Nobody disputes that Uber can have employees or contractors (or both), or that drivers should, in principle, be able to choose what status they hold.
The problem is that Uber currently exerts so much control over its "independent contractor" relationships that they have become, as a matter of law, employment relationships.
Moreover, in practical terms drivers don't end up with the choice they ought to. If they want any working relationship with Uber, they have to accept a mash-up of all the burdens of employment minus many of the benefits of being a contractor.
"I'm afraid you're repeating Uber's favorite talking point, which is that everyone should respect the worker's decision to be an employee or contractor."
I've never seen Uber argue that everyone should "respect the worker's decision to be an employee or contractor." I have seen them argue that drivers are contractors based on the flexibility in the job, but not that it should be "the worker's decision".
"Nobody disputes that Uber can have employees or contractors (or both), or that drivers should, in principle, be able to choose what status they hold."
Actually, pretty much all US employment law disputes that drivers should be able to choose what status they hold. Employee vs. contractor is not determined by what an employer says someone is, or what an employee says they are. Instead, it is determined by some key factors about the nature of the job, which (as you do point out) mainly centers around control of important aspects of the job.
But it is important to understand that you never really get to "choose" whether you're a contractor or an employee, it's determined solely as a function of the type or work you do and the nature of your relationship to the employer.
I don't understand what you're trying to say here. In my experience, on both sides of this, a good deal of thought is put into what kind of position to seek / offer. I think employers and workers think a lot about which legal arrangement would work better and there is a great deal of choice involved.
For instance, I can imagine Uber offering jobs v.s. contractor positions with differing levels of support, remuneration, and expectations. That they don't do so seems like a choice to me?
Legally, in California, they can't do that. As outlined in the article, the 'ABC test' is the legal test for determining whether someone is an employee or a contractor. The 'B' part of that test is "The worker performs work that is outside the usual course of the hiring entity's business." If you are an employer, you could not have one group of drivers that you classify as employees and the other you classify as contractors, not if they're basically doing the same work.
Note this is common in a lot of different businesses, and there have been many lawsuits where contractors who DID want to be classified as employees argued that they were basically doing the same work as employees. There was a fairly famous case involving Microsoft 2 decades ago: https://www.computerworld.com/article/2589538/it-personnel-m...
Being a contractor is not fundamentally bad if US hadn’t tied medical insurance and companies hadn’t tied stock bonuses with employment. Technically there is no such need for “employment”. You go work for the time and you get paid equitably without an artificial status called “employment”. Unfortunately this status has became part of many arcane laws and difficult to get rid of.
That's not the fundamental difference in either federal law or the California ABC test. It's not a factor in the ABC test, [0] and it's one of several factors in the “relationship” prong of the federal test. [1]
[0] https://www.californiaemploymentlawreport.com/2019/03/unders...
[1] https://www.irs.gov/newsroom/understanding-employee-vs-contr...
Edit: Good article and video about how AB5 affects technology consultants: https://www.viodi.tv/2019/11/15/will-ab5-drive-software-engi...
I think that's case by case though. Contractors usually do finite focused projects and don't want to be employees. I myself was self-employed for 5 years doing specific contracts as a software engineer. I was "writing code" which is "the same work" as employees. Were all those companies breaking the law?
> Legally, in California, they can't do that.
Definitely wrong.
This is actually a really good thread, because most people are surprised to discover that yes, those companies probably were "breaking the law".
As other posters pointed out, AB5 is relatively new, so the test is relatively stricter now, and only relevant in California.
More importantly though, employment classification is only challenged when a plaintiff files a lawsuit. Thus, even if someone is technically misclassified, if the relationship is mutually beneficial, nobody is going to complain. This goes on all the time, which is why most people are surprised to find out they were technically misclassified.
Case in point: I worked at a company (in a state much more permissible regarding employment law than CA, and pre AB5) that forbid using the term "contract-to-hire", even though that happened pretty frequently. Reason being that technically contract-to-hire is not legal unless there is a substantial difference in the work and relationship when the person is a contractor. Now, many times there is, but that phrase alone can make it seem like the work contractors do is too similar to the work employees do, which is why our legal department banned the phrase.
I'll give a Dutch perspective (which perhaps applies to some degree to other parts of Europe):
Until 2016, clients had to proactively ask for a 'Verklaring Arbeidsrelatie (VAR)'. An 'explanation of the work relationship'. If I understand correctly, the contractor/freelancer had to prove that they had more clients than just that one, and it had to be reasonable. So no having five clients of which one accounted for 99% of all income.
If a client didn't ask for this 'VAR', it could cause problems down the road.
From 2016 on they changed this, but apparently the result has been a confusing mess, so in 2021 they'll try to clear up some of it.
Practically speaking, as a contractor, I've found that only the big clients (with legal teams, I imagine) would ask for a VAR, if at all.
Most of the time, whether working in Holland or Germany, I usually did the exact same work that their employees did. In some cases there seemed to be vague distinction where I worked on shorter projects and they did support and the like, but in practice that distinction was very blurry.
I suppose with some of these clients I could've caused trouble, but because I got paid well, often better than the full-timers (even with insurance and all that deducted), I didn't see any reason to.
My general impression is that NL is a bit more 'liberal' in these matters than many other parts of Europe, so I'd be curious to hear how this works in France/Germany/Italy, etc.
In Sweden, if you want to become contractor, you have two options - start a limited liability company of which you owns all shares (Aktiebolag). Or you can start a business in your own name (Enskild firma), which legally is not separate from your own liabilities.
In the first case, you are making yourself employed by the corporation you own. I do not know if there is any legislation that prevents that business from having just a single customer. But I know that in my own case, my business have had a single customer the entire time it has existed.
But I strongly suspect that this is one of those 'spirit of the law' situations. So I suspect that a company that doesn't want, well, liability, would avoid hiring an LLC that really is just one person working only for said company.
AB5 is looser than preexisting law, since it adopted the preexisting ABC test from the Dynamex decision, but added new exceptions.
There is no advantage to the individuals from that decision, nor is there any intended.
So people spending 5 years working for the same company doing the same commute and same work as employees, subject to the same kind of control over their work etc., cannot maintain a claim to be self-employeed for the tax flexibility that goes with that.
However. You "writing code" as a contractor is not the same work as an employee if the manner in which you are doing it differs.
For example, if you have to purchase your own equipment, set your own hours, work on a "statement of work" basis instead of set hours, can substitute a subcontractor to do your work for you, and can and sometimes do work for multiple companies at the same time, and often switch the site at which you are working, those sorts of things signify that you are not operating as an employee would, and that it would be correct to classify you as running your own business and therefore subject to business taxation instead.
Of course every contractor wanted to claim that status for the tax benefits, which are basically less income tax and the ability to deduct more expenses. The government saw this and decided, although the law was what it was all along, people weren't applying it adequately. So they changed who does the assesment, and the tax liability if they get it wrong, from the contractor to the company hiring them. This is called the IR35 reform; IR35 is the name of the legislation that sets out what kind of working patterns must be treated as employment for tax purposes.
Although the reform will change who is liable for making the assessment, in principle it is still possible for a contractor to be retroactively assessed for their past as having been an employee all along, and have to pay back-tax. That's because you are supposed to have done the right assessment for yourself already, or perhaps your accountant should. This seems unlikely for most people now as long as the changes are followed through, but some people have been caught out by it.
The AB5 law has only been in effect since Jan 1.
The federal rules are already very strict. Generally contractors violate them a lot. The law was pushed by IBM to eliminate competition, and the feds incorrectly thought they would get more tax money by making the software contractor industry into employees. It's a sordid tale ending in domestic terrorism and murder: https://www.nytimes.com/2010/02/19/us/19tax.html
I’m not convinced you have adequately eliminated other potential reasons he may have done the uncharacteristic thing he did. Even if he was in his right mind, I’m not convinced he had anyone’s interest at heart but his own personal one, as jobs are a form of social control. He desired to be free of this control. Even if individual liberty is worth fighting for, the Constitution doesn’t grant you the right to the job you want on the terms you want. That’s what the courts are for.
