News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by ridgered4 on Monday April 10, 2023 @02:44PM (#35515818)
Anyone ever think about what a nightmare driverless cars will be if they actually work? Right now our crumbling infrastructure is loaded with traffic. Imagine if the max amount of driving a human can endure is removed entirely as a final constraint on the total utilization rate of this infrastructure and is replaced with a relentless driving machine that never tires or gets frustrated and has no fear of death.

People would commute up to 4 hours one way, napping in their cars, maybe even longer. Delivery vehicles running all hours of the night, perhaps with no one ever in them at all. People sending the cars to go pick things up or people that they otherwise wouldn't have time in their day to do.

Even if you don't want to live in your car that the pressure will still be exerted on you because you'll be competing with people that do. Cars instructed to circle the block in areas with no parking clogging the streets. You'll need a self driving car yourself to even get a spot since you'll never defeat all the robot vultures.

People will forget how to drive entirely of course so there will be no going back. The whole thing will feed on itself, people will need more self driving cars to get back the time stolen by other self driving cars.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by lallysingh on Monday April 10, 2023 @03:03PM (#35516047)
I guess it's the season of AI fear. Humans don't rarely drive to their endurance levels now, so why would removal of a rarely-used limit affect much?

8 hours (4+4) spent in commuting, driving or not, is an entire life. This isn't a realistic concern, but something pulled out of a cyberpunk novel.

Cars can park away from you and come back to pick you up. This should alleviate parking problems, and reduce parking-space-search based congestion on the street.

Learning to drive was never that hard.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by yesco on Monday April 10, 2023 @03:21PM (#35516249)
> 8 hours (4+4) spent in commuting, driving or not, is an entire life

There are already people who live in their vans anyway, if they didn't even need to drive them anymore perhaps areas with overzealous zoning laws that circumvent supply & demand would see an influx of small moving apartments instead.

It would be like a land yacht, and economically sound so long as the price of gas is lower than the price of rent.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by theossuary on Monday April 10, 2023 @03:34PM (#35516403)
This is my plan. As soon as self driving tech is available I'm putting it in a school busy mini-house. Punch in any destination and then live my life while I head there. It'll basically be teleportation in my lifetime.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by elif on Monday April 10, 2023 @06:27PM (#35518140)
What you describe is basically how my wife and I treat the model Y on road trips, except we speak the destination instead of punch it in.

But you'll still want to wear a seatbelt because although self driving cars don't tend to cause accidents, they very much are the victim of them.

And consider the electricity demand of keeping your big skooli heated and cooled compared to that of a small and tight modern vehicle, you'll likely be forced into charging last thing every night and first thing every morning while on the road, while for us it is about 25% of battery on the worst nights so we can camp anywhere.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by donmcronald on Monday April 10, 2023 @03:11PM (#35516125)
> 8 hours (4+4) spent in commuting, driving or not, is an entire life. This isn't a realistic concern, but something pulled out of a cyberpunk novel.

What if that time is spent sleeping? Maybe you don't even need a house, so you'll have more money to spend on a nice car.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by lallysingh on Monday April 10, 2023 @03:19PM (#35516225)
That just digs deeper into cyberpunk distopia.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by trgn on Monday April 10, 2023 @04:55PM (#35517280)
lol

It's really uncanny, every time, there it is, man must submit to the technology rather than have technology submit to us. Because a self-driving car is advanced technology, therefore men must move with self-driving cars. Even if that literally includes having to live out of your car.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by TeMPOraL on Monday April 10, 2023 @06:30PM (#35518172)
Indeed this is how it works. Or, more accurately, man has to use the new technology to keep up with other men, as those who don't get outraced by those to do. The end result is a ratchet of progress.

It's ironic how people in software don't notice it, despite the fact that our industry caused several such shifts, and we're all living with (and whining about) the consequences. Myself I didn't notice it for close to two decades since first learning to code. The realization came to me with age - I'm at the point where I have more disposable income than free time, so all the "wonderful" self-service software enabled now grates and irritates me to no end.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by trgn on Monday April 10, 2023 @07:40PM (#35518794)
> The realization came to me with age

same

> self-service software enabled now grates and irritates me to no end.

haha yeah, devil's bargain

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by lallysingh on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @08:15AM (#35524055)
Technology is a tool, often to make one group submit to another.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by sporkl on Monday April 10, 2023 @04:47PM (#35517203)
If you don't have a house, and sleeping when you're in the car, then why would you bother commuting at all?
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by nix0n on Monday April 10, 2023 @04:55PM (#35517284)
In many places within the USA it is illegal to sleep in a car.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by TeMPOraL on Monday April 10, 2023 @06:24PM (#35518114)
Maybe you're the next generation of digital nomads - working from a nice location for a day, then sleeping in your car while it shuttles you to a new nice location for tomorrow.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by mrcode007 on Monday April 10, 2023 @03:46PM (#35516548)
This debate reminds me of one of the funniest hacks ever: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drzymała%27s_wagon
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by roughly on Monday April 10, 2023 @04:12PM (#35516851)
> This isn't a realistic concern, but something pulled out of a cyberpunk novel.

Can I direct your attention to all of the labor market everything since Reagan?

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by anigbrowl on Monday April 10, 2023 @04:25PM (#35516979)
I've met several people who in pre-pandemic times were commuting from beyond Sacramento to San Francisco, which is about a 4-5 hour daily commute. You'd be surprised how far some people will go to have both a good paying job and the house of their dreams.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by manquer on Monday April 10, 2023 @04:40PM (#35517133)
* * *
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by thuuuomas on Monday April 10, 2023 @07:14PM (#35518563)
Those dang irrational personal choices!

All models are wrong, but some keep your hopes closer

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by manquer on Monday April 10, 2023 @10:48PM (#35520139)
Almost anywhere in the world a one way 110+ miles commute one way is a personal choice that maybe makes sense to that person.

It is certainly not because of economics of rent or house ownership or any other reasonable criteria so not sure what point such personal outliers prove in this discussion

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by Arrath on Monday April 10, 2023 @05:06PM (#35517412)
What the hell is the point? With that kind of commute assuming they work a full day they'll be home for a scant few hours a night sleeping (we hope, for the sake of other commuters) and the weekends for which they'll probably be dead tired.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by pc86 on Monday April 10, 2023 @05:29PM (#35517625)
Nobody actually does this commute 5 days a week, 45-50 weeks a year. It's either someone who does it sporadically but regularly (e.g. every other Monday or something for a few years) or briefly while finding something less insane (for a few weeks, maybe a month or two).

I had a job with an effective ~4-hour round trip commute, from one major city to another in both my car and a train, but only had to do it once a month.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by RandallBrown on Monday April 10, 2023 @05:39PM (#35517713)
I used to have a similar commute into NYC. I lived about a 10 minute walk from the train station and my office was another 10 minute walk from Grand Central Station. Round trip was about 4 hours. I did the commute about 3 days per week but saw tons of people on the train that did it every day. I saw a guy talking to the conductor saying it was his last time commuting after THIRTY YEARS. I imagine most of those people were driving to the train station and then taking another subway once they made it into the city, adding a considerable amount of time to the already brutal commute.

I only lasted a year before I went fully remote.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by Spooky23 on Monday April 10, 2023 @06:04PM (#35517945)
I take the 510 AM train from Albany to NYC about once a month. There’s a dozen folks who are on that train enough that I recognize them or chat with them. There’s a few who board at Hudson too.

It’s a mix of lawyers, construction guys and others like FDNY guys.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by ghaff on Monday April 10, 2023 @06:17PM (#35518068)
If I go into the city for a customer visit (not frequent/not rare), I'm 2 hours going in whether mostly train or mostly car. And about the same going home by train and maybe more like an hour+ by car.

I did have a job that was about 90 minutes door-to-door each way (train schedules were a bit better then) but even then "only" had to do it about 50% of the time. Wouldn't have been long-term sustainable.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by brightlancer on Monday April 10, 2023 @10:01PM (#35519793)
The OP was referring to a 5 days a week, 50 weeks a year dystopia:

"Even if you don't want to live in your car that the pressure will still be exerted on you because you'll be competing with people that do."

Which is why so many folks are mocking the idea.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by earthling8118 on Monday April 10, 2023 @06:48PM (#35518331)
Now if only there were time to enjoy those things
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by brenns10 on Monday April 10, 2023 @04:38PM (#35517113)
> Cars can park away from you and come back to pick you up. This should alleviate parking problems, and reduce parking-space-search based congestion on the street.

I know this sounds nice for just a moment, but if you consider it longer, it's awful. It won't decrease congestion, it will increase it. Why?

1. Cars will still be searching for parking: many people will prefer to have their car nearby. It's not as if every car will altruistically drive to a far-off area. Since self driving cars have more patience than humans, they'll be on the road much longer searching for their parking. It may be more efficient to keep the car circling the block, which is even worse.

2. Parking availability is a major inhibitor of car trips, especially in cities. This is a good thing. If it becomes easier to "park" (ie leave your car driving on the street or send it away), that will induce more car trips, and more car trips means more congestion, until there's a new equilibrium (maybe a 7-minute parking search is eliminated, but it's replaced with 7+ minutes of traffic).

3. Pick-up and drop-off in cities is already difficult with rideshare services. If all personal vehicles are doing it as well, they'll definitely congest the curb lanes more. This is definitely a more solvable problem than the first two, but still an annoyance.

And for what it's worth, the 4-hour commute may be a bit far fetched, but it's hard to deny that many wouldn't mind an extra 20 minutes of commute time in traffic if they can relax, nap, read, watch a show, etc. People will chose that option more, adding more trips and more congestion, until an equilibrium is reached. Maybe it won't be 4-hour commute times but it will be a major increase and added congestion.

All of these extra miles traveled searching for parking, and adding extra congestion, are disastrous to cities and neighborhoods. Sure, the fossil fuel emissions alone would be awful, but suppose (charitably) that all autonomous vehicles are electric, and assume that their electricity generation is emission free (unrealistic for decades). The weight of EV batteries will dramatically increase road wear and tear, and they'll increase the pollution due to rubber tires, which are already the major source of microplastic pollution. And of course, it's a dramatic waste of energy from the power grid. And all of this is ignoring that dedicating that much road space storing to idling and parked vehicles is a no-good, terrible, awful way to utilize public space in a city or neighborhood, when it could be used by some efficient public transit, parks, and safer infrastructure for personal vehicles when necessary.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by lallysingh on Monday April 10, 2023 @04:48PM (#35517212)
Price the spots by location (or bid) and make their availability known through a web service. The parking trip is a straight shot and spot congestion is managed better than today. Another benefit of automating a manual process.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by brenns10 on Monday April 10, 2023 @05:05PM (#35517405)
Sure, fair market pricing for parking via bidding would be amazing. Of course, there's decades of subsidies for parking built-in, but the price would still be much higher than you'd expect. (Check out "The High Cost of Free Parking" by Donald Shoup for a great overview of the huge public subsidy we already give cars, paid for by non-drivers).

You'd then need to price the time a vehicle spends on the road without an occupant. Otherwise you're just pushing people to send their cars around the block for an hour to avoid paying market rate for parking.

But it's hard to enforce the "unoccupied vehicle" rule, so it would be much better to just charge for all road use time in high congestion areas. Maybe... congestion pricing?

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by fortran77 on Monday April 10, 2023 @05:30PM (#35517640)
Everyone pays for free parking, not just non drivers.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by brenns10 on Monday April 10, 2023 @05:46PM (#35517787)
Exactly. Which means drivers are getting a great discount thanks to the people who don't use a car, and the non-drivers are getting a markup on all the prices they pay. And the non-drivers were already paying a huge amount to maintain car infrastructure (at least in the US) because the gas tax doesn't nearly cover it.

