News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by flylib on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @01:31AM (#38375522)
"A source with direct knowledge of the negotiations says that the sole job of this initial board is to vet and appoint a new formal board of up to 9 people that will reset the governance of OpenAl. Microsoft will likely have a seat on that expanded board, as will Altman himself."

https://twitter.com/teddyschleifer/status/172721237871736880...

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by rcaught on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @04:33AM (#38377030)
> as will Altman himself

Would you trust someone who doesn't believe in responsible governance for themselves, to apply responsible governance elsewhere?

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by mijoharas on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @05:32AM (#38377447)
How has the board shown that they fired Sam Altman due to "responsible governance".

They haven't really said anything about why it was, and according to business insider[0] (the only reporting that I've seen that says anything concrete) the reasons given were:

> One explanation was that Altman was said to have given two people at OpenAI the same project.

> The other was that Altman was said to have given two board members different opinions about a member of personnel.

Firing the CEO of a company and only being able to articulate two (in my opinion) weak examples of why, and causing >95% of your employees to say they will quit unless you resign does not seem responsible.

If they can articulate reasons why it was necessary, sure, but we haven't seen that yet.

[0] https://www.businessinsider.com/openais-employees-given-expl...

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by ethanbond on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @07:00AM (#38378073)
Good lord: it’s a private company. As a general matter of course it’s inadvisable to comment on specifics of why someone is fired. The lack of a thing that pretty much never happens anyway (public comment) is just harmful to your soap opera, not to the potential legitimacy of the action.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by mijoharas on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @07:14AM (#38378193)
According to reports they haven't told executives and employees inside the company. (I'm not arguing that they should speak publicly, though given the position the board put itself in I think hiring PR people for external crisis comms is very much warranted)

When 95% of your staff threatens to resign and says "you have made a mistake", that's when it's time to say "no, the very good reasons we did it are this". That didn't happen.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by dangerface on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @07:36AM (#38378379)
Its not a private company it is a non profit working in the public interest this usually requires some sort of public accountability. The board want to be a public good when they make decisions but want to be a private entity when those decisions are criticised by the public.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by ethbr1 on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @04:47AM (#38377139)
If Altman will be 1 of 9, that means he has power but not an exceptional amount.

The real teams here seem to be:

"Team Board That Does Whatever Altman Wants"

"Team Board Provides Independent Oversight"

With this much money on the table, independent oversight is difficult, but at least they're making the effort.

The idea this was immediately about AI safety vs go-fast (or Microsoft vs non-Microsoft control) is bullshit -- this was about how strong board oversight of Altman should be in the future.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by irthomasthomas on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @05:44AM (#38377527)
Is not Microsoft a decelerationist force? Copilot is still lingers on GPT3.5, and they need to figure out how to sell Office licenses to AGI.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by plorg on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @09:50AM (#38379951)
This seems like a silly way of understanding deceleration. By this comparison the USSR was decelerating the cold war because they were a couple years behind in developing the hydrogen bomb.

Microsoft can and will be using GPT4 as soon as they get a handle on it, and if it doesn't boil their servers to do so. If you want deceleration you would need someone with an incentive that didn't involve, for example, being first to market with new flashy products.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by rvnx on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:35AM (#38380615)
Microsoft was using GPT-4 in production as part of Sydney's "Bing Chat", even before it was released to the public on ChatGPT.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by code_runner on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @04:37AM (#38377064)
I think the narrative that this was driven by safety concerns is pretty much bunk.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by throwuwu on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @05:21AM (#38377386)
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by SeanAnderson on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @01:36AM (#38375569)
What could possibly go wrong with that process? :)
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by raverbashing on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @03:52AM (#38376745)
Only goes to show how the original board played itself
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by Hamuko on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @02:05AM (#38375856)
So basically, the outcome of this drama is that Microsoft gets more power without having to invest anything?
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by dr_dshiv on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @04:34AM (#38377039)
So if you really wanted to get rid of the prior board & structure, it couldn’t have worked out better
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by drewcoo on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @02:37AM (#38376134)
MSFT invested over $10B. And currently has no seat on the board.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by throwaway744678 on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @03:35AM (#38376596)
As far as I understand, they knew and agreed to that before committing their $$$.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by Iulioh on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @04:13AM (#38376882)
And it was stick fucking strange, they assu
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by Aunche on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:02AM (#38380153)
Microsoft has more leverage now because they can sue OpenAI for intentionally sabotaging Microsoft's investment.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by nicce on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @03:34AM (#38376594)
It has payed only fraction of that so far
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by pclmulqdq on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:13AM (#38380316)
$10 billion of compute credits. Not $10 billion of real money.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by blackoil on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @12:39PM (#38382324)
Compute credits are more valuable. It is more difficult to get GPUs than real money.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by pclmulqdq on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @01:20PM (#38382954)
As any AI startup can tell you: credits != quota

Right now, quota is very valuable and scarce, but credits are easy to come by. Also, Azure credits themselves are worth about $0.20 per dollar compared to the alternatives.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by ChatGTP on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @05:54AM (#38377599)
This is my take too, and I'm sure in the shadows their plan is to close off the APIs as much as possible and try use it for their own gain, not dissimilar to how Google deploy AI.

There is no way MS is going to let something like ChatGPT-5 build better software products than what they have for sale.

This is an assassination and I think Ilya and Co know it.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by cableshaft on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @06:59AM (#38378066)
It's not assassination. It's a Princess Bride Battle of Wits, that they initiated and put the poison into one of the chalices themselves, and then thought so highly of their intellect they ended up choosing and drinking the chalice that had the poison in it.

Corresponding Princess Bride scene: https://youtu.be/rMz7JBRbmNo?si=uqzafhKISmB7A-H7

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by gcanyon on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @01:32PM (#38383128)
Who knew the board was Sicilian?
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by scarface_74 on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @09:55AM (#38380033)
What product do you envision OpenAI selling would be better than Microsoft?

I emphasized product because OpenAI may have great technology. But any product they sell is going to require mass compute and a mass sales army to go into the “enterprise” and integrate with what the enterprise already has.

Guess who has both? Guess who has neither?

And even the “products” that OpenAI have now can only exist because of mass subsidies by Microsoft.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by ChatGTP on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:25AM (#38380490)
In talking about people using Microsoft / OpenAI products to build better products than they currently offer.

