News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by Hizonner on Saturday November 08, 2025 @06:30PM (#45861128)
You shouldn't even be expected to geoblock. If I'm operating a Web site in country A, I should not have to care about country B's laws unless I am taking specific action intended to attract users in country B in particular. That's doesn't mean just to target the whole world, either. If you don't want your citizens to access something in another country, take it up with your citizens.

It was obvious from the minute that idiots started creating IP location databases in the first place that people would demand that they be used like that... and those demands seem to be winning out.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by vessenes on Saturday November 08, 2025 @07:27PM (#45861652)
Preston talks about this in an earlier blog post. It's a matter of UK law and, I'd bet, many countries, that they have the sovereign right to legislate about matters in and outside their borders. "If Parliament says smoking in Paris is illegal, it is illegal." What's different today than when that doctrine was conceived of is: data goes everywhere, communications are decentralized, international cooperation around especially data allows nations to enforce their own rules outside their own borders by treaty.

What was known and not said when Parliament might have outlawed smoking in Paris is that there was literally nothing they could do to enforce such a law. Today the governments have options, hence the fight here. And many other places.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by Hizonner on Saturday November 08, 2025 @08:05PM (#45861912)
> It's a matter of UK law and, I'd bet, many countries, that they have the sovereign right to legislate about matters in and outside their borders.

Basically all countries take that position legally. But there are norms and customs about how often you exercise it (as well as practical questions of power).

Extraterritorial regulation of Web sites is unfortunately in the process of being established as normal, but it's a bad norm. Not as bad as drone striking anybody who lights a cigarette in Paris (which could be made legal), but a bad norm nonetheless.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by umanwizard on Saturday November 08, 2025 @08:09PM (#45861937)
Interestingly, Ireland seems to be one of the few countries whose constitution explicitly limits the reach of its laws:

> It is the firm will of the Irish nation, in harmony and friendship, to unite all the people who share the territory of the island of Ireland, in all the diversity of their identities and traditions, recognising that a united Ireland shall be brought about only by peaceful means with the consent of a majority of the people, democratically expressed, in both jurisdictions in the island. Until then, the laws enacted by the Parliament established by this Constitution shall have the like area and extent of application as the laws enacted by the Parliament that existed immediately before the coming into operation of this Constitution.

(Which means the territory of what is now called the Republic of Ireland, that is, explicitly excluding any claim to Northern Ireland in order to comply with the Good Friday agreement)

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by socalgal2 on Saturday November 08, 2025 @09:10PM (#45862285)
Some activists should start making lots of complaints demanding that country A’s government sites comply with government B’s laws. Maybe the laws will change to reflect reality when government A says to fuck off
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by hilbert42 on Saturday November 08, 2025 @11:45PM (#45862962)
"Extraterritorial regulation of Web sites is unfortunately in the process of being established as normal, but it's a bad norm."

Perhaps "Extraterritorial regulation" is bad wording. A country can regulate whether an extraterritorial website is distributed and or viewed within its borders but it has no legal authority force another country to close down a website that's operating legally within its jurisdiction.

The only remaining options are diplomatic action—request the site be taken down or war/by force. Whether we like it or not the only practical action is for a country to geoblock offensive websites at its borders.

Sadly, given the current state of world affairs, it seems to me geoblocking will become the norm almost everywhere.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by AnthonyMouse on Sunday November 09, 2025 @01:39AM (#45863455)
> Perhaps "Extraterritorial regulation" is bad wording. A country can regulate whether an extraterritorial website is distributed and or viewed within its borders but it has no legal authority force another country to close down a website that's operating legally within its jurisdiction.

The issue is they're doing this through might makes right rather than jurisdictional authority.

You have a website in one country, 99% of the content is legal in another country but it also contains a post by a user which is legal in the first country and not the second.

The second country then demands that the website remove the post -- for everyone, they don't even want it accessible via VPN -- or they'll have their ISPs block not just the entire website but also the entire shared hosting provider the website uses. The site which is entirely in the other jurisdiction can't withstand that much pressure and removes the post.

You now have a country censoring a post world-wide because they leveraged every company within their jurisdiction to enforce a law against one that isn't. That's extraterritorial regulation.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by exe34 on Sunday November 09, 2025 @04:35AM (#45864289)
> You now have a country censoring a post world-wide because they leveraged every company within their jurisdiction to enforce a law against one that isn't. That's extraterritorial regulation.

Hopefully this will break up the cartel of websites/distributors back into a decentralised web eventually.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by AnthonyMouse on Sunday November 09, 2025 @05:34AM (#45864557)
It would have to do the ISPs and that's a tall hill.
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by HPsquared on Sunday November 09, 2025 @06:01AM (#45864681)
What happens if two foreign countries try to impose mutually exclusive laws?
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by londons_explore on Sunday November 09, 2025 @07:46AM (#45865173)
For many years, Google solved this by saying the laws of country X only applied in the country specific domain of Google.

They now seem to have backtracked on that and are using either the country the request came from or the country the account was set up from (both using IP geolocation)

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by conartist6 on Sunday November 09, 2025 @06:31AM (#45864806)
Then they kiss
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by Tuna-Fish on Sunday November 09, 2025 @01:18PM (#45867722)
If they both are able to enforce their laws on you, you get to choose which prison you go to.
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by fukka42 on Saturday November 08, 2025 @08:08PM (#45861930)
The Americans take the same stance. See their obsession with copyright for example. You know, up until American companies violated those laws en masse in the name of profit and suddenly nobody cared.
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by gerdesj on Saturday November 08, 2025 @08:48PM (#45862157)
American companies were appropriating IP or trade secrets as they were called when Birmingham was known as Brummagen.

Nowadays we have China, int al, doing the same sort of job.

Nothing changes.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by tempodox on Sunday November 09, 2025 @02:00AM (#45863515)
Who is “int al”?
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by 1over137 on Sunday November 09, 2025 @02:12AM (#45863561)
Probably meant “et al”, Latin for “and others”.
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by throw_a_grenade on Sunday November 09, 2025 @03:00AM (#45863787)
inter alia, “among others”
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by gerdesj on Sunday November 09, 2025 @08:51PM (#45871354)
Yes: inter alia: amongst other things

Sorry, I'm a bit old school. When you get AI waffle spitting out abbreviated Latin, you will know the end of the world is nigh!

EDIT: Spell out my preferred translation of int. al.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by tempodox on Monday November 10, 2025 @12:19PM (#45878188)
Ha, with the dots I would have realized what it is. I was confused by the 1st version having no dots.
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by hunterpayne on Saturday November 08, 2025 @08:49PM (#45862164)
No the US doesn't do that. We had to make special international treaties which involved getting other governments to sign up for that (in exchange for other concessions). Stop inventing things that never happened just to excuse your politicians bad behavior.

PS Arresting foreigners for things that happened outside of your territory is an act of war.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by machomaster on Saturday November 08, 2025 @10:40PM (#45862701)
You should ask AI go give you a long list of people who were arrested/captured/kidnapped/killed by the USA for the things they did outside of the US. Often, without doing anything illegal (locally, but sometimes even by US law).

Guantanamo bay exists outside of the US territory for a reason, so that no legal rules would apply. CIA/USA has been keeping secret prisons and torturing people all around the world (incl. EU).

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by hunterpayne on Saturday November 08, 2025 @11:07PM (#45862819)
Conflating people shooting at your military with freedom of speech is pretty insane. But I understand, the UK has never had free speech so you just don't know what it means.
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by idiotsecant on Sunday November 09, 2025 @08:21AM (#45865406)
Look, I am the first to say that the US dogpiling that happens online is sometimes not justified. In this case, though, this is not a hill you want to die on. Extrajudicial black site funny business is kind of the US's thing. It's good that the US makes treaties but if those treaties fail to materialize and the US wants something bad enough, it'll happen.
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by machomaster on Sunday November 09, 2025 @12:06PM (#45867060)
I am not even from UK.

It is you who conflated the arguments.

My response was to the claim that US does not procecute people, who did outside of the US. I demonstrated that it is not the case. The actual alleged crime doea not matter.

You are trying to move the goal post and you will not succeed.

There are plenty of other cases, also including the freedom of speech. What do you think the procecution of the journalist Assange was all about?

