely false... People can already download for free drm-free content that is available on Netflix, etc, yet, they still subscribe.
Legally I'm sure that's true since content creators wouldn't agree to it, but in practice that's probably wrong. People would pay for the convenience of a it-just-works streaming service.
If you count only the kernel then yes, we "won". The trouble is a kernel is not an OS. You need also userspace. (linux will panic if no "init" is found). And when we count the userspace, we lost. Android is a closed system.
> 3. We won the battle for browsers -- everything now runs on top of an open source rendering engine.
Just because the rendering engine is OSS i would not call it a win. The rest (Chrome, Edge, Safari) have nothing to do with OSS. And Firefox is an old impaired browser who still remembers its glory days.
This.
It's very funny to still see the same fans comparing a kernel to an entire OS. Android and ChromeOS are still closed operating systems that use the Linux kernel. The kernel itself is useless on its own and needs a user-space to function. So unless there is a LinuxOS? I didn't think so. Since the user-space in Android and ChromeOS is closed and owned by Google. A widespread failure.
The desktop is also a failure as well as the user-space is too as the second problem is Google owning both of them and there is a likely chance that Fuchsia is going to replace them too. So we're back to square one again.
> Just because the rendering engine is OSS i would not call it a win. The rest (Chrome, Edge, Safari) have nothing to do with OSS. And Firefox is an old impaired browser who still remembers its glory days.
Well they still don't know that they actually lost; so badly that the winner (Google) is keeping the sore loser (Mozilla) on life support and is unable to be independent or even achieving their mission statement without being dependent on their anti-privacy foe's money. It is not early days and it is been decades since the Mozilla CEO promised that they would be not dependent on Google's money. A decade later it hasn't happened.
Firefox was supposed to be the dominant browser but today it's (you guessed it) Google Chrome. I consider this a catastrophic and chronic failure.
Still there is AOSP and projects which build on it.
Does microsoft take Blink, and insert their own crap into it? What could they possibly have to gain from doing that? Why not just contribute upstream?
Not only does Edge Chrome offer specific Microsfot features, its developer tools are also customized.
https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/microsoft-edge/develop-web-...
The important parts of them - the rendering engines - are indeed open source, so this isn't as bad as it seems. One can still build their own browsers on top of those engines (e.g, Ungoogled Chromium).
The "war" that's lost here isn't source availability, but two mega-entities (Apple & Google, primarily) getting to steer so much of the web.
I'm not so sure, it's not bad.
If Google decided to remove, for sake of example, add-ons. Would un-Googled Chromium be able to keep it?
Huh? I've never seen a device that has sideloading or ADB disabled. Yes, rooting is a different issue, but on the other hand it's not really needed in day-to-day usage and pretty much all phones sold outside of US carriers can be easily rooted. (The fact that US carriers regularly prohibit rooting should be tackled nevertheless)
But there's plenty of reviewers of Chinese-territory-only smartphones running emulators on it, which I'm guessing they installed by sideloading an APK.
It's even worse than that: NFTs are basically an argument that DRM is a great idea and we should have more of it. The aspiration for NFTs is that sites, apps, and games will treat owning a file's NFT differently from possessing the file itself, possibly even restricting usage to NFT owners.
Not to mention that they killed W3C in its sleep and the web isn’t even based on standards anymore.
What? You can easily install non-store apps too. It's just a single setting. There's F-Droid as alternative store or you just load the apk on the phone.
It is so easy that Fortnite (the biggest game at the time, and maybe now) was/is distributed directly by APK.
Amazon Prime Video used to be like this back in the day. You'd have to allow sideloading, install Amazon's custom store, then install the video app from there.
This sort of thing is one of the reasons I like that iPhone is locked down. I know that none of the apps I use will decide they can make reducing my phone's security a condition of using their app. If they want to be in the iPhone store -- and they do -- then they'll have to work with iPhone's strong security.
For example, I go to Telegram's site and download an APK of it because it lets me look at channels that are explicitly censored by versions downloaded from the Google Play and Apple App store. I do this all on stock, non-root Android.
A messier world with more freedom is always better for the public.
2. On the contrary, it's remarkable that the majority of smartphones now run an operating system that provides both good security (compared to desktops) and openness, and not just the kernel: Developers can write highly privileged apps like MicroG and F-Droid using official APIs to manage the phone (what MicroG does talking to the Google servers is a separate issue). Users can choose to use these apps using the sideloading feature, which is officially supported. For even more access, several smartphone manufacturers offer an official way of "getting root" and replacing the ROM with a custom one. For me this was a rather unexpected and welcome development! Then there are several communities of Android ROMs and companies build all sorts of devices using the AOSP source code. There is actually an ecosystem of apps for writing code on Android. It's indeed small and little used. My guess is that it's due to a combination of factors: IDEs that require huge ressources, separation of work and private devices, something else?