Now don't get me wrong, I understand the value of a public good. Grocery stores receive food via trucks on roads, so even non-drivers get the benefit of the road. The parking subsidy, however, is insidious because it's so much less visible. It's not a government investing in a public good: the city instead requires businesses to maintain off-street parking, and they pass that cost on to everyone. It lets everybody believe that parking, and driving altogether, is much cheaper than it really is, because the (actually enormous) parking costs are hidden away and subsidized by those who don't use it.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by ghaff on Monday April 10, 2023 @06:11PM (#35518007)
>the city instead requires businesses to maintain off-street parking, and they pass that cost on to everyone

I'm not sure how generally true that is where I live relatively nearby (Boston/Cambridge). There are some businesses that have generally fairly crowded/small parking lots. (And places like hospitals certainly do though you generally have to pay for them.) But in general you have to pay for metered parking or find a garage.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by brenns10 on Monday April 10, 2023 @07:00PM (#35518439)
Much of this depends on the particular city's rules and when development happened. Off-street parking requirements have become far more common since the 1950s. Places that developed prior to this (and didn't dramatically re-develop) may not have this as much, since the rules would only apply to new development. I think a fair bit of the US northeast may fall under that category.

And, for instance, San Francisco has no required off-street parking, and has limits to off-street parking instead: https://codelibrary.amlegal.com/codes/san_francisco/latest/s...

However, plenty of other places in the US are different. The rest of the Bay Area is quite sprawled, as are the areas of the Midwest I've spent time in.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by fortran77 on Monday April 10, 2023 @09:16PM (#35519458)
In San Fransisco, it's too "costly" to park on the street because your car will be broken into, with full support of the people of SF and law enforcement.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by fortran77 on Monday April 10, 2023 @09:15PM (#35519444)
Non drivers benefit because workers at the businesses they patronize don't have to pay for parking, delivery people don't have to pay for parking, visitors don't have to pay for parking, etc.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by brenns10 on Monday April 10, 2023 @11:16PM (#35520329)
That's an argument that's pretty hard to justify. Most zoning rules with parking minimums attempt to meet peak demand for free parking. Subsidized free parking means that all the extra spaces are paid for by the business regardless of whether they're used. So the business (and thus the customer) is always overpaying for parking, compared to some hypothetical business with no free parking, but reimburses all market-rate parking for visitors and employees. Of course, that hypothetical business could only exist in a dense or very pedestrianized area, and not all businesses are suited to zero-parking.

The point I'd make is that mandating minimums of free parking is absurd: businesses and developers could instead decide how much parking they anticipate their business would need. They could come up with many creative solutions somewhere between the extremes of zero parking and plentiful free parking depending on the area. In most towns and cities across America, except for a few dense urban cores, we mandate one extreme and the result is higher prices for everyone (including the non-drivers, who get to help pay for all that unused parking as well).

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by DangitBobby on Monday April 10, 2023 @10:05PM (#35519825)
Not sure how many cities' economies can get get by just with their population buying locally, but if your parking is too expensive, I'm not visiting, and I'm not patronizing businesses. I don't actually know how sustainable a policy of "we don't accommodate visitors" is for a large city.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by freeone3000 on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @06:50AM (#35523296)
The entire point of a city is it to be a nexus of industry! Any place worthy of the name can get by just fine — the restaurants patronized by the locals, staffed by the locals, who have jobs in other locations. It’s not as if NYC needs your income (tourism accounts for about 7% of the economy). Not having a bunch of people clogging up the streets is a good policy.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by fortran77 on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @09:42AM (#35525007)
Tourists in NYC generally don't drive their own cars around manhattan.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by tuatoru on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @10:55AM (#35526042)
Now, they don't. When cars are self-driving?
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by elif on Monday April 10, 2023 @06:12PM (#35518018)
In many European and Asian cities this is a solved problem. You buy your own parking spot, lease one by year, or pay for the expensive hourly lots. Those are your only options.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by renewiltord on Monday April 10, 2023 @06:15PM (#35518040)
Tolled roads and market parking are likely to come, just with different names. Bay Area terms are "demand-responsive parking pricing" and HOT.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by Dylan16807 on Monday April 10, 2023 @06:31PM (#35518180)
I'm not seeing the downsides.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by brenns10 on Monday April 10, 2023 @06:42PM (#35518281)
Congestion pricing and market rate, unsubsidized parking _should_ be the default already. So let's start with those policies now :)
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by purpleblue on Monday April 10, 2023 @05:07PM (#35517424)
> 1. Cars will still be searching for parking: many people will prefer to have their car nearby.

You're not thinking with an open mind.

If I own a robot car and I know I'm going to be at dinner for 2 hours, I will send the robot car to do a few Uber rides while I'm eating. Or it will go and charge. It doesn't have to just drive around in circles like a human. It can coordinate will all the other robot cars in the area and pick a place where it won't create traffic, or they can distribute traffic among each other. Maybe it can park-share, where if there are 3 cars and 2 parking spots, the 3 cars can coordinate and rotate who goes driving around.

Maybe robot cars will be fungible, so you don't own a specific robot car, but you own a time share, so all the cars are basically like Ubers, and you can call the one closest to you.

The possibilities are endless, don't think that a robot car will just emulate a human.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by brenns10 on Monday April 10, 2023 @05:27PM (#35517601)
I mean, for sure there are some cool moonshot ideas. However I think it's pretty important to have some proof of concept or even a technical idea of how that would work before dismissing all of the concerns around congestion. Waving around "tech will save us" is really easy to do. (Especially when the solution to congestion already exists and is criminally underfunded.)

You're right that I did predicate that little rant on the idea that the majority of AVs would be personally owned and not part of a fleet. I'm sure that car share will come into play to some degree, but I do think it's tough to convince people who are used to their car being a personal, (relatively) private space that they can store nearly for free on public roads, to give that up. It's especially hard to convince the automobile industry that the incredibly profitable 1-2 car per household model should be pushed aside in order to manufacture fewer, shared vehicles. Cruise (i.e. GM) will not cannibalize their personal car sale business: they're using this as a way to get test data to build personal AVs. Maybe car share will increase over time, but we're not about to witness some revolution, especially if it reduces consumption or profit.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by coeneedell on Monday April 10, 2023 @06:18PM (#35518071)
I’m not sure why the idea that the cars will talk to each other is so “moonshot”. We have much more impressive pieces of infrastructure in place already. What might be moonshot is my proposal that it should be run by the US Postal Service.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by brenns10 on Monday April 10, 2023 @06:50PM (#35518347)
I think it's a moonshot because it expects that we will have shared, open standards and protocols for all of this, which will either need to come from industry, or from regulators. Neither feels very likely. But then again, it could happen :)
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by olyjohn on Monday April 10, 2023 @07:32PM (#35518729)
* * *
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by brightlancer on Monday April 10, 2023 @09:47PM (#35519694)
> (Especially when the solution to congestion already exists and is criminally underfunded.)

I presume you mean mass transit, but that's disproven by induced demand: cars removed from the roads will be replaced by others, either drivers who were previously taking other forms of transportation or by new trips. Removing cars frees up capacity, which is effectively no different than new capacity from expanded roads.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by abenga on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @04:07AM (#35522253)
Then you add mass transit and make driving your own car expensive enough to dissuade this induced demand.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by jayknight on Monday April 10, 2023 @05:22PM (#35517544)
Having a car come pick me up and take me to/from work would be great, and with no human to pay would be cheaper than owning a car for that purpose. But the family car packed with backpacks, jackets, sports gear, etc is gonna make owning at least one car per family that can afford it a reality for a long time. But self driving taxis will revolutionize how we get places and get stuff delivered, and ultimately for the better.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by elif on Monday April 10, 2023 @06:17PM (#35518063)
Or, your car parks in the spot you yourself would park in, the ones building codes require the restaurant to provide.

No one wants their $60k+ self driving car casually risking accidents. And I certainly don't want to end my date night with drunk/messy Uber patron roulette for like $10 profit. Not hating if you do.. just not for me.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by Dylan16807 on Monday April 10, 2023 @06:32PM (#35518189)
> Or, your car parks in the spot you yourself would park in, the ones building codes require the restaurant to provide.

In that case it sounds like the self-driving doesn't matter and we're no worse off.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by elif on Monday April 10, 2023 @07:09PM (#35518516)
agree. there's a lot of neo-luddite FUD on HN about self-driving.

plenty of actual academics project that autonomous vehicles improve occupancy of city streets by 40% and highways by 80%.

https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/abstract/document/8317654

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by bluGill on Monday April 10, 2023 @07:54PM (#35518901)
I've seen those, but they make a lot of assumptions that I do not think are reasonable. Only time will tell.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by brenns10 on Monday April 10, 2023 @07:28PM (#35518693)
If there was already plentiful parking at your destination then the whole "cruising for parking" discussion is moot anyway, right? The concerns were about congested commutes to denser downtown areas where parking is difficult, or the date night into the city from the suburbs, etc. Difficult/expensive parking disincentivizes car trips there, and shifts them to public transit, ride share, and commuter rail, which are better suited for cities. If you weren't encountering difficulty finding street parking or paying steep garage prices, then of course you wouldn't suddenly be sending your AV on a joyride around town or letting random people use it as car share.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by CPLX on Monday April 10, 2023 @06:19PM (#35518086)
> If I own a robot car and I know I'm going to be at dinner for 2 hours, I will send the robot car to do a few Uber rides while I'm eating.

I mean assuming I don’t want to leave my sunglasses in the car, or anything else.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by cmsj on Monday April 10, 2023 @07:36PM (#35518763)
I think "coordinate with all the other robot cars in the area and pick a place where it won't create traffic" is pretty unlikely to happen. Tesla will do their own version of that which only negotiates with other Teslas, GM will do one that sends all cars to the wrong city, and Waymo will have their cars perform some optimal algorithm that is somehow incompatible with any human drivers they encounter.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by bluGill on Monday April 10, 2023 @07:53PM (#35518887)
That won't happen. It sounds good, but the details kill it. Someone will trash your car and now it isn't acceptance when dinner is done. Someone will take a longer than expected trip and you won't have a ride when dinner is done.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by singleshot_ on Monday April 10, 2023 @08:16PM (#35519071)
If I own a robot car and I know I am going to be at dinner for two hours, I will send the car someplace where no dirty person whom I have never met can possibly find or enter my car, because I am not a destitute person looking to monetize my own personal property. If you live in this world, bless your heart, but you are absolutely positively not allowed in my car and I suspect a fair number of people agree with me.

If all cars are Ubers I’ll just move to some other place that isn’t the ninth circle of rent seeking, sharing economy, dot com nightmare dystopia.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by ghaff on Monday April 10, 2023 @05:20PM (#35517527)
I don't think it's 8 hour commutes so much. But that I could now take the 75-90 minute trip into the city that's about 50 miles away for dinner/show without thinking about it too much. I've really cut down on casually swinging into town to meet someone or do an activity on a weeknight because it's just a hassle to drive with all the traffic and driving back home when I'm probably getting a bit tired.

Of course, it still costs money and if everyone does that now maybe it's 2+ hours in a car each way and I still won't mostly do it.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by throwaway2037 on Monday April 10, 2023 @09:59PM (#35519769)

    I've really cut down on casually swinging into town to meet someone or do an activity on a weeknight because it's just a hassle to drive with all the traffic and driving back home when I'm probably getting a bit tired.
This sounds like age, more than anything. Your energy levels fall, and you tell yourself "next time". In reality, next time comes less and less.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by ghaff on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @10:12AM (#35525437)
In part that's probably true. I've also been working from home most of the time since well before the pandemic and it both takes longer and has a higher "activation energy" to do something in the evening when I'm not already out and about. That said, the driving time has also increased 15 to 30 minutes over time.