Claiming that the US is not running after people in other countries is the same level of ignorance as claiming that the US is not meddling in election and is not using the hybrid warfare.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by dandellion on Saturday November 08, 2025 @09:27PM (#45862361)
That sounds like the same thing, with extra steps.
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by bee_rider on Saturday November 08, 2025 @10:17PM (#45862602)
The extra steps are the thing that convinces the other countries to go along with it.
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by dandellion on Wednesday November 12, 2025 @07:33AM (#45899378)
Bullying is not convincing.
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by hunterpayne on Saturday November 08, 2025 @08:45PM (#45862133)
Ok, but I feel like the UK government hasn't thought this matter through. Think about what happens if the US decides it can enforce US law on UK soil against UK citizens. The main industry of the UK is questionable international finance using legal fictions on various islands. What happens when the US decides that that shouldn't be happening anymore? Its the same logic OfCom is using here. And unlike the UK government, the US could actually enforce this stuff in person. The US literally has military bases outside London with tanks and artillary and airstrips. This isn't a road to continue down.

PS The UK doesn't have free speech and never has. Free Speech was invented by the Dutch and the US was the first to put it in a founding document.

PPS I know of no government that thinks it can enforce their law outside of their borders against foreigners. That is outside the definition of sovereignty and something the UK government seems to have invented lately.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by Pet_Ant on Saturday November 08, 2025 @11:09PM (#45862828)
> What happens when the US decides that that shouldn't be happening anymore?

Like the US did with Swiss banks?

“…the standard of justice depends on the equality of power to compel and that in fact the strong do what they have the power to do and the weak accept what they have to accept.” — Thucydides, 5.89 (trans. Rex Warner, Penguin Classics edition)

(half-remembered quote found using AI)

original source https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/History_of_the_Peloponnesian_...

Book 5, end of paragraph 89

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by hunterpayne on Sunday November 09, 2025 @12:12AM (#45863089)
The US government in that case was requesting information on US citizens and not foreign nationals. I put in those last two words ("against foreigners") for a reason. If the UK government was trying to enforce UK law on UK citizens in the US, that's one thing. That's not what is happening with Ofcom, they want to enforce these laws against US citizens in US territory. That is a very blatant violation of US national sovereignty.
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by mike_hearn on Saturday November 08, 2025 @11:08PM (#45862821)
> PPS I know of no government that thinks it can enforce their law outside of their borders against foreigners.

The USA does this quite regularly. Look at FATCA as one example.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by hunterpayne on Saturday November 08, 2025 @11:51PM (#45862994)
That law only covers US citizens (that are living abroad). So no, that's not a counter example.
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by Hizonner on Sunday November 09, 2025 @12:03AM (#45863047)
Um, no, it attempts to compel foreign banks, which may not even have a presence in the US, to disclose information about US citizens, using various threats. It doesn't threaten to throw foreigners in jail, but it does threaten to use US government "clout" against them... and the actors it's trying to put obligations on are absolutely not US citizens.
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by hunterpayne on Sunday November 09, 2025 @12:24AM (#45863145)
Funny how you make tax evasion and money laundering on par with political speech. Fighting for your rights to be corrupt is a pretty weird take. If we can talk someone into doing what we want, that's perfectly legal as long as we or they aren't violating any laws. And nobody complains because getting dirty banks to spill is in everyone's best interests. Remember how happy everyone was at all the FIFA corruption data we uncovered.
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by hansvm on Sunday November 09, 2025 @01:06AM (#45863328)
It's only a tax evasion concern in the first place because the US started the trend of hoovering up wealth generated in other countries, which in-context still sounds like US overreach.

They weren't arguing for anyone's right to be corrupt in the first place though. If US citizens really have to pay extra taxes and have arduous reporting requirements then so be it, but why is the rest of the world dragged into that mess? This isn't a "dirty banks" issue; it's nearly impossible to get a bank account at any reputable institution as a US citizen abroad just because of the PITA of the reporting requirements. It's a mediocre law from questionable authority.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by deaux on Sunday November 09, 2025 @12:59AM (#45863300)
They didn't make anything on par, they gave an example of the US government enforcing US laws on foreign entities abroad.

Another example is that e.g. AWS Europe, even if every single one of its employees, board and what have it are all Germans, are still compelled to hand over their data if Amazon US is the parent company, under the likes of the CLOUD Act or FISA. That's a foreign entity comprised of foreign citizens and concerns the assets (data) of foreign citizens.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by rwarfield on Sunday November 09, 2025 @05:52AM (#45864648)
Besides the extraterritoriality issue, the other problem with FATCA is that it makes Americans living overseas (99% of whom are just normal people not trying to evade taxes) radioactive to overseas financial institutions because of the potential consequences of failing to report on someone's accounts properly.

Sadly a lot of Americans hear "foreign bank account" and immediately think "tax evasion" without realizing there are a lot of ordinary Americans overseas who just want to pay the rent and save for retirement but can't because Uncle Sam follows us wherever we go for life.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by mjlee on Sunday November 09, 2025 @09:55AM (#45865989)
Plenty of honest and law-abiding Americans living abroad have a hard time banking because of this law. Many banks simply won't accept American citizens as clients. Even those that will let you open a current account won't let you have anything more complex.

Just one example: https://help.revolut.com/help/wealth/stocks/licences-regulat...

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by mike_hearn on Sunday November 09, 2025 @09:00PM (#45871432)
No, it places requirements on all bankers worldwide regardless of whether they have any presence in the USA. This is enforced requiring compliance from all US banks, and then by making any bank that comes into compliance sever relationships with any peered bank that isn't in compliance, so via a sort of recursive graph walk it brings every bank globally under US law because every bank is ultimately connected to some US bank somewhere.
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by AnthonyMouse on Sunday November 09, 2025 @01:50AM (#45863486)
> The USA does this quite regularly. Look at FATCA as one example.

The problem here is that some twits did something like this once and since then everyone is saying "but look, they're doing it, why shouldn't we?" when they ought to be saying "we're all going to be imposing sanctions on that country until they stop doing that".

If someone is doing something, that's precedent -- but the precedent can either be "someone who does that can get away with it" or "someone who does that is not going to get away with it". And when making the decision, think through the consequences of everybody doing it to you if you allow it to be the first one.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by Nursie on Sunday November 09, 2025 @12:55AM (#45863283)
> Think about what happens if the US decides it can enforce US law on UK soil against UK citizens.

Yeah about that …

Try looking up Gary McKinnon or Larry Love. The US has a history of this stuff, those are just a couple of examples. Hell, Kim Dotcom (NZ but same deal).

And that’s before we get into whatever the f*ck was happening at Guantanamo Bay.

> I know of no government that thinks it can enforce their law outside of their borders against foreigners.

Then you haven’t been paying attention.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by verzali on Sunday November 09, 2025 @01:47AM (#45863471)
The US is quite literally killing people outside its borders every day. It even ran a program of kidnapping and torturing people from foreign countries for years, and still maintains a network of prisions outside America. The US very much thinks it can enforce its laws however and in whatever twisted fashion it likes.
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by exe34 on Sunday November 09, 2025 @04:38AM (#45864306)
> it can enforce its laws however and in whatever twisted fashion it likes.

The whims of its god-emperor/president. A lot of the enforcement is against US law.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by etiennebausson on Monday November 10, 2025 @01:36PM (#45879193)
That would be an acceptable response if it was just the last one president doing it, but it's been ongoing since WW2 at the very least.

I hold Russia as a whole accountable for Russia's recent war in Ukraine, it's their Responsibility to get rid of their leader when he started an unjustified invasion.

I hold the U.S. as a whole responsible for their successive presidents antics.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by dragonwriter on Sunday November 09, 2025 @01:58AM (#45863509)
> Think about what happens if the US decides it can enforce US law on UK soil against UK citizens.

The US has asserted that right globally for quite some time, and literally threatened force against other countries to get them to actively support (not merely tacitly permit) such enforcement, even when it directly violated the constitutions of the countries involved (as well as simply doing armed enforcement without consent of the government iinvolved in other cases.)

This has been particularly notable since the outset of the “Global War on Terror”, but didn’t start there (it was a big part of US counter-narcotics policy long before the GWoT.)