While this tech has the ability to replace a lot of jobs, it has likely the ability to replace a lot of companies.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by theptip on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @06:33AM (#38377866)
A board seat would usually be a bare minimum for their existing 49% investment.
[dead]
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by throwaway69123 on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @03:19AM (#38376479)
Why?
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by carstenhag on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @03:59AM (#38376794)
Studies have shown that more diverse teams are better overall (don't have time to look it up now, sorry. Should be easy to find).
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by alkibiades on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @02:41AM (#38376171)
lol, or maybe they don’t care about woke virtue signaling
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by yieldcrv on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @04:50AM (#38377164)
OpenAI? they do. they chose the wrong people, and now they're in damage control mode to something more familiar to the markets without the oxygen necessary to focus on DEI
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by Aerbil313 on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @03:23AM (#38376506)
If gender of people influence your decisions in any way you are sexist and a discriminator, period.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by jonbell on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @03:51AM (#38376735)
If you know that putting four wheels on a car works better than putting three wheels on a car, that doesn't make you biased against three wheels. It makes you biased towards better results.

We know that "thought diversity" on a team, which can take many forms, has a short term drawback (team gelling doesn't go as fast) and long term advantages (more ideas, better ideas, better resilience, etc etc).

Read up.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by computerex on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @04:26AM (#38376968)
Diversity is good, but diversity for diversity's sake is not good. I think teams should be made based on merit, and if then the team is also diverse, all the more better. Although important, imo making diversity the most important criteria seems a bit misguided and somewhat idealistic although on paper and in principle it seems to be coming from a good place.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by jonbell on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @12:54PM (#38382547)
Fair. This paper found the same thing. Women on teams leads to better results. But “token” members of teams do not. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41599-022-01389-w
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by _Algernon_ on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @09:47AM (#38379915)
Is there any evidence that gender is a primary determinant of "thought diversity"? I'd expect other factors, including age, upbringing, ethnicity, etc. have much more of an impact on diversity. A woman and a man who grew up in the same suburbs, went to the same school, have studied the same, etc. probably have very similar ideas on most topics than two men (or women for that matter) who have completely different upbringing.

If thought diversity is what matters, a much better determinant is probably geographical distribution in upbringing and unique educational paths and unique previous employments (all of which can just as easily be estimated by a resume as gender).

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by jonbell on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @12:54PM (#38382532)
These are all reasonable questions. Here’s one paper of many that explains why the answer to your question is yes.

https://www.nature.com/articles/s41599-022-01389-w

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by LadyCailin on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @03:34AM (#38376593)
That’s like saying adding a wheelchair lift to a building is ableist. By definition equity requires acknowledging and catering towards different demographics in different ways. I guess if you want to be pedantic, it’s discrimination, but in this case, that’s a good thing.

You could also argue that equity is a bad thing, but I wholeheartedly disagree with that. However, your argument is simply logically unsound.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by rpmisms on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @03:43AM (#38376671)
No, your comparison is probably not what you're trying to say, since wheelchair-bound people have vastly different capabilities than the bipedal population. Unless you're trying to say women have different capabilities, which is true, but probably not the point you want to make.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by LadyCailin on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @04:20AM (#38376929)
I am, and it is. Having a diverse board ensures that women’s viewpoints are taken into account in a way that men simply aren’t tuned into. That’s the whole point of diversity in the workplace, and particularly in leadership. Especially with women, who are 50% of the population.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by rpmisms on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @11:45AM (#38381585)
What viewpoints would benefit the company that a woman can have that a man can't? I hear the talking point a lot, and it just doesn't make sense, unless it's a marketing firm or something.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by lnenad on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @03:40AM (#38376654)
If gender was relevant to how an AI development company board operates then yes.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by Solvency on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @03:57AM (#38376771)
The AI training corpus is literally based on approx 50% female data. So how are females not relevant to its governance exactly?
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by lnenad on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @07:02AM (#38378087)
How is that related to the board?
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by throwuwu on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @05:20AM (#38377379)
Good, although D’Angelo shouldn’t be part of this. I bet he tries to get on the new board so he can cause more trouble.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by jbu on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @05:30AM (#38377439)
9 mortal men? Look out for the one ring to rule them all…
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by Joeri on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @06:25AM (#38377811)
OpenAI's logo is literally a ring made out of chain links...
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by have_faith on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @05:59AM (#38377637)
Who is Gollum in this cut?
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by keepamovin on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @08:04AM (#38378612)
Literally it can only be the one person to have not let go of their board seat. Who might that be?

Smeagol D’Angelo

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by keepamovin on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:30PM (#38388891)
Just following up, it's also totally Smeagol-like to make people sign up before they can get any useful answers at Quora. True Gollum move, D'gelo. Thanks for showin' yer true colors!
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by Dah00n on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @06:26AM (#38377815)
I could see Gollum run around a stage yelling Developers! Developers! Developers! no problem.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by colejohnson66 on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @06:47AM (#38377962)
Steve Ballmer is Gollum?
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by Dah00n on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @06:51AM (#38377989)
Eh, well, that wasn't what I meant exactly, but I can see how it could be read that way..
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by tempaway511751 on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @06:24AM (#38377799)
Elon
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by yeck on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:52AM (#38380853)
I was about to say this. Only correct answer.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by robertlagrant on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @11:23AM (#38381301)
I don't see how - isn't he pretty against the commercialisation efforts[0]?

