News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by Havoc on Friday May 08, 2026 @12:17PM (#48065196)
Whether it's AMP or manifest 3 or android source shenanigan or attempts to replace cookies with their FLOC nonsense or this...Google is rapidly turning into a malicious force when it comes to the open internet
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by willio58 on Friday May 08, 2026 @04:12PM (#48068153)
> AMP

My god AMP was such an annoying thing ~4-5 years ago when I was working in a marketing-forward web dev shop.

"Google really likes when you pipe your words into their shitty UI because it saves some time for the user"

We were all like, cool so on one hand we're being given complex designs for sites to differentiate them, and on the other hand we're bowing to a megacorp who actually wants to skip the whole web design part entirely and pipe our content through their pre-defined UI.

So glad it died. Should have known it would die in a matter of a couple of years with that being the track record for Google in general.

Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by xnx on Friday May 08, 2026 @07:56PM (#48070242)
> skip the whole web design part entirely and pipe our content through their pre-defined UI

It's a shame this part didn't stick. I use reading mode every chance I get be cause the more design a page has, the worse it is. For some reason orgs agreed that it is ok to let medium or substack own their content, but hated Google's high speed CDN.

Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by xiaoyu2006 on Friday May 08, 2026 @01:24PM (#48066157)
Turns out RMS has always been right. How surprising.
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by tgsovlerkhgsel on Friday May 08, 2026 @03:11PM (#48067401)
Turns out that identifying a problem doesn't help without a workable solution/alternative.
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by dylan604 on Friday May 08, 2026 @03:20PM (#48067520)
I hate this trite and the managers that say "don't bring me problems, bring me solutions" nonsense. I'm not the person to be able to fix it so the solution is make the problem known so others responsible can fix it. If I could fix it, I wouldn't be telling you about the problem. If anything, I would tell you how I fixed an issue in some stand up or other of the many meetings scheduled keeping me from working.
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by janalsncm on Friday May 08, 2026 @04:24PM (#48068322)
I am only aware of two solutions:

1) proof of identity, tying accounts to real-world things that are hard or impossible to replicate

2) proof of work, tying accounts or actions to the ability to run computations

Proof of identity in theory can solve the problem but at the cost of privacy.

Proof of work can be defeated but has the possibility of preserving privacy.

Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by Worf on Friday May 08, 2026 @05:15PM (#48068868)
3) micropayments

There are many issues with those, like the wildly different standards of living across the globe. OTOH anyone can acquire Monero if they want to. But someone from a rich country will likely be able to pay for more fake accounts/visits than someone from a poor country. With the ad market the difference between where the visitor is from is very important. Some ad clicks may cost a dollar if they're coming from a rich country and 0.01 cents if they're coming from a poor country.

I'm not suggesting cryptocurrency micropayments for accessing the web but it's on par with PoW in that it only requires money, not privacy.

Perhaps the way forward is for people to wake up and stop visiting sites that infringe on their privacy.

Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by janalsncm on Friday May 08, 2026 @10:37PM (#48071233)
Fair enough, I didn’t think of that one. I suppose macropayments could be in the same bucket.

Analogous to hardware disparities and POW, wealth disparities make payment a toll but not a roadblock.

Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by supern0va on Friday May 08, 2026 @04:57PM (#48068694)
>Proof of identity in theory can solve the problem but at the cost of privacy.

All current implementations: yes. I do think there are some privacy preserving solutions, but they're obviously imperfect. But assuming you have a central authority that can validate and sign valid government identification, it seems like some sort of ZK scheme could allow one to verify that they have a valid government issued ID, but without disclosing which one it is.

I still don't love the idea, but it sure seems better than everything else I've seen proposed.

Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by Worf on Friday May 08, 2026 @05:16PM (#48068885)
From what I've seen no such solution guarantees privacy to the user if the signing body (or the government) and the website collude to deanonymize the user.
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by fsflover on Sunday May 10, 2026 @10:55AM (#48084508)
What if the the government signs your private key but doesn't store the list of people who requested this?
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by Worf on Wednesday May 13, 2026 @01:24PM (#48124820)
Can you elaborate on how that would work exactly? What would the flow be - which party would request what from whom? Would there be technical assurances that no list is stored by the government?
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by account42 on Monday May 11, 2026 @06:14AM (#48093107)
Why are you skipping entirely over good old legislation and law enforcement against offenders, including diplomatic pressure for foreign offenders.

Not everything calls for a purely technical solution.

Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by m463 on Friday May 08, 2026 @03:24PM (#48067558)
nonsense on all levels.

RMS has offered broadly solutions/alternatives since the beginning, along with reporting early on trends that other people ignore.

Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by janalsncm on Friday May 08, 2026 @03:30PM (#48067636)
What is his solution to combatting botnets at scale?
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by chadgpt2 on Friday May 08, 2026 @04:02PM (#48068003)
His solution is don't. Why would you? In fact, if you don't block the script that's running on one computer, the script operator won't need to run it on a botnet.

I don't know RMS's solution to spam or DDoS which are the real problems.

Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by janalsncm on Friday May 08, 2026 @04:17PM (#48068225)
> Why would you?

Because controlling a large number of accounts can allow you to manipulate the algorithms on Web2.0 websites. For example, this one. If you don’t combat spammers the front page quickly gets filled up with garbage.

Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by chadgpt2 on Friday May 08, 2026 @06:25PM (#48069510)
Yeah, that's the spam problem I referenced. It shouldn't be reframed as a bot problem. The problem isn't that someone scripted your website—it's that someone scripted your website to post spam. They had spam in RMS's days too and I'm not aware of how it was solved. As far as I can tell, it appears that spam is fundamentally unsolvable.

At least we can mitigate it by using less web2.0 algorithms.

Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by mrsssnake on Friday May 08, 2026 @06:31PM (#48069569)
His solution would be taking democracy and freedom above interest of couple of botnet attacked websites.
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by janalsncm on Friday May 08, 2026 @10:40PM (#48071256)
What does that even mean?

I don’t mean to be rude but every single person who references RMS here seems to only have platitudes rather than solutions.

Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by jjulius on Friday May 08, 2026 @03:45PM (#48067798)
The whole "don't point out a problem unless you have a solution" trope is bullshit.
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by skinfaxi on Saturday May 09, 2026 @01:48AM (#48072169)
The first step in solving a problem is identifying it.
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by backprop1989 on Friday May 08, 2026 @03:33PM (#48067664)
Root mean square?
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by snailmailman on Friday May 08, 2026 @03:35PM (#48067689)
richard stallman
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by Aloha on Friday May 08, 2026 @01:28PM (#48066219)
Indeed, occasionally hammers do find nails to hit.
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by stronglikedan on Friday May 08, 2026 @01:32PM (#48066265)
Strange analogy considering that RMS got to where he is precisely by finding nails to hit much, much more than occasionally, and much, much more than most hammers.
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by Supermancho on Friday May 08, 2026 @03:01PM (#48067293)
I think it hits perfectly. He espouses that almost every vendor everywhere is doing something immoral and it will inevitably be used against you. Eventually, some of these predictions come true enough for some part of his audiences.

I don't think you've made a point about his abilities. I do think you've restated his proclivities, which reinforces the basis for the quip.

Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by rpdillon on Friday May 08, 2026 @03:58PM (#48067947)
This is particularly uncharitable to someone that saw around many corners and was articulate enough to warn us about them in advance.

There's a reason there's a subreddit called "Stallman Was Right", and it's not that he was shotgun blasting opinions and landed a few of them. It's because he has a systemic understanding of the incentives our system sets up and is able to project decades into the future about how those incentives will play out.

Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by behringer on Friday May 08, 2026 @01:38PM (#48066324)
The analogy works if you think of RMS as a nailgun.
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by smallnix on Friday May 08, 2026 @01:42PM (#48066374)
A nailgun hitting nails? This is going nowhere..
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by CalRobert on Friday May 08, 2026 @03:07PM (#48067352)
Much as a hammer tacker hits tacks internally, so a nailgun strikes the nails within itself.
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by behringer on Friday May 08, 2026 @02:27PM (#48066915)
well it drives nails, we've lost the plot!
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by traderj0e on Friday May 08, 2026 @01:52PM (#48066498)
If RMS said not to trust Google's self-proclaimed altruism and relationship with open source, yeah. I always assumed that was a backstab waiting to happen. But that only meant I used an iPhone and didn't care that it was more closed than Android, not that I got an Arch Linux phone or something. (And a Mac more importantly, but there's not really a Google counterpart to that.)
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by janalsncm on Friday May 08, 2026 @04:27PM (#48068352)
What is RMS’ solution to this problem?
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by kibwen on Friday May 08, 2026 @04:34PM (#48068437)
Uncompromisingly insist on only using things you have ultimate ownership and control over, even when that means dramatic and life-altering inconvenience, and where those things don't exist, build them yourself.

Unfortunately, "build it yourself" is relatively easy when it comes to software, and almost impossible when it comes to the hardware running that software. It doesn't matter if you have full ownership of a complete open-source stack if no hardware manufacturer will permit you to run unsigned arbitrary code. The lack of open hardware--chips that you could build in your garage using materials nobody could reasonably prevent you from acquiring--is the lynchpin upon which open source software will wither and die.

Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by Borealid on Friday May 08, 2026 @05:11PM (#48068824)
There is already plenty of open hardware, it's just not this-year's-top-performance.

In the category of ~1-3 years' performance lag you get Rockchip and friends, which are closed hardware that allows open computation. See computers made by the company MNT as an example.

In the category of ~5 years' performance lag you get "soft" cores, where you buy an FPGA (dynamically reprogrammable hardware) and make it run a CPU you design yourself. If you want to, for example, make your CPU have more cache and fewer ALUs, you can do that by tweaking some files and reprogramming the FPGA. This has a cost in terms of power efficiency and runtime speed, but you can absolutely run a full Linux desktop experience on an FPGA today, and the hardware has no way to try to prevent you from running any software.

You can solve the problem of all the cellular basebands being closed source with either software-defined-radio or using a closed USB/PCIe cellular modem connected to an open processor.

Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by bix6 on Friday May 08, 2026 @05:08PM (#48068787)
So why doesn’t someone build these chips in their garage then?
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by kibwen on Saturday May 09, 2026 @05:57PM (#48078655)
Despite my hopes, I somewhat doubt that anyone would accept computing on the sort of chips that one could produce in their garage for less than $10,000 capital investment. You can, probably, with some effort and research, produce something analogous to the original Intel chips from the 70s in your garage using off-the-shelf tools. Sam Zeloof has blazed the trail here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IS5ycm7VfXg . And for a less than a million it's not inconceivable that a municipality could produce chips that would be at home in the 90s. Maybe that would be enough for a lot of tasks, especially if you're willing to resort to hardware coprocessors for common tasks like media decoding and encryption, but it would take a huge sea change to get people to accept it, and nearly all of our software would need to be rewritten.
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by Refreeze5224 on Friday May 08, 2026 @04:38PM (#48068492)
I know what his solution is not. It's not a mechanism that conveniently enables the fine-grained surveillance of people that just so happens to be google's business model.
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by janalsncm on Friday May 08, 2026 @10:33PM (#48071185)
I specifically asked the question I did because rejecting solutions without proposing your own is a great way to not solve the problem.
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by wafflemaker on Friday May 08, 2026 @04:40PM (#48068527)
In Eve online you used to be able to have people (outside your contacts list) pay some cash in escrow to send you a message.
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by phpnode on Friday May 08, 2026 @01:21PM (#48066123)
Last time this happened we got a bunch of Google employees downplaying the impact of WEI and calling it a nothingburger, that people were being hysterical. I just checked, and everyone I saw defending it has since left the company. I'm sure another wave of Google managers, keen to appeal to the higher-ups, will be here to defend this new initiative any minute now.
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by gessha on Friday May 08, 2026 @04:43PM (#48068553)
This makes me curious, where did they go?
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by phpnode on Friday May 08, 2026 @06:34PM (#48069586)
at least one went to Shopify, I'm not sure about the rest
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by EGreg on Friday May 08, 2026 @01:27PM (#48066198)
Don't you see it closing all around you?

It's not just Google. It's governments, corporations, all around the world, simultaneously. The noose is being tightened gradually, then all at once. And it's coming for all of us:

https://community.qbix.com/t/increasing-state-of-surveillanc...

The threats above interlock by design or convergence: Identity layer (1-5) creates the prerequisite for the others. Once identity is established at SIM/account/device level, the carve-outs that make surveillance politically viable become possible (powerful users get exemptions; ordinary users get watched).

Device layer (10-12, 16-19) creates the surveillance endpoint. Once content is scanned on the device before encryption, the cryptographic protections at the communications layer become irrelevant.

Communications layer (6-9) is the most-defended. Mass scanning has been defeated repeatedly. This is the layer where the resistance has the best track record.

Reporting layer (13-15) is nascent. Direct OS-to-government reporting hooks haven't been built yet at scale. The UK's December 2025 proposal is the leading edge.

Platform control (20-24) determines whether alternatives can exist. Browser diversity, app distribution diversity, and engine diversity are the structural protections. All three are narrowing.

A society with all five layers complete has the technical infrastructure for total surveillance with elite carve-outs. We are roughly 40% of the way there. Whether that infrastructure becomes a dystopia depends on political choices, not technical ones.

HN as a whole is surprisingly oblivious to the noose tightening, because many here are super against decentralized distributed things, if they involve any sort of token. You can complain all you want, but downvoting and burying the decentralized alternatives just for groupthink makes you somewhat complicit in the erosion of our privacy and liberties. Even if you might disagree with a project, all the work that goes into it might be a good reason to upvote it instead, considering that without this work, we're basically doomed.

Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by CalRobert on Friday May 08, 2026 @03:08PM (#48067371)
Hell, even using cash feels like a minor form of dissent. And of course even if you leave your phone at home, your car will be scanned with ANPR wherever it goes. And if that fails, there's still your face to be tracked.
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by hellojesus on Friday May 08, 2026 @06:24PM (#48069499)
The cars themselves phone home all the time. You have to physically remove the transceiver to prevent it or run a jammer nonstop at the risk of a felony.
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by CalRobert on Saturday May 09, 2026 @12:06AM (#48071726)
Yeah. I’ve never owned a car newer than 2006 though. These days I just ride a bike. Though the fancier e-bikes have gps tracking…
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by hellojesus on Saturday May 09, 2026 @09:36AM (#48074868)
The APL readers still get you without the cars transceiver. Plus if you have automatic tire pressure sensors, those are mandated to communicate in plaintext over rf when sending the data to the car, from my understanding, and you can farm those to track location by setting up radios next to roadways.
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by narrator on Friday May 08, 2026 @02:24PM (#48066901)
I said 16 years ago that when IPV6 was coming into use was the only reason for a 128 bit address space was so they could tie every packet on the internet back to you as a person. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1464940
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by chadgpt2 on Friday May 08, 2026 @04:06PM (#48068051)
No, the main reason is because NAT is terrible and restoring the end to end principle is important if we want the internet to stay not separated into server networks and eyeball networks. If we want to decentralize the internet it's necessary that eyeball machines can talk with each other, not only with servers. This ability reduces the possibility of surveillance.

When IPv6 was designed it was normal for each IPv4 address to be traceable to someone's desk. Fortunately, as that changed with IPv4 so did it with IPv6, so we got IPv6 privacy extensions.

Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by pneumonic on Friday May 08, 2026 @03:09PM (#48067374)
It doesn't help that your first sentence makes you sound like a conspiracy theorist riding his hobby horse. I read on despite that, but others may not.
[dead]
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by EGreg on Friday May 08, 2026 @02:37PM (#48067024)
I refer you to all my own comments about decentralized solutions, which you can see in my history. And the posts that have been flagged after amassing too many upvotes. I think that's sufficient.
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by kogasa240p on Friday May 08, 2026 @02:59PM (#48067269)
My apologies then
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by ocdtrekkie on Friday May 08, 2026 @12:37PM (#48065475)
> rapidly becoming

Always has been.

Google was creating cartels like the "Open Handset Alliance" literally decades ago.

Via their control of Chrome and Search which are both monopolies, Google holds absolute authority on how websites are rendered and if websites can be found.

Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by parineum on Friday May 08, 2026 @01:31PM (#48066250)
> Chrome and Search which are both monopolies

I'm on Firefox and use DuckDuckGo.

Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by ToValueFunfetti on Friday May 08, 2026 @02:21PM (#48066861)
You'd be better off mentioning Safari (17% of users vs. Chrome's 68% and Firefox's 2.2%) and Bing (10% vs Google's 85% and DDG's 1.7%). But nice to know there are two of us!
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by vel0city on Friday May 08, 2026 @01:36PM (#48066308)
It cracks me up when people say Chrome is a monopoly, because a massive amount of computing devices do not even ship with Chrome. Windows computers, Macbooks, and iPhones require users go search out and install Chrome on their own out of their own volition, shipping with entirely functional and decent browsers out of the box that they have lots of patterns to push. Even many Android phones ship with browsers other than Chrome as a default still from what I understand.

How is Chrome, of all things, a monopoly? Have words just entirely lost all meaning and now monopoly just means "things which are popular that I dislike"?

Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by MSFT_Edging on Friday May 08, 2026 @01:50PM (#48066470)
Chrome is a monopoly by extending the internet in ways that force users into chrome. Due to market share and Google's prevalence, they have the sway to introduce things that cannot meaningfully be avoided without extreme siloing.
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by vel0city on Friday May 08, 2026 @02:24PM (#48066894)
Outside of WebUSB I personally haven't meaningfully been impacted in any ways. Can you share which ways this is?

Note, this is separate from a "so many things are just Chromium", which I agree is an issue, but isn't the same as a "Google Chrome is a monopoly". Because in the end there are still many non-Chrome browsers which support WebUSB which do not end up with a lot of the downsides of Chrome specifically about Google harvesting your data and what not.

Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by CursedSilicon on Friday May 08, 2026 @02:32PM (#48066975)
Ah, the "this doesn't fit my very specific technicality argument"

You know full well what people mean when they say "Chrome"

Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by vel0city on Friday May 08, 2026 @02:39PM (#48067050)
> You know full well what people mean when they say "Chrome"

Yeah, Chrome, the web browser made by Google that bugs you to sign in with your Google Account. Most people don't mean Microsoft Edge when you say "Chrome". Do you call Microsoft Edge "Chrome"?

Chrome is a product made by Google that is a web browser. If the argument is Chromium is too interwoven, that's a separate argument.

But even then, what does it mean that "Chromium is a monopoly"? Is Linux a monopoly as well? Why or why not?

Note you haven't actually given me any other ways one would be impacted like I asked. What are the other majorly missing features Chrome pushes that other browsers don't have that most sites require? What else am I missing by not using a non-Chromium-based browser?

Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by majorchord on Friday May 08, 2026 @02:43PM (#48067090)
> what does it mean that "Chromium is a monopoly"

As someone else said earlier, it is a monopoly by extending the internet in ways that force users into using their browser engine. Due to market share and Google's prevalence, they have the sway to introduce things that cannot meaningfully be avoided without extreme siloing.

> What are the other majorly missing features Chrome pushes that other browsers don't have that most sites require?

This is a different question, please don't move the goalposts.

Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by vel0city on Friday May 08, 2026 @02:44PM (#48067108)
> by extending the internet in ways that force users into using their browser engine

And yet after multiple times of me asking you've yet to give me a single real feature lost.

> This is a different question

Its literally the thing we're saying is the problem, how is it a different question entirely?!

You're saying the problem is they're adding features that force Chromium, but asking about which features you're talking about is just bringing up unrelated and different questions.

Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by majorchord on Friday May 08, 2026 @02:58PM (#48067262)
It's not so much forcing people to Chrome/chromium for specific features, but trying to increase market share through more subtle means, like paying to have their search engine featured, advertising their products everywhere possible (including inside other people's apps), slowing down their sites (like youtube) on other browsers, or tying in other services (along with way too much personal info) to try to keep people within their sphere of influence.

Is Linux also a monopoly? In a way sure, but I think a big difference is they're not "doing evil" as people claim Google is, and all the development/decisions are still made out in the open in a democratic way.

Former Google execs have even compared their setup to "running the New York Stock Exchange while trading on it."

At least Linux isn't trying to tell people what to do with their software.

Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by philipallstar on Friday May 08, 2026 @03:10PM (#48067386)
> it is a monopoly by extending the internet in ways that force users into using their browser engine

2 messages later that seems to be contradicted?

> It's not so much forcing people to Chrome/chromium for specific features

I might've misread.

> but trying to increase market share through more subtle means, like paying to have their search engine featured

This isn't Chromium, the open source basis of many web browsers. Now you're talking about Google the company.