So it is a combination.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by Spooky23 on Monday April 10, 2023 @05:59PM (#35517899)
How many cars are operating 12 hours a day?

With self driving cars, it will be like a NYC taxi, the goal is 24 hour operations.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by Dylan16807 on Monday April 10, 2023 @06:29PM (#35518168)
Only if it's serving a lot of users.

So for those cars, the time on the road per user doesn't change much, but the need for parking greatly decreases.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by mgsouth on Monday April 10, 2023 @06:20PM (#35518091)
> 8 hours (4+4) spent in commuting, driving or not, is an entire life. This isn't a realistic concern, but something pulled out of a cyberpunk novel.

You poor innocent child. Spent a couple of years of my life doing pretty much that, in crowded trains with a thousand others doing the same. Some did it for many, many years. It's a thing. (OK, I was lucky about where I worked and only had a 3-hr commute each way.)

Related data point... my commuting choices were

a) drive all or most of the way (saving 45 minutes to an hour each way);

b) drive 15 minutes to a park-and-ride, take a commuter bus;

c) drive 45 minutes to train station, take train in (extra 30 to 45 minutes each way, exta $$/mo).

Often did (b) for practical reasons, much preferred (c) for comfort. Didn't do (a) too often. (d) "black car" (private driver) was an idle astronomically expensive dream. But if it was only a relatively small premium over normal car ownership? I and 100's of thousands of my fellow commuters would have given our left kidneys.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by tmpz22 on Monday April 10, 2023 @06:29PM (#35518166)
In the Bay Area in particular it is known commutes from Sacramento, Gilroy, and elsewhere happen. To say nothing of traffic and closures (devil's slide is STILL closed between Pacifica and Half Moon Bay) creating 3+ hour commutes from what google maps may indicate as < 2 hour commutes.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by jjav on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @01:10AM (#35521095)
I've had a coworker who used to commute from Fresno to Palo Alto daily.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by brightlancer on Monday April 10, 2023 @09:08PM (#35519397)
Respectfully, some people drink motor oil, that doesn't make it a realistic concern.

I drove 90 minutes each way in/ around Atlanta and that was considered long; I had friends in NYC who were on the train 90 minutes each way and that was considered long.

I can't think of anyone I knew who had 2 hours each way, every day. (Some days, yes, but not as the norm.)

I do know folks who drive/ ride/ fly and then stay locally for some days, then commute back for the weekend or their WFH days. And most are for 2-3 hour driving commutes, not 4.

I agree with them 8 hours a day of travel "isn't a realistic concern".

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by runesofdoom on Monday April 10, 2023 @08:36PM (#35519196)
>8 hours (4+4) spent in commuting, driving or not, is an entire life. This isn't a realistic concern, but something pulled out of a cyberpunk novel.

To paraphrase a certain fictional pirate captain, "You'd best start believing in cyberpunk dystopias... you're in one!"

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by user3939382 on Monday April 10, 2023 @02:59PM (#35515995)
Cars that never have a driver could be much smaller. Eventually what we need for this scenario in congested areas is a driving decision protocol that's based on consensus with neighboring cars, some kind of leader election algorithm, etc. If all cars were full self driving they could in some situations drive at super high speeds as a swarm, you wouldn't even need stoplights.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by akiselev on Monday April 10, 2023 @03:03PM (#35516043)
I love your optimism. I predict the GP is correct though, since everyone will want one of those Mercedes megavans to set up a comfortable bed or office while stuck in traffic. There's no way I'm going to sleep or work in a tiny self driving smartcar.

Since they'll autopark or circle anyway, their size no longer becomes a limiting factor for most people.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by syntheweave on Monday April 10, 2023 @07:00PM (#35518446)
I'll save money and get there faster on a bicycle. There won't be any human drivers, so they will all yield to me even if I treat them like slalom poles.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by throwaway2037 on Monday April 10, 2023 @10:16PM (#35519910)

    There won't be any human drivers, so they will all yield to me even if I treat them like slalom poles.
I genuinely laughed when I read your post, but there is some truth to it. Most of these posts here are "doomers". Ignoring that for a moment, no one (except you) has talked about pedestrians or bicyclists. One "hack" that sounds great as a walker/rider: In a world of 99% self-driving cars, just walk/ride anywhere you want. Literally, casually cross a ten lane expressway. All the self-driving cars will bow dutifully to you!

This thought experiment sounds like a performance art dream. Do you remember the artist who created a Google maps traffic jam in London by filling a wagon with mobile phones and walking slowly? Ref: https://www.simonweckert.com/googlemapshacks.html

Another thing: You can sabotage self-driving cars by putting traffic cones everywhere. Or sit in the middle of a major intersect with ten of your friends and read the newspaper (or pick your nose!). The passengers will be furious, and the self-driving cars won't know what to do.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by TchoBeer on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @05:29AM (#35522745)
Note: that is illegal.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by freeone3000 on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @07:14AM (#35523462)
What’s a small fine versus how funny this is?
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by user3939382 on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @02:23PM (#35529109)
> All the self-driving cars will bow dutifully to you

Well assuming no minimum stopping distance per vehicle momentum. Might want to be sure about that first lol

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by HDThoreaun on Monday April 10, 2023 @04:24PM (#35516954)
Wouldn’t want to be in the car swarm that had a Byzantine fault.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by idkyall on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @10:42AM (#35525864)
I imagine someday we'll see a protocol like this - autonomy in a controlled situation, such as clearing out a traffic jam
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by dpkirchner on Monday April 10, 2023 @03:15PM (#35516178)
I suspect a lot of people won't want to own self-driving cars, especially if you're right and people forget how to drive themselves. We could drastically reduce the amount of parking we need, at least within cities, meaning there probably won't be many cars idly circling blocks.

Personally, I'd be down for a driverless Uber-like service.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by runnerup on Monday April 10, 2023 @03:16PM (#35516186)
This also implies that some nontrivial amount of the driving on roads will be cars with no humans in them, which may also be worse than the status quo.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by dpkirchner on Monday April 10, 2023 @03:26PM (#35516313)
It's possible.

I wonder if we would see as many idle/empty self-driving cars as we do idle/empty human-driven cabs and Ubers/etc. I could see a self-driving system being a lot more efficient because it doesn't have to keep a car on the road for a driver's entire shift.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by Ekaros on Monday April 10, 2023 @03:53PM (#35516626)
I think we will see more. If just keeping them running circles around blocks with most expected demand is nearly same cost it will happen. Specially if they are EVs with automatic charging.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by JohnFen on Monday April 10, 2023 @04:04PM (#35516769)
Damn. I never thought of SDCs as being particularly dystopic, but this would be squarely in that area.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by JohnFen on Monday April 10, 2023 @04:02PM (#35516753)
> I suspect a lot of people won't want to own self-driving cars

If it involves the car having a data link to someone else's server, then I have no interest whatsoever in self-driving vehicles.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by HDThoreaun on Monday April 10, 2023 @04:25PM (#35516975)
This view will have a negligible effect on the market. You and the dozens like you can still have cars and a lot of other people can use the self driving ubers
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by JohnFen on Monday April 10, 2023 @04:36PM (#35517096)
I'm always curious when these "your preference is irrelevant" comments pop up.

Yes, you're probably right. So what? I wasn't even remotely asserting otherwise.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by HDThoreaun on Monday April 10, 2023 @04:56PM (#35517302)
So it doesn’t matter if a small number of people defect from self driving ride share. Enough people will use it to decrease parking needs.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by tshaddox on Monday April 10, 2023 @06:13PM (#35518026)
Well, the conversation is mostly about the impact of new technology on large-scale trends. When someone makes a prediction about how "a lot of people" will react to new technology, it's understandable that a reply of "I won't react like that" could be seen as irrelevant.

Like if someone says "a lot of people will buy the new iPhone" and someone replies "I will never own a cellular phone or even a cordless landline phone" I can understand why that could seem irrelevant to the conversation.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by JohnFen on Monday April 10, 2023 @06:23PM (#35518109)
In this case, I was replying to a speculation that a lot of people won't want to own self-driving cars by saying I'm one of those people, and why. My response was on-topic and relevant.

Replies to comments such as mine saying "you don't matter" strike me as interesting because they come off as overly defensive, is all.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by TeMPOraL on Monday April 10, 2023 @06:47PM (#35518320)
I'd say it's an important reminder, especially that even here, people still cling to the view that you can "vote with your wallet".

Also, it's more than just having "a negligible effect on the market" - if your preferences diverge too much from the main trend, they'll simply not be met at all. In this context, it means that with large enough self-driving car adoption, you won't get to keep a regular car - they'll eventually stop being sold, but by that time you won't be allowed to legally drive one anyway.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by JohnFen on Monday April 10, 2023 @07:15PM (#35518573)
> people still cling to the view that you can "vote with your wallet".

Not only can you, you do. Every dollar you spend is a vote telling the company that you approve of how they do business and should continue doing what they're doing.

But my comment isn't that. My point about not purchasing self-driving cars isn't that I'm trying to influence companies to stop making their cars spying platforms. It's just that such a product is not one that I'm interested in owning.

> you won't get to keep a regular car - they'll eventually stop being sold, but by that time you won't be allowed to legally drive one anyway.

I'll get to keep my regular car for sure. By the time the used car market dries up to the point that getting an old used car isn't a realistic option (or that they're made illegal), I'll have died from old age.

It's the younger crowd that may not have the choice. But they may not care.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by brightlancer on Monday April 10, 2023 @10:33PM (#35520045)
Having lived in the boondocks on America, I'm confident it will remain legal to sell and drive regular cars, both for practical and ideological reasons.

It may be that those cars are prohibited in big cities or are prohibitively expensive to insure in a city, but they won't go away entirely.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by TeMPOraL on Monday April 10, 2023 @06:42PM (#35518273)
> You and the dozens like you can still have cars

Until they don't, because of prohibitive insurance premiums or some accelerated phase-out of HDC bill. That's the blessing and the curse of the technology market: you don't get to keep your old toys if most of the market has moved on.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by Gigachad on Monday April 10, 2023 @09:11PM (#35519418)
The rest of society will not accept recklessly controlled death machines around them because some sovereign citizen didn't want a networked car.

You might think that viewpoint is extreme, but that's exactly how it will look when cars have been made completely safe with new technology. You'll be made to take your manual car to private property to use away from other people.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by brightlancer on Monday April 10, 2023 @10:24PM (#35519985)
> but that's exactly how it will look when cars have been made completely safe with new technology

"completely safe"

No, they won't be completely safe. They might be safer than the current median driver, they might even be safer than the top 10% driver, but they won't be completely safe.

> The rest of society will not accept recklessly controlled death machines around them because some sovereign citizen didn't want a networked car.

Our "recklessly controlled death machines" are doing pretty good today. In fact, automobile related death rates are down in most Developed nations, sometimes down in raw numbers.

But hyperbole will certainly solve all of our problems.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by shredprez on Monday April 10, 2023 @02:55PM (#35515942)
And thus the motor vehicle takes his rightful place at the top of the food chain: King of the concrete jungle. May he reign forever, tire never, and render his enemies unto the road.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by mindvirus on Monday April 10, 2023 @02:53PM (#35515916)
Of course, like anything there will be major societal changes. But consider a few brighter possibilities:

* Cars are all electric, since the one downside major downside (a long time to charge versus gas) is reduced if they can go charge themselves. So less pollution and noise.

* The number of cars may increase, but so will the capacity of roads due to faster speeds and higher density. So a city could possibly only have a couple of car accessible roads.

