News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by bko on Monday June 08, 2026 @03:31PM (#48450427)
Or, hear me out, maybe there's a compute shortage and xAI has compute and manages that well.

There are no dark GPUs. Compute translates directly to money for these frontier labs.

I think everyone is reading way too much into this. Sure there is some circular transactions that are sus, but this ain't it.

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by jklinger410 on Monday June 08, 2026 @03:42PM (#48450654)
> I think everyone is reading way too much into this. Sure there is some circular transactions that are sus, but this ain't it.

Let us pin this comment and see how it ages

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by fragmede on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @03:57AM (#48458028)
Let's say it does all collapse. How would we know it's the 5-6% stake (which in my mind doesn't make them a "major shareholder") that was a circular deal that was the fall of the house of cards vs some other segment?
Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by bastawhiz on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @11:21AM (#48462298)
It doesn't even have to be circular. One company is juicing another company's valuation to make their stake worth more. Down the road they'll sell their stake, end the deal, and leave everyone else holding the bag.

Nothing about this deal is about better technology or talent. It's about an opportunity that's too juicy for Google to pass up on.

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by senordevnyc on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @02:45PM (#48465666)
When has that kind of nuance ever stopped an angry mob with an axe to grind?
Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by oblio on Monday June 08, 2026 @04:14PM (#48451216)
> I think everyone is reading way too much into this. Sure there is some circular transactions that are sus, but this ain't it.

Alphabet/Google profits:

Q1 2025: $34.54 billion

Q2 2025: $28.20 billion

Q3 2025: $34.98 billion

Q4 2025: $34.46 billion

<<Q1 2026: $62.58 billion>>

Amazon profits:

Q1 2025: $17.1 billion

Q2 2025: $18.16 billion

Q3 2025: $21.2 billion

Q4 2025: $21.19 billion

<<Q1 2026: $30.3 billion>>

Both Alphabet/Google and Amazon have invested recently into Anthropic and are doing all sorts of financial chicanery.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-bjNrGFiAI4

Nah, man, it's all fine, they're just going to take down the entire global financial system doing this crap, and by global, I mean <<everyone's>> pensions are going to take a hit, even "fully funded" pension systems.

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by JumpCrisscross on Monday June 08, 2026 @04:19PM (#48451279)
> Both Alphabet/Google and Amazon have invested recently into Anthropic and are doing all sorts of financial chicanery

bko didn’t say there isn’t circular financing going on. They’re just saying this isn’t an example of it. They’re right.

It’s a potential conflict of interest. And if the agreement is fake—if Google cancels without paying the cash—it could be market manipulation. But the influencer space likes to latch onto jargon, and the one it’s overapplying right now is circular financing.

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by oblio on Monday June 08, 2026 @04:47PM (#48451766)
Did I say it was circular financing? I said "financial chicanery". I even included a link to a video explaining said financial chicanery.

What are you even going on about?

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by JumpCrisscross on Monday June 08, 2026 @04:58PM (#48451933)
The comment you’re responding to and the comment above it are about circular financing. It’s reasonably to assume that’s the same chicanery you’re talking about; expecting everyone to watch a random video to understand your comment is unreasonable.
Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by oblio on Monday June 08, 2026 @05:35PM (#48452492)
I listed a bunch of data points that make no sense (profits spiking 50% in a non-Christmas quarter for companies) and weren't directly tied[1] to the circular financing.

[1] They're indirectly tied to it.

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by JumpCrisscross on Monday June 08, 2026 @05:58PM (#48452841)
> that make no sense (profits spiking 50%

They were unrealized gains on non-marketable equities. It’s clearly disclosed and done according to GAAP. It’s put under other income precisely so analysts can strip it out when modelling long-term trends.

Like, yes, if SpaceX goes to zero Google would have to realize losses and probably lose a quarter or two of GAAP profits. (But not cash flows. Cash-flow wise, it may wind up being positive due to tax effects.) It’s a risk factor, of course, but far from making no sense.

None of which is particularly relevant to the deal at hand other than in raising a potential conflict of interest among related parties.

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by oblio on Monday June 08, 2026 @06:23PM (#48453162)
> but far from making no sense.

When I said "it makes no sense", I didn't mean "the accounting math doesn't work out". I meant "raising a potential conflict of interest among related parties".

This whole AI financing this is the motherlode of "potential conflict of interest among related parties".

And people who are obtuse enough to ignore this because it's not illegal right now will discover 5-10 years from now that laws are written in blood (or massive bankruptcies).

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @02:39AM (#48457394)
> whole AI financing this is the motherlode of "potential conflict of interest among related parties"

Sure? Lots of things are potential conflicts. In the Google and Anthropic deals, I'm not seeing evidence of problems.

And that's saying something, because we have a lot of evidence of actual circularity or related-party deals being done with no arms-length anything across AI, in many cases in ways that definitely do see like they are illegal.

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by oblio on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @06:48AM (#48459303)
> Sure? Lots of things are potential conflicts. In the Google and Anthropic deals, I'm not seeing evidence of problems.

And that's where my video comes in. Google and Amazon are very likely juicing up their share price. Of course, in this day and age we can't prove it's a pump and dump anymore...

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by tootie on Monday June 08, 2026 @05:02PM (#48452012)
Compute is presently in shortage but generally it's a commodity. It also depreciates.
Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by JumpCrisscross on Monday June 08, 2026 @05:10PM (#48452128)
> generally it's a commodity

The NVIDIA GPUs, HBM, land-use permits and power-supply agreements xAI nailed down are absolutely not commodities.

I think xAI is a mess. But let’s call a spade a spade, they speculated on AI compute and they are currently right.

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by grogers on Monday June 08, 2026 @07:01PM (#48453627)
My read is that xAI built a lot of compute for their own use, but they didn't get any adoption so they are reselling the unused capacity to recoup at least some of the costs. So calling it a good bet is kind of misleading
Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by mirekrusin on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @01:15AM (#48456754)
"Some" of the cost? More like 120%-200% recovery during shortage and it's still going to be an asset after that period.
Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by fc417fc802 on Monday June 08, 2026 @05:40PM (#48452574)
> and power-supply agreements

Don't you mean gas turbine purchases and questionably legal operation? But yeah I feel exactly the same way. The AI part of xAI looks like a mess but it seems that they still managed to score a massive win.

