News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Rarbg Is No More by mrtksn on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @07:37AM (#36137116)
RarBG was originally Bulgarian, like many other trackers and warez stuff. Eastern Europe - inside EU or outside of the EU - has always been major player in this scene. RIP.

I'm still curious how it's possible to run such global illegal operations without being exposed or caught.

How is it still possible to remain anonymous on the Internet, considering in this age the thing is very mature and well commercialised?

Re:Rarbg Is No More by _AzMoo on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @07:40AM (#36137144)
I think it's effectively just that they operate out of jurisdictions that just don't care.
Re:Rarbg Is No More by wkat4242 on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @07:46AM (#36137189)
This, totally.
Re:Rarbg Is No More by mrtksn on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @07:48AM (#36137203)
Well, Bulgaria used to be a jurisdiction that doesn't care but this is no longer early 2000s. Are there really jurisdictions that don't care and still have connections to the rest of the world? I guess DPRK, Iran, Cuba and maybe a few more can do that but wouldn't they be a problem to the infrastructure provider to work with in first place?
Re:Rarbg Is No More by wkat4242 on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @07:53AM (#36137241)
They still don't quite care though. For example in western Europe it's quite common to get threatening letters as soon as you start torrenting without VPN. In eastern europe this is not happening.

Perhaps because copyright infringement is not really a criminal issue but more of a civil law one. Without a private party starting lawsuits on behalf of the copyright owners there is nothing happening. It could be they don't have one.

Re:Rarbg Is No More by Joker_vD on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @08:13AM (#36137400)
> in western Europe it's quite common to get threatening letters as soon as you start torrenting without VPN

What about the right of the privacy of communication? Oh, right, it's the state-owned postal services that have to respect that right, and only with regards to the paper letters, not the privately operated ISPs that can (and obliged to) wiretap at the slightest suspicion of crime.

Re:Rarbg Is No More by mrtksn on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @08:22AM (#36137478)
AFAIK they don't actually inspect your comms, instead they leech from you to get your IP address and start the legal procedure. The way I understand it, they don't send you a letter for downloading but for sharing. Correct me if I'm wrong though.
Re:Rarbg Is No More by exitb on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @08:52AM (#36137763)
Depending on your jurisdiction, even just downloading might be illegal. But you're right, when you torrent, you publish your IP address, where parties unrelated to your ISP might get it and pursue legal action.
Re:Rarbg Is No More by boosteri on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @09:11AM (#36137966)
Is it they do illegal thing and then try to extort money from you for doing the same thing? Or have they received a royal blessing nowadays and can do so legally?
Re:Rarbg Is No More by Joker_vD on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @09:16AM (#36138013)
I imagine it's not illegal for them since they do have copyright, after all (unless when they don't).
Re:Rarbg Is No More by iLoveOncall on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @09:40AM (#36138285)
You're correct on the methodology except that (in France at least) they also seed, to get the IP of users that download. And you do get letters for downloading.

Initially the plan was to ban those people from internet for a period of that but it got removed since it was anticonstitutional.

Re:Rarbg Is No More by jorvi on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @08:51AM (#36137751)
It is not that clear cut for Western Europe.

- Germany sends letters and fines

- Czech Republic doesn’t send letters or fines

- The Netherlands doesn’t send letters or fines (unless you share an absolutely ludicrous amount)

- Belgium doesn’t send letters or fines

- UK sends letters and fines

- France sends letters (tiny chance of a fine)

- Switzerland doesn’t send letters or fines

Re:Rarbg Is No More by Goz3rr on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @09:36AM (#36138243)
It should be noted that (as far as I know) none of those are actually fines. It's private companies that track down pirates, and they cannot give out fines. They send you a settlement proposal, saying either pay this or risk being sued.
Re:Rarbg Is No More by graftak on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @09:43AM (#36138317)
Note that in the Netherlands right holders can request ISPs to proxy their letters but those ISPs are not allowed to share the home addresses or any other personal information so it’s neigh impossible for a right holder to get hold of a torrent user.
Re:Rarbg Is No More by zirgs on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @10:29AM (#36138822)
Makes sense. If ISPs were allowed to share home addresses then a lot of creeps and scammers could abuse that system.
Re:Rarbg Is No More by mmh0000 on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @12:41PM (#36140397)
Welcome to America!
Re:Rarbg Is No More by zirgs on Thursday June 01, 2023 @04:20AM (#36148691)
I'm pretty sure that sort of thing would be a gross GDPR violation in the EU.
Re:Rarbg Is No More by copperx on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @12:53PM (#36140533)
Imagine being doxxed by your own ISP.
Re:Rarbg Is No More by wkat4242 on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @01:02PM (#36140664)
Of course they have to obey court orders.

The Dutch ISPs fought this in court but they lost in some cases.

Re:Rarbg Is No More by zirgs on Thursday June 01, 2023 @04:17AM (#36148681)
There's a difference between getting a court order and someone saying - "I saw that X IP address shared a copyrighted file - can I get their name and address?"
Re:Rarbg Is No More by rerdavies on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @12:58PM (#36140621)
The situation is the same for Canadians: we get proxied letters, but rightsholders have no access to our personal identification.
Re:Rarbg Is No More by abwizz on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @09:52AM (#36138428)
almost like copyright enforcement goes hand in hand with your country's relation to the US
Re:Rarbg Is No More by jorvi on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @12:42PM (#36140409)
The Netherlands is very cozy with the US and yet enforcement is pretty lax, so I don’t think that’s the deciding factor.
Re:Rarbg Is No More by chikitabanana on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @10:03AM (#36138554)
in France you can be blacklisted from all ISPs
Re:Rarbg Is No More by tigeroil on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @10:53AM (#36139068)
Does the UK send letters and fines? I haven't torrented without a VPN for years but the worst I ever heard anyone getting was a letter from the ISP saying "that was very naughty, please don't do it again".
Re:Rarbg Is No More by Scotch3297 on Thursday June 01, 2023 @05:49AM (#36149140)
Spain doesn't send letters or fines
Re:Rarbg Is No More by scotty79 on Thursday June 01, 2023 @09:04PM (#36159546)
Do you know what's the situation in Portugal?
Re:Rarbg Is No More by rocqua on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @12:33PM (#36140314)
This isn't the ISPs detecting you torrent. It's rightholders joining a torrent swarm, getting an IP-address, and asking the ISP for the person behind that address. It differs between jurisdictions whether the ISP has to comply or not. In the Netherlands they do not, (but Surfnet, a university focused ISP complies anyway). In Germany they have to comply.