* Parking can also get denser, as cars can presumably park themselves and coordinate. So you could build a few massive parking garages (for example) to serve thousands of cars, or require them to park outside of the city.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by gpm on Monday April 10, 2023 @03:14PM (#35516176)
> Cars are all electric [...] So less [...] noise

Tire noise dominates at speeds above roughly 30 kph (20 mph), so on reasonably fast roads not really.

https://www.researchgate.net/figure/Propulsion-noise-the-tyr...

Of course, self driving cars might also mean slower cars, because the drivers are less impatient, and if that is true then noise would go down. On the flip side, self driving cars might end up meaning faster cars because they can coordinate better, increasing noise levels.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by mejutoco on Monday April 10, 2023 @04:25PM (#35516969)
I honestly cannot imagine self-driving cars until trains never crash and trucks are automated.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by JohnFen on Monday April 10, 2023 @04:05PM (#35516786)
> The number of cars may increase, but so will the capacity of roads due to faster speeds and higher density.

As someone who enjoys walking and biking, this strikes me a serious negative, not a positive.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by agumonkey on Monday April 10, 2023 @02:56PM (#35515959)
It was supposed to improve allocation (less people trying to find a parking spot etc) but I guess it may trigger the usual perverse effect.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by astrange on Monday April 10, 2023 @03:18PM (#35516211)
The "usual perverse effect" of policies (aka "risk compensation") almost never happens, people just say it's going to happen and then it doesn't.

This is a disease of the soul caused by reading Freakanomics which makes you think everything that's counterintuitive must actually be true.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by baremetal on Monday April 10, 2023 @03:34PM (#35516405)
Who needs to park, just let the car sit in an alley or side street in the middle of the road and if someone comes it moves on its own.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by Ekaros on Monday April 10, 2023 @03:54PM (#35516647)
Or drive circles around the block... At current parking rates might be the cheaper option. And it probably doesn't consume that much power when all the cars are doing it and whole thing is gridlocked.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by tenebrisalietum on Monday April 10, 2023 @03:11PM (#35516114)
Gosh, if it gets to the point where cars never stop circling because there's no parking ... we could like, make the cars bigger, and longer, and then people can just hop on and off as needed ... maybe even make a few of them go underground and such. Could even give them a cool name - like Timed Rides Around In the Near Streets or something like that. If we put these things on rails then they would even cause far less wear and tear on the road.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by yjftsjthsd-h on Monday April 10, 2023 @03:43PM (#35516507)
Yes, if cars continue to just massively decline in performance and quality of life, become entirely a shared resource, and lose all their advantages, than they could rival trains.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by tenebrisalietum on Monday April 10, 2023 @04:32PM (#35517051)
If the road is full and cars are circling because there is nowhere to park, then performance doesn't matter, quality of life is already low, and cars no longer have advantages.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by nuancebydefault on Monday April 10, 2023 @03:43PM (#35516495)
Once you buy the self driving car, you will want it to be on the road as much as possible, you want return on investment.

What will happen is:

Companies will buy fleets of self driving cars.

The best self driving cars will be too expensive for most people to buy.

People will just pay one of those companies for transportation services.

The transportation - serving companies who will use the cars in the most efficient way will survive. They will use AI to optimize the usage of the fleets.

Regulators (governments) will tax the companies per km / time interval / peak hours.

People will pay more if they want to travel alone or want to travel in a straight line. They will pay more if they want more exact timing.

Roads will be safer because they will communicate with the cars and the cars will communicate with other cars.

There will be manned vehicles that will help relieve any obstructions.

In other words, given proper tax rules, transportation will regulate itself in effective and efficient ways.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by bombcar on Monday April 10, 2023 @04:25PM (#35516973)
> Once you buy the self driving car, you will want it to be on the road as much as possible, you want return on investment.

This is not necessarily a given; after all, most Americans have other little-utilized equipment that nobody bothers to try to "rent out" to maximize usage. Think - washing machines, dish washers, lawn mowers, snow blowers, etc. In fact, there's an entire industry built around storing little-used equipment (storage units).

And we have high-usage vehicles transport already, they're called taxis and they're at use in most major cities; the AI cannot save MORE than the cost of the driver without some magical accounting.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by zdragnar on Monday April 10, 2023 @05:09PM (#35517435)
Most of those things are dirt-cheap compared to a car. A better analogy would be a boat or an RV in a northern climate. Even those tend to be priced roughly in line with a higher end car (where you're more likely to find full self driving).
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by onlyrealcuzzo on Monday April 10, 2023 @03:46PM (#35516539)
Shortly after we get self-driving cars widely available, most municipalities will have trolly busses that run the grid so that the most you need to wait is like 2 minutes. At which point, a substantial amount of people aren't going to pay $20 to get from A to B when you can get there slightly slower for $2.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by opportune on Monday April 10, 2023 @03:57PM (#35516688)
Yeah, I think a lot of people don’t recognize that SDC technology can eventually be applied to busses or smaller transit vans. You can get fancy with dynamic routing (with my fleet of busses and customers asking me to take them from A to B, how do I route the busses to serve the most customers the fastest?) but even just running a SDBus on a fixed route could be pretty convenient. It would basically take us back to the “streetcar suburb” paradigm.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by Ekaros on Monday April 10, 2023 @03:50PM (#35516593)
Even individual companies will drive it to the bottom. Humans out of picture they will drive price to few percentage of margins. Or if we get VC money involved beyond that.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by zdragnar on Monday April 10, 2023 @05:10PM (#35517443)
The wages of the driver are hardly the limiting factor of busses right now. We could easily have many more in operation, but we don't, because running an empty bus is very expensive.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by bps4484 on Monday April 10, 2023 @06:37PM (#35518232)
Is this true?

That's a legitimate question I haven't done the research on this. It would seem though that usually it's a municipal employee, probably a union job, so probably paid pretty well (relative to say an uber driver). Also that cost for the driver would be double if you half the size of the bus and run them twice as much which would be a better experience for passengers. It would seem like the cost of drivers could be a real impact but this is me being handwavy I haven't crunched any numbers.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by onlyrealcuzzo on Monday April 10, 2023 @09:06PM (#35519383)
It's completely false. Bus wages and pensions are the majority of expenses and BY FAR the largest line item.

The average bus only drives less than miles in cities like NYC, Chicago, and LA per day.

They get >6 MPGe. Fuel is about $65 per day or less. The cost of the vehicle financed probably averages less than that - and should definitely be less than $85 per day. Maintenance and insurance are peanuts. Parking should be quite expensive, but they usually have pieces of land worth tons of money they already own and aren't going to sell. Practically, it's close to $0.

A driver for 12 hours per day costs >$360 without factoring in pensions. With a pension it's >$450.

The reality of the situation is bus fare is currently less than $2. If you get rid of the driver, it's gonna cost a lot less than $2. If you can make trollies ubiquitous, a huge potion of the population isn't going to take taxis anymore (or drive themselves).

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by kiliantics on Monday April 10, 2023 @10:21PM (#35519962)
According to the NYC MTA[1], there are close to 6k buses in the fleet with 1.2M riders per day. That's over 200 riders per bus per day. With each paying a $2.75 fare, you are making about enough to cover your estimated costs.

I think the problem is not the cost of the bus but the organisation of the city's infrastructure. The bus could be a viable option for a lot more people -- far more than 200 per bus per day -- they just don't structure the roadways to maximise bus use but rather to minimise it. If there isn't a dedicated lane for buses (physically separated since NYPD cannot or will not enforce painted separation) then buses will go at least as slow as traffic, along with regular stopping, making it a less attractive option to driving or cabbing. It's pointless to operate the system this way and very cheap to fix it, where fixing it would make everyone's lives so much better as explained in this video with the extreme example of the Bahamas [2]

[1] https://new.mta.info/agency/new-york-city-transit/subway-bus... [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kdz6FeQLuHQ

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by hnav on Monday April 10, 2023 @06:31PM (#35518184)
IDT that's the future, and here's why: if you go to any modern skyscraper you'll find that elevators ask you which floor you're going to rather than just which direction. Applying this in 2 dimensions, it becomes obvious that the future is something like Zoox's 4 passenger car running point to point a la Uber pool.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by onlyrealcuzzo on Monday April 10, 2023 @07:48PM (#35518853)
That would be true if you could only have one car on the road per lane. But you can have more...
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by brightlancer on Monday April 10, 2023 @10:52PM (#35520163)
> Shortly after we get self-driving cars widely available, most municipalities will have trolly busses that run the grid so that the most you need to wait is like 2 minutes.

On what are you basing this?

I grew up in NYC which had the most frequent buses I've seen anywhere in the US, and 10+ minutes on a route was common, far far more on off hours. Plus, that route would only get me so far, so I'd have to change buses.

My ~2 mile trip from my apartment to my elementary school required at least two buses, often three.

> a substantial amount of people aren't going to pay $20 to get from A to B when you can get there slightly slower for $2.

NYC MTA trip fare is $2.75. Atlanta is $2.50.

Are you Chuck Wollery? How are you doing 2 and 2?

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by onlyrealcuzzo on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @01:17PM (#35528124)
As you pointed out - the bussing infrastructure even in NYC is not good - because busses are too expensive, because drivers are the biggest expense by far.

Comparing to a current system limited in service by the cost of the driver to a future system that won't have this meaningless.

And I've got news for you. Your $2.75 ticket wouldn't be $2.75 without a driver.

Additionally, the vast majority of transit rides are covered by a monthly pass, and the average trip price is less than $2.75.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by bell-cot on Monday April 10, 2023 @05:26PM (#35517575)
> ...given proper tax rules, transportation will regulate itself in effective and efficient ways.

And if you mix together "modern American government" and "billions of dollars at stake for mega-corporations" - just how close to zero is the real-world probability of those "proper tax rules" being made and maintained?

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by EvanAnderson on Monday April 10, 2023 @05:32PM (#35517663)
This is mostly the future scenario I see, albeit thru a much more dystopian (realistic?) lens.

The nasty world the Internet has become seems like a realistic future for transportation once automation fully engages with it.

> Companies will buy fleets of self driving cars.

> The best self driving cars will be too expensive for most people to buy.

Transportation service companies will lobby, in the name of safety, to make sure the "best self driving cars" are priced out of reach of the majority of individuals.

> Roads will be safer because they will communicate with the cars and the cars will communicate with other cars.

Infosec and shady capitalism being what they are I expect this is an overly rosy picture. Instead of just data, ransomware will be able to operate on people. Imagine your self-driving ride unexpectedly delivering you into a bad neighborhood where people wait to kidnap you. Your abductors will only need to share a cut of the ransom w/ the malicious operator who routed your car there.

> In other words, given proper tax rules, transportation will regulate itself in effective and efficient ways.

The transportation service providers will have sufficient capital to influence legislation such that the regulation is effective and efficient for the operators and high-margin, high-spend passengers. Regular consumers will get whatever is left.

Rich people, of course, will be able to pay for priority and bypass the entire system.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by tshaddox on Monday April 10, 2023 @06:07PM (#35517974)
> Once you buy the self driving car, you will want it to be on the road as much as possible, you want return on investment.

I don't really follow the argument. I don't think of my car as an "investment." In fact quite the opposite, I think of it as an extremely depreciatory purchase that is partly a necessary cost of living (commuting for work, shopping) and partly for leisure (visiting friends and family, going out on the town, road trips). It makes very little sense to me to "want to be on the road as much as possible," especially considering that most of the depreciation for when I eventually sell it or trade it in is likely going to be based on the odometer rather than the calendar.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by TeMPOraL on Monday April 10, 2023 @06:36PM (#35518223)
> I don't really follow the argument. I don't think of my car as an "investment." In fact quite the opposite, I think of it as an extremely depreciatory purchase that is partly a necessary cost of living (...)

