News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by dnautics on Monday August 10, 2020 @07:31PM (#24115453)
Having been a driver for 1.5 years my questions for you are these:

1. If Uber and Lyft allow their drivers to choose, would it be reasonable for them to make "having the other app on at the same time" cause for dismissal? I know of no other employee that is allowed to simultaneously bill time on a competitor. Contractors, absolutely. Employees, no.

2. What if Uber, instead, charged $1.00/mo for the drivers to use the app, thereby making them customers instead of contractors?

Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by baddox on Monday August 10, 2020 @07:51PM (#24115630)
Regarding #2, that's just generally not how the law works. There may be some cases where legal technicalities are successfully argued, but in general the legal system doesn't put up with someone sticking their finger a millimeter from its face and saying "technically I'm not touching you."
Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by dnautics on Monday August 10, 2020 @08:31PM (#24115923)
okay, let's make the price higher. Let's make it $150/mo. Now we're about 10 centimeters away from your face, and not too far off from what taxicab companies do.
Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by saurik on Monday August 10, 2020 @10:26PM (#24116603)
Yeah. I pay PayPal to process payments for me: I don't work for them. Hell: I pay Apple to publish apps to the App Store on my behalf, and they even decide whether my app is "OK" or not: when they tell me to make a change to my app, I must do that or I lose my ability to collect revenue. They even require I use certain tools that I have to purchase from the company store to do my work. I have no direct relationship with the customer. They collect all of my money, and then pay me. Am I somehow an employee of Apple? Supposedly I am Apple's customer, but it sometimes doesn't feel like that ;P.
Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by nl on Monday August 10, 2020 @11:23PM (#24116865)
You set the price that the customer pays (via Apple) though. That isn't the case for Uber drivers.
Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by aflag on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @05:32AM (#24118667)
And, perhaps more importantly, the user sees your app and branding in the end and they can choose to pick you again. Which is not the case for uber either.
Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by eru on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @12:50AM (#24117271)
You think, if Uber let drivers bid on customer fares, they could classify the drivers as contractors again?
Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by himinlomax on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @02:08AM (#24117590)
Not sure about California, but here in France it's the kind of difference that would change the nature of the relationship. Although it would be evaluated as a whole, and would be under a lot of scrutiny to determine whether this change wasn't meaningless for practical purposes.
Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by eru on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @02:13AM (#24117614)
I suspect that in practice there seems to be a political consensus in Californian that Uber is evil. The rest is just trying to find ways to punish them.

If the existing laws can be interpreted to punish them, they will be used. If not, the coalition against Uber will look into getting new laws passed. (As they already have.)

Thus rendering any discussion about whether existing laws can justify punishment somewhat moot.

(Of course, even a moot discussion can be interesting. Just like people can have fun arguing whether the Stark Trek Enterprise would beat a Star Wars Destroyer.

The legal discussion is also very important to Uber lawyers. Even if they lose in the end, any delay is worthwhile.)

Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by aflag on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @05:33AM (#24118674)
I think giving the ability for one driver to promote their services over other drivers is also a key feature. Each driver needs to be able to differentiate themselves and not be essentially interchangeable.
Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by eru on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @08:52AM (#24119753)
> Each driver needs to be able to differentiate themselves and not be essentially interchangeable.

Is that an opinion on the legal situation, or meant as a suggestion for how to build a better business?

Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by aflag on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @10:10AM (#24120394)
That's the a key difference for me to consider it a contractor/client relationship rather than a employer/employee relationship. I'm not a lawyer, so I don't know what the law says in each country Uber operates.
Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by Firehawke on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @12:45AM (#24117240)
They already do it. I've spoken to several drivers who rent their vehicles through the ride sharing company just like a Taxi driver does, and the price per day is about the same as the local cabs.
Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by sanderjd on Monday August 10, 2020 @07:47PM (#24115602)
For #2, are you suggesting that the drivers would then get the full fare in exchange for the payment for the app? If so, yes, that would clearly be a great, extremely driver-friendly change that would defuse the employee vs contractor controversy... But, I suspect it would also result in layoffs and perhaps lawsuits from the shareholders.
Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by nagispringfield on Monday August 10, 2020 @08:31PM (#24115926)
I'm currently interning at a startup called Empower. This is their exact business model, the company provides software, the driver can set their own rates and they get the full fare. The drivers pay a monthly subscription free.
Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by Jommi on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @02:23AM (#24117664)
Unfortunately it doesnt solve the biggest issue, which is actually getting the demand in.
Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by sanderjd on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @12:37AM (#24117203)
Sounds great, hope it works out!
Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by dnautics on Monday August 10, 2020 @08:29PM (#24115910)
no. There's no reason why you couldn't do both. There's plenty of apps where you both pay for entry and pay a cut out of each transaction.
Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by sanderjd on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @12:40AM (#24117215)
Ah, then the reason this wouldn't work is that the court would still deem them to be employees, after seeing through this incredibly transparent and cynical facade.
Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by dnautics on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @03:56PM (#24136142)
the courts haven't seen through the facade of the taxi companies (the point is: this would be uber doing exactly what the taxi companies do)
Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by jkaplowitz on Monday August 10, 2020 @08:14PM (#24115806)
There's nothing in the law that prevents employers from giving their permission to remain available for competitive work at the same time. Indeed, isn't that quite close to the dynamic of a union hiring hall situation, where union members are simultaneously available for jobs from any of the employers with contracts with that union?

