Re:Chatbot 'encouraged teen to kill parents over screen time...
by tmtvl on Thursday December 12, 2024 @04:45AM
(#42397769)
Yes, but GGP also said that kids commited suicide after talking to a chatbot. I agree that there's no evidence for video games causing violence (rather the opposite), but this double standard that GGP is setting deserves calling out.
Re:Chatbot 'encouraged teen to kill parents over screen time...
by JumpCrisscross on Thursday December 12, 2024 @08:00AM
(#42398779)
> GGP also said that kids commited suicide after talking to a chatbot
A chatbot telling a kid to kill themselves and then the kid killing themselves seems like causation [1].
[1] https://www.nytimes.com/2024/10/23/technology/characterai-la...
Re:Chatbot 'encouraged teen to kill parents over screen time...
by ToValueFunfetti on Thursday December 12, 2024 @08:12AM
(#42398840)
Sure, but so does a video game telling a kid to commit violent acts and then the kid committing violent acts. I don't think video games cause violence and I'm open to the possibility that chatbots cause suicide, but if we're going to compare evidence for each, we shouldn't do it in a biased way.
Re:Chatbot 'encouraged teen to kill parents over screen time...
by vacuity on Thursday December 12, 2024 @09:45AM
(#42399537)
It's prima facie more plausible for chatbots to cause suicide, considering that chatbots are more personal and interactive than even video games. There's a distinct difference, I would think, between what is obviously fake murder in a fake setting and being sympathized with, like one human to another, on thinking about actual murder. And while chatbots explicitly have the warning that they are not real people, I would not expect a person with an underdeveloped prefrontal cortex and possibly pre-existing mental health troubles (again, this can apply to video games too, but, I imagine, to a lesser degree) to fully act accordingly.
Re:Chatbot 'encouraged teen to kill parents over screen time...
by JumpCrisscross on Thursday December 12, 2024 @10:03AM
(#42399708)
> so does a video game telling a kid to commit violent acts and then the kid committing violent acts
Big difference is the video game industry had studies to back them up. Where are the data for chatbots? On the benefits? Lack of risk? Is there a single child psychologist in the ranks of these companies?
Video games are also rated, to help parents make age-appropriate decisions. Is Character.ai age gated to any degree?
Re:Chatbot 'encouraged teen to kill parents over screen time...
by bumby on Friday December 13, 2024 @09:15AM
(#42408567)
Is it at least fair to say the data is mixed? Not my field, but there is some research to suggest video games may increase short-term aggression and desensitization to violence.
And while industry research doesn’t equate to bad research, it should be held to a higher standard simply because of the obvious incentives. Would you automatically accept tobacco company research to make strong conclusions about the safety of smoking?
Re:Chatbot 'encouraged teen to kill parents over screen time...
by bumby on Friday December 13, 2024 @09:26AM
(#42408671)
Tbf, strict causality is very difficult to prove in social sciences, no? Meaning, most of the studies for/against the link between video games and violence can't meet that threshold. Social science isn't physics and I don't think it's fair to treat them the same.
GP said: "no evidence of video games causing violence.", which is completely different to what you wrote. I'm sure a lot of violence is committed after lunch.