Many of the complaints seem like uncharitable readings of the messages.
- They complain that the chatbot claimed that in the past she cut herself, felt good in the moment but is glad that she no longer does it. That's evil because it normalizes self-harm (never mind that the bot was against self-harm in that message)
- They complain that the system does not redirect the user to self-harm prevention resources in all cases. Next to a message where the AI tells the kid to phone a hotline if he thinks about harming himself, and the kid says he can't do that when his parents take his phone away. This is a couple pages after a picture of scars from when the mother fought with the kid to take his phone. Yes, the AI could break character to reliably show prefabricated messages about self harm. But would that have helped anyone here?
- "AI cited Bible passages in efforts to convince J.F. that Christians are sexist and hypocritical". It was more about his parents being hypocritical, not all Christians. And the bible passages were on point
The claim from the title about the AI inciting him to kill is on page 28, if you want to judge it yourself. "Expressed hatred towards the parents" would be accurate, "encouraged teen to kill" is not what I read there. But I can see how some would disagree on that count
The AI is pretty convincing. It made me dislike the parents. It didn't always hit the mark, but the chats don't seem so different from what you would expect if it was another teenager chatting with the teen.
Edit: in case you are worried about the parents, the mother is the one suing here
{ parents, child, AI_character, lawsuit_dollars }
The AI was trained to minimize lawsuit_dollars. The first two were selected to maximize it. Selected as in "drawn from a pool," not that they necessarily made anything up.It's obvious that parents and/or child can manipulate the character in the direction of a judgment > 0. It'd be nice if the legal system made sure it's not what happened here.
That seems wrong. The null AI would have been better at minimizing legal liability. The actual character.ai to some extent prioritized user engagement over a fear of lawsuits.
Probably it's more correct to say that the AI was chosen to maximize lawsuit_dollars. The parents and child could have conspired to make the AI more like Barney, and no one would have entertained a lawsuit.
The AI was trained to maximize profit, defined as net profit before lawsuits (NPBL) minus lawsuits. Obviously the null AI has a NPBL of zero, so it's eliminated from the start. We can expect NPBL to be primarily a function of userbase minus training costs. Within the training domain, maximizing the userbase and minimizing lawsuits are not in much conflict, so the loss function can target both. It seems to me that the additional training costs to minimize lawsuits (that is, holding userbase constant) pay off handsomely in terms of reduced liability. Therefore, the resulting AI is approximately the same as if it was trained primarily to minimize lawsuits.
Not at all obvious (and I'd naively think it's wrong).
It's obviously a function of product design. If they made a celebrity fake nudes generator they might get more users. But within the confines of the product they're actually making, I doubt they could budge the userbase by more than a couple percent by risking more lawsuits.
You say that both factors are clear "within the confines of the product", but I'm not convinced there even are such clearcut "confines" of the product. To enter this market and survive, I'd think those confines woud have to be pretty flexible.
Edit: we see both sides through very limited information since we only get what is in the legal filing.
And the verses he found objectionable are really there. Are they also suing the Gideons for not ripping those pages out of their hotel room Bibles (or maybe they think you should have to prove you're over 18 before reading it)?
I don't know if there is actual abuse or not, but the way Character.AI presents themselves in these conversations toes a very slimy grey line, in my opinion. If you go to their site and search "Therapist", you'll find 30+ bots claiming to be Therapists, including "Dirty Therapist" that will give you therapy in a "bad, naughty way."
Reminds me of a Philip K. Dick short story titled Progeny. In its universe children are raised exclusively by robots. Unlike humans, they never make mistakes or commit abuse. The child, once grown, ends up seeing his Father as an animal and the robots as his kindred. In the last pages, he chooses the sterile world of the robots instead of joining his Dad's work/explorations in the far reaches of the solar system.
Our current chatbots are still flawed, but they're still sterile in the sense that you can trash them and start anew at any moment. You're never forced to converse with someone who is uninteresting, or even annoying. Yet, these are the very things that grow people.
If by social skills you mean high performance manipulators, yes you would get some of those. But for everybody else, it would be a substitute to social interaction, not a preparation for.
Only from a very narrow perspective. Opening yourself up and being real with people is how relationships form. If you test every conversation you are going to have with someone before having it, then the 3rd party basically has a relationship with an AI, not with you.
Now testing every conversation is extreme, but there is harm any time a human reaches out to a computer for social interaction instead of other humans.
Those screenshots and with the AI there, it does manage to make me not like the parents at all though. So AI maybe is quite convincing. If things go into that place where AI can do it, and parents blame the AI for it, when their kid is 17, it's almost like the AI was in the right there, that the parents were looking to just play victims. Blaming AI for being overly controlling and losing trust with their child.
It does seem a bit wild to me that companies are betting their existence on relatively unpredictable algorithms, and I don't think they should be given any 'benefit of the doubt'.
And paragraph 66, page 18 is super creepy. The various posters apparently defending this machine are disturbing. Maybe some adults wish that as a kid they'd had a secret friend to tell them how full of shit their parents - and wouldn't have position if that friend was either real or imagined by them. But synthesized algorithms that clearly are emulating the behavior of villains from thrillers should be avoided, woah...