2a. Of course web servers are in data centers. What's your point? It's still nice that they are using open source software. There's a point to be made however about the closed SaaS apps like Google Docs that have replaced open source apps like LibreOffice. I don't care much: people/companies can run whatever they want on their own computers to provide me with a service. What matters for services are 1) data privacy issues (I agree with you on that) and 2) data export options (the SaaS apps I use are generally satisfying on this front).
3. Firefox's market share is small but it's still a perfectly capable browser. And I'm still amazed the whole of Chromium can be built from open source for both desktop and mobile. Sure Chromium is not Chrome but it's not far and many people use it as main browser. There's probably some meat here for a discussion.
An analyst I know made an argument that Napster was so popular because it was so much more convenient than going to the record store--rather than because it was free.
I didn't really accept the argument at the time but, as time goes on, I've at least partly changed my mind. Especially with music, assuming you have reasonably mainstream tastes, it really does make sense for a lot of people to just pay for a streaming service rather than download/rip and curate their own catalog. I have a big catalog but it's only somewhat organized and I don't use it much at this point.
(The situation with video is somewhat more complicated because of the fragmentation.
I don't think smartphones are safer than PCs at all. On which metric? Leaking personal and private information? Digital fraud? Sure, that isn't called malware on smartphones, there we call it just app.
I compiled Android multiple times and kudos to those still sticking to it for new models and security patches. Of course it isn't just the OS developer that is guilty here. But overall the devices are trash, even those > 1000$.
The security is only as good as your security update availability, which is still a major problem for those 3b devices.
Huh? With content spread out over Netflix, HBO, Disney, etc., you need multiple subscriptions which you can't possibly call "convenient".
Spotify is good enough for most people even if audio quality is mediocre and there is missing music. Most people do not care about obscure music or about audio quality.
Netflix also solved the issue (it used to have most stuff people cared about) and then it got unsolved. Indeed, with all of the competing streaming services with their own exclusives, the situation is worse than ever. This is why movie piracy is on the rise. With all of the exclusives it no longer is convenient. People do not care which corp owns which franchise. They just want to press play and watch. The fact that the industry truly does not understand user convenience and managed to mess up movie and tv streaming after it was solved, is just sad.
SaaS, though often based on FOSS, is far more closed than closed-source commercial software ever was. I can run a closed-source DOS app from 1989 in DosBox today and if I had data in it I could still access it. Same with most commercial PC software for Windows and Mac.
Can't do that with SaaS. Even if I can run it the SaaS has my data. If I stop paying it's gone. If the company goes out of business it's gone. If they rev the software in a way that ruins it for me, I'm out of luck and I have to start over. (Sometimes they let you export your data, but never conveniently and never in a good format.)
Here's the thing. Software is not actually free. Easy to use mature software is hugely labor-intensive to produce.
If you don't design the economic model, the market will design one for you. Usually that model will be worse than what you would have done. The most popular creative way to monetize "free" software is surveillance capitalism followed by adware and cloud-as-DRM SaaS.
Oh, and a sure fire get rich quick scheme for quite some time has been to take a promising FOSS software or standard and slap up a SaaS around it. Something tells me none of these companies pay anything to the original creators.
TL;DR: FOSS lost the war because it confused free "as in beer" with free "as in freedom" and never figured out an economic model. As a result we got one, SaaS with the cloud as back-door DRM, that is worse in every way than the old closed source shrink wrap model.
But the fact that most people in this thread are bringing up DRM for media means that people may care more about free "as in beer" than freedom. Few people are bringing up what FOSS was supposed to be about: control of your own computing environment and ownership of your own stuff. It was never about getting other peoples' stuff for free or even about software not costing any money. It was about software not restricting you and honest freedom-respecting models.
OSS development moving to internet and hardware companies is the most direct cause, as for them MIT-licensing makes sense (in the sense that others need to use it to be an option for them).
But, increasingly, the people writing the software, at those companies and elsewhere, not just prefer MIT over GPL; they actively don't have an opinion and, in many cases, not even an understanding of the issue, or, worst case, the basics of copyright.[0]
Some of this is simply due to most of the salient issues being decisively won or, at least, being replaced by a solid truce: Linux is everywhere but Microsoft still flourishes. Other software companies have either also found out that co-existence is possible. Or they no longer exist/no longer have the power (Netscape, SCO, Oracle), or never had the chance to get started in this environment (that httpd you are not paying for). Facebook, Apple, Netflix, and Google were never threatened. Thus, nobody is fighting Open Source, and the need to defend it has seized to be a motivating factor to get acquainted with the old ways of lawfare.
But growing up without such challenges leads to a generation trying to find meaning. Having lost ideals of freedom to an assumption of such, they've found much the same ideas as other bored generations: getting rich and, along the way, maybe finding some group or other to occasionally hate-stomp into the curb for shits and giggles.
So they're now running GPUs as space- and world-heaters, while whatever capability for political thought they have is busy balancing their love of Ayn Rand and Jordan Peterson with their hatred of women and the New York Times.
