News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by dfdz on Monday August 10, 2020 @07:12PM (#24115262)
>I'm afraid you're repeating Uber's favorite talking point

True, but that does not mean rdgthree's argument has no merit.

> Nobody disputes that Uber can have employees or contractors

What about the California judge?

Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by dan-robertson on Monday August 10, 2020 @07:24PM (#24115380)
The argument which won was not that there is some legal reason Uber can’t have both independent contractors and employees, but rather that the relationship between Uber and it’s drivers is de facto employment and should therefore be subject to employment law.
Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by fastball on Monday August 10, 2020 @08:41PM (#24115994)
Huh? The whole point is that the California judiciary is literally saying that legally Uber cannot classify drivers as contractors.

So no, they cannot have independent contractors, unless you mean for the operations side of their business, which nobody is talking about so I hope not.

Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by Gunax on Monday August 10, 2020 @08:57PM (#24116109)
I don't think so... The ruling is that the relationship as it is in employment. The test is:

A) the worker is free from the control and direction of the hiring entity in connection with the performance of the work, both under the contract for the performance of the work and in fact; and

B) the worker performs work that is outside the usual course of the hiring entity’s business; and

C) the worker is customarily engaged in an independently established trade, occupation, or business of the same nature as the work performed.

Of course you can argue about the minutia of each test (that's what lawyers are for) but there's nothing stopping the hiring of drivers as contractors per se. It's just that the judge thinks the current relationship as it is does not pass this test.

Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by fastball on Monday August 10, 2020 @09:02PM (#24116142)
Right, but the issue is that there doesn't seem to be any clear way Uber as an entity with the business model that it has (make an app that connects drivers with riders, take a portion of proceeds) can ever have drivers that are contractors.

Said another way, what could Uber change from their current policies that would pass ABC if they don't at the minute?

Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by dragonwriter on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @06:03AM (#24118789)
> B) the worker performs work that is outside the usual course of the hiring entity’s business;

This seems to be the insurmountable point; the judge seems to be inclined to see drivers as within the usual course of business, which means nothing changing on A and/or C would matter, and, assuming the strong statements in the injunction reflect the eventual ruling on the merits, Uber would have no means other than radically changing the business they are in to have drivers-as-contractors.

Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by gamblor956 on Monday August 10, 2020 @09:07PM (#24116172)
There's correct, under CA law Uber would need to restructure its entire business model if it wants to treat drivers as contractors. (The ABC test in the other reply was codified into CA law.)
Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by dragonwriter on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @05:47AM (#24118725)
> The whole point is that the California judiciary is literally saying that legally Uber cannot classify drivers as contractors.

It's not (as a matter of what the law generally mandates), because it's a preliminary injunction, not summary judgement.

Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by sangnoir on Monday August 10, 2020 @07:41PM (#24115542)
The Carlifornia judge also agrees, just that the definition of a contractor is based on more than flexible hours. If Uber truly wants to have contractors, they'll have to cede more decision-making/autonomy to drivers; or alternatively have 2 classes of drivers and have them choose to be employees or honest-to-goodness contractors with full autonomy (or enough autonomy to cross the line between employee and contractor).
Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by TheColorYellow on Monday August 10, 2020 @08:30PM (#24115919)
What autonomy would Uber need to provide?
Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by sangnoir on Monday August 10, 2020 @09:13PM (#24116218)
One part of the "ABC test"[1] used to check the "contractorness" under law requires that "...the worker is free from the control and direction of the hiring entity in connection with the performance of the work..." - Uber controls every minute of drivers work time, so this will be a high hurdle to clear.

Part B is similarly challenging, because it requires that the contractor & the work they are doing not be in the same line of business as hiring entity

1. https://www.californiaemploymentlawreport.com/2019/03/unders...

Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by fastball on Monday August 10, 2020 @08:43PM (#24116011)
Yes I would like to know this too. I know a guy that drives more than full-time for Uber (50+ hours pw).

I have a friend that drives approximately 8 hours pw for Uber.

