News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by nicolashahn on Thursday November 22, 2018 @01:21PM (#18511559)
My faith in Apple would be completely redeemed if they took the 2015 Macbook Pro, put current gen hardware in it, maybe add a couple USB-C ports, and call it the 2019 Macbook Pro. My personal computer is a 2015 and my work is a 2017, and there are zero features from the 2017 that I prefer.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by unknownsavage on Thursday November 22, 2018 @01:49PM (#18511761)
I recently upgraded from the 2015 to the current gen.

2015 pros: * Better battery life * Way better keyboard * More robust * More useful port selection * Trackpad is a more reasonable size

2018 pros: * Way better speakers * Slightly better screen * Lighter * Faster * Trackpad is not mechanical * Finger print login is useful

I'd really love a proper "pro" macbook pro, that sacrificed a bit of the thin-and-lightness for an actual professional level of stuff (better cooling, more ports, bigger battery, no touchbar)

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by NeedMoreTea on Thursday November 22, 2018 @08:06PM (#18513657)
I updated from 2012 to 2016, hated and sold it after a couple of keyboard fails, and bought a 2015. My next Macbook will probably be a Thinkpad way things are going.

The better speakers I'd like. I still need to use USB sticks and SD pretty frequently and have always hated bags of adaptors. They always seem to break or get lost at the moment you're sitting with the important client.

The rest seems to come with a cost far worse than the benefit (for me anyway).

Larger trackpad was so large I would constantly get false activations when typing. Perhaps I have the wrong sort of fingers.

The touchbar was constantly activating when I typed on the top row of physical keys. Perhaps I have the wrong sort of fingers again. :)

The newer thinner keyboard was both horrible and horribly unreliable. Dust sensitive? LOL I think back to when the kids were little and throwing rusks, or putting toast in the VCR the moment we blinked. Then the amount of dog and cat hair (that magically gets everywhere) that's been removed from our keyboards over the years.

Lighter is OK, but not at a huge battery life cost compared to the 2015.

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by dsego on Friday November 23, 2018 @02:58AM (#18515040)
Well, don't get the Thinkpad for better speakers. Speaking as an owner of a new t480s, whose dumb idea was to put speakers on the bottom of the case? My lap don't have ears. Of course the battery life is even worse than the bad 2016 Macbook, not by much though. But it's not whatever double digit hours they claim. If you think apple makes nonsensical design decisions, try any windows laptop, apple is still miles ahead in certain areas. Windows is so bad it's not even funny anymore (for example cortana guided setup is disturbing) and don't get me started about linux.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by boomskats on Friday November 23, 2018 @03:13AM (#18515089)
What's wrong with Linux? Its support for Thinkpad hardware is pretty exceptional, it just isn't great at holding your hand.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by dsego on Friday November 23, 2018 @04:44AM (#18515443)
If by holding your hand you mean stuff works out of the box, then yes it isn't great. I did manage to get hidpi working in just 1-2 days (not with wayland, nothing works on wayland, let's give it just 5 more years and I'm sure it will happen), and it also goes to sleep fine, trackpad is not as bad as I expected it to be. All perfectly great achievements for 2018.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by jhcl on Friday November 23, 2018 @12:30PM (#18517772)
xubuntu versions running perfectly on my Thinkpad E550 (and Desktop) for many years already. Raspbian on my PI's and ubuntu on my beaglebone black. Don't settle for the provided software configuration. Settle for the open tool that is made for support.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by C1sc0cat on Friday November 23, 2018 @07:20AM (#18515983)
Not sure why a laptop really needs better speakers (or even any speakers) both of mine are permanently hooked up to headphones.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by sumedh on Friday November 23, 2018 @07:39AM (#18516047)
Because some people dont like to use headphones. Some couples prefer watching a movie in bed.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by inawarminister on Friday November 23, 2018 @08:06AM (#18516148)
Easily solved with a Bluetooth speaker, unlike say dust-vulnerable KBs...
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by sumedh on Friday November 23, 2018 @08:40AM (#18516322)
What if you dont carry your speaker everywhere?
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by inawarminister on Friday November 23, 2018 @08:44AM (#18516347)
your scenario was about a couple watching movies in bed, though...

To be honest, I really love my rMBP 2014 hardware, it was basically perfect. Great speaker, as you say, good enough keyboard, BEST display, etc.

If Apple releases another MBP based on 2015 I'll take a quite good look again.

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by 4ad on Friday November 23, 2018 @09:34AM (#18516608)
I only use my laptop when I am traveling. At home, I have no need for it. I am not traveling with speakers. I doubt I am alone.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by sumedh on Friday November 23, 2018 @10:10AM (#18516818)
Are you really going to carry around a bluetooth speaker in everyroom though, if someone wants to watch it on the couch?
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by allannienhuis on Friday November 23, 2018 @11:55AM (#18517529)
How many rooms in a house do people really watch movies in? A couple of bluetooth speakers covers the 95% case, and just using the crappy laptop speakers or use earbuds or headphones for the 5% case.

Of course it would be nicer if the laptop had better speakers in it, but there are always trade-offs to be made on cost vs benefit, and fairly cheap bluetooth speakers are a pretty good workaround for a lot of people.

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by sumedh on Friday November 23, 2018 @12:22PM (#18517705)
Not sure why you call the macbooks speakers crappy, i would imagine most people would consider them good enough and be happy with then instead of dealing with external Bluetooth speakers and carrying them around with the laptop.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by allannienhuis on Friday November 23, 2018 @05:13PM (#18519202)
My comment wasn't meant to be macbook specific. Most laptop speakers don't sound as nice as a reasonable set of bluetooth speakers or headphones. The main point of my comment was to counter the (strawman) idea that the only option for someone who didn't like the laptop speaker was to carry around a bluetooth speaker with them from room to room, which is of course not very practical. But having a couple of them strategically placed in the house is affordable and practical for most cases.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by sumedh on Saturday November 24, 2018 @12:19AM (#18520574)
Now instead of a room think about a house or a office, is your idea of carrying a speaker everywhere still practical or do you think adding a speakers on laptop is more practical?
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by allannienhuis on Sunday November 25, 2018 @03:27PM (#18528826)
I think you've misread/misunderstood my comment. I'm trying to say that carrying around a bluetooth speaker IS impractical (and the initial criticism of it a type of strawman argument because it's obviously impractical). I'm not suggesting in any way that carrying around a speaker everywhere is a good idea (it's not).

What I'm trying to say is that if really good audio quality is important to you, then having a couple of sets of bluetooth speakers in your house strategically placed in the places where you'd regularly watch movies or consume other high-quality audio is a reasonable workaround for a lot of people. OF COURSE having better speakers (equivalent in sound quality to the bluetooth workaround) in your laptop would be better if you care a lot about audio quality. But that would add to the cost of the laptop for every user, even the ones that don't care about having really high-quality audio on their laptop. I'm saying that it's not unreasonable for a manufacturer to make some tradeoffs like that when there are workarounds that work fairly well.

Over time the costs of adding higher-end features like this drop, and things like audio quality improve to the point that the workarounds aren't needed (the audio quality of my phone speaker is actually pretty amazing).

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by dahfizz on Friday November 23, 2018 @10:31AM (#18516952)
Do people not have TVs?
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by ucosty on Friday November 23, 2018 @11:31AM (#18517397)
By a strange coincidence I'm also in the group of people using their Macbook Pro while sitting on the sofa, due to not having a tv. I wouldn't use a dedicated TV enough to justify having one.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by sumedh on Friday November 23, 2018 @11:45AM (#18517462)
I dont know about others but I dont have a TV.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by C1sc0cat on Friday November 23, 2018 @08:56AM (#18516406)
Ah like the annoying teenagers on the bus sodcasting
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by newen on Friday November 23, 2018 @11:51AM (#18517497)
Why would you even argue for bad speakers for laptops? Of course a laptop should have good speakers..
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by StreamBright on Friday November 23, 2018 @02:59AM (#18515041)
I was checking Yoga from Lenovo and or Matebook X

https://consumer.huawei.com/en/laptops/matebook-x-pro/

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by Matthias247 on Thursday November 22, 2018 @02:54PM (#18512140)
I have the 2015 and the 2017 (without touch bar).

I agree to most things, with the minor correction that the trackpad on the 2015 is also not mechanical (and works fine, I also like the size better).

Regarding the screen I observed: The 2017 has better colors. However it is far more of a dust and dirt magnet, and harder to clean. It seems like the coating or glass might be different, which allows more dust and grease to stick. As a result the display of my 2015 looks mostly clean, the 2017 is messed up as soon as I use it for two hours and have it in my backpack.

All in all I like the 2015 more. They should have just replaced the DisplayPort/TB2 connector with USB-C/TB3 and it would have been fine. The extra lightness of the 2017 is nice to have, but from a practical standpoint the form factor of the 2015 was already great.

