there are so many really cool sites from the past that i cant recall what they were but i recall the experience, like that one with the gallaxy cluster of all music genres and how each were related, and each node played an sample for that genre...
/one handed popsicle typing
Or: Pokemon, but you can trade the pokemon outside the game itself; and the game can prove that your competitive mon were authentically caught and raised, rather than hacked in, because it records all the actions you took to train it.
Most obviously: in any MMO with an in-game currency you can and are encouraged to buy with real-world money (e.g. EVE Online), just tokenize the darn thing, so that people playing can easily cash back out of the game when they don't feel like playing any more.
These become loot boxes / gambling as well.
Where’s the need for crypto in this business model?
> Pokemon, but you can trade the pokemon outside the game itself; and the game can prove that your competitive mon were authentically caught and raised,
So… cheating protection? Every notable multiplayer game in the world already does hat.
> so that people playing can easily cash back out of the game
Sounds a lot like a cinema where you can resell your ticket after the show is over – why would any content creator do that?
> Where’s the need for crypto in this business model?
Crypto advocates misinterpret this as a technological failing or gap. It's actually an issue that could be solved purely in existing technology, but no one wants to because lock-in is desirable to everyone but the consumer. The market will never decide on its own to offer this solution.
This is usually the problem with any crypto idea. They fail to distinguish between people problems and technology problems. Ticketmaster ain’t charging hidden bullshit fees because their database somehow forces them to.
This is already possible and always has been. The reason steam and the game studios haven’t implemented it is because it wasn’t in their interest to do so, not because they didn’t have the technology to.
They've been winding it back best they can ever since because having a tradable USD proxy (keys) led to money laundering and under-age gambling websites where people used "keys" as a proxy for dollars so eventually they had to make the keys non-tradable.
The cat was out the bag and too late to make the skins themselves non-tradable, but it's worth noting that other companies haven't tended to follow suit in having their skins fully marketplace enabled.
There just isn't the incentive for one, why would a company want people to be able to resell skins when they can just sell a fresh new copy at full price.
The point of putting a blockchain in the middle is that the immutability of the smart contract underlying the tokenized asset guarantees that you still own the thing even if the person who sold it to you disagrees, and the person running the show backs them up†. Which is not true in the by-fiat system.
To put that in terms of non-digital assets: a country that issues a fiat currency, can declare at any point that some asset token they've issued is "no longer legal tender." Canada did it with pennies a while back. But they can't declare by fiat that a commodity has no value. Commodity values can be manipulated (see: oil prices), but they can't simply "make it go away" by withdrawing their backing from it. A commodity has inherent value, whether or not it's backed.
(How would that work, in this case? You'd need 1. IP ownership [or at least sub-licensable use] rights sold to a legal trust, 2. where that legal trust's beneficiary is a DAO; 3. where that DAO declares in its immutable articles of incorporation that non-fungible tokens issued by smart contract X represent transferrable sub-licenses of its acquired IP license; and where 4. smart contract X is immutable.)
If you've got all four of those properties satisfied, then what you've created is less like a fiat currency, and more like a commodity. The IP owner cannot revoke selling a sub-licenseable IP license to the DAO, any more than you can revoke selling your house to someone. The DAO has no path to change the rule by which it allocates IP rights through the token. And the token itself can't be tampered with to change who owns it. The only place you could affect this system would be at the level of getting the government that issued the original IP license, to declare it void. (But why would they do that? The US government didn't do it for Tolkien's dumb sale of sub-licenseable IP-rights to LOTR in the 1970s, and that was pretty much the case where you'd expect big-Hollywood lobbying to win out over the public good.)
---
† Yes, technically, you can also create this guarantee just using the regular legal system, without involving blockchains — you'd issue individual IP licensing "deed" contracts to each primary-market buyer, such that they can prove they own the rights; and players could then resell these "deeds" to each-other with a notarized and registered document of sale, similar to land title transfer, so that you can prove that a given "deed" is legitimately acquired rather than stolen or forged. But that's extremely impractical — the costs of the overhead of the transfer process far outweigh the costs of the goods being transferred! In this sense, a blockchain is just a way to make this process scale for lower-value items, by making the whole "notarized transfer-of-sale ledger" into just some (digitally-signed) bits, such that people can transfer each-other IP rights — and other low-value "deedable" things — from an app on their phone, at the cost of maybe a dollar for "notarization and registration" by the chain's validators.