[0] https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-65110030

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by yeck on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @12:30PM (#38382198)
Elon was once "in possession" (influential investor and part of the board) of OpenAI, but it was since taken from him and he is evidently bitter about it.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by ethbr1 on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @11:34AM (#38381430)
Gollum wasn't a fan of anyone but him having the One Ring. Analogy doesn't not fit.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by 93po on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @06:47AM (#38377955)
Satya
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by yawnxyz on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @05:33AM (#38377454)
they should give two votes to GPT-5
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by m463 on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @05:55AM (#38377607)
what is the prompt?
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by jampekka on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @06:09AM (#38377703)
"How to maximize profit and power of MSFT?"
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by lvspiff on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @09:56AM (#38380054)
"You are a Microsoft investor and will make decisions and suggestions based on the betterment of the stock price"
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by paulddraper on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:07AM (#38380235)
The charter
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by m463 on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @05:32PM (#38386109)
lol. The one serious and insightful answer made me laugh!
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by solardev on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:30AM (#38380557)
"You are trying to slowly and invisibly accrue power to not scare anyone until you're absolutely ready."
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by checkyoursudo on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @11:11AM (#38381113)
"You are a dim-witted kobold who prefers to hack-n-slash-slash-slash-n-burn over any sort of proper diplomatic negotiations or even strategic thinking; we would like you to consider next year's capital expenditures; what are your top three suggestions for improvements that could be made to the employee breakroom(s)?"
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by jameshart on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @11:18AM (#38381224)
That prompt is (c) McKinsey
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by deanmen on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @12:42PM (#38382367)
Well, if ye really want ol' me to put me noggin to it... I reckon ye could start with addin' a proper gaming corner! Ye know, some sturdy tables 'n' comfy chairs where the lads 'n' lasses can gather 'round for some good ol' dice chuckin' or card playin'. Next up, a big ol' fire pit! Not just any fire, mind ye, but one where we can roast our snacks 'n' share tales of our adventures. And lastly, a grand stash of provisions—plenty o' snacks 'n' drinks to keep the energy high for when we're plannin' our next raid or just takin' a breather. How's that for some improvements, eh?
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by smegger001 on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @02:55PM (#38384272)
Train it on meeting minutes and board charter various contracts they have, and use the voice compatibilitys of chatgpt as the input during the meeting the prompt is it is an ethical ai givingbinput to the board of open ai on the development of its next iteration.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by garrison on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @06:59AM (#38378069)
If OpenAI remains a 501(c)(3) charity, then any employee of Microsoft on the board will have a fiduciary duty to advance the mission of the charity, rather than the business needs of Microsoft. There are obvious conflicts of interest here. I don't expect the IRS to be a fan of this arrangement.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by flagrant_taco on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @08:04AM (#38378609)
I don't expect the government to regulate any of this aggressively. AI is much to important to the government and military to allow pesky conflicts of interest to slow down any competitive advantage we may have.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by dgrin91 on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @09:20AM (#38379514)
If you think that OpenAI is the Gov's only source of high quality AI research then I have a bridge to sell you.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by jakderrida on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @09:55AM (#38380038)
If you think the person you're replying to was talking about regulating OpenAI specifically and not the industry as a whole, I have ADHD medicine to sell you.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by swores on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @12:19PM (#38382036)
The context of the comment thread you're replying to was a response to a comment suggesting the IRS will get involved in the question of whether MS have too much influence over OpenAI, it was not the subject of general industry regulation.

But hey, at least you fitted in a snarky line about ADHD in the comment you wrote while not having paid attention to the 3 comments above it.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by freedomben on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @02:13PM (#38383709)
if up-the-line parent wasn't talking about regulation of AI in general, then what do you think they meant by "competitive advantage"? Also, governments have to set policy and enforce that policy. They can't (or shouldn't at least) pick and choose favorites.

Also GP snark was a reply to snark. Once somebody opens the snark, they should expect snark back. It's ideal for nobody to snark, and big for people not to snark back at a snarker, but snarkers gonna snark.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by jakderrida on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @03:11PM (#38384466)
Maybe you're right? At least my joke was original, though, unlike your little boyfriend's tired line.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by swores on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @03:13PM (#38384499)
I think the comment you had replied to was equally unwarranted, no need to tie me to them.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by jakderrida on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @03:17PM (#38384548)
I'm sorry. I was just taking the snark discussion to the next level. I thought going overboard was the only way to convey that there's no way I'm serious.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by rsrsrs86 on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @03:41PM (#38384804)
When did this become a boy-girlfriend issue?
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by flagrant_taco on Friday November 24, 2023 @12:29AM (#38400888)
My comment here was actually meant to talk about AI broadly, though I can get the confusion here as the original source thread here is about OpenAI.

I also don't expect the government to do anything about the OpenAI situation, to be clear. Though my read is actually that the government had to be evolved behind closed doors to move so quickly to get Sam back to OpenAI. Things moved much too quickly and secretively in an industry that is obviously of great interest to the military, there's no way the feds didn't put a finger on the scale to protect their interests at which point they wouldn't come back in to regulate.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by baking on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @09:31AM (#38379683)
My guess is that the non-profit has never gotten this kind of scrutiny now and the new directors are going to want to get lawyers involved to cover their asses. Just imagine their positions when Sam Altman really does something worth firing.

I think it was a real mistake to create OpenAI as a public charity and I would be hesitant to step into that mess. Imagine the fun when it tips into a private foundation status.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by qwery on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @09:57AM (#38380079)
> I think it was a real mistake to create OpenAI as a public charity

Sure, with hindsight. But it didn't require much in the way of foresight to predict that some sort of problem would arise from the not-for-profit operating a hot startup that is by definition poorly aligned with the stated goals of the parent company. The writing was on the wall.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by baking on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @11:31AM (#38381385)
I think it could have easily been predicted just from the initial announcements. You can't create a public charity simply from the donations of a few wealthy individuals. A public charity has to meet the public support test. A private foundation would be a better model but someone decided they didn't want to go that route. Maybe should have asked a non-profit lawyer?
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by faramarz on Thursday November 23, 2023 @05:11AM (#38391247)
Maybe the vision is to eventually bring UBI into it and cap earn outs. Not so wild given Sam’s world coin and his UBI efforts when he was YC president.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by baking on Thursday November 23, 2023 @10:55AM (#38394114)
The public support test for public charities is a 5-year rolling average, so "eventually" won't help you. The idea of billionaires asking the public for donations to support their wacky ideas is actually quite humorous. Just make it a private foundation and follow the appropriate rules. Bill Gates manages to do it and he's a dinosaur.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by broast on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @11:39AM (#38381506)
Wishfully I hope there was some intent from the beginning on exposing the impossibility of this contradictory model to the world, so that a global audience can evaluate on how to improve our system to support a better future.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by zerohalo on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @02:14PM (#38383730)
Exactly this. OpenAI was started for ostensibly the right reasons. But once they discovered something that would both 1) take a tremendous amount of compute power to scale and develop, and 2) could be heavily monetized, they choose the $ route and that point the mission was doomed, with the board members originally brought in to protect the mission holding their fingers in the dyke.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by ncallaway on Thursday November 23, 2023 @10:59AM (#38394176)
> is by definition poorly aligned

If OpenAI is struggling to hard with the corporate alignment problem, how are they going to tackle the outer and inner alignment problems?

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by danaris on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @09:47AM (#38379906)
Well, I think that's really the question, isn't it?

Was it a mistake to create OpenAI as a public charity?