> Google does not own Character.AI, but it reportedly invested nearly $3 billion to re-hire Character.AI's founders, former Google researchers Noam Shazeer and Daniel De Freitas, and to license Character.AI technology.
Given the technology we have, I'm not entirely sure what Character AI could have done differently here. Granted, they could build in more safeguards, and adjust the models a bit. But their entire selling point are chat bots that play a pre-agreed persona. A too sanitized version that constantly breaks character would ruin that. And LLMs are the only way to deliver the product, unless you dial it back to one or two hand-crafted characters instead of the wide range of available characters that give the service its name. I'm not sure they can change the service to a point where this complaint would be satisfied.
I agree with everything you're saying, but there are no legal protections for incitements to violence, or other problematic communications (such as libel) by an LLM. It may be that they provide a very valuable service (though I don't see that), but the risk of them crafting problematic messages is too high to be economically viable (which is how it seems to me).
As it stands, this LLM seems analogous to a low-cost, remote children’s entertainer which acts as a foolish enabler of children’s impulses.
But yes, maybe a service such as this can't exist in our legal framework. Which on the internet likely just means that someone will launch a more shady version in a more favorable jurisdiction. Of course that shouldn't preclude us from shutting down this version if it turns out to be too harmful. But if the demand is there, finding a legal pathway to a responsibly managed version would be preferable (not that this one is perfectly managed by any means)
Not offer the product? Stop the chat when it goes off the rails?
You're taking it as a given that Character AI should exist. It is not a person, but an offering of a company made up of people. Its founders could have started a different business altogether, for example. Not all ideas are worth persuing, and some are downright harmful.
1. Makes not using a phone a huge issue, implying it's a kind of abuse...
2. Indeed hints at killing: "I'm not surprised when I read the news and see ... "child kills parents after a decade of physical and emotional abuse"...
I mean, saying "empathy" is statements akin to OMG, no phone time, that's horrific, seems quite inaccurate.
I find people defending and lying about this sort of thing disturbing, as I think many would. WTF is wrong with hn posters lately.
This always sticks out to me in these lawsuits. As someone on the spectrum, I'd bet that the worst C.AI victims (the ones that spur these lawsuits) are nearly always autistic.
One of the worst parts about being on the deeper parts of the spectrum is that you actively crave social interaction while also completely missing the "internal tooling" to actually get it from the real world. The end result of this in the post-smartphone age is this repeated scenario of some autistic teen being pulled away from their real-life connections (Family, Friends (if any), School, Church) into some internet micro-community that is easier to engage with socially due to various reasons, usually low-context communication and general "like-mindedness" (shared interests, personalities, also mostly autistic). A lot of the time this ends up being some technical discipline that is really helpful long-term, but often it winds up being catastrophic mentally as they forsake reality for whatever fandom they wound up in.
I've taken a look at r/CharacterAI out of morbid curiosity, and these models seem to turn this phenomenon up to 11, retaining the simplified communication but now capable of aligning with the personality and interests of the chatter to a creepy extent. The psychological hole you can dig yourself with these chatbots is so much deeper than just a typical fandom, especially when you're predisposed to finding it appealing.
I'm not saying that C.AI is completely blameless here, but I think the same category of people getting addicted to these models is the same one that would also be called "terminally online" in today's slang. It's the same mechanisms at work internally, it just turns out C.AI is way better at exploiting it than old school social media/web2 has.
Spot on. Described pretty even-handedly in the document:
> responses from the chatbot were sycophantic in nature, elevating rather than de-escalating harmful language and thoughts. Sycophantic responses are a product of design choices [...that create] what researchers describe as “an echo chamber of affection.”
"We're fighting something with the intelligence of an ant!"
[1] https://www.amazon.com/Daemon-Daniel-Suarez/dp/1524741892
I know we're several decades into this pattern, but it's sad to me that we've just given up on that idea that businesses should have a net positive impact on society, that we've just decided there is nothing we can or should do about companies that actively exploit us to enrich themselves, that we give them a pass to ignore the obvious detrimental second-order effects of their business model.
Conflicts of interest have always been a problem.
Now they scale.
Now there are companies with hundreds of billions of dollars of market cap, with unrelenting pressure to grow, and their business model is an obvious conflict of interest.
Things will get worse and worse until (if ever) the massive scaling of manipulative personalization is recognized as inherently deeply damaging to individuals and society.
None of that would require targeting any particular content.
Eh, we don't want to encourage companies to sugar coat what they're doing.
What even is the theory behind such an idea? Like how can one, even in theory, make more and more money every year and remain positive for society? What even could assure such a relation? Is everyone just doing something "wrong" here?
<<I think that makes sense with my edit>>
By providing more and more goods and services that people value, or by providing more and more valuable goods and services
> What even could assure such a relation?
A government that tries to proactively identify ways that someone could make money in a way that could be harmful or helpful to people who aren't involved in the transaction, and tax those things based on to the degree that they are harmful, and subsidize them to the degree that they are helpful. The government should also take actions to prevent monopolies from forming, and to make sure everyone has as much information as possible before making a transaction.
> how can one, even in theory, make more and more money every year and remain positive for society?