Of course, one wouldn't be actively working for two employers at the same instant, but neither would one be simultaneously driving an Uber ride and a Lyft ride.

Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by dnautics on Monday August 10, 2020 @08:30PM (#24115920)
So when lyft is liable for meeting a minimum wage, how is time calculated? Based on logged-in time? Based on in-ride time? What if I'm in ride and I leave the other app on, and get a ride on the tail end of the ride I'm in (I've seen a driver do this).
Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by jkaplowitz on Monday August 10, 2020 @09:14PM (#24116222)
Judges have lots of experience at (and precedents for) figuring out when employees are on the clock in many contexts, including ones where employees have some degree of ability to select whether and when to accept a given work shift. Guidance does exist.

I don't know California law on this specifically, but any state would definitely include time when actively serving as a driver for a ride, many would include time driving to pick up an accepted passenger, some might include time when logged in as a driver.

Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by yomly on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @04:29AM (#24118358)
>Of course, one wouldn't be actively working for two employers at the same instant, but neither would one be simultaneously driving an Uber ride and a Lyft ride.

Until someone figures out how to multiplex the cabshare part of the two apps :p

Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by jkaplowitz on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @12:14PM (#24122018)
Hehe, true. :P Well I imagine both companies would kick you off their platform under either type of worker status if you did that, and being an employee wouldn't protect you (the typical default duty of loyalty probably does extend at least as far as working for just one company per ride).
Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by kangaroozach on Monday August 10, 2020 @07:40PM (#24115535)
1. Makes sense. CA is wrong to outlaw voluntary working relationships between two parties.

2. Interesting idea, but then all companies could just do this and make the same claim that their employees/contractors/vendors are just customers too! Not gonna fly.

Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by Gunax on Monday August 10, 2020 @08:48PM (#24116051)
In terms of legality I agree with the judge.

In practical terms, this is trivial for uber to dodge. All they need to do is transform from a company offering rides, to a company connecting riders to drivers. It sounds like a big difference but I susoect very little about the user experience would change.

For instance they could allow riders to offer different rates, but heavily favour (through ui and other soft incentives) the suggested rate.

In the end the drivers would be driving the same car at the same price with the same benefits.

Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by unishark on Monday August 10, 2020 @11:19PM (#24116843)
> In practical terms, this is trivial for uber to dodge. All they need to do is transform from a company offering rides, to a company connecting riders to drivers. It sounds like a big difference but I susoect very little about the user experience would change.

There's typically an agenda behind these laws in terms of trying to increase the benefits and power of workers at the expense of the company. So I'm not sure Uber will be allowed to sidestep that goal by simply changing the way things are handled and presented. The govt could simply argue that giving users the option to choose a ride from Bob or Sally is meaningless since customers have no idea who these people are and just choose the first or cheapest on the list. Especially considering the amount of gray area already crossed to classify uber drivers as employees in this ruling.

Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by sk5t on Monday August 10, 2020 @09:51PM (#24116422)
I submit that it's not trivial, in that Uber will have to either let drivers set their own rates, or let drivers cherry-pick without penalty the contracts they wish to accept. Either change constitutes a monumental change to the rider experience.
Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by dnautics on Monday August 10, 2020 @08:38PM (#24115964)
2. Just FYI, this is basically what the taxicab companies do. And a lot of companies that you interact with basically do this, except at a higher level of organization: namely franchises. A manager at a mcdonald's is not typically an employee of mcdonald's, and is responsible for paying a lot in fees (and has to fulfill a lot of XYZ requirements to maintain the franchise).
Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by eru on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @12:53AM (#24117283)
> 1. Makes sense. CA is wrong to outlaw voluntary working relationships between two parties.

Wrong in what sense? In a moral sense I might agree with you. In a legal sense, governments around the world do that all the time, and get away with it.

Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by masonic on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @06:53AM (#24119055)

  CA is wrong to outlaw voluntary working relationships between two parties.
Indentured Servitude is a voluntary working relationship between two parties. Is it wrong that it's illegal in CA?
Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by gamblor956 on Monday August 10, 2020 @08:54PM (#24116100)
1) if they forced that requirement on drivers, that would 100% indicate an employment relationship. But note that it is generally regarded as fraud to double bill multiple clients for the same unit of time.

2) irrelevant to the employee/contractor determination. It is possible for an employee to also be a contractor, see for example restaurants...

Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by dnautics on Monday August 10, 2020 @09:08PM (#24116186)
Ok, so we are saying

#1, If you pick to be in a contractor relationship you can do whatever with regards to having both apps on simultaneously.

#2 If you pick to be in an employee relationship, uber and lyft have a right to exclusivity during all phases of the ride. Of course a driver can choose to work for both, but lyft can terminate a driver if they find that a driver is online for uber, and vice versa.

Or #3, the state can decide that the "employees" are "not working" unless they are in the phases where they are going towards an accepted ride or have a passenger in the car.

The state will almost certainly not go with #3. Between #1 and #2, I can tell you which option 90% of drivers will take. It's not #2. So we will be back to square one.

Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by eru on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @12:55AM (#24117287)
What's wrong with #2, but Uber and Lyft decide not to use that right, and also to cede that right in the employment contract?
Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by brightball on Monday August 10, 2020 @07:38PM (#24115516)
Point 1 is big. So many Uber drivers are also Lyft drivers.
Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by greggman3 on Monday August 10, 2020 @10:23PM (#24116584)
AFAIK here is a "duty of loyalty" that requires you not to compete with your employer so working for a company that directly competes with them would be out. Like working for both Waymo and Uber self driving cars at the same time "as an employee". As a contractor no such standard exists.
Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by jkaplowitz on Monday August 10, 2020 @11:10PM (#24116801)
That's an oversimplification. Uber could just as readily add an exclusivity provision in an independent contractor agreement as waive (or strengthen) any default duty of loyalty in their employment contract.

The fact that this question is practically speaking unilaterally up to Uber and not the result of any meaningful negotiation between the parties makes the relationship even more employment-like, as there's usually much less negotiation around terms of employment (certainly some still happens) than in true independent contracting.

What's more, it's not clear to me that courts would enforce the duty of loyalty (and maybe not even an express contractual provision depending on the state) against a part-time rank-and-file provider of comparatively unskilled labor, just as they wouldn't prevent a 20-hour-per-month sandwich shop employee from spending an additional 20 hours per month at a different sandwich shop in parallel. Maybe a guarantee from Uber of full-time pay would change that. I believe a federal trial court has even ruled that non-fiduciary employees in California have no duty of loyalty, though I don't know if that was overturned on appeal or whether state courts have agreed.

Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by drewmol on Monday August 10, 2020 @08:14PM (#24115800)
2. Contractors can also be customers.
Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by jacobsenscott on Monday August 10, 2020 @08:28PM (#24115898)
I can wait tables part time at multiple restaurants.
Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by dnautics on Monday August 10, 2020 @08:35PM (#24115944)
not at the same time, you can't, unless you're talking about a taco bell/kfc joint.
Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by reaperducer on Monday August 10, 2020 @08:40PM (#24115984)
not at the same time, you can't

Just as a ride hailing driver can't simultaneously have an Uber and a Lyft passenger in his car. What's your point?

Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by dnautics on Monday August 10, 2020 @09:04PM (#24116148)
A lyft driver can have the uber and lyft apps on at the same time during the phase when you don't have a passenger in the car. This is basic driver strategy 101. It's generally good etiquette to turn it off when you get pinged for a passenger, but that doesn't always happen[0], and for sure I have seen drivers flip the other one back on towards the end of their ride. This is critical question for employment law because: how do you calculate minimum wage hours?

[0] I did this once, uber had a really stupid and un-thought-out halloween weekend bonus on a weekend where halloween fell on a friday night (people don't party hard on saturday night of a halloween weekend like that), and pink mustache copied with their own equally asinine bonus. So I went out to a place within the service area where I knew I would not get very many uber or lyft rides, and left both apps on for hours while reading inside a Denny's. I did happen to get ONE ride, and I left the other service on to rack up bonus time on it. I was definitely nervous as hell though, which in retrospect, was unnecessary.

Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by reaperducer on Monday August 10, 2020 @09:55PM (#24116445)
A lyft driver can have the uber and lyft apps on at the same time during the phase when you don't have a passenger in the car.

I'm well aware of this. If you look in my comment history, you'll see that I drove for Uber and Lyft, too.

But the point stands — You can't earn money from both at the same time, just like someone can't earn money from waiting tables at two different restaurants at the same time.

uber had a really stupid and un-thought-out halloween weekend bonus

Ick. Don't get me started about Uber's promotional games. Like making everyone sign up for a big promotion during a big event, and then there are no qualifying rides.

Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by gamblor956 on Monday August 10, 2020 @09:02PM (#24116143)
He's not making one.

You can be an employee of multiple companies at once. Many people are.

You just generally don't get paid by multiple companies for the same period of time if you are paid hourly wages.

Re:Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify dri... by garmaine on Monday August 10, 2020 @08:54PM (#24116094)
No his point is that under the California law waiting tables at two restaurants would (supposedly?) make him employees of both.

I certainly know it is true of journalist freelancers.