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by JumpCrisscross on Monday June 08, 2026 @05:54PM (#48452783)
> Don't you mean gas turbine purchases and questionably legal operation?

The point is it’s running. They built fast before the backlash got organized. Now everyone has to deal with delays and thoughtful permitting processes.

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by hn_acc1 on Monday June 08, 2026 @07:47PM (#48454075)
Sure, they brought in artillery and a small freelance militia to shoot at the unionized workers, but the point is, the survivors are back working the mines...
Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by BoorishBears on Monday June 08, 2026 @07:13PM (#48453759)
You're taking an odd tone here.

The "backlash" is the poorest residents one of the poorest large cities in America trying to fight for their right to clean air.

Your point might end "it's running", but wholistic thinkers have no problem considering the how they arrived there, given what it's doing to these folks for marginal benefit.

It's not like xAI would go under if they had chosen a less populated location and waited to get permanent power.

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @02:33AM (#48457343)
> "backlash" is the poorest residents one of the poorest large cities in America trying to fight for their right to clean air

Sorry, I'm referring to the national pushback against datacenters being built in peoples' backyards. xAI didn't face backlash. At least not organised enough to stop them. Their competitors, today, are facing backlash sufficiently powerful to stop new datacenters from being put down.

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by XorNot on Monday June 08, 2026 @07:01PM (#48453631)
The point is they're in a business no one would claim is particularly profitable but claiming a valuation like they're in a totally different business - one where they're not even top 3.

Its not that there isn't value in that business, but it's not the AI business either. Its the one where Oracle is laying off staff to try and avoid a revenue crash on future commitments.

Both Google and Anthropic would be trying to can this sort of rental arrangement as fast as possible since it's a mind bogglingly expensive way to get something you already do in house.

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by fc417fc802 on Monday June 08, 2026 @07:47PM (#48454078)
It isn't normally particularly profitable but given their lucky timing they appear to temporarily be doing quite well. When their tenants eventually vacate either they make a move to reenter the race for the cutting edge and get lucky or else they revert to a "boring" cloud rental business with near cutting edge hardware. That seems like an extremely favorable mode of failure to me.
Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by BoorishBears on Monday June 08, 2026 @06:56PM (#48453584)
This feels highly revisionist: they bet on becoming a frontier lab and were aiming for AGI.

If they were speculating on compute, it seems highly unlikely they'd have spent the operating costs for the last 3 years of model development and deployment instead of just getting even more compute.

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by Earw0rm on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @02:30AM (#48457315)
And while there's no challenging the underlying proposition "AI has value", right now 95% of corporate users are still at the "throw everything at the wall and see what sticks" level in terms of model usage compute.

It's sheer brute force, tons of waste, seems like very little thought going in to fitting the implementation to the problem.

The value of compute can drop significantly in the event of users figuring out how to optimise for their particular need. And yep, there are wasteful applications that can burn whatever compute is available, but how much demand for that is there when it's properly priced?

Extreme example. Generating novel 4K VR video on demand. I'm certain there's a market for it, at $10/hour probably quite a healthy one, at $100/hour not so much.

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by b112 on Monday June 08, 2026 @05:06PM (#48452065)
Indeed, that hardware was bought on old RAM, SSD, etc pricing. These are now 5x the price.

To reap massive profits before depreciation is just plain smart. LLM space, model generation is just plain crowded now too. And everyone thinks a crash is coming.

They could also build out their own end-user infra, but letting someone else which already sells direct to the public do so, is sensible.

I know of the desire to show profit for the IPO, but my point is, this is a good move on its own.

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by jhallenworld on Monday June 08, 2026 @05:57PM (#48452829)
>There are no dark GPUs

This might not be true. Someone was comparing Nvidia's production rate with known data center capacity, and they do not match. Their conclusion was that people (possibly even Nvidia) were hoarding GPUs- in the very short term this might be a good strategy, but GPUs go EOL fast. There are other stories about paused datacenter builds that match with this.

TSMC is definitely fully allocated, based on current 40 wk lead times for FPGAs..

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by Dig1t on Monday June 08, 2026 @06:49PM (#48453481)
All that means is that there's a bottleneck at the data center layer. When he says "dark GPUs" he's saying that there are no dark DEPLOYED GPUs.

This is a reference to the 1990's dot com bubble where internet infrastructure companies overbuilt network capacity, leading to the term "dark fiber". That was an indicator of a bubble because it showed that capacity was larger than demand. OP is saying that this is specifically NOT happening in the case of GPUs yet, indicating that demand still outstrips supply of compute.

>GPUs go EOL fast

We are seeing the opposite of what was expected, GPUs are actually getting more valuable because demand is so great, something that basically never happens. Even older chips have become more valuable.

>paused datacenter builds

It doesn't seem that datacenters have been paused because of lack of demand for AI, it seems mostly that there is a lot of pushback by cities to build these things and also there is a shortage of power to run them.

IMO none of these things point to a AI being a bubble (over-hyped, demand does not match the stated value). It mostly points to the opposite, there is massive demand for AI and every layer of the supply chain is struggling to keep up with that demand.

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by hadlock on Monday June 08, 2026 @07:21PM (#48453841)
Adding to this, a lot of fiber installed in the 1990s is still dark. Multi-wavelength XYZ and other improvements mean the same fiber from 35 years ago can carry 100 or 1000x what it was originally designed for. Also, like Solar, all the cost is in labor. When they designed the Seattle/King County fiber network, they knew they would never have access/permits to go back and add more, so instead of running a single 12 fiber bundle the size of your pinkie, they ran 3 x 1024 bundles the size of your arm through the hollow bridges that span I-5 freeway and snakes through Seattle underground. Almost all of that sits dark today despite being in a very busy area, simply because fiber technology keeps getting better.
Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by db48x on Monday June 08, 2026 @08:02PM (#48454216)
Yea, fiber is great. They can do hundreds of terabits/s per fiber today, and petabits/s is not far away. Bandwidth is fundamentally cheap enough that my ISP offers 50Gbps residential service!
Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by podocarp on Monday June 08, 2026 @09:52PM (#48455193)
Can I ask where do you stay? Korea? 50G is insane, is it on qsfp? Also what's the pricing on that?
Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by db48x on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @02:31PM (#48465435)
I live in Oregon. The price was $900/month last time I checked. I believe they do provide a QSFP+ module to plug into your equipment. They also allow residential customers, at any tier of service, to announce their own IP blocks via BGP.