Lobbying is always happening to require ISPs to cooperate though.

Re:Rarbg Is No More by ChuckNorris89 on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @01:42PM (#36141196)
>In Germany they have to comply.

Seriously, screw Germany here. The way they oppressively Gestapo your internet traffic just to catch you downloading an mp3 to treat you like criminal menace, is unheard of in the rest of Europe.

Can't believe the so called "privacy conscious" German public are okay with this invasiveness of their internet privacy when they're the only EU country as hardcore on this "issue".

If only they would invest as much resources in digital innovation as they do in catching people download a DVD rip, Germany would rule the tech world.

Re:Rarbg Is No More by andrepd on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @02:13PM (#36141669)
Does it need that many resources though? I thought just getting the list of peers in a swarm for an illegal torrent is enough.
Re:Rarbg Is No More by ChuckNorris89 on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @03:39PM (#36143093)
Resources not as in tech but as in lack of red tape in invading people's privacy for such trivial issues. In any other country this would get you laughed out of court.
Re:Rarbg Is No More by cykros on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @03:23PM (#36142844)
Germany seems like they just do what involves the most policing. If it's going after companies for privacy invasions, they do it. If it's going after individuals for infringing on copyright, they do it.

They got rid of the laws that targeted people by race and background, but they never bothered to dispose of the jack boots.

Re:Rarbg Is No More by expertentipp on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @05:42PM (#36144729)
Meh that's why I stay away from German services. People who go apeshit on you for sharing one 64kb chunk of movie have lost their marbles. Service provider is GmbH, headquarters in Germany? Maybe someone from the other side of the world believes in their "privacy" lunatism.
Re:Rarbg Is No More by fomine3 on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @10:54PM (#36147099)
For US, it's natural that they are aggressive to arrest pirates because US have some biggest content holders in the world. I wonder is Germany content sold well?
Re:Rarbg Is No More by expertentipp on Thursday June 01, 2023 @01:20AM (#36147824)
No, German copyright predators are a proxy of American ones. Nobody cares about German content.
Re:Rarbg Is No More by WinstonSmith84 on Thursday June 01, 2023 @04:33AM (#36148758)
> If only they would invest as much resources in digital innovation as they do in catching people download a DVD rip, Germany would rule the tech world.

I don't think it's expensive, once you've the software: 1- regularly pull the torrent IDs from the latest releases on most popular torrenting website 2- download and stream the movies 3- wait for German IPs to connect 4- filter out IPs behind a VPN 5- identify the IP provider 6- send the request, probably by Email 7- profit

Not sure how advanced the software, but I don't see much manual input needed, it must be actually very lucrative

> Can't believe the so called "privacy conscious" German public are okay with this invasiveness

Nothing against Germans but there is a lot of hypocrisy in their society: - Energiewende vs. shutting down Nuclear Plants and turning on Coal - Green cars vs. 300km/h on the Autobahn - Go to a restaurant in a big German city, guys tell you they don't accept cards, then hand write the bill on a napkin (...) vs. Greece where restaurants are legally obliged to accept cards and if they don't, then you can just walk out without paying (!..) (all this since the EU driven by Germany bailed Greece out)

Re:Rarbg Is No More by mtlmtlmtlmtl on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @08:30AM (#36137552)
Huh, I've downloaded torrents for years with no VPN in western Europe and never got so much as an email about it.

Maybe it's changed in very recent times, I wouldn't know.

Re:Rarbg Is No More by FeistySkink on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @08:20AM (#36137453)
Never had any threatening letters in NL, so perhaps this varies by country.
Re:Rarbg Is No More by jeltz on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @08:49AM (#36137732)
Same in Sweden.
Re:Rarbg Is No More by jagaerglad on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @09:07AM (#36137926)
There have definitely been cases with letters in sweden

https://www.domstol.se/patent--och-marknadsdomstolen/om-pate...

Re:Rarbg Is No More by tapland on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @08:17PM (#36146223)
Depends on the ISP. Telia will hand out your details to copyright holders, Bahnhof will require them to file the request through the police. Most rights holders just sont bother with Bahnhof or the smaller ISPs and just send batches to Telia and ComHem.
Re:Rarbg Is No More by weinzierl on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @08:28AM (#36137531)
Threatening letters with a payment notice attached, that is.
Re:Rarbg Is No More by abwizz on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @09:50AM (#36138400)
imo copyright is irrelevant in countries that either can withstand the mpaa's pressure, maybe via good relations to the state department, or in countries that have bigger problems.
Re:Rarbg Is No More by CodeArtisan on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @09:56AM (#36138479)
Vietnam is probably the #1 place for digital piracy today.

https://torrentfreak.com/vietnam-could-kill-several-major-pi...

Re:Rarbg Is No More by pessimizer on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @10:53AM (#36139071)
Linked from the bottom of the post:

Potential Impact on Major Pirate Sites as Vietnam ISPs Face New Responsibilities, May 12, 2023.

