News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by whatever1 on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @09:06PM (#36235861)
Crypto investing should die.

But I would also want to see derivatives die. Like what it even mean to "invest" in QQQ or VIX? This is just gambling (unless you have market inside knowledge).

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by rzi on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @09:25PM (#36235997)
Derivatives let you trade things other than price and are important in hedging against certain types of risk. I don’t think the point is to invest in them so I agree it seems like gambling for most people.
Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by whatever1 on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @10:10PM (#36236300)
If it is insurance call it insurance and regulate it as such.

But today we are the point where we’re trading each others insurances betting on whether they will be triggered or not. That is bonkers.

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by lumost on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @10:28PM (#36236426)
Not inherently, when the numbers get big - strange things happen. It's not unreasonable that there would be insurance of insurance - it's also not unreasonable that there would be market traded contracts for the insurance of insurance. Provided that all parties can maintain their obligations under the contract... which may be a dubious/untested claim.
Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by vagab0nd on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @10:29PM (#36236438)
Why is it bonkers though? In a complete free market, everybody does whatever they want and as a result you get the best deal on your insurance premium.
Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by jojobas on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @10:23PM (#36236397)
Let's say you invest in green energy. But as a hedge, you buy some deep OOM oil options.

Should you call that insurance as well?

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by whatever1 on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @11:32PM (#36236831)
You can invest in oil companies instead. Why do you need leverage? Why do you have the expectation of making 100X from a 2X price increase?
Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by roywiggins on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @11:57PM (#36236997)
They're a lot cheaper than buying the actual stock, because there's every chance they'll expire worthless- and when you're hedging, you think they will probably expire worthless, too.
Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by whatever1 on Thursday June 08, 2023 @12:06AM (#36237047)
Problem is that the person who sells the option to you literally cannot guarantee that they can pay you because there is an infinite downside to them.
Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by jojobas on Thursday June 08, 2023 @12:11AM (#36237090)
A "person" can't sell a naked option, this can only be done by bigger companies with a margin account, and will be margin-called when the price approaches the strike price.

The point is, should call options used for hedging regulated as insurance?

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by whatever1 on Thursday June 08, 2023 @01:03AM (#36237442)
In any system you aim to stabilize you don’t want unregulated factors with exponential effects.
Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by jojobas on Thursday June 08, 2023 @01:34AM (#36237648)
There's a balance between stability and progress, and we seem to be at about the right spot.

Anyway your argument to regulate hedge trading as insurance is lacking.

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by wesapien on Thursday June 08, 2023 @02:21AM (#36237978)
Margin accounts aren't that exclusive. I opened a margin account just because but I've never dipped into it. It's just a tool and if you know how to use it, good for you.
Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by jojobas on Thursday June 08, 2023 @04:15AM (#36238756)
Margin accounts may not be, naked options seem to be.
Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by umanwizard on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @11:49PM (#36236948)
> But today we are the point where we’re trading each others insurances betting on whether they will be triggered or not.

Who is “we” ? You don’t have to trade anything you don’t want to.

> That is bonkers.

Why?

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by red369 on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @09:21PM (#36235967)
Aren't there more legitimate use for some of these for hedging? I don't know any specific examples, but I'm sure I've heard of situations where people use these because they want to invest in something quite specific, but remove the upside or downside of general market movement.

Regardless, I'm inclined to agree the main point is probably gambling and insider trading.

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by plewd on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @09:13PM (#36235907)
That's what most day trading seems to be, there's almost no way to tell how prices will fluctuate in a single day
Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by consumer451 on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @09:44PM (#36236128)
> But I would also want to see derivatives die.

My gut instinct is to agree. I also feel the same about the fossil fuel industry for the most part.

I am curious which one of those two death wishes would lead to more negative economic impact in the short term.

Based on my ignorant googling of relative values, I think erasing the fossil fuel industry would be much less devastating to investors in general, correct?

In any case, years ago I thought I invented the term “economic inertia.” I still think it’s THE problem to solve once the inertia is significant, and the particular industry is a net negative for humanity.

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by ficklepickle on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @10:36PM (#36236478)
Erasing the fossil fuel industry over night would have the unfortunate effect of grinding the rest of the economy to a halt. You can't just look at it in isolation. Unless you had something like worldwide nationalization in mind. I suppose then it might be possible to transport other goods while still eliminating the speculation on and profiteering of the fossil fuel industry.
Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by consumer451 on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @11:50PM (#36236950)
I was trying to edit myself for brevity.