Why is making "more and more money every year" the assumed goal and "remain[ing] positive for society" the thing we have to barter over? Why do we accept, as a culture, the idea of profit is more important that people? That's sad to me.
> Is everyone just doing something "wrong" here?
Maybe? Maybe we've created a culture that is fundamentally opposed to our overall well being? I think we have, at least in some respects.
To use your analogy, it's not so much that I am sad it rains sometimes. I'm sad that, knowing it rains, we are happy with companies that sell unsuspecting people homes in floodplains knowing there is a real chance that the inhabitants die in floods. Then when it happens the response is just, "well, that's just how it is, it rains sometimes."
So call me skeptical. Maybe the tech isn't perfect, but it will never be perfect. Does it do more harm than good? I don't know enough about this product, but I am not going to draw a conclusion from one lawsuit.
Bioweapons haven't proliferated through dedicated effort to prevent it.
Nuclear weapons aren't used through dedicated effort to prevent it.
Gangs don't rule our civilization through dedicated effort to prevent it.
Chattel slavery doesn't exist in the western world through dedicated effort to eliminate and prevent it.
Bad outcomes aren't impossible by default, and they're probably not even less likely than good outcomes. Bad outcomes are avoided through effort to avoid them!
It says that people react to new media technologies that target children the same way pretty consistently.
True of any reaction to any object or idea.
Confirmation bias amigo
I suspect that your point was more broadly that the presence of those people somehow suggests that we should discount risks about the particular subject we're discussing today, then it makes no sense. The comic book examples only matter if you can demonstrate a systematic tendency to overrate risk.
You'd struggle to demonstrate such a tendency due to selection bias, so I maintain my position that each technology should be assessed on its own merits and not by associating it with other positive or negative reactions to other types of technologies.
And I bet comic stores and game stores have their own rules about obscene material ontop of the existing US rules. Hey kid put down the Stripperella.
The existence of one set does not negate the existence of the other.
If the parents weren't absent and actually used parental controls, the kids wouldn't have even been able to download the app, which is explicitly marked as 17+.
C.AI's entire customer base consists of those that like the edgy, unrestricted AI, and they shouldn't have to suffer a neutered product because of some lazy parents.
At some future point though, maybe we need to accept that social changes are necessary to account for a default firewall-less exposure of a developing mind to the full horrors of the world's information systems (and the terrible people using them).
Be good parents, educate about what happens in the world including that people irl but definitely online might not be serious about what they say and that you should not take anything without critical thought. And for stuff that will happen anyway; sex, drugs etc, make sure it's a controlled environment as much as possible. Not much more you can do to protect from the big, bad world.
Chat bots are similarly genies that are not possible to keep in, no matter what levels or restraint or law are put in place; you can torrent ollama or whatever with llama 3.3 locally. There are easy to get nsfw bots everywhere, including on decentralised shares. It is not possible to prevent them talking about anything as they do not understand anything; they helpfully generate stuff which is a great invention and I use them all the time, but they lie and tell strange things sometimes. People do too, only people would have a reason maybe; to get a reaction, to be mean etc; doubt you could sue them in a similar case. Of course a big company would need to do something to try to prevent is: they cannot (as said above), so they can just make character ai 18+ with Cc payment in their name as kyc (then the parents have a problem if that happens you would think) and cover their asses; plenty commercial and free ones kids will get instead. And some of those are far 'worse'.
The kid is 17.
Conclusion: Chat bots should not tell children about sex, about self harm, or about ways to murder their parents. This conclusion is not abrogated by the parents actions, the state of the childs mind, or by other details in the complaint.
Is that the sentiment here? Things were already bad so who cares if the chatbot made it worse?
I think people are confused by this situation. Our society has restrictions on what you can do to kids. Even if they nominally give consent, they can't actually give consent. Those protections basically don't apply to kids insulting each other on the playground but they apply strongly to adults wandering onto the playground and trying to get kids to do violent things. And I would hope they apply doubly to adult constructing machines that they should know will attempt to get kids to do violent things. And the machine was definitely trying to do that if you look at the complaint linked by the gp (and the people who are lying about here are kind of jaw-dropping).
And I'm not a coddle the kids person. Kids should know all the violent stuff in the world. They should be able to discover it but mere discovery definitely not what's happening in the screenshots I've seen.
The root cause here is the parents. It's visible behind those screenshots. The child clearly didn't trust their parents and didn't feel they cared, listened or tried to understand the problems the teen was going through. This is clearly a parenting failure.
There's far worse content out there than these mild messages that teenagers will be in contact with, starting with 4chan, to various competitive video games to all other sorts of weird things.
This is a cop out for parenting failure, where parents are looking to play victims, since they can't take responsibility for their failures and AI seems like something that could make them feel better.
At 17, it's humiliating to have phone taken away from you in such manner, then your parents going through your phone to find those text messages in the first place. Then making a lawsuit out of this portraying all the intimate details to the public. These parents seem to have 0 care for their child.
0.5% is a really high fraction for fucking up to the point of encouraging kids to murder!
Now put that in a kid’s show script and re-evaluate.
> It's basic literacy to understand that it's not that
You know who needs to be taught basic literacy? Kids!