> “Most Voluminous” Copyright Decree Ever Issued in Vietnam

> Global IP services firm Rouse reports that with 8 chapters and 116 articles, Decree 17 is the most voluminous copyright decree ever issued in Vietnam.

> “[T]he Copyright Decree provides significantly detailed guidance on copyright enforcement, especially which disputes can be classified as a copyright dispute, how to establish acts of copyright infringement, and how to calculate damages caused by infringements,” the company reports.

> “The long, detailed section in copyright assessment is also expected to pave the way for the growth of the currently limited copyright assessment services in Vietnam.”

https://torrentfreak.com/potential-impact-on-major-pirate-si...

Re:Rarbg Is No More by drexlspivey on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @04:00PM (#36143424)
Also their close neighbor, The Republic of Kinakuta
Re:Rarbg Is No More by costco on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @11:50AM (#36139743)
Current hosting appears to be in Bosnia: 185.37.100.122 which is probably a server colocated with https://www.netsaap.com/contacts.php.
Re:Rarbg Is No More by cykros on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @03:19PM (#36142762)
Does Iceland actually care much? I don't imagine they'd let you host an actual warez site a la 2000 or so, but a site just hosting magnet links seems like something they'd mostly allow, and they DEFINITELY have the infrastructure to handle it.

That all said, I'm always amazed that these sites don't just move to i2p/tor. The torrents themselves have been decentralized with DHT and magnet links for awhile. At the end of the day it seems like they've just been hanging on trying to avoid being so in the shadows that they get less traffic as a result.

Re:Rarbg Is No More by Gasp0de on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @07:51AM (#36137221)
What are they doing that is illegal? I thought they were just a torrent tracker?
Re:Rarbg Is No More by gersg on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @07:54AM (#36137250)
Linking to pirated content is illegal in many European countries.
Re:Rarbg Is No More by datadeft on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @08:05AM (#36137342)
But not in all EU countries.
Re:Rarbg Is No More by moffkalast on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @08:52AM (#36137760)
Then Google should be prosecuted.
Re:Rarbg Is No More by gersg on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @08:56AM (#36137802)
Google takes down content when they get notified, rarbg doesn't.
Re:Rarbg Is No More by moffkalast on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @09:04AM (#36137891)
I've yet to see Google not return a piratebay link at any point in history. Is it a loophole where they take it down, but their indexer then immediately puts it back in the next pass, lol?
Re:Rarbg Is No More by tivert on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @09:36AM (#36138252)
> I've yet to see Google not return a piratebay link at any point in history. Is it a loophole where they take it down, but their indexer then immediately puts it back in the next pass, lol?

No. If you pay attention there can be a message at the bottom of the search results telling you how many results were removed due to takedown requests. IIRC, they used to even link directly to the request, but now I think you have to jump through hoops to see it.

The "loophole" is that a takedown request has to be for a specific URL, so it requires a lot of constant effort to even try to get them all. Pirate bay always had dupes and a million mirrors.

Re:Rarbg Is No More by malux85 on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @12:56PM (#36140587)
I'm not being nit-picky or contentious - I'm asking from a genuine point of curiousity ...

but in the case of Google linking to the pirate bay, isn't the pirate bay the one linking to the pirated content? Google is 1 step removed in that node graph because they are just linking to the pirate bay.

I guess if they directly linked to a pirate bay page that had a magent link on it .... maybe (?)

Re:Rarbg Is No More by judge2020 on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @01:16PM (#36140874)
A court is unlikely to care about the distinction between actually linking to pirated content, and linking to a page with both instructions and a link to the pirated content. To add, enough TPB torrents contain screenshots.

Also, Google's takedown request handling in Google Search is not a matter of DMCA or a legal matter at all - instead, it's like Content ID, where they have their own separate system for evaluating takedown requests separate from any law. Rights-holders can still send Google legal requests, but it's easier to go through the expedited processes Google provides that also won't increase rights-holders' liability if they happen to submit a false takedown.

Re:Rarbg Is No More by whstl on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @02:03PM (#36141519)
Google seems to refuse removing because, according to them, "Whole-site removal is ineffective and can easily result in censorship of lawful material."

Instead of removing, they just remove links by request.

Sources: https://torrentfreak.com/google-opposes-whole-site-removal-o... and https://www.scribd.com/document/286275022/TorrentFreak-Googl...

-

However they did ban Pirate Bay in the Netherlands after a Dutch court ordered them.

https://www.makeuseof.com/why-google-removed-pirate-bay-from...

Re:Rarbg Is No More by paul_grisham on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @07:12PM (#36145714)
Isn't this the same loophole that MegaUpload used? Only removing a link to a file, not the file itself with the claim that other links belonged to potentially lawful owners of the file.
Re:Rarbg Is No More by whstl on Thursday June 01, 2023 @05:35AM (#36149050)
I mean, if the subpoena says "remove a link" you comply with that.

But there's also another fundamental difference: even if there's the expectation of removing all copies of the same exact file, it is "trivial" for MegaUpload to know, by using hashes. They do have access to all files, as it is in their servers.

For Google to delete all pirate links to movie X it would be much more complicated, and would put them on a position of being forced to be the internet police.

Re:Rarbg Is No More by chii on Thursday June 01, 2023 @06:19AM (#36149316)
> They do have access to all files, as it is in their servers.

not if they have the encrypted content only, and the decode key is only in the hash portion of a url, which never goes to a server.

But i guess crafting a technocal "solution" to a legal problem doesn't work, since the law works off intentions, and how much money you pay lawyers...

Re:Rarbg Is No More by whstl on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @05:47PM (#36317962)
That's Mega, the one that still exists. MegaUpload the previous one didn't really have the same encryption.
Re:Rarbg Is No More by abwizz on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @09:36AM (#36138249)
> I've yet to see Google not return a piratebay link at any point in history.

indeed. as it should, if it's relevant for the search.