https://ziplyfiber.com/internet/multigig

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by snypher on Monday June 08, 2026 @07:49PM (#48454096)
Don't you think that under excess demand, production will ramp, competition will become available etc? These posts read like we're all out of fresh silicon or something.
Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by aprdm on Monday June 08, 2026 @08:00PM (#48454199)
No. Because the investment to get into the game is too big and takes too long. The ones who can create the silicon are already oversubscribed.
Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by elictronic on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @05:16AM (#48458622)
Supply will catch up, it will just take 3-5 years, with the price rising the whole time. Basically a worse version of the Covid supply disruption where I sold my car for more than I bought it for years later.

The physical world can’t be patched overnight, and cutting edge manufacturing takes a long time. Fortunately we are in a very peaceful low tension world right now and no one would try burning down or blowing up one of those extremely important, irreplaceable fabs.

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by LearnYouALisp on Monday June 08, 2026 @11:12PM (#48455860)
> ...GPUs are actually getting more valuable because demand is so great, something that basically never happens. Even older chips have become more valuable.

Huh, anybody want to buy a GTX 680? Or even a formerly-SLI'd pair?

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by userbinator on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @02:11AM (#48457164)
The retrocomputing community is driving up prices at that end of the market.
Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by baq on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @01:34AM (#48456908)
> IMO none of these things point to a AI being a bubble (over-hyped, demand does not match the stated value).

I agree the demand is there, but hyperscaler capex is what now? 3% GDP? This is an absurd amount of money and people who question whether the ROI is there have a point just because of the order of magnitude of this spend number.

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by dan00 on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @08:16AM (#48460105)
> IMO none of these things point to a AI being a bubble (over-hyped, demand does not match the stated value). It mostly points to the opposite, there is massive demand for AI and every layer of the supply chain is struggling to keep up with that demand.

Yes, the demand is there for the currently unsustainable price. Lets see what happens when the dumping of money into AI stops and the companies are forced to increase prices a lot.

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by adjejmxbdjdn on Monday June 08, 2026 @06:08PM (#48452984)
Compute is also a rapidly depreciating asset.

I want to make a comparison with a car rental business and say that it would be like valuing Hertz entirely on the basis of the number of cars they own, as opposed to how many they rent out, but cars have a much longer depreciation period, if there are no customers they’re not costing you more money, unlike your computer which you are using for training and sucking up massive amounts of energy, and those cars do maintain decent value even after they’re of little use to the car rental company, unlike the compute here.

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by shdh on Monday June 08, 2026 @07:02PM (#48453636)
It is depreciating, but demand has been very high.

There's a reason old 3090's went from $600 in 2022 o to over $1K in 2026.

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by noosphr on Monday June 08, 2026 @07:25PM (#48453871)
My local inference rig now costs three times what I bought it for. If I'd gotten the max ram I could at the time I would have made $10k after selling the excess to my current spec.

How someone can look at an asset class thats appreciated an order of magnitude in the last two years and say it will depreciate in value when the tailwinds are even stronger now is beyond me.

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by snypher on Monday June 08, 2026 @07:47PM (#48454073)
Yes, toilet paper and N95s were expensive and hard to buy once, which is why I stockpiled a lifetime supply of them. Suckers!
Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by dpark on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @12:06AM (#48456249)
“Graph go up to the right. Graph stop at edge of paper. Must go up forever!”
Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by shdh on Monday June 08, 2026 @07:32PM (#48453930)
Fundamentals dictate hardware is a depreciating asset, they're not wrong. They're just ignoring the reality of the current market.
Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by noosphr on Monday June 08, 2026 @07:34PM (#48453955)
This was true when Moores law wasn't dead. Per watts performance has been flat since Ampere. There is a reason why undervolted 3090s are still used.
Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by codechicago277 on Monday June 08, 2026 @08:43PM (#48454596)
GPUs do have a life expectancy. They don’t run forever, especially at high temperatures and full utilization.
Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by noosphr on Monday June 08, 2026 @09:17PM (#48454896)
You undervolt them because the last 50% of power adss 10% of compute.
Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by baq on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @01:21AM (#48456813)
Undervolting is not running at max utilization by definition almost.

…but the real question whether you want to undervolt your asset if you’re renting it out is why bother? You probably expect to replace it anyway after it’s spec lifetime, for sure want to replace it when a more efficient solution is available since datacenters are power and volume constrained and customers care about performance much more than hardware longevity (otherwise they’d buy instead of rent).

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by imtringued on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @02:39AM (#48457398)
Why bother saving opex and capex?

Just waste more money! It's easy.

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by baq on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @02:49AM (#48457470)
Why do you think it’s a waste? If you’re buying GPUs to rent them you’re almost buying a bond. If you’re leasing them, it’s even more obvious that you’re collecting the spread. The GPUs have a financial lifetime after which the business doesn’t pencil and they get sold for peanuts so you can put a better bond in your volume-power.
Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by imtringued on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @04:06AM (#48458102)
Consumer GPUs/CPUs tend to be operated at higher clock rates and voltages, because they need to win benchmarks. If you ever bothered to pay attention to how data centers operate their hardware you would notice that they have always gladly sacrificed 10% of performance if the total cost of ownership is reduced.

Since this entire sub-thread is in the context of used 3090s or consumer GPUs in general, you've failed to bring up anything relevant yet again.

Here is your strategy:

1. Increase power consumption by 50%: This costs you more energy to run the GPU, it also costs you more energy to cool the GPU, it ruins the GPU and since you hit power limits of your infrastructure earlier, you will have fewer GPUs in total.

2. Increase maximum performance by 10%: This is hardly noticeable, since the standard inference use case primarily involves taking advantage of the high memory bandwidth of a GPU. This means prompt processing will be 10% faster, or maybe your segmentation model that ingests video runs at 33 fps instead of 30 fps. You're optimizing for winning a benchmark with what will be used hardware in the future, that's asinine.