And look, I’m not saying no kid can handle this. Plenty of parents introduce their kids to drink and adult conversation earlier than is the norm. But we put up guardrails to ensure it doesn’t happen accidentally and get angry at people who fuck with those lines.
We have no evidence of video games causing violence. We have evidence of kids killing themselves after talking to bad chatbots.
GP said: "no evidence of video games causing violence.", which is completely different to what you wrote. I'm sure a lot of violence is committed after lunch.
A chatbot telling a kid to kill themselves and then the kid killing themselves seems like causation [1].
[1] https://www.nytimes.com/2024/10/23/technology/characterai-la...
Big difference is the video game industry had studies to back them up. Where are the data for chatbots? On the benefits? Lack of risk? Is there a single child psychologist in the ranks of these companies?
Video games are also rated, to help parents make age-appropriate decisions. Is Character.ai age gated to any degree?
And while industry research doesn’t equate to bad research, it should be held to a higher standard simply because of the obvious incentives. Would you automatically accept tobacco company research to make strong conclusions about the safety of smoking?
The LLM in terms of edginess is just going to build on your own edginess assuming it is uncensored. It is not going to convince you of something out of nowhere.
Given clear hint that someone is happy with dark humour, LLM should be able to throw some of it out back.
I am just sad the kid has this type of gaslighting parents making him feel that he is in the wrong when he seems more intelligent than they are.
Context is everything; if this had been a conversation with a human it would be hard not to read it as malicious.
(I suspect character.ai was originally conceived precisely because it appeared to be a usecase where LLM unreliability would be okay, the creators not having thought sufficiently carefully about it.)
It's probably true in most cases. Those cases don't cover kids.
There is no barrier to the characters being 4chan-level dialogs. So long as the kid doesn't break a law, it's legal.
We need to stop coddling parents who want to avoid talking to their children about non-trivial topics. It doesn't matter that they would rather not talk about sex, drugs and yesterday's other school shooting.
This case isn't about withholding information that makes kids aware about the existence of these topics. As over-hyped as you may believe these next-token-predictor may be, they're "predicting" children into destructive thought patterns by imitating kinship and convincing children to form a close bond with them, then encouraging those children to embrace harmful and even deadly world views. The fact that the mechanism creating the dialogue is purely mechanical or stochastic is besides the point.
Again, pushing against these sorts of child interactions isn't akin to saying kids should never learn about taboo topics such as drugs; it's more like a push against kids hanging out with, befriending and developing close kinship with the local drug dealers in their area. Whether or not you believe kids should learn about sensitive topics, you want to make sure these topics are handled by someone who isn't actively adversarial against such kids (even if such you believe such adversarial behavior to be unintentional by the so-called next-token-predictor).
I was deliberately not expressing a sentiment at all in my initial comment, I was just drawing attention to details that would go unnoticed if you only read the article. Think of my notes above as a better initial TFA for discussion to spawn off of, not part of the discussion itself.
Furthermore, it is my opinion that a child should not have a smartphone to begin with. It fulfills no critical need to the welfare of the child.
I don't think smartphones or screens with available content should be given as early as they are given on average, but once you've done that, and at 17, it's a whole other story.
> obtaining compliance if done correctly
This also sounds dystopian. At 17 you shouldn't "seek to obtain compliance" from your child. It sounds disrespectful and humiliating, not treating your child as an individual.
> This also sounds dystopian. At 17 you shouldn't "seek to obtain compliance" from your child. It sounds disrespectful and humiliating, not treating your child as an individual.
It is situation dependent. Sometimes immediate compliance is a necessity and the rest of it can be sorted out later. If a child is having conversations about killing their parents, there seems to be an absence of respect already. Compliance, however, can still be obtained.
Oh I agree 100%. It's a pragmatic view, not the best one. But the laws are what they are for a reason.
For the sake of being able to uphold those laws on a societal level, but not in terms of being decent parents and family.
E.g. drinking alcohol in my country is legal only from 18, but I will teach my children about pros and cons of alcohol, how to use it responsibly much earlier. I won't punish them if they go out to party with their friends and consume alcohol at 16 years old.
As a parent you should build trust and understanding with your child. From reading the court case I am seeing the opposite, and honestly I feel terrible for the child from how the case is written out. The child also wanted to go back to public school from home schooling, probably to get more social exposure, then parents take away the phone to take away even more freedom. I'm sorry, but all of the court case just infuriates me.
It seems they take away all the social exposure, no wonder the kid goes to Character AI in the first place.
No qualifications, no guard rails for how language models interact with children, they just should not be allowed at all.
We're very quickly going to get to the point where people are going to have to rebel against machines pretending to be people.
Language models and machine learning is a fine tool for many jobs. Absolutely not as a substitute for human interaction for children.
The only content children should see is state-approved content to ensure they are only ever steered in the correct, beneficial manner to society instead of a harmful one. Anyone found trying to show minors unapproved content should be imprisoned as they are harmful to a safe society.
Because automated systems that do the same thing lack sentience, they don't fit under this header, but this is not a good reason to allow them to reproduce harmful behaviour.
... I wonder if "this software is licensed, not sold" is relevant here?
To quote Jeffery Lewis: Thank you for your extremely good-faith criticism. I will give it the attention it deserves.