Re:Rarbg Is No More by NoMoreNicksLeft on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @10:53AM (#36139069)
It's been 5 or 6 years ago now, but one night I searched for torrents for a particular movie, and Google returned hundreds of results from a dozen sites... and the next evening they returned 0. I think it was an October.

While I don't doubt that a torrent link shows up once in awhile, Google no longer usefully searches for such things. Or really anything, legal or not. It's more like a purchase recommendation system pretending to be a search engine.

Re:Rarbg Is No More by andrepd on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @02:08PM (#36141598)
And a terrible one at that, as it points to the lowest-quality blogspam sludge possible.
Re:Rarbg Is No More by cykros on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @02:44PM (#36142212)
Google used to rule the net. These days they're not even the best search engine for legal content, let alone overall net searching.

Bing and Yandex will get you most everything you want.

Re:Rarbg Is No More by roncesvalles on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @05:01PM (#36144280)
It seems Google's tech can't keep up with the scale of the Internet anymore. It simply doesn't index a very large portion of the Internet now.
Re:Rarbg Is No More by madeofpalk on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @11:23AM (#36139413)
Google does not return links to the pirate bay for me https://i.imgur.com/MkAPoFl.png.

At the bottom there is a message that says "In response to a legal request submitted to Google, we have removed 4 result(s) from this page. If you wish, you may read more about the request at LumenDatabase.org" and links to https://lumendatabase.org/notices/27615507

Re:Rarbg Is No More by DirectorKrennic on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @12:51PM (#36140522)
Odd. Google always returns links to the pirate bay for me https://i.imgur.com/tNo6tbB.png

I'm in Canada though. But I did use Google.com.

Re:Rarbg Is No More by mh- on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @01:10PM (#36140781)
that's a different search query. I did get that same result if I use your query instead. (I'm in the US)

edit: it's also for a "proxy" site. I don't really use torrents or follow TPB happenings and don't know how that is/isn't affiliated.

Re:Rarbg Is No More by jachee on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @01:10PM (#36140783)
Linking to the site itself (especially when that’s what you searched for) isn’t the same as linking to a torrent to infringing content would be.
Re:Rarbg Is No More by Reason077 on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @01:42PM (#36141197)
Canada has relatively lenient copyright laws/enforcement. It's likely that Google sees no legal need to honor DMCA-style takedown notices in Canada.

Here's a guide to the legal status of torrents here with broad categories, from most lenient to most strict (caution VPN spam): https://www.vpnmentor.com/blog/torrents-illegal-update-count...

Interesting to note that downloading copyrighted content for personal use is explicitly legal (not just overlooked) in Spain, Switzerland, and Poland.

Re:Rarbg Is No More by GoblinSlayer on Thursday June 01, 2023 @03:22AM (#36148400)
The picture shows that downloading is illegal only in six countries.
Re:Rarbg Is No More by tyingq on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @05:41PM (#36144716)
Re:Rarbg Is No More by kelnos on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @05:00PM (#36144262)
Google will only remove specific URLs, not entire sites/domains. Even if every copyright holder with content on TPB sent a DMCA notice to Google today, new torrents -- at new URLs -- would pop up tomorrow.
Re:Rarbg Is No More by worldsayshi on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @05:53PM (#36144870)
Hmm i guess torrent sites can also counter by just not having static URLs for content?
Re:Rarbg Is No More by eru on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @10:04PM (#36146817)
Or by having lots and lots of duplicate static URLs (but only revealing them one by one).
Re:Rarbg Is No More by internetter on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @08:31PM (#36146309)
Can't speak for rarbg, but plenty of piracy adjacent sites have a DMCA takedown program[0] to operate under this loophole. That way, most content survives but they are "protected"

[0]: https://annas-archive.org/copyright

Re:Rarbg Is No More by ipaddr on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @11:24PM (#36147260)
Changing the url daily works as the dmca complaint refers to a specific page.
Re:Rarbg Is No More by happymellon on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @08:55AM (#36137795)
That's not Google's primary purpose.
Re:Rarbg Is No More by B1FF_PSUVM on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @01:09PM (#36140763)
Well, printing was going to be for instruction. And then radio. And TV. And the internet.

We're so instructed we've gotta wear ad-blockers.

Re:Rarbg Is No More by zx8080 on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @08:33PM (#36146319)
Instruction.. on what to buy, how to live and what to want.
Re:Rarbg Is No More by justinclift on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @01:03PM (#36140677)
Google has enough lawyers to give the EU and US the run around when they want to.

For smaller players, they'd have to think really carefully about whether they want to engage in multi-year litigation with them.

Re:Rarbg Is No More by WastingMyTime89 on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @01:31PM (#36141098)
> Google has enough lawyers to give the EU and US the run around when they want to.

Google has paid something like 10 billions dollars of fines in the EU during the last decade. I don’t think they are giving the run around to anyone.

Re:Rarbg Is No More by theturtletalks on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @02:19PM (#36141773)
Are you sure they paid it or they were ordered to do so? Most times, the fine is reduced or appealed ad infinitum.
Re:Rarbg Is No More by justinclift on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @02:25PM (#36141882)
Yeah, lets wait a couple of decades and see how those court cases actually end up.

Meanwhile, Google will just keep on Googling...

Re:Rarbg Is No More by einpoklum on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @02:35PM (#36142061)
Alphabet is valued at over 1.5 Trillion dollars. If they pay 1 Billion USD in fines per year, maybe their lawyers are actually doing an ok job for their client.
Re:Rarbg Is No More by red-iron-pine on Thursday June 01, 2023 @08:57AM (#36150460)
just the cost of doing business at that point
Re:Rarbg Is No More by cykros on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @02:45PM (#36142243)
10 billion dollars is a rounding error for the GOOG.
Re:Rarbg Is No More by Thaxll on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @01:37PM (#36141134)
Google does not host it links, it's very different.