Diablo 3 actually did this exact thing at launch with the real money auction house. Shockingly, they didn't need crypto to do so! But it also didn't make them too many friends, and they had to pull it down a year or two later.
Nintendo at no point WANTS their players to be able to use their pokemon in something that you didn't have to buy from Nintendo. This isn't complicated to understand.
There is no desire from IP holders, from investors, from developers, from anyone involved, to allow you to export your Keanu Reeves skin from Fortnite into whatever else. Why do that when they can just make you buy it again? Why would anyone forgo that literal free money when the vast majority of video game players seem perfectly willing to spend 10s of real dollars on a simple, half assed texture made by an intern in a few days. It's been a literal gold mine.
And the games are not fun, and ultimately no one playing really cares because everyone is just trying to make money.
Very strange industry.
What I'm saying is that what you experienced is not a technology problem, and nothing about cryptocurrency inherently fixes that problem. I could absolutely create a cryptocurrency that puts you through mountains of bullshit and bureaucracy anytime you want to make an account or wallet.
But most HNers here are not begging for donations, or suffering from starvation or are currently at war (Ukraine) or not experiencing hyperinflation (Argentina) and are not the ones who experienced their bank accounts getting locked after protesting against their government (Canada).
But never-mind. But a clear pattern I’ve seen on HN is that they only care as long as it directly affects them. (For example, look at the herd reaction about the Bob Lee situation in San Francisco [1])
Since they are not experiencing all of the above and are comfortably sitting in their chairs browsing on this site on their computers, why would they care about crypto use-cases since it doesn’t affect their luxuries, yet?
No it isn't as it is true on this site and the truth hurts and bleeds your eyes doesn't it? Obviously people like you can't stand it due to your highly emotional reaction.
> You only care about crypto because you invested in it.
Please.
Speculating on a stablecoin which the Stellar and Moneygram use case is for sending stable currencies for worldwide payments cheaply and instantly is hardly useful as an 'investment'.
> Please tell me how much volunteer work you have put in for food relief or refugee causes then tell me how much money you have put into crypto and then let's see if you can claim the moral high ground.
I can tell that people like you complaining have about it here isn't a solution to helping the refugees such as the ones in Ukraine for example or any of the help they need or anything close to a solution, whilst others are providing a solution today. [0]
So this is indeed a great crypto use case that you yourself realise that it works.
[0] https://thefintechtimes.com/stellar-aid-assist-creates-new-r...
What is “well” here?
Using Wise or similar almost always ends up cheaper and faster when you factor in the need to go to/from fiat, and the chances that you’ll fat-finger the transfer and lose your money, get difficult questions from your bank, or that Wise will collapse with your balance are much reduced as compared to using crypto for this.
If you’re trying to evade capital controls, however immoral you may consider them, well that’s something different.
I guess the United States doesn't have much of a future either? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boston_Tea_Party
Now I am begining to understand why people like Moral Relativism, it gets them gotcha moments on internet.
You think all those people paid under the table is "legal"?
Unfortunately it hasn't been a priority for the community and the focus has always been on getting rich, instead of working for infrastructure and adoption.
Even Bitcoin itself made this choice.
But I would also want to see derivatives die. Like what it even mean to "invest" in QQQ or VIX? This is just gambling (unless you have market inside knowledge).
But today we are the point where we’re trading each others insurances betting on whether they will be triggered or not. That is bonkers.
Should you call that insurance as well?
The point is, should call options used for hedging regulated as insurance?
Anyway your argument to regulate hedge trading as insurance is lacking.
Who is “we” ? You don’t have to trade anything you don’t want to.
> That is bonkers.
Why?
Regardless, I'm inclined to agree the main point is probably gambling and insider trading.
My gut instinct is to agree. I also feel the same about the fossil fuel industry for the most part.
I am curious which one of those two death wishes would lead to more negative economic impact in the short term.
Based on my ignorant googling of relative values, I think erasing the fossil fuel industry would be much less devastating to investors in general, correct?
In any case, years ago I thought I invented the term “economic inertia.” I still think it’s THE problem to solve once the inertia is significant, and the particular industry is a net negative for humanity.