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by SCdF on Thursday November 22, 2018 @02:31PM (#18511999)
To clarify, are you saying that your 3 year old 2015 laptop has, today, better battery life than your new 2018 laptop? That's mad...
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by n1000 on Thursday November 22, 2018 @10:52PM (#18514229)
To those of you that complain about battery life. I noticed that using Safari as my browser gives me almost an hour extra compared to Firefox. To me it seems that newer CPU may be more efficient overall, but they seem to consume more power under medium to heavy load.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by theriddlr on Friday November 23, 2018 @10:22AM (#18516890)
My front-end dev colleague used to tell me to use a "proper" browser (i.e. Chrome) because I favoured Safari and even with DevTools. I said it gives me more battery life on a MacBook!
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by kylec on Thursday November 22, 2018 @02:33PM (#18512015)
The 2015 15" had a 100Wh battery, the 2018 has an 83Wh battery. The 2015 gets better battery life because it has 20% more battery capacity.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by arvinsim on Friday November 23, 2018 @02:37AM (#18514977)
I wonder if the touchbar is also doing significant drains on the battery.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by giovannibajo1 on Thursday November 22, 2018 @04:03PM (#18512542)
That would make sense if they had the same hardware. Different hardware absorbs different current. You cannot deduce anything from battery size.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by nikanj on Thursday November 22, 2018 @04:10PM (#18512579)
I've had the pleasure of upgrading from a 2015 to a 2017. The battery life on the latter is definitely worse, no matter what the official specs say.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by davnicwil on Thursday November 22, 2018 @08:59PM (#18513842)
Yeah I went from 2014 to 2017, and went from broadly not worrying about doing 6 hours of solid dev work without thinking about battery to essentially never feeling comfortable away from a plug.

I'd guesstimate I get at most 3 hours on the 2017 before the battery level gets low enough I have to start planning where I'll next plug in. Not ideal.

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by blueboo on Friday November 23, 2018 @05:03PM (#18519163)
part of the issue is if you have anything other than textedit open, the discrete GPU is on hoovering up all your watt-hours.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by saagarjha on Thursday November 22, 2018 @08:23PM (#18513731)
It is, but I haven't found it to be significantly worse. About an hour less.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by reversengineer on Thursday November 22, 2018 @09:43PM (#18513986)
Many people would describe an hour's difference to be a "significant" change, especially when a scale of around 10 hours total battery life is being considered.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by saagarjha on Thursday November 22, 2018 @10:30PM (#18514152)
Sure, but considering the "fudge factor" that Apple often applies for their battery life estimates ("casual browsing", etc.) an hour isn't all that much.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by jammygit on Thursday November 22, 2018 @10:50PM (#18514223)
I think decaying batteries might drive people to get new machines? Just a suspicion. They do it with iphones :p
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by bluescrn on Friday November 23, 2018 @03:03AM (#18515056)
It’s certainly an incentive to upgrade, but only if the newer model is a clear upgrade...

I suspect that Apple will be seeing a lot of 2015 MBPs brought in for battery replacements...

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by wild_preference on Friday November 23, 2018 @11:09AM (#18517216)
All batteries decay.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by thebooktocome on Thursday November 22, 2018 @07:17PM (#18513471)
I concur.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by hamstergene on Thursday November 22, 2018 @11:05PM (#18514278)
That's kinda the point... Instead of using more energy efficient new gen CPU to add ~3 hours of life, Apple used it to make the already perfect laptop insignificantly thinner and lighter by reducing the battery size.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by kowdermeister on Friday November 23, 2018 @03:16AM (#18515104)
> You cannot deduce anything from battery size.

physics might have a word with you :)

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by bengale on Friday November 23, 2018 @08:52AM (#18516388)
This isn't my experience at all, I have a 2015, a 2017 and 2018 MacBook pros. The 17 isn't all that tbh and I only have it because they replaced my 16 model. The battery isn't all that and the keyboard is a big dodgy. The 2018 though is absolutely fine, the battery is great and the keyboard has been fine the whole time. I have to use the 2015 for one of my contracts and Im always glad to get back to the 2018.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by 8fingerlouie on Friday November 23, 2018 @03:40AM (#18515196)
I just replaced the battery in my Early 2015 MacBook Pro Retina 13.

When it was new i would regularly get ~12 hours of light usage from it (safari, email, terminal, VPN, citrix, remote desktop). It has been providing around 8-9 hours steadily for the past year or so. I finally noticed when placed flat on a table it wasn't sitting flat, and the battery was swollen.

Now with a new battery we're back to 12+ hours of light usage.

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by lowercased on Thursday November 22, 2018 @02:39PM (#18512049)
i had a 2016 mbp, and it had (IIRC) ~7000mAh battery. My 2015 mbp had ~8800mAh. The battery itself was smaller in the 2016 model, presumably for thin/weight.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by TylerE on Thursday November 22, 2018 @10:33PM (#18514163)
Those numbers can't be right. That's only double what an iphone has.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by coin on Thursday November 22, 2018 @11:02PM (#18514263)
Different voltages
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by icebraining on Friday November 23, 2018 @03:16AM (#18515101)
mAh is not a measure of energy; Apple says the Macbooks have about 54 watt-hours, whereas an iPhone has between 6 and 10.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by dguaraglia on Friday November 23, 2018 @11:05AM (#18517189)
My old 2015 MacBook Pro without a discrete GPU had amazing battery life. I'd get at least 8 hours, and over 10 if I wanted to sacrifice some of the brightness and turn bluetooth off. I got upgraded to the discrete GPU model and I could get at most 6 to 7 hours for the same workload.

Nowadays, you can't even get a 15 inch MacBook Pro without a discreet GPU.

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by kalleboo on Friday November 23, 2018 @11:58AM (#18517546)
You can stop the OS from switching to the discrete GPU using an app like gfxCardStatus
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by crazysim on Thursday November 22, 2018 @02:33PM (#18512013)
I thought the 2015 had a force touch and non mechanical touchpad too.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by mygo on Thursday November 22, 2018 @08:20PM (#18513716)
exactly ;) so well-designed that you can't even tell it's non mechanical (unless you turn the clicky sound and vibrations off)

I still prefer the 2015 Macbook Pros to the current release and that's just sad. How is it so easy for Apple to throw away so much good design research and implementation? They don't even have the mag-safe chargers, nor the the battery indicator lights on the chargers, what a step backwards on such simple but great functionality!

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by WildGreenLeave on Friday November 23, 2018 @04:00AM (#18515268)
I own a 2015 Macbook since the launch in 2015 (duh), and I remember letting people use my force touch trackpad saying that it doesn't 'click'. Took almost everyone at least several minutes to convince them that the trackpad doesn't actually click. :-)

Furthermore I do agree with you on pretty much every point. I don't like my 2017 Macbook and I most certainly won't upgrade my 2015 to any new pro laptop.

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by abrowne on Thursday November 22, 2018 @02:41PM (#18512070)
Correct, the 2015 has force touch, which is how they fit the 99.5 Wh battery.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by techstrategist on Friday November 23, 2018 @02:43AM (#18514998)
Whoa, I switched to a 2015 MBP last year and didn't know about force touch yet. Time to repeat the onboarding I guess, there is some incredibly useful hidden UI.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by tobyhinloopen on Friday November 23, 2018 @05:04AM (#18515537)
Yes it has force touch trackpad
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by jamiepenney on Thursday November 22, 2018 @02:31PM (#18512001)
Better cooling, definitely. My machine gets quite hot on my lap unless I have it turn on the fans earlier using Macs Fan Control. I'm using it as a pro machine, so it's running a bunch of docker containers, Slack, VS Code, a million tabs across Firefox and Chrome. It's a busy machine and it doesn't need to be silent if that means it's hot enough to be uncomfortable on my legs and hands.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by zepolen on Thursday November 22, 2018 @07:31PM (#18513528)
MBP heating issues are from the fact that the dedicated GPU doesn't get enough cooling, the frame is too small.

Add https://github.com/0xbb/gpu-switch - run the integrated gpu only - and you will never listen to a fan again, and prolong the life of your MPB.

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by j45 on Friday November 23, 2018 @10:14AM (#18516839)
It's discouraging to hear the 15" MBP GPU's still have heating/failure issues, I toasted a few 15" MBP GPU's in 2006-2009. Not sure what the point is to have a GPU in a laptop I don't use.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by sooheon on Thursday November 22, 2018 @08:12PM (#18513684)
The project readme warns it's broken on recent macos versions.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by dwighttk on Thursday November 22, 2018 @11:36PM (#18514391)
Chrome is probably the biggest culprit. It is awfuly inefficient on macOS
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by bluescrn on Friday November 23, 2018 @03:21AM (#18515121)
Firefox burns through battery rapidly too. Seems that you have to stick with Safari to get good battery life out of an MBP - it makes a very real difference
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by wild_preference on Friday November 23, 2018 @11:13AM (#18517252)
I switched to Safari when it added favicons to browser tabs the other month. The CPU-usage/battery difference is huge. I also like the new Safari extension paradigm and have ported some extensions of my own that could be improved by moving CPU-bound work to Swift.