I do think that for both industries a multi-decade phase out would give people plenty of time to change their investment portfolio. This would do Less economic damage in the short term. That’s a good thing.

But look up synthetic derivatives as part of the global economy. It is crazy. Such a huge piece of the economy. So crazy that it makes me have crazy thoughts like maybe let it be, with a Tobin tax of sorts assigned to novel anti-poverty solution attempts.

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by cplusplusfellow on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @11:57PM (#36236994)
Until the last already-drilled oil well runs dry.
Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by consumer451 on Thursday June 08, 2023 @12:03AM (#36237034)
No new wells sounds like a great lever to pull.

Forget CO2, just the economic flourish of all those very smart people released from oil exploration duties would be very interesting.

Yes, fossil fuels created the world we have now, but they are obsolete on this planet. We have alternatives now.

When I look at what oil companies have engineered, I am truly in awe. Sub-sea well heads are nuts! Rigs are gonzo engineering / operations in the coolest ways! Those people should be working on asteroid mining, or civilization scale geothermal, or 2-story-house-sized PV panel laying robots roaming the deserts. They could pull it off, and it is already 2023 ffs.

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by ncraig on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @10:44PM (#36236523)
>Like what it even mean to "invest" in QQQ... just gambling

There are many arguments that index investing is the best long-term strategy. Is NASDAQ the issue?

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by khuey on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @10:45PM (#36236528)
In what sense is QQQ a derivative?
Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by arcticbull on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @11:01PM (#36236639)
Indeed NQ=F is the derivative
Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by arcticbull on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @10:49PM (#36236561)
QQQ, like most ETFs, isn't a derivative. You get a share that represents a basket of all of the NASDAQ-100 companies. This tracks the price of the components through creation/redemption mechanism. Authorized participants are able to create QQQ by sending a share of the constituent companies to the trust, and they're able to redeem QQQ for the shares in the trust. In this way participants are able to arbitrage the spread between QQQ and the components and keep the price tracking extremely, extremely closely. It also pays a 0.61% dividend because when the component in the trust pay a dividend it's distributed to QQQ shareholders - the ones who actually own the shares of the companies in the trust.

I would argue index investing is far less gambling than stock picking because you're betting on the overall direction of a market segment, in this case tech, as opposed to a specific tech stock. Stock investing, in aggregate, can be viewed as a positive-sum game - the value of your holdings tends to appreciate through the contributions of non-investor participants (company customers buying products -> increase in intrinsic value of the company).

VIX on the other hand is a very exotic product, and it's not an investment - it's a hedge, if you can call it that. VIX is a mean-reverting index that spikes up when volatility goes up and drops back down over time, the notional value of which is based on the premium of calls and puts on the S&P 500 over the coming 30 days. It's the derivative of a derivative - a 2nd derivative, if you will. Note that, importantly, you cannot buy a "VIX," there's no such thing. You can buy cash-settled VIX futures where people speculate on the index value on a certain date, and you can buy cash-settled European-style calls or puts (i.e. they cannot be exercised except at expiration, vs American options which can be exercised any time on or before expiration). You can also buy ETFs like VXX and UVXY that use futures and cash positions to attempt to track the index.

QQQ and VIX are very different things.

[edit] When I say VIX futures aren't an investment, check this out lol. Set the graph in [1] to Max duration. Since 2018 it's lost 96.5% of its value. Heck it's lost just shy of 50% of its value since January 1st. They just continuously reverse-split so the numbers aren't silly.

[1] https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/VXX?p=VXX&.tsrc=fin-srch

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by whatever1 on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @11:14PM (#36236715)
Apologies I meant SQQQ, inverse QQQ
Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by arcticbull on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @11:17PM (#36236732)
Ah, nice, another classic product. I quite enjoy deep-diving on this stuff. I looked them up, they hold a bunch of QQQ index swaps. I'll have to research them some more later, may follow up if I learn something interesting :) I just happened to know how QQQ and the VIX worked off hand.
Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by electric_muse on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @11:17PM (#36236729)
Thanks for such a great ELI5
Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by lmm on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @11:17PM (#36236728)
Either you're hedging, you're taking risk and getting paid for it, you're market-making, you're arbitraging, or you're purely speculating/gambling. The first and second are genuinely useful, the third and fourth are necessary to grease the wheels, and the fifth is at least relatively harmless (no-one's taking a rake, so it's better than betting on the horse racing or whatever).