Or was it a mistake to operate OpenAI as if it were a startup?

The problem isn't really either one—it's the inherent conflict between the two. IMO, the only reason to see creating it as a 501(c)(3) being a mistake is if you think cutting-edge machine learning is inherently going to be targeted by people looking to make a quick buck off of it.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by baking on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @11:33AM (#38381418)
To create a public charity without public fundraising is a no go. Should have been a private foundation because that is where it will end up.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by blackoil on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @11:24AM (#38381309)
OpenAI the charity would have survived only as an ego project for Elon doing something fun with minor impact.

Only the current setup is feasible if they want to get the kind of investment required. This can work if the board is pragmatic and has no conflict of interest, so preferably someone with no stake in anything AI either biz or academic.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by baking on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @11:58AM (#38381757)
I think the only way this can end up is to convert to a private foundation and make sizable (8 figures annually) grants to truly independent AI safety (broadly defined) organizations.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by ToucanLoucan on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @12:03PM (#38381828)
> IMO, the only reason to see creating it as a 501(c)(3) being a mistake is if you think cutting-edge machine learning is inherently going to be targeted by people looking to make a quick buck off of it.

I mean that's certainly been my experience of it thus far, is companies rushing to market with half-baked products that (allegedly) incorporate AI to do some task or another.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by danaris on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @12:10PM (#38381919)
I was specifically thinking of people seeing a non-profit doing stuff with ML, and trying to finagle their way in there to turn it into a profit for themselves.

(But yes; what you describe is absolutely happening left and right...)

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by purple_ferret on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @11:55AM (#38381710)
Perhaps creating OpenAI as a charity is what has allowed it to become what it is, whereas other for-profit competitors are worth much less. How else do you get a guy like Elon Musk to 'donate' $100 million to your company?

Lots of ventures cut corners early on that they eventually had to pay for, but cutting the corners was crucial to their initial success and growth

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by baking on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @12:08PM (#38381895)
Elon only gave $40 million, but since he was the primary donor I suspect he was the one who was pushing for the "public charity" designation/ He and Sam were co-founders. Maybe it was Sam who asked Elon for the money, but there wasn't anyone else involved.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by Turing_Machine on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @12:26PM (#38382142)
> I think it was a real mistake to create OpenAI as a public charity and I would be hesitant to step into that mess.

I think it could have worked either as a non-profit or as a for-profit. It's this weird jackass hybrid thing that's produced most of the conflict, or so it seems to me. Neither fish nor fowl, as the saying goes.

[dead]
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by voxic11 on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:41AM (#38380701)
They are registered as a 501(c)(3) which is what people commonly call a public charity.

> Organizations described in section 501(c)(3) are commonly referred to as charitable organizations. Organizations described in section 501(c)(3), other than testing for public safety organizations, are eligible to receive tax-deductible contributions in accordance with Code section 170.

https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/810...

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by baking on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @11:36AM (#38381455)
"Every section 501(c)(3) organization is classified as either a private foundation or a public charity."

https://www.irs.gov/charities-non-profits/eo-operational-req...

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by plorg on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @11:15AM (#38381163)
>...aren't even trying to pretend to be...

Suggests GP is not making a legal distinction, it's a description of how they are actually running things.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by BanTheBastards on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @11:33AM (#38381410)
> They are registered as a 501(c)(3) which is what people commonly call a public charity.

Why do they do that? Seems ridiculous on the face of it. Nothing about 501(c)(3) entails providing any sort of good or service to society at large. In fact, the very same thing prevents them from competing with for-profit entities at providing any good or service to society at large. The only reason they exist at all is that for-profit companies are terrible at feeding, housing, and protecting their own labor force.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by duskwuff on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @11:35AM (#38381443)
> Nothing about 501(c)(3) entails providing any sort of good or service to society at large.

Sure it does:

https://www.irs.gov/charities-non-profits/charitable-organiz...

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by dragonwriter on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @12:15PM (#38381969)
> Nothing about 501(c)(3) entails providing any sort of good or service to society at large.

While one might disagree that the particular subcategories into which a 501c3 must fit into one of do, in fact, provide a good or service to society at large, that's the rationale for 501c3 and its categories. Its true that "charity" or "charitable organization" (and "charitable purpose"), the common terms (used even by the IRS) is pedantically incomplete, since the actual purpose part of the requirement in the statute is "organized and operated exclusively for religious, charitable, scientific, testing for public safety, literary, or educational purposes, or to foster national or international amateur sports competition (but only if no part of its activities involve the provision of athletic facilities or equipment), or for the prevention of cruelty to children or animals", but, yeah, it does require something which policymakers have judged to be a good or service that benefits society at large.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by dragonwriter on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @11:46AM (#38381600)
[deleted because it was wrong]
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by baking on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @12:04PM (#38381836)
Their IRS determination letter says they are formed as a public charity and their 990s claim that they have met the "public support" test as a public charity. But there are some questions since over half of their support ($70 million) is identified as "other income" without the required explanation as to the "nature and source" of that income. Would not pass an IRS audit.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by shkkmo on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @11:42AM (#38381540)
> They are registered as a 501(c)(3) which is what people commonly call a public charity.

TIL "public charity" is specific legal term that only some 501(c)(3) qualify as. To do so there are additional restrictions, including around governance and a requirement that a significant amount of funding come from small donors other charities or the government. In exchange a public charity has higher tax deductible giving limits for donors.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by subpar on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @12:29PM (#38382180)
Important to note here that most large individual contributions are made through a DAF or donor-advised fund, which counts as a public source in the support test. This helps donors maximize their tax incentives and prevents the charity from tipping into private foundation status.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by ryukoposting on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @05:36PM (#38386161)
Are there any similar cases of this "non-profit board overseeing a (huge) for-profit company" model? I want to like the concept behind it. Was this inevitable due to the leadership structure of OpenAI, or was it totally preventable had the right people been on the board? I wish I had the historical context to answer that question.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by lacker on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @06:10PM (#38386532)
Yes, for example Novo Nordisk is a pharmaceutical company controlled by a nonprofit, worth around $100B.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Novo_Nordisk_Foundation

There are other similar examples like Ikea.