This guy was wrong to do what he did in every way but for the right reasons in a very minor way that is more a matter of principle rather than tax law. No matter his beef, it was just his own, and as such, it doesn’t justify so much as slapping someone’s hand, let alone the stunt he pulled.
I do see your point, though I disagree.
I'm not clear what point you are referring to. It's possible for all sides in a story to be wrong in their actions.
AB5 essentially codified the test the California Supreme Court adopted in Dynamex (April 30, 2018), though.
> Definitely wrong.
Based on what? Were you a contractor while AB5 was in place? Everything I have seen suggests that Uber and Lyft will be legally prevented from having drivers that are classified as contractors.
So, for instance, you might hire initially a contractor to create the encrypted part of your product, but once you had hired someone to do that work full time you would be legally barred from hiring additional contractors to do that?
Pretty much, though even then it is determined by what the courts decide is the company's "normal course of business." Obviously there are big gray areas here. And, also obviously, there are many cases where both the worker and the employer would prefer to treat the relationship as a contractor relationship, and if they both agree there is nobody to file a lawsuit contesting it (unless, of course, there are lots of people in the exact same role who could challenge the classification, as is the case with Uber).
Also, note while there are federal rules that determine IRS classification, California has stricter laws when it comes to employee vs contractor.
I don't know about Uber in US, but in Russia this is how it typically works. Drivers are hired by local taxi companies, which partner with large-scale Uber-like aggregators. This way, user-facing (aggregator) companies don't have drivers as employers, but contract other companies (or individual drivers, shall they want to act as sole proprietors) for the actual transportation services.
That is exactly how software development contract jobs are handled in the US. They are called contract companies (and many other names) but essentially find talent, place them at a contract position, then bill the company for that contractor. They pay the contractor directly, with or without benefits (W-2 vs 1099). And in most cases, the contractor gets to choose contract or employee status with the contract company, although at different pay.
Here is an example of Postmates doing it, I wouldn’t be surprised to see Uber doing the same.
You've effectively spend a few paragraphs adding nothing of value to the conversation.
You've effectively restated the grandparent's points, but tried to do so in an adversarial manner.
You might want to check what you consider "adversarial" when it comes to a discussion forum.
The issue is that the comment I responded to seems to be under the false notion that workers (or employers, for that matter) get to "choose" how they want to be classified, and that's what this debate is about. My point is that, when it comes to employment law, a worker or employer's preference about how they are classified does not factor in at all about how the law classifies the job.
If I owned slaves and called them unpaid indefinite interns the law would rightly disagree. You can call the relationship whatever you like, but the law is there to keep the playing field level for everyone. That it's taken Uber so long to play by the same rules as everyone else is a travesty and should take a billion dollar law suit or two for damages to sort out.
They are independent contractors in the sense that they can choose how much and when to work.
They are employees in that they cannot negotiate rates.
I don't think it's so clear cut.
Hmm... How is an Uber driver different from a plumber here?
Let's say Google needs some pipes fixed at one of its offices and they tell me how much they'll pay, refusing to budge from that figure. That doesn't make me Google's employee. I can choose to do the work for that price, or I can go fix Apple's pipes instead. What am I missing?
The driver doesn't have the ability to turn up a dial and say "I'm going to charge more now".
(This isn't the only distinction between an employee and contractor though of course)
A licenced taxi driver cannot do that, either.
If instead, my analogy were that I was a general contractor who built water slides and a water park put out a bid on construction of a water slide and refused to negotiate, my only option is to take that bid or leave it. Why does it matter what the water park is going to charge the people to ride the slide?
Now that the app driving companies turned over the apple cart by essentially cyber-squatting on the legal system while backed by high power lawyers paid by VC cash, the driving companies themselves want to cry foul when they don’t get the way they bought and paid for. I guess what they didn’t foresee is the long view of judgeship, and their concomitant dim view of cheaters, no matter the problem domain.
It’s too ironic to be believed. The judges apparently agree with me.
What makes you think so?
1. If Uber and Lyft allow their drivers to choose, would it be reasonable for them to make "having the other app on at the same time" cause for dismissal? I know of no other employee that is allowed to simultaneously bill time on a competitor. Contractors, absolutely. Employees, no.
2. What if Uber, instead, charged $1.00/mo for the drivers to use the app, thereby making them customers instead of contractors?
If the existing laws can be interpreted to punish them, they will be used. If not, the coalition against Uber will look into getting new laws passed. (As they already have.)
Thus rendering any discussion about whether existing laws can justify punishment somewhat moot.
(Of course, even a moot discussion can be interesting. Just like people can have fun arguing whether the Stark Trek Enterprise would beat a Star Wars Destroyer.
The legal discussion is also very important to Uber lawyers. Even if they lose in the end, any delay is worthwhile.)
Is that an opinion on the legal situation, or meant as a suggestion for how to build a better business?
Of course, one wouldn't be actively working for two employers at the same instant, but neither would one be simultaneously driving an Uber ride and a Lyft ride.
I don't know California law on this specifically, but any state would definitely include time when actively serving as a driver for a ride, many would include time driving to pick up an accepted passenger, some might include time when logged in as a driver.
Until someone figures out how to multiplex the cabshare part of the two apps :p
2. Interesting idea, but then all companies could just do this and make the same claim that their employees/contractors/vendors are just customers too! Not gonna fly.
In practical terms, this is trivial for uber to dodge. All they need to do is transform from a company offering rides, to a company connecting riders to drivers. It sounds like a big difference but I susoect very little about the user experience would change.
For instance they could allow riders to offer different rates, but heavily favour (through ui and other soft incentives) the suggested rate.
In the end the drivers would be driving the same car at the same price with the same benefits.
There's typically an agenda behind these laws in terms of trying to increase the benefits and power of workers at the expense of the company. So I'm not sure Uber will be allowed to sidestep that goal by simply changing the way things are handled and presented. The govt could simply argue that giving users the option to choose a ride from Bob or Sally is meaningless since customers have no idea who these people are and just choose the first or cheapest on the list. Especially considering the amount of gray area already crossed to classify uber drivers as employees in this ruling.
Wrong in what sense? In a moral sense I might agree with you. In a legal sense, governments around the world do that all the time, and get away with it.
CA is wrong to outlaw voluntary working relationships between two parties.
Indentured Servitude is a voluntary working relationship between two parties. Is it wrong that it's illegal in CA?2) irrelevant to the employee/contractor determination. It is possible for an employee to also be a contractor, see for example restaurants...
#1, If you pick to be in a contractor relationship you can do whatever with regards to having both apps on simultaneously.
#2 If you pick to be in an employee relationship, uber and lyft have a right to exclusivity during all phases of the ride. Of course a driver can choose to work for both, but lyft can terminate a driver if they find that a driver is online for uber, and vice versa.
Or #3, the state can decide that the "employees" are "not working" unless they are in the phases where they are going towards an accepted ride or have a passenger in the car.
The state will almost certainly not go with #3. Between #1 and #2, I can tell you which option 90% of drivers will take. It's not #2. So we will be back to square one.
The fact that this question is practically speaking unilaterally up to Uber and not the result of any meaningful negotiation between the parties makes the relationship even more employment-like, as there's usually much less negotiation around terms of employment (certainly some still happens) than in true independent contracting.
What's more, it's not clear to me that courts would enforce the duty of loyalty (and maybe not even an express contractual provision depending on the state) against a part-time rank-and-file provider of comparatively unskilled labor, just as they wouldn't prevent a 20-hour-per-month sandwich shop employee from spending an additional 20 hours per month at a different sandwich shop in parallel. Maybe a guarantee from Uber of full-time pay would change that. I believe a federal trial court has even ruled that non-fiduciary employees in California have no duty of loyalty, though I don't know if that was overturned on appeal or whether state courts have agreed.