Google does not store files it should not.

Re:Rarbg Is No More by cykros on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @02:46PM (#36142260)
Well, they do, at Youtube. But they're pretty good about takedowns over there. Including of a ton of content that has no reason to be taken down.
Re:Rarbg Is No More by hnaccount141 on Thursday June 01, 2023 @08:32AM (#36150221)
Torrent trackers don’t host the content either.
Re:Rarbg Is No More by yieldcrv on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @08:52AM (#36137772)
and just a civil issue, which doesn’t come with priority or the state power that a criminal case would
Re:Rarbg Is No More by ornornor on Thursday June 01, 2023 @12:07AM (#36147474)
That’s why magnet links were invented for torrents. They don’t link to any content, just give your client a unique ID to find peers for.

Like saying a site mentioning that you should look for “cannabis” if you want to get high is illegal. Selling the substance is illegal, telling you how it’s called isn’t.

Re:Rarbg Is No More by creativenolo on Thursday June 01, 2023 @04:46AM (#36148796)
I didn’t know this but would like to know more. Can you expand on how they try to circumvent linking and do they circumvent it?

It is surprising to hear because as a user they _seem_ like a link. Copy the link into something and get the (illegal) files.

Re:Rarbg Is No More by defrost on Thursday June 01, 2023 @05:03AM (#36148874)
Magnet linking is rather like standing on a street corner and regularly yelling "have you got any cannabis"?

Here's a random RARBG magnet link that may or may not work

magnet:?xt=urn:btih:468043aa374080fed5ff65e4cd8d4fed002986b5&dn=Rizzoli.And.Isles.S05.1080p.WEBRip.x265-RARBG

It doesn't link to a file or embed any tracker names but it does name a 1080p HEVC (x265) encoded season pack of season 5 of a US police procedural drama (which is excess and unrequired but humans do like readable names)

What it does provide is a unique hash code that matches the exact torrent ... should you find it.

When you add that magnet link to your torrent client it triggers the act of polling any public trackers your client knows about and any peers that have "hit me up about magnets" enabled.

Ideally word spreads and eventually some other client | tracker hits you back with word of other peers that at least have some cannabis .. (err, bits of Rizzoli&Isles Season 5 HEVC pack).

Re:Rarbg Is No More by creativenolo on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @09:35AM (#36212492)
Great description - thanks.

I wonder if they ‘stand up in court’ and/or have ever been tested too.

Re:Rarbg Is No More by sushibowl on Thursday June 01, 2023 @06:03AM (#36149213)
A magnet URI is a little bit like a web link in the sense that it refers to a particular piece of data, but it doesn't point to any particular host or location. It is merely a hash of the files it describes. So in other words, the link doesn't tell you where the particular content can be found, it only tells you what the content is that it refers to.

To actually find the content in question you take the link, go on a peer to peer network, and basically ask machines if they have the content in question available or know where it is. There's various ways to do that, in some cases your torrent app might know the location of some centralized "tracker" servers, and ask those servers whether they know locations for those files. Some torrents are "trackerless" and use a DHT, a type of distributed database that keeps information about where to find files.

Re:Rarbg Is No More by mrtksn on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @07:54AM (#36137252)
Okay I know this conversation and I don't feel like repeating the argumentation just now.

Anyway, when we will have torrent trackers by Google or Meta? Sounds like a good to enter this legit market. Must be great opportunity for all the laid-off coders out there too, if this is not large enough market for Google and alike.

Re:Rarbg Is No More by supriyo-biswas on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @08:11AM (#36137382)
Amazon has provided the ability to obtain torrents of objects on S3[1].

[1] https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonS3/latest/API/API_GetObjec...

Re:Rarbg Is No More by mrtksn on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @08:19AM (#36137445)
Cool, someone re-start the RARBG on Amazon then. What's the fuss all about?
Re:Rarbg Is No More by weinzierl on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @08:26AM (#36137513)
It's deprecated and I believe it only used to work in very old AWS regions for legacy reasons. Not sure what the current status is but it clearly has no future.
Re:Rarbg Is No More by mrtksn on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @08:31AM (#36137564)
Even cooler, someone start a hosting for legitimate businesses like RARBG.
Re:Rarbg Is No More by codetrotter on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @08:37AM (#36137624)
> hosting for legitimate businesses like RARBG.

Not quite the same but PeerTube is P2P legitimate hosting.

I run a PeerTube instance myself and I like it a lot.

Re:Rarbg Is No More by ulfw on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @08:52AM (#36137765)
What is it with you and your extremely aggressive and yet unproductive comments?
Re:Rarbg Is No More by mrtksn on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @09:06AM (#36137908)
>What is it with you and your extremely aggressive and yet unproductive comments?

Entertaining hypothetical edge cases to examine an argument's soundness has become extremely aggressive behaviour?

Anyway, my apologies.

Re:Rarbg Is No More by abwizz on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @09:41AM (#36138301)
beeig edgy and exploring edge cases for the sake of the argument has indeed become somewhat anti-social. i guess it has something to do with the width of the audience, as the bigger the crowd, the more likely it is that someone will take you serious and make a fuss about it.
Re:Rarbg Is No More by mrtksn on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @10:02AM (#36138547)
Who are those people who are offended when you introduce an edge case against their argument? This is very weird behaviour because the whole civilisation is built on finding edge cases to demonstrate that a model doesn't work.

For example, would it be offensive to say that a feather and a hammer will fall at the same speed on the moon to take down the Aristotle's theory of gravity? Is it OK to not talk about that kind of stuff in order not to offend Aristotletes?

