News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by ProjectArcturis on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @08:58PM (#36235805)
It's more the failure of the crypto community over the past 14 years to develop a use for crypto beyond speculation and crime.
Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by lelandfe on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @09:40PM (#36236103)
A friend of mine that works with crypto gaming companies frequently expresses frustration that every game they see is either gambling, slightly disguised gambling, or terrible.
Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by jrmg on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @10:16PM (#36236341)
What other kinds of ‘crypto gaming company’ _could_ there be?
Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by derefr on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @10:35PM (#36236470)
Steam but where you actually own, and so can resell, your game licenses. And where other supply-side companies can take over providing the game-download-delivery logistics if the original company providing that service goes belly-up.

Or: Pokemon, but you can trade the pokemon outside the game itself; and the game can prove that your competitive mon were authentically caught and raised, rather than hacked in, because it records all the actions you took to train it.

Most obviously: in any MMO with an in-game currency you can and are encouraged to buy with real-world money (e.g. EVE Online), just tokenize the darn thing, so that people playing can easily cash back out of the game when they don't feel like playing any more.

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by re-thc on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @11:00PM (#36236632)
> Or: Pokemon, but you can trade the pokemon outside the game itself

These become loot boxes / gambling as well.

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by lxgr on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @11:01PM (#36236641)
> Steam but where you actually own, and so can resell, your game licenses.

Where’s the need for crypto in this business model?

> Pokemon, but you can trade the pokemon outside the game itself; and the game can prove that your competitive mon were authentically caught and raised,

So… cheating protection? Every notable multiplayer game in the world already does hat.

> so that people playing can easily cash back out of the game

Sounds a lot like a cinema where you can resell your ticket after the show is over – why would any content creator do that?

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by brendoelfrendo on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @11:21PM (#36236764)
> > Steam but where you actually own, and so can resell, your game licenses.

> Where’s the need for crypto in this business model?

Crypto advocates misinterpret this as a technological failing or gap. It's actually an issue that could be solved purely in existing technology, but no one wants to because lock-in is desirable to everyone but the consumer. The market will never decide on its own to offer this solution.

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by Zanfa on Thursday June 08, 2023 @12:10AM (#36237079)
> Crypto advocates misinterpret this as a technological failing or gap.

This is usually the problem with any crypto idea. They fail to distinguish between people problems and technology problems. Ticketmaster ain’t charging hidden bullshit fees because their database somehow forces them to.

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by umanwizard on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @11:46PM (#36236931)
> Steam but where you actually own, and so can resell, your game licenses.

This is already possible and always has been. The reason steam and the game studios haven’t implemented it is because it wasn’t in their interest to do so, not because they didn’t have the technology to.

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by xnorswap on Thursday June 08, 2023 @06:55AM (#36239828)
Exactly this, and in fact as seen with CSGO skins / keys, steam had tradable skins which meet all the definitions of an "NFT" without blockchain.

They've been winding it back best they can ever since because having a tradable USD proxy (keys) led to money laundering and under-age gambling websites where people used "keys" as a proxy for dollars so eventually they had to make the keys non-tradable.

The cat was out the bag and too late to make the skins themselves non-tradable, but it's worth noting that other companies haven't tended to follow suit in having their skins fully marketplace enabled.

There just isn't the incentive for one, why would a company want people to be able to resell skins when they can just sell a fresh new copy at full price.

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by derefr on Friday June 09, 2023 @11:11AM (#36259011)
No, it wouldn't have been possible. Because nobody (read: secondary-market game collectors) is willing to be on the other side of that deal and actually value these transferrable game licenses to the degree that they value physical games. Because, in turn, the hypothetical little by-fiat "federation" of companies willing to honor it could just decide to renege on the deal at any time and stop honoring it. (Which would probably include shutting down the database that remembers who owns what!)

The point of putting a blockchain in the middle is that the immutability of the smart contract underlying the tokenized asset guarantees that you still own the thing even if the person who sold it to you disagrees, and the person running the show backs them up†. Which is not true in the by-fiat system.

To put that in terms of non-digital assets: a country that issues a fiat currency, can declare at any point that some asset token they've issued is "no longer legal tender." Canada did it with pennies a while back. But they can't declare by fiat that a commodity has no value. Commodity values can be manipulated (see: oil prices), but they can't simply "make it go away" by withdrawing their backing from it. A commodity has inherent value, whether or not it's backed.

(How would that work, in this case? You'd need 1. IP ownership [or at least sub-licensable use] rights sold to a legal trust, 2. where that legal trust's beneficiary is a DAO; 3. where that DAO declares in its immutable articles of incorporation that non-fungible tokens issued by smart contract X represent transferrable sub-licenses of its acquired IP license; and where 4. smart contract X is immutable.)