Just as a ride hailing driver can't simultaneously have an Uber and a Lyft passenger in his car. What's your point?
[0] I did this once, uber had a really stupid and un-thought-out halloween weekend bonus on a weekend where halloween fell on a friday night (people don't party hard on saturday night of a halloween weekend like that), and pink mustache copied with their own equally asinine bonus. So I went out to a place within the service area where I knew I would not get very many uber or lyft rides, and left both apps on for hours while reading inside a Denny's. I did happen to get ONE ride, and I left the other service on to rack up bonus time on it. I was definitely nervous as hell though, which in retrospect, was unnecessary.
I'm well aware of this. If you look in my comment history, you'll see that I drove for Uber and Lyft, too.
But the point stands — You can't earn money from both at the same time, just like someone can't earn money from waiting tables at two different restaurants at the same time.
uber had a really stupid and un-thought-out halloween weekend bonus
Ick. Don't get me started about Uber's promotional games. Like making everyone sign up for a big promotion during a big event, and then there are no qualifying rides.
You can be an employee of multiple companies at once. Many people are.
You just generally don't get paid by multiple companies for the same period of time if you are paid hourly wages.
I certainly know it is true of journalist freelancers.
If rideshare drivers are employees, then there's going to be fixed overhead costs of hiring employees and drivers will not be able to set their own hours. The rideshare company would not recoup the costs of benefits for drivers that drive less than a certain number of hours per month, and so drivers would have to be required to work at least that many hours.
Can you elaborate on what you mean by, "in practical terms drivers don't end up with the choice they ought to"? I know people who drive for Uber and Lyft less than 10 hours per week, and some do it nearly full time.
It's up to the employer what freedoms they allow. Generally, like with existing businesses, it would probably utilize a shift assignment system, where employees get assigned shifts but can swap them with other employees.
The way I see it, as employees, their employers will either give them benefits for 10 hour work, or force them to work 40 hours.
Most benefit mandates apply to full-time workers, usually triggered at somewhere between 30-35 hours/week; those that apply to part time workers at all tend to be scaled down for them based on working hours.
There will be less flexibility about hours, but less risk that an hour reserved for work will be unpaid. Within the need not to overbook available business, and laws requiring payment for scheduled time even if cancelled at the lat minute, there's no inherent reason rideshare companies couldn't provide scheduling flexibility, including a notice-of-availability system for immediate call-ups.
(Optimizing decision algorithms for when to bring on additional staff becomes is a challenge that this opens up, also similar with when to accept the cost of short-noticd cancelling scheduled shifts.)
> The rideshare company would not recoup the costs of benefits for drivers that drive less than a certain number of hours per month
Nor would they be required to provide benefits for them; most benefit mandates apply only to full-time employees, not part-time employees.
True, but that does not mean rdgthree's argument has no merit.
> Nobody disputes that Uber can have employees or contractors
What about the California judge?
So no, they cannot have independent contractors, unless you mean for the operations side of their business, which nobody is talking about so I hope not.
A) the worker is free from the control and direction of the hiring entity in connection with the performance of the work, both under the contract for the performance of the work and in fact; and
B) the worker performs work that is outside the usual course of the hiring entity’s business; and
C) the worker is customarily engaged in an independently established trade, occupation, or business of the same nature as the work performed.
Of course you can argue about the minutia of each test (that's what lawyers are for) but there's nothing stopping the hiring of drivers as contractors per se. It's just that the judge thinks the current relationship as it is does not pass this test.
Said another way, what could Uber change from their current policies that would pass ABC if they don't at the minute?
This seems to be the insurmountable point; the judge seems to be inclined to see drivers as within the usual course of business, which means nothing changing on A and/or C would matter, and, assuming the strong statements in the injunction reflect the eventual ruling on the merits, Uber would have no means other than radically changing the business they are in to have drivers-as-contractors.
It's not (as a matter of what the law generally mandates), because it's a preliminary injunction, not summary judgement.
Part B is similarly challenging, because it requires that the contractor & the work they are doing not be in the same line of business as hiring entity
1. https://www.californiaemploymentlawreport.com/2019/03/unders...
I have a friend that drives approximately 8 hours pw for Uber.
How are drivers not choosing their own hours, exactly? That seems to be exactly what they are doing.
And when I say "Uber", I actually mean Uber/Lyft. And obviously in some parts of the US there are other apps and drivers use those too.
I also don't know any employee who gets paid money by the customer to do a job, of which a small portion is taken by the company. For every "employee" I know, it works in exactly the opposite way.
Independence goes much further - can the driver assign someone else to do the job?
As with any other marketplace/platform: Amazon, Patreon, App Stores, Twitch, Steam, etc.
Stripe collects payments for me when I sell my app. The money does not drop directly into my bank account.
And I don't think Uber has any problem with drivers hiring other people to drive their car and do Uber for them. The people that take an issue with that are the municipalities that want to require background checks, etc. for drivers.
Nothing about the ruling prevents Uber from having contractors. It prevents them from having employees (as determined by California law) that they label as contractors in order to skirt around legal requirements for employees.
For the record, I am not saying the ruling is incorrect, but it does make me feel uneasy because:
1) I think that Uber does provide a public good (increased efficiency compared to a taxi) 2) If all drivers are employees, the business does not seem sustainable
I think that new laws are needed rather than using pre-sharing-economy labels like employee, but that the ruling by the judge may be correct given the current laws.
I don't think it is sensible to justify exploitation with "but the public benefits from it' and 'without it the business might go under'. By that logic we'd still have Victorian workhouses, 12-hour workdays, and there'd be no health & safety.
It's absurd to compare providing a service that hooks drivers up with clients to child labour.
Maybe they’re not losing their fingers in factory machines like child laborers are but I think they deserve employer provided healthcare at the very least.
What makes you think so? There's more than one reason for the demise of child labour. Society has gotten richer over time, and so families place a comparatively higher value on not having their children work.
The problem with taxis was the medallion system and other crazy regulations.
There is a middle ground. No medallions or other protectionist measures, but you have to treat your employees like employees.
The old system with medallions also had the drivers as independent contractors.
Your suggestion would be something different from both existing approaches.
Edit: no opinion implied on whether your suggestion is any good or not.
Uber lost $19,000,000,000 in 2019. It lost money last quarter. Uber is already unsustainable. Despite its labor practices, Uber has been unsustainable since its founding. And it’s not like Amazon’s early days where lack of profits was offset by acquisition of physical infrastructure. Uber loses money on via unit economics.
This write-up from today sums up some of the story so far. https://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2020/08/hubert-horan-can-ube...
> Uber was always less efficient than the traditional taxis it drove out of business
This is patent nonsense. I suspect he never rode taxis often before Uber appeared.
Also Uber’s core ride business was profitable before corona hit. Lots of businesses are hemorrhaging money right now, especially ones in travel.
Maybe address that instead of hand wringing the conversational communication style used on every forum ever?
I am in the group that says if you want to be a contractor and the employer agrees so be it. I have a good number of friends doing uber after hours aimed at specific purchases and the flexibility is what sold them. Not the life for me but for some it is a good alternative.
Plus the biggest benefit was the kick in the pants traditional taxi services got so they now how to treat their "drivers" better. How they get off with how that business is run and Uber and Lyft get called out should tell you the priorities here.
I wonder how this decision will play out to other businesses
Sure, this could be true.
But people should recognize that a possible solution to this, is for companies to provide more flexibility and control to these people, such that they stay contractor but also get the additional contractor benefits, as opposed to forcing the employee relationship.
To be fair, given that a judge has ruled on it, it now is true as a matter of law until repealed or otherwise changed by a higher court...
The real decision will be made many months, or years, from now once everything had made its way through the appeal process.
The current one doesn't really mean much.