This means you'll end up not owning a car at all. Like with housing, those who look at it as investment game outcompete and drive up prices for those who just want a place to live in and call their own.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by thexumaker on Monday April 10, 2023 @06:43PM (#35518290)
Except there needs to be natural demand and short enough supply. You’re viewing them like its early 2020 where people were buying up cars and selling them used at a marked up price somehow. People really be trying to treat everything as a profit nowadays
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by opportune on Monday April 10, 2023 @03:52PM (#35516616)
I see self driving cars as a backwards compatible way for us to reimagine infrastructure.

Right now, SDC is operating in the real world, in non-trivial environments (San Francisco), without special road infrastructure to make them work. It’s beautifully backwards compatible, at the cost of not being generalized (the service areas are extensively mapped).

Once SDC take off we’ll likely start getting infrastructure and rules to support them. Think standards for communicating position locally - ie car A broadcasts its position and route to cars B, C, D within 200m, special road infrastructure to make lanes and corners more manageable for SDC, rules against aimless circling. There’s already a carrying cost in the form of gas or electricity plus wear incentivizing aimless driving, also the opportunity cost of not actively moving someone or something, but we can probably introduce some kind of toll or tax on a SDC operating with no humans inside it to further disincentivize this.

A very useful thing about SDC, and something I think people forget about rideshare and taxis, is that they let people move around independently without needing parking for those trips. In dense cities like SF and NYC that’s hugely useful. A single rideshare or SDC can move 10 people on custom routes without any of those people needing to find and pay for parking, and without using any parking infrastructure. That’s great because it disincentivizes wasting more space on parking in aggregate. Over time this should let us build denser.

Of course, public transit could obviate all these concerns, and I’m a big believer in funding way more public transit than we do already, but it will take a lot of time and political will to make that happen in the US. And it still does not offer the flexibility of SDC and rideshare. SDC is fully compatible with existing infrastructure and may give us a way to morph into public transit more smoothly with things like dynamically routed SDBusses and a reduction of parking infrastructure leading to denser urban environments that more easily support public transit. I think we can solve the “spending too much time on the road doing nothing” problem with congestion pricing, which we should really be doing already.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by pc86 on Monday April 10, 2023 @05:32PM (#35517661)
I've never been to a major city, especially NYC or SF, and thought "man this would be great if it was just a little denser."
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by renewiltord on Monday April 10, 2023 @06:11PM (#35518002)
Funny, that's my prime complaint about SF (which I otherwise love). I'd like it to be like Tokyo's inner districts.

I believe it's quite common. In about 50 y this place will look very different.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by q7xvh97o2pDhNrh on Monday April 10, 2023 @06:36PM (#35518225)
SF could frankly stand to be 5-10x denser. It's not getting any bigger, but more and more people want to live there.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by rightbyte on Monday April 10, 2023 @07:48PM (#35518859)
I believe the feedback loop is that so many leave due to bad living conditions (mainly driven by cost and commutes) that there are plenty of jobs to get which makes people want to move there.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by RC_ITR on Monday April 10, 2023 @08:23PM (#35519128)
In 2010, SF/Oakland + San Jose MSAs had 3.2 million people in the workforce.

Today, it's 3.7 million.

Austin in 2010 had 950K and now has 1.4mn.

Cities like Austin just felt like they grew more b/c they had a smaller starting point.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by pc86 on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @08:32AM (#35524251)
Cities like Austin feel like they grow more because 50% growth is a LOT more than 15% growth.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by RC_ITR on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @02:47PM (#35529515)
>I believe the feedback loop is that so many leave due to bad living conditions (mainly driven by cost and commutes) that there are plenty of jobs to get which makes people want to move there.

GP's implication was that SF has abundant jobs because so many people leave and I was clarifying how that is a misconception.

Your point is different entirely, but thank you for making it.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by prawn on Monday April 10, 2023 @06:46PM (#35518312)
The most enjoyable cities/suburbs I've experienced around the world have been fairly dense in terms of narrow streets and multi storey buildings. 3-6 storey buildings on average. NYC and SF already have a good amount like this, though still dominated by roads. There'd also be scope to turn parking lots into actual parks or multi-purpose areas for events, food stalls and so on. Parking lots are just grim.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by akira2501 on Monday April 10, 2023 @06:53PM (#35518375)
> I see self driving cars as a backwards compatible way for us to reimagine infrastructure.

Which may be.. but backwards compatibility doesn't absolve you of actually doing maintenance on your legacy systems. Unless the upgrade is free.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by amluto on Monday April 10, 2023 @07:52PM (#35518883)
Sadly, no amount of amazing self-driving AI can compensate for geometry:

https://s3-ap-southeast-2.amazonaws.com/ehq-production-austr...

That picture has the cars bumper to bumper, which is likely rather better than even the self-driving best case. Cars take up a lot of space.

I can imagine interesting and efficient ways to move large numbers of people that involve self-driving vehicles for part of the journey, but for high capacity at reasonable cost and space utilization, feet, bicycles, busses, trains, subways, etc are dramatically better.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by brightlancer on Monday April 10, 2023 @10:06PM (#35519831)
I'm from NYC and very familiar with taxis. They produce quite a bit of congestion on their own, without needing to park regularly.

And stop calling for-hire cars "rideshare", because it isn't sharing, it's hiring or renting.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by crazygringo on Monday April 10, 2023 @04:24PM (#35516957)
Maybe.

On the other hand, ride sharing could mean less cars overall and less car ownership. Electric cars mean fewer or no emissions. Totally automated traffic management could enable vastly higher throughput, and otherwise congested roads could have dynamic tolls applied so people won't use them unless they really need to. Delivery vehicles can batch shopping pickups and dropoffs to use less vehicles than currently.

If problems arise, they can be fixed through policy and incentives. Otherwise, traditional economic incentives for efficiency continue to apply.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by rrradical on Monday April 10, 2023 @04:33PM (#35517061)
Tires emit a fair amount of micro plastics. There's no such thing as zero emission cars.

https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2020/11/car-tire...

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by apendleton on Monday April 10, 2023 @04:49PM (#35517220)
All the more reason to shift to a pay-per-use model rather than the high-fixed-cost model of car ownership, which incentivizes uses your car for as many trips as possible once you've made the initial expenditure to buy the thing. If these get good enough and cheap enough that significant numbers of people can get away with ditching their cars, those people will probably end up in a situation where transit (including kinds with no tires) will be cheaper on a per-trip basis where it's practical, and robocars will make sense for the remainder.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by ChatGTP on Monday April 10, 2023 @05:56PM (#35517866)
All the more reason Americans should just try learn and adapt to public transport.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by hnav on Monday April 10, 2023 @06:07PM (#35517978)
public transport as implemented in Asia and Europe, especially for last (couple) mile sort of uses is an antiquated idea in a world of self-driving. In a city like San Francisco you could literally ban cars in downtown and have the local transit authority run something like Uber pool of cars that fit 4 passengers comfortably and do point 2 point transit with optimized routing 24/7. The reason buses/trains are so large is to amortize a bunch of things, not the least of which is the driver.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by ChatGTP on Monday April 10, 2023 @06:16PM (#35518045)
Your body needing to go anywhere might become an antique idea very soon… the only reason roads exist is so you can go do work and pay taxes and make wealthy people more wealthy.

After that isn’t important, let’s see how much priority roads will get.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by hnav on Monday April 10, 2023 @07:21PM (#35518623)
that too, in the long-term, living in meatspace will be an expensive privilege reserved for the wealthy
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by ChatGTP on Monday April 10, 2023 @07:37PM (#35518773)
Which is funny because it’s exactly the opposite to what Silicon Valley is selling to us…
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by crazygringo on Monday April 10, 2023 @04:57PM (#35517321)
I'm definitely not disputing that, although I think "emissions" are generally understood to be airborne. Micro plastics that run off the road into storm water are pollution for sure, but "emissions" seems misleading.

And obviously fewer/no emissions is also referring just to operation, not manufacture or disposal or power plants either.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by rrradical on Monday April 10, 2023 @08:23PM (#35519124)
From the linked article: "A study published in July suggests that vast quantities of tire fragments find their way into the ocean not just via rivers and waterways, but also through the air. Swept on the wind, they drift far from where they were shed. The study warned that so many tire particles are landing in the Arctic that they pose a climate-change risk."
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by cozzyd on Monday April 10, 2023 @05:07PM (#35517423)
I mean, driverless buses (or perhaps minibuses or vans, depending on density) are the way to go.

But... there's another dimension here. Would you share a car with a random stranger with no "trusted" third-party (i.e. the driver) present?

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by hnav on Monday April 10, 2023 @06:11PM (#35518009)
I would if the "bus" was small, traveled more like an uber pool (to my destination rather than along a corridor with 30 useless stops a block apart), and if the identity of those strangers was known to a system that could then remove their ability to hail future rides if anything went down.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by californical on Monday April 10, 2023 @06:55PM (#35518390)
But what about the dystopian flip side? You commit a crime once and suddenly you aren’t allowed to travel, otherwise the other passengers would feel unsafe? Or your transportation costs increase by 5x to account for you needing private-only accommodation?

Sounds like a great way to isolate someone and make sure there is no chance of rehabilitation, being shunned by the car swarm and isolated away

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by hnav on Monday April 10, 2023 @07:25PM (#35518658)
totally, I think the social credit score system in China, background checks for employment, no-fly lists are all things we should look at when building such systems. Ultimately though it's not going to be fair, I don't really care for subway performance arts as practiced in urban metro systems and I'd vote to eject and ban the artists, whereas someone else might find that to be an authoritarian overreach
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by cozzyd on Monday April 10, 2023 @08:51PM (#35519292)
but how would the driverless vehicle know that something went down? reports from other passengers? What if the other passengers are lying? Or simply don't like you? So the vehicle will have to surveil the passenger conversations and actions and beam it up to Waymo or Cruise (ok, that's fine, a human driver would do that too). But who will look at the surveillance? An algorithm? And, what if they say you are smelly? The microphone and camera won't pick that up...

And the smelly (or messy) passenger problem doesn't even require ridesharing! Who will clean the previous passenger's McNugget crumbs off your seat?

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by hnav on Monday April 10, 2023 @09:34PM (#35519626)
all of these are pre-existing problems with public transport that have solutions along the anarchy<->totalitarianism spectrum, with US, European and Asian mega-cities' transit agencies serving as illustrative examples of tradeoffs of various approaches. I'm not sure how self-driving changes the game, ain't nobody helping you when the foil and torch lighter comes out on BART late at night.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by cozzyd on Monday April 10, 2023 @09:50PM (#35519716)
Well typically you're not the only other one the train (at the very least there's an operator). Somehow sitting in a small car next to someone else feels different.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by baloki on Monday April 10, 2023 @04:27PM (#35516995)
Honestly I think by that point owning one won’t even be a thing. You’ll rent it from the manufacturer on demand or via a subscription with your subset of features enabled just for your trip.

They won’t park, they’ll just move from one job to the next (like taxis and ubers).

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by calvinmorrison on Monday April 10, 2023 @04:35PM (#35517088)
I think that's naiive. There's a reason why taxis aren't couriers. There will certainly be specialization. There will still be buses, with AI drivers instead of humans, to get a lot of people from A to B, there will be delivery vans, with maybe delivery robots, maybe there will be taxi's, long haul, etc.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by ajcp on Monday April 10, 2023 @04:51PM (#35517243)
I completely agree they can change our relationship with vehicles. Let's look beyond a subscription service though and think how it can be part of a stand-alone auto insurance policy, or offered by your apartment complex as part of your monthly rent, or the HOA and paid for as part of your dues the same as landscaping is. SDCs will be services that are offered as part of a larger relationship/service.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by isquaredr on Monday April 10, 2023 @05:28PM (#35517612)
Interesting take. Would my HOA be controlling utilization and maintenance? If the car has a flat tire or my neighbor monopolizes the usage, would the larger relationship/service be responsible for fixing the issue?
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by ajcp on Monday April 10, 2023 @05:48PM (#35517805)
Sure it would, just as any other service provided for by your condo/HOA fees or what have you. BTW I think having a HOA do anything beyond landscaping is probably more of a headache than it's worth, but still...