If you've got all four of those properties satisfied, then what you've created is less like a fiat currency, and more like a commodity. The IP owner cannot revoke selling a sub-licenseable IP license to the DAO, any more than you can revoke selling your house to someone. The DAO has no path to change the rule by which it allocates IP rights through the token. And the token itself can't be tampered with to change who owns it. The only place you could affect this system would be at the level of getting the government that issued the original IP license, to declare it void. (But why would they do that? The US government didn't do it for Tolkien's dumb sale of sub-licenseable IP-rights to LOTR in the 1970s, and that was pretty much the case where you'd expect big-Hollywood lobbying to win out over the public good.)

---

† Yes, technically, you can also create this guarantee just using the regular legal system, without involving blockchains — you'd issue individual IP licensing "deed" contracts to each primary-market buyer, such that they can prove they own the rights; and players could then resell these "deeds" to each-other with a notarized and registered document of sale, similar to land title transfer, so that you can prove that a given "deed" is legitimately acquired rather than stolen or forged. But that's extremely impractical — the costs of the overhead of the transfer process far outweigh the costs of the goods being transferred! In this sense, a blockchain is just a way to make this process scale for lower-value items, by making the whole "notarized transfer-of-sale ledger" into just some (digitally-signed) bits, such that people can transfer each-other IP rights — and other low-value "deedable" things — from an app on their phone, at the cost of maybe a dollar for "notarization and registration" by the chain's validators.

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by umanwizard on Saturday June 10, 2023 @10:29AM (#36270771)
Even if there was a blockchain, Steam still has to decide to honor it, because they’re the ones who physically decide whether you get to play the game, or not. Nothing prevents them from choosing not to honor transfers that appear on the blockchain after a particular date, thus effectively switching back to a centralized database system.
Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by tsimionescu on Thursday June 08, 2023 @01:53AM (#36237763)
Any way of making real money out of game mechanics (selling Pokémon, cashing out in-game currency) instantly turns your game into (a) gambling (assuming you have any kind of randomness at all, which virtually all games do), and (b) a Mecca for bots, scammers, gold farmers etc. Someone losing their account is no longer losing just some in-game items, they are losing real money, which gets the police involved real quick.

Diablo 3 actually did this exact thing at launch with the real money auction house. Shockingly, they didn't need crypto to do so! But it also didn't make them too many friends, and they had to pull it down a year or two later.

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by charlieyu1 on Thursday June 08, 2023 @04:58AM (#36239033)
D2R trading is alive and well, the failure of D3 is more about it being a poor game, poor itemisation, every build was the same, nothing is worth farming except gold.
Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by mrguyorama on Thursday June 08, 2023 @04:13PM (#36248176)
None of these things have been impossible in a fiat economy. Nothing about the crypto economy makes these easier, more profitable, or desirable for private companies to implement.

Nintendo at no point WANTS their players to be able to use their pokemon in something that you didn't have to buy from Nintendo. This isn't complicated to understand.

There is no desire from IP holders, from investors, from developers, from anyone involved, to allow you to export your Keanu Reeves skin from Fortnite into whatever else. Why do that when they can just make you buy it again? Why would anyone forgo that literal free money when the vast majority of video game players seem perfectly willing to spend 10s of real dollars on a simple, half assed texture made by an intern in a few days. It's been a literal gold mine.

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by lelandfe on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @10:31PM (#36236454)
NFTs, mostly. Also play-to-earn stuff, which I don't fully understand.

And the games are not fun, and ultimately no one playing really cares because everyone is just trying to make money.

Very strange industry.

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by Paradigma11 on Thursday June 08, 2023 @04:01PM (#36247936)
You can have conventional good multiplayer games with resources that are tokens on the blockchain. That way you can leverage the existing smart contract ecosystem for free. Ppl can create futures, auctions, binary options, arbitrarily complex contracts depending on ingame data that you make available on the blockchain.... without you being responsible for it.
Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by mrguyorama on Thursday June 08, 2023 @04:06PM (#36248020)
Seeing as the only value cryptocurrency can bring to your game is law evasion, that's expected.
Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by TheDudeMan on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @10:08PM (#36236276)
It works well for sending money across the world. Seems like a nice thing to be able to do.
Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by cft on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @10:24PM (#36236404)
When i was in Ukraine before the war an ATM ate my debit card. Being stranded in a foreign country without an ATM card is pretty difficult. I thought that as soon as I walk into that Russian-owned Alpha Bank I would get my ATM card back. It actually took 4 days of daily visits and arguing with them in English and sometimes even in Spanish, where they asked me to write a letter to Kiev in Ukrainian, and wait a month for a decision. After that experience I was afraid to insert my ATM card into any bank machine over there. Instead I started buying Bitcoin on Coinbase and selling it at the local Bitcoin outfit for Hryvna and USD, to pay my rent.
Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by mrguyorama on Thursday June 08, 2023 @04:18PM (#36248267)
That's cool. One day my debit card refused to work. I walked out of the supermarket into the bank that literally shared the parking lot, they told me it had been possibly compromised so they killed it so I wouldn't lose any money. They then printed me a brand new debit card right then and there, and I walked back into the store and bought my stuff.

What I'm saying is that what you experienced is not a technology problem, and nothing about cryptocurrency inherently fixes that problem. I could absolutely create a cryptocurrency that puts you through mountains of bullshit and bureaucracy anytime you want to make an account or wallet.