3. Throw away old GPUs or sell them for peanuts when they still sell for $1000 on the used market if they are in good condition and for $400 if they are damaged. I think the mistake here is obvious. If your GPUs are sold for peanuts, it's because you didn't take care of them.

Your business strategy is obsolete and based around the idea of pre COVID excess hardware capacity before there was massive AI demand where throwing out hardware made sense, because Moores' law was in full swing. Even Google is still offering their v2 TPUs from 2017 even though they've been long since obsoleted. Now in 2026, there isn't enough memory for consumers and people are snatching up all the hardware they can get their hands on. There were some big initial energy efficiency wins from implementing smaller data types that are no longer possible now that fp4 is the smallest possible floating point type that still makes sense and even if you go smaller, you can go down to two bits at best. The parameters are starting to become so small that 2:4 sparsity is becoming unattractive, because it adds one bit to the parameters.

2:4 sparsity for fp4 means 4+4 bits are compressed to 4+1 bits, but 2 bit parameters mean 2+2 bits are compressed down to 2+1 bits.

If you understand even a little bit about hardware, you notice that the tensor core hardware has already been optimized to the extremes and that there isn't much more you can pull out of it. Unlike CPUs there is hardly any control flow in matrix multiplication. The tensor cores implemented in Nvidia GPUs might be a little bit less efficient than an NPU/TPU based implementation (think Google), but there are no more obvious micro architectural improvements here. With CPUs the micro architecture has become so complex, that there may be ways to increase performance further, but for GPUs and NPUs, there is not much left other than process scaling. Further gains require better manufacturing processes from TSMC. TSMC introduced 3nm in 2022 and only started producing 2nm in 2025. That's a three year gap where barely anything happened and all the gains came from going from bf16 or half precision floating point, to fp8 and fp4.

Burning through hardware at high power consumption and mediocre performance increases is clearly not the way to go.

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by fragmede on Monday June 08, 2026 @10:31PM (#48455513)
Performance goes way up if you use liquid nitrogen to cool the chips. Maybe finally someone's willing to pay for that.
Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by iririririr on Monday June 08, 2026 @08:01PM (#48454211)
everything* is 3x more expensive in the same amount of time though. that's inflation mostly.

* except ram

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by mlyle on Monday June 08, 2026 @11:23PM (#48455959)
Will it continue to appreciate to infinity? Maintain its value forever? Or will something else happen?

The same argument you’ve made would work for tulip bulbs, dotcom prices, or whatever. Prices go up until they don’t. Exponentials don’t last forever and the intrinsics of technology assets depreciate: things wear out and are also replaced with better things.

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by DanielHB on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @11:04AM (#48462097)
I have been hearing that memory suppliers are _intentionally_ not scaling up new factories like crazy because they assume the demand won't be there on the long term and they don't want to have spare unused capacity. Probably because Samsung and SK have a near duopoly on it as well...

At some point the market will be saturated with supply and prices will come down for older gen hardware. It can take years though, but it happened to fiber cable and fiber doesn't even depreciate like chips.

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by iririririr on Monday June 08, 2026 @07:59PM (#48454196)
no need for a car analogy.

the comment you replied to is word-by-word what people hyping canadian telecoms were saying before the dotcom crash!

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by BoorishBears on Monday June 08, 2026 @06:52PM (#48453524)
Compute is about to come an appreciating asset in the near-term, and it some ways it already is.

The frontier labs are shifting from pricing grounded in the price of compute, to pricing grounded in the intelligence provided, or more specifically the economic value of that intelligence downstream.

The margins on that allow them to pay a hefty premium on compute and still come out ahead.

As they buy more compute at high prices, they're also pricing out competition from cheaper models. It's already become materially more difficult to get compute to run open weight models at competitive prices as a result of frontier labs in the last year.

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by enos_feedler on Monday June 08, 2026 @07:45PM (#48454059)
There is zero evidence of this shift in pricing occurring. It’s still a dream which seems unlikely
Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by dylan604 on Monday June 08, 2026 @07:56PM (#48454161)
It feels like this is the line people are using to justify the expense of compute capex
Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by BoorishBears on Monday June 08, 2026 @08:17PM (#48454378)
I run a consumer AI product and the current reality of trying to get compute vs what it was 6-12 months ago is enough to justify it to anyone who has the money.

I think OpenClaw created a mania that was completely unfounded (Apple Silicon is worth dirt compared to literally anything from NVIDIA including consumer GPUs), but the prediction of compute becoming scarce was correct

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by otterley on Monday June 08, 2026 @08:02PM (#48454219)
The fact that you can sell or lease out something for more than you bought it for is justification in and of itself.
Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by adgjlsfhk1 on Monday June 08, 2026 @11:26PM (#48455977)
Not necessarily. The GPU leases Spacex has made are month to month, so they are taking on all of the risk. If demand goes down, they're the ones stuck with the assets.
Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by otterley on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @10:16AM (#48461469)
That's a very big "if," which this what thread has been about.
Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by BoorishBears on Monday June 08, 2026 @08:13PM (#48454344)
News to me?

Opus 4.7 has all the signs of a smaller model distilled from a newer pretraining run... except a smaller price.

Flash 3.5 raised in price pretty meaningfully over Fladh 3

GPT 5.4 got a small price bump over 5.3-Codex/5.2 and then gpt-5.5 doubled pricing over gpt-5.4

Even open weights isn't immune: Kimi K2.6 was originally priced higher despite openly being 2.5 + more post-training, same with GLM 5.1 vs 5

-

All while rental prices are spiking month over month, NVIDIA Inception discounted prices for buying are higher than undiscounted prices for buying 6 months ago...

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by koolala on Monday June 08, 2026 @10:52PM (#48455695)
Dream? It is a nightmare that computers aren't getting significantly more efficient anymore.
Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by leoedin on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @09:22AM (#48460812)
In the short term, compute becomes an appreciating asset.

In the medium term, everyone ramps up production. Huawei and other Chinese companies work really hard to develop in-house alternatives. At some point, the hype cycle will peak and less money will flow into datacentres (yes, this will happen. It always does. Even for technologies that change society. The bubble always bursts).