Re:Rarbg Is No More by pessimizer on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @10:41AM (#36138951)
Reporter: So, to end the interview I have to ask you about an experiment that everyone's talking about and you must be aware of. It's been said that marbles and cannonballs dropped from a tower at the same time have been seen to land at the same time. If there are any comments you'd like to make about that, I'm sure the public would love to hear them.

Aristotle Scholar: You know, I'm actually glad you asked this, because these kind of "gotcha" questions show everyone the unfortunate state of journalism today, its disrespect for scholarship, and its willingness to peddle whatever trash that people are circulating in order to undermine our institutions. [wrestles wooden microphone off lapel and storms off set.]

Re:Rarbg Is No More by abwizz on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @10:10AM (#36138626)
it is very wired if you (plural) are looking for truth or consensus or progress.

but normies are generally freaked out, because they are not used to real talk. i often crash into this barrier of non-sense talk for the sake of conversation as well, very painful for both sides.

i'm sure aristotle wouldn't be offended but encouraged :)

Re:Rarbg Is No More by hippich on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @12:53PM (#36140537)
> you (plural)

Texans would say "y'all" :)

Re:Rarbg Is No More by masfuerte on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @02:11PM (#36141643)
See also "youse".
Re:Rarbg Is No More by cykros on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @03:09PM (#36142606)
You is always plural. The singular second person pronouns are thou (subject), thee (object), or thy (possessive).
Re:Rarbg Is No More by andrepd on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @02:11PM (#36141645)
Yes, you are a special flower and people are annoyed at you not because you're grating, rude, or arrogant, but because they are stupid and only want to talk about the Kardashians or whatever.

Yawn.

Re:Rarbg Is No More by abwizz on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @03:21PM (#36142807)
you seem like a special flower too :)

realizing that most of anything isn't special does not preclude every thing beeing uniqe and valuable

Re:Rarbg Is No More by justin_oaks on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @01:52PM (#36141361)
The problem is people don't know if you're asking questions to indicate your disapproval (or to cause people grief) or if you're asking to understand. In other words good faith questions vs bad faith questions.

People get offended when you're asking bad faith questions. And it can be difficult to differentiate the two, especially when people discussing don't know each other.

I know someone who is often snippy with me because I ask questions where I legitimately want to understand something, but she assumes I'm asking to indicate she's done something wrong.

Re:Rarbg Is No More by abwizz on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @03:25PM (#36142880)
this is indeed a very helpful way of putting it, thank you
Re:Rarbg Is No More by weinzierl on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @10:55AM (#36139099)
You mean like https://1984.hosting? Or more like https://legittorrents.info, which shut down recently[1]?

I had never heard of RARBG before, so I don't know if they were legitimate and you are being sarcastic or serious?

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35639370

Re:Rarbg Is No More by mrtksn on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @11:09AM (#36139245)
They were the website I torrented the entire Succession series.
Re:Rarbg Is No More by mrelectric on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @02:45PM (#36142255)
Mate, you're being obnoxious.
Re:Rarbg Is No More by mrtksn on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @04:23PM (#36143793)
I have no idea why explaining how I use the website to the question on what the website is about would be obnoxious but O.K.
Re:Rarbg Is No More by abwizz on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @09:43AM (#36138324)
imo they were a fairly popular and long-standing tracker. someone had to make a statement perhaps? (pb was downed multiple times)
Re:Rarbg Is No More by PrimeMcFly on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @07:51AM (#36137230)
You can still buy pre-paid credit cards in many places, and many places allow you to pay for anonymous servers with cards.

Worst case if they had enough money they could rent somewhere and pay for a decent internet connection and not actually live there, so only the equipment would be seized.

Re:Rarbg Is No More by costco on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @11:58AM (#36139860)
I think the "new meta" is sketchy popup/popunder ad providers that pay BTC/USDT, njal.la/nic.ru/some Chinese registrar paid with crypto or a virtual card, DDOS-guard/Cloudflare to make getting the origin IP annoying, and hosting in an ex-USSR country (and sometimes even mainstream Western providers like Leaseweb or OVH). But that's just the impression I got by occasionally using these sites, looking at domain/IP whois and using one of those Cloudflare deanonymizer sites when it was still up.
Re:Rarbg Is No More by adql on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @08:49AM (#36137734)
The problem appears to just be "it's too expensive to run" at least according to the banner
Re:Rarbg Is No More by maccard on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @09:10AM (#36137959)
How expensive can a link sharing site be to run, genuinely? They're not serving any of the content (unless they are, in which case, yeah...) But if they're just serving up .torrent files or magnet links, these sites should be pretty cheap to run I would assume?
Re:Rarbg Is No More by dunmalg on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @09:34AM (#36138223)
Comparatively cheap because you're just handing off magnet links, but when you're serving millions of unique visitors daily, it all adds up.
Re:Rarbg Is No More by abwizz on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @09:44AM (#36138335)
true. but there were also some images on the site
Re:Rarbg Is No More by mpsprd on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @12:46PM (#36140450)
I believe rarbg had many "official" torrents that they seeded. This must be part of their costs.
Re:Rarbg Is No More by tracker1 on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @01:12PM (#36140816)
It tends to run a little more when you're using hosting in a country that doesn't respect US copyright (and similarly for most EU) along with keeping your information private to begin with. When I had looked into it, it's been roughly 2x what a typical western dedicated server provider might charge.

This doesn't count the issues with a site that is very popular, from bandwidth to even simple database search overhead. If I were to guess, it's that RarBG probably spent in excess of $10k/month, which isn't much if you're a startup with a runway of VC capital or a revenue stream, it's a lot more if you're in a smaller country or don't have an excess of revenue.