I only use Chrome for development now.

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by dwighttk on Friday November 23, 2018 @11:44AM (#18517455)
I have Chrome only for the built in Flash. I don’t play many flash games these days, but I don’t know what I’m going to do when Google finally strips that out. Seems like Kongregate has drifted towards Unity but there are a few classics, and I have an old game that a friend and I made a long time ago that I like to play from time to time.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by patzal on Friday November 23, 2018 @03:08PM (#18518611)
Am I misunderstanding something, or you just said Safari added favicon support in 2018?
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by dwighttk on Friday November 23, 2018 @05:55PM (#18519376)
You did not misunderstand: that is a new thing in Safari
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by nodesocket on Thursday November 22, 2018 @09:35PM (#18513965)
I upgraded from a 2017 13" MacBook Pro touch bar to 2018 15" MacBook Pro touch bar, and noticed a huge improvement.

  - 6 cores (12 threads) was absolutely noticeable
  - NVme disk performance is much faster
  - 2nd generation butterfly keyboard is much improved
  - Speakers are way louder, bassy, and crisp
  - 15" screen is much better in terms of real-estate than 13"
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by AnthonBerg on Friday November 23, 2018 @08:30AM (#18516269)
I upgraded from a top-end 2017 15" to a top-end 2018 15", and even that was very noticeable. I was quite surprised at how much better the 2018 was.

I really liked the 2017 to begin with.

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by Matthias247 on Thursday November 22, 2018 @10:17PM (#18514094)
You actually have the 3rd gen butterfly keyboard. The first gen was only on the 12“ MacBook series. And that one was really bad (have zero feedback). The 2nd gen on the 2017 is bearable, but doesn’t seem to be long term reliable
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by dep_b on Thursday November 22, 2018 @02:42PM (#18512076)
2015 trackpad isn’t mechanical either
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by dzhiurgis on Thursday November 22, 2018 @06:02PM (#18513129)
> I'd really love a proper "pro" macbook pro

More like MacBook Dev, imagine:

- Good keyboard, with Lenovo-like mouse clitoris

- Edges that aren't cutting your wrists off

- No touch bar and regular size trackpad (heck, I'll pay extra for this)

- 15" OLED screen for outdoors

- Figure out GPU. I do not want annoying GPU switching and beast of graphics card - I just enough to drive 5K screen.

- A USB port

- MacBook Air weight/size or insane battery life

- CPU with best single thread performance

- RAM up to 128GB or more

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by Ardon on Thursday November 22, 2018 @07:40PM (#18513569)
It's never been clear to me why people want a mouse clitoris on a computer with a real trackpad.

I've seen plenty of windows laptops with awful trackpads where I get it, but aren't they just a huge step back compared to a macbook trackpad?

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by NeedMoreTea on Thursday November 22, 2018 @09:21PM (#18513928)
My ideal laptop would be a 2015 Macbook Pro with Thinkpad keyboard (the older one before Lenovo moved all the keys around) and trackpoint. Preferably without the trackpad at all like was an option on older Thinkpads. On my last Thinkpad you could customise the trackpad to activate differently and do entirely different things to the trackpoint. Useful for a select few apps. I ultimately disabled the trackpad as I didn't use those few often enough.

Middle click scroll whilst still typing, as your fingers stay on the home keys. Precision and acceleration that's leagues ahead of every trackpad, including Apple, and faster than moving hand to a mouse. OK, I know quite a few seem to struggle with a trackpoint when first using by using actions that worked on their trackpad and other oddities. It's so long ago I forget my first encounters and learning curve.

I carry a small mouse around with the Macbook. When I have used Thinkpads I never carried a mouse and often didn't use the mouse at my desk either.

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by scottlocklin on Friday November 23, 2018 @01:13AM (#18514701)
Mine would be a new X220 form factor thinkpad with modern battery tech and... any linux OS. It's OK though; I've got enough X220s and batteries to last me the rest of my career.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by tokai on Friday November 23, 2018 @09:52AM (#18516709)
And a better screen. The X220 is really let down by that horrible panel.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by scottlocklin on Friday November 23, 2018 @12:25PM (#18517734)
The TFT isn't totally horrible, but there aren't enough of them.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by philwelch on Thursday November 22, 2018 @07:46PM (#18513588)
I've never developed the muscle memory to be effective with the trackpoint, but it does have the distinct advantage of being usable without taking your hands off the keyboard.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by binomialxenon on Thursday November 22, 2018 @09:02PM (#18513861)
I can use it without moving my hands away from home-row position, I can drag-n-drop much more easily than a trackpad, middle-clicking and right-clicking are both more consistent, and I can scroll indefinitely in any direction without picking up my hands.

This is probably just me, but when using my laptop on my lap, if I were using the trackpad i would have to bring my hands down closer to my body which is less comfortable, or move my laptop further away from me.

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by akarambir on Friday November 23, 2018 @12:29AM (#18514561)
Can you provide some info into how you typically use trackpoint. Which fingers do you use and how do you control the acceleration when going few pixels away or whole screen corner to corner. What about the clicks.

I have a thinkpad and am always curious on how to effectively use it. Even a video of someone using it might help.

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by NeedMoreTea on Friday November 23, 2018 @12:39AM (#18514583)
This will be hard to describe. I'll try.

Treat it as a tiny proportional joystick, which it is. I use index finger of dominant hand. Press hard and it'll fly the cursor across the screen. Press gently and it'll give excellent precision. If you keep overshooting, you haven't adjusted to gently enough. It is less movement and more thought for pixel perfect precision as you can barely feel any feedback but still get movement.

I always have to turn up acceleration, but rarely sensitivity, in Trackpoint settings a notch or two for my own preference. For me, if I turn sensitivity down, it ruins it. YMMV.

I will left, right and middle click with thumbs as they're just below space and land there naturally.

Thumb on middle and drag to scroll at pressure sensitive speed for as long as you press. No need to "reset" when you reach the end of trackpad or finger on scrollwheel. Two thumbs and index finger means select and paste are almost as fast as vi-only approaches, as it's placed so you're essentially still typing. :)

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by kannanvijayan on Friday November 23, 2018 @09:19AM (#18516523)
I realize the original poster responded, but I am currently in the process of going through this transition and my experience may be of use to you.

The thinkpad was the latest machine I got, after a string of macbooks and one XPS-15. I made a concerted effort to switch simply because I'm spoiled on OSX trackpads, and the thinkpad trackpad widget just isn't up to par (especially on ThinkPad + Linux). I asked a few colleagues how they got around the trackpad issue and a couple mentioned they just use the nipple cursor.

It's been a few months now. Changing over was really annoying at first. As the other poster mentioned - the key is learning muscle memory for _sensitivity_ to control the speed of the cursor. A light firm touch with a small pressure in the correct direction is all that's necessary for moderate speed.

I use my left index finger to control the cursor, and my left (spacebar) thumb to at the same time to click/drag/etc (as the mouse buttons are right below the spacebar).

Middle-click + drag-down for scrolling is really convenient.

I find myself having just crossed that midway point where the new system is becoming dominant. The trackpads are starting to feel somewhat unwieldy and cumbersome to me now - even the macbook ones when I use my wife's or friends'. It feels like they require too much hand movement, and are far more "gesticulatory" than gentle pushes and pulls on the nipple cursor.

I think I'm faster with the cursor now than with even high-quality trackpads.

If you do end up trying it out, be prepared to tweak settings a bit to get the right ones for you (and as the other replier mentioned - don't skimp on sensitivity), and be prepared to spend a couple weeks feeling like your hands are tied when you want to move the cursor around.

It gets better after that.

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by NeedMoreTea on Friday November 23, 2018 @06:15PM (#18519450)
Interesting to read as I first used one so long ago most of the learning curve is lost to the mist of time.

> It feels like they require too much hand movement, and are far more "gesticulatory" than gentle pushes

Well put. This encapsulates it well.

> I think I'm faster with the cursor now

When I'd got the hang of never overshooting and changing pressure to vary acceleration as I move around, trackpads, even Apple's, just start to feel cumbersome. Quite apart from the need to move hand away from the keyboard so you can't press keys at the same time. It's the thing I miss most on my Mac.

Oh, and just to address the parent's comment that a video might help. Probably not, as there's not much movement to see. Press an index finger on a desk or table and roll your finger around the pad - that's the extremes of movement you should expect with a trackpoint, assuming your finger didn't move on the table at all. :)

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by binomialxenon on Saturday November 24, 2018 @02:01AM (#18520872)
I'm left handed, I use my left index finger to manipulate the trackpoint, and my left thumb for any of the three mouse buttons. Clicking the middle button is a middle click, and holding the middle button makes the trackpoint movements act as scrolling.

My laptop is a T450s, running Debian and KDE Plasma. Acceleration is set to medium, and "Adaptive". The key is tuning your sensitivity/accelaration so you can make very fine/slow movements, but also move the cursor all the way across the screen with stronger/faster ones.