I think the possibility is more around SDCs becoming not simply a business to individual customer service or subscription, but rather SDCs being offered by organizations the individual customer is already a member of as part of that organizational offering. This can begin at large and wealthy retirement communities first (like Sun City Grand in Phoenix), but there's no reason why it couldn't be implemented elsewhere or why an organization that is already setup to handle customer and vehicle relationships can't offer it as well. Think AARP or your auto insurance company.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by adrr on Monday April 10, 2023 @05:03PM (#35517393)
If cars could talk to each other you'll get better utilization of the road because you could cut follow distance to a few feet.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by isquaredr on Monday April 10, 2023 @05:17PM (#35517503)
Sounds good in theory. I’m not optimistic about all the car makers cooperating on an industry standard, though. Plus the failure scenario seems pretty catastrophic to overall throughput. I hope some bright thinker figures those problems out; it does seem like a great opportunity
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by tshaddox on Monday April 10, 2023 @06:20PM (#35518093)
It doesn't seem like you'd need an "industry standard" beyond the actual rules of the road. In the same way that normal human-operated cars with better visibility can change lanes on the highway more safely and efficiently, any improvements in sensor ability, reaction times, etc. in self-driving cars (and even automatic safety features for human-operated cars) should make traffic safer and more efficient.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by ntr-- on Monday April 10, 2023 @10:56PM (#35520194)
what do the actual rules of the road say the braking point should be for an 8 person minivan with 5 passengers in dry weather? what about 8 passengers in the wet at night with ice on the roads?

old argument i know, but if a human gets that wrong and plows a pedestrian they wear the consequences, will an auto manufacturer do the same?

my guess is no, and the result of that is that even if we can get a majority of cars to be self driving they are probably not going to be pushing the limits of road capacity any time soon like GP suggests, more likely they will continue to drive super conservatively and fail fast like the videos in the linked article.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by Gordonjcp on Monday April 10, 2023 @06:29PM (#35518167)
No, because physics is not affected.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by adrr on Monday April 10, 2023 @10:36PM (#35520065)
Instant reaction time to what the car is doing in front of you. What physics are you talking about?
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by kryptiskt on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @05:33AM (#35522774)
Say the car in front of you runs into a stationary object, or something travelling the other way. Instant reaction time wont help as there is no way to decelerate as fast as a colliding car.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by adrr on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @11:02AM (#35526143)
Stationary object? Like a tree or a light pole?
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by Gordonjcp on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @11:27AM (#35526488)
More like a Tesla that randomly freaks out and emergency brakes to a dead stop in the middle of 70mph traffic for absolutely no reason at all.

As happens surprisingly frequently.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by adrr on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @11:58AM (#35527023)
Wouldn't the car in front detect the stopped tesla, the lead car would hit the brakes and the cars behind it would hit their brakes at the exact same time?
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by Gordonjcp on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @04:02PM (#35530704)
I'm not convinced it would detect it significantly faster than a human.

We are surprisingly fast, and the slow part is that we have to perceive that the thing in the road is no longer moving past the landmarks in the road.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by adrr on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @04:39PM (#35531229)
Assuming most cars have similar stopping distances. There would be no rear end collisions if we had instant reaction time to cars stopping in front us. Rear end collision is the most common collision and attributed to follow distances. Standard safe follow distance is 3 seconds. Standard reaction time is 1 second which means at 60mph you travel 88 ft. Most modern cars can stop from 60mph around 150ft.

https://www.qld.gov.au/transport/safety/road-safety/driving-...

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by Gordonjcp on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @07:09AM (#35523424)
Reaction time isn't really significant.

The variation in brake performance between vehicles will more than outweigh the effects of reaction time.

My old Citroën CX will easily outbrake a Tesla. If you are driving too close, even if the Tesla could brake at the same instant as I do, it will still hit me.

How long is it going to take to communicate between cars? How do you see that communication working? How will it respond to interference and packet loss?

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by adrr on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @02:24PM (#35529126)
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by Gordonjcp on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @04:03PM (#35530721)
Which just proves my point. Shaving 1% off the total stopping distance by making it react a little quicker isn't going to help.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by adrr on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @04:35PM (#35531183)
You mean 1 second which at 60mph is 88 feet. Tesla stopping distance at 60mph is 150 ft for comparison.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by SergeAx on Monday April 10, 2023 @05:59PM (#35517903)
On the other hand, we will see a sharp decline in human-driven cars on the streets. Who would do it themself anyway? At every moment we will have on the streets exactly the number of cars to serve current demand. They will not clog curb parking places - there's no point for driverless car just to stay there for nothing. They will not roam free - there's no point for that too. They will stay in the cheapest, ergo most inaccessible for humans places waiting for orders.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by elif on Monday April 10, 2023 @06:02PM (#35517928)
Actually my experience with self driving cars is the exact opposite.

After giving control over to an AI, suddenly I don't care at all about saving 3 minutes by picking the perfect lane, getting the best spot on every merge, maxing out the speed limit threshold where the local police will pull me over.

That kind of gamification with no tangible reward actually generates the anxiety. When you're no longer the player, there's no more anxiety about those weird time optimizations.

If streets are "clogged" it saves me a few pennies and gives me less reason to worry about a human cutting across to risk my life for no reason. It's actually kinda relaxing.

But you are wrong about one thing: AI have a fear of death. Every aspect of their training is hyper focused on a paranoid level of death avoidance.

When I picked up my father from the airport last month, I did your worst nightmare, my car circled the terminal for about an hour while I jammed out to progressive rock. 90% of the time I was in bumper to bumper on a closed access road with no entrance or exit. From a traffic perspective it was irrelevant whether I was there or not. On the 10% when I reached the terminal on the loop, surprise, I was blocked by loading cars in front of me... The same blockage the car behind me would face.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by Gordonjcp on Monday April 10, 2023 @06:29PM (#35518162)
Why can't you just drive like that yourself?
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by rodgerd on Monday April 10, 2023 @06:23PM (#35518108)
> Anyone ever think about what a nightmare driverless cars will be if they actually work?

The scenario you outline was part of Mega-City One's landscape in the 2000AD/Judge Dredd comics: cars on the road all day every day, with people living out of their perpetually moving RVs; something similar was depicted for Termight in the Nemesis the Warlock series.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by rtsao on Monday April 10, 2023 @06:26PM (#35518127)
I recall many years ago Jonathan Hall (economist at Uber) describing a "traffic apocalypse" caused by empty self-driving cars flooding city streets. I think this scenario was discussed as an argument for congestion pricing, serving as a vital solution to the tragedy of the commons exacerbated by self-driving cars.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by prawn on Monday April 10, 2023 @06:40PM (#35518258)
I've never forgotten a Hacker News comment about the same idea - might have predated Uber even. If parking costs increase, and self-driving cars can recharge cheaply, then we'll see them slowly navigating streets en masse while waiting for their next gigs. Like a molasses taxi rank oozing around with no urgency.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by medellin on Monday April 10, 2023 @06:59PM (#35518427)
I already had this experience where i had to wait 30 minutes for someone to come pickup a car. Driving it around was cheaper than parking it for 30 minutes
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by Firmwarrior on Monday April 10, 2023 @11:02PM (#35520234)
haha, I experienced this myself. My friend fell on some hard times, and it was actually a net financial gain for me to have him sleep on my couch and pay for his food, since he'd drive me to/pick me up from work in downtown Seattle and save me $30/day on parking (or 60+ minutes a day in crappy bus commuting)
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by kiliantics on Monday April 10, 2023 @08:20PM (#35519107)
As someone who mostly cycles to get around the city, I would love this situation. I could get around everywhere so quickly between all the car-tar without the fear of being killed by a careless human driver. But if this thought experiment teaches anything, it's that we should give public pathways over to non-car users way before we ever get to this stage. We've already gone way too far out of our way for cars. Make most roads bike/train/tram only and save one or two lanes max for delivery trucks and maybe buses.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by lotsoweiners on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @02:11AM (#35521440)
Not gonna happen...next idea?
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by tomcam on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @03:11AM (#35521832)
I’m going to call my 60s cover band Molasses Taxi Rank
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by prawn on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @03:13AM (#35521849)
Liner notes credit please. (Are there still liner notes?)
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by thedrbrian on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @03:35AM (#35521994)
The best I can do is an ID3v2 mention.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by tomcam on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @03:38PM (#35530344)
Sold
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by tomcam on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @07:04AM (#35523387)
We’ll do a vinyl release as a tribute to your nominal brilliance
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by Disruptive_Dave on Monday April 10, 2023 @07:51PM (#35518877)
HOV lanes for 1+ passenger cars.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by chongli on Monday April 10, 2023 @10:37PM (#35520076)
traffic apocalypse

I think this would ultimately be for the best. If the streets clogged up so severely with traffic then the value of owning a car would drop precipitously. Even if car owners lobbied successfully to widen all the streets the traffic would just expand to fill the available capacity.

People would finally be forced to seek alternatives!

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by pigsty on Monday April 10, 2023 @11:32PM (#35520450)
One thing I’ve learned is that unless the option absolutely disappears, people usually won’t search for alternatives when something goes to absolute shit. They’ll just complain and accept it.

It’s more likely that roads will be widened and traffic will grow to meet that supply than it is that cars start to go away. Cars only go away when governments announce near immediate bans.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by petre on Monday April 10, 2023 @11:56PM (#35520622)
Or they'll vote the driverless vehicles out of their city like the Parisians did with the e-scooters.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by Salgat on Monday April 10, 2023 @10:58PM (#35520205)
At the same time you'll have a dramatic drop in car ownership (since it'll be far cheaper to be taxied), meaning less waste overall as each car is fully utilized for potentially dozens of people a day, rather than sitting on a concrete pad 20+ hours a day doing nothing but aging.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by nytesky on Wednesday April 12, 2023 @08:05AM (#35538315)
I think people are too optimistic about the personal car as taxi approach. For anyone with families, I’ll have car seats installed, often you have personal items which I guess I would have to remember to always lock in the trunk. You will have passengers make a mess in your car, smoke and vape, even have sex (no driver!), and then I’ll pick up my kids and take them to soccer on same seat?
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by Salgat on Sunday April 16, 2023 @11:33AM (#35590862)
If most cars on the road are taxis, this means a few things. 1) It'll be much cheaper than owning a car. 2) There will always be a car within a minute or two to pick you up when you're ready. 3) There will be cars of every configuration available, including ones with car seats for kids (although it's not a huge deal, my twin's car seats take less than a minute to install). 4) These cars will be checked daily, and if you do happen to get a dirty car, you can just report it and get another one in the next few minutes. They'll likely have cameras in the cars that will know if someones smoking or having sex in there, so not many folks will do it if they don't want to pay a huge fee or get banned from the service.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by q7xvh97o2pDhNrh on Monday April 10, 2023 @06:41PM (#35518268)
> Imagine if the max amount of driving a human can endure is removed entirely as a final constraint on the total utilization rate of this infrastructure and is replaced with a relentless driving machine that never tires or gets frustrated and has no fear of death.

Sure!

An entire class of accidents and injuries will be entirely gone, saving countless lives. Insurance will get cheaper for everyone. Cities will be able to adapt and grow more quickly, since traffic management can finally happen in realtime and at scale. Pollution will plummet.