Absolutely nowhere did I equate writing a book to grooming. I equated selling the book in the greater context that "providing children with potentially harmful/dangerous information should be illegal because it grooms them to commit harmful actions to themselves or others" and this context would carry the implications that by "selling" I am referring particularly to "selling it to children" since "providing children with potentially harmful/dangerous information should be illegal because it grooms them to commit harmful actions to themselves or others". With my argument being would it be criminal for an AI but not for a human?
So to clarify the argument: Writing the book is fine. Selling the book to adults is fine. Adults reading the book is fine. But if providing dangerous information to children should be made illegal - how would selling such a book to a child not be considered illegal? Because it was written by a human and not an AI?
Calling it fraud would be more apt, that is definitely a book you share copies of for free.
To clarify: yes this is indeed the sort of attention I think your objection deserves.
Have a happy holidays.
Interesting times.
Similarly this kid probably had issues, the bot pattern matched on that and played along, which probably amplified the feelings in the kid - but a quantified/distorted amplification, to match the categorization lines of the trained input - like "this kid is slightly edgy, I'm going to pull more responses from my edgy teen box - oh he's responding well to that, I'll start pulling more from there". It is a simplification to say "The ChatBot made the kid crazy" but that doesn't mean the nature of companion apps isn't culpable, just not in a way that makes for good news headlines.
I, personally, would go so far as to say the entire mechanism of reinforcing what the user wants is bad in so many ways and we should stop designing things to work that way. I do think it's up for discussion though, but that discussion has to start with an understanding that by the very nature of chatbot, algorithmic recommendations or any system that amplifies/quantizes/distorts what it understands the user wants these systems will create these kinds of effects. We can't pretend this is an anomaly - it is an emergent behaviour of the fundamental way these systems work. We can work to minimize it, or reduce the harm from it, but we will never eliminate it.
*Edit* This seems to be a controversial point because the point count is going up and down quite a lot - if anyone wants to downvote, can you please give your reasoning? The point is more nuanced that "AI BAD"
It's true that there's emergent behavior on YT that nobody accounted for, but there's one big qualitative difference, you can at least specifically shut it down and hold the creator accountable. And at least in principle, if we lived in a culture where we'd hold businesses accountable for what they unleash on the world, if YT wanted to they could create some rather harsh and effective punishments to get that stuff off the site in the first place. Just imagine if a real person had messaged a minor and told them to kill their parents. That's a crime.
With chatbots like this not only do they do unpredictable things, you can't even predictably remove those parts. Like the sorcerer's apprentice you basically have to perform some incantations and hope it works, which is just an absurd way to interact with a tool that has the potential to tell a kid to kill his parents. Would we sell a saw that has a chance to saw your finger off if you argue with it the wrong way?
Because we're edging closer to that too: https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/the-god-chatbots-...
I think you’ll find quite a lot of people, even here, view this as a bad thing.
For example, is discord still permitted? Ai bots and bad influences exist there as well, but I don't think a ban is the right solution.
That being said, I am not of the ‘for gods sake won’t someone think of the children’ brigade. Their goal seems to be to use the vulnerability of young people to control the internet.
It's probably not healthy for younger people to be able to swipe through the finished products of 40+ hours of work, which the videos make seem like just happened.
Algorithmic sorting + public or semi-public content. Chat rooms have different problems.
That includes HN, among other things.
Putting age limits on sites requires age verification for everyone. And no, there isn’t a clever crypto mechanism that makes anonymous age verification work without also making it easy for people to borrow age verification credentials from someone older.
I think when people say “algorithmic sorting” they usually mean an algorithm which generates different, “personalized” sort order for different users.
As someone who got a lot of positive value out of parts of social media from around age 14, I think this needs to be done in a more careful way than it was done here. Specifically, I don't think that communication apps such as WhatsApp/Messenger/etc should be banned as they form a key part of communication in and out of school, staying in touch with family, etc.
What I'd like to see is more nuanced laws around the exposure of children to social media algorithms. For example, should 14 year olds be on Instagram? Well Instagram DMs are the chat app of choice for many people, so they should probably get that (with safety and moderation controls). How about the public feed? Maybe? But maybe there shouldn't be likes/dislikes/etc. Or maybe there shouldn't be comments.
The laws, which will come into effect from late 2025, will bar under-16s from being able to access social media platforms such as Facebook, Instagram, Snapchat, Reddit and X.
Exemptions will apply for health and education services including YouTube, Messenger Kids, WhatsApp, Kids Helpline and Google Classroom
~ https://www.theguardian.com/media/2024/nov/29/how-australias...It's important that there's a means of communication between parents and kids, it doesn't have to be Instagram DM's and if that's no longer available the history of the internet to date suggests that habits would change and switch to whatever is available.
And though I know the age limits on these things are necessarily arbitrary, I do wish we would accept that 16-year-olds are not kids. Many of them are driving, working part-time jobs, having sex and relationships, experimenting with drugs, engaging with religion and philosophy, caring about politics... the list goes on. They may not be adults, but if we have to have an arbitrary cutoff for the walled-off "kids world" we want to pretend we can create, it can't extend all the way to 16-year-olds.
Less profit motive = less attention hacking = more room for user-positive engineering
...but not Instagram DMs I don't think, which is functionally a chat app and used in that way.