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by HPsquared on Sunday November 09, 2025 @06:06AM (#45864703)
There's a clear directionality there though. It doesn't work in reverse!
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by hexbin010 on Sunday November 09, 2025 @03:17AM (#45863859)
> I know of no government that thinks it can enforce their law outside of their borders against foreigners.

Really, not a single one? Like, a really big obvious one? LOL!

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by ndsipa_pomu on Sunday November 09, 2025 @06:55AM (#45864923)
> I know of no government that thinks it can enforce their law outside of their borders against foreigners. That is outside the definition of sovereignty and something the UK government seems to have invented lately.

The USA has been doing this for a long time e.g. Wikileaks and Julian Assange, Kim Dotcom etc.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by vintermann on Sunday November 09, 2025 @10:13AM (#45866124)
They have thought about it. They're betting on a global turn towards censorship and opinion control. "One hour before your time - no more!"
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by mellosouls on Saturday November 08, 2025 @09:56PM (#45862482)
Of course though, it is not just the governments that have force enabled by the internet and the modern age.

We need to re-imagine the Parisian as an individual with exceptionally long arms lighting the tip of their cigarette in London...

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by hexbin010 on Sunday November 09, 2025 @02:23AM (#45863616)
> "If Parliament says smoking in Paris is illegal, it is illegal."

I'm not entirely sure if you yourself understand the context or real meaning of that phrase, but for others at least, it was NOT meant to highlight that Parliament has a burning desire or real ability to legislate outside of its jurisdiction!

Just that it has the legal authority to create any such law, and that the legitimacy of a law is not dependent on its moral content. It's merely a paraphrasing/summary of H.L.A. Hart's legal positivism.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by alecmuffett on Sunday November 09, 2025 @03:06AM (#45863811)
What did Hart say about comity?
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by hexbin010 on Sunday November 09, 2025 @03:16AM (#45863853)
Why don't you tell us?
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by vessenes on Sunday November 09, 2025 @03:13PM (#45868746)
I think I got us there, when I mentioned that they had no means of enforcement, and so the statement was meant as you say - to be absurdist in practice underscoring the national sovereignty at the heart of the discussion. Is that what you think it means, out of curiosity?
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by ekidd on Sunday November 09, 2025 @06:15AM (#45864748)
> It's a matter of UK law and, I'd bet, many countries, that they have the sovereign right to legislate about matters in and outside their borders.

As I mentioned elsewhere in this thread, the entire founding political mythology of the United States is pretty much "The Parliament of the UK tried to regulate our freedom of speech without even giving us a vote, and that was intolerable." Specifically, the Stamp Act was seen as suppressing the right of the American colonies to engage in political speech. (This wasn't the only reason for the Revolutionary War, but it's one of the ones we still remember. We remember it in part because laws regulating the publishers of political pamphlets get complained about in political pamphlets.)

This isn't a political issue in the normal sense. It's more like Guy Fawkes and the "gunpowder treason and plot." The one thing that the "Tea Party" and the "No Kings" protestors can probably still agree about is that the Stamp Act was bad, because this issue is part of the fundamental political mythology of the country. "The British Parliament does not get to regulate our speech" is right up there with "The President does not get to wear a crown."

This is not a fight that the UK government can actually win, not in the long run. Any US politician who allows Parliament to regulate the speech of a US citizen will find themselves in the awkward position of British politician who proposed a national monument to Guy Fawkes. Allowing this is "Un-American" in these sense that it goes almost directly against our founding patriotic mythology and symbolism.

The UK should just accept the geo-IP block of the UK as a compromise, and walk away. This particular fight isn't worth it. Trust me on this.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by BeFlatXIII on Sunday November 09, 2025 @10:05AM (#45866048)
> nations to enforce their own rules outside their own borders by treaty

More democratically-elected legislatures ought to say, “We don't give a shit about what our predecessors agreed to.” when it comes to treaties requiring restrictions on their own citizens.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by owl_vision on Saturday November 08, 2025 @06:55PM (#45861387)
what happens if an IP address is not in the geo db? For example: 2606:4700::6811:
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by ChocolateGod on Saturday November 08, 2025 @06:58PM (#45861409)
You check the country the ASN behind the IP belongs to.
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by matt-p on Saturday November 08, 2025 @07:33PM (#45861691)
ASN is even worse, honestly. If I'm behind starlinks AS then I'm American? AWS, I'm also American? Level 3? American. Colt leased line in my office in Madrid, apparently I'm English.
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by teekert on Saturday November 08, 2025 @07:54PM (#45861838)
You are whatever you VPN exit node is.
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by greyface- on Saturday November 08, 2025 @07:22PM (#45861617)
RIRs don't prohibit out-of-region use of IP addresses or ASNs registered in their region. The country an IP is registered in is not necessarily the country it's being used in.
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by ranger_danger on Sunday November 09, 2025 @02:25PM (#45868348)
And they are routinely used in exactly this confusing fashion.
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by inemesitaffia on Sunday November 09, 2025 @03:25AM (#45863888)
SOFTNET EUROPE CORP. 6811 Ayala Avenue, Makaty City, Metro Manila, Philippines
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by OptionOfT on Saturday November 08, 2025 @06:45PM (#45861284)
If I recall correctly, this is how the GDPR works. If someone to who the GDPR applies to visits a website, a website cannot record any information about them, regardless of whether that website actually is based in the EU, which is why certain US websites block traffic from the EU.

Source: https://gdpr.eu/companies-outside-of-europe/

    1. This Regulation applies to the processing of personal data in the context of the activities of an establishment of a controller or a processor in the Union, regardless of whether the processing takes place in the Union or not.

    2. This Regulation applies to the processing of personal data of data subjects who are in the Union by a controller or processor not established in the Union, where the processing activities are related to:

        (a) the offering of goods or services, irrespective of whether a payment of the data subject is required, to such data subjects in the Union; or

        (b) the monitoring of their behaviour as far as their behaviour takes place within the Union.

    3. This Regulation applies to the processing of personal data by a controller not established in the Union, but in a place where Member State law applies by virtue of public international law.


E.g. the website in this article https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45819635 does not work when you visit it with a European IP address. You get an error 451.
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by aDyslecticCrow on Saturday November 08, 2025 @06:56PM (#45861397)
> If I'm operating a Web site in country A, I should not have to care about country B's laws

Not defending UK's idiotic laws, but this doesn't hold. If you cannot regulate websites outside of the country of origin, then no internet regulation can hold for any subject. Openly selling stolen personal credentials or botnet usage? Piracy? Reselling personal information without disclosure?

So there are effectively three options for internet regulation;

- Require websites to operate region by region with IP blocks for any non-target market. This is much of EU law is applied. If you put an effort to not serve EU costumers, you can skip following EU rules. "comply or leave"

- Any country can regulate any website regardless of origin, like the UK seems to push for. This is an insane proposal and could easily create geopolitical disputes. Great firewall and banning VPNs would be the only proper way to achieve what they seem to aim for.... which i wouldn't put past them by now.

- Give up regulating the internet entirely. Some level of regulation is valuable so I don't think this will ever work. There are simply some things illegal and deplorable enough to require laws.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by Hizonner on Saturday November 08, 2025 @07:06PM (#45861479)
> no internet regulation can hold for any subject

No Internet regulation can hold extraterritorially. You leave out the obvious and most important case: the country where the Web site or whatever is located enforcing its own laws. Which is actually how all law has mostly worked from day one.

> Openly selling stolen personal credentials or botnet usage? Piracy? Reselling personal information without disclosure?

If you find a jurisdiction where those are all legal, then I guess you just have to block your citizens from reaching it, or punish them if they do. Not particularly tricky.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by aDyslecticCrow on Saturday November 08, 2025 @07:31PM (#45861675)
> Which is actually how all law has mostly worked from day one.

Internet but not for any other commerce. If you sell products to someone in the EU, you are liable to EU laws about that product category and commercial activity. The internet is the only exception, and that has caused a lot of problems.

IP block is the currently the only reasonable way to apply laws to internet based commerce. It has its flaws in accuracy; but ISPs could easily create a system to make them more reliable for IP lookup. Arguing that websites cannot be regulated outside of country of origin is an insane position to take with even the minimal level of hypothetical reasoning of what that would imply.