There is nothing in this ruling that prevents Uber from allowing people to chose rides _exactly_ as they are doing it now.
The changes are:
1. Uber needs to pay into unemployment insurance.
2. Uber needs to pay into workers compensation.
3. Uber needs to pay into social security.
4. Uber needs to collect payroll taxes in advance.
5. Uber cannot discriminate based on protected classes such as race or gender.
6. Uber must comply with the WARN if large scale layoffs occur.
7. Uber has to provide for heath insurance depending in accordance with local and federal laws.
8. Uber needs to verify the legal working status of their drivers
9. And many other things all other businesses pay into and rules they have to follow.
We make businesses pay into this because the general public is ends up footing the bill anyway. Like right now where we’re providing Uber drivers with unemployment benefits even though Uber cheated their responsibility. And when a driver gets in an accident and we have to pick up the bill of unpaid hospital bills and disability payments.
Flexibility has nothing to do with it. Paying into the system everyone else has to and following the rules everyone else needs to follow is.
I agree with some other posters, I think a new categorization for "gig" workers is necessary, as I think a lot of your other points (e.g. paying workers comp) make sense.
Workers can choose platforms that maximize the worker's wages while platforms would need to minimize costs for customers. The more efficient the platform gets, the better position they would be in vs competitors.
Possible in what sense? Legally possible, or do you mean economically feasible?
As we've seen with the pandemic, unemployment can mean withdrawal of healthcare and eviction.
Really the question here is risk. Who takes the risk that employees can get sick? Who takes the risk that levels of work coming in can vary?
Should it be the individual employees, who generally have a couple month's income saved or less, or should it $50 billion market cap company? Which is better able to absorb risk? Or should the risk instead be handled by the state or federal government?
There are plenty of people working more than one job in the US where they're classified as an employee at all of them.
1. Work for the competitors
2. work as much or as little as they want
3. Take as much vacation time as they want
4. Leave with zero advance notice
Also, should Twitch streamers and Youtube creators also become employees? What about Etsy/Ebay sellers or AirBnB hosts?
Absolutely they can. California, like almost all states in the US, is an “at-will” employment state.
None of these things are required under employment law at all. Can I ask where you found this wildly false information? Do you happen to live outside the US?
Nowhere in California labor law does it prevent people from taking vacations or anything else you mentioned if they are an employee.
I worked in California for a few years but I'm not longer there. And those were questions, they weren't meant to be stated as facts.
> Nowhere in California labor law does it prevent people from taking vacations
Hmm, maybe I understood my rights wrong, but from my understanding I wasn't free to take an arbitrary number of vacation days without getting fired. I know Netflix allows that but other than them, wouldn't most employers let you go if you just decided to not show up on random days?
Also, again I'm not expert, but are you sure that someone can simultaneously work for Apple and Google? That doesn't sound right but again, these are mostly discussion questions, let me know if I'm missing something here.
You are correct that they can limit vacation time, but Uber could also limit vacation time for contractors. There is nothing specific in California employment law that does not allow employers and employees to mutually agree to open vacation time.
I think we agree about vacation time.
It would take much less effort
However, they are extremely unpopular politically. Especially in California, where they seem to hate all kinds of real estate taxation.
Hilariously, you are so far off that you don’t realize that the only legal way Uber could prevent their drivers from working for Lyft in California was if they were contractors and not employees
Where did you get this information?
If you accept, you just set your own rate.
Being a contractor doesn't mean you get to pick where you work, it means you get to pick where you work out of the people willing to hire you for contract work. Many companies have different criteria for what they require out of contractors. I don't see this as all that different.
Okay, but none of this is about people who wanted to do work for Uber but didn't. This issue is about people who did in fact do work for Uber. If you never submit any bids and never do any work, you're neither a contractor nor an employee.
>>> except uber/lyft will remove you from the platform if you decline too many rides, thereby only giving the illusion of choice.
I don't see any real difference to that than to someone who was is contractor and maybe did some work, but hasn't responded in a while and the company removes them from the list of people they notify (and fast-track) for bids. If I'm at a company and I have a couple preferred contractors and one hasn't even bothered to reply to my the last few times I contacted them, maybe I'll lose faith in them being responsive while they're on the job.
Any contractor relationship is a two way street. If either side doesn't maintain the relationship, the other side may choose to alter it or cut if off entirely.
Contract work is all about trust. If you show any behavior that makes you look less reliable, are they going to trust you with work? Flipped around, if the company doesn't respond to requests for payment, are you going to want to do work for them? It works both ways.
(The point is moot though because apparently Uber rolled out a feature that allows drivers in California to set their rates).
A fourth contractor thinks the price is too little and rejects it outright.
The fourth contractor has "submitted a lower bid"?
But no, the fourth contractor did not submit a bid at a higher price. They did not submit a bid at all.
I see your point too. Essentially, rather than contractors proposing prices and then clients accepting or moving on, if clients propose prices and then contractors accept or move on, it's still a market with negotiated rates.
Factually incorrect for Uber drivers in CA, the platform no longer penalizes drivers for declining trips and now allows them to pick and choose trips without any impact on driver rating. (I worked in Uber Eng up until the 5/18 layoffs)
At least in Europe all competitors still work with the % of fare calculations.
(While dropping drivers from the platform if they refuse too many rides doesn't make such collusion impossible in theory, it introduces enough individual risk to make such coordination unlikely in practice.)
drivers already have those groups btw. they use to coordinate a LOT of stuff. i've seen a driver on a huge whatsapp group where they basically tried to set some areas to surge so they could earn more money.
I took a flyaway to Union Station and then got an Uber from there for $15.
Oh the humanity, how will they manage? They only have like the entire dataset of all rides ever taken plus a world class data science team plus a ton of market power. Will they be able to negotiate on equal footing rate with cab-drivers?
> Drivers then could, over their local "$city Uber drivers" FB/WhatsApp group, agree to not take any ride below $X,
This is, of course, illegal.
>This is, of course, illegal.
What law does this break?
In general, price fixing of the cost of labour is only found to be illegal price fixing when the people fixing the price are not (or not only) employees/workers. Which isn't the case here.
Firstly, if you consider that Uber is only an intermediary and nothing else, then the consumer is the employer. Making this collective bargaining, Employers are consumers in the labour market. Price fixing is always against the interests of a pure consumer, including collective bargaining. Unions are beneficial because (and only if) the vast majority are workers much moreso than consumers.
Secondly, as we have seen, since the money is paid to Uber, and Uber decides how much the rides cost and to who they are assigned when, as well as the fact as Uber pays drivers, and in combination with the fact that drivers are the core business of Uber, they are indeed employees, and this is collective bargaining.
In both cases, it is collective bargaining. If the consumer is the rider, and they directly pay with a cut to Uber the fare, as well as decide the price they are offering and control how the ride goes, then the driver is the employee. In the real world and according to California statute, the driver is the employee (of Uber).
Therefore, it is collective bargaining.
The price of rides is determined by the market. Uber arguably has the least say of the three stakeholders – their goal is to merely "make the market". Riders demand low-prices, drivers demand high ones. Uber doesn't really "choose" a price, they just find the happy medium that the market demands.
Uber pays drivers in the same way that Stripe "pays" me when I make a sale of my app – that is to say, not at all. Stripe pays me, but they are clearly not my employer. Uber is collecting payments and then disbursing them, as literally any marketplace does. Does Steam "employ" all the game developers that sell on their platform? Does Etsy employ all the independent makers? Apple's App Store? Twitch? Amazon? Patreon?
The core business of Uber is an app/marketplace for transport, not drivers. This is obvious when you consider the fact that Uber also provides things like scooters and e-bikes through their app (and in London, now boat services!), which obviously don't involve mostly independent driver-contractors.