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by wink on Friday November 23, 2018 @09:06AM (#18516450)
See, it's never been clear to me how anyone would willingly work with a touchpad. My first laptop had one and I used with a mouse whenever I could, even in uni lecture halls where there wasn't really much space.

Only when I got my first thinkpad I could finally work without a mouse and haven't looked back since.

And yes, the mac ones are a bit better than the others, but I still don't like them. At all.

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by Lio on Friday November 23, 2018 @09:22AM (#18516542)
I'd have give a trackpoint on the HP Elitebook I was given to work with by one customer if only there was a way to scroll with it.

Not sure if that's possible on a Thinkpad but there was no obvious way on the HP running Ubuntu to do the equivalent of two finger touchpad scrolling.

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by umichguy on Friday November 23, 2018 @01:42PM (#18518157)
I dunno. Most of the windows laptops I've used all had mediocre touchpads, so if I was going to do some serious amount of work on them, always used the mouse. But for my MBPs, the thought never even occurs to me, the touchpad does the job quite well.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by camgunz on Sunday November 25, 2018 @10:16AM (#18527189)
I'm a big thinkpad fan, and I prefer the trackpoint to trackpads. You never have to move your hands out of position, and the benefit of that is hard to communicate to someone who is used to trackpads. You can also have better form factors, better keyboards, etc, because you don't need to leave a big chunk of space free for the trackpad.

FWIW I'm ok with trackpads too; I'm an engineer and all my jobs have given me an MBP for work. But like, I'm never pinching and zooming, keyboard shortcuts work just fine for paging and back/forward. Love I know gestures have been successful because keyboard shortcuts aren't intuitive, but to someone like me who uses them, gestures just seem like gimmicks for which we sacrifice smaller laptops and bigger keyboards.

Also FWIW I dislike naming things after genitals. I find it crude and vaguely misogynistic in this case, and wish people would stop.

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by virmundi on Friday November 23, 2018 @10:20AM (#18516879)
Put the mouse pad at the top of the keyboard, not under your hands. For most people you only need a 1"x2" pad. Maybe have two for lefties. It makes more ergonomic sense. If you need more than that, you're probably better off with an external mouse.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by eptcyka on Thursday November 22, 2018 @09:08PM (#18513875)
It's more precise when operated without moving hands away from the keyboard. I can almost play dota or FPS games to the same degree I can with a mouse with the clitmouse, such things can't really be said about the trackpad. There are also 3 distinct buttons which I find handy - I don't recall exactly how trackpads solved the right mouse click or middle click issues - so whilst I miss out on the gestures, I find I can do about the same things with keyboard shortcuts or extra buttons on the mouse (scrolling with the middle click and moving the cursor).

However, extended use does induce tension in my wrist - hence I prefer not to play games on a laptop. The first thing I do when I get a new laptop with a trackpoint and a trackpad is disable the trackpad. If the glorious fruit company offered laptops with trackpoints, I'd do the same. I don't believe that a trackpoint is better than a trackpad in every conceivable way, but it does fit my way of using my devices far better than trackpads do. However, I also don't believe that there will ever be a trackpoint on a glorious fruit device - they don't allow for multiple ways of doing the same thing, and I'm very aware that most people do prefer trackpads to trackpoints. I just hope that my niche will be served by someone until I no longer want to use laptops.

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by tom_ on Thursday November 22, 2018 @09:02PM (#18513859)
I believe the more usual term is 'trackpoint'.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by saagarjha on Thursday November 22, 2018 @08:31PM (#18513747)
The only computer Apple sells with 128 GB of RAM is the iMac Pro. There's no way they will sell a laptop with that much in the foreseeable future.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by accnumnplus1 on Friday November 23, 2018 @09:24AM (#18516553)
When did we start calling it a clitoris?
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by idontpost on Friday November 23, 2018 @02:56PM (#18518547)
Twenty five years ago, when they first came out.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by 4ad on Friday November 23, 2018 @09:36AM (#18516616)
It always was either a clitoris or a nipple.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by jsjohnst on Friday November 23, 2018 @08:12AM (#18516178)
> RAM up to 128GB or more

Do you know how much physical space that would take? I highly doubt you’ll see it any time soon.

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by detaro on Friday November 23, 2018 @08:19AM (#18516210)
Right now you need 4 SO-DIMMs: 32 GB each. you can get that already in Lenovo's P72. That is a 17" workstation laptop though, so it has more room available than others, but it's not totally crazy, especially if a vendor used a different format instead of bothering with DIMMs. I don't think Apple's gonna do that anytime soon though, it's too niche for what they do.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by Tuna-Fish on Friday November 23, 2018 @09:57AM (#18516739)
Hynix has a 32Gb LPDDR4 chip on their catalog, listed as "in production". If a laptop was LPDDR4 compatible, you could fit 128GB in two double-sided SODIMMs.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by philjohn on Friday November 23, 2018 @04:52PM (#18519106)
128GB of RAM and long battery life are mutually exclusive.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by jsjohnst on Sunday November 25, 2018 @10:43PM (#18530877)
Except Intel doesn’t support LPDDR4 ram on most CPUs they ship currently.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by Jmcdd on Friday November 23, 2018 @02:36AM (#18514972)
How long have you had it for? I'd be willing to go back to the new models (having returned my 2017) if they truly fix the keyboard issue
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by oarsinsync on Friday November 23, 2018 @05:49AM (#18515686)
> 2018 pros: Trackpad is not mechanical

My 2015 MBP has a force-touch trackpad. Is the 2018 one substantially different from that?

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by Ndymium on Friday November 23, 2018 @07:08AM (#18515943)
It's the same, just a lot bigger.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by brian-armstrong on Thursday November 22, 2018 @01:52PM (#18511773)
Well, there's no way that's going to happen. I'd put more money on them replacing all the mechanical keys with capactive touch and removing the headphone jack.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by forgot-my-pw on Thursday November 22, 2018 @02:31PM (#18512000)
I'm considering getting a Dell XPS or Lenovo Ideapad instead and install macos (hackintosh laptop).
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by baroffoos on Thursday November 22, 2018 @10:32PM (#18514159)
I got a dell XPS 13 this week for work and its absolutely insane. Best laptop I have ever had and I have had macbooks. I'm running Fedora 29 on it and it works perfect. The battery life is amazing, I'm seeing about 10+ hours while running Gnome and a bunch of dev tools. Made sure to pick one without a nvidia GPU. The only thing I can fault it for is you can't open the hinge with one hand.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by Lio on Friday November 23, 2018 @09:29AM (#18516586)
I have an XPS 13 with Linux too. One thing I notice that's not mentioned very much about battery life is how hybrid sleep works.

On macOS closing the lid is suspends to sleep i.e. it keeps RAM powered only. On Fedora 29 (and every other Linux I've tried) it's the same.

The difference is that after some set amount of time macOS is smart enough to stop powering the RAM and suspend to SSD. That's not the case under Linux and instead the laptop just goes completely flat.

Anyone with any suggestions on that I'd love to hear it.

(I should add that I see the XPS 13 as a competitor to the old MacBook Air 11 but with a quad-core CPU and a bigger screen).

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by Tharre on Sunday November 25, 2018 @05:04AM (#18526239)
This feature exists under linux as well, it's called `suspend-then-hibernate`. See [0] for more details.

[0] https://jlk.fjfi.cvut.cz/arch/manpages/man/systemd-sleep.con...

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by Lio on Wednesday November 28, 2018 @04:09AM (#18550217)
Yes! Thank you. It's not working out of the box for me on Fedora but I've decided to play with an Arch install anyway so hopefully should be able to get this working.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by Tepix on Friday November 23, 2018 @08:56AM (#18516402)
Personally I like the 2017 model (9360) better than the 2018 model (9370).

The 2018 model notebook is thinner but it suffers from problems as a result of this: No USB A port. The SD card slot was replaced by a Micro SD card slot. CPU heat management is also an issue. Finally, it has a smaller battery (52Wh instead of 60Wh, 13% less!). The display went from 3200x1800 to 4K which doesn't really make sense for a 13inch display anyway.

See https://www.notebookcheck.com/Editorial-Dell-XPS-13-9370-Sex... for details (German)

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by Lio on Friday November 23, 2018 @09:32AM (#18516597)
Also the keyboard layout on your older 9360 is better than on my 9370. On the 9370 they've split the left and right arrow keys to do PgUp and PgDown.

Personally, I find that difficult to touch type with. I'd rather have that as fn keys as it is on a mac.

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by baroffoos on Sunday November 25, 2018 @07:52PM (#18530138)
I got the 9360. It seems they updated it to have a 2018 version. I guess for the people who don't want to go all usb C. The specs seemed to be way better for the price as well.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by bacon_waffle on Thursday November 22, 2018 @09:58PM (#18514036)
I made the MacBook Pro (mid-2011) to XPS (15" i7 9570 4K) switch a few months ago, after putting off an upgrade about as long as possible. I'm still not liking the XPS with Kubuntu 18.04 - to the extent that I'm seriously considering switching back to Apple. At this point, I've got all the major issues sorted (like, not going to sleep when closed, docking station weirdness, etc), but there are constant smaller issues with the sort of things that "just work" with Apple hardware and MacOS.