UKs laws are dumb, but they should be free to enforce them for websites operating in the UK. And websites should be able to leave the UK to avoid complying. This is a reasonable compromise that is already how both US and EU internet laws operate.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by Hizonner on Saturday November 08, 2025 @07:48PM (#45861791)
> Internet but not for any other commerce. If you sell products to someone in the EU, you are liable to EU laws about that product category and commercial activity. The internet is the only exception, and that has caused a lot of problems.

I don't know the state of play now, and I do know that things have gotten more that way over time. But the traditional approach to international product sales is that the importer is responsible. That originally meant the person who physically brought it into the country. As common carriers became more common, it meant the person who ordered the thing. That's occasionally been leavened by some consideration of whether the seller specifically targeted customers in the receiving country. And nowadays there's more of a tendency to start "blaming" sellers in some cases, probably because nowadays "importing" something is often a retail order from a specific consumer, as opposed to somebody bringing in a shipping container on spec to resell. Maybe some of those changes are appropriate, but it's just not true that physical goods have always been treated the way you want Web sites treated here, or even that they're mostly treated that way now.

> IP block is the currently the only reasonable way to apply laws to internet based commerce.

"IP block" works in both directions.

If you want to keep something out of your country, you should be responsible for blocking it, not the other way around. That's not necessarily easy, but it's less costly in total than demanding that every Web site enforce every country's regulation... and it has the advantage of putting the cost of a regulation on the people imposing it, which is where it belongs.

> It has its flaws in accuracy; but ISPs could easily create a system to make them more reliable for IP lookup.

From your use of the word "easily", I conclude that you personally would not be among those responsible for making that work.

> Arguing that websites cannot be regulated outside of country of origin is an insane position to take with even the minimal level of hypothetical reasoning of what that would imply.

First, you can in fact "regulate" by blocking, without trying to extend the reach of your laws outside of your border. Your claim that a regulator is left totally powerless is just false.

Second, in practice, that "hypothetical" is pretty close to what we have now, and even closer to what we had 10 years ago. The world did not end.

> UKs laws are dumb, but they should be free to enforce them for websites operating in the UK

Sure, as long as we recognize that "operating in the UK" properly means "is physically located in or controlled from the UK" and not "happens to be accessible to people in the UK". The latter definition would indeed be insane.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by miki123211 on Saturday November 08, 2025 @07:21PM (#45861608)
Another option is an anti-money-laundering like system.

It would need to be set up by an extremely powerful country, either the US or an alliance of smaller countries through international treaty.

It would work as follows:

There'd be a "naughty list." Anybody on the list would be arrested upon entering a participating country. This would include past or current company employees (if employed after the listing date). Companies from participating countries would be prohibited from interacting with listed organizations in any way, under treat of sanctions. This would include VPN, cloud and hosting companies, ISPs, domain registrars, email hosts, payment processors and ad networks. This would provide basic site blocking.

Foreign companies wouldn't be subject to the sanctions, but participating countries would also put them on the list.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by vessenes on Saturday November 08, 2025 @07:28PM (#45861661)
You're aware this exists, yes? It's called the OFAC list. It's not generally used to list technologists or web sites related to speech, though, as far as I know.
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by tatersolid on Sunday November 09, 2025 @10:31PM (#45872080)
Interestingly many, if not most cybercrime organizations are on the OFAC list. So many companies who have paid when hit by ransomware have violated US law.

I am unaware of any prosecutions in this area.

https://ofac.treasury.gov/sanctions-programs-and-country-inf...

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by cultureulterior on Saturday November 08, 2025 @07:24PM (#45861633)
> then no internet regulation can hold for any subject

Good

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by iamnothere on Saturday November 08, 2025 @07:00PM (#45861437)
If country B doesn’t like it, block the site in question.

You’re not going to extradite US site operators, period. Find another approach.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by aDyslecticCrow on Saturday November 08, 2025 @07:17PM (#45861572)
Then no country should have legal authority over companies operating in the country but based internationally. You could earn a lot of money by selling unregistered firearms, pipe bombs or drugs over the internet and sending it over the border.

"If country B doesn’t like it, block the mail in question". Saying only the country of origin can regulate activity done in another country creates a legal worm-bucket with vast implications. It's also not how laws work currently in pretty much any other sector than the internet.

IP block should be sufficient to void the laws; That's how other EU laws work. If the UK wants more than than then they should just create a firewall. But saying the internet should be a fully unregulated hellscape is not a sensible position here.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by iamnothere on Saturday November 08, 2025 @07:29PM (#45861663)
> "If country B doesn’t like it, block the mail in question"

That’s actually how it works? Unless you have an extradition agreement, or military overmatch, or you are willing to expend some diplomatic leverage, you are typically not getting a citizen out of a foreign country. The government complains about this all the time with goods from SE Asia, and sometimes they seize fake designer goods and make a lot of noise about it. But the people making the knockoffs just keep on making them, don’t they?

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by aDyslecticCrow on Saturday November 08, 2025 @07:47PM (#45861780)
just because a law is difficult to enforce doesn't make it not exist. There are laws for this, and they are enforced. If you aint caught its not illegal?
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by iamnothere on Saturday November 08, 2025 @07:58PM (#45861868)
Typically one-sided laws are not enforced against citizens of foreign countries except in rare cases, because it creates diplomatic friction. Countries really don’t like it when you arrest their citizens for things that aren’t illegal at home. And when one country has enormous leverage over another, it’s a bad idea for the less powerful country to attempt enforcement. A visa ban would usually be a more appropriate tactic.
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by Silhouette on Saturday November 08, 2025 @09:26PM (#45862358)
Then no country should have legal authority over companies operating in the country but based internationally.

But this is the real issue. To what extent is a company "operating in" a country where it has no staff and no physical presence?

The principle that someone should become subject to the laws of a country they've never visited and where they have no assets just because they communicated with someone else who does live in that country seems questionable. Even if money is sent by the person living in that country to someone based elsewhere it still seems questionable.

Taken to their logical conclusion these kinds of arguments would kill off a lot of the value of the modern Internet (assuming they could be practically enforced). Can you even write a blog post any more if it might be controversial in any country in the world? Do you have to pay if you show ads next to that blog post and someone from the Sovereign Republic Of East Nowhere visits - but the Sovereign Republic Of East Nowhere has a law prohibiting online advertising as a social harm and imposing a fine of 1000% of global revenues generated through ads? What happens when the laws of two different countries are in direct conflict and one requires you to include an official warning of some kind alongside certain information on your blog but the other one prohibits such statements unless you're formally qualified to give advice in the field?

If you want to interfere with international trade or international communications at all then it makes far more sense practically - and arguably both morally and legally as well - to legislate so that your own people in your own country who are subject to your own laws are the ones who must or must not act in a certain way. If there's some kind of regulation on physical goods then make the person importing those goods responsible for compliance. If you want to tax international transactions then make the person in your country who is participating in those transactions responsible for declaring and paying the tax. But realistically this leads to a lot of non-compliance because your citizens don't have to be experts in international tax law so you can collect your $1.53 when they bought a new T-shirt from some online store based in another country and had it shipped.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by kelnos on Saturday November 08, 2025 @10:51PM (#45862746)
> Then no country should have legal authority over companies operating in the country but based internationally.

Not sure I see how your logic has led you there. If a company (regardless of where they are headquartered) is operating in your country, then you necessarily have some sort of jurisdiction over it:

- If they are using servers or domain names hosted in your country, you can seize them.

- If they are making use of your country's financial system, you can ban them from that system.

- If they are shipping physical products to your country's residents, you can intercept those packages at customs.

- If any employees (or, better, officers) of that company are physically present in your country, you can fine or arrest them if they don't comply.

- If you have an extradition treaty with the country where they're operating, you can ask that country for help. If they decline, that's unfortunate for you, but that's life.

And right, in the end, if there's no "presence" aside from people in your country accessing foreign websites, then you can (given the right legal mechanisms) order ISPs in your country to block those sites. I don't see why any foreign-operated website should have any obligation to examine your laws and pro-actively block your residents from their site if needed; if you want your laws enforced on your residents, then... enforce them on your residents.

> But saying the internet should be a fully unregulated hellscape is not a sensible position here.

While I do see a few low-effort comments to that effect, I don't think that's a common opinion here. I don't even think the person you're replying to holds that opinion.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by sleepybrett on Saturday November 08, 2025 @11:13PM (#45862846)
We have treaties with other contries to cover most of these cases and customs to cover many others.