To compare this to Steam again – the core business of Steam is not "game developers", even though their core business would not exist without game developers. Their business is a marketplace. I actually really like the Steam comparison because it literally ticks all the same boxes you are ticking for Uber: they set prices, accept/disburse payments, and wouldn't exist without 3rd parties and their labor. But nobody is claiming that Steam should start paying health/holidy/etc benefits for all the indie game developers that sell games on their platform.
There is a huge difference between this and an Uber driver. All Uber drivers are commodified, there is no distinction between them outside what Uber itself does. Uber's drivers have no control over how they do their job. Uber's drivers have no control over the fares they charge outside accept/refuse. If the three welders were indistinguishable from each other, and all had the same entity decide vast amounts of how they do their job and for how much, then yes, it would be simply collective bargaining.
Once again, there is massive strawman going on here that you are perpetuating. I'm not saying that it isn't price-fixing. All collective bargaining is price fixing. All of it, without exception. As a society, we allow workers to engage in price fixing because workers have very low individual power and it is in our collective interest for workers to negotiate together. That is the point I'm trying to get across. All square are rectangles, not all rectangles are squares. All collective bargaining is price-fixing, not all price-fixing is collective bargaining.
>The price of rides is determined by the market. Uber arguably has the least say of the three stakeholders – their goal is to merely "make the market". Riders demand low-prices, drivers demand high ones. Uber doesn't really "choose" a price, they just find the happy medium that the market demands.
This is ridiculous on its face. Unless there is a mechanism on Uber for drivers to bid on rides, then fare prices are not fair market prices negotiated between drivers and riders, but instead prices decided between Uber and riders. Uber very certainly chooses a price, and the riders don't. They do not participate in market pricing any more than a factory worker threatening to quit their job contributes to increasing the price of a widget. Most importantly, Uber does not allow the drivers to even know the actual price the riders pay, so this is just ridiculous.
>Uber pays drivers in the same way that Stripe "pays" me when I make a sale of my app – that is to say, not at all. Stripe pays me, but they are clearly not my employer. Uber is collecting payments and then disbursing them, as literally any marketplace does. Does Steam "employ" all the game developers that sell on their platform? Does Etsy employ all the independent makers? Apple's App Store? Twitch? Amazon? Patreon?
If Stripe told you exactly which app to make and how, and did not let you explicitly state which price you would sell the app for, and did not even let you know which price consumers were paying, had a variable cut that is obscure to you, did not let you market your apps individually, and only gave you the option to either make the app or not, then you would be an employee of Stripe, yes. If Steam told you which app to make and how, which price it would give you, didn't tell you how much they would charge customers, and didn't differentiate you from other gamedevs then yes, you would be an employee of Steam. Rinse and repeat.
The core business of Uber, in revenue and valuation, is 100% to provide rides for people. Scooters and bikes are a drop in the bucket, and technically come from an acquisition and thus are not a core business. This is like saying that the core business of Apple isn't to make iPhones, it's connect consumers with engineers and factory workers that make phones. Except the consumers don't choose which engineers make them, how much they are paid, or even really differentiate them before paying at all.
>To compare this to Steam again – the core business of Steam is not "game developers", even though their core business would not exist without game developers. Their business is a marketplace. I actually really like the Steam comparison because it literally ticks all the same boxes you are ticking for Uber: they set prices, accept/disburse payments, and wouldn't exist without 3rd parties and their labor. But nobody is claiming that Steam should start paying health/holidy/etc benefits for all the indie game developers that sell games on their platform.
Steam does not set prices. Steam lets the gamedevs/publishers decide of they price they want. Steam lets you market yourself. Steam does not tell you what game you should make (what route you should take), they do not tell you which programming languages you can use (which cars you can use), and does not rely on contractors for its core business (Steam does not rely on one-person indie game developers for their core business). Steam is incomparable to Uber. The idea of why Uber doesn't let you use any car, by the way, is in order not to damage their brand. Because you, as a driver, represent Uber, and they know it. In a way, your most important asset, Uber's brand, is not owned by you but by Uber - you then generate profit from someone else's capital for a wage - an employee.
2. I am not perpetuating a straw man that "all collective bargaining is price-fixing". I am arguing that in this particular case, this is the bad one (price fixing), not the good one (collective bargaining). This is because the drivers (not Uber) have monopoly power in the market. The disagreement is stemming from the fact that you believe that any action taken by "labor" cannot be price-fixing, which I disagree with.
3. "This is ridiculous on its face." It is not ridiculous. This is called supply-and-demand and it actually works quite well for pricing things. If Uber "sets" the price too high, riders will not use the service. If they "set" the price too low, drivers will not want to participate and then you don't have a market. Again, the price is "set" at whatever value riders are willing to pay and drivers are willing to accept. Anything else and the system fundamentally doesn't work.
4. At least in California:
a. you choose which rides you want. you are not forced to take certain rides ("make a certain app").
b. drivers can set prices
c. the Uber cut is not obscure (pretty sure it's always been 30%). The time this doesn't apply is when Uber gives both counterparties a great deal by paying the driver more and charging the rider less and using VC money to split the difference.
d. you can ride for Lyft as well, or be a private car for hire without a ride-sharing app ("market yourself")
e. my option with Stripe is "sell my app using them or not", ditto for Steam. Can I sell it without them? Sure. Just like a driver can sell private car-for-hire services without Uber.
5. You might want to break it to a number of companies that some of their core businesses don't actually exist because they came out of acquisitions. Regardless, that wasn't my point. Investors invested in a ride-sharing app. Uber makes money because they have an app. Without the app (but 1000s of drivers) they would not have a business. They would literally be a cab company. But actually they wouldn't be because they don't have any medallions, which you need if you're not connecting riders directly to drivers with... your app. The core business is definitely the app. That's how Lyft can also exist in the same space with the same drivers. Because their business is in making an app that enables a marketplace for ride-sharing, just like Uber. But it's a different app. But the same drivers. Given your assertions, I guess they're pretty lucky to exist in an industry where you could have 100 competing ride-sharing apps, but because "the drivers are their core business", they will all do just fine because they all have drivers!
6. Most of this is addressed in 4. For the rest of it, you're just tacking on more and more made-up criteria that obviously don't apply. If I hire a guy to mow my lawn, I can stipulate that he uses an electric mower. Maybe this is because I care about the environment, don't like gas fumes, or want to look fancy in front of my neighbors. My reasons are my own and he is still an independent contractor. Likewise, Apple forces you to develop in a certain way for the App Store – still a marketplace. They require you to adhere to certain standards of app design/development – ya know, so you don't hurt their brand. Steam could (does?) do that too, and it wouldn't make them not a marketplace. I also notice you ignored Etsy/Twitch, which most certainly do rely on one-person delivery for their core business.
This rating is given by Uber only. It is a single number, with nothing else. This is literal commodification, the exact same way that housing or vegetables are com modified following a grade or a rating. When drivers will be able to market themselves and make a case for themselves it will be something else. A synthetic, numerical rating is literally a hallmark of commodification.
>2. I am not perpetuating a straw man that "all collective bargaining is price-fixing". I am arguing that in this particular case, this is the bad one (price fixing), not the good one (collective bargaining). This is because the drivers (not Uber) have monopoly power in the market. The disagreement is stemming from the fact that you believe that any action taken by "labor" cannot be price-fixing, which I disagree with.
I've written about a dozen times. All collective bargaining is price fixing. Your argument that I am saying that it's not or that I am applying an inconsistent standard is literally a strawman.
>3. "This is ridiculous on its face." It is not ridiculous. This is called supply-and-demand and it actually works quite well for pricing things. If Uber "sets" the price too high, riders will not use the service. If they "set" the price too low, drivers will not want to participate and then you don't have a market. Again, the price is "set" at whatever value riders are willing to pay and drivers are willing to accept. Anything else and the system fundamentally doesn't work.