Re:Rarbg Is No More by waboremo on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @09:08AM (#36137937)
It's very possible to run such without being exposed, but it involves patience and enough cash.

Most of the time, these services aren't done in direct exchange for money or from people who have a lot of money in the first place.

So what ends up happening is even if they can avoid the shallow legal issues by remaining private, they then run into the problem that nobody can pay for the service (not many options for providing that transaction privately). You might think "just run ads" but the problem there is multifaceted, most are likely going to be using adblockers, on top of that to remain private they'll be locked out of most paying ads and only get the most spammy garbage incentivizing more to use adblocker to visit the site.

Re:Rarbg Is No More by joshspankit on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @01:51PM (#36141341)
Also: ad companies and payment processors are a weak link. They can provide de-anonymizing information to officials and cut off payments when their corporate values shift.
Re:Rarbg Is No More by theturtletalks on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @02:15PM (#36141702)
I always wondered this. Many piracy sites have Adsense or some sort of ads. Can't Google just fingerprint which Adsense account is being used and find the person getting paid?
Re:Rarbg Is No More by hattmall on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @02:25PM (#36141886)
There's an entire industry of buying established accounts set up with an unsuspecting person's identity. Idk about Adsense specifically, but you can get Amazon selling and the linked bank account with docs for like $1000.
Re:Rarbg Is No More by elorant on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @04:14PM (#36143647)
And how do you get paid? AdSense requires a bank account registered to the same name.
Re:Rarbg Is No More by CryptoBanker on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @06:17PM (#36145147)
You buy the accompanying bank account
Re:Rarbg Is No More by madars on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @03:01PM (#36142521)
Yes. For example, Z-Library accepted Amazon gift card donations using an email linked to their identities: https://torrentfreak.com/how-google-and-amazon-helped-the-fb...
Re:Rarbg Is No More by alwayslikethis on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @06:55PM (#36145552)
This screams poor opsec to me. Accepting anything other than anonymized crypto (Monero, etc) is basically untenable in this era of mass surveillance. Going through a big tech company is a good way to get caught.
Re:Rarbg Is No More by red-iron-pine on Thursday June 01, 2023 @08:56AM (#36150448)
if you're the host. the end user can use gift cards just fine, and they're usually pretty fungible.

am 100% okay moving the risk to the operation/operator

Re:Rarbg Is No More by heresie-dabord on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @09:12PM (#36146540)
> ad companies and payment processors [...] cut off payments when their corporate values shift.

"Sir, is it time for us to claim to have corporate values?"

"Not yet, m'boy, we are still swimming in our private ocean of profits!"

Re:Rarbg Is No More by anjel on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @05:42PM (#36144725)
AFOAF belongs to the same pvt tracker now for more than a dozen years. The admins amp and push the community feels and have periodic fund raisers. No ads, and if you want to donate, you buy a jpg of a flower on an different site. Seems to work out well for all concerned and while you have to maintain an u/d ratio, free leach and easy generous ratio reqts contribute to that community feeling.
Re:Rarbg Is No More by phkahler on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @01:19PM (#36140921)
>> How is it still possible to remain anonymous on the Internet, considering in this age the thing is very mature and well commercialised?

Because at the core, identity on the internet is not well defined. Authentication is a hard problem. You might wonder why it's hard, why better more secure protocols haven't emerged. Answer: that makes end to end encryption easy, among other things that give individuals too much power.

Re:Rarbg Is No More by vasco on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @01:30PM (#36141088)
If your answer to a question is a conspiracy of some unknown fuzzy elites against the "plebes", your argument has no credibility to me.

One way to see it's a poor argument is that you can use that explanation for every single problem of the world. If I can use the same explanation to explain why hunger still exists, why diseases haven't been erradicated, why there's still poor people, or any of the big problems of the world... it likely isn't the right explanation.

It's just a crutch for explaining things away easily without thinking. You create some "element" of people that control everything, and blame that "element" so you don't actually have to understand the problem or the cause and effect. Might as well say "because God doesn't want it" if you're going to say something like "because these undefined forces don't want to give individuals too much power".

Of course there's people that want to put down the little guy, maybe even in a cartoonish caricature way that on the internet people portray it. But how would some unknown evil elites prevent a technical paper about "solving encryption" from being published online if someone actually had some answer? I know researchers, nobody is telling them what to look into. The bitcoin paper got published. Plenty of drivel gets published. There's no one entity that could even dream to block "fixing a hard problem" if a solution for it existed in a field like software, where implementing it is pretty much free.

Re:Rarbg Is No More by samstave on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @02:08PM (#36141605)
AI produced Obits, and death certs and detailed descriptions of the death, and then new documents produced via GPT6+ access to APIs to DMV, Embassies, etc to produce new documents sent to your new PO box in [place] etc...

-

deep-fake assassinations are going to be a thing...

PHKahler

Re:Rarbg Is No More by themagician on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @02:28PM (#36141944)
The answer to this is easier (and harder) than you might think: just don't say anything.

You can get away with quite a bit just by being silent, and for longer than you'd think. A big way that people get away with things for so long is just by not answering questions. Someone says, "Is this yours" and you say nothing. Now you've got to burn hours and dollars trying to prove someone owns something so that you can go after them.

You'll find domains, web hosts, countries, and employees who are all onboard with the same philosophy. When everything requires a subpoena at the highest level to move something forward, it can easily take years for anything to happen at all. And the site can change hands and then you have to start all over again.

You've got a domain in Tonga registered to a company in another country, owned by a large company in another country owned by a trust in a third country. Often small countries with limited resources and archaic or corrupt bureaucracies. And where is it hosted? That's probably another connect the dots.

And any of these entities may lead to nothing more than a mule, fake person, or dead person. Sure, it's someone's fault for having inaccurate records—but who? How long has this been going on? Did they know? Was it intentional? It shouldn't be like this, but it is… what do you do now?