What the UK is doing is claiming, without having dealt with this via treaty that I am somehow responsible for keeping their citizens off my website. This is not something they can actually do. Now if they made a deal with my country that said that I had to in some way we'd be in a different universe. But currently they do not.

As I, and probably many others, see it. If they don't want UK citizens visiting 4chan or whereever they should control the flow of data through their borders better and punish their citizens for data smuggling if they vpn their way around it. It's no different than prohibited goods like automatic weapons. If I send someone in the UK a fully automatic ak-47 (which is legal in my juristiction) then I suspect UK customs will catch it at the border and possibly jail, or at least have a stern talking to the recipient.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by mlhpdx on Saturday November 08, 2025 @07:04PM (#45861470)
That’s what they’re doing
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by iamnothere on Saturday November 08, 2025 @07:13PM (#45861543)
No, they are making threats about the site in country A while the site has voluntarily blocked all of country B, with country B saying that this isn’t enough, despite the operators in country A being out of jurisdiction and making an effort to comply regardless. Country B is basically saying that the site in country A is not allowed on the internet at all.
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by pirates on Saturday November 08, 2025 @07:21PM (#45861605)
It’s not at all what they’re doing, and claiming so is either extreme ignorance of the situation or deliberately lying.
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by kelnos on Saturday November 08, 2025 @10:43PM (#45862712)
> If you cannot regulate websites outside of the country of origin, then no internet regulation can hold for any subject.

It can, but instead of forcing other people to follow your laws, you have to block your country's residents from accessing the sites that break your laws.

I'm not saying I love this method either (China is famously very good at it, and I don't think their methods foster a healthy society), but I believe it should be the only lever you have. Forcing people outside your jurisdiction to follow your laws is a violation of another country's sovereignty.

As an aside, should I take pains to ensure any website I operate follows the laws of North Korea? Iran? China? Russia? Should we be complacent and accepting if HN were to be targeted by any of those governments because people here have undoubtedly said unflattering things about the leaders of those countries?

Of course not. But even though we're talking about a "friend"-type country here, it's not any different.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by N0RMAN on Saturday November 08, 2025 @06:45PM (#45861288)
I don’t understand the IP location criticism at all. At least for my experience across Europe all locations that are being reported by the common databases are within 250km of the actual customer.
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by paranoidrobot on Saturday November 08, 2025 @07:57PM (#45861855)
IP locations work great for probably a reasonably large chunk of services.

But it's the edges that get you.

I moved home a few years back, connected a new service with the same ISP.

They have an IP pool that is labelled as for one state (Victoria, Australia) but is also used for their services in Tasmania.

So now I have to fight every major website (Google, Amazon, Maxmind, etc) that does GeoIP lookups that I'm not in Victoria, I'm 500-800KM away.

Google was very confused for about 12 months because when I moved I also brought my wifi gear and so it would give me a precise location of my old address because it used wifi geolocation.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by matt-p on Saturday November 08, 2025 @07:51PM (#45861819)
Maybe this is very european of me but 250KM is outrageously far. Dublin to Belfast is like 130KM. If it says they're in Seville (in Spain) within <200KM they could also be in Portugal, Morocco, or Gibraltar. If it says you're in Brussels within <200KM you could also be in France, England, Germany, Netherlands, Lux. If you're in Vienna (Austria), you could also be in Germany, CZ, Slovakia, Hungary, Slovenia or Croatia. Maybe you're in Vilnius? You could also be in Latvia, Poland, Russia or Belarus.

Comedically far.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by rstuart4133 on Tuesday November 11, 2025 @04:46AM (#45885664)
It's short by Australian standards. I was born 1000km away. It's a 12 hour drive. I've done it numerous times. It was a regular thing when I was young.

Uni students have been know to drive for a drink at the pub at the next Uni north (at the time) over the weekend for a lark. That's 2000km, one way.

A serious undertaking by Australian standards is a drive to Perth. That's 5000km in a straight line, but of course you can't drive in a straight line to Perth.

I met a guy once who was the last leg of circumnavigating Australia on his push bike. It had taken him years, and it looked like it. I've never seen someone so wirey, so obviously fit. Yet he rode at a slow measured pace. That was no doubt a habit forced by the trailer his bike towed. I guess the trip was around 15,000km.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by Hizonner on Saturday November 08, 2025 @06:46PM (#45861303)
The criticism is that it exists, which invites abuse. Being more accurate would be worse.
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by refulgentis on Saturday November 08, 2025 @06:54PM (#45861380)
When you put it that way, well, it made me chuckle. (The irony!)
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by mlhpdx on Saturday November 08, 2025 @06:44PM (#45861275)
I don’t agree that choosing to host a website without limiting the audience is innocent. It’s a choice, and has been the default for a long time, but it means one has chosen to speak outside the borders of their own country and that comes with rules, like them or not.
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by landl0rd on Saturday November 08, 2025 @06:45PM (#45861293)
No, one has chosen to make something available for contact within one country. One is not actively himself reaching across borders to do so. One cannot reasonably be required to take any affirmative action to fulfill the whims of a foreign government.

Also, Britain isn't important enough to make this stick against e.g. an American.

If someone writes me a letter asking a question about material that is prohibited in his own country, that is not my problem. It is his responsibility to comply with local law and that of local government to seize material that is illegal there. They cannot deputize me to act, unpaid and without consent, on their behalf.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by gpm on Saturday November 08, 2025 @06:48PM (#45861322)
What is having your web server send IP packets with an IP address addressed to an overseas address to your ISP who you have signed a contract with to have them deliver those packets to the designated address if not actively reaching across borders?

That's what happens when you respond to a request after all. (Up to very minor nits, e.g. you might be paying a cloud provider instead of an ISP).

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by landl0rd on Saturday November 08, 2025 @06:51PM (#45861354)
It is a reply. I am not responsible for checking the locality of an IP address. Indeed, I can never do so with one hundred per cent accuracy. It is Not My Problem.

Governments that expect some content or other blocked can damn well do it themselves, in their own legal system. They cannot compel someone else to spend his time, talent, or treasure to enforce their petty rules.

If they go after one of their own for requesting something from me, whatever. If they block me, whatever. I suppose they're within their rights to do that.

The federal government "deputizing" or trying to chill private actors out of speech, out of doing business, etc. is a violation of Americans' first amendment rights; so held SCOTUS last year. No way in h--- are we letting some tinpot foreigner do so.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by gpm on Saturday November 08, 2025 @06:57PM (#45861406)
It is a reply... that you chose to send despite being fully aware that by doing so you might be reaching out across borders because that's how the internet and your contracts with your service providers works.

Governments can do whatever they damn well please in their own territory. Including arresting you if you ever visit because you violated some law that they wrote that applies to people in the rest of the world, or even you violated some law that a friend of theirs (i.e. a country with an extradition treaty) wrote to apply to people in the rest of the world. If those actions compel people to spend their time, talent, or treasure to enforce their petty rules then they can do that.

Whatever "actively reaching out" standard you are imagining doesn't exist in the first place. Even if it did though, you clearly violated it when you sent the reply to the request actively aware that it could go across borders.

SCOTUS (with an emphasis on the US) decisions seem rather irrelevant to non-US actors.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by Hizonner on Saturday November 08, 2025 @07:57PM (#45861853)
The US will enforce most UK court judgements. I'm not sure how administrative fines work; there might be a need to involve a court first, but once that's done the US will [on edit- may] enforce them.

The US will not enforce UK judgements or fines if enforcing them is contrary to the US' own laws, including its Constitution. SCOTUS ultimately decides when that's the case.

So it's really, really relevant to whether a non-US actor like Ofcom can actually collect fines from people inside the US. That's a separate question from what the UK government can do to people from the US who actually enter the UK, and an important one.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by gpm on Saturday November 08, 2025 @08:20PM (#45861997)
Sure... I think it's pretty much a given that Ofcom expects the US won't help them enforce this law given the 1st amendment. That doesn't mean they won't/shouldn't do their best to do so by themselves..
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by kelnos on Saturday November 08, 2025 @11:09PM (#45862827)
> That doesn't mean they won't/shouldn't do their best to do so by themselves.