It is indeed ridiculous. It isn't the drivers negotiating with the riders, it is Uber negotiating with the riders. This is absolutely crucial. The driver has only the option to refuse work. This is, quite literally, how being an employee works. You have no input over the price of the good, you can only refuse or accept the job at the price and in a perfect frictionless vacuum your refusal or acceptance is perfectly mirrored in the end price. Which it isn't in practice for endless reasons, and certainly not in Uber where the margin Uber takes is a secret that no one knows and that varies instantly.
>a. you choose which rides you want. you are not forced to take certain rides ("make a certain app").
If you are an employee, you also aren't forced to make a certain app. You can refuse and either be assigned something else (that you didn't decide), or be fired. If you were a developer on Steam for example, you would be able to make any software, in any way you like, and charge exactly how much you like. All things you can't do on Uber. The right of refusal is also key to being an employee. Contractors, in general, have more than the right of refusal - they decide how the job is done.
>drivers can set prices
Only in California, in a transparent attempt to skirt the letter of the law, and only very, very indirectly through a multiplier.
>the Uber cut is not obscure (pretty sure it's always been 30%). The time this doesn't apply is when Uber gives both counterparties a great deal by paying the driver more and charging the rider less and using VC money to split the difference.
Not always! Uber claims that their cut is around 25-30%. You have to trust them, and independent analysis shows that the cut can exceed 50% in some cases : https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2019/08/uber-and-lyfts-c.... In any case, the algorithm used to calculate the fare charged to the rider and credited to the driver is different, so there can never be a fixed cut. It is obscure, and you can never know.
>my option with Stripe is "sell my app using them or not", ditto for Steam. Can I sell it without them? Sure. Just like a driver can sell private car-for-hire services without Uber.
On Stripe, you can sell almost anything. On Steam, you can sell any software at all. On Uber, you can only do the specific trip that Uber wants you to do at the price that Uber decided to offer you, and only in the specific route that is calculated, only in the specific allowed vehicles.
>You might want to break it to a number of companies that some of their core businesses don't actually exist because they came out of acquisitions. Regardless, that wasn't my point. Investors invested in a ride-sharing app. Uber makes money because they have an app. Without the app (but 1000s of drivers) they would not have a business. They would literally be a cab company. But actually they wouldn't be because they don't have any medallions, which you need if you're not connecting riders directly to drivers with... your app. The core business is definitely the app. That's how Lyft can also exist in the same space with the same drivers. Because their business is in making an app that enables a marketplace for ride-sharing, just like Uber. But it's a different app. But the same drivers. Given your assertions, I guess they're pretty lucky to exist in an industry where you could have 100 competing ride-sharing apps, but because "the drivers are their core business", they will all do just fine because they all have drivers!
Does Uber not have a contractual relationship with Uber drivers in which they must complete a ride? Does Uber not spend the vast majority of their revenue in this contractual relationship? Then it is core to their business. If Uber's job was only to connect riders to drivers, then the contractual obligation would be between drivers and riders, and not between drivers and Uber. This is as absurd as claiming that the core business of Microsoft is to connect users of operating systems with programmers. It isn't, it's to sell software, because the engineers have an obligation towards Microsoft.
>If I hire a guy to mow my lawn, I can stipulate that he uses an electric mower. Maybe this is because I care about the environment, don't like gas fumes, or want to look fancy in front of my neighbors. My reasons are my own and he is still an independent contractor.
If you hire a guy to mow your lawn, tell him exactly how to do it, specify the equipment with which you do so, and if he has no lawn-mowing practice, then yes he is your employee. Furthermore, you seem to be missing the fact that Uber drivers are contractors of Uber, not contractors to the riders.
This is, of course, illegal."
Although I am not 100% certain on this, I think that these kinds of anti-trust laws only apply when certain companies have huge amounts of market power. I believe that certain "anti-competitive" behavior would not be illegal, if done by a whole bunch of small contractors.
The obvious example would be unions that do this. But it is possible that this is a special exception to the law.
Obviously you may stop working with a person if their prices are too high or because quality of their work is shit.
However if you use this as a pretence for firing contractors, but the real reason you are firing them is because of their sex / gender / race - that would be illegal.
In the same vein, if you fire contractors for doing things that are none of your business, and it is common knowledge that you do that and exercise control you should not have over them, then a court may decide that in fact the relationship is not that of a contractor. That in fact this is nothing more than a legal fiction created for the purpose of tax avoidance or similar.
Like what?
I'm pretty sure you can put all the terms you want in a contractual relationship. Even things that are none of your business (as long as not protected class).
An employee is just a contractor with additional rules.
However, because the drivers choose to participate in the Uber/Lyft marketplace and benefit from the network affects that they have created, it follows that Uber/Lyft would have a say in the cost of goods sold in that marketplace. Just because the drivers can't set their own rates doesn't mean they aren't independent contractors.
If I hire you to mow my lawn, we mutually come to an agreement of what time and price you would perform the service. Just because you want to work for $100 / hour doesn't mean I'm willing to pay that. And because I'm only willing to pay a certain price only for your services doesn't make you an employee.
I think it's that simple. Uber/Lyft have a price they are willing to pay for services. They even allow their drivers to pick their own schedule (unlike my lawn service example). Drivers are not setting the price directly with the customers, they are getting paid by Uber/Lyft, but that doesn't make them employees.
Maybe if Lyft/Uber allowed drivers to bid on rides drivers would become more contractor-esque? But then the latency would be much higher for users. The system would likely also regress to the proposed price, as well, since drivers would likely just accept the price proposed by the platform to save time.
- drive on their own schedule - drive for competing ride share services (concurrently even) - drive for themselves - not drive at all
Seems very independent contractor. Uber/Lyft created a marketplace; drivers are agreeing to drive within the constraints of that marketplace. They can also create their own customer relationships and ride share marketplace if they choose.
If Uber/Lyft imposed restrictions on things like who a driver could give rides to or restricted concurrent ride share engagements, then that starts to feel like an employee. Rates have very little to do with it, in my humble opinion.
As far as I understand one of the problems is that the drivers' market is so saturated that both Uber and Lyft can act as if they where monopolies (or maybe monopsonies). They can technically move to a competitor but that applies no pressure on the market.
Again, what makes this situation tricky is that it is essentially creating a new kind of employement-like relationship that current laws and regulation do not really account for.
So: "moving to a competitor definitely applies pressure" -> true; "keep both companies in check" -> false
You are thinking too much about just workers, when actually the smalelst divisible unit is hours. There is portion of drivers that barely ever switch, and then there is another portion that are constantly looking for the better deal, switching through outh the day. Its a scale.
So to keep drivers happy and on your paltform, you need to implement bonus schemes or have certain base pays.
Im not sure why so many people feel that they can comment on how the ridehailing platforms work without having any real experience in driving for them or working for them.
https://www.irs.gov/businesses/small-businesses-self-employe...
By a similar reasoning one could claim that waiters/factory workers should also be independent contractors. If they don't like the pay in one business they can go work in another marketplace.
By this contrived example I mean to say that your analysis applies only to the superficial structure of the concept of employment. Ultimately social structures are not axiomatic field and should be treated accordingly.
Uber in CA launched a feature allowing drivers to set their own fares https://www.uber.com/blog/california/set-your-fares/ so there is inbuilt flexibility.
In California, gardeners are considered employees. The only reason most people don't have to deal with employment taxes, payroll, insurance, etc., is because they typically hire gardening companies that actually employ the workers.
Thanks for the link, that's interesting.
I can participate in Ebay / Amazon marketplace, and I can set any price I want if I decide to sell my TV there. They take their commission, and provide some conflict mediation.
It just feels like forcing everyone to be an employee will box out a large number of happy part-time drivers who weren't too concerned with setting their own rates.
We, the readers of Hacker News, are going to fix the gig economy! Everyone, download a copy of your local laws and send a pull request to your country's highest Court.
But seriously, I think having a discussion, working out a perfect system where we'll all be better off is more than a bit hopeful.
So who's the resistant party? Right -- Uber. Why? Because they can't make their unit economics work either way.