Cars can get smaller and smaller, focusing only on having a safe space for passengers and eliminating all the extra "driver" nonsense. With so many cars on the road, you'd always be able to catch a ride, anywhere, anytime.

Each car could have a delicious sandwich compartment, so that it's always doing double-duty for carrying both passengers and sandwiches. (Every car would have a couple drones it could dispatch to pick up and deliver sandwiches, so that passenger trips can go on uninterrupted.)

People will forget how to drive entirely, of course, so there will be no going back. The whole thing will feed on itself, and we'll enter a golden era of cheap transportation and ever-faster sandwich delivery.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by johnnymorgan on Monday April 10, 2023 @07:08PM (#35518511)
Ok you lost me at the first part but then came in for the win with the sandwich compartment and drone delivery.

I for one welcome our autonomous sandwich delivery overlords.

Joking aside I'm more curious on the negative aspect of self driving vehicles as I'm not entirely convinced they will explode into the market quite the way it's been pitched.

In the long run however you can't ignore the productivity increases and the cultural changes that will come with it being a net positive.

Governance and ownership is the sticky point for me.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by ramblenode on Monday April 10, 2023 @07:21PM (#35518629)
There may be sandwiches but there will definitely be ads.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by thegabriele on Monday April 10, 2023 @06:48PM (#35518330)
Surely all these points are food for thoughts, but it seems that in this scenario we solved the energy cost/production problem first
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by Jeff_Brown on Monday April 10, 2023 @06:51PM (#35518361)
Easy to solve: Price time on the road quadratically.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by WalterBright on Monday April 10, 2023 @07:16PM (#35518586)
> and is replaced with a relentless driving machine that never tires or gets frustrated and has no fear of death.

Listen, and understand! That relentless driving machine is out there! It can't be bargained with. It can't be reasoned with. It doesn't feel pity, or remorse, or fear. And it absolutely will not stop... ever, until you are dead!

FTFY

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by robomartin on Monday April 10, 2023 @07:18PM (#35518602)
> Anyone ever think about what a nightmare driverless cars will be if they actually work?

Actually, yes. However, my take is a bit different from yours.

The future driverless car will not at all look like a Tesla.

It will be a moving office or comfortable room for family trips. This does not mean it has to be massive. Something of the size of a modern minivan could be fantastic if you did not have to worry about driving at all.

In other words, I actually see future driverless cars giving us more time rather than taking it away by being stuck on traffic paying attention to stay in a lane, press the brake or accelerator.

As for people forgetting how to drive. Well, maybe in one or two more generations?

Nobody really likes driving. People either need to go from point A to point B or want to (vacations, eating out, etc.). I enjoy driving, not on the street, on the race track. I do that with some frequency. Driving on the street is boring, dangerous, time consuming and stressful. I hate that kind of driving. I can't wait until I don't have to do it any more.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by NikolaNovak on Monday April 10, 2023 @07:19PM (#35518607)
Not to say I'm a current enthusiast of self driving cars, but I assume many of the issues you outlined would get better rather than worse. Ownership of car will become continually less rational with hyper effective rented transport. With fewer cars overall parking should be much better especially on busy areas. Cars of the far off future may be more predictable and thus more rational when traffic increases. Networked cars open up a lot of possibilities.

None of this is coming soon as far as I'm aware mind you. I just don't think the end game of self driving vehicle is bleak - just the long mid game :)

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by rightbyte on Monday April 10, 2023 @07:44PM (#35518821)
> Ownership of car will become continually less rational with hyper effective rented transport.

Why? Attrition on a car is mainly miles based. Sharing a car won't make it last more miles. Not accounting for vandalism.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by Gigachad on Monday April 10, 2023 @09:12PM (#35519426)
Storage of cars is extremely expensive
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by NikolaNovak on Monday April 10, 2023 @09:32PM (#35519609)
I love cars and I love driving them (I used to take mine rallying and on the track etc).

But even today, even in north America, they're barely rational. Most people don't mentally add up the purchase price plus insurance plus gas plus maintenance etc. And the inconvenience of garage and parking and clearing driveway and snow etc etc.

The reason we have them is convenience. Public transit in North America with our huge suburbs is on average crap.

I firmly believe that for modern generation, car is increasingly a liability not pleasure. So if we / they can exchange it for a self riding car that magically shows up when needed but also magically buggers off when not, we / they will.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by cmsj on Monday April 10, 2023 @07:30PM (#35518707)
What I'm hearing is that I should do a self-driving startup whose fleet heads out in the morning to take all of the prime parking spots in the city and then have an app for people to bid in auctions for access to the spaces come prime shopping/restaurant/bar hours!
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by bityard on Monday April 10, 2023 @09:05PM (#35519376)
Please sir, where do I send my money?
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by peterleiser on Monday April 10, 2023 @10:32PM (#35520039)
There were companies that enabled "selling" the parking space that you currently occupy, but cities successfully argued that on-street parking specifically (and city-owned parking generally) belongs to the city and these companies were issued cease and desist orders.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by mrshadowgoose on Monday April 10, 2023 @07:30PM (#35518715)
> Cars instructed to circle the block in areas with no parking clogging the streets. You'll need a self driving car yourself to even get a spot since you'll never defeat all the robot vultures.

Why do you think this would happen? Self-driving cars are poised to dramatically improve parking overall. One can be dropped off exactly at their destination, and the car can then go elsewhere. Even an elsewhere of "somewhere 5 minutes away" is a large amount of potential parking in a typical urban environment. Additionally, any existing parking lot that chooses to only accept self-driving vehicles instantly gets additional capacity: self-driving cars could cooperatively pack/unpack themselves into space efficient configurations.

And if your counter is "a minority of selfish entitled people", the answer to that is "laws and regulations". Self-driving cars will have to follow the laws of wherever they're driving. If your "circling the block" apocalypse comes to pass, the mitigation would literally be a law/regulation that self-driving cars would have to obey.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by hackernewds on Monday April 10, 2023 @07:40PM (#35518789)
also commercially it is not in the benefit of the car to waste fuel circling around, instead of parking
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by glaucon on Monday April 10, 2023 @07:43PM (#35518819)
Where I live the electricity costs of having an EV 'just drive around until I call you' would be an order of magnitude cheaper than paying for parking.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by chroma on Monday April 10, 2023 @08:38PM (#35519207)
Electricity isn't the only cost of operating an EV. There's wear and tear on the drivetrain, suspension, and tires. And every mile driven slightly increases the chance of a collision. That's why insurance companies charge more for vehicles that are driven more miles per year.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by iknowstuff on Monday April 10, 2023 @08:59PM (#35519343)
A natural consequence of this is congestion pricing like in London.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Congestion_pricing

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by bluGill on Monday April 10, 2023 @07:49PM (#35518867)
Maybe, but fuel is cheap and so many people will want their car to circle close instead of parking 5 minutes away and thus being 5 minutes away when they are done. Even if it is a longer time inside they will have the car circle starting ten minutes before they think they will be done.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by bmelton on Monday April 10, 2023 @08:54PM (#35519309)
I can't imagine why I wouldn't send it home to be useful for other family members, or just sublet its unproductive time as a way to earn its keep as a ride share driver.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by ntr-- on Monday April 10, 2023 @10:33PM (#35520047)
you are 30 minutes from home for a 15 minute appointment and do not like waiting for your car.

do you:

- send the car home

no, it would only get halfway home before the end of your appointment

- send it on a rideshare journey

let's say (conservatively, and according to some minimum regulations from the rideshare service) it gets assigned a job after 5 minutes to drive somebody 10 minutes away. it finishes its job at the same time as your appointment ends. you have to wait 10 minutes for it to return to you. again no.

- send it to a parking lot

assuming the parking lot is 5 minutes away and you can tell it to return 5m before your appointment ends this seems reasonable

- drive circles around your appointment

all the benefits of sending it to the parking lot but requires even less effort as you no longer have to remember to tell it your appointment is finishing.

now apply this logic to the general public. what is the most likely outcome?

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by haweemwho on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @05:12PM (#35531636)
Exactly. People are already occupying public resources for their private luxury (in the form of parking on public street in front of their house), nobody would think twice just letting the thing circle. Especially in places where parking costs money, which will then only be a thing for people who can't afford self-driving add-ons or need to charge the thing.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by ertian on Monday April 10, 2023 @08:08PM (#35519007)
Not to mention, if self-driving taxis were ubiquitous and cheap, people would be far less likely to take their own car downtown--or own a car at all. In retrospect, the idea that there's a car sitting idle in a parking spot right in the middle of downtown all day for nearly every person in the area will seem downright insane.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by haweemwho on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @05:08PM (#35531578)
Congratulations, you just reinvented public transit.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by mrshadowgoose on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @09:21PM (#35533887)
Not really. A lot of people simply don't want to commute in a space shared with others.

Cars are not going anywhere.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by haweemwho on Thursday April 13, 2023 @04:48PM (#35561860)
What is a street if not a space shared with others? Worse, everybody else on the street (pedestrians, cyclists, ...) who is sharing the street with your car is suffering from you using the car by taking up disproportionally much space, needing disproportionally much maintenance and causing disproportionally much noise.

Imagine an inner city without cars. Cities in which this is a reality are a bliss to be in. And people get in and out just fine.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by ertian on Wednesday April 12, 2023 @05:36PM (#35547331)
Well, first, mrshadowgoose has a point: I know a lot of people who would love to take a self-driving car but wouldn't got near a bus.

But also, while I'd love (love!) to see much better, European-style public transit in US cities, it would take a fantastic level of political will, lobbying, and pitching to even begin to happen. For all sorts of reasons, public transit is wildly unpopular in the US, and construction is wildly expensive.

But a company like Tesla could (if they could figure out the FSD part) just roll out self-driving taxis after a few legal tweaks. It's achievable in a reasonable timeframe (once the tech is in place).

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by haweemwho on Thursday April 13, 2023 @04:42PM (#35561776)
The total cost of driving around people individually in cars is substantially higher than the total cost for public transit with similar convenience and significantly higher throughput. (This is including upfront infrastructure investments and maintenance.)

Seems Americans are just too used to staring at a 2 ton steel can in front of them.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by xnx on Wednesday April 12, 2023 @06:23PM (#35547865)
> Congratulations, you just reinvented public transit.

Reinvented, but much better. It's the difference between Circuit-Switched vs. Packet-Switched in networking. Trains are extremely inefficient use of resources. They require a dedicated and very expensive path, cannot re-route around problems (e.g. broken tracks or obstructed tracks), and frequently travel at a fraction of their capacity. Properly sized and routed electric vehicles are much more efficient in terms of cost per mile, travel time, and almost any other metric.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by haweemwho on Thursday April 13, 2023 @04:46PM (#35561831)
Trains are also much safer, more energy efficient and have lower TCO than a car fleet with similar capacity.

> frequently travel at a fraction of their capacity.

The average occupancy of a car with 5 seats is only marginally above 1. So, 20-25%? The average occupancy of a European streetcar is far above that.

> Properly sized and routed electric vehicles are much more efficient in terms of cost per mile, travel time, and almost any other metric.

Just as much as you can optimize those factors in electric cars can you optimize them in trains/trams/buses/...

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by gonzo41 on Monday April 10, 2023 @08:28PM (#35519160)
just imagine when someone's driverless car get's into an accident 20 miles away from it's owner whilst it was looking for a park.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by mrshadowgoose on Monday April 10, 2023 @09:05PM (#35519373)
And? What exactly is the severe implication here? A PMV does not have 100% uptime in any case, self-driving or not.

If the concept of a remote accident is so appalling to you...just don't get a self-driving vehicle. But other car users are capable of processing statistical risk non-emotionally, and they will get to enjoy stress-free parking once these vehicles become available.