The question is not if this will happen. It will happen. It's just a question of when it happens and how big the magnitude of the cycle is.

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by nl on Monday June 08, 2026 @08:40PM (#48454554)
> Compute is also a rapidly depreciating asset.

That's the default assumption but in the new GPU+Memory constrained age isn't true.

Time on 4 year old H100 servers costs more now than when they were new (!!)

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by RealityVoid on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @12:21AM (#48456354)
> That's the default assumption but in the new GPU+Memory constrained age isn't true.

Is it an age or a temporary situation?

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by frognumber on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @12:36AM (#48456468)
It's very unclear to me.

The key question is on direction of LLMs. Right now, LLMs are taking over human jobs. If the cost of silicon+power < cost of human being doing the same work, what rational reason is there to employ a human being?

If this applies to SWEs, lawyers, business analysts, many research scientists, .... this situation could persist for a long, long time. While capital costs less than the inputs of labor (nominal food, housing, etc.), there is no need for labor.

The key question is about continued progress in models, and of the tooling around them:

- Plateau: Old silicon obsoletes in due course

- Rise quickly: Old silicon maintains value for a long time

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by fluidcruft on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @01:39AM (#48456941)
What I don't understand is if nobody has jobs, who's paying the machines to do anything?

So okay cool you don't need people to design and build cars. Who's going to buy the cars and where exactly are they finding money?

But see also the "radiologists driving to work" meme for why I think tech in general is currently getting high off their own farts.

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by somenameforme on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @03:48AM (#48457951)
The overwhelming majority of the labor force remains service, manual labor, and other such stuff that LLMs will have no real effect on. So the economy will be fine, but I do agree with you from a different angle. The entire goal of LLMs seems self destructive. If they're successful then the endgame is completely removing the barriers to entry to producing software and other digital tech. But if we do reach that endgame then the value of tech is going to plummet because there will be absolutely no barriers to entry to compete, or even just individuals homebrewing up what they need on demand.

Like imagine there was something you could buy where you insert some lumber, give it some passable description of furniture, and it outputs it. And you paid $20/month for access to this. And this was all being bankrolled by the furniture industry? I mean, sure guys - it's much appreciated, but I don't think I've ever seen anybody so enthusiastic about digging their own grave. I think it's already obvious that the gazillion dollars of API calls isn't going to materialize - it seems the handful of companies that trialed that are already reversing course hard. And in the future where LLMs are successful, that'd be even more true.

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by hdgvhicv on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @03:59AM (#48458050)
Llms either reach the point where they can quickly design and build physical robots to take on that service industry or they stop exponential growth.

Both of those are devastating for their valuation. Stopping growth means open modes catch up in a year or so. Continuing means end of the current economy.

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by solumunus on Wednesday June 10, 2026 @01:15AM (#48471740)
There’s a good chance physical humanoid robots will always be more expensive than humans, especially in this new hypothesised reality where there’s an enormous labour surplus.
Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by somenameforme on Wednesday June 10, 2026 @01:53AM (#48471989)
China is advancing robotics at a crazy pace, and hitting typical Chinese prices. This [1] robot is available starting at $6k. And of course what matters isn't the up-front cost, but the maintenance. If their maintenance costs are lower than human wages+taxes, then robots win.

The biggest practical issue will be that if these robots ever did start replacing people on a large enough scale, then you'd have a lot of angry, desperate people with a lot of time on their hands. So that alone will probably work as the primary mediating factor.

Quite an interesting time to be alive because the future is so completely impossible to predict. The world just a decade from now could look entirely different, or it could just be self driving cars all over again.

[1] - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v1Q4Su54iho

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by saulpw on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @01:59AM (#48457092)
Rich people become the only consumers.
Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by andy_ppp on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @04:16AM (#48458184)
Yes, the plan seems to be anti human in the extreme. Why do you need the plebs if they can be entirely replaced by AI? But the question then becomes why does the AI (and before that their security detail in a post money world) need billionaires?
Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by iugtmkbdfil834 on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @05:06AM (#48458556)
This likely is the tertiary reason as to why llms are so heavily kneecapped. Granted, at this point, projects do exist to remove those arbitrary restrictions, but the effort that goes into it suggests it is a real concern.
Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by ben_w on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @06:36AM (#48459218)
Long term, or short term?

Short term, money physically exists and gets spent, so if you wave a magic want of oversimplification and transition all labour to AI instantly, all the money currently in bank accounts and wallets gets spend on the same businesses it was already getting spent on, a lot of which gets spent on stuff from other businesses who have in this scenario also replaced all their labour with AI.

Eventually, perhaps quickly, all this money ends up in the hands of shareholders and landlords. There's a lot of both in the economy; famously retirement funds, but smaller-scale shareholders and landlords also exist. I wouldn't want to guess what the distribution looks like, probably highly variable between countries not just social classes (the definitions of which themselves can vary between countries).

Long term, money exists as a convenient fiction to help us organise transactions of goods and services: while it may be physically possible to eat gold and banknotes, you're not getting any real nutrients out of it when you do. So in a world where goods and services come from machines, the options are too broad to forecast: humanity could be relegated to the same role and economic stature as other primates (both in and out of zoos), or we could get universal UBI denominated in machine labour credits which lets each of us live better lives than the most extravagant billionaires live today.

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by fluidcruft on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @07:56AM (#48459910)
I don't know. It just seems odd because money was used as an abstraction of labor and if labor disappears it seems like money has no fundamental value. If you can't pay people to do something (because machines are doing all the labor). Then people have no money and money has no value to people. Industrialization resulted in transition to service-based economy but this new wave of machines are being said to replace service work.

I'm just trying to understand if suppose you have fully robotic farms and fully automated slaughterhouses and fully automated McDonald's, who is McDonald's selling anything to and how do these people supposedly buying fully-mechanized burgers have jobs? Something just doesn't add up about this in my head about how this equation balances.

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by ben_w on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @01:13PM (#48464074)
> I'm just trying to understand if suppose you have fully robotic farms and fully automated slaughterhouses and fully automated McDonald's, who is McDonald's selling anything to and how do these people supposedly buying fully-mechanized burgers have jobs? Something just doesn't add up about this in my head about how this equation balances.

