News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We won the battle for Linux, but we're losing the battle ... by hulitu on Thursday June 09, 2022 @02:52AM (#31678266)
> 2. We won the battle for Linux -- and have thoroughly lost the free software war. No matter how you count, it is, by far, by very far, the most used operating system.

If you count only the kernel then yes, we "won". The trouble is a kernel is not an OS. You need also userspace. (linux will panic if no "init" is found). And when we count the userspace, we lost. Android is a closed system.

> 3. We won the battle for browsers -- everything now runs on top of an open source rendering engine.

Just because the rendering engine is OSS i would not call it a win. The rest (Chrome, Edge, Safari) have nothing to do with OSS. And Firefox is an old impaired browser who still remembers its glory days.

Re:We won the battle for Linux, but we're losing the battle ... by rvz on Thursday June 09, 2022 @05:58AM (#31679356)
> If you count only the kernel then yes, we "won". The trouble is a kernel is not an OS. You need also userspace. (linux will panic if no "init" is found). And when we count the userspace, we lost. Android is a closed system.

This.

It's very funny to still see the same fans comparing a kernel to an entire OS. Android and ChromeOS are still closed operating systems that use the Linux kernel. The kernel itself is useless on its own and needs a user-space to function. So unless there is a LinuxOS? I didn't think so. Since the user-space in Android and ChromeOS is closed and owned by Google. A widespread failure.

The desktop is also a failure as well as the user-space is too as the second problem is Google owning both of them and there is a likely chance that Fuchsia is going to replace them too. So we're back to square one again.

> Just because the rendering engine is OSS i would not call it a win. The rest (Chrome, Edge, Safari) have nothing to do with OSS. And Firefox is an old impaired browser who still remembers its glory days.

Well they still don't know that they actually lost; so badly that the winner (Google) is keeping the sore loser (Mozilla) on life support and is unable to be independent or even achieving their mission statement without being dependent on their anti-privacy foe's money. It is not early days and it is been decades since the Mozilla CEO promised that they would be not dependent on Google's money. A decade later it hasn't happened.

Firefox was supposed to be the dominant browser but today it's (you guessed it) Google Chrome. I consider this a catastrophic and chronic failure.

Re:We won the battle for Linux, but we're losing the battle ... by pjmlp on Thursday June 09, 2022 @07:56AM (#31680074)
I need to keep bringing the Termux's use case, and pointing out the documentation of what Google considere public APIs on Android NDK, how apps get killed since Android 7 when they violate this public contract, and how classical Linux drivers are considered legacy since Android 8, to show how irrelevant it is that Android uses the Linux kernel for userspace in Android.
Re:We won the battle for Linux, but we're losing the battle ... by _emacsomancer_ on Thursday June 09, 2022 @08:56PM (#31688781)
> Android is a closed system.

Still there is AOSP and projects which build on it.

Re:We won the battle for Linux, but we're losing the battle ... by black_puppydog on Thursday June 09, 2022 @03:51AM (#31678628)
I think the win for 3 (browsers) was to displace IE?
Re:We won the battle for Linux, but we're losing the battle ... by herbst on Thursday June 09, 2022 @04:20AM (#31678803)
Tell that to any developer that is writing CSS and JS quirks for edge right now. We haven't won when the problem still persists in a different outfit.
Re:We won the battle for Linux, but we're losing the battle ... by executesorder66 on Thursday June 09, 2022 @06:05AM (#31679401)
I haven't done frontend dev for years. So I'm surprised to read this. I thought Edge switched to using Blink. How is it possible for there to be "edge quirks" that you need to cater for?

Does microsoft take Blink, and insert their own crap into it? What could they possibly have to gain from doing that? Why not just contribute upstream?

Re:We won the battle for Linux, but we're losing the battle ... by pjmlp on Thursday June 09, 2022 @07:59AM (#31680098)
Vendor differentiation, just like there is no pure Linux distribution or Android phone that is 100% just like upstream.

Not only does Edge Chrome offer specific Microsfot features, its developer tools are also customized.

https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/microsoft-edge/develop-web-...