News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by cycomanic on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @11:16PM (#36236727)
Why is evading tax not as bad as scamming people? Isn't it really just scamming the public (i.e. everyone)?
Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by nroets on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @11:30PM (#36236820)
Tax evasion is rife: How many tradesmen fixing stuff around your house for cash will report that income on their return ?

Governments can get most of their revenue with little economic distortion by taxing stuff where evasion is much harder: Fuel taxes and property taxes.

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by ryan_lane on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @11:41PM (#36236903)
Tax evasion is people stealing from you, just in an indirect way. Just because some people already steal from us doesn't mean it's OK for other (richer) people to steal even more from us.

You may believe there's a better way for the government to tax us, but that's not how the system works currently.

Crypto being used for tax evasion is a good reason for it to be regulated out of existence.

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by nroets on Thursday June 08, 2023 @12:05AM (#36237045)
You can make the same argument that governments should ban physical cash.
Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by flangola7 on Thursday June 08, 2023 @12:16AM (#36237118)
And many countries are moving in that direction, so what's your point?
Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by nroets on Thursday June 08, 2023 @12:50AM (#36237347)
For millennia governments survived with cash in circulation. Crypto is no real threat to their existence.

Regulating it with a heavy hand will do more harm than good. Those innovators will just move offshore.

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by forgetfreeman on Thursday June 08, 2023 @01:18AM (#36237543)
Crypto's been a think for almost 15 years now. I think we can dispense with the narrative that there's anything innovative going on.
Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by codetrotter on Thursday June 08, 2023 @04:02AM (#36238663)
Money of account (debits and credits on ledgers) have existed for 30,000 years

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_money

But a system that takes the concept of ledgers, and makes it tied to pseudonymous addresses instead of persons, is distributed across the world, resilient to tampering, and which gives its users control over their money, and which has been in use for 15 years is

1. “Not innovative”, and

2. That in the span of 30,000 years that 15 years is enough time to really tell if this is something that will survive or if it’s just a dumb idea that will die out.

I think that Bitcoin is a wonderful system, and I think that more people should take time to study Bitcoin in detail. Do not let the crypto bros and the people that only care about measuring Bitcoin in dollars distract you from the real point of Bitcoin.

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by TeMPOraL on Thursday June 08, 2023 @04:26AM (#36238836)
> But a system that takes the concept of ledgers, and makes it tied to pseudonymous addresses instead of persons, is distributed across the world, resilient to tampering (...) is 1. “Not innovative”

Well, it is innovative, in the same sense a jet engine is. What you don't do with jet engines is using them to keep static structures in the air indefinitely. You use steel beams or concrete for that.

Crypto tech as cash alternative is pretty much jet engine as a steel tower alternative.

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by Gh0stRAT on Thursday June 08, 2023 @10:13AM (#36242196)
That's a fantastic analogy for how incredibly wasteful Bitcoin & similar cryptocurrencies are just to maintain a steady state!
Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by forgetfreeman on Thursday June 08, 2023 @08:46AM (#36240963)
Beer has been a thing for ~5,000 years but we've only had beer hats for the last 28. Our society could benefit from extensive investment into ongoing research and development of beer hat related industries, as we clearly haven't had enough time to determine if they're bullshit novelty garments.
Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by codetrotter on Thursday June 08, 2023 @09:28AM (#36241540)
Beer hats are both funny, and in some cases practical.

I don't personally own any beer hats. But I see how they are useful at a baseball game for example.

Thanks for reminding me that beer hats exist. Now, if only I can find a store that sells beerhats for BTC :thinking_face:

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by TeMPOraL on Thursday June 08, 2023 @04:19AM (#36238785)
The difference between cash and crypto is like the difference between building a room on top of a tall tower, vs. strapping a few jet engines to it and pointing them downwards. Both methods solve the same problem - but one does it mostly passively, while the other one wastes absurd amount of energy simulating the same thing you normally get for free.
Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by ryan_lane on Thursday June 08, 2023 @04:38AM (#36238905)
> Those innovators will just move offshore.

Yes, let them move offshore. Being able to more easily commit tax fraud and money laundering isn't the kind of innovation we need to keep.