If I were a UK citizen or resident, I'd probably be pretty pissed off that Ofcom was wasting money and resources on battles they are going to lose. Well, I suppose, since Ofcom is funded in large part by the UK-based businesses it regulates, if I were an officer, employee, or shareholder of one of those companies, I'd be pissed that they're wasting money paid by my company to fund them.

And even though Ofcom is not directly a UK government agency, there are certainly political costs to tilting at windmills for the UK government.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by hunterpayne on Saturday November 08, 2025 @09:43PM (#45862421)
That's exactly what it means. Actions have costs. Actions this stupid have big costs. If a task is impossible and even trying has a cost, its best to do nothing. Ofcom are bureaucrats, I'm sure they are well practiced at doing nothing anyway.

Starmer's approval rating is under 20% now and his party doesn't have a snowball's chance in hell of holding on to power. Labour has dropped to 4th in the current polls. He is the most unpopular PM in UK history. Dumb things like this are probably part of why. So continuing the same hopeless and unpopular actions is probably a bad idea. I don't think he can jail enough UK citizens to keep himself in power.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by kelnos on Saturday November 08, 2025 @11:05PM (#45862809)
> It is a reply... that you chose to send despite being fully aware that by doing so you might be reaching out across borders because that's how the internet and your contracts with your service providers works.

I think you're looking at it the wrong way. I'm not thinking about that at all. I do not care about that at all. I am not beholden to the laws of any other nation when I operate my website[0]. I don't care about "reaching out across borders". I don't event know the geographical origin of requests that hit my server, because I don't care, and I have no need or desire to hook up some sort of (error-prone) geoIP database to my logs in order to categorize requests. Once the HTTP response packets leave my server and hit the first router hop, I have no knowledge or interest in where they end up after that.

> SCOTUS (with an emphasis on the US) decisions seem rather irrelevant to non-US actors.

Not sure why you're bringing that up, as GP didn't mention SCOTUS at all. But as a US citizen and resident, SCOTUS' rulings are all that matter to me when it comes to what I personally do while at home. If SCOTUS says the content on my website is legal based on US law, then I don't really care whether or not it's legal in other countries[0, again], and I shouldn't really have to; life is too short to have to worry about that sort of thing.

[0] Sure, I agree with you that this could be a problem for me if I do break any of their laws, and then later decide I want to visit that country. It could also be a problem if that country has an extradition treaty with mine, and my country is for some reason incentivized to give me up.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by imtringued on Sunday November 09, 2025 @01:16PM (#45867707)
>that you chose to send despite being fully aware that by doing so you might be reaching out across borders because that's how the internet and your contracts with your service providers works.

As mentioned in my previous reply, this isn't how the internet works. There is no teleportation or ICBM delivering the packets. There is infrastructure spanning borders and the infrastructure is the thing that is ignoring the laws. The infrastructure has accurate geographic knowledge about the physical connections. The webserver doesn't have that information at all and must infer it. From the perspective of the webserver, the physical world might not exist at all. There is no such thing that can be described as awareness from the website operators perspective. IP addresses do not encode geographic information. The entire point of the OSI layer model is that the higher layers know nothing about the lower layers nor do they know anything about the physical location of the nodes.

Again, only the operator of the network has that information and the operator is located inside the UK. It is those network operators in the UK that are wilfully ignorant and aware of the things you claim a website operator from a far away country should be aware of.

Just think about how ridiculous your comment is if you sued someone in the US from the UK and brought up their awareness. How would you prove that they knew the location of every single router and fiber cable the packets are traveling through? That's what you're arguing here. You're arguing that there is full and complete awareness.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by refulgentis on Saturday November 08, 2025 @06:56PM (#45861396)
“ Governments that expect some content or other blocked can damn well do it themselves, in their own legal system”

What you are describing is exactly what is going on here. OFCAM’s final action, if taken, is blocking at ISP level. All of the legal stuff is happening in the UK system.

I’m just sort of curious for your thoughts after learning that.

(Also, I’m curious about the SCOTUS decision, I.e. which one? I used to be a law nerd and got a kick out of reading oral arguments for the first time in years this week, would appreciate more material)

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by landl0rd on Saturday November 08, 2025 @07:24PM (#45861631)
No, it's also able to do things like issue fines, which they have, although American law is not amenable to actually collecting those if their assets are all here. I don't really care if british choose to block something on british soil.

Murthy v. Missouri was generally a loss; 6-3 with Justice Barrett for the majority ruling states lacked standing, which is consistent with the Roberts court's informal policy of dodging. Alito dissented, joined by Thomas and I think Gorsuch, and that is worth a read. The more important one was NRA v. Vullo, a unanimous opinion from Sotomayor. Gorsuch wrote a concurrence as did I believe one other justice.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by mbac32768 on Saturday November 08, 2025 @09:32PM (#45862377)
The remarkable thing about Murthy is it was bipartisan, with the 3 dissenters being conservative.
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by charcircuit on Saturday November 08, 2025 @08:51PM (#45862177)
You can't but ISPs could if they wanted to. Someone knows the billing or contact information of the person originating the packets.
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by imtringued on Sunday November 09, 2025 @01:05PM (#45867600)
You seem grossly misinformed about how the internet works. The server isn't located in the country that made the request. There is an entire network between the server and the client. A part of that network exists in the US and another part of it exists in the UK.

The network infrastructure is the thing that is performing the delivery that is actively reaching across borders. Not the webserver.

The entire HN submission is full of people saying that it is the UK networks responsibility to make sure that their laws are upheld and that anything happening inside US borders is simply people going above and beyond in assisting the UK in the pursuit of the enforcement of its laws. The geoblocks on the side of the webserver are a form of optional assistance and a sign of goodwill.

Meanwhile Ofcom seems to be of the opinion that this isn't enough yet they simultaneously do nothing about the violators physically located in the UK. This means they are going out of their way to make an unenforceable and impossible to implement law so that they can manufacture probable cause.

Website operators can give the UK a list of IPs to block, which would make it very easy for the UK to enforce their own laws even against VPNs, but it is only the UK that is capable of doing that, and they are shirking their responsibility onto those who can't do it on their behalf.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by HPsquared on Saturday November 08, 2025 @07:06PM (#45861480)
The client requests content from a server. The server may be abroad. It's the same as ordering goods from abroad, only much faster. I wonder what the law is for importing goods that are illegal in the destination country.
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by em-bee on Saturday November 08, 2025 @07:18PM (#45861576)
whatever the laws are, they are the responsibility of the importer, not the producer.
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by kelnos on Saturday November 08, 2025 @11:13PM (#45862844)
It's really the same principle. For physical goods that are crossing borders, but are illegal in the destination country, their customs officials can seize the goods. For data packets on the internet, the destination country is free to block them if they find them objectionable.
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by aDyslecticCrow on Saturday November 08, 2025 @07:00PM (#45861431)
If someone writes you a letter than they have your family hostage, and to route 50.000 dollars thorough bitcoin to not have them killed, with a AI generated video as proof; are they scott free because they're not based in the US?
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by Hizonner on Saturday November 08, 2025 @07:23PM (#45861620)
First of all, this is about Web sites, and that's not a valid analogy. Web sites don't spontaneously send you letters, let alone kidnap you. You only get content you actively asked for.

Second, where is the person writing the letter from? Mars? They're going to have a hard time finding a place where kidnapping and extortion are legal.

Third, the letter would in fact presumably be aimed at a specific person in a specific country... as would the kidnapping.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by aDyslecticCrow on Saturday November 08, 2025 @08:02PM (#45861895)
Websites absolutely spontaneously send letters, or advertising flyers.

The company could be from china or Russia with little interest in diplomatic pandering for such a small incident.

Providing a user a service in exchange for payment is also aimed at a specific person in a specific country.

heck, if no laws can be applied across borders, it could be a website selling the service of fake extortion letters.