I do think that for both industries a multi-decade phase out would give people plenty of time to change their investment portfolio. This would do Less economic damage in the short term. That’s a good thing.
But look up synthetic derivatives as part of the global economy. It is crazy. Such a huge piece of the economy. So crazy that it makes me have crazy thoughts like maybe let it be, with a Tobin tax of sorts assigned to novel anti-poverty solution attempts.
Forget CO2, just the economic flourish of all those very smart people released from oil exploration duties would be very interesting.
Yes, fossil fuels created the world we have now, but they are obsolete on this planet. We have alternatives now.
When I look at what oil companies have engineered, I am truly in awe. Sub-sea well heads are nuts! Rigs are gonzo engineering / operations in the coolest ways! Those people should be working on asteroid mining, or civilization scale geothermal, or 2-story-house-sized PV panel laying robots roaming the deserts. They could pull it off, and it is already 2023 ffs.
There are many arguments that index investing is the best long-term strategy. Is NASDAQ the issue?
I would argue index investing is far less gambling than stock picking because you're betting on the overall direction of a market segment, in this case tech, as opposed to a specific tech stock. Stock investing, in aggregate, can be viewed as a positive-sum game - the value of your holdings tends to appreciate through the contributions of non-investor participants (company customers buying products -> increase in intrinsic value of the company).
VIX on the other hand is a very exotic product, and it's not an investment - it's a hedge, if you can call it that. VIX is a mean-reverting index that spikes up when volatility goes up and drops back down over time, the notional value of which is based on the premium of calls and puts on the S&P 500 over the coming 30 days. It's the derivative of a derivative - a 2nd derivative, if you will. Note that, importantly, you cannot buy a "VIX," there's no such thing. You can buy cash-settled VIX futures where people speculate on the index value on a certain date, and you can buy cash-settled European-style calls or puts (i.e. they cannot be exercised except at expiration, vs American options which can be exercised any time on or before expiration). You can also buy ETFs like VXX and UVXY that use futures and cash positions to attempt to track the index.
QQQ and VIX are very different things.
[edit] When I say VIX futures aren't an investment, check this out lol. Set the graph in [1] to Max duration. Since 2018 it's lost 96.5% of its value. Heck it's lost just shy of 50% of its value since January 1st. They just continuously reverse-split so the numbers aren't silly.
[1] https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/VXX?p=VXX&.tsrc=fin-srch
What kind of users an alternative Reddit attracts?
1. People who don't like Reddit because of privacy concerns or other ideological reasons.
2. People who are banned by Reddit.
It turns out group 2 is much larger than group 1 and the community rots.
Now what kind of people who cryptos (a.k.a. alternative money) attract?
1. People who don't like banks or the government's monetary policy, and ideologically believe they have to own their own wallets.
2. People who literally cannot safely use normal money, from non-conventional porn artists to scammers and drug dealers.
It turns out group 2 is bigger than group 1 and you know the rest of story.
Crypto is people who see the tax that credit card networks are on all transactions, but their problem with it isn't that it's wealth redistribution from those with bad credit to those with good credit, but rather that they aren't the ones collecting the tax.
I guess my definition of tyranny is different...
Crypto is also used to evade taxes. I'm not saying it's a good thing, but it's not as bad as dealing drugs or scamming people.
You know what, this narrative is funny, because 99.999% of the time in which "crypto" is used to evade taxes, it's the kind of taxes that would need to be paid because of capital gains on the crypto assets because their value increased. But most of the time, they are unrealized gains, which means that tax evasion didn't actually happen. But anyway, let's now think of the cases where the person sold the crypto back to fiat: how easy is to evade taxes at that moment? Not very, because most exchanges report trades to authorities.
And anyway, the fact that their crypto balance increased is due ultimately to politicians doing QE! So they tax us in a hidden-way via money-printing, and after the scarce assets increase in value because of this, they want to tax us again.
But I suppose some crypto owners are changing their tax residence without declaring their crypto i.e. no deemed disposal and exit tax.
Want to buy a house? Now you need to convert your crypto into fiat and a deed transfer. People will start asking where your funds are coming from. This is where you tend to get caught.
This is a weird statement.
If it's a cash offer, it's a seller's job to determine if you have the money, not if you paid taxes on it.