Well, people need to eat, so either the customers are on government support, or it comes from passive income, or from savings.

The people without those options, do it the old fashioned way: pick berries, throw rocks at animals, rub sticks for fire to cook them, or starve. Mostly starve, as the maximum number of humans who can survive as hunter-gatherers is 100-1000x smaller than the current global population.

> UBI ultimately seems like socialism with extra steps.

I agree. It's very much "from each according to their ability, oh wait we're all strictly worse than machines I guess that's from each nothing, to each according to their needs".

> Mostly is comes across as billionaires desperately begging for an alternative to being nationalized.

Perhaps, but that feels like claiming they're playing 5D chess, when Zuckerberg only plays Settlers of Catan with sycophants who let him win.

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by andrekandre on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @01:23PM (#48464245)

  > how do these people supposedly buying fully-mechanized burgers
stand in line and watch some ads; the more you watch, the more you can order!
Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by ben_w on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @01:56PM (#48464852)
What good is showing ads to someone with no money?

(Only answer I can think of is political ads).

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by BobbyTables2 on Wednesday June 10, 2026 @11:49PM (#48485993)
I’ve also wondered about this.

Industrialization allowed people to shift human labor from agriculture to factories and such.

Seems like intellectual labor became more possible as people looked beyond subsistence but also more valuable since a greater population could drive demand for more than just subsistence related activities.

If both aren’t done by many humans, what’s left? Sports training and massage therapy? Sports training might not even be safe…

OTOH, my current lifestyle is already weird if I think about it. Developing software for a machine that I cannot make myself, whose raw materials I cannot obtain, using energy I cannot produce on my own — somehow entitles me to get a particular amount of goods and services from others including food, healthcare, entertainment, landscaping, and manufactured goods.

We live in interesting times…

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by ben_w on Thursday June 11, 2026 @03:39AM (#48487460)
> If both aren’t done by many humans, what’s left? Sports training and massage therapy? Sports training might not even be safe…

Peacock tails.

As in, things where the effort itself is the point, to show off that you are capable of surviving when you consume resources so extravagantly on something other than (or even detrimental to) mere survival.

This includes stuff like hand-made art, being in a literal cult, extreme sports, and also refusing modern medical interventions/seeking out infections.

You may ask how someone can get paid for those things; I don't know, but we did manage to monetise talking to each other (ads on Facebook) and being locked in a house with some strangers while everyone's under surveillance cameras for a few weeks (TV show Big Brother).

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by laichzeit0 on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @10:49AM (#48461907)
I think the Amish will mostly be fine. Maybe that's how the future looks like.
Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by paulhebert on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @01:05AM (#48456686)
> what rational reason is there to employ a human being?

To maintain a functioning society and social contract?

Is wanting low unemployment in our society not rational?

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by Earw0rm on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @02:19AM (#48457208)
It's ethnically rational, and morally right.

However.

It's not rational relative to the short-term incentives of a typical corporation or investment vehicle. PE, VC, fund managers aren't paid to give a fuck about the social contract. Literally not in their job description.

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by hackyhacky on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @03:17AM (#48457694)
Correct. Unfortunately, that's not how capitalism makes decisions.
Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by tirant on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @07:42AM (#48459808)
Capitalism does not decide anything. Capitalism allows individuals to take decisions in a free market.

If you want to complain about selfishness then do it on selfish individuals, which by the way, are present in all types of economic systems.

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by goatlover on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @08:57AM (#48460527)
Which includes SCOTUS recognizing corporations as persons.
Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by hackyhacky on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @09:01AM (#48460563)
> Capitalism allows individuals to take decisions in a free market.

Capitalism provides a set of incentives that shape how people make decisions. Anyone can be selfish, but selfishness in capitalist society has a particular shape. To ignore the external incentives when looking at human behavior is horribly naive and shortsighted, but is frequently done by capitalism-apologists who seek to disregard any criticism of their favorite incentive system.

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by ben_w on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @06:45AM (#48459291)
> Is wanting low unemployment in our society not rational?

Only conditionally on there being bad consequences for high unemployment.

I don't particularly trust politicians, but there's a whole host of hypothetical scenarios about futures where work is essentially optional. Unfortunately, they're all either in the sci-fi or religion sections of the book store:

Despite people occasionally investigating UBI, the efforts to research UBI seriously have the same problems that Marx had with literal Communism, in that there's an obvious difference between any partial transition as compared to a global transition, and we don't have a completely disconnected parallel world to be a petri dish for us to test the economic outcomes on.

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by nl on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @02:09AM (#48457154)
Memory is unlikely to drop in price before mid-2027 when new capacity starts to come online.

The GPU shortage looks to be even longer lived.

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by williamdclt on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @09:03AM (#48460587)
So, temporary situation then. That's a pretty short period with no paradigm shift, just a delay in capacity.
Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by __blockcipher__ on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @12:34PM (#48463368)
It’s gonna take a lot longer than mid 2027. 2029 earliest IMO. Hyperscaler spend is basically already spoken for the next 2 years.
Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by Seanambers on Wednesday June 10, 2026 @05:37AM (#48473805)
Temporary until its not.

It's the new normal, get used to it.

The MAG7 isn't pumping all their FCF + new debt issuance into DC's just for fun.

The world is seemingly moving into a era where compute is becoming expensive and scarce.

Only thing that can possibly change this is LLMs hitting a vertical unscalable wall.

More AI compute = more CPU, memory, storage needs.

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by _1100 on Wednesday June 10, 2026 @09:00AM (#48475659)
Do you think we will recognize any walls? Or is there a point where the output might look different with respect to different paradigms / modalities we throw at it, but we won't be able to understand the quantitative differences as good/bad/scalable?
Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by baq on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @01:16AM (#48456770)
Everything is a temporary situation on long enough timeframes, especially if it’s exponentially growing. Moore’s law which dictates that compute depreciates quickly has been slowing down a lot in the last few years, coupled with the explosion in demand we’ve found ourselves in a prolonged shortage situation. The bubble will pop, but if you predict when correctly, you will be a rich man.
Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by mikepurvis on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @12:41AM (#48456510)
Are current datacenter deployments structured in such a way that the memory can later be moved to newer GPU dies? Or is it all packaged together as on consumer graphics cards?