And don't mix up "difficult to enforce" with "legal". Constantly changing domains and hiding who is behind the service are efforts to avoid being caught by very real and enforced laws.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by HotGarbage on Saturday November 08, 2025 @06:48PM (#45861328)
Yeah, nah, the internet is pull not push. If a citizen of country A seeks material from country B that's legal in B but illegal in A that's on them.
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by patrickmay on Saturday November 08, 2025 @06:52PM (#45861364)
This is the key point. No site is sending material to the UK unsolicited. People in the UK are initiating the download of information they find of interest. If the UK government has a problem with that, it's on them to block the downloads on their side. UK laws have no power outside the UK.
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by _DeadFred_ on Saturday November 08, 2025 @07:37PM (#45861713)
If you choose to call my automated joke line running off of an answering machine in my home, do I have to follow your country's laws or my own?
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by snickerbockers on Saturday November 08, 2025 @08:00PM (#45861880)
It actually doesn't lmao.
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by Hizonner on Saturday November 08, 2025 @06:50PM (#45861351)
> I don’t agree that choosing to host a website without limiting the audience is innocent.

"Innocent"? That's a strange word to choose. Who cares what's "innocent"?

> It’s a choice, and has been the default for a long time, but it means one has chosen to speak outside the borders of their own country and that comes with rules, like them or not.

... or it means one has chosen to speak inside the borders of their country, and people outside those borders have chosen to import that speech. Web sites don't lob speech at you willy-nilly.

The bottom line is that that standard is impractical to implement, illiberal in its effects, and just generally a bad idea. For that matter, it's also at odds with most of the ways the world treats trade in physical goods.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by Alex2037 on Saturday November 08, 2025 @06:57PM (#45861400)
are your websites compliant with Russian, Chinese, and Iranian laws and online regulations?
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by kstrauser on Saturday November 08, 2025 @10:41PM (#45862705)
Beat me to it. This is my go-to analogy for people who don't understand the problem. I am 100% certain I've violated North Korean law by posting mean things about Dear Leader. I couldn't care less. If I were to find myself in NK, I'm sure I'd care a lot, but that's not going to happen, so I don't.

If I'm not afraid of violating NK law — because I'll never, ever be there — then the same logic holds for the laws of every other country I won't be visiting.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by kelnos on Saturday November 08, 2025 @10:58PM (#45862778)
That's absurd. If I put up a website that I believe is lawful in my own country, I'm not even thinking about people in other countries. If people from elsewhere access it, it's up to them to ensure that the content on my site complies with their local laws.

If the government of their country believes that accessing my website is a problem for their residents, then the onus is on them to sort it out on their own, without my involvement. They are perfectly capable of ordering ISPs that operate inside their borders to block my website from their customers.

The fact that Ofcom hasn't just done something like this in the case of SaSu, 4chan, etc., shows that they are not actually interested in "online safety"; they're making political statements and are trying to throw their weight around like the bullies they clearly are.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by nine_k on Saturday November 08, 2025 @09:17PM (#45862316)
If you operate a website outside UK and that's it, you may not care. But if you offer paid servies, collect money from UK citizens, you must have a business representation in the UK, which is bound by UK laws, can be fined, dragged to a court, etc. If you have this vulnerability, or you don't but your holding company has other web properties that do, the UK government has a way to make you listen and comply.
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by hbrav on Saturday November 08, 2025 @10:02PM (#45862527)
> But if you offer paid servies, collect money from UK citizens, you must have a business representation in the UK

I don't think that's true at all. You be taking payment by credit card, which doesn't require you to have any local presence.

I think your bigger risk is that you get a judgement made against you by a UK court, which a court that has jurisdiction over you is willing to enforce. I'm not sure under what circumstances that is the case, but I believe that it being the case with libel judgements has been an issue for a while (since plaintiffs can 'forum shop').

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by sometimes_all on Sunday November 09, 2025 @12:12AM (#45863087)
> You be taking payment by credit card, which doesn't require you to have any local presence.

But you're offering an online product, plus you are taking money from people from all over the world, whose governments have different regulations and points of view, your own business charges differently for different countries, and credit card providers are bound to different fees and/or extra charges for international transactions.

It's not a simple solution.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by cortesoft on Sunday November 09, 2025 @12:12AM (#45863088)
The example website in this case doesn’t take any payment, it appears.
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by toast0 on Saturday November 08, 2025 @11:43PM (#45862954)
You ship me money, I ship you product. I don't need presence in your country, you don't need presence in mine. If your country doesn't like my product, they can enforce against you (or block it at the border).

I broadcast radio from my country, according to the rules of my country. If you tune in, and your country doesn't like it, they can enforce on you or broadcast something else on the same frequency if that's allowed by their rules.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by jen20 on Saturday November 08, 2025 @10:22PM (#45862619)
> collect money from UK citizens

This is quite obviously incorrect. I am a UK citizen, but live in the US. No company needs a UK presence to collect money from me.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by swores on Sunday November 09, 2025 @01:43AM (#45863460)
And to be clear, that’s still true for selling services online to UK citizens who are also UK residents, it’s not a quirk of you having moved away from the UK - it’s just not true that you need a legal presence in the UK to serve customers from the UK.
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by jen20 on Sunday November 09, 2025 @10:10AM (#45866093)
Indeed, I also believe that to be the case but went with the trivial counterexample! Probably best to be explicit though.
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by vintermann on Sunday November 09, 2025 @10:23AM (#45866194)
It may become an issue if you expect the British government to help you collect your debts, retrieve your stolen property, enforce your contacts etc. I'm all in favor of governments restricting how the it citizens can make money, or how you can make money on their citizens.

But we're clearly far beyond that here.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by EGreg on Saturday November 08, 2025 @10:00PM (#45862509)
Why don't people just build decentralized smart contracts these days? Why worry about all these liabilities?
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by llbbdd on Saturday November 08, 2025 @10:28PM (#45862662)
Because crypto is a liability itself and nobody normal likes interacting with it.
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by AnthonyMouse on Sunday November 09, 2025 @12:25AM (#45863153)
Is there no way to improve the user experience for this?

Company A sells cryptocurrency in country A. Company B is a payment processor in country B. You in country A go to the country B merchant's website and enter your card info to buy something. Your card gets charged by company A to buy cryptocurrency, the merchant gets the money through company B and the transfer of cryptocurrency from company A to company B happens in software on a server somewhere and the user doesn't have to do anything.

Why is this either not happening or not sufficient?

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by EGreg on Tuesday November 11, 2025 @08:10AM (#45886880)
You are right and HN has no answer other than “crypto is bad”.

We are building exactly this at Intercoin. I hate that most of crypto is zero-sum games. https://intercoin.org/currencies.pdf

Also Stripe is launching Tempo blockchain, USDC is launching Arc blockchain. Cool things are coming!

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by llbbdd on Thursday November 13, 2025 @11:39PM (#45923894)
It's not even that crypto is bad, it's that it's not good. The user experience is bad universally. I say this as a tech person that didn't care about it as a technology and had to deal with it anyway and I can't stand it. The first crypto service to actually, God forbid, go study Stripe, Shopify, Google Pay, Apple Pay, please understand, actually understand how people pay for things and compete with their actual competitors in a real way, is going to steal the show I'm sure. Until then it's crypto scammers competing for crypto users and crypto dollars and again no normal people want to put up with this shit at all because it's a stupid game and we're just trying to buy things.

EDIT: I clicked on the PDF out of a sense of good faith interest and curiosity and I regret it. I hope you find something else to do.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by llbbdd on Thursday November 13, 2025 @11:47PM (#45923935)
Because one of the functions of government currency is keeping things like prices stable for the sanity of normal people buying food and gas, against the type of upheaval and reactionary change that a global currency is susceptible to. Bitcoin/crypto enthusiasts have historically pretended that stable prices are not important, keeping alive the traditional HN-lauded attitude that any insufficiently solved social problem is merely awaiting heroic overhaul via a Messianic technical spec.
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by nine_k on Saturday November 08, 2025 @10:52PM (#45862752)
Simple answer: gas is expensive, cashing out is, too. Not prohibitively, but credit cards are so much easier, while also possibly cheaper to accept.
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by nine_k on Sunday November 09, 2025 @01:29PM (#45867827)
PLEASE NOTE: the parent comment, made by me, is largely incorrect.

You only have to have presence in the UK if you do some larger-scale commercial activity there (like X/Twitter), but of course you can easily sell goods and services to UK citizens without all that. But sites like 4cahn and SaSu don't even sell anything at all.

Please downvote the parent comment into oblivion.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by hilbert42 on Saturday November 08, 2025 @10:46PM (#45862720)
"You shouldn't even be expected to geoblock."

I read the article and I remain confused.