0: Note how there was never a thought expended to any moral or legal issues with the use of vast datasets of text, photos, or music to create text-, photo-, or music-generating AI models. But when someone started doing the same to source code, the possibility that their creative use of fopen to open a file provoked outrage usually reserved for female reddit-CEOs or game journalists. Free Software, for someone writing software, was about giving others such freedoms. This was altruism in its purest form (it's in the dictionary close to alt-right, if someone wants to look it up).
Looking around, within the scientific community, free software is today stronger than ever, and going even stronger. All the basic tools used by scientists today are 100% free software: R, gfortran, octave, python, torch, numpy, lapack, fftw3, gmp, overleaf, jupyter, git... The only remaining non-free software pieces of infrastructure are github and some proprietary chat rooms that will go unnamed.
GPL : R, gfortran, octave, fftw3, git
LGPL : gmp (dual-licensed with gpl2)
AGPL : overleaf
BSD-like: python, numpy, torch, jupyter, lapack
What is your point?
> Big corporate ran a campaign to dirty the name of GPL, Richard Stallman and the FSF. They won.
"Hey, can we use this GPL software?"
"Better not. We don't have the infrastructure to publish all our code publicly, and legal definitely doesn't want to be in the business of deciding what code we are required to publish by the license and what code we can keep proprietary. Adding GPL code is adding a time bomb to our project."
"Good point. There's some MIT-licensed code that does basically the same thing; I'll use that."
The GPL itself was the best argument not to use the GPL. It placed impositions on the code's consumer that other licenses don't, and network effects will tend to optimize to the path of least resistance (which in this case is the saddle-point between "We want to use other people's code" and "We don't want it to be a hard legal question what code of ours must be published").
It may be true that GNU would advocate for removing software copyright, but that in no way means that they believe (deem) software to be non-copyrightable today.
I do not pay for these services. I restrict myself to YouTube and Odysee.
We're losing the war, but we do fight on.
I am not losing any war.
Content restricted by DRM is not worth watching to me. The best content is produced by real people (such as commenters on HN), not large companies.
DRM customers will have to find out the hard way that as soon as the DRM server has a glitch, they're unable to see the content they paid for. Hell, even an expiring contract might make some ebooks you bought [1] or the music in your game disappear [2]. No thanks.
[1] https://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=106989...
[2] https://www.resetera.com/threads/some-of-gta-ivs-music-licen...
That's a good principle, and a hard bar to meet when the content is free, but still encumbered.
A chap from our local dads group was really keen to share his Disney+ account with me. That's actually a "legitimate" thing, I guess Disney want to get other people's kids hooked so they have a "share with a friend" scheme. I have to admit it was a struggle for us to decide against using a free child pacifier service.
Aren't YouTube and Odysee for UGC, so not really the same content type as Netflix, Prime, etc.
> I do not pay for these services.
Do you watch anything on Prime Video, given that it comes bundled with a Prime subscription?
Practice showed that in the overwhelming majority of cases, the apps user chooses to "install" is malware that he is not aware of.
The love of being free to do what I want with the most incredible device in history drives me. The conviction that this freedom is one of the pillar of a free future society drives me.
Millions of lost battles will never ever change my mind.
"But that's silly! You can strip it off!"
Of course you can, and you can strip DRM off proprietary DRM schemes too. All of them are cracked. That's not the point. The point is that there's a way for someone to indicate their usage terms along with a piece of media. An OpenDRM would not even necessarily encrypt, or would do so only in a very trivial way. It would instead be a standard for indicating terms of use and automatically checking for licensing entitlements.
In an ideal world we would subsidize content consumption for those who can’t afford it (we already do this via public libraries, and public funding of content creation in many countries, but we should do more) and also more strictly enforce laws against piracy by shutting down torrent trackers. Then we wouldn’t need DRM. But until this pipe dream comes true, I think DRM is valuable.
2. We won the battle for Linux -- and have thoroughly lost the free software war. No matter how you count, it is, by far, by very far, the most used operating system. A year ago there were three billion active Android devices, all of them using the Linux kernel -- and the overwhelming majority of them only allows sanctioned apps to be installed. There is no freedom any more. And despite the phones have capable CPUs, practically no one uses it to develop software, the entire development ecosystem is completely absent from Android. By any means you should be able to attach keyboard, mouse and monitor and develop and deploy your own phone apps but who does that?
2a. In the web server space, once again, it's Linux all the way. Although w3tech only says "unix alike" for the 80% it reports it's not unreasonable to think the overwhelming majority of that is Linux. But, guess what? increasingly all of that is in a cloud data center where your control is ... limited.
3. We won the battle for browsers -- everything now runs on top of an open source rendering engine. But, do I need to mention how much we lost the war here? Because neither Safari nor Chrome are open source and what else has any market share whatsoever? And in a familiar manner, they restrict of what you can install on them.