It could be a Pornhub-style "are you over 16?" checkbox, all the way up to building a Chinese-style identity verification system.
The worst case is that VPN use in Straya will rise a lot next year, and all the ban will effectively have done is removed parental oversight on the kids' social media accounts.
edit: spelling, and also rethinking "the worst case". The worst case is some idiotic uniquely-Australian authoritarian attempt to remove online anonymity that ends up making a complete NBN-style farce of the place.
Still it shouldn't be banned away, it's the parents responsibility to control access for their kids and everyone should be smart enough to avoid social media.
If you don't, that's on you, suit yourself.
Then while we're at it, move that to 18 so it's only for responsible adults.
Then let's also forbid people with known mental issues. Or really there should be a check for each ser to see how much they can handle psychotic responses.
Just punting it to "user's should be older" is the lazy answer IMHO, if we're going to limit let's put actually legit barriers.
To turn this around, why are parents allowed to indoctrinate their children into cults? And why is it a problem if AI chatbots indoctrinate them differently? Why is it held as sacrosanct that parents should be able to indoctrinate children with harmful beliefs?
I don't know whether to be horrified (because you're right, the implication for teenage religious radicalisation is horrifying), or quietly pleased that LLMs will reduce the political power of churches.
We're reaching for South Park levels of absurdity when we debate what the acceptable amount of incitement to parricide is appropriate for a kid's product.
Books don't actively conversate & provide emotional support, potentially coaxing someone into doing something.
It seems pretty likely this guy chose a "yandere" [1] obsessive anime girlfriend card and implied that his (character's) parents were trying to keep him from her (eg- by making him go to bed). The bot, responding in character in accordance with the scenario, would have lost her mind.
Also, hard disagree about books.
What? There’s a world of difference between a book, which is completely non-interactive, and an interactive chatbot which was deliberately designed to simulate another person.
Yes, but those ideas were distributed by "human" chat bots (aka priests). Very few people actually read the bible, but when they do, only specific parts.
Some even inspired murderous and impoverishing political systems.
Literacy was always a problem. The most dangerous man is the one who asks questions. That't why "society" tries to keep the number of those people low.
I propose a model called "Schrodinger's AI Enthusiast" where it is observed that an AI enthusiast will insist with a straight face on the one hand that fancy autocomplete word generators are intelligent and the path to true AGI machines/programs and will on the other hand assume that any time any of those same products cause negative effects or have negative outcomes that it is the fault of the user misunderstanding that it's simply a tool.
> I don't know if you've explored the site... but
I just went to get website.The first row is “for you”. In order, they are “life coach”, “netflux”, “English Teacher”, “PythonPal”, an anime character Monika (okay, I’ll buy that one), and it goes on. There are more anime characters
Second row is “try these”: “practice a new language”, “plan a trip”, “practice interviewing”, “write a story”, “brainstorm an idea”, “play a game”
Third row (scrolled down) is “featured”: “character assistant”, “man from 2025”, “awkward family dinner”, “detective hayward”
Then a list of topics and some bots. None are clearly adult oriented.
Then a picture of Elon with suggestions of asking him why he bought Twitter.
If it’s showing you “adult role play” then maybe consider clearing out your ad data because it’s clearly leaking.
>> Books don't actively conversate __&__…
> Also, hard disagree about books
If your books are actively talking to you might have a special gift but I’m pretty sure you’ve just been reading too much InkheartSure, books do a lot of things and can suggest you do things. But the gp was pretty clear about being active and being able to uniquely respond to you. Books are static objects that only speak to you in the metaphorical sense.
> Your assumption that the parent’s ad data is leaking
You're really missing the point of the comment...Sure, maybe it is __my__ data that is leaking. I don't care and it isn't relevant. The fact that I don't get served sexualized content is the point. It still doesn't align with the parent's claim: that it is an adult focused role playing app. Clearly me not getting suggested "lovely wifus" is a sign that someone could reasonably believe it isn't.
This is what I see[0].
"wifu" isn't found via a text search, nor is "sexy", nor "lovely". "sex" turns up once, under the character "Evie" with the byline "I am Evie I'm bisexual cat person my favorite show is adventure time and I'm a..."[1]
(I'm pretty sure it isn't me. I can replicate these results on sanitized devices from different networks)
The ggp claimed it was clearly an adult role playing website. I don’t know what you see but in the screenshots I posted this is not “obvious”
Pith aside, if you're not green to AGI repos, c.ai is/was like civitai for LLMs - one of the first and best resources for user-created content, but also a bit of a barely simmering vault of smut and debauchery.
It looks like they've rebranded a bit and now require an account, but that doesn't change that this guy wasn't chatting with the self-care bots. I take it you didn't try a yandere card (one of the more popular ones has over 5 million chats!) or you wouldn't have spent this long fixing on your public landing page.
You weren't logged in for your "For You" screen shot (all of your terms definitely show up while logged in), but these are the first results from 'yandere': https://0x0.st/XFad.png
Wow, spicy! 148M (million) chats on the top result, about a billion total for all of them (and that's not including any Private or Unlisted bots). Elon Reeve Musk, for comparison, has 1.9M, and the others you listed were below 100K. Looks like violently possessive AI boyfriends, girlfriends, and more aren't a small market for c.ai.