"But if the drivers want this intermediate arrangement, and Uber wants it, why should Calif stand in the way?" States make a lot of contracts, especially labor contracts, illegal because they go against public policy (including externalizing too many costs on state & local govts themselves). Still, Uber would be welcome to restrict its activities to states and countries that have labor laws more to its liking. Chemical & manufacturing & agricultural firms have been doing this for years. But Uber can't turn a profit without being in dense cities in liberal states (where labor laws are usually stronger)
One more argument is often advanced, which is "there is no scenario under which Uber could use contractors." This is also untrue. For instance, instead of working directly with individual drivers, Uber could pursue a franchise-style model, where it might, say, solicit bids among companies representing groups of drivers to handle all the rides in a certain zip code. Variations of this model are already used in a lot of industries, of course. But Uber's margins are already too thin, and it would have to give up too much control. Uber prefers the current model precisely because the balance of negotiating power is permanently asymmetric.
Edit - Or allow customers to set the rate, and again take a cut of whatever that was.
https://farm8.staticflickr.com/7512/15985103560_ed7985fc2a_o...
I suppose the great-grandparent is more an 'appeal to emotion' fallacy rather than ad hominem.
This is a fuzzy line.
I guess uber could put the jobs up for bid.. to address that.
The equivalent here would be something like, "Okay candidate, I offer you a job as a contractor and the contract says you get paid based off of this algorithm. Accept or decline?"
Even when I was starting out, years ago, the palette of contract work offered was vast. I was never obliged to follow a cab-rank rule.
If you were to set up an agreement with the software company yourself, then it'd be conventional contracting.
This is simply closing a loophole gig platforms were built on (misclassifying workers in violation of labor law).
Pretty sure drivers have to "accept" a ride, isn't that agreeing to a rate?
I think it's reasonable to argue that because the contractor had no input into the rate, and if they decline too many rides they might be removed from the service, that they do not have the power to set rates.
What would make this a lot easier is if the apps would just allow you to set a rate below which you're not willing to accept work. The reason they punish you for declining too often is that they don't want the rider to have to wait for multiple drivers who regularly decline all offers before finding one willing to accept it, so that would solve that because you wouldn't even get the offer.
I'm curious to see how this shakes out in the end, because we keep getting these decisions where they say they're employees because X, but then won't they just change X to make them contractors again?
It is clearly not equivalent since uber literally determines the rate. Yes, they can refuse to work below a certain threshold but they aren't in-fact "setting the rate".
A software contract offers $50 an hour. I can either take it or leave it.
Uber offers $x an hour (or mile, or however it works.) Drivers can either take it or leave it.
What do you think is the essential difference here?
Do you think software contractors can somehow force clients to accept any rate they want? No. If they client doesn't want to pay above $x then there's nothing you can do but decline the job. Just like Uber driver can do nothing but decline the job, surely?
The essential difference is that the role of uber is absent from your analogy.
> Do you think software contractors can somehow force clients to accept any rate they want
I'll just assume that's a sarcastic quip in rhetorical question form rather than what you actually think I believe. Obviously, a software contract is negotiated between two parties, unlike in the case of Uber where all possibility of negotiation is eschewed for a price explicitly set by uber. If a driver wants to offer their services for more or less than uber decides, they cannot, and are forced to lower or raise their price in order to gain access to the market.
The drivers can ask for any price they want from Uber. Uber can either accept it or not. That’s a negotiation. What more do you think it needs to be a negotiation? That’s just like a normal contract. I may want my fence painted but I’m not paying over £500. If I won’t go below that is it no longer contracting?
Like any contractor!
If I offer to pay $500 for get my fence painted, a contractor can either accept that or not.
If you want to hire a web developer for $500 a day, a contractor can either accept that or not.
The fence painter, the web developer and the Uber driver, can all set their own rates by either accepting the job or not, can't they? I don't understand what you think is the difference between the first two and the last one?
Not true. Uber's algorithm sets the rate within certain profitability margins which are determined by uber, "the market" is very artificial since customers only ever see the rates that uber decides they should see rather than what some drivers would actually offer.
> Uber won't find drivers if the rate is too low, for example because it's lower than the costs, lower than the risk, or lower that the competition. Uber (and the driver too) won't find customers if the rate is too high.
Right... uber deliberately structures the market through their explicit control of the price. The price is only "too low" or "too high" with respect to uber's business goals not with respect to what the actual market would do.
True, but not relevant to my point which is that uber explicitly sets the rates, not drivers, and not the market. I understand why they do this, but it's simply false to say that drivers having the option to sometimes pass up on rides is the equivalent of setting their own rate.
Are drivers removed from the platform if they refuse too many rides?
It seems like the drivers actually have very little power to enact any effective bargaining over rates in practice.
Second, Uber is running the supply/demand auction system behind the scenes already. Prices are not fixed but dynamic and change in real-time based directly on supply and demand.
I’ve often brought up the app to check prices and decided not to ride for a while. Drivers do something similar.
> thus "the market rate" cannot escape a threshold that is contrary to uber's business prerogatives.
I’m not sure what this means. I’m sure Uber sets some reasonable floor on the price, but it’s more in the driver’s interest than their own. There are absolutely drivers who would drive for below operating cost of the vehicle because either they aren’t bothering to calculate it or they aren’t the ones actually paying for it (e.g. a car that is late on payments and soon to be repo’d).
I think the real issue here can't be resolved by an examination of terms - it involves a power dynamic where Uber contractors are extremely at disadvantage when it comes to being able to set your own rates. I don't know if Uber even has someone on staff that's qualified or expected to negotiate with independent drives that are interested - they have a posted rate that you either accept or they walk away. And, the worst part, they change that posted rate for BS reasons constantly in a way that people can't predict, it makes for an unreliable and misleading income.
They don't just let you go in demanding whatever you want. There's a limit to what they want to pay. Just like Uber.
You can absolutely go in and demand whatever you want. If you ask for 3x, you probably won't get the job. But 5% or 10% over x? It's possible. I don't see how contracting is 'locked in'. You are certainly free to negotiate, unlike on Uber or Lyft's platform.
"Rating" is generally accepted as the "star rating" or some other statistics that users will see. Yes your "acceptance rate" will be affected, but this is a vanity metric that is secret to the driver => It is irrelevant.
There is no mention of deplatforming in any of these articles.
https://help.doordash.com/dashers/s/article/Dasher-Ratings-E...
https://driver-support.grubhub.com/hc/en-us/articles/3600298...
https://taskers.taskrabbit.com/2018/06/01/acceptance-rate-wh...
Those legal protections can be enforced by those who have the means to hire a lawyer. Yes, white collar contractors often get to enjoy the legally enshrined protections to decide how, when and where their work is done. They are often paid twice as much or more than their salaried peers to make up for the increased costs of self-employment and lack of employer provided benefits.
Blue collar workers working as contractors are almost always doing so not for their own benefit, but for the economic benefit of their employers. The workers get little say in how, when or where their work is done. Their pay does not reflect the increased cost of self-employment, and they are not offered benefits.
Uber drivers can't even set their own rates.
As an aside, there are plenty of people employed as employees with flexible hours and schedules in the US.
0 - https://www.npr.org/2020/01/28/800437791/due-to-new-californ...
I suspect that you're implying some sort of objective universal metaphysical state of "being an employee" or "being a contractor", but that's pretty clearly false.
They don't. The distinction between a contractor[1] and employee[2] has a broad rule at the federal level[3]. Contractors decide their rates and how they're paid, and they determine how, when and where their work is done.
People who work for Uber outside of a part of a single state can't set their rates or how they're paid, nor can they determine how or where their work is done because Uber only allows drivers to use certain vehicles.
[1] https://www.irs.gov/businesses/small-businesses-self-employe...
[2] https://www.irs.gov/businesses/small-businesses-self-employe...
[3] https://www.irs.gov/businesses/small-businesses-self-employe...