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by stale2002 on Thursday June 08, 2023 @04:24AM (#36238815)
So the point is that a large amount of people think that banning cash would be completely absurd and therefore this isn't just some issue that is relegated to obscure crypto fans.
Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by ryan_lane on Thursday June 08, 2023 @04:37AM (#36238893)
Crypto scales a lot better than cash, and allows for considerably larger amounts of fraud, and not just locally, but also internationally.

I also think that businesses avoiding tax by not reporting cash are putting themselves into an unfair position against businesses that are legally operating, and I'd have a preference that businesses doing this should be shut down. If you're running a thin margin business and your competitor is able to price themselves better by committing tax fraud, then you need to also commit tax fraud to compete, and that's a race to the bottom that's not good for anyone.

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by mrguyorama on Thursday June 08, 2023 @03:53PM (#36247803)
You cannot, because the two systems have entirely different sets of pros and cons, for entirely different sets of people.

You can also compare apples and oranges, but the comparison might not be useful.

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by elzbardico on Thursday June 08, 2023 @09:22AM (#36241447)
Tax is the burden of the middle class.

If you are Donald Trump or Nancy Pelosi, other rules apply to you, because they are the ones who write the rules or lobby for them.

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by forgetfreeman on Thursday June 08, 2023 @01:16AM (#36237530)
The subject of tax evasion comes up and invariably some flathead has the gall to point at folks that actually work for a living. Like they aren't a rounding error compared to corporate interests and oligarchs in this context.
Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by safety1st on Thursday June 08, 2023 @03:47AM (#36238554)
It's certainly more morally complex than just scamming somebody. Money is property. People generally agree that once you earn your money, it belongs to you. Is the government automatically entitled to part of it? The Boston Tea Party, the Women's Tax Resistance League, and Gandhi's Salt March are a few examples where people said no.

Usually in this context the "evaders" will refer to it as tax resistance or tax protest. It is a form of civil disobedience. The government being disobeyed, of course, is unlikely to see it that way, and in a modern context, would call it evasion. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tax_resistance

The Indian example is especially poignant because refusing to pay salt taxes was one of their key strategies for achieving independence from the British, and they managed to do it without firing a shot. So yeah I'd say refusing to pay the salt tax was a big win morally and probably saved a lot of lives.

What the best examples typically have in common is that the government in question didn't possess the consent of the governed. In the case of the British WTRL the refrain was "No vote, no tax." If the government won't let women vote then what right does it have to tax them? Women weren't able to indicate consent (or lack thereof) via the political process, and they were ultimately successful in their argument that this taxation without representation was unjust. Incidentally this line of thinking was expanded upon decades later across the pond in the US, which ultimately decided via the 26th amendment that it was immoral to draft men into the army when they were still too young to vote, and lowered the voting age to 18.

See also https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_historical_acts_of_tax... for hundreds of examples you might or might not agree with ...!

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by a2800276 on Thursday June 08, 2023 @04:25AM (#36238833)
> Is the government automatically entitled to part of it? The Boston Tea Party, the Women's Tax Resistance League, and Gandhi's Salt March are a few examples where people said no.

Your argument doesn't make sense. The example you cite are examples of protest against unjust taxation not that "the government is not entitled" to any of my crypto. As you yourself elaborate in the following paragraphs. Are you seriously suggesting parallels between the crypto bros and Gandhi in that they are both participating in civil disobedience? Oh. Please.

And SBF is just a modern day MLK because both are referred to by TLAs!

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by safety1st on Thursday June 08, 2023 @04:48AM (#36238974)
I think it makes perfect sense in its immediate context, my parent asked a question about the morality of tax evasion, I gave some examples where there was wide consensus that people not paying their taxes was moral, but it still would have been referred to as evasion. Other people were bringing up examples of tradesmen and stuff, not just crypto. I will leave it to the federal government to render the final verdict on SBF but he ain't got shit on Gandhi, that's for sure.
Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by citizenkeen on Thursday June 08, 2023 @08:15AM (#36240598)
Your examples of tax protest were by people who didn't really want to be a part of the government they weren't paying taxes to, or felt they weren't being treated properly as a class.

This doesn't seem to want crypto or finance exchanges. Thistle people just want the benefits of the government without paying for it.

That's just fraud.