Hardware wise - it's most of the way to being a great laptop, but has a few aspects that seem "designed by committee". The 4K screen looks really nice, keyboard is pretty good, it's quite fast, battery life is good. But, the trackpad is massively irritating - it's constantly picking up the heel of my hands while typing and causing the cursor to jump and click. The webcam is terribly located, the TB16 dock is a piece of junk, speakers only sound OK if you're working on a hard surface. They still use a barrel connector for power - would've preferred to get power over USB-C (which the dock uses to provide power), and have a second USB-C port on the laptop.

There are several issues with Linux support - if you're successful making an XPS Hackintosh, then those won't be a problem, but I'd encourage getting the lower resolution screen if you're considering the Linux route.

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by StreamBright on Friday November 23, 2018 @03:06AM (#18515066)
Linux won't be a good choice for desktop os on a laptop for a long time. It is not a priority for any vendor to fix issues and the community won't support 10.000 different hardware effectively. Hackintosh is an interesting option. I am wondering if you can run it on XPS properly.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by bacon_waffle on Friday November 23, 2018 @03:37AM (#18515186)
For most of the last 15 or so years, I've been running Linux on the desktop on a work or personal computer, actually, and wouldn't say it has always been a bad choice.

Some hardware + distro combinations have certainly made that easier than others, but the general trend has been towards a good experience. Certainly there's been less headache with the average Linux desktop, than some Windows (plus whatever Antivirus that the IT higher-ups have mandated) machines I've had...

This particular laptop though, has highlighted the poor Linux support for "DPI Scaling" (a 15" 4K screen was the only option at the time), and touch screens. Combined with some questionable hardware design decisions (webcam, speakers), and some generally crap design (the TB16 dock) though, this whole package just isn't a purchase that I'm really happy about - and that's only partially about Linux. The touchpad might well be the sort of issue you describe, where a better driver could better adjust the sensitivity, but even there I'd look first at the vendor before blaming "the community".

It's a shame really, because as these MacBook Pro threads attest, there are a lot of folks looking for something that's totally feasible, but no manufacturer seems to be aiming at...

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by funkydata on Friday November 23, 2018 @05:43AM (#18515664)
Why don't you just use Windows with the included Ubuntu subsystem?

https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/wsl/install-win10

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by eptcyka on Friday November 23, 2018 @01:05PM (#18517969)
Because the I/O performance sucks, there's an AV process that goes haywire whenever anything is compiled, the terminals suck, I've not found a non-bad way of SSH'ing into WSL remotely, it's about as clunky as using Wine on Linux some years ago, there's spyware and ads on the enterprise install of Windows 10, software I can't remove by using the tools to remove all other software (installers for Office and the like), but above all, when I'm running the NT kernel, it's mostly to run software that only runs on the NT kernel. I've not run NT on bare metal in a while, but looking at the struggles of people around me, I don't intend to in the near or long term.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by watersb on Friday November 23, 2018 @07:57PM (#18519795)
Have you tried to use WSL?

It is its own silo on Windows. Yes, it is native from an implementation standpoint, but does not play well (yet) with the rest of the Windows environment.

Install Visual Studio Code, the usual Windows version.

Explain to VS Code that it is really a good idea to use the Linux subsystem as its command-line environment. Not only interactive sessions like Bash on its integrated terminal, but also for git, compilers, Node, etc.

Once you have got that set up and your development workflow going ok, try setting up the same on Linux or macOS.

Which one would you prefer?

The Windows Subsystem for Linux is brilliant. PowerShell is brilliant. The dotNET universe can be brilliant.

I wish it was easy.

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by Tepix on Friday November 23, 2018 @08:49AM (#18516375)
Are you talking out of experience? I've used a linux laptop for the last 6 years and have had only small issues.

Hackintoshes tend to break (more specifically, the OS) with every OS update.

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by kklimonda on Friday November 23, 2018 @09:19AM (#18516518)
I've switched from Linux (Thinkpad X240) to macOS (Macbook Pro 2015, and now 2018) because of those small issues [1]. However, nowadays I feel like your experience with Linux laptop really depends on what kind of work you are doing, and how often do you have to interact with 3rd party tools. I've been primarily desktop Linux user for something like 13 years before switching to Mac, and those small issues had only become a problem once I've started encountering them on a daily basis.

[1] For me issues were mostly interaction with random conference software and screen sharing (e.g. webex), or random hangs when connecting external displays (e.g. doing a presentation before CTO).

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by j88439h84 on Saturday November 24, 2018 @06:18PM (#18524462)
FWIW I've found the Dell xps 13 with ubuntu very pleasant
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by StreamBright on Saturday November 24, 2018 @07:20AM (#18521703)
I am not sure how it is relevant to the subject that you can use a Linux desktop.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by handzbagz on Friday November 23, 2018 @06:30AM (#18515830)
If you're worrying about the long term use of Linux on a Dell or Lenovo machine you are going to hate trying to run Mac OS on it.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by chainwax on Thursday November 22, 2018 @09:00PM (#18513845)
At that point why not just run Ubuntu? Unless you're REALLY deep in the Apple ecosystem, moving from MacOS to Ubuntu or Mint is really easy.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by forgot-my-pw on Friday November 23, 2018 @05:45PM (#18519331)
Keeping it more consistent with work setup.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by ENGNR on Thursday November 22, 2018 @04:33PM (#18512721)
I had a Dell XPS 9530 and the support was an absolute disaster. The techs had no idea (all local contractors I’d imagine), they fried the power, WiFi and incorrectly applied the thermal paste so it never worked properly

After just one year I tried to get more support and they said I’d have to send it in for three weeks which was impossible, I was using it every day. Onsite support was only for the first year, whereas apple stores you can just walk into

Finally the warranty ended and I decided to fix the damn thing myself. Was extremely careful and it was perfect for about a week, then the power somehow failed and it now refuses to turn on. Windows is also horrible for coding due to heavy file system use, fat threads and windows defender, let alone the constant privacy invasion. Was planning to install Ubuntu but figured if I ever did send it in it would just confuse them all the more

I finally got an MBP 2015, should have done it from the beginning.

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by Tepix on Friday November 23, 2018 @09:01AM (#18516426)
I had only one issue with my XPS 13 9350 so far - at one point the battery died and I had to send it in. It got replaced quickly and since then it's been fine.

One thing I love about the Dell vs the Macbook I had previously is that I can just download a service manual from https://www.dell.com/support/manuals/de/de/debsdt1/xps-13-93... if I want to service it myself.

Apple on the other hand will disable your computer if they detect that an unauthorized 3rd party has serviced it (if you bought a recent one with a T2 chip).

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by jmkni on Friday November 23, 2018 @02:55AM (#18515029)
Weird, I have the 9550 and had the opposite support experience. It did have a couple of issues, but each time Dell had a guy out at my house the following day with replacement parts, no charge, no questions asked.

I purchased the extended support once the warranty expires, so have another 2 or so years left on that.

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by nickthemagicman on Thursday November 22, 2018 @07:52PM (#18513611)
Yeah I agree. I have an XPS and it's cool but despite the MacBooks faults I still enjoy using it over the XPS.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by philliphaydon on Thursday November 22, 2018 @07:47PM (#18513591)
I was agreeing with your post until you went off on your windows rant of fud.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by binomialxenon on Thursday November 22, 2018 @09:03PM (#18513866)
Ideapads are generally pretty garbage, aren't they? In my limited experience they range from terrible to middling.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by chupasaurus on Friday November 23, 2018 @02:43AM (#18514996)
I have Y500, trackpad is useless, keyboard was OK. But it's more like a mobile WS, with power usage of 110W and 3 hours on battery (:
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by will_pseudonym on Thursday November 22, 2018 @09:10PM (#18513885)
Don't give them any more ideas!
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by eksemplar on Thursday November 22, 2018 @01:42PM (#18511710)
I upgraded from a late 2015 to a 2018 earlier this fall.

I don’t really miss anything, especially not the weight or the keyboard.

The touchbar has never been of use to me though. It doesn’t annoy me much, but the user design for changing volume requires more clicks than the non touchbar, so it’s obviously terrible design.

I don’t miss any of the ports, I thought I would, but it’s not like there was an Ethernet port so I still needed a dongle for the 2015 version.

There’s certainly room for improvement, but the 512gb 13” version isn’t crazy expensive for what you’re getting compared to other laptops, at least not in my country.

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by nicolashahn on Thursday November 22, 2018 @01:52PM (#18511772)
The keyboard is the part I dislike the most on the 2017, although I heard they made it better on the 2018. Loud, no travel, requires more force to actuate, more difficult to touch type reliably because I can barely feel the edges of the keys.

I definitely hate the touchbar, for the same reason. I just want the buttons I need to be there when I need them. Changing volume or screen brightness just takes that much longer and I have no tactile feedback, so I actually have to look at the keyboard instead of relying on muscle memory.