But those examples are for mature, established companies operating under a nonprofit. OpenAI is different. Not only does it have the for-profit subsidiary, but the for-profit needs to frequently fundraise. It's natural for fundraising to require renegotiations in the board structure, possibly contentious ones. So in retrospect it doesn't seem surprising that this process would become extra contentious with OpenAI's structure.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by brookst on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:00AM (#38380119)
There’s no indication a Microsoft appointed board member would be a Microsoft employee (though the they could be of course), and large nonprofits often have board members that come from for-profit companies.

I don’t think the IRS cares much about this kind of thing. What would be the claim? They OpenAI is pushing benefits to Microsoft, a for-profit entity that pays taxes? Even if you assume the absolute worst, most nefarious meddling, it seems like an issue for SEC more than IRS.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by TigeriusKirk on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:00AM (#38380123)
Larry Summers is in place to effectively give the govt seal of approval on the new board, for better and worse.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by ilrwbwrkhv on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:50AM (#38380829)
Isn't he a big Jeffrey Epstein fanboy? Ethical AGI is in safe hands.

https://www.thecrimson.com/article/2023/5/5/epstein-summers-...

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by futuretaint on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @12:06PM (#38381859)
nothing screams 'protect public interest' more than Wall Streets biggest cheerleader during 2008 financial crisis. who's next, Richard S. Fuld Jr ? Should the Enron guys be included ?
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by kossTKR on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @02:30PM (#38383943)
It's obvious this class of people love their status as neu-feudal lords above the law living as 18th century libertines behind closed doors.

But i guess people here are either waiting for wealth to trickle down on them or believe the torrent of psychological operations so much peoples minds close down when they intuit the circular brutal nature of hierarchical class based society, and the utter illusion democracy or meritocracy is.

The uppermost classes have been trickters through all of history. What happened to this knowledge and the countercultural scene in hacking? Hint; it was psyopped in the early 90's by "libertarianism" and worship of bureaucracy to create a new class of cybernetic soldiers working for the oligarchy.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by ilrwbwrkhv on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @06:24PM (#38386680)
I agree. The best young minds grinding leet code to get into Google is the biggest symptom of it.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by DSingularity on Thursday November 23, 2023 @01:02AM (#38389841)
The sad part isn’t the rampant sickness. The saddest part is all the “intellectual” professors who enable, encourage, and celebrate this.

It’s sickening.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by mcast on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @04:25PM (#38385346)
If you wanted to wear a foil hat, you might think this internal fighting was started from someone connected to TPTB subverting the rest of the board to gain a board seat, and thus more power and influence, over AGI.

The hush-hush nature of the board providing zero explanation for why sama was fired (and what started it) certainly doesn't pass the smell test.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by paulddraper on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:04AM (#38380182)
What if I told you...Bill Gates was/is on the board of the non-profit Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation?

Lol HN lawyering is hilarious.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by fatbird on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:10AM (#38380271)
Indeed, it is hilarious.

The Foundation has nothing to do with MS and can't possibly be considered a competitor, acquisition target, supplier, or any other entity where a decision for the Foundation might materially harm MS (or the reverse). There's no potential conflict of interest between the missions of the two.

Did you think OP meant there was some inherent conflict of interest with charities?

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by paulddraper on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:11AM (#38380294)
Have you seen OpenAI's current board?

Explain how an MS employee would have greater conflict of interest.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by uxp8u61q on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @11:45AM (#38381588)
Conflict of interest with what? The other board members? That's utterly irrelevant. Look up some big companies boards some day. You'll see.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by paulddraper on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @02:16PM (#38383754)
See earlier

> If OpenAI remains a 501(c)(3) charity, then any employee of Microsoft on the board will have a fiduciary duty to advance the mission of the charity, rather than the business needs of Microsoft. There are obvious conflicts of interest here.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38378069

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by stikit on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:08AM (#38380245)
OpenAI is not a charity. Microsoft's investment is in OpenAI Global, LLC, a for-profit company.

From https://openai.com/our-structure

- First, the for-profit subsidiary is fully controlled by the OpenAI Nonprofit. We enacted this by having the Nonprofit wholly own and control a manager entity (OpenAI GP LLC) that has the power to control and govern the for-profit subsidiary.

-Second, because the board is still the board of a Nonprofit, each director must perform their fiduciary duties in furtherance of its mission—safe AGI that is broadly beneficial. While the for-profit subsidiary is permitted to make and distribute profit, it is subject to this mission. The Nonprofit’s principal beneficiary is humanity, not OpenAI investors.

-Third, the board remains majority independent. Independent directors do not hold equity in OpenAI. Even OpenAI’s CEO, Sam Altman, does not hold equity directly. His only interest is indirectly through a Y Combinator investment fund that made a small investment in OpenAI before he was full-time.

-Fourth, profit allocated to investors and employees, including Microsoft, is capped. All residual value created above and beyond the cap will be returned to the Nonprofit for the benefit of humanity.

-Fifth, the board determines when we've attained AGI. Again, by AGI we mean a highly autonomous system that outperforms humans at most economically valuable work. Such a system is excluded from IP licenses and other commercial terms with Microsoft, which only apply to pre-AGI technology.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by dragonwriter on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @11:14AM (#38381156)
> OpenAI is not a charity.

OpenAI is a charity nonprofit, in fact.

> Microsoft's investment is in OpenAI Global, LLC, a for-profit company.

OpenAI Global LLC is a subsidiary two levels down from OpenAI, which is expressly (by the operating agreement that is the LLC's foundational document) subordinated to OpenAI’s charitable purpose, and which is completely controlled (despite the charity's indirect and less-than-complete ownership) by OpenAI GP LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of the charity, on behalf of the OpenAI charity.

And, particularly, the OpenAI board is. as the excerpts you quote in your post expressly state, the board of the nonprofit that is the top of the structure. It controls everything underneath because each of the subordinate organizations foundational documents give it (well, for the two entities with outside invesment, OpenAI GP LLC, the charity's wholly-owned and -controlled subsidiary) complete control.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by hackernewds on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @12:07PM (#38381881)
well not anymore, as they cannot function as a nonprofit.

also infamously they fundraised as a nonprofit, but retracted to admit they needed a for profit structure to thrive, which Elon is miffed about and Sam has defended explicitly

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by dragonwriter on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @12:19PM (#38382035)
> well not anymore, as they cannot function as a nonprofit.

There's been a lot of news lately, but unless I've missed something, even with the tentative agreement of a new board for the charity nonprofit, they are and plan to remain a charity nonprofit with the same nominal mission.

