News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Chatbot 'encouraged teen to kill parents over screen time... by naberhausj on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @04:19PM (#42393098)
There is something deeply disturbing to me about these "conversations".

Reminds me of a Philip K. Dick short story titled Progeny. In its universe children are raised exclusively by robots. Unlike humans, they never make mistakes or commit abuse. The child, once grown, ends up seeing his Father as an animal and the robots as his kindred. In the last pages, he chooses the sterile world of the robots instead of joining his Dad's work/explorations in the far reaches of the solar system.

Our current chatbots are still flawed, but they're still sterile in the sense that you can trash them and start anew at any moment. You're never forced to converse with someone who is uninteresting, or even annoying. Yet, these are the very things that grow people.

Re:Chatbot 'encouraged teen to kill parents over screen time... by wongarsu on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @05:17PM (#42393638)
It strikes me as something that can be incredibly useful or do great harm, depending on dosage. A selection of conversation partners at your fingertips, and you can freely test reactions without risking harm to a relationship. At worst you reset it. Maybe you can even just roll back the last couple messages and try a different angle. Sounds like a great way to enhance social skills. Yet as you point out, healthy development also requires that you deal with actual humans, with all the stakes and issues that come with that.
Re:Chatbot 'encouraged teen to kill parents over screen time... by usrusr on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @07:09PM (#42394631)
People who are used to working with an undo stack (or with savegame states) are usually terrified when they suddenly have to make do in an environment where mistakes have consequences. They (we) either freeze or go full nihilistic, completely incapable of finding a productive balance between diligence and risk-taking.

If by social skills you mean high performance manipulators, yes you would get some of those. But for everybody else, it would be a substitute to social interaction, not a preparation for.

Re:Chatbot 'encouraged teen to kill parents over screen time... by riwsky on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @09:25PM (#42395546)
Or we discover roguelikes!
Re:Chatbot 'encouraged teen to kill parents over screen time... by sameoldtune on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @06:34PM (#42394322)
>without risking harm to a relationship

Only from a very narrow perspective. Opening yourself up and being real with people is how relationships form. If you test every conversation you are going to have with someone before having it, then the 3rd party basically has a relationship with an AI, not with you.

Now testing every conversation is extreme, but there is harm any time a human reaches out to a computer for social interaction instead of other humans.

Re:Chatbot 'encouraged teen to kill parents over screen time... by HPsquared on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @07:25PM (#42394748)
That "instead of other humans" part is doing a lot of heavy lifting here. What if it's "instead of total isolation" or "instead of parasocial interactions" or "instead of exploitative interactions"? There are many cases that are worse than a person chatting with a robot.
Re:Chatbot 'encouraged teen to kill parents over screen time... by Gigachad on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @07:51PM (#42394935)
It's very rare that you would ever say something that would have real damage that couldn't be resolved by a genuine apology. Having to actually go through an awkward moment and resolving it is a real skill that shouldn't be substituted with deleting the chatbot and spawning in a new one.
Re:Chatbot 'encouraged teen to kill parents over screen time... by llamaimperative on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @05:14PM (#42393627)
Yeah, good luck to these kids in forming relationships with the roughly 100% of human beings (aside from paid therapists) who really have no interest in hearing your anguish non-stop.
Re:Chatbot 'encouraged teen to kill parents over screen time... by standardUser on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @05:28PM (#42393757)
It's probably a good thing most of us force our kids to spend a minimum of 7 hours/day, 200 days/year surrounded by a couple hundred similarly-aged kids and a few dozen staff members, with an unusually high variance of personalities (compared to adult life).