I mostly don't care about the ports, but I'd still rather not have to use dongles if I don't have to. Would it have been that hard to add one or two USB 3.0 ports? No, but then how would they sell $80 dongles?

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by eksemplar on Thursday November 22, 2018 @02:27PM (#18511976)
I think the keyboard is down to preference, I prefer the new one.

It does seem silly not to include a dongle in the box though. I mean, I’m buying apple because I want my tech to just work, and now my mouse or magic keyboard can’t connect and charge?

The only real port annoyance I have though, is the damn headphone jack. :p I mean, I can’t connect my iPhone XS headphones to my MacBook Pro...

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by saagarjha on Thursday November 22, 2018 @08:36PM (#18513764)
I'm not saying that a USB adapter wouldn't be useful, but for your specific use case (which is pretty rare: using an external keyboard and mouse with your laptop) you shouldn't need an adapter at all. You should be able to connect to both through Bluetooth.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by huehehue on Thursday November 22, 2018 @10:00PM (#18514040)
> You should be able to connect to both through Bluetooth.

Did I miss the news about charging devices over bluetooth?

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by saagarjha on Thursday November 22, 2018 @10:29PM (#18514147)
You don't need to charge your keyboard and mouse from your computer; I'm assuming you have a USB-A power brick from your phone, tablet, etc. already that you can use to charge your stuff.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by snovv_crash on Friday November 23, 2018 @04:45AM (#18515447)
So, yet another device to carry around that used to be part of the functionality of a laptop.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by ubernostrum on Friday November 23, 2018 @08:07AM (#18516155)
If you were already carrying a 15" laptop plus full-size external keyboard plus mouse plus power brick for the laptop, a dongle is not much of a burden to add on. And many people who did that with USB-A machines tended to carry other accessories as well and end up with an external USB hub in the bag too.

I have a keyboard and mouse at my desk. I plug them into my laptop when I'm working at my desk. I don't carry them with me at all times, though, and I don't know many people who've ever done that.

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by saagarjha on Friday November 23, 2018 @04:58AM (#18515507)
No, not really, since you'd have to carry around a USB to Lightning charging cable even if your laptop had a standard USB-A port.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by breuleux on Thursday November 22, 2018 @09:11PM (#18513887)
I installed BetterTouchTool on mine, and you can configure an action to run when sliding anywhere on the touchbar with 2, 3 or 4 fingers. I set 2 fingers to volume control and 4 fingers to brightness and that works pretty well, no need to look. I also make it display the time and battery percentage at all times, which is nice to have when an app is running full screen. BTT isn't free, but it's pretty cheap, worth it IMO.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by intopieces on Saturday November 24, 2018 @05:13PM (#18524240)
BTT is so useful it ought to be bought by Apple and incorporated in the OS. Throw in the top 20 used presets as checkboxes and be done with it. It's the first thing I install when I set up a Mac.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by dillondoyle on Thursday November 22, 2018 @08:12PM (#18513682)
I actually made the same comment about the volume touch bar when it came out... Another hidden Apple os interaction: if you have it set to slider you can just hit it and move your finger without lifting even if not 'hover' the slide area. Or you can change to the old mute, quite, loud buttons in settings
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by woolvalley on Thursday November 22, 2018 @03:47PM (#18512446)
I'm fine with using the keyboard. I'm not fine how the keyboard fails all the time still and how unrepairable it is for an easy to break part.

Apple is moving more and more away from acura into mercedes car territory.

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by spullara on Thursday November 22, 2018 @02:52PM (#18512119)
You touch and drag to change volume. Not sure how that could possibly be more clicks?
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by dylan604 on Thursday November 22, 2018 @03:25PM (#18512301)
Depends on which OS you have. The touch bar behaves differently in Mojave than it did in Sierra. The mode I used in Sierra is no longer available in the Mojave, and I've had to re-learn the touch bar. First thing up, remove the damned Siri button so I don't accidentally hit it when reaching for the delete button.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by jonathankoren on Thursday November 22, 2018 @03:42PM (#18512420)
Has anyone used Siri on the desktop? I tried once to set a timer with it, and it said it couldn’t. WTF Siri? You have a clock.

And then I never used it again.

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by jamie_ca on Thursday November 22, 2018 @04:55PM (#18512816)
I _can't_. "Hey Siri" picks up faster on my phone, and when the mac hears the acknowledgement chirp it shuts that down.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by lostgame on Thursday November 22, 2018 @08:50PM (#18513817)
Ha! Did they seriously not come across this in testing? Blows my mind.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by dwaite on Thursday November 22, 2018 @11:07PM (#18514285)
I'm not sure what you mean; Siri only activating on a single device at a time is absolutely a core design goal.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by jonathankoren on Friday November 23, 2018 @03:08PM (#18518615)
You can always click the circle I’m the upper right.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by spullara on Friday November 23, 2018 @02:21PM (#18518369)
You can just edit the buttons on the Touch Bar if you don't want Siri on it. Also, I don't see any change in behavior with the Touch Bar in Mojave. Touch drag works on both brightness and volume just like before.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by coin on Thursday November 22, 2018 @11:08PM (#18514287)
I often want 1 or 2 increments more volume. With real keys I just tap up volume once or twice. With touch bar I have to carefully slide it one or two volume units.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by simonbarker87 on Thursday November 22, 2018 @01:48PM (#18511747)
Tap hold and slide for volume and brightness. It’s faster than the old keys.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by eksemplar on Thursday November 22, 2018 @02:23PM (#18511947)
It’s terrible compared to the old way.

You click the sound icon, then the slide opens up, then you can either slide it or click one of the two icons.

It’s probably quicker to change the volume from one to ten this way, but 99% of my use cases for changing volume is for one or two steps, for which the slider absolutely sucks.

It’s some of the worst design I’ve ever seen for volume control, and the old system is some of the best.

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by askafriend on Thursday November 22, 2018 @03:04PM (#18512183)
I don't think you're quite understanding the trick the parent comment is trying to tell you.

You press your finger on the sound icon, and just start sliding without waiting. It's one fluid gestural motion. Try it out. It takes the same effort as tapping a physical button but gives you more fine grained control. Yes, it's something new and different from the way you're used to, but give it a chance.

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by lostgame on Thursday November 22, 2018 @08:51PM (#18513820)
Sliding still does not a simple tap, with tactile feedback, equate.

I'm aware I can do this. It still drives me nuts - and I have to agree with eksemplar when I think it is simply a serious step backwards in design and should be an option, not forced like the 2018 models.

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by bluedino on Thursday November 22, 2018 @10:24PM (#18514123)
The lack of tactile feedback is huge.

Take a MacBook with the function keys, and one with the touchbar. Then adjust the brightness or volume on both at the same time and the hand that operates the touchbar gets “lost” so easily

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by coin on Thursday November 22, 2018 @11:09PM (#18514296)
Still more work than quickly tapping once or twice. With the slider I have to carefully slide to get the exact amount, all without any tactical feedback.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by 4ad on Friday November 23, 2018 @09:39AM (#18516631)
Tactile feedback? What for? You have visual and audio feedback. After all, you are trying to set volume or brightness to a specific level...
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by efrafa on Thursday November 22, 2018 @02:40PM (#18512064)
You can just tap and slide at once. (Without releasing your finger) Its actually faster than with old buttons.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by eksemplar on Thursday November 22, 2018 @02:56PM (#18512151)
How is tapping and sliding easier than pressing a button once?
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by saagarjha on Thursday November 22, 2018 @08:38PM (#18513775)
You don't need to lift your finger, which takes time. Just shift your finger left/right a little bit.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by eksemplar on Friday November 23, 2018 @12:42AM (#18514597)
But that’s not faster.

The old way: click, you’re done. The new way: click, hold finger, slide, and you’re done.

Like I said, it’s faster to go from 1 to 10, but 99% of the times I use it, I’m just changing the volume by 1.

Hell, it’s easier for my brain to just click 10 times than to watch where the damn slider is too.

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by saagarjha on Friday November 23, 2018 @04:35AM (#18515401)
Ah, you're comparing it to the old hardware keys. I see your point.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by yakshaving_jgt on Thursday November 22, 2018 @03:47PM (#18512447)
Anything is possible in the Reality Distortion Field.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by jpb0104 on Friday November 23, 2018 @07:13PM (#18519631)
Another alternative is to simply flick the touch bar button.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by kayoone on Thursday November 22, 2018 @02:52PM (#18512122)
you don't need to click and wait though, just tap and without lifting your finger immediately slide to adjust. If anything it's a super minor annoyance imo.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by _asummers on Thursday November 22, 2018 @02:25PM (#18511959)
That interaction is not at all obvious. I've used the 2017 since they came out and have been tapping then lifting my finger every time to drag the slider.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by danieldk on Thursday November 22, 2018 @02:20PM (#18511929)
My personal computer is a 2015 and my work is a 2017, and there are zero features from the 2017 that I prefer.