If it's a mortgage down payment, then the bank is more interested in if your assets are going to disappear (e.g. are they actually a loan from a third party?). I've never had a mortgage bank inquire about my tax situation.
If you're talking about IRS audits... then yes, they might be curious how you purchased a giant asset without any declared income. But that's similar to any unreported income situation.
>This is a weird statement.
Not in the UK. Here there's a legal obligation on the conveyancing practitioner - which you have to use - to confirm the source of funds for the purchase. They "will ask questions about your salary, request bank statements and ask you to give details of any family inheritances"[1].
[1] https://www.bannerjones.co.uk/your-property/services/buying/...
Or has it always been a thing?
Yes, but your bank and the bank of the seller both have strict KYC/AML rules to respect. And the seller probably doesn't want to accept a pile of bills that requires laundering.
Honestly, to op's point, the IRS audit would be the likeliest to nail you, post-purchase.
"Person without demonstrated income suddenly buys expensive asset" is hard to hide and a huge, trackable signal.
Governments can get most of their revenue with little economic distortion by taxing stuff where evasion is much harder: Fuel taxes and property taxes.
You may believe there's a better way for the government to tax us, but that's not how the system works currently.
Crypto being used for tax evasion is a good reason for it to be regulated out of existence.
Regulating it with a heavy hand will do more harm than good. Those innovators will just move offshore.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_money
But a system that takes the concept of ledgers, and makes it tied to pseudonymous addresses instead of persons, is distributed across the world, resilient to tampering, and which gives its users control over their money, and which has been in use for 15 years is
1. “Not innovative”, and
2. That in the span of 30,000 years that 15 years is enough time to really tell if this is something that will survive or if it’s just a dumb idea that will die out.
I think that Bitcoin is a wonderful system, and I think that more people should take time to study Bitcoin in detail. Do not let the crypto bros and the people that only care about measuring Bitcoin in dollars distract you from the real point of Bitcoin.
Well, it is innovative, in the same sense a jet engine is. What you don't do with jet engines is using them to keep static structures in the air indefinitely. You use steel beams or concrete for that.
Crypto tech as cash alternative is pretty much jet engine as a steel tower alternative.
I don't personally own any beer hats. But I see how they are useful at a baseball game for example.
Thanks for reminding me that beer hats exist. Now, if only I can find a store that sells beerhats for BTC :thinking_face:
Yes, let them move offshore. Being able to more easily commit tax fraud and money laundering isn't the kind of innovation we need to keep.
I also think that businesses avoiding tax by not reporting cash are putting themselves into an unfair position against businesses that are legally operating, and I'd have a preference that businesses doing this should be shut down. If you're running a thin margin business and your competitor is able to price themselves better by committing tax fraud, then you need to also commit tax fraud to compete, and that's a race to the bottom that's not good for anyone.
You can also compare apples and oranges, but the comparison might not be useful.
If you are Donald Trump or Nancy Pelosi, other rules apply to you, because they are the ones who write the rules or lobby for them.
Usually in this context the "evaders" will refer to it as tax resistance or tax protest. It is a form of civil disobedience. The government being disobeyed, of course, is unlikely to see it that way, and in a modern context, would call it evasion. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tax_resistance
The Indian example is especially poignant because refusing to pay salt taxes was one of their key strategies for achieving independence from the British, and they managed to do it without firing a shot. So yeah I'd say refusing to pay the salt tax was a big win morally and probably saved a lot of lives.
What the best examples typically have in common is that the government in question didn't possess the consent of the governed. In the case of the British WTRL the refrain was "No vote, no tax." If the government won't let women vote then what right does it have to tax them? Women weren't able to indicate consent (or lack thereof) via the political process, and they were ultimately successful in their argument that this taxation without representation was unjust. Incidentally this line of thinking was expanded upon decades later across the pond in the US, which ultimately decided via the 26th amendment that it was immoral to draft men into the army when they were still too young to vote, and lowered the voting age to 18.
See also https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_historical_acts_of_tax... for hundreds of examples you might or might not agree with ...!
Your argument doesn't make sense. The example you cite are examples of protest against unjust taxation not that "the government is not entitled" to any of my crypto. As you yourself elaborate in the following paragraphs. Are you seriously suggesting parallels between the crypto bros and Gandhi in that they are both participating in civil disobedience? Oh. Please.
And SBF is just a modern day MLK because both are referred to by TLAs!