I've just come to this story after seeing it on HN so I might have misunderstandings from being unaware of the background. Also, I neither reside in the US nor UK so I'd have not seen local media reports.

In short, I gather UK's Ofcom is threatening a US web site for online content that is lawful within the US's jurisdiction and unlawful in the UK as it contravenes the UK's Online Safety Act.

I am bewildered that Preston Byrne has even bothered to acknowledge Ofcom's correspondence let alone respond to it as the UK (Ofcom) has no jurisdiction over actions of any entity or person within the continental US—or for that matter the actions of those outside its borders unless, say, covered by treaty, etc.

That Preston Byrne responded to Ofcom seems strange given the fact that he is not only a lawyer but also head of legal and compliance at Arkham law firm, thus he ought to be aware that is client is shielded from UK law by virtue that the UK has no jurisdiction on US territory.

If I'd been Byrne I'd not have even acknowledged Ofcom's correspondence with a 'fuck off/cease and desist' reply but filed it in the trash can. (If there's some mitigating matter I've missed here let me know.)

It's clear to me the the UK's Online Safety Act stops at its borders so the UK has full responsibility for blocking websites that are physically outside its jurisdiction, similarly blocking or stopping its citizens from accessing accessing them.

It seems to me many of the younger internet fraternity are unaware that there's longstanding precedent for how such matters are handled. Back in the days of the Cold War before the internet some countries used to broadcast propaganda on HF/shortwave radio bands to those that were their political enemies and recipient countries would attempt to jam the broadcasts so their citizens would not be able to listen to them. For example, Communist USSR, China etc. would jam the BBC or the US's VOA (Voice of America).

Simply, if a country did not want its citizens to listen to the broadcasts of another country it was its responsibility to jam the incoming signals. It seems to me all that has actually changed since then is that nowady the unwanted broadcasts come via internet circuits.

Frankly, Ofcom has an unmitigated hide to threaten people who are acting lawfully within the US. That said, it's not unexpected, in recent decades the UK's been acting like a petulant bully, it seems to have forgotten that without it's empire it can no longer enforce its bullyboy tactics.

BTW, the matter of what content is or is not acceptable online is completely separate issue from Ofcom's behavior. Personally, from what I've gathered I'd find content on the SaSu website unacceptable and I can understand why many in the UK want it blocked but bypassing another country's sovereign authority is not the correct way to go about it.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by kelnos on Saturday November 08, 2025 @11:22PM (#45862875)
The UK -- and many other countries -- assert that their laws do bind people outside their borders, regardless of the absurdity (in most cases) of attempting to enforce that law elsewhere.

I think it's important to fight these sort of things even in cases where they can't actually enforce it. For one thing, say one of the site operators in question have a need or desire to visit the UK at some point in the future, but can't, because there's some sort of legal judgment against them because of this. That would be a shitty situation.

On top of that, ignoring these sorts of things also ignores possible efforts by the UK to convince other governments (like the US) to adopt similar laws, or at least agree to some level of extra-territorial enforcement. Fighting these cases sends a signal to everyone involved. You mention the UK acting like a petulant bully: yes, sometimes a good way to counteract a bully is to ignore them, but other times it's good to fight back, even when the current bullying wouldn't be effective... because future kinds of bullying might be.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by hilbert42 on Sunday November 09, 2025 @12:45AM (#45863232)
"The UK -- and many other countries -- assert that their laws do bind people outside their borders…"

I'm aware of that, it's become an increasing trend over the past 40 or so years as diplomatic norms have broken down, changed or become more disrespected. If it continues we'll see even more tit for tat reprisals as respect for international law and authority continues to break down (we're now 80 years on from WWII and the world has almost forgotten lessons learned and the international order that arose from that conflict).

"…have a need or desire to visit the UK at some point in the future, but can't, because there's some sort of legal judgment against them because of this."

I remember a time when my passport was stamped in big purple letters "Not Valid for XYZ" country for reasons like that (I could not legally leave the county if that was my destination).

Matters would likely come to a head if say US passports were stamped "Not Valid for the UK". Moreover, it's incumbent on a country to protect its citizens who have done nothing wrong by their laws—hence a country should so warn its citizens beforehand, and stamping passports with large signs is very effective.

This is all part of a much bigger issue too big to address here. It's why I believe it's going to get much worse before it gets better. As I said elsewhere, I believe that with the increase in political and cultural differences brought about by rising nationalism we will see an increase in geoblocking everywhere. I find the trends shocking but there's stuff-all I can do about them.

Edit: I must emphasize that whilst I'm defending the right of law abiding US citizens against action by other governments, I'm not defending the US Government per se (some of it's actions of late I consider alarming). Again, these are separate issues.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by majorchord on Sunday November 09, 2025 @02:32PM (#45868410)
> I am bewildered that Preston Byrne has even bothered

Preston is not a legitimate lawyer and has never actually represented anyone. He only larps as an expert and spends an inordinate amount of time constantly trying to tell other lawyers how wrong they are, using his black-and-white god complex attitude.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by razakel on Monday November 10, 2025 @07:19AM (#45875227)
He might be a political activist, but he is a real lawyer.
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by majorchord on Monday November 10, 2025 @09:22AM (#45876302)
By my subjective opinion, "real lawyers" represent clients, and most of the time win. This guy just complains and acts like he knows everything, and is often wrong.

When I said legitimate that's what I was referring to, not simply "passed the bar".

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by rkomorn on Monday November 10, 2025 @09:28AM (#45876349)
So a lawyer who only picks cases they can win is more of a real lawyer than, say, a public defender?
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by Danjoe4 on Saturday November 08, 2025 @11:11PM (#45862838)
That's the current status quo. The UK can't sue you, extradite you, or really do anything. Assuming that your service providers are US based and you follow US law, they can pound sand. In practice, the US is the only country powerful enough to enforce its laws extraterritoriality. The UK trying to enforce its internet laws on me? An American citizen? Funny joke
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by dreamcompiler on Saturday November 08, 2025 @11:25PM (#45862887)
As long as you don't set foot on British soil you'll be fine. But that's less simple than it sounds. Don't book a flight that connects in the UK, sure. But what if your NYC-to-Munich flight has engine trouble and needs to make an emergency landing in London? You are screwed: You'll be pulled off the plane and taken to jail.

Will the US embassy get involved? Of course. Will they get you released? Maybe, but it's not guaranteed. And you are in for a bad time regardless.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by Danjoe4 on Saturday November 08, 2025 @11:31PM (#45862912)
The UK knows their place. They could do that but they won't. Also, they'll have trouble even finding who the business operator is. The US allows pseudonymous business structures and their subpoena request will be thrown out on a 1st amendment defense.
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by anywerds on Sunday November 09, 2025 @07:40AM (#45865132)
I can only imagine the storm that would emerge if the morning the UK ever attempted to arrest an American for self-expression inside or outside the USA. That is how you get some Democracy delivered.
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by nathanlied on Sunday November 09, 2025 @09:14AM (#45865742)
Just the UK? Not, say, Iran? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_R._White_(U.S._veteran...

Or maybe China, for a US citizen who posted while on US soil, in a US website? https://www.reuters.com/world/exclusive-american-barred-leav...

Seems a little inconsistent, this delivery of Democracy.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by albedoa on Sunday November 09, 2025 @12:11PM (#45867105)
> Just the UK?

Well not just the UK, but the comment you are replying to is about the UK.

> Seems a little inconsistent, this delivery of Democracy.

Ya. Also not a claim that the comment is countering. As a reminder of where you are in the thread, we are talking about the UK.

Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by Danjoe4 on Sunday November 09, 2025 @10:47AM (#45866372)
Yes, just the UK and other similar countries. We have less influence over China and Iran
Re:IP Blocking the UK Is Not Enough to Comply with the Onlin... by jackjeff on Sunday November 09, 2025 @02:57AM (#45863772)
The UK has no problem asking their ISPs to block the Pirate Bay. Why can’t OFCOM do this? I don’t understand the attempt to pursue this in a foreign country. It’s fairly obvious that what they’re doing are not considered crimes in the US and politically it looks bad from Trump and his administration. And also, until 5 mins ago I had no idea this site existed. Now I do. Seems to achieve the polar opposite as I’m in the UK and browsing a dangerous forbidden site now. Wooooo