4k@60Hz. The MacBook Pro 2015 with Intel Iris (I don't know about the Radeon GPU) only supports 4k@30Hz, which is terrible.

(My wife has the 1st gen MacBook 12", which has the same downside.)

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by ianhowson on Thursday November 22, 2018 @02:37PM (#18512035)
> only supports 4k@30Hz, which is terrible

Are you using the HDMI port? I'm using a 2015 with Iris and can run 4k@60Hz through the mini-DP.

https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT206587 shows that both 13" and 15" from 2015 should support 4k@60Hz.

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by subraizada3 on Thursday November 22, 2018 @02:38PM (#18512044)
I recently bought a used 2013 MBP; while Apple specs say it can only do 4k@30, the DisplayPort output is in fact capable of 4k@60.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by yhoiseth on Friday November 23, 2018 @12:12PM (#18517637)
Do you have to tweak anything to achieve this?
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by subraizada3 on Friday November 23, 2018 @01:56PM (#18518229)
No, it worked out of the box on the 15" model.

The GPU must have a HDMI 2.0 output for 4k@60, and this is usually not present on all but the most recent laptops, producing the 30 Hz limitation.

On the other hand, DisplayPort 1.2 supports 4k@60. This is built into the Thunderbolt 2 ports on Macs, so as long as the GPU supports DP 1.2 it will work.

On my MBP (15"), the DP(Thunderbolt) + HDMI ports are wired directly to the Nvidia GPU. Parent mentioned his computer only had the Intel Iris graphics (13" model), which apparently can't do 4k@60 (so my previous comment was incorrect :( ).

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by tobyhinloopen on Friday November 23, 2018 @05:09AM (#18515550)
All 2015 macbook pros (13", 15", with or without dedicated gpu) support 1 or 2 4K 60Hz displays on using a displayport 1.2 compatible monitor
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by Rebelgecko on Friday November 23, 2018 @07:32PM (#18519699)
My 2015 MBP drives two 4k monitors at 60hz just fine. Well, not just fine— sometimes it randomly forgets which monitor is which. But the GPU is powerful enough.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by nik736 on Thursday November 22, 2018 @02:29PM (#18511991)
My 2017 13-inch nTB MBP is running 4k@60Hz just fine.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by lurker82 on Thursday November 22, 2018 @07:58PM (#18513633)
there is a patch you can apply to some kexts to get around this and support 4k@60hz
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by saagarjha on Thursday November 22, 2018 @08:32PM (#18513757)
I was under the impression that this was a bandwidth issue for the HDMI port, so I'm curious to see how a kernel extension would get around this issue.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by lurker82 on Friday November 23, 2018 @02:04AM (#18514880)
https://github.com/Floris497/mac-pixel-clock-patch-V2

I came across this while looking to see if I could buy a 4k display for my 12" Macbook (2nd gen.). My brief reading of it implied that it would be possible to drive it at 60hz. but maybe you are correct.

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by saagarjha on Friday November 23, 2018 @04:36AM (#18515403)
Looks like it might require an extra graphics card, or something like that? I haven't looked into it in detail, but it doesn't look like this thing works on a MacBook.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by bluedino on Friday November 23, 2018 @08:47AM (#18516361)
LG 4K over usb-c

They are really cheap used or refurb

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by dougdonohoe on Thursday November 22, 2018 @11:15PM (#18514313)
I have an early 2009 17" mac book pro - still the best one out there. Running great (now on an SSD), although stuck at El Capitan. On 2nd display and 3rd battery, but still humming along. Wish they'd bring back the 17", with tons of ports and no touch bar.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by Tepix on Friday November 23, 2018 @09:03AM (#18516436)
There are patches for the OS if you want to run something more recent.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by tokyodude on Thursday November 22, 2018 @08:17PM (#18513704)
My faith in Apple would be redeemed if they actually lived up to their hype. LG makes 15inch metal cased laptop that weights 2.1 lbs (specs similar to a 15" MBP but weighs less then a Macbook Air). Apple should be able to do the same.

I also recently got a 2018 MBA to try replace my 2014 MBP but unfortunately my eyes suck so 13 inches is turning out to be an issue. It's not enough screen space to do my normal dev without having to be constantly opening and closing panes.

Examples would be trying to us VSCode with 2 panes and the project panel open. The 2 panes are two small so I have to keep opening and closing the project panel anytime I want to switch files.

Another example is trying to debug JavaScript I need both the page and the devtools visible and there just isn't enough screen real estate to do it comfortably.

Jacking up the scaled rez to 1680 mode I get my space back but my eyes aren't good enough to focus at that rez

It is also super notably slower than my 2014 MBP. As an example if I run pretty much any WebGL page and try to view a detailed PDF in another window in the browser it's practically unusable. My 2014 MBP had no issues multi-tasking.

Also connect it to a 30inch 4k monitor at my office and it just doesn't feel up do it. Just switching apps often takes long enough it feels super sluggish.

If Apple would get rid of the touch bar I'd have gotten the MBP again though am really loving the weight so really disappointed Apple can't match or beat LG in that.

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by Patrick_Devine on Friday November 23, 2018 @12:30AM (#18514564)
I accidentally dropped my work 2015 MBP a few months back and broke the screen. Actually, I'm not even certain the screen was dead, but the display wouldn't turn on any more. Unfortunately, work wouldn't let me keep/fix it (which is super annoying), but they did offer me the choice of a new MBP or a slightly loved older 2015 MBP. I chose the latter.

For my home laptop, I'm finally getting around to replacing my mid-2009 MBP and decided to go with a Lenovo X1 Carbon Extreme. I'm so annoyed at Apple at this point that I figure it's time to go back and give Linux another shot.

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by deafcalculus on Friday November 23, 2018 @12:57AM (#18514654)
Linux support on laptops is much more mature than it was 5 years ago. I'd still avoid anything with an nVidia Optimus setup, but Intel graphics has had decent drivers on Linux for a long time now.

I was a little worried about hardware support, so I bought a Dell laptop with Ubuntu pre-installed. Pretty much everything worked out of the box. But my friends tell me that the Linux experience is good with other laptops too.

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by kevinherron on Thursday November 22, 2018 @02:23PM (#18511950)
I prefer everything about my 2018 to the 2012-2015 generation, keyboard included, but I can see how the lack of ports would be a bummer to some people. I hook it up to a dock and LG 5K at work though, so it's not an issue.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by diogenescynic on Thursday November 22, 2018 @08:21PM (#18513721)
They really need to stop gauging for memory upgrades. It’s honestly obscene what they charge to get a bigger hard drive.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by lostgame on Thursday November 22, 2018 @08:38PM (#18513776)
It's more obscene that they negatively impact the environment and artificially limit the lifespan of the devices by soldering the memory and the hard drive.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by yodsanklai on Friday November 23, 2018 @07:46AM (#18516069)
I'm happy with my MBP 2018. I'm neutral to the touch bar, keyboard, big touchpad. I don't see them neither as a nuisance nor a useful innovation. We can argue about details but it's a great machine. I don't see myself switching to a non-apple laptop yet.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by spiderfarmer on Friday November 23, 2018 @07:49AM (#18516083)
Did you 'upgrade' from a 2015 model? I'm asking because I still happily use that model and can't see myself switching just yet.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by jSully24 on Thursday November 22, 2018 @01:37PM (#18511673)
Yes! For our latest round of machines we bought for our team were refurbished 2015 MBPs. A great machine.

(ed: spelling)

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by ryanbertrand on Friday November 23, 2018 @02:59AM (#18515044)
I do enjoy having the TouchID but I can live without everything else on my 2017 MBP.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by shams93 on Thursday November 22, 2018 @02:59PM (#18512160)
This is why I upgraded from a 2010 thinpad to a 2017 macbook air. Sure for a designer this screen might suck but I do music and web development. Turns out having usb A ports built in is very very handy when you can just plug your DJ and midi controllers straight into the laptop instead of diving into dongle hell. It still has the amazing magnetic charger, sure not usb C but its more robust when you're playing a live show compared to a small, potentially easy to break usb c slot when you're playing in a nightclub with poor lighting where its easy for someone to step on your power cable by mistake.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by coder543 on Thursday November 22, 2018 @03:08PM (#18512208)
The display in the 2017 MBA is atrocious, and the processors are really old at this point. USB-C is better than magsafe at this point, because charger interchangeability is amazing, and it doesn't lock into laptops like the old barrel jack connectors. It lets go when needed without damage in my experience. Durability hasn't been a problem on a single USB-C device that I own. Do you not think smartphones get abused more than laptops? Yet the port continues working fine.

Why not just get a decent Windows laptop, if you want nice port selection? The X1 Carbon is incredible, while Dell, Microsoft, and more offer yet other options. If you truly love MagSafe, the Microsoft Surface series offers magnetic charge connectors, good displays, and regular USB.

If you wanted a laptop from 2014, there were plenty of ways to get one without paying Apple their premium price.