This doesn't seem to want crypto or finance exchanges. Thistle people just want the benefits of the government without paying for it.
That's just fraud.
I never met his dealer, but I'm sure the dealer saw the decay and did nothing.
Dealers have no morals. Even the law that bartenders aren't allowed to serve drunk people is an absolute farce. Walk into any bar in this country and you'll find drunk people being served alcohol.
Maybe there is more to it than whether something is legal or illegal.
Regular tax paying people who want to alter their mind; ok.
But also customers who break the law in order to pay for drugs.
And when and where is it okay to deal? Personally I would not want drug addicts frequenting any place where I am trying to live.
Then what about the product they sell: supplied by violent cartels? No thanks.
Designer drugs laced with who knows what manufactured in an overseas lab? Again no.
I'd wager that group 3 is much larger than groups 1 and 2.
(Yes, I'm considering VCs to be part of group 3.)
Banking and financial services is about 1/4 of world GDP and insurance is about 1/12th of world GDP. Anything making 25x "than all other industries around the world combined" would be ~96% of the economy.
Competition happens inside an industry. And there is fierce competition between banks, much more so than in many other modern industries (e.g. there is much more competition than in tech).
And that's why Apple is worth 6x more than JP Morgan Chase?
What is the return on profits in the banking industry compared to tech, oil, etc.?
What are you even trying to say?
Was it by being trustworthy, or just their scams not yet being publicized?
There are bitcoin-only exchanges, e.g. Bitaroo. There are also P2P exchanges that don't hold user's funds, like LN2bot (this one is very handy because it supports Lightning, so fees are ridiculously low, and trades very fast for not being a SPOT exchange).
> I can't afford to mine it anymore.
Right, it's a professional industry now; hobbyists can still do it, but at a loss.
> What if I want to buy some more? Or sell some of what I have?
See the aforementioned exchanges above, in my first answer.
> What can I spend Bitcoin on?
Anything, really. For example you can buy flights & book hotels with travala.com. Or buy things in Amazon with a discount thanks to purse.io .
> What does Bitcoin solve for me?
Not being affected by events like SVB closures (or worse: smaller banks that may not be bailed out[1]); not being affected by QE in the medium-long term (e.g. put your savings in it and forget about for 4 years[2]).
[1] If you don't believe it, watch this: https://twitter.com/Stromens/status/1664977520750370816
[2] Try to find 2 points in the historic data of a BTCUSD chart, which differ by 4 years, the oldest point is never higher value than the newest point.
I tried to bring my bitcoin to the grocery store to buy some brownie mix and cheese slices but they wouldn't take any coins from my Trezor.
And Bitcoin absolutely tanked with rising interest rates, just like the equity markets. Can't say it's not responding to QE.
Did you miss the part where I recommended an exchange that doesn't hold user's funds?
> And Bitcoin absolutely tanked with rising interest rates, just like the equity markets.
Right, and where's the value of it 4 years after each value-tank event?
The only search result in Google for '"Ln2bot" crypto exchange' is this article.
It's peer to peer, but not trustless. There's a moment in the transaction at which one party can default. So they need a reputation and dispute resolution system.[1]
You'd think there would be trustless decentralized exchanges by now. Ones have been proposed.[2] Some even exist. It's possible to have a truly trustless exchange where orders are smart contracts on a blockchain, transactions are atomic swaps, and at no moment does a third party have custody of anything. This is called an "on-chain order book". It's rarely seen, because it's slow, lacks liquidity providers, and is subject to front-running. Also, nobody makes a billion dollars running one. Most so-called "decentralized exchanges" turn out not to be totally trustless inside.
[1] https://lnp2pbot.com/learn/common-problems-and-solutions.htm...
[2] https://www.smartcontractresearch.org/t/research-summary-tex...
This concept applies to custody, not to fiat-to-crypto exchanges. Because a fiat-to-crypto exchange is an on/off ramp into/outside crypto. And as fiat cannot be held in a trustless way, the most "trustless" way to make a swap without the exchange holding the fiat amount is by using an escrow system. If the escrow system can only be moved to party A or party B during a trade-dispute, then it's the most trustless thing you can get, my friend.
PS: Your 2nd link seems to suggest that you're saying "DEXes are better than p2p exchanges!", well, DEXes don't have fiat-to-crypto pairs, only crypto-to-crypto. Nice try.