> Is Linux also a monopoly?

Monopolies in the sense worth discussing are highly popular things that are held in place by things other than competition. If anything, Google props up Chrome's competitors to reduce this.

Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by vel0city on Friday May 08, 2026 @03:19PM (#48067502)
So now Chrome is a "monopoly" because they're "advertising their products everywhere possible". I guess I can only ever drink Redbull, they're a monopoly, because they're advertising their products everywhere.

Seriously? That's our standard of what is a "monpoply"?

Words have no meaning anymore.

You can choose to use something different. The device you bought probably came with an alternative! Otherwise, the device next to it on the shelf on the store where you bought it likely would have had an alternative browser, because most devices on the store shelves outside of some hypothetical physical Google store don't come with Chrome.

Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by Dylan16807 on Friday May 08, 2026 @04:07PM (#48068063)
> Seriously? That's our standard of what is a "monpoply"?

No. That part of the post was answering your question about how it impacts people. Not what makes it a monopoly.

Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by vel0city on Friday May 08, 2026 @04:44PM (#48068567)
I'm asking what features force me to use Chrome instead of Firefox or Edge or Safari. I've yet to hear an answer other than it's advertised heavily and that it's popular.
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by traderj0e on Friday May 08, 2026 @05:41PM (#48069125)
There's nothing forcing you to use Chrome instead of Edge, but some websites don't work with Safari or Firefox because Google has pushed nonstandard stuff. And it's weirdly not only advanced WebWhatever stuff, but also some things that affects basic features like forms. Though sometimes they have a separate mobile site that was tested in iPhone Safari.

I find the discrepancy kinda minor though. It's enough that I have Chrome installed alongside Firefox and Safari, but not enough that I use it often. It used to be worse.

Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by vel0city on Friday May 08, 2026 @10:05PM (#48071025)
> There's nothing forcing you to use Chrome instead of Edge

This is what I mean. How is it a "monopoly" when one can easily just use something else?

The only thing people are saying its "its a monopoly because it has high market share". But a high market share does not a monopoly make, there's more to it than just purely market share. A monopoly requries outsized market power, something that to me at least it doesn't seem like Chrome, the web browser has.

Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by traderj0e on Friday May 08, 2026 @10:12PM (#48071071)
The argument others are making is that Google has a monopoly on browser engines, or that it's becoming that way. IE switched to Chromium partially to resolve compatibility issues. I don't have a strong opinion on this though.
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by Dylan16807 on Friday May 08, 2026 @10:08PM (#48071043)
People being able to switch relatively easily means that they're a lot more likely to lose their market power in five years. It doesn't do much to diminish their current market power, which is enormous.

High market share almost always means high market power. That's why people focus on market share since it's easy to cite.

Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by vel0city on Friday May 08, 2026 @10:12PM (#48071068)
> they're a lot more likely to lose their market power in five years

It doesn't take users five years to install a different browser. It takes maybe two to five minutes. If they really do things to piss off their users they'll be gone far faster than that.

What kind of lock-in does a browser even really have? Its not like some kind of social network or financial setup or anything like that. The browser itself doesn't have the content. Its run an installer, have it import bookmarks and extensions, and you're using a different browser. Its not like we're back in the days of ActiveX where there were entirely proprietary extensions to the web that only Microsoft blessed browsers could run that only ran on certain OSes.

> almost always means high market power.

It doesn't when the competition is so readily available, practically interchangeable, and also zero cost.

Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by majorchord on Friday May 08, 2026 @02:38PM (#48067043)
Do you actually think the majority of everyone else is being just as pedantic (or cares) about Google Chrome vs chromium-based?

For most, for the purposes of market share (the type of "monopoly" I believe they are referring to), I think they count it as one and the same.

Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by vel0city on Friday May 08, 2026 @02:40PM (#48067063)
Do most people call Microsoft Edge or Safari "Chrome"?

Are the security and privacy implications the same for Edge, Safari, and Chrome?

Seems to me like they're still quite different products despite having some similar codebases!

Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by jmholla on Friday May 08, 2026 @03:03PM (#48067315)
Safari isn't based on Chromium.
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by vel0city on Friday May 08, 2026 @03:30PM (#48067626)
Ah, you're right, still WebKit based.
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by dns_snek on Friday May 08, 2026 @04:00PM (#48067976)
What's the point of this pedantry? Replace "monopoly" with "dominant market player" and their point still stands. A company doesn't need to be a literal monopoly to engage in anti-competitive behavior. The EU would call this "abuse of dominance". [1]

>> Google holds absolute authority on how websites are rendered and if websites can be found.

This is still 100% correct. Google owns the dominant browser and the dominant search engine, this means that they get to dictate how websites function and pick winners and losers through their search algorithm. If you're a publisher (i.e. anyone who hosts a website) you're forced to fall in line or go out of business.

[1] https://competition-policy.ec.europa.eu/system/files/2021-05...

Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by vel0city on Friday May 08, 2026 @05:12PM (#48068833)
> If you're a publisher (i.e. anyone who hosts a website) you're forced to fall in line or go out of business.

What features of Chrome are website publishers forced to fall in line with or go out of business that practically other browser makers aren't also pushing?

Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by Dylan16807 on Friday May 08, 2026 @02:45PM (#48067116)
Why do you keep talking about who installs the app? That has nothing to do with whether something is a monopoly, which is primarily about market share.
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by vel0city on Friday May 08, 2026 @02:48PM (#48067144)
If a user is openly going out of their way to go and install a competitor's product despite a perfectly serviceable version coming by default, how can the the one being sought out be seen as a monopoly? The competition came pre-installed!

How did the user manage to install Chrome on Windows if Chrome is a monopoly, the only serviceable browser around? They copy the source code from a magazine or something? Get a floppy disk in the mail?

Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by Dylan16807 on Friday May 08, 2026 @02:56PM (#48067241)
Whatever your definition of monopoly is, it's wrong. The threshold is not 100% market share. If that was the threshold no monopoly has ever existed.
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by vel0city on Friday May 08, 2026 @03:34PM (#48067672)
> Whatever your definition of monopoly is, it's wrong

Ok, so enlighten me which standard of monopoly they're so obviously breaking?

> The threshold is not 100% market share.

I never once said so

I'm not arguing it requires 100% marketshare. I'm just pointing out there are tons of workable competitors out there, in fact one has to use a functional and fully featured competitors product to go and install Chrome on most platforms out there.

How can one claim Chrome is a monoply when there are tons of competitors out there which work just fine, and for most users their computers came with the competitors products?

Please, do enlighten me, how is Chrome a monopoly?

Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by Dylan16807 on Friday May 08, 2026 @04:04PM (#48068019)
> Ok, so enlighten me which standard of monopoly they're so obviously breaking?

Breaking?

They're being a monopoly by having a huge market share. A majority of browers are directly branded chrome, and the chrome team has strong codebase control over most of the alternatives too. Especially on desktop. It's that simple.

> I'm not arguing it requires 100% marketshare. I'm just pointing out there are tons of workable competitors out there, in fact one has to use a functional and fully featured competitors product to go and install Chrome on most platforms out there.

> How can one claim Chrome is a monoply when there are tons of competitors out there which work just fine, and for most users their computers came with the competitors products?

The existence of competition doesn't change whether something is a monopoly. It only disproves 100%, which is why I mentioned 100%.

The choices of users don't change whether something is a monopoly.

Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by vel0city on Friday May 08, 2026 @04:32PM (#48068412)
> having a huge market share.

Marketshare alone isn't a defining part of if a product is a monopoly.

> majority of browers are directly branded chrome

They're not Chrome, in many extremely important aspects.

> The choices of users don't change whether something is a monopoly

The fact users can make a choice is a huge part of the argument that Chrome isn't a monopoly. There are lots of competitors out there that can be freely chosen. So much so people have to go out of their way to install Chrome.

When AT&T was ruled a monopoly it was practically the only choice in many markets. When Standard Oil was ruled a monopoly it was practically the only choice in many markets. People can choose Edge. People can choose Safari. People can choose Firefox. All of these browsers work fine (I've yet to be told a single other major feature they're missing despite asking many times), and are not Chrome.

Lay's sells like 60% or so of the chips sold in the US. Are they a monopoly? Are you practically unable to buy any other chips at the store outside of Lays products? I guess it's not really just marketshare that makes the difference! So just pointing at them and saying they're a monopoly because they have a large marketshare is meaningless.

Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by Dylan16807 on Friday May 08, 2026 @04:57PM (#48068698)
> Marketshare alone isn't a defining part of if a product is a monopoly.

Yes it is. You're thinking of something else.

> The fact users can make a choice is a huge part of the argument that Chrome isn't a monopoly.

That argument is wrong.

It's size and market power. If users could change but don't, the monopoly company still has huge power.

> Lay's sells like 60% or so of the chips sold in the US. Are they a monopoly?

They're at least close, yeah.

Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by vel0city on Friday May 08, 2026 @05:07PM (#48068784)
> It's size and market power

Finally one states something other than its a monopoly because it has market share or because its advertised heavily. Its a monopoly because it allegedly has market power. But does it, really?

> If users could change but don't, the monopoly company still has huge power.

Is it that it has power or just that its currently popular?

I once again ask, what features actually force me to use Chrome over the other products on the market? If there are none, how does it actually have "market power"? What truly makes me use Chrome over the others? The fact its highly advertised?

Market power is usually defined as "a firm's ability to profitably raise prices above the competitive level (marginal cost) without losing significant sales to competitors." Clearly we're not talking about prices here, practically all the prices are free here. So we're talking other kinds of featuresets. What is this market power, other than users like it? I've asked many times, and yet everyone has refused to answer this core, critical part of the claim.

If people can make a choice for a competitor's product that's priced the exact same and has essentially the same feature set, how does Chrome have "market power"?

I pointed out WebUSB. For a bit pretty much only Chrome supported it. Is that really market power that's pushing everyone to use Chrome? What other things are actually giving it that immense market power you claim?

Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by Dylan16807 on Friday May 08, 2026 @05:14PM (#48068865)
> I've asked many times, and yet everyone has refused to answer this core, critical part of the claim.

It's a core, critical part of a monopoly abuse claim, not a monopoly claim. I don't want to get in that argument.

They don't have some weird ultra low market power for their size. They're a monopoly.

Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by vel0city on Friday May 08, 2026 @10:07PM (#48071036)
You have stated a monopoly is:

> It's size and market power.

