If the existing laws can be interpreted to punish them, they will be used. If not, the coalition against Uber will look into getting new laws passed. (As they already have.)
Thus rendering any discussion about whether existing laws can justify punishment somewhat moot.
(Of course, even a moot discussion can be interesting. Just like people can have fun arguing whether the Stark Trek Enterprise would beat a Star Wars Destroyer.
The legal discussion is also very important to Uber lawyers. Even if they lose in the end, any delay is worthwhile.)
Is that an opinion on the legal situation, or meant as a suggestion for how to build a better business?
Of course, one wouldn't be actively working for two employers at the same instant, but neither would one be simultaneously driving an Uber ride and a Lyft ride.
I don't know California law on this specifically, but any state would definitely include time when actively serving as a driver for a ride, many would include time driving to pick up an accepted passenger, some might include time when logged in as a driver.
Until someone figures out how to multiplex the cabshare part of the two apps :p
2. Interesting idea, but then all companies could just do this and make the same claim that their employees/contractors/vendors are just customers too! Not gonna fly.
In practical terms, this is trivial for uber to dodge. All they need to do is transform from a company offering rides, to a company connecting riders to drivers. It sounds like a big difference but I susoect very little about the user experience would change.
For instance they could allow riders to offer different rates, but heavily favour (through ui and other soft incentives) the suggested rate.
In the end the drivers would be driving the same car at the same price with the same benefits.
There's typically an agenda behind these laws in terms of trying to increase the benefits and power of workers at the expense of the company. So I'm not sure Uber will be allowed to sidestep that goal by simply changing the way things are handled and presented. The govt could simply argue that giving users the option to choose a ride from Bob or Sally is meaningless since customers have no idea who these people are and just choose the first or cheapest on the list. Especially considering the amount of gray area already crossed to classify uber drivers as employees in this ruling.
Wrong in what sense? In a moral sense I might agree with you. In a legal sense, governments around the world do that all the time, and get away with it.
CA is wrong to outlaw voluntary working relationships between two parties.
Indentured Servitude is a voluntary working relationship between two parties. Is it wrong that it's illegal in CA?2) irrelevant to the employee/contractor determination. It is possible for an employee to also be a contractor, see for example restaurants...
#1, If you pick to be in a contractor relationship you can do whatever with regards to having both apps on simultaneously.
#2 If you pick to be in an employee relationship, uber and lyft have a right to exclusivity during all phases of the ride. Of course a driver can choose to work for both, but lyft can terminate a driver if they find that a driver is online for uber, and vice versa.
Or #3, the state can decide that the "employees" are "not working" unless they are in the phases where they are going towards an accepted ride or have a passenger in the car.
The state will almost certainly not go with #3. Between #1 and #2, I can tell you which option 90% of drivers will take. It's not #2. So we will be back to square one.
The fact that this question is practically speaking unilaterally up to Uber and not the result of any meaningful negotiation between the parties makes the relationship even more employment-like, as there's usually much less negotiation around terms of employment (certainly some still happens) than in true independent contracting.
What's more, it's not clear to me that courts would enforce the duty of loyalty (and maybe not even an express contractual provision depending on the state) against a part-time rank-and-file provider of comparatively unskilled labor, just as they wouldn't prevent a 20-hour-per-month sandwich shop employee from spending an additional 20 hours per month at a different sandwich shop in parallel. Maybe a guarantee from Uber of full-time pay would change that. I believe a federal trial court has even ruled that non-fiduciary employees in California have no duty of loyalty, though I don't know if that was overturned on appeal or whether state courts have agreed.
Just as a ride hailing driver can't simultaneously have an Uber and a Lyft passenger in his car. What's your point?
[0] I did this once, uber had a really stupid and un-thought-out halloween weekend bonus on a weekend where halloween fell on a friday night (people don't party hard on saturday night of a halloween weekend like that), and pink mustache copied with their own equally asinine bonus. So I went out to a place within the service area where I knew I would not get very many uber or lyft rides, and left both apps on for hours while reading inside a Denny's. I did happen to get ONE ride, and I left the other service on to rack up bonus time on it. I was definitely nervous as hell though, which in retrospect, was unnecessary.
I'm well aware of this. If you look in my comment history, you'll see that I drove for Uber and Lyft, too.
But the point stands — You can't earn money from both at the same time, just like someone can't earn money from waiting tables at two different restaurants at the same time.
uber had a really stupid and un-thought-out halloween weekend bonus
Ick. Don't get me started about Uber's promotional games. Like making everyone sign up for a big promotion during a big event, and then there are no qualifying rides.
You can be an employee of multiple companies at once. Many people are.
You just generally don't get paid by multiple companies for the same period of time if you are paid hourly wages.
I certainly know it is true of journalist freelancers.
1. If Uber and Lyft allow their drivers to choose, would it be reasonable for them to make "having the other app on at the same time" cause for dismissal? I know of no other employee that is allowed to simultaneously bill time on a competitor. Contractors, absolutely. Employees, no.
2. What if Uber, instead, charged $1.00/mo for the drivers to use the app, thereby making them customers instead of contractors?