I agree with some other posters, I think a new categorization for "gig" workers is necessary, as I think a lot of your other points (e.g. paying workers comp) make sense.
Workers can choose platforms that maximize the worker's wages while platforms would need to minimize costs for customers. The more efficient the platform gets, the better position they would be in vs competitors.
Possible in what sense? Legally possible, or do you mean economically feasible?
As we've seen with the pandemic, unemployment can mean withdrawal of healthcare and eviction.
Really the question here is risk. Who takes the risk that employees can get sick? Who takes the risk that levels of work coming in can vary?
Should it be the individual employees, who generally have a couple month's income saved or less, or should it $50 billion market cap company? Which is better able to absorb risk? Or should the risk instead be handled by the state or federal government?
There are plenty of people working more than one job in the US where they're classified as an employee at all of them.
1. Work for the competitors
2. work as much or as little as they want
3. Take as much vacation time as they want
4. Leave with zero advance notice
Also, should Twitch streamers and Youtube creators also become employees? What about Etsy/Ebay sellers or AirBnB hosts?
Absolutely they can. California, like almost all states in the US, is an “at-will” employment state.
None of these things are required under employment law at all. Can I ask where you found this wildly false information? Do you happen to live outside the US?
Nowhere in California labor law does it prevent people from taking vacations or anything else you mentioned if they are an employee.
I worked in California for a few years but I'm not longer there. And those were questions, they weren't meant to be stated as facts.
> Nowhere in California labor law does it prevent people from taking vacations
Hmm, maybe I understood my rights wrong, but from my understanding I wasn't free to take an arbitrary number of vacation days without getting fired. I know Netflix allows that but other than them, wouldn't most employers let you go if you just decided to not show up on random days?
Also, again I'm not expert, but are you sure that someone can simultaneously work for Apple and Google? That doesn't sound right but again, these are mostly discussion questions, let me know if I'm missing something here.
You are correct that they can limit vacation time, but Uber could also limit vacation time for contractors. There is nothing specific in California employment law that does not allow employers and employees to mutually agree to open vacation time.
I think we agree about vacation time.
It would take much less effort
However, they are extremely unpopular politically. Especially in California, where they seem to hate all kinds of real estate taxation.
Hilariously, you are so far off that you don’t realize that the only legal way Uber could prevent their drivers from working for Lyft in California was if they were contractors and not employees
Where did you get this information?
There is nothing in this ruling that prevents Uber from allowing people to chose rides _exactly_ as they are doing it now.
The changes are:
1. Uber needs to pay into unemployment insurance.
2. Uber needs to pay into workers compensation.
3. Uber needs to pay into social security.
4. Uber needs to collect payroll taxes in advance.
5. Uber cannot discriminate based on protected classes such as race or gender.
6. Uber must comply with the WARN if large scale layoffs occur.
7. Uber has to provide for heath insurance depending in accordance with local and federal laws.
8. Uber needs to verify the legal working status of their drivers
9. And many other things all other businesses pay into and rules they have to follow.
We make businesses pay into this because the general public is ends up footing the bill anyway. Like right now where we’re providing Uber drivers with unemployment benefits even though Uber cheated their responsibility. And when a driver gets in an accident and we have to pick up the bill of unpaid hospital bills and disability payments.
Flexibility has nothing to do with it. Paying into the system everyone else has to and following the rules everyone else needs to follow is.