How are drivers not choosing their own hours, exactly? That seems to be exactly what they are doing.

And when I say "Uber", I actually mean Uber/Lyft. And obviously in some parts of the US there are other apps and drivers use those too.

Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by hypersoar on Monday August 10, 2020 @09:08PM (#24116181)
Being an independent contractor is about more than "choosing your own hours". you can be an employee and have flexible hours. You can be a contractor and have fixed hours. There are plenty of examples of both in the tech industry.
Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by fastball on Monday August 10, 2020 @09:16PM (#24116230)
Hmm, maybe I just don't know enough people, but I don't know any employee (with benefits and such) that can just stop working for their company for 12 months with no prior notice, and then pick it back up whenever. And infinite variations on that refrain.

I also don't know any employee who gets paid money by the customer to do a job, of which a small portion is taken by the company. For every "employee" I know, it works in exactly the opposite way.

Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by ClumsyPilot on Monday August 10, 2020 @09:47PM (#24116393)
Uber gets paid, not the driver. The money does not drop directly into the driver's bank account. The driver cannot decide to change his rate or charge extra if the customer pukes in the car. And besides, Getting a cut of your sales and it's called commission.

Independence goes much further - can the driver assign someone else to do the job?

Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by fastball on Monday August 10, 2020 @10:24PM (#24116593)
Uber collects the payment. But it belongs to the driver. Uber then takes a fraction of it.

As with any other marketplace/platform: Amazon, Patreon, App Stores, Twitch, Steam, etc.

Stripe collects payments for me when I sell my app. The money does not drop directly into my bank account.

And I don't think Uber has any problem with drivers hiring other people to drive their car and do Uber for them. The people that take an issue with that are the municipalities that want to require background checks, etc. for drivers.

Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by sudosysgen on Monday August 10, 2020 @10:59PM (#24116752)
Uber doesn't tell the driver how much it's charging the customer, takes an arbitrary cut, and doesn't let you decide of the price, exactly unlike the Apple App store, Amazon, Patreon, and Steam. There are also more reasons why they are employees, but these are material to your claims.
Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by saurik on Monday August 10, 2020 @10:32PM (#24116634)
A quick search is showing me a ton of answers on Quora of being emphatically stating that Uber actively allows you to hire people to drive your car for you, as long as you can show they are insured to do so: the money goes to you, to the one parent account, so you get to decide how to pay your subcontractors; supposedly you can even register as a corporation?
Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by zaksoup on Monday August 10, 2020 @07:25PM (#24115399)
I don't think the CA Judge disputed that Uber could have a relationship with drivers that was legally structured as "independent contractor" but rather that the relationship Uber currently has with drivers does not meet the legal requirements to be classified as "independent contractor". If Uber wanted to change the requirements they place on drivers nobody is saying they couldn't be contractors under different circumstances.
Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by crooked-v on Monday August 10, 2020 @07:28PM (#24115426)
> What about the California judge?

Nothing about the ruling prevents Uber from having contractors. It prevents them from having employees (as determined by California law) that they label as contractors in order to skirt around legal requirements for employees.

Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by dfdz on Monday August 10, 2020 @07:47PM (#24115593)
True, but when 100k uber drivers (contractors) in California are reclassified as employees, it seem fair to say a "dispute" is happening.

For the record, I am not saying the ruling is incorrect, but it does make me feel uneasy because:

1) I think that Uber does provide a public good (increased efficiency compared to a taxi) 2) If all drivers are employees, the business does not seem sustainable

I think that new laws are needed rather than using pre-sharing-economy labels like employee, but that the ruling by the judge may be correct given the current laws.

Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by ClumsyPilot on Monday August 10, 2020 @09:53PM (#24116436)
1) In Victorian Britain, child labour provided a great many public goods. 2) After it was outlawed, many of businesses that relied on it became unsustainable.

I don't think it is sensible to justify exploitation with "but the public benefits from it' and 'without it the business might go under'. By that logic we'd still have Victorian workhouses, 12-hour workdays, and there'd be no health & safety.

Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by logicchains on Monday August 10, 2020 @11:07PM (#24116785)
>I don't think it is sensible to justify exploitation with "but the public benefits from it' and 'without it the business might go under'.

It's absurd to compare providing a service that hooks drivers up with clients to child labour.

Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by xnyan on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @12:55AM (#24117289)
Driving for a living is hard on a person. Truck drivers have bad health and quite high divorce/problematic relationship rates. Taxi driving is relatively dangerous. Driving is the most dangerous activity we commonly perform today and the risk corresponds to miles driven.
Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by reidjs on Monday August 10, 2020 @11:59PM (#24117036)
driving is one of the most dangerous things you can do nowadays. most Uber drivers have to support themselves and possibly others. Many drivers can’t afford private healthcare so in the case of an accident it would really suck for them and their family.

Maybe they’re not losing their fingers in factory machines like child laborers are but I think they deserve employer provided healthcare at the very least.

Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by eru on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @01:06AM (#24117329)
> By that logic we'd still have Victorian workhouses, 12-hour workdays, and there'd be no health & safety.

What makes you think so? There's more than one reason for the demise of child labour. Society has gotten richer over time, and so families place a comparatively higher value on not having their children work.

Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by anonunivgrad on Monday August 10, 2020 @08:06PM (#24115740)
But for Uber being allowed to seize the market with their ultra low prices, which are only possible because they class their labor as contractors, there would be companies more like Uber than like taxis but that treat their employees like employees.

The problem with taxis was the medallion system and other crazy regulations.

There is a middle ground. No medallions or other protectionist measures, but you have to treat your employees like employees.

Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by eru on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @01:08AM (#24117335)
I wouldn't call that a middle ground, that would sort-of imply that your suggestion is in between the two approaches.

The old system with medallions also had the drivers as independent contractors.

Your suggestion would be something different from both existing approaches.

Edit: no opinion implied on whether your suggestion is any good or not.

Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by anonunivgrad on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @08:25AM (#24119560)
All good points.
Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by brudgers on Monday August 10, 2020 @08:35PM (#24115947)
If all drivers are employees, the business does not seem sustainable

Uber lost $19,000,000,000 in 2019. It lost money last quarter. Uber is already unsustainable. Despite its labor practices, Uber has been unsustainable since its founding. And it’s not like Amazon’s early days where lack of profits was offset by acquisition of physical infrastructure. Uber loses money on via unit economics.

Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by jeffbee on Monday August 10, 2020 @08:03PM (#24115719)
Uber has not ever been more efficient than the services it replaced. Better in many ways, definitely for riders and arguably for some drivers, but not efficient. Uber has simply been shoveling tens of billions of dollars in funny money into the maw of their attempt to corner a market, which has never worked.

This write-up from today sums up some of the story so far. https://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2020/08/hubert-horan-can-ube...

Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by jquery on Monday August 10, 2020 @11:31PM (#24116913)
From your link

> Uber was always less efficient than the traditional taxis it drove out of business

This is patent nonsense. I suspect he never rode taxis often before Uber appeared.

Also Uber’s core ride business was profitable before corona hit. Lots of businesses are hemorrhaging money right now, especially ones in travel.

Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by fastball on Monday August 10, 2020 @08:44PM (#24116026)
So what changes (in your opinion) would allow Uber to reasonably classify drivers as contractors?
Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by crooked-v on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @12:00AM (#24117041)
There's no "opinion" about it. There are fairly clear-cut rules that are applied under California law: https://www.californiaemploymentlawreport.com/2019/03/unders...
Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by fastball on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @03:49AM (#24118142)
Yes, and from my reading, Uber cannot possibly change anything without literally becoming an entirely different company with different business model in order for their drivers to be classified as contractors.
Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by waheoo on Monday August 10, 2020 @07:20PM (#24115338)
I don't think they stated it does have merit on those points, but they certainly laid out a pretty solid argument that does.

Maybe address that instead of hand wringing the conversational communication style used on every forum ever?