I assumed the latter and therefore that the memory is depreciating along with the GPU cores it's soldered onto PCBs with.

... or is it a different argument being made, perhaps that depreciation for GPUs has slowed because rising demand will keep them in service longer?

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by nl on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @02:11AM (#48457165)
The argument is that all GPUs are currently appreciating (!!)

Google is still running 10 year old Tesla T4s at full capacity.

This is way beyond the expected lifetime.

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by fragmede on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @02:56AM (#48457519)
Removing RAM chips off old cards is uneconomical, until it isn't. With things going the way they are, if you've got a card with soldered on RAM that could be transplanted to a newer card, I think you'll start seeing that happening.
Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by fer on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @05:43AM (#48458812)
It has already become economic. While not exactly the same, the NVIDIA 2080 11GB cards are notorious for being upcycled with extra RAM: https://www.reddit.com/r/nvidia/comments/146us12/nvidia_gefo...
Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by blensor on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @02:28AM (#48457303)
I also feel that the GPU/NPU value does not lose money as fast anymore.

What I am wondering though is how long can you run such a system at basically full load without interruption before it starts to just physically degrade.

If I have a H100 and I let it run for 4 years at full throttle does it still have the same theoretical value as it had at the start or are the chips just burning out.

I think I remember that back when the cards used for crypto mining were sold en masse on ebay the advice was to stay away from them because they are more likely to fail?

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by SkiFire13 on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @02:36AM (#48457370)
Quite the opposite, GPUs running at a stable rate degrade less than GPU that continuously hit highs and lows (like it would happen on a gaming rig).
Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by yobbo on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @04:10AM (#48458129)
Normal use means loading data into the GPU for each batch. The load is not even, though training might be worse than "production".
Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by blensor on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @09:02AM (#48460578)
After digging around a bit I found an unverified claim from 2024 that GPUs in datacenters have a lifespan of 1-3 years

https://www.tomshardware.com/pc-components/gpus/datacenter-g...

Others say that moderate load means a lifespan of ~5 years

Not sure what that means but I would assume that a datacenter will start replacing a node once the error rate hits a certain threshold without really investigating why it failed, so the practical lifespan may be shorter than 5 years even if it would technically still be usable enough

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by formerly_proven on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @05:33AM (#48458761)
> I also feel that the GPU/NPU value does not lose money as fast anymore.

That's because the rate of improvement in silicon manufacturing has been continually declining for a few decades, which has a compounding effect. Just compare the technological improvements in successive decades. 1976->1986->1996->2006->2016->2026.

That's why "in real terms" performance has only been very slowly improving if you compare apples to apples (and not e.g. apples to oranges by reducing precision, like nvidia tends to do, or by comparing chips with x W to an MCM with x*2 W and saying the latter is much faster). The "just halve the number of bits in each generation" strategy has also run out now, there's no more bits to halve.

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by RetroTechie on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @09:52AM (#48461181)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electromigration

Temperature is a big factor, as well as current density.

But there's also the # and magnitude of thermal cycles (which translate into mechanical stress, leading to metal-fatigue like effects on contact points etc), attack from chemicals in the air, cosmic radiation, ESD damage & more. Some may matter, some not.

That's why "new" > "used" in case of electronics. Especially since you don't know the (ab)use history of used parts.

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by almog on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @04:21AM (#48458225)
Depreciating doesn't just mean it could depreciate in value relative to the performance of newer GPUs, but also that its lifespan is limited by reliability issues and failures.
Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by code51 on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @05:03AM (#48458525)
That's just inflation (yeah, the global one) and demand at play.

Let's not mix up depreciation of real value vs USD price (which is arbitrary, plus government controlled)

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by adjejmxbdjdn on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @05:43AM (#48458825)
> Time on 4 year old H100 servers costs more now than when they were new (!!)

There are several confounding factors.

We’ve seen massive inflation since then. So some growth in cost was expected.

More importantly, the current Tech industry almost always starts by selling things at a loss. The increased cost could simply be the industry choosing to not subsidize that particular service anymore.

But also, I don’t think that’s a realistic comparison. Rented out GPUs are likely not a similar use profile as compute used for training LLMs. The latter is likely closer to the cryptocurrency GPUs that are running at full tilt 24/7.

And those things physically burn out.

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by nl on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @07:14AM (#48459526)
> Rented out GPUs are likely not a similar use profile as compute used for training LLMs. The latter is likely closer to the cryptocurrency GPUs that are running at full tilt 24/7.

This is untrue.

H100's are used for training (well were, but are now outdated because B100/B200s are much faster).

Most of the reason people rent H100s is for smaller training runs.

If you are doing inference you usually buy managed capacity at Baseten or something, and that is often priced differently (although it comes down to an extra margin on longer term H100 prices basically).

Inference utilization is often actually higher than training now because so much effort has been spent on optimizing that stack.

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by latchkey on Monday June 08, 2026 @10:20PM (#48455436)
"depreciating" is not being used in the right sense.

There is depreciation, which is taking the purchase price and dividing it across N number of years (typically 5). That's the D in EBITDA and is mostly used as a profitability calculation.

The depreciation of a GPU also gets mucked up in the current GPU financed market as well. DDTL loans. The people running the GPUs often don't even own the GPU, they lease it, so there is nothing for them to depreciate (D).

The analogy that a GPU is like a used car makes zero sense. There is no oil or tires to change on a GPU. They don't wear out in the same way that a rental car would. They are housed in climate controlled locations with clean power. They just don't fail the way that is portrayed in the press.

Useful life of a GPU is based on profitability. When does opex cost more than profitability?

Some companies, like mine, also have support contracts. Anything goes wrong with the GPU (or any part of the system), Dell comes and fixes it at no extra charge. We just migrate customers and workloads to hot spares while the parts are replaced.

As for compute going down in value... the 122TB of enterprise nvme and 2GB of ram in each server that I bought 2 years ago is now worth vastly more than I paid for it. I'm also renting my GPUs out for more money now due to supply being so tight and demand being so high.

