News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We won the battle for Linux, but we're losing the battle ... by IfOnlyYouKnew on Thursday June 09, 2022 @02:26AM (#31678112)
"We" also stopped caring. People used to prefer GPL over MIT-style licenses for ideological reasons. That thought you are having now, namely that "ideology" is a dirty word, is a symptom of the same change.

OSS development moving to internet and hardware companies is the most direct cause, as for them MIT-licensing makes sense (in the sense that others need to use it to be an option for them).

But, increasingly, the people writing the software, at those companies and elsewhere, not just prefer MIT over GPL; they actively don't have an opinion and, in many cases, not even an understanding of the issue, or, worst case, the basics of copyright.[0]

Some of this is simply due to most of the salient issues being decisively won or, at least, being replaced by a solid truce: Linux is everywhere but Microsoft still flourishes. Other software companies have either also found out that co-existence is possible. Or they no longer exist/no longer have the power (Netscape, SCO, Oracle), or never had the chance to get started in this environment (that httpd you are not paying for). Facebook, Apple, Netflix, and Google were never threatened. Thus, nobody is fighting Open Source, and the need to defend it has seized to be a motivating factor to get acquainted with the old ways of lawfare.

But growing up without such challenges leads to a generation trying to find meaning. Having lost ideals of freedom to an assumption of such, they've found much the same ideas as other bored generations: getting rich and, along the way, maybe finding some group or other to occasionally hate-stomp into the curb for shits and giggles.

So they're now running GPUs as space- and world-heaters, while whatever capability for political thought they have is busy balancing their love of Ayn Rand and Jordan Peterson with their hatred of women and the New York Times.

0: Note how there was never a thought expended to any moral or legal issues with the use of vast datasets of text, photos, or music to create text-, photo-, or music-generating AI models. But when someone started doing the same to source code, the possibility that their creative use of fopen to open a file provoked outrage usually reserved for female reddit-CEOs or game journalists. Free Software, for someone writing software, was about giving others such freedoms. This was altruism in its purest form (it's in the dictionary close to alt-right, if someone wants to look it up).

Re:We won the battle for Linux, but we're losing the battle ... by Gigachad on Thursday June 09, 2022 @02:36AM (#31678182)
Big corporate ran a campaign to dirty the name of GPL, Richard Stallman and the FSF. They won.
Re:We won the battle for Linux, but we're losing the battle ... by enriquto on Thursday June 09, 2022 @04:57AM (#31679049)
It doesn't seem that they "won"; at least not yet. In my case, the bullying of RMS moved me to join the FSF, to stop all use of non-free software in my life, and to become an even more vocal activist for free software.

Looking around, within the scientific community, free software is today stronger than ever, and going even stronger. All the basic tools used by scientists today are 100% free software: R, gfortran, octave, python, torch, numpy, lapack, fftw3, gmp, overleaf, jupyter, git... The only remaining non-free software pieces of infrastructure are github and some proprietary chat rooms that will go unnamed.

Re:We won the battle for Linux, but we're losing the battle ... by pjmlp on Thursday June 09, 2022 @06:00AM (#31679372)
Now count how much of that is GPL.
Re:We won the battle for Linux, but we're losing the battle ... by fnord123 on Thursday June 09, 2022 @08:53AM (#31680609)
All of those projects pre-date the campaign against RMS afaict so their licenses were a settled matter already.
Re:We won the battle for Linux, but we're losing the battle ... by pjmlp on Thursday June 09, 2022 @11:03AM (#31682089)
First part of OP's sentence is "Big corporate ran a campaign to dirty the name of GPL...."
Re:We won the battle for Linux, but we're losing the battle ... by enriquto on Thursday June 09, 2022 @06:36AM (#31679572)
why, I was just citing some common free software. Anyhow, about half of my random list seems to be copyleft:

GPL : R, gfortran, octave, fftw3, git

LGPL : gmp (dual-licensed with gpl2)

AGPL : overleaf

BSD-like: python, numpy, torch, jupyter, lapack

What is your point?

Re:We won the battle for Linux, but we're losing the battle ... by pjmlp on Thursday June 09, 2022 @07:50AM (#31680021)
Basically what OP's was referring to,

> Big corporate ran a campaign to dirty the name of GPL, Richard Stallman and the FSF. They won.

Re:We won the battle for Linux, but we're losing the battle ... by shadowgovt on Thursday June 09, 2022 @01:00PM (#31683754)
It wasn't much of a campaign. My experience with using GPL in a commercial setting went something like this:

"Hey, can we use this GPL software?"

"Better not. We don't have the infrastructure to publish all our code publicly, and legal definitely doesn't want to be in the business of deciding what code we are required to publish by the license and what code we can keep proprietary. Adding GPL code is adding a time bomb to our project."

"Good point. There's some MIT-licensed code that does basically the same thing; I'll use that."

The GPL itself was the best argument not to use the GPL. It placed impositions on the code's consumer that other licenses don't, and network effects will tend to optimize to the path of least resistance (which in this case is the saddle-point between "We want to use other people's code" and "We don't want it to be a hard legal question what code of ours must be published").

Re:We won the battle for Linux, but we're losing the battle ... by quickthrower2 on Thursday June 09, 2022 @06:43AM (#31679611)
Ideology aside, isn’t licensing GPL better for the copyright owner? Makes it harder for someone else to commercialize your work.
Re:We won the battle for Linux, but we're losing the battle ... by pfortuny on Thursday June 09, 2022 @06:56AM (#31679694)
The GPL is for software, which the GNU org deems non-copyrighteable AFAIK.
Re:We won the battle for Linux, but we're losing the battle ... by simiones on Thursday June 09, 2022 @08:30AM (#31680358)
Where did you get the idea that GNU deems software non-copyrightable? The GPL itself would not work in any way, shape or form if software copyright weren't enforceable, since you could simply copy the source code without regard to its license.

It may be true that GNU would advocate for removing software copyright, but that in no way means that they believe (deem) software to be non-copyrightable today.

Re:We won the battle for Linux, but we're losing the battle ... by quickthrower2 on Thursday June 09, 2022 @07:13AM (#31679784)
I don't think you forfeit copyright. I might be wrong.
Re:We won the battle for Linux, but we're losing the battle ... by IfOnlyYouKnew on Thursday June 09, 2022 @06:19PM (#31687681)
See? That's what I mean, above.
Re:We won the battle for Linux, but we're losing the battle ... by carapace on Thursday June 09, 2022 @11:44AM (#31682641)
s/seized/ceased/