“States will vary on exactly what parts of the test they apply and when they apply the test to workers. In September 2019, California put into place Assembly Bill 5, which found that a worker could only be an independent contractor if they met each of these three factors...”
https://www.thebalancesmb.com/what-is-the-abc-test-for-indep...
1) The worker is free from the control and direction of the hiring entity in connection with the work's performance, both under the contract for the performance of the work and in fact.
2) The worker performs work that is outside the usual course of the hiring entity's business.
3) The worker is customarily engaged in an independently established trade, occupation, or business of the same nature as the work performed.
IANAL but this ABC test reads to me as markedly different from the typical IRS “balance of factors” tests and significantly narrows the scope of “independent contractor”.
People who work for Uber as contractors can accept or decline rides, and only accept rides at a rate they want, so yes they are setting their rates. Just as a software contractor can accept or decline a job based on the rate offered. You're entitled to accept work at a rate you want, but you are not entitled to be guaranteed work at the rate you want.
What "legal protections" are you talking about? Uber can put out a notification right now that if you don't take 1 ride in the next hour that you are banned from the platform and there's nothing your friends could do about it.
A contractor gets to work w/e hours they want because they are their own boss and collect their own contracted work. Uber basically forms a new contract with a driver per-ride. There's no promise of future rides, and Uber has every right to withhold new rides for whatever reason, including that they do not like your schedule.
IRS Common Law Rules for Determining Status:
Behavioral: Does the company control or have the right to control what the worker does and how the worker does his or her job?
Financial: Are the business aspects of the worker’s job controlled by the payer? (these include things like how worker is paid, whether expenses are reimbursed, who provides tools/supplies, etc.)
Type of Relationship: Are there written contracts or employee type benefits? Will the relationship continue and is the work performed a key aspect of the business?
Source: https://www.irs.gov/businesses/small-businesses-self-employe...
CA ABC Test:
Autonomy. The worker must be free from the control and direction of the hiring entity with regard to how the work is performed.
Business Dissimilarity. The worker’s labor or services must fall outside the usual course of the hiring entity’s business.
Custom of the Worker. The worker must be customarily engaged in an independently established trade, occupation, or business of the same nature as that involved in the work performed.
Source: https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySectio...
I'd love to see the US government actually step up to the healthcare plate though - especially after so many years of terrible FDA & Dept. of Edu. policies have led to widespread obesity. Personal responsibility doesn't really work as an excuse when your entire country is an outrageous outlier compared to the rest of the world - that seems more systemic.
[1] https://www.smh.com.au/national/australians-are-fat-and-gett...
I work as a 1099 contractor under my own LLC consulting business. This is valid under CA law. The law is meant to protect people who are unfairly classified as contractors outside of a trade.
While that may be, we all know that laws aren't interpreted based on their intended meaning. They are interpreted as one or more judges sees fit.
It's not a decision if they have no choice in the matter (one way or another).
Large companies can use their massive leverage to force sub-optimal conditions which are in their favour.
Though there are definitely arguments to be made for 'prefer contractor' - there is no doubt, that on the aggregate, there are huge, systematic problems with the new 'gig economy' that need to be sorted out.
Free markets work when people have skills and at least some leverage, but at the bottom end, where people are less skilled, it doesn't work well, which is why we need to have minimum wage, possibly unions in some cases etc..
New economy, new rules.
I've worked many years as a contractor billing at a daily rate.
The difference being that I can choose to enter permanent employment any time I wanted, due to the field we work in.
It's not the same as contracting for Uber or Lyft. Not even close.
Just some perspective here, not discounting what you said.
The most marginalized and desperate gain more from employment structure.
Honestly, I think objectively I'd look at this as very much sympathetic to the employers, if I had to assign bias (though honestly it's fairly neutral).
As far as the law goes: this result was coming for sure, the only surprise here is the fact that it happened via injuction. The California "AB5" law under which the suit was filed is a new law from last year, and it was very much written with the intent to make gig economy positions into "employee" relationships. There's a link in the article to this explainer, which is pretty good:
https://www.californiaemploymentlawreport.com/2019/03/unders...
In my city, which fortunately is not in California, being classified as an Uber employee would destroy my 10-20 hour weeks at $20-$30/hour. The key is to work during busy times and for $30+/hour you generally have to be entertaining to get tips (which I have tons of fun doing). If you work during slow times, then it's $10/hour or less.
Busy times are too nuanced for a manager to determine when the best time to work is.
And I don't want to subsidize other drivers with my hard work because they don't want to do the market research to know when to drive.
Maybe Uber can keep all the incentives the same (like surge) and classify drivers as employees, but I doubt it.
Not sure why you think you know what my limitations are. Or where you get the idea that employers actually hire disabled people. Look at the unemployment rate for disabled people.
Uber and Lyft employees are paid on commission. Uber and Lyft don't call it commission, but that's exactly what it is. You get X% of your sales, with bonuses, etc.
For me, price was never the primary motivator of using Uber or Lyft. It's the convenience and having a well known brand that will more likely than not actually come pick me up.
This pandemic has proven that EVERYONE needs unemployment insurance, and it is already well-known that everyone needs income and healthcare in retirement.
Sp sure, let people do gig work on their own time, but don't let them opt out of the basic social safety nets we all need to survive.
Various companies forced people to become fake contractors. They didn't pay them enough that these fake contractors actually could still have the same social benefits/security.
This resulted in the government bailing out loads of contractors. Basically the "profit for the company, losses for the government" way of working.
The only thing that is being lost here is the inability of Uber/Lyft to pay less than a minimum wage and otherwise deprive the drivers of the benefits that employees are entitled to.
Anyway, it's not like Uber/Lyft were giving drivers the choice whether to be contractors or employees so that the drivers could pick the status they prefer - nor does the law ever truly allow that except when the genuine nature of the services relationship is adjusted based on the answer to legitimately conform to the desired status. They're forcing everyone to pick the status that's generally more expensive and precarious for the worker.
I work as a 1099 contractor doing software engineering under my own LLC consulting business. This is valid under CA law. The law is meant to protect people who are unfairly classified as contractors outside of a trade, not restrict choice of those of us already working in this capacity.
Technology has decreased the lead time needed to let someone know that you're available to work to 0. There's absolutely no reason why that should mean that you can't be an employee.
This ruling is a reclassification - the work that they have been doing in the manner they've been doing it is already employment. Or, in other words: the current relationship doesn't have to change a single bit, they just get additional benefits.
I'm sure the flexibility is nice when you are making $100+ per hour but drivers make a tenth of that and struggle to get health insurance
I’m guessing many would rather see Uber drivers all be forced to be employees even if 99% don’t want to, than a spreading erosion of workers rights.
That is possible for employees as well. Part time employment is also possible. What is different is ability to set rates etc.
It’s quite a different story being a specialist contractor compared to a easily replacable minimum-wage earner.
...not going to make it.
How much do your contracting friends invest? What's their compensation?
The sharing economy, gig economy, concessionaire model, MLM ponzi, franchise system, value-added reseller channel are minor variations of a time proven wealth transfer scheme.
The mark provides the capital and labor, and carries most of the risk.
The landlord, platform, broker, aggregator extracts all of the profit, value, wealth.
Any time a serf prospers is accidental. And quickly remedied.
By any other name, right?
It's be nice if the critics would reject the frame. Instead of phrases like late stage capitalism, just speak plainly.
It's feudalism. Repackaged and rebranded. But still just plain old feudalism.
One irony, all the gig economy workers do make a car a LOT less necessary if you are in an area well served by them.
Sure - some (non-insignificant) portion of Uber and Lyft drivers would like to be employees. But surely some (also non-insignificant) portion would prefer to be contractors for Uber and Lyft and keep the legal protections that come with that.
These articles always make it seem like it's a no-brainer win for all drivers no matter what, but it's never seemed so clear cut to me.