Re:We won the battle for Linux, but we're losing the battle ...
by RobertRoberts on Friday June 10, 2022 @02:31PM
(#31697750)
> That doesn't really address people circumventing copyright during that 14 years.
This is really the crux. How many lawsuits have there been where someone used a patent for personal use, shared their use on the internet and was sued for millions of dollars and lost in court? (even 1?)
I feel it's an absurdity that I can spend _millions_ making a widget and after 15 (or 14?) years anyone can use my design for free, and somehow people support this limitation for patents but not for copyrights. (and we still have a vibrant economy based on patents)
"There was a time when by default _everything_ was public domain, unless explicitly copyrighted."
That wouldn't really change rhis issue because the producers would still copyright.
"Now, do you even know a _single_ person that has committed a _crime_ of copyright infringement?"
Given this:
"Released over a publically accessible computer network material that was intended for commercial distribution"
Yes, a fair amount. The reason they focus on the civil side is that the company can recover damages that way. They likely could go after many individuals criminally if people are distributing over publiclly accessible torrents or download a lot of new movies (not released on DVD digital) in 180 days. Either civilly or criminally, it can be a terrible time, and many people don't want to risk that.
"If you copy a movie and even share it on the internet, NOT criminal, it's civil offense."
As long as the movie is not theaters-only.
"If you cross the street without using the crosswalk you are breaking a criminal law."
Not quite. Jaywalking also requires that you impede the travel of a vehicle.
"If your core argument is loss of money if copyright was put back to 14 years instead of the bonkers length it is now"
I'd be fine with shorter lengths. I believe Disney was one that lobbied for the longer length. That doesn't really address people circumventing copyright during that 14 years.