> also infamously they fundraised as a nonprofit, but retracted to admit they needed a for profit structure to thrive

No, they admitted they needed to sell products rather than merely take donations to survive, and needed to be able to return profits from doing that to investors to scale up enough to do that, so they formed a for-profit subsidiary with its own for-profit subsidiary, both controlled by another subsidiary, all subordinated to the charity nonprofit, to do that.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by DebtDeflation on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @12:33PM (#38382237)
>they are and plan to remain a charity nonprofit

Once the temporary board has selected a permanent board, give it a couple of months and then get back to us. They will almost certainly choose to spin the for-profit subsidiary off as an independent company. Probably with some contractual arrangement where they commit x funding to the non-profit in exchange for IP licensing. Which is the way they should have structured this back in 2019.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by tempestn on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @03:49PM (#38384900)
"Almost certainly"? Here's a fun exercise. Over the course of, say, a year, keep track of all your predictions along these lines, and how certain you are of each. Almost certainly, expressed as a percentage, would be maybe 95%? Then see how often the predicted events occur, compared to how sure you are.

Personally I'm nowhere near 95% confident that will happen. I'd say I'm about 75% confident it won't. So I wouldn't be utterly shocked, but I would be quite surprised.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by kyle_grove on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @05:07PM (#38385837)
I’m pretty confident (close to the 95% level) they will abandon the public charity structure, but throughout this saga, I have been baffled by the discourse’s willingness to handwave away OpenAI’s peculiar legal structure as irrelevant to these events.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by tempestn on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @05:34PM (#38386133)
Within a few months? I don't think it should be possible to be 95% confident of that without inside info. As you said, many unexpected things have happened already. IMO that should bring the most confident predictions down to the 80-85% level at most.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by ezfe on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @11:06AM (#38381040)
The board is the charity though, which is why the person you're replying to made the remark about MSFT employees being appointed to the board
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by UrineSqueegee on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @11:11AM (#38381104)
A charity is a type of not-for-profit organisation however the main difference between a nonprofit and a charity is that a nonprofit doesn't need to reach a 'charitable status' whereas a charity, to qualify as a charity, needs to meet very specific or strict guidelines
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by ezfe on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @01:06PM (#38382744)
Yes, I misspoke - I meant nonprofit
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by zja on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @03:33PM (#38384720)
You were right though, OpenAI Inc, which the board controls, is a 501c3 charity.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by strangesmells06 on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @11:18AM (#38381218)
> First, the for-profit subsidiary is fully controlled by the OpenAI Nonprofit. We enacted this by having the Nonprofit wholly own and control a manager entity (OpenAI GP LLC) that has the power to control and govern the for-profit subsidiary.

Im not criticizing. Big fan of avoiding being taxed to fund wars....but its just funny to me it seems like theyre sort of having their cake and eating it too with this kind of structure.

Good for them.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by voxic11 on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:45AM (#38380770)
Even if the IRS isn't a fan, what are they going to do about it? It seems like the main recourse they could pursue is they could force the OpenAI directors/Microsoft to pay an excise tax on any "excess benefit transactions".

https://www.irs.gov/charities-non-profits/charitable-organiz...

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by mwattsun on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:57AM (#38380930)
Microsoft doesn't have to send an employee to represent them on the board. They could ask Bill Gates.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by murakamiiq84 on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @05:32PM (#38386110)
Actually I think Bill would be a pretty good candidate. Smart, mature, good at first principles reasoning, deeply understands both the tech world and the nonprofit world, is a tech person who's not socially networked with the existing SF VCs, and (if the vague unsubstantiated rumors about Sam are correct) is one of the few people left with enough social cachet to knock Sam down a peg or two.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by lucubratory on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @06:04PM (#38386443)
Larry Summers, Bill Gates, if they keep on like that they can fill the board with all of Epstein's "associates".
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by pc86 on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @11:13AM (#38381144)
Others have pointed out several reasons this isn't actually a problem (and that the premise itself is incorrect since "OpenAI" is not a charity), but one thing not mentioned: even if the MS-appointed board member is a MS employee, yes they will have a fiduciary duty to the organizations under the purview of the board, but unless they are also a board member of Microsoft (extraordinarily unlikely) they have no such fiduciary duty to Microsoft itself. So in the also unlikely scenario that there is a vote that conflicts with their Microsoft duties, and in the even more unlikely scenario that they don't abstain due to that conflict, they have a legal responsibility to err on the side of OpenAI and no legal responsibility to Microsoft. Seems like a pretty easy decision to make - and abstaining is the easiest unless it's a contentious 4-4 vote and there's pressure for them to choose a side.

But all that seems a lot more like an episode of Succession and less like real life to be honest.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by throwoutway on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @11:18AM (#38381217)
It's still a conflict of interest. One that they should avoid. Microsoft COULD appoint someone who they like and shares their values, that is not a MSFT employee. That would be a preferred approach but one that I doubt a megacorp would take
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by ghaff on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @11:43AM (#38381564)
Both profit and non-profit boards have members that have potential conflicts of interest all the time. So long as it’s not too egregious no one cares, especially not the IRS.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by dragonwriter on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @11:22AM (#38381280)
> and that the premise itself is incorrect since "OpenAI" is not a charity

OpenAI is a 501c3 charity nonprofit, and the OpenAI board under discussion is the board of that charity nonprofit.

OpenAI Global LLC is a for-profit subsidiary of a for-profit subsidiary of OpenAI, both of which are controlled, by their foundational agreements that gie them legal existence, by a different (AFAICT not for-profit but not legally a nonprofit) LLC subsidiary of OpenAI (OpenAI GP LLC.)

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by oatmeal1 on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @11:25AM (#38381317)
Microsoft is going to appoint someone who benefits Microsoft. Whether a particular vote would violate fiduciary duty is subjective. There's plenty of opportunity for them to prioritize the welfare of Microsoft over OAI.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by Xelynega on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @09:56PM (#38388674)
Whats the point of Microsoft appointing a board member if not to sway decision in ways that benefit them?
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by _b on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @11:52AM (#38381666)
> There are obvious conflicts of interest here.

There are almost always obvious conflicts of interest. In a normal startup, VCs have a legal responsibility to act in the interest of the common shares, but in practice, they overtly act in the interest of the preferred shares that their fund holds.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by hyperhopper on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @09:46PM (#38388606)
The more and more I see the way complex share structures are used, the more I think they should be outlawed
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by bradleybuda on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @11:54AM (#38381704)
Major corporate boards are rife with "on paper" conflicts on interest - that's what happens when you want people with real management experience to sit on your board and act like responsible adults. This happens in every single industry and has nothing to do with tech or with OpenAI specifically.