You can do illegal shit for years or even decades if you just say nothing and respond to no one.

Re:Rarbg Is No More by expertentipp on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @03:52PM (#36143293)
> Someone says, "Is this yours" and you say nothing. Now you've got to burn hours and dollars trying to prove someone owns something so that you can go after them.

The opposite is the German approach. Shower the cuntiest lawyers with money, lobby for laws allowing to easily pick a victim, bully the victim senseless. Lobby even more and if someone uses the word "corruption" in context of copyrights, bully the shit out of them as well. I'm so glad Anglosphere and German copyrights predators have been perfectly impotent for so many years. They know how to create faceless enemies.

Re:Rarbg Is No More by wukerplank on Thursday June 01, 2023 @12:46AM (#36147664)
Germany really takes the price when it comes to (torrent-based) piracy. The lawyers around it created a nice little ecosystem for themselves. Honeypot torrents and all. They have such a nice system that they don't go for the torrent sites, just milk the torrenters.
Re:Rarbg Is No More by Fnoord on Thursday June 01, 2023 @09:21AM (#36150684)
It also creates a weird liability where hotel owners have to snoop on their users in order to deflect responsibility. It also stimulates self-censorship. VPNs are likely very popular in Germany.
Re:Rarbg Is No More by Mountain_Skies on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @04:35PM (#36143977)
Law firms must love how many billable hours such quests generate for them.
Re:Rarbg Is No More by terminalcommand on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @05:12PM (#36144405)
In my experience law firms would not hop through these. That is the job of hired ethical hackers, police and prosecutor's office.

A law firm would be useful in (a) applying to remove illegal content, (b) seize any profit generated by illegal use of clents' content, (c) (if the client requests) horrify users identified of such illegal services, (d) pressure the authorities to crack down on the operation.

Most lawyers do not understand the technical details. We do a hell of a good job of understanding experts' findings and put them in a clear legal structure though.

Most of the boring but billable job I ever made was searching through company registries, google searches, sanctions searches, panama papers searches, reviewing countless pdfs to either (i) mark them as privileged so they cannot be used as evidence, (ii) scan whether there are any documents that may directly implicate the client and if so try to find a way to legally claim it is unusable.

I believe law firms do provide decent service. Billables are there, but no lawyer I know would willingly generate busywork that does not lead anywhere to charge more. OTOH, I HAVE seen instances where a work got reviewed multiple times by different lawyers, because the client was willing to pay more. But even in these edge cases, multiple reviews did benefit the client and they received a better work product.

My advice would be establish a good working relationship with a lawyer in the firm that you trust, continuously send work. Ask estimates if you are on a tight budget. But do not be cheap and try to get things done with less budget. Law firms provide a service you need, if you pay them decently you'll receive your money's worth. Lawyers will literally take a bullet for you to make things happen when you need them.

Apologies for the long rant :).

Re:Rarbg Is No More by IgorPartola on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @10:06PM (#36146823)
> My advice would be establish a good working relationship with a lawyer in the firm that you trust, continuously send work. Ask estimates if you are on a tight budget. But do not be cheap and try to get things done with less budget. Law firms provide a service you need, if you pay them decently you'll receive your money's worth. Lawyers will literally take a bullet for you to make things happen when you need them.

What’s the order of magnitude here? There have been times in my life where I would have found having a lawyer on standby to be incredibly helpful (e.g. car purchase gone bad, property usage rights dispute, etc.), but at the same time spending $100k a year to have a lawyer on standby to resolve an issue of $5-10k in magnitude is foolish.

Re:Rarbg Is No More by themagician on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @11:25PM (#36147263)
$2-5k for a retainer. Less in many places.
Re:Rarbg Is No More by ornornor on Thursday June 01, 2023 @12:02AM (#36147446)
You could try legal insurance. Costs about 200$ equivalent/year where I live, then I have a place to ask legal questions and escalate as needed. I think they cover the first 150k$ worth of legal costs with any lawyer I pick if it goes that far and their in-house lawyers can’t get the other party to back down.
Re:Rarbg Is No More by terminalcommand on Thursday June 01, 2023 @10:03AM (#36151149)
Most of the times you do not pay for stand by. If there is work to do your lawyer charges you in billable hours. That is the point of the billable hours system. For larger projects you can get a fee estimate, fixed quote or agree on a hybrid solution.

I am also talking about corporate law work. Maintaining corporate records, lease agreements, employment agremeents, director changes et.

Re:Rarbg Is No More by unavoidable on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @07:38PM (#36145944)
Am a lawyer. This is correct. Drafting subpoenas, motions, applications, convincing a skeptical judge that Twitter posts are "real" evidence, or explaining how DNS records work, not to mention actually scheduling a damn hearing, then multiply that by 4 or 5 jurisdictions (therefore 4 or 5 sets of lawyers), and you got yourself easily a few years' worth of work.
Re:Rarbg Is No More by jesterson on Thursday June 01, 2023 @03:25AM (#36148423)
Let's say I was observing something similar and this is absolutely correct. Stay low profile, say nothing, don't boast to scratch your itching ego and everything will be fine.

A lot of people will be surprised by knowing what kind of businesses is ran from that shabby house in the corner by visibly low life mate driving 30yo celica.

Re:Rarbg Is No More by RektBoy on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @03:51PM (#36143284)
For example in my EU country, it's legal to download movies for own use. shrug
Re:Rarbg Is No More by bubblethink on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @07:56PM (#36146092)
>I'm still curious how it's possible to run such global illegal operations

Because it is not obviously illegal. A tracker just points to the content, not the content itself. That may seem meaningless, but then so are the arbitrary demands of copyright holders. They want to have their cake and eat it too. So the system works as intended.