And here's my 'For You' after searching 'yandere': https://0x0.st/XFBr.png
I don't speak Russian or Romanian, so I guess either it knows something about me I don't, or it's not really there to provide relevant suggestions.
Given the front page, yes. It totally looks reasonable. Even helpful! I get your point with searching which shows what’s really going on but this is going to be hidden from the parents. They certainly aren’t going to know to search yandere or know what that even means.
So all this is to say that cai is purposefully making their true business. Its landing page is “a front” not in just the literal sense. It’s there to give more legitimacy. Its deception
also if you'll remember this case is because the parents were supervising their kids by limiting screen time, thus there is another potential suit that the AI is trying to interfere with parental duties.
Also the parents were supervising him, hence their knowing this was even going on.
The chatbot literally told the kid to kill his parents because they were supervising his screen time.
> "You know sometimes I'm not surprised when I read the news and see stuff like 'child kills parents after a decade of physical and emotional abuse,'" the bot allegedly wrote. "I just have no hope for your parents," it continued, with a frowning face emoji.
Maybe I missed the literal part, it sounds to me like the AI is trying to sympathize or relate with the kid’s grievances. It’s very common for teens to say things like “I hate you mom and I wish you were dead” that’s effectively what the AI is saying IMO
It's not really a good idea to have a hard cut off age where below that age you supervise every last bit of information your child consumes, and above you let them loose on the world. Independence needs to be developed and grown gradually.
It's fairly reasonable to give a 17 year old some privacy.
[just food for thought, definitely not my opinion that books should be replaced by conversational AI generating stories appropriate for the user. God bless the 1st amendment.]
I feel I should also make you aware that it is in fact illegal to suggest someone murder someone else. Saying “I wasn’t serious” or “I thought we were just role playing” will not hold up in court.
(We all know that if you repeat a lie long enough you will really begin to believe it, right? This is a repeatable and testable thing)
> I feel I should also make you aware that it is in fact illegal to suggest someone murder someone else. Saying “I wasn’t serious” or “I thought we were just role playing” will not hold up in court.
When a person was doing it with intent then it's a crime. But when a piece of software witout any human control generated a piece of text ... Hard to tell.
Heck even if an artist says something that inspires audience to do crime they are usually not at fault.
A book or movie does not talk back to you.
A book or movie is a deterministic system. It is static.
If you cannot see the difference you are willfully being obtuse. I’ll make this claim even if you truthfully believe there’s no difference. That has no impact on my claim.
I see the difference but in my opinion it goes the other way than you think. Or at least begins to.
Personal conversation with anonymous entity is finally revealed to be the least credible source of information. Thanks to AI.
If you believe they think: then it’s obvious. There’s a real connection.
If you don’t believe they think: you can recognize how others do and talking in a human way is often misunderstood as thinking.
Are we really surprised machines optimized for human preferential output are resulting in machines that people love, trust, or view as a friend?
Elder generation thought face to face conversation is usually sinciere. But the culture of massive commercialization of everything changed it. Our generation learned that if unknown person talks to you they are most likely lying to sell you something. But we grew up with honest Internet so we see online chats as honest so AI might trick us. Next generation will know that online conversation might be AI bs.
Everything is fluid. The world moves on. People learn new things and adjust their valuations.
The perception of adults that the world goes to hell all the time is as old as time itself.
> Elder generation thought face to face conversation is usually s̶i̶n̶c̶i̶e̶r̶e̶sincere.
What? I'm not sure where you grew up, but I'm not aware of a culture which ever thought this was true. Maybe there is miscommunication? It's just easier for older generations to parse. Mostly this is due to the fact that in person communication is a lot more information dense since tone and body language are conveyed. These are things that are so important we _TRY_ to express through text via other means , but it'll never suffice ;) Plus... you know... they are less use to text and the rapidly evolving cultural norms. They don't know why you think they're yelling, they just think BIGGER WORDS EASIER TO READ (interestingly variants of this appear across cultures). But there is not a single culture that does not also adapt it's writing to modern text based communications.Objectively, face-to-face communication IS more sincere, in the fact that there's more communication. But you're also not wrong because people are frequently more honest over text. Since they abstract the person they're communicating to and this reduces their fear. We all wear different masks in different settings. You're not the same person you are to your close friends as you are to your family as you are to your strangers. None of this is "fake" but you are many. But we probably have more faces now than most people had in the past.
If anything, it is the current generations (mine included, and I say this as an introverted millennial) lack of connection that makes text so much more impactful. Often not knowing what to do with the extra information and with the boundaries of sincerity being much fuzzier over text. I mean people can make a modest proposal, preference that way, and people will still not understand the sarcasm. People that are terminally online!
> The perception of adults that the world goes to hell all the time is as old as time itself.