We both agree on the size. Its the most popular browser for sure. And I agree, a monopoly generally has to be quite large and it doesn't need to be 100%.

When I ask you for evidence of the market power side of the monopoly claim, you just throw up your hands and say "I don't want to get in that argument", make some claim about the self-evidence of their market power, and then just assert they're a monopoly.

I'm just asking someone to actually point out how Chrome, the web browser has outsized market power. Not just restate they have high usage numbers, but actual instances showcasing their market power. Real studies about how sticky Chrome actually is. Anything like that. But nobody here will actually point to anything other hand waving about how much its marketed and what not.

Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by wil421 on Friday May 08, 2026 @01:47PM (#48066429)
I’m constantly badgered by google apps on my iPhone to use Chrome. In fact I’m not able to just click a link and open my default browser, I have to see the big chrome logo and a smaller link to choose my default browser.
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by vel0city on Friday May 08, 2026 @02:21PM (#48066865)
> by google apps on my iPhone

Ever thought about just not using those apps if you want to avoid the Google ecosystem? Too bad there's just absolutely no mapping application available on iPhone but Google Maps. Too bad there's no way to send an email on an iPhone outside of Gmail.

What's that? A user has to once again go out of their way to install those apps as well? Well isn't that strange. I thought Google was a monopoly on iPhones.

Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by traderj0e on Friday May 08, 2026 @01:50PM (#48066469)
and even the iPhone Chrome doesn't use the Chromium engine, it's Safari under the hood
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by ranger_danger on Friday May 08, 2026 @02:32PM (#48066976)
> Windows computers

Ship with a chromium fork called Edge

Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by vel0city on Friday May 08, 2026 @03:46PM (#48067805)
Edge isn't Chrome though, is it? Like, its not shipped by Google, it doesn't bug you to log in with a Google account, doesn't ship metrics back to Google, right?

Not quite the same thing now is it?

Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by traderj0e on Friday May 08, 2026 @04:24PM (#48068330)
The usual complaint is that Chromium dominates as an engine. I don't fully understand the complaint because anyone can fork it, but maybe they're (rightfully) concerned nobody will fork it because Google controls the web standards, or they're concerned Chrome could stop using the open version of the engine.
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by newphone733 on Friday May 08, 2026 @01:32PM (#48066259)
They lost their search monopoly when LLMs came.
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by imglorp on Friday May 08, 2026 @02:38PM (#48067031)
Lost? No, they shoveled search into the furnace day after day as they prioritized sewage like paid results, link farms, and blog spam while burying the actual result far below, if returned at all. LLM showed up and gave you the direct answer you wanted in <1s; you don't even have to read the shitty troll result page.
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by Melatonic on Friday May 08, 2026 @05:28PM (#48069002)
Huge fan of Kagi so far - especially SmallWeb if you do want to find websites that probably would not hit the top of Google search results
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by ocdtrekkie on Friday May 08, 2026 @05:40PM (#48069115)
I am a Kagi early adopter. ;) But the reality is what can be on the web is dictated by Google Search, because nothing survives if you can't find it on Google.
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by xenophonf on Friday May 08, 2026 @12:37PM (#48065471)
I'm amused at how thoroughly Google adopted Microsoft's playbook. Chrome supplanted Internet Explorer by embracing the open web. But then Google immediately started on extensions, and now they're trying to extinguish the open web with nonsense like Cloud Fraud Defense. All very smoothly done. I mean, people are actually _asking_ for this junk. I'm impressed.
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by olyjohn on Friday May 08, 2026 @12:59PM (#48065794)
No they didn't. Firefox unseated Internet Explorer. Chrome then got big by putting its installer right on the Google homepage and harassing users to install it. And they had it bundled with other software, and would install as a user so that locked down computers could still run it. They absolutely did not win by embracing open standards.
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by traderj0e on Friday May 08, 2026 @01:32PM (#48066251)
Chrome has gone off doing their own standards to some extent, but you're forgetting what it was like when Internet Explorer dominated. You basically couldn't use the web without IE because they broke so many standards and implemented them in closed source. Then there was ActiveX on top, straight up Windows binaries in web. And besides there being a dominant engine, only one browser could use that engine. Trading that for Chrome dominance was at least a step up.

I use Firefox right now. Occasionally I need to open a site in Chrome instead, but it's rare.

Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by ndriscoll on Friday May 08, 2026 @01:36PM (#48066309)
Chrome didn't solve that though. Quoth Wikipedia:

> Firefox usage share grew to a peak of 32.21% in November 2009, with Firefox 3.5 overtaking Internet Explorer 7, although not all versions of Internet Explorer as a whole;

Firefox was the browser that embraced open standards and was unseating IE. And ActiveX was used for corporate stuff, not general web sites, so the main reason it died was that Microsoft gave up.

Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by traderj0e on Friday May 08, 2026 @01:44PM (#48066392)
Eh, it was brief and never majority. Chrome was the first to truly usurp IE.
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by generalpf on Saturday May 09, 2026 @09:27AM (#48074805)
I just got a Docusign and it didn't work in Firefox, I had to use Chrome. That's a huge blow right there. (I sent negative feedback about this to Docusign.)
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by traderj0e on Sunday May 10, 2026 @10:06PM (#48090277)
I vaguely remember running into that too a few times, strangely not on every doc. Also one particular part of the Chase mortgage website.
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by vel0city on Friday May 08, 2026 @01:40PM (#48066346)
Chrome and v8 was just stupidly faster than any other browser and JS stack at the time when I first adoped it. It was a lot buggier in many other ways and many sites just didn't work quite right at the time, but the tradeoff on performance in the early days was very much worth it.
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by ocdtrekkie on Friday May 08, 2026 @01:23PM (#48066150)
People forget that Sundar Pichai's entire claim to success at Google was injecting the Google Toolbar into the Adobe Reader installer which would hijack your search and browsing data on IE, and the launch of Chrome, which was then also injected into the Adobe Reader installer, occurred because Google was concerned IE might block or limit their toolbar.

People absolutely did like Google at the time, but the majority of its growth is actually shoveling hijackers into other software installs just like BonzaiBuddy.

Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by lotsofpulp on Friday May 08, 2026 @01:26PM (#48066187)
I recommended everyone to use Chrome simply because Microsoft couldn't be bothered to provide built in PDF viewing and creation.

There was a good, long period where Microsoft just decided to let the market run amok with malware for critical software, instead of providing something like Preview on macOS. As a result, the safest option for most lay people was to use Chrome, where they could quickly and easily view, and most important, save pdfs of websites, receipts, etc.

Then, once MacBook Airs were solidified + iPhone, I started recommending people use macOS simply because Preview could edit PDFs and easily allow signing them.

I haven't used Windows in a very long time, so I assume it's still the same situation.

Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by traderj0e on Friday May 08, 2026 @01:41PM (#48066362)
Yeah I remember when Windows lacked every basic utility that Mac OS had. The most common malware was PDF readers, because a very common search was "how to open pdf." Same with zip.
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by lotsofpulp on Friday May 08, 2026 @01:21PM (#48066114)
I recall Chrome being a superior browser in the early days, prompting many to switch and evangelizing it.
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by traderj0e on Friday May 08, 2026 @01:45PM (#48066407)
It was the first to do a separate process per tab, which had security and stability benefits. But it also used like 2x the RAM from the start.
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by homebrewer on Friday May 08, 2026 @01:21PM (#48066120)
Lots of supposedly technically advanced users switched to Chrome en masse and promoted it on every occasion they could, because it was so much faster, simpler, safer, etc etc. Don't excuse useful idiots from their share of the blame. People warned about dangers of Chrome's growing domination for about as long as I can remember, back to at least 2012, only to be dismissed as paranoid.
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by narrator on Friday May 08, 2026 @02:27PM (#48066931)
If I may tie this into other things going on, The California wealth tax as written would force Larry and Sergei, if they didn't move out of California, to basically sell almost their entire stake in Google, and it would probably wind up owned by State Street and Vanguard who outsource their proxy votes to ESG consultants, who will probably vote for more surveillance.
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by doctorpangloss on Friday May 08, 2026 @01:58PM (#48066579)
what alternative to WEI do you propose? it solves a bajillion Internet-existential problems. it is definitely a crisis. the bot problem is at least as serious as facebook, gmail serving without https.

the fact that this kind of comment gets downvoted proves my point. so what if you personally don't like WEI? it doesn't mean the problems aren't real...

that aside, i don't know how people say stuff like "malicious force" and then you go and use a bajillion Google-authored, completely free as in beer and often free as in freedom technologies that nobody obligates you to use at all. It's not like Apple, where their software is so shitty (Messages, Apple Photos, etc.) that the only reason people use it is because it is locked down and forced upon you. it's interesting to me that @dang worries about the tenor of conversation changing - he longs for that 2009 world of university-level math people hanging out and writing comments about LISP or whatever - when the real deficit is not intelligence about math but, at the very least, seeing that things are nuanced, to see more sides to a problem besides the most emotionally powerful and the most mathematically neutral ones.

Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by idle_zealot on Friday May 08, 2026 @02:48PM (#48067140)
Bombing every AI data center on Earth would also solve the Internet-existential problems we're facing. But that solution is beyond the pale of course, instead it's incumbent on me to prove to you that panopticon surveillance of every living human being from now until the Sun consumes us is not a reasonable solution to "bots use the Internet".
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by traderj0e on Friday May 08, 2026 @04:14PM (#48068183)
Ok so what's your solution to the bot problem? I don't have one, unless you count the option of websites not being free-as-in-beer anymore.
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by idle_zealot on Friday May 08, 2026 @05:03PM (#48068749)
First, I would sooner support the criminalization of misrepresentation of web traffic as human when it is actually a bot than I would allow companies to de-facto require bio-authentication on approved hardware+software stacks to participate in online life. Let the courts sort it out from there. Second, it's not my problem if some website's business model doesn't work anymore, and I resent them trying to make it my problem. If a website is offering a vital service then it is access to that service that needs to be preserved, not whatever company happens to be offering it, especially not if the cost of keeping them solvent is giving up entirely on privacy rights.
Re:Google Cloud Fraud Defence is just WEI repackaged by traderj0e on Friday May 08, 2026 @04:19PM (#48068269)
People use iMessage because it has worked for a long time, during which all the leading alternatives were terrible. Maybe they still are cause I'm still not convinced that RCS even works reliably, seeing how Android users go on WhatsApp instead.