I don't think it is sensible to justify exploitation with "but the public benefits from it' and 'without it the business might go under'. By that logic we'd still have Victorian workhouses, 12-hour workdays, and there'd be no health & safety.
It's absurd to compare providing a service that hooks drivers up with clients to child labour.
Maybe they’re not losing their fingers in factory machines like child laborers are but I think they deserve employer provided healthcare at the very least.
What makes you think so? There's more than one reason for the demise of child labour. Society has gotten richer over time, and so families place a comparatively higher value on not having their children work.
The problem with taxis was the medallion system and other crazy regulations.
There is a middle ground. No medallions or other protectionist measures, but you have to treat your employees like employees.
The old system with medallions also had the drivers as independent contractors.
Your suggestion would be something different from both existing approaches.
Edit: no opinion implied on whether your suggestion is any good or not.
Uber lost $19,000,000,000 in 2019. It lost money last quarter. Uber is already unsustainable. Despite its labor practices, Uber has been unsustainable since its founding. And it’s not like Amazon’s early days where lack of profits was offset by acquisition of physical infrastructure. Uber loses money on via unit economics.
This write-up from today sums up some of the story so far. https://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2020/08/hubert-horan-can-ube...
> Uber was always less efficient than the traditional taxis it drove out of business
This is patent nonsense. I suspect he never rode taxis often before Uber appeared.
Also Uber’s core ride business was profitable before corona hit. Lots of businesses are hemorrhaging money right now, especially ones in travel.
For the record, I am not saying the ruling is incorrect, but it does make me feel uneasy because:
1) I think that Uber does provide a public good (increased efficiency compared to a taxi) 2) If all drivers are employees, the business does not seem sustainable
I think that new laws are needed rather than using pre-sharing-economy labels like employee, but that the ruling by the judge may be correct given the current laws.