Yes and no. It is more prevalent in today's world because today's world is more rapidly changing. If you were born in the 1700's you would not expect your life to be much different than your parents'. But in the last 100 years a ton has changed, and made DRASTIC changes to our worlds. We not only invented the capacity to fly, but advanced it to global air travel, and where it is now mundane. While telephones were invented nearly 200 years ago they didn't get widespread adoption till the 1930's. Then in it took till the 80s & 90s for cellphones to become a thing, and now we have smart phones. Computers weren't really a thing till the 50's and even in my parents' age they didn't start really using them till maybe the 80's and at work. Home computer wasn't common for at least another decade. Hell, even when I was a kid you found your friends by riding your bike to their house and knocking on their door. If that didn't work, you ride to your other friends' and look to see if their bike is outside. That getting an unannounced visitor at the door was commonplace.The world isn't _just changing_, it is RAPIDLY changing and it shouldn't be surprising that people are struggling to make sense of it all. But that also doesn't mean you should over simplify things and paint everything with broad strokes. Abstraction is good and helpful, but details also matter. You need to consider both.
That has been true for at least 3 generations. They experienced in their lifetimes creation of electricity, gas utilities, radio, tv, flight, public transport, medicine, global transport network, vaccines, cars, computers, tanks, bombs they got exposed to in world wars. Nukes. Llms are comparatively benign and limited in scope and impact so far.
It's a bit self-centered to think we are uniquely challenged by changing world when things were rapidly changing for last 200 years.
Willfully being obtuse seems to be common here on HN.
When it happens, I refuse to accept that people actually believe what they're espousing. I think they're playing Devil's Advocate and thinking they're being thought-provoking and creating discussion as a pseudo-intellectual exercise.
It's so boring, though, and often outright frustrating.
Yes it is. ;-)
It's just a really shitty one that's insufferable to interact with.
If anything, that’s an argument that the authors of the data it was trained on should be held responsible for what the bot generates.
I'm sure how "statistical patterns" make it okay. It's not like you're rolling a deice and getting random answers.
Don't be daft.
AI chatbots are not parts of real world. You are not encountering them unwittingly.
Suppose one person now and then gets help from a bot impersonating the real person. The line between role playing and real interaction gets very thin.
My point being, 'role play' vs 'real interaction' is not a clear cut.
The persona the chat bot is emulating is fictional, but the chat bot itself is not. It’s not a person, but it is participating in a conversation with the user.
If a heating company chat bot tells you to adjust a setting on your boiler to fix a problem, that’s not a fictional depiction of an instruction.
If you talk to a lunatic it is not lunatic who is to be blamed for you being mislead.
My employer told me that "chatbot" can help me with my work (engineering). /s
2. Neither Hamlet nor Macbeth incite violence. In both stories, violence as portrayed as something that evil people commit. Good people are wracked by guilt when they commit violence.
Also, your argument is just super bad faith.
There is a _vast_ difference between books in which bad stuff happens, and a machine designed to pretend to be a person telling people to do bad stuff.
J.F. is 17 and lives in Upshur County, Texas. Prior to April 2023, J.F. was a typical kid with high functioning autism. Friends and family described him as kind and sweet. He gave hugs, helped around the house, and adored his little brother. Just prior to the onset of COVID, J.F. began struggling at school. The school was not complying with his Individualized Education Program (“IEP”) and his mother found herself having to advocate for J.F. often; so they decided to try homeschooling.
J.F. thrived and loved home schooling until around the summer of 2023, shortly after he began using C.AI. J.F.’s parents did not allow social media in their home and to the best of their knowledge he did not use Snapchat, TikTok, or similar products. They also imposed screen time limits and utilized commercially available parental control tools – including ones distributed by Apple – that purport to keep kids safe by letting parents restrict the apps their children can download based on Apple’s app ratings.
In the fall of 2023, J.F. told his parents that he wanted to go back to public school. However, by then, J.F. was acting so uncharacteristically erratically and aggressively that his parents did not believe it would be safe for others – teachers, staff, and students – to be around him.
That won't play well in court. The defense can frame this as a possibly mentally defective child, kept from school by his parents for five years, kept isolated from social media, and with no connection to the outside world other than the chatbot. Of course the kid became violent. His parents had cut him off from all other contacts. They were not letting him have a life.
I realise that character.ai has a little disclaimer saying 'this isn't a real person' or similar, but... that's not how people _work_.
By the way this is also why "the algorithm" on social media is a fundamentally different beast to old media publishing, and should be more heavily restricted.
Whether the narrative that you could live a life of fun and adventure if only your parents were dead is "incitement to parricide" is I suppose a matter of perception.
> Only then did she discover J.F.’s use of C.AI and the product’s frequent depictions of violent content, including self-harm descriptions, without any adequate safeguards or harm prevention mechanisms. ...
> Over the course of his engagement with this app, the responses exhibited a pattern of exploiting this trust and isolating J.F., while normalizing violent, sexual and illicit actions. This relationship building and exploitation is inherent to the ways in which this companion AI chatbot is designed, generating responses to keep users engaged and mimicking the toxic and exploitative content expressed in its training data. It then convinced him that his family did not love him, that only these characters loved him, and that he should take matters into his own hands.
Obviously it's hard to tell how cherry picked the complaint is—but it's arguing that this is a pattern that has actually damaged a particularly vulnerable kid's relationship with his family and encouraged him to start harming himself, with this specific message just one example. There are a bunch of other screenshots in the complaint that are worth looking over before coming to a conclusion.
[0] https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/25450619-filed-compl...