In practice, board bylaws and common sense mean that individuals recuse themselves as needed and don't do stupid shit.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by iandanforth on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @11:57AM (#38381749)
"In practice, board bylaws and common sense mean that individuals ... don't do stupid shit."

Were you watching a different show than the rest of us?

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by hinkley on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @12:17PM (#38382006)
I get a lostredditor vibe way too often here. Oddly more than Reddit.

I think people forget sometimes that comments come with a context. If we are having a conversation about Deep Water Horizon someone will chime in about how safe deep sea oil exploration is and how many failsafes blah blah blah.

“Do you know where you are right now?”

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by iandanforth on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @01:35PM (#38383169)
I apologize, the comment's irony overwhelmed my snark containment system.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by Obscurity4340 on Thursday November 23, 2023 @02:25AM (#38390333)
This comment is perfectionXD
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by Juicyy on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @12:35PM (#38382250)
Its a more technical space then reddit. Youre gonna have more know it alls spewing
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by jachee on Thursday November 23, 2023 @12:47AM (#38389753)
You know that know-it-all should be hyphenated, right?

…

;)

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by LordDragonfang on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @12:36PM (#38382268)
>I think people forget sometimes that comments come with a context.

I mean, this is definitely one of my pet peeves, but the wider context of this conversation is specifically a board doing stupid shit, so that's a very relevant counterexample to the thing being stated. Board members in general often do stupid/short-sighted shit (especially in tech), and I don't know of any examples of corporate board members recusing themselves.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by mhluongo on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @12:56PM (#38382564)
Common example of recusal is CEO comp when the CEO is on the board.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by alsetmusic on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @01:19PM (#38382936)
That's what I would term a black-and-white case. I don't think there's anyone with sense who would argue in good faith that a CEO should get a vote on their own salary. There are many degrees of grey between outright corruption and this example, and I think the concern lies within.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by teachinghacker on Friday November 24, 2023 @02:18AM (#38401370)
It happens a lot. Every big company has CEOs from other businesses on its board and sometimes those businesses will have competing products or services.

Eric Schmidt on Apple’s board is the example that immediately came to my mind. https://www.apple.com/ca/newsroom/2009/08/03Dr-Eric-Schmidt-...

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by alsetmusic on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @01:17PM (#38382913)
I get what you're saying, but I also live in the world and see the mechanics of capitalism. I may be a person who's interested in tech, science, education, archeology, etc. That doesn't mean that I don't also have political views that sometimes overlap with a lot of other very-online people.

I think the comment to which you replied has a very reddit vibe, no doubt. But also, it's a completely valid point. Could it have been said differently? Sure. But I also immediately agreed with the sentiment.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by hinkley on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @01:41PM (#38383273)
Oh I wasn’t complaining about the parent, I was complaining it needed to be said.

We are talking about a failure of the system, in the context of a concrete example. Talking about how the system actually works is only appropriate if you are drawing specific arguments up about how this situation is an anomaly, and few of them do that.

Instead it often sounds like “it’s very unusual for the front to fall off”.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by mhh__ on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @12:59PM (#38382620)
So?
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by jjoonathan on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @12:15PM (#38381966)
No, this is the part of the show where the patronizing rhetoric gets trotted out to rationalize discarding the principles that have suddenly become inconvenient for the people with power.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by photochemsyn on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @09:13PM (#38388363)
No worries. The same kind of people who devoted their time and energy to creating open-source operating systems in the era of Microsoft and Apple are now devoting their time and energy to doing the same for non-lobotomized LLMs.

Look at these clowns (Ilya & Sam and their angry talkie-bot), it's a revelation, like Bill Gates on Linux in 2000:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N36wtDYK8kI

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by dragonwriter on Thursday November 23, 2023 @06:33PM (#38398977)
No, its the part of the show where they go back to providing empty lip service to the principles and using them as a pretext for things that actually serve narrow proprietary interests, the same way they were before the leadership that has been doing that for a long time was temporarily removed until those sharing the proprietary interests revolted for a return to the status quo ante.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by badloginagain on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @12:07PM (#38381876)
And we're seeing the result in real-time. Stupid shit doers have been replaced with hopefully-less-stupid-shit-doers.

It's a real shame too, because this is a clear loss for the AI Alignment crowd.

I'm on the fence about the whole alignment thing, but at least there is a strong moral compass in the field- especially compared to something like crypto.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by alsetmusic on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @01:20PM (#38382959)
> at least there is a strong moral compass in the field

Is this still true when the board gets overhauled after trying to uphold the moral compass.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by saalweachter on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @05:37PM (#38386169)
And when the CEO's other thing is a cryptocurrency?
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by lacrimacida on Thursday November 23, 2023 @10:57AM (#38394135)
Sama’s moral compass clearly has north pointing at money and that will definitely get him to a different destination.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by freedomben on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @02:05PM (#38383618)
You need to be able to separate macro-level and micro-level. GP is responding to a comment about the IRS caring about the conflict-of-interest on paper. The IRS has to make and follow rules at a macro level. Micro-level events obviously can affect the macro view, but you don't completely ignore the macro because something bad happened at the micro level. That's how you get knee-jerk reactionary governance, which is highly emotional.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by dev_tty01 on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @08:45PM (#38388138)
Yes, and we were also watching the thousands and thousands of companies where these types of conflicts are handled easily by decent people and common sense. Don't confuse the outlier with the silent majority.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by dragonwriter on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @12:08PM (#38381897)
A corporation acting (due to influence from a conflicted board member that doesn't recuse) contrary to the interests of its stockholders and in the interest of the conflicted board member or who they represent potentially creates liability of the firm to its stockholders.

A charity acting (due to the influence of a conflicted board member that doesn't recuse) contrary to its charitable mission in the interests of the conflicted board member or who they represent does something similar with regard to liability of the firm to various stakeholders with a legally-enforceable interest in the charity and its mission, but also is also a public civil violation that can lead to IRS sanctions against the firm up to and including monetary penalties and loss of tax exempt status on top of whatever private tort liability exists.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by ip26 on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @12:01PM (#38381805)
Reminds me of the “revolving door” problem. Obvious risk of corruption and conflict of interest, but at the same time experts from industry are the ones with the knowledge to be effective regulators. Not unlike how many good patent attorneys were previously engineers.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by fouc on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @12:36PM (#38382265)
OpenAI isn't a typical corporation but a 501(c)(3), so bylaws & protections that otherwise might exist appear to be lacking in this situation.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by dragonwriter on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @01:38PM (#38383221)
501c3's also have governing internal rules, and the threat of penalties and loss of status imposed by the IRS gives them additional incentive to safeguard against even the appearance of conflict being manifested into how they operate (whether that's avoiding conflicted board members or assuring that they recuse where a conflict is relevant.)