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by sokoloff on Thursday November 22, 2018 @03:28PM (#18512316)
It's not just about port durability. USB-C disengages easier than barrel jacks, but it's still often enough to pull the laptop off the desk/table. Magsafe 1&2 let go without moving the laptop much, meaning it's very unlikely to be knocked off.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by coder543 on Thursday November 22, 2018 @04:12PM (#18512599)
If someone is that concerned, Amazon is full of magnetic breakaway adapters for USB-C, bringing MagSafe into the USB-C era. I also mentioned the Surface, which uses a MagSafe-like connector.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by ableal on Friday November 23, 2018 @12:35PM (#18517794)
I had noted those magnetic connectors over at AliExpress, e.g. https://www.aliexpress.com/item/Micro-USB-Magnetic-Cable-Qui...

Any cons to using them like MagSafe?

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by umichguy on Friday November 23, 2018 @01:57PM (#18518234)
Yeah, but they don't really seem to work well at all. A friend of mine who works in IT bought a bunch of these to test for work laptops, according to him they are all basically crap, with maybe one or two half decent. And they don't have the handy charging light indicator either, like on the old magsafe.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by duskwuff on Saturday November 24, 2018 @12:18AM (#18520570)
Sadly, none of them are any good. :( Read the reviews for details.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by kebman on Thursday November 22, 2018 @01:48PM (#18511748)
This. If I could give you more points, I would. Enough said. Also take back the old Final Cut Pro to really compete with Adobe, and some of the quality of life features they used to have, but oversimplified away.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by ed_balls on Thursday November 22, 2018 @01:47PM (#18511745)
Agreed, I want my late 2014 13 inch Macbook Pro with the latest hardware. Also:

- swap the SD port for UBC C (1 regular USB; 2 USB C) - move the microphone from the side next to the camera (when I'm talking to someone a slightest move makes loud noise for the other person) - round the front edge (next to the trackpad) - add 0.5mm "jump" ot the keys

If someone would make that with OS X or Ubuntu I'd buy it on the spot.

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by DonHopkins on Thursday November 22, 2018 @02:59PM (#18512161)
Stuff all that new hardware into an old Lombard case, with two removable battery bays (10 hours of life on a pair, and hot swappable) and great airflow, and I'd be happy as a clam.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PowerBook_G3#PowerBook_G3_Seri...

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by dylan604 on Thursday November 22, 2018 @03:14PM (#18512234)
That was my first laptop. I had a spare battery and the DVD that could be swapped out as well. I even had an Orinoco Gold express card for wifi. Built an antenna from a Pringles can to go war driving with that guy too. Fond memories, but there are not so fond memories of it weighing like 50lbs or something. I know I exaggerate, but the newer models really feel like a feather in comparison.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by bonestamp2 on Thursday November 22, 2018 @09:19PM (#18513917)
I'm 2015 and 2018 and I generally agree... with one exception, the 2018 is a little lighter which I do prefer. But, I'd go back in a heartbeat if that meant I could have the better keyboard and some more universal ports. Yes, I'll use USB-C for a lot of stuff and continue to buy new USB-C devices. But that zero-year transition time was a little short.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by kilroy123 on Friday November 23, 2018 @03:18AM (#18515113)
I could not agree more! I want the glowing apple light on the back, to return though.

FaceID on the Mac would be a cool addition. Lighter would be nice.

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by dmitriid on Friday November 23, 2018 @05:06AM (#18515542)
> Lighter would be nice.

It's already beyond the point of where "lighter would be nice". Now "lighter" only means "we'll take all the capabilities you care about and all the ports you need away".

I wish Apple stopped with their obsession on "lighter and thinner".

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by kalleboo on Friday November 23, 2018 @12:18PM (#18517678)
I wish they differentiated the lines on the priority. Make the "MacBook" line super light (go ahead and introduce a 15" one too). Make the "MacBook Pro" line super performant.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by goodoldneon on Friday November 23, 2018 @09:15AM (#18516488)
It comes down to preference. Personally, I love thinner and lighter. I like using a machine that feels premium.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by tobyhinloopen on Friday November 23, 2018 @05:12AM (#18515560)
Nooo don't make it lighter! I want it heavier! Put more batteries or cooling in it!
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by foobarian on Thursday November 22, 2018 @01:57PM (#18511794)
And and and 64GB of RAM. Or at least 32!
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by spockz on Thursday November 22, 2018 @02:10PM (#18511870)
The 2018 model is upgradable to 32gb.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by hvs on Thursday November 22, 2018 @10:17PM (#18514096)
A few guys at work got the new MBP and I've heard nothing but complaints (and one return due to a defective unit).

My personal MBP circa 2014 is still chugging along wonderfully and will probably continue to do so until Apple comes up with something better.

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by teekert on Friday November 23, 2018 @09:58AM (#18516744)
I have an early 2011 mbp, swapped the hdd for an ssd, got 16 GB of Ram and a new battery and the only thing I'd like is a higher res screen. Other than that the thing is pretty perfect. As a bonus I can still read and burn DVDs.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by viburnum on Thursday November 22, 2018 @01:36PM (#18511666)
I'm using a 2012 retina and it's way better than anything they make now.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by louisswiss on Thursday November 22, 2018 @02:06PM (#18511849)
I had been using a 2016 MBP at work and couldn't take it with me. Booted up my old 2011 MBP non-retina and it was painfully slow. 5min startup and a lot of programs completely unusable.

Took me all of 10min to swap out the HDD for an SSD and 2x2gb RAM for 2x8gb RAM (and cost about $100). Now I don't notice any difference for normal web development/light design work between the new and old machines.

Sure - the 2011 is a lot heavier and the screen is rubbish, but I love that keyboard and the trackpad is perfectly sized for me.

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by your-nanny on Thursday November 22, 2018 @09:56PM (#18514029)
I reaaaally like my 2012 nonretina MBP. except it's heavy and I bike to work
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by rdl on Friday November 23, 2018 @06:13AM (#18515768)
I'd like to keep the TouchID without touchbar, but what I really want is shortpassword+touchid (failing back to longpassword) everywhere they currently only support longpaswordpassword||touchid.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by mossplix on Friday November 23, 2018 @07:05AM (#18515936)
I ditched the 2012 for a lenovo p50 with 8 cores and 32GB of Ram. I am never going back. I don't get the obsession with apple.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by ppeetteerr on Thursday November 22, 2018 @01:52PM (#18511775)
You're not the first to say this but it's never going to happen. Apple is not going back. USB-C, smaller batteries, et al.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by nixpulvis on Thursday November 22, 2018 @01:34PM (#18511645)
Funny how true that is. While they are at it, make the new iPhone the 2019 iPhone and simply put the headphone jack back.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by dylan604 on Thursday November 22, 2018 @03:28PM (#18512319)
While I have not upgraded my 6S Plus because it has the headphone jack, it is hard to make a water tight device when the users keep asking for holes to be put into the case.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by binomialxenon on Thursday November 22, 2018 @09:11PM (#18513886)
Samsung, LG, and others can make phones with both headphone jacks and water resistance, but that's obviously not the real reason that Apple removed it. (The iPad Pro is huge, not water resistant, and doesn't have one either.)
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by arvinsim on Thursday November 22, 2018 @07:22PM (#18513493)
Number of users asking for headphone jack >>> Users asking for waterproof phones.

Besides, it’s not an excuse. Samsung can design a waterproof phone with headphone jack. Why can’t Apple?

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by lostgame on Thursday November 22, 2018 @08:59PM (#18513841)
>> Number of users asking for headphone jack >>> Users asking for waterproof phones.

As much I as a musician, who can't stand the unplayable latency of bluetooth headphones with any of my daily drivers, such as Garageband, and has invested in extremely high-quality headphones with cables, would take the headphone jack over a waterproof phone in a heartbeat; I have to say [citation needed]...

That's a bold statement to make. While I'd prefer a headphone jack, due to my particular use case, most of my friends have or have no problem with using wireless headphones, and many of them have also lost phones or other electronics to even a small amount of water in the wrong place.

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by arvinsim on Friday November 23, 2018 @12:02AM (#18514466)
I went back home 2 weeks ago. My home is not part of the first world bubble that some people live in.

Obviously this just anecdata but let me tell you that wireless headphones/earbuds have not even been a consideration for most people. Heck, even first world countries have lots of people still using wired earbuds for most use cases.

I heard lots of grumbling about the loss of headphone jacks. I never even once heard someone say "this is not waterproof? I won't buy it!"

Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by allenleein on Thursday November 22, 2018 @10:08PM (#18514062)
Totally agree. I upgraded my mid-2014 Macbook Pro with new battery and SM961 SSD. Now I feel like Steve Jobs is back.
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by mikkelam on Friday November 23, 2018 @04:07AM (#18515292)
Was that without the force touch trackpad? gotta say i enjoy that one more than the previous one, otherwise I agree
Re:Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air by funkydata on Friday November 23, 2018 @05:40AM (#18515651)
2010 17 inches Macbook Pro. This machine is a tank. Still using it. Still productive.