Irrationality, Extortion, or Trusted Third-parties: Why it is Impossible to Buy and Sell Physical Goods Securely on the Blockchain
Sure, why care about the possibility that cashing out early might mean you lose half your money? Trust instead in the long long long history of BTC as a stable currency.
You perceive it as unstable because you're using USD as a unit-of-account. As a thought exercise, if you were using BTC as the unit of account, what you would perceive unstable is the US dollar. And what you would see is that the USD value would be trending down against BTC, especially if you choose a time-frame equal or higher than 4 years.
So yeah mate, nothing to see here, keep holding your cash.
No one ever suggests using some S&P500 ETF shares as money even though it also trends up vs the USD. Just like BTC it's also more volatile than money. Unlike BTC it represents something real though.
The point is that USD isn't for holding. It's for spending. BTC is more like a stock or asset than money. Money isn't supposed to be volatile and it's not supposed to appreciate in value.
And if I choose a time frame of, say, 25 months or 19 months instead of 4 years, my savings lost more than half their purchasing power, which is far worse than anything QE has done to cash over equivalent time frames (ironically over a timescale which has been exceptionally bad for cash and exceptionally favourable to a notional "safe asset" alternative)
No, you would literally have to negotiate prices every single day. The vast majority of currencies have less volatility than Bitcoin. People don't think the dollar is unstable in the euro area.
Like you would do with gold.
FINES BY SEC: Merrill Lynch – $100 million Fine in 2002, Goldman Sachs- $550 million 2010, Eli Lilly & Co. – $1.42 billion 2009, UBS AG – $1.5 billion in 2012, Abbott Laboratories – $1.6 billion in 2012, Siemens $1.9 billion in 2008, HSBC Holdings – $1.9 billion in 2003, Pfizer – $2.3 billion in 2009, Bank of America – $3.6 billion in 2009, JP Morgan Chase – $13 billion in 2013
Did the SEC send a clear message? Are these company's dead? lol.. Are the industries they are in dead?
It's like saying tulips outperformed every other assets for a few years in the 1600s.
What risk do you think the market has been handsomely compensating Bitcoin investors for over the last year?
Genuine question, I don't know the answer, but if the market were pricing in the risk of Bitcoin suddenly going to zero through regulatory action, it might make sense that the price goes up a lot as old investors compensate new investors to exit while the music slows.
I feel like people smarter about finance than me who were paying close attention to Bitcoin might gather clues about this hypothesis from watching the order book consistently, so yeah, genuinely asking.
I cannot make any sense of this.
Law enforcement came down heavily on a crime and your response is - "Bitcoin solves this". Tells us all we need to know about the uses of Bitcoin.
Bitcoin also loves this. Lots of people will use the coming fall to make money shorting this. Then eventually as BTC stabilises they will make money going long as well.
In short a lot of BTC doomers will celebrate, and BTC mooners will celebrate as well. Except for different reasons.
Makes no sense at all to me.
How much of crypto is collectively going through FTX, Binance, and Coinbase? If they are really shut down, especially in a way where it's clear their business model will not be tolerated in the USA (so no one will take their place), how much will that pull down on the whole ecosystem?
However, because it is so poorly designed, almost nobody does that, and instead store their crypto in exchanges. Which have all the downsides of banks (they can hold your money hostage) but none of the upsides (security and regulation).
* Early adopters disproportionately end up in control of majority of coins (currently 0.03% of wallets own 59% of all bitcoins)
* Proof-of-work is wasteful
* Chain is very inefficient
* Loss of coins with loss of wallet means, for one, that inheriting the coins is not possible unless special precautions are taken which undo a lot of the security
* Other libertarian nonsense that shows very naive understanding of economics that I can't think of at the moment
You could argue about people losing their private keys being deflationary, but that's still different from blockchains like Ethereum whose currency is literally burned in small amounts during block creations (and therefore has the chance to be truly deflationary at times).
Aside from that your other points are valid.
Indeed. Bitcoin is the only cryptocurrency that the powers have deemed a commodity. The rest are securities.
Now let's talk use cases.
Sorry I just had to. I think crypto as an investable asset class is finished. SEC is sending a very clear signal here. It’s entirely the community’s fault for failing to properly manage this space.