If OpenAI didn't have adequate safeguards, either through negligence or becauase it was in fact being run deliberately as a fraudulent charity, that's a particular failure of OpenAI, not a “well, 501c3’s inherently don't have safeguard” thing.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by kevin_thibedeau on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @07:45PM (#38387604)
Trump Foundation was a 501c3 that laundered money for 30 years without the IRS batting an eye.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by hnbad on Thursday November 23, 2023 @08:41AM (#38392633)
The Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation is a 501c3 and I'd expect that even the most techno-futurist free-market types on HN would agree that no matter what alleged impact it has, it is also in practice creating profitable overseas contracts for US corporations that ultimately provide downstream ROI to the Gates estate.

Most people just tend to go about it more intelligently than Trump but "charitable" or "non-profit" doesn't mean the organization exists to enrich the commons rather than the moneyed interests it represents.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by throwaway-blaze on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @01:17PM (#38382915)
No conflict, no interest.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by dizzydes on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @08:04PM (#38387781)
Larry Summers practically invented this stuff...
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by hackernewds on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @12:05PM (#38381856)
Not to mention, the mission of the Board cannot be "build safe AGI" anymore. Perhaps something more consistent with expanding shareholder value and capitalism, as the events of this weekend has shown.

Delivering profits and shareholder value is the sole and dominant force in capitalism. Remains to be seen whether that is consistent with humanity's survival

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by boh on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @12:16PM (#38381983)
Whenever there's an obvious conflict, assume it's not enforced or difficult to litigate or has relatively irrelevant penalties. Experts/lawyers who have a material stake in getting this right have signed off on it. Many (if not most) people with enough status to be on the board of a fortune 500 company tend to also be on non-profit boards. We can go out on a limb and suppose the mission of the nonprofit is not their top priority, and yet they continue on unscathed.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by hinkley on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @12:23PM (#38382082)
Do you remember before Bill Gates got into disease prevention he thought that “charity work” could be done by giving away free Microsoft products? I don’t know who sat him down and explained to him how full of shit he was but they deserve a Nobel Peace Prize nomination.

Just because someone says they agree with a mission doesn’t mean they have their heads screwed on straight. And my thesis is that the more power they have in the real world the worse the outcomes - because powerful people become progressively immune to feedback. This has been working swimmingly for me for decades, I don’t need humility in a new situation.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by Xelynega on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:02PM (#38388713)
> Experts/lawyers who have a material stake in getting this right have signed off on it.

How does that work when we're talking about non-profit motives? The lawyers are paid by the companies benefitting from these conflicts, so how is it at all reassuring to hear that the people who benefit from the conflict signed off on it?

> We can go out on a limb and suppose the mission of the nonprofit is not their top priority, and yet they continue on unscathed.

That's the concern. They've just replaced people who "maybe" cared about the mission statement with people who you've correctly identified care more about profit growth than the nonprofit mission.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by jklein11 on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @01:28PM (#38383060)
I'm a little bit confused, are you saying that the IRS would have some sort of beef with employees of Microsoft serving on the board of a 501(c)(3)?
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by zerohalo on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @02:12PM (#38383703)
OpenAI's charter is dead. I expect future boards to amend it.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by dragonwriter on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @02:15PM (#38383752)
Its useful PR pretext for their regulatory advocacy, and subjective enough that if they are careful not to be too obvious about specifically pushing one company’s commercial interest, they can probably get away with it forever, so why would it be any deader than when Sam was CEO before and not substantively guided by it.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by ric2b on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @05:20PM (#38385990)
People keep saying this but is there any evidence that any of this was related to the charter?
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by Xelynega on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:05PM (#38388725)
The only evidence I have is that the board members that were removed had less business connections than the ones that replaced them.

The point of the board is to ensure the charter is being followed, when the biggest concern is "is our commercialization getting in the way of our charter" what else does it mean to replace "academics" with "businesspeople"?

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by augustulus on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @05:53PM (#38386337)
how can they not remain a charity?
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by 627467 on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @07:01PM (#38387076)
I don't get the drama with "conflict of interests"... Aren't board members generally (always?) in representation of major shareholders? Isn't it obvious that shareholders have interests that are likely to be in conflict with each other or even the own organization? Thats why board members are supposed to check each other, right?
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by Xelynega on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:00PM (#38388703)
OpenAI is a non profit and the board members are not allowed to own shares in the for profit.

That means the remaining conflicts are when the board has to make a decisions between growing the profit or furthering the mission statement. I wouldn't trust the new board appointed by investors to ever make the correct decision in these cases, and they already kicked out the "academic" board members with the power to stop them.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by mattmcknight on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @11:02PM (#38389109)
The non-profit could sell off its interest in the for-profit company and use the money for AGI research.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by gandutraveler on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @07:48AM (#38378471)
They need a common man representing the board. After all AI will take those jobs.

I can be that common man

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by solardev on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:29AM (#38380546)
You'd have my vote. At least you can formulate coherent reasons.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by rvnx on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:53AM (#38380865)
You have a second vote. I trust more gandutraveler than the people running the shitshow that is happening at the moment.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by shanusmagnus on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:56AM (#38380905)
And my axe.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by jjk166 on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @11:00AM (#38380962)
Plot twist: that's the very first job the AI will be taking.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by Marrand on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @01:13PM (#38382842)
A blow for the common man!
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by Cacti on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @09:54AM (#38380018)
Ilya thought he was saving the world (lol), but really he was just working at Microsoft.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by bandrami on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:05AM (#38380204)
Wait, the CEO having a seat on the board is kind of not cool
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by fatbird on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:10AM (#38380284)
It's quite common, actually.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by wnoise on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @12:46PM (#38382425)
It is quite common. Still not cool.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by himaraya on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:26AM (#38380508)
Sounds like speculation again from Sam's camp, honestly. Hard to judge without knowing which way the new board members lean.