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by rvz on Thursday June 08, 2023 @01:49AM (#36237733)
Exactly. For example there is this with Stellar [0] which is certainly a use case for sending money across the world into crypto wallets, same day, near instant and very low fees.

But most HNers here are not begging for donations, or suffering from starvation or are currently at war (Ukraine) or not experiencing hyperinflation (Argentina) and are not the ones who experienced their bank accounts getting locked after protesting against their government (Canada).

But never-mind. But a clear pattern I’ve seen on HN is that they only care as long as it directly affects them. (For example, look at the herd reaction about the Bob Lee situation in San Francisco [1])

Since they are not experiencing all of the above and are comfortably sitting in their chairs browsing on this site on their computers, why would they care about crypto use-cases since it doesn’t affect their luxuries, yet?

[0] https://stellar.org/moneygram

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35448899

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by Eisenstein on Thursday June 08, 2023 @03:42AM (#36238529)
This kind of 'you only care if it affects you' argument is so disingenuous it makes my eyes bleed. You only care about crypto because you invested in it. Please tell me how much volunteer work you have put in for food relief or refugee causes then tell me how much money you have put into crypto and then let's see if you can claim the moral high ground.
Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by rvz on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @04:01AM (#36307056)
> This kind of 'you only care if it affects you' argument is so disingenuous it makes my eyes bleed.

No it isn't as it is true on this site and the truth hurts and bleeds your eyes doesn't it? Obviously people like you can't stand it due to your highly emotional reaction.

> You only care about crypto because you invested in it.

Please.

Speculating on a stablecoin which the Stellar and Moneygram use case is for sending stable currencies for worldwide payments cheaply and instantly is hardly useful as an 'investment'.

> Please tell me how much volunteer work you have put in for food relief or refugee causes then tell me how much money you have put into crypto and then let's see if you can claim the moral high ground.

I can tell that people like you complaining have about it here isn't a solution to helping the refugees such as the ones in Ukraine for example or any of the help they need or anything close to a solution, whilst others are providing a solution today. [0]

So this is indeed a great crypto use case that you yourself realise that it works.

[0] https://thefintechtimes.com/stellar-aid-assist-creates-new-r...

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by petesergeant on Thursday June 08, 2023 @06:17AM (#36239551)
> It works well for sending money across the world

What is “well” here?

Using Wise or similar almost always ends up cheaper and faster when you factor in the need to go to/from fiat, and the chances that you’ll fat-finger the transfer and lose your money, get difficult questions from your bank, or that Wise will collapse with your balance are much reduced as compared to using crypto for this.

If you’re trying to evade capital controls, however immoral you may consider them, well that’s something different.

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by TheDudeMan on Thursday June 08, 2023 @05:58PM (#36249784)
How many times has the Bitcoin network collapsed?
Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by petesergeant on Friday June 09, 2023 @04:00AM (#36254744)
The network? No idea, but I suspect low. The exchanges that the vast majority of humans will need to use to convert to and from fiat? I think it's easier to count the ones that haven't collapsed tbh
Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by ProjectArcturis on Thursday June 08, 2023 @07:01AM (#36239877)
Does it? If it works well for that, why hasn't it replaced Western Union after all this time?
Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by TheDudeMan on Thursday June 08, 2023 @06:08PM (#36249898)
You'd have to ask the people who prefer Western Union.
Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by Apofis on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @10:46PM (#36236540)
Anything that begins in crime never has a future. Just look at the Soviet Union, started by Terrorists and Thieves. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1907_Tiflis_bank_robbery
Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by nwiswell on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @10:51PM (#36236579)
> Anything that begins in crime never has a future.

I guess the United States doesn't have much of a future either? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boston_Tea_Party

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by qazpot on Thursday June 08, 2023 @12:14AM (#36237104)
Lol, you are calling an act of rebellion a crime.

Now I am begining to understand why people like Moral Relativism, it gets them gotcha moments on internet.

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by lettergram on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @11:46PM (#36236935)
Quite literally how liquidity is kept in the cash market as well. lol

You think all those people paid under the table is "legal"?

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by concordDance on Thursday June 08, 2023 @04:10AM (#36238717)
Paying for porn, avoiding your bank randomly freezing your accounts (happened to a friend of mine, heuristics are only right most of the time), sending money to other countries and donating to peaceful protests.
Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by lawn on Thursday June 08, 2023 @06:43AM (#36239736)
The use case was always there: paying for stuff.

Unfortunately it hasn't been a priority for the community and the focus has always been on getting rich, instead of working for infrastructure and adoption.

Even Bitcoin itself made this choice.

Re:SEC granted emergency restraining order to freeze, repatr... by swift532 on Thursday June 08, 2023 @04:36PM (#36248577)
I know for a fact that normal people use crypto in Venezuela, albeit through apps and Binance. Their currency is crap and USD was outlawed for a while. I got the info first hand recently when a Venezuelan dev colleague visited my country.