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by scionaura on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @12:12AM (#48456294)
it’s more like if you were to value Hertz as if they were a self-driving car company, only to find they’re a car rental company
Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by rolisz on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @02:02AM (#48457110)
> if there are no customers they’re not costing you more money, unlike your computer which you are using for training

So are you using the computers or not? I'd argue that if you're using them for training, then it's not wasted capacity. And if you're not using them, then you can turn them off, so you're not sucking up energy.

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by eecc on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @02:50AM (#48457476)
Compute is also a rapidly depreciating asset.

I don’t know but this dude at my son’s school has a 32GB RTX 5090 and it’s worth more than what he paid for; and he did the same trick with the RTX 4090 before that.

Until shortages are the rule, these assets are appreciating

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by jubilanti on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @10:25AM (#48461597)
Car rentals are a great comparison, but not for the reason you think. Cars depreciate value similarly to GPUs. The depriciation lifecycle timeframe is actually similar between hyperscaler GPUs and mainstream corporate car rental companies ike Hertz. They sell their cars after 2-3 years or 20-40k miles. There is a huge market for used cars. Hertz runs their used car sales out of their rental retail offices and a lot of overhead is shared. So take the difference in cost to buy new in bulk from the manufacturer from the retail sales price for a 2-3 year old car. As long as Hertz can make more money renting it out in that time, that's revenue positive.

Same with GPUs. There is also a huge market for used GPUs from 1-2 generations ago. The A100 is a six year old chip at this point and is still running strong, especially for inference. Like cars, chips can be refurbished and repaired. A hyperscaler or even mid level player here isn't going to hold onto chips for their entire usable lifespan.

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by Spooky23 on Monday June 08, 2026 @06:47PM (#48453462)
xAI lets companies like Google move fast and hurt people at arms length.

Google itself has a good reputation as a facilities operator. SpaceXAI is operating gas turbines emitting exhaust at ground level.

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by seltzered_ on Monday June 08, 2026 @07:48PM (#48454088)
Google has also tried to hide things like water consumption data, see:

- https://cloud.sustainability.watch/explore-issues/example-go...

- https://www.sfgate.com/national-parks/article/mount-hood-wat...

They also seemingly dropped their net-zero climate goal:

https://www.tomshardware.com/tech-industry/google-quietly-re...

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by AtlasBarfed on Monday June 08, 2026 @07:29PM (#48453897)
There is a compute shortage.

In fact, for all these companies to do what they're going to do, they need a massive, massive massive amount of data centers, a highly improbable number of data centers that need to be built in an highly improbably short amount of time.

And the capitals about to dry off in about a year. So it's a race between these improbable timelines on data center construction, with capital evaporating.

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by podocarp on Monday June 08, 2026 @09:54PM (#48455216)
Source for capital drying up in one year? Not trying to be snarky but that's super big if true.
Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by AtlasBarfed on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @01:05AM (#48456679)
- iran destabilization will shift middle east capital to military spending and infrastructure repair

- Ukraine war similarly is triggering an EU buildup and reduction in us dependency

- all the IPOs indicate the companies themselves know the private investment is coming to an end so they need the retail investors to keep the boondoggle moving

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by epsteingpt on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @01:02AM (#48456660)
correct

but it's really bad news for the industry capacity if your best option is unproven space datacenters.

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by baq on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @01:27AM (#48456859)
> There are no dark GPUs.

There are actually lots of GPUs in storage somewhere waiting for data center megawatts to put them in.

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by 0xbadcafebee on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @02:25AM (#48457264)
The compute is useless if nobody is left to pay for the compute, once all the AI companies die, from all that debt getting called in, once everyone realizes it's a scam. (AI isn't a scam, but the financial deals and promises of unrealistic recoupment are)
Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by ViscountPenguin on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @05:28AM (#48458721)
The thing I've never understood about the ai investment model is the upside. What's the point of valuations that only make sense if you've built a digital god, when at that point you've literally got a digital god. I can't imagine the tangible value of money being high in that scenario
Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by 0xbadcafebee on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @11:53AM (#48462742)
Money is imaginary, it's just a placeholder, doesn't need to be tangible. In the case of AI it's the promise that you can replace humans with cheap fast robots, to do more things and cheaper. That's valuable. But the wealthy aren't considering that our economy depends on people (replacing all the people too fast would tank the economy from unemployment, and cause a revolt). So you might wonder, why don't they just move at a slower, sustainable pace? The answer is greed. Make as much as you can, as fast as you can, before the next guy does.

All this investment is completely driven by the companies leading the pack. OpenAI and Anthropic have been telling everyone they need to spend hundreds of billions in a few years. Of course they don't, they could do this over 10-15 years and still be profitable. But they're terrified they won't be able to dominate the market. So to dominate the market, they've estimated they need this growth to beat China (and each other). And the US technically has the capital to make this happen, but there's only so much money available to spend. By growing too fast, they spend money faster than they can make it, and the bills are so big that the investors go bankrupt.

That's what happened in the panic of 1873 (railroads instead of AI). That's what's going to happen here in the next 2-4 years.

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by danielmarkbruce on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @12:00PM (#48462830)
But this doesn't sound exciting to folks who like a good conspiracy theory. The google/xai deal is the least interesting thing at spacex.

"you have compute, i need compute, i'll pay you for some compute.".

Re:xAI is looking more like a datacentre REIT than a frontie... by killerstorm on Tuesday June 09, 2026 @12:41PM (#48463473)
Presumably from internal all-hands presentation in Google: “Now we must double every 6 months… the next 1000x in 4–5 years.” reported by CNBC in November 2025, attributed to Amin Vahdat, Google Cloud VP / AI infrastructure lead.

Sundar Pichai at Q4 2025 earnings call: “We’ve been supply-constrained".

Satya Nadella, 2026: Microsoft would increase total AI capacity by over 80% in the year and roughly double total datacenter footprint over two years.

Microsoft CFO, 2026 earnings call: “We’ve been short now for many quarters. I thought we were going to catch up. We are not. Demand is increasing.”

So yeah, either top management of hyperscalers are doing a 'bit' for the last few years, or Aschenbrenner 'Situational Awareness' is going roughly as predicted and hyperscalers are desperate to acquire compute even at higher cost.