Anyway, in all likelihood, self-driving cars will result in a large pivot away from car ownership. The impact of "your car" being involved in a remote accident becomes moot if it's not even your car.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by kevin_thibedeau on Monday April 10, 2023 @08:43PM (#35519244)
> Why do you think this would happen?

It was already starting to happen in NYC with Uber's exponential growth before they capped the number of cars permitted. They were a year away from carmageddon.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by mbesto on Monday April 10, 2023 @08:59PM (#35519342)
> Self-driving cars are poised to dramatically improve parking overall.

And interestingly, all of the parking lots in a city, in theory, will be obsolete, opening a whole bunch of opportunities for new urban design. The idea behind self-driving cars is not to own the car, but to rent it...which is why some people are super bullish in the long term on Uber.

The cutover to autonomous cars will be a huge PITA however, and I think this is really what the OP is getting at.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by zamnos on Monday April 10, 2023 @09:45PM (#35519685)
Where are you going to go that's five minutes away though? if you're in the inner city, like downtown Manhattan, it's all urban so it's not like there's anywhere to go.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by schiffern on Monday April 10, 2023 @11:11PM (#35520297)
>self-driving cars could cooperatively pack/unpack themselves into space efficient configurations.

I've had this same thought, but haven't seen it discussed much.

Parking lots essentially switch from random access (which requires expensive unoccupied 'lanes') into a slowly snaking space-filling curve. Cars can crawl slowly from entrance to exit, moving like water through a pipe. The paths can even branch and merge to make efficient use of the entire surface area.

If you also want to charge the cars stored in the parking lot, your solutions fall into two broad categories:

1.) Arrange the parking lot with rows of chargers that automatically plug in. Cars choose the appropriate row based on state-of-charge, twith he algorithm making sure the entire row finishing charging at roughly the same time. This minimizes unnecessary disconnect/move forward/reconnect cycles. Or,

2.) put wireless charging under the parking lot. This would be a lot more feasible than electrifying large swaths of highway.

Personally I still prefer option 1, because the peak charging speeds can be much greater.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by haweemwho on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @05:10PM (#35531610)
> Parking lots essentially switch from random access (which requires expensive unoccupied 'lanes') into a slowly snaking space-filling curve.

Why would they? You still need to get the car to unpark itself when the owner needs it?

Oh, you mean everybody shares cars with everybody? What about letting sections of that "snake" just drive around, stopping at different spots and let people enter and leave? And perhaps let them walk around inside? Congratulations, you've just re-invented public transit.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by haweemwho on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @05:07PM (#35531573)
> self-driving cars could cooperatively pack/unpack themselves

This is unlikely to ever happen. Even in the human-driver world, there would be huge potential to have cars communicate directly with each other. Never materialized.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by shahbaby on Monday April 10, 2023 @07:55PM (#35518914)
I'd love to see a black mirror episode on this.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by dgunay on Monday April 10, 2023 @08:38PM (#35519216)
I think it's important to realize that part of the reason self driving cars are so hard is because there is a necessary period of coexistence with human drivers.

In your hypothetical future, where no humans manually drive anymore, it opens up the possibility of completely redesigning our vehicle infrastructure without having to worry about the training and compliance of a mixed human/AI population on the road.

My optimistic hope is that with fully automated vehicles, mass transit wins out on sheer efficiency in order to negate the wasteful deadheading inherent in personal vehicles.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by chongli on Monday April 10, 2023 @10:24PM (#35519988)
Even in that hypothetical future the cars would still have to deal with pedestrians, road workers, construction, weather, road damage, flooding, and many other random situations that are much more complicated than just staying in your lane and maintaining a two car lengths gap from the car in front.

How does a self driving car deal with a blizzard with white-out conditions or a complete loss of traction due to ice? Yes, humans get into a lot of accidents in these conditions but as a percentage of the time the rate is still remarkably low.

If you want to eliminate large classes of those adverse situations then the best approach we have right now is to switch to rail transport. Public transit is truly the way to go!

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @01:00AM (#35521038)
Those policepersons randomly waving hands and emitting incomprehensible shouts on Manhattan crossroads ... AI will replace openai CEO before it can handle that.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by red-iron-pine on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @11:59AM (#35527033)
they're due to be replaced: huge capital drain on the company. Esp. for folk making decisions based on reports generated by (mostly) automated systems.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by jjulius on Monday April 10, 2023 @10:30PM (#35520024)
>... completely redesigning our vehicle infrastructure...

The eternal pessimist within me looks at how difficult it is to get anything with infrastructure accomplished, both at a reasonable pace and reasonable cost, in the US and can't help but expect this sort of thing to not play out as wonderfully as that sounds.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by stouset on Monday April 10, 2023 @10:44PM (#35520117)
You are completely ignoring the existence of pedestrians, bicycles, animals, construction, fallen trees, rain, snow, ice, and on and on and on.

We are nowhere near a future where cars exist in hermetically sealed tubes, completely walled off from the rest of existence.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by Turskarama on Monday April 10, 2023 @11:16PM (#35520327)
With the rate AI has improved over just the last year, I expect a lot of these problems to go from "impossible to solve" to "trivial" pretty quickly at some point within (pessimistically) the next 5 years.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by freeone3000 on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @06:42AM (#35523238)
We can, and have, crested such tubes at various times in the past. While expensive and require dedicated fixed routes, they can also move lots of people very quickly with nearly no congestion. A shame we can never build these anymore.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by stouset on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @12:52PM (#35527784)
Congratulations, you’ve reinvented a metro subway but with extra steps.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by ehnto on Monday April 10, 2023 @11:15PM (#35520323)
Well I hadn't yet thought about a possible outcome of driverless cars being better mass transit, that makes sense to me though. Once personal ownership is removed, and as atomicity is slowly reduced in exchange for efficiencies/cheaper rates to the customer, certaim areas would be analogous to mass transit.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by Schroedingersat on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @12:59AM (#35521032)
My brother in christ, it's called a driverless metro. It has existed for decades and isn't even slightly like a google owned surveillance drone "accidentally" causing delays for ts competition.

Excommunicating humans from all public space and drawing a moat of monopoly owned robo taxis around every block and every destination isn't a utopia, it's a complete nightmare.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by zsz on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @05:01AM (#35522581)
I remember the day when the car I'd been driving in college finally broke down sufficiently that the various repairs exceeded the value of the car. By that time, I'd been working for well over a year, and my 18 mile / 25 minute commute by car was, for that one day, affected as follows: 1. I was working at NCEP at the time, which was still located in Camp Springs (off 495 Branch Avenue exit 5), which was about a mile away from the last stop of the green line metro. Walking a mile isn't bad, but it does add about 15 minutes to the trip. 2. Because of the way the green line is set up, taking the metro from college park to branch ave is in effect a 45-60 minute ride (nearly from one end of the line to the other end, even though the distance around the beltway is only about 15 miles, or less; the problem is, the green line makes a huge detour through DC). 3. This was compounded by the fact that I had to get to the metro station in greenbelt first. I could either walk there, which would have taken about an hour, or I could ride a bus--which, as it turned out, took 50 minutes to traverse the same ~4 mile distance. Why? Because a) it had to worm its way through the labyrinthine neighborhood of Greenbelt, with very frequent stops.

In short, what took 25 minutes door to door on any given day before ended up taking ~two hours on the way to work. And for reasons I can no longer remember, getting back home ended up taking twenty minutes longer.

In other words, a total commute time of ~50 minutes (max) was turned into a ~4.5 hour commute due to having to rely on public transportation.

I also remember the specific reason why I went and bought a new car that same weekend (fortunately this happened on a Friday): it was the realization, upon arriving at home (after said ~2.5 hour commute), that I had forgotten my apartment keys at work.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by Schroedingersat on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @05:35AM (#35522777)
Bad busses that snake because there aren't enough routes and get stuck behind broken driverless cars are bad. This isn't news. Nor does it mean you shouldn't male a good transit system instead.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by haweemwho on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @05:06PM (#35531562)
That's not an inherent issue with public transit vs. individual transport though. You are comparing a really bad public transit implementation with a good implementation of individual transport. In many European cities, getting from A to B by public transit is much faster than by car since they don't focus so much on car infra, with all the downsides it brings (huge areas reserved for 10-lane highways and parking everywhere, air pollution, cost of owning/leasing/insuring, ...). If you get good public transit infra, life has one issue less to worry about.

It's pretty neat, I've moved to a European city recently myself and I'm slightly horrified at the prospect of moving back.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by ilyt on Wednesday April 12, 2023 @10:44AM (#35540575)
Good fucking luck making company A driverless cars communicate company B to cooperate...
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by TaylorAlexander on Monday April 10, 2023 @08:47PM (#35519268)
Something I’ve realized is that people have been saying this for a long time.

I used to write them off as over the top worries of uninformed people.

More recently as Elon Musk’s failure to deliver has been made clear, I’ve realized that I was myself taken in by a lot of hype.

Now when I go back and look at some of the cyclical content around self driving cars that has been around for years, I realize that a lot of it makes sense. The most damning criticism is that automobile-focused infrastructure sucks, and self driving cars won’t change that. We need to invest in traditional forms of transit. But in a world with cheap money (the last decade) and winner-take-all mentality, we get huge investment in individualized technology like self driving cars instead of better urban design and transport infrastructure.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by recursivecaveat on Monday April 10, 2023 @08:50PM (#35519289)
This was tested empirically by giving people access to a chauffeur temporarily. Not having to personally drive your car nearly doubles vehicle miles: http://www.joanwalker.com/uploads/3/6/9/5/3695513/mustapha_e... The study is a pretty small sample though, so I would take it with a grain of salt.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by iknowstuff on Monday April 10, 2023 @08:52PM (#35519296)
Eh you don't really see people commuting for 4h en masse in places with excellent trains. Also don't forget pedestrians exist
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by Gigachad on Monday April 10, 2023 @09:08PM (#35519395)
Self driving cars will completely collapse when pedestrians are factored in. You'll just walk out on the street and expect all the cars to stop. You don't do it now because someone inattentive could kill you. But when the tech works well, all car traffic will just be locked in stand still.

Hopefully we can use this moment to purge inner city areas of cars.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by psychomugs on Monday April 10, 2023 @09:13PM (#35519430)
This is Jevon's Paradox: increased efficiency increases usage.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by BurningFrog on Monday April 10, 2023 @09:51PM (#35519720)
The solution to this is the same as for human driven traffic:

Road Pricing

When a scare resource is given away for free, it becomes overused. Somehow we have a hard time seeing that for road access, but it's true anyway.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by tap-snap-or-nap on Monday April 10, 2023 @10:21PM (#35519958)
Corporations want all the rights an individual wants but no social, ethical and financial responsibility towards the humans they are meant to serve. It is time we rethink the concept of corporate personhood and legal protections an individual's get for acting via such entities, as they are getting compensated generously, the risks they take are miniscule to the entitlements they actually enjoy for their decisions and their consequences on the society.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by yanderekko on Monday April 10, 2023 @10:50PM (#35520152)
Corporate personhood really has nothing to do with the idea that scarce resources should be allocated via prices.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by Salgat on Monday April 10, 2023 @10:56PM (#35520192)
This isn't even necessary; between fuel and wear & tear on the vehicle, you'll be paying a small fortune for those daily 8 hour commutes.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by BurningFrog on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @12:41PM (#35527617)
Well, this ensures a non-zero price.

It's very unlikely that it happens to be the optimal price.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by explaininjs on Monday April 10, 2023 @10:48PM (#35520141)
Good news! Nobody is around to give you a hard time for chucking a brick through an unoccupied car's window.

(Group parking spots are typically better monitored than streets.)

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by Salgat on Monday April 10, 2023 @10:53PM (#35520171)
What will really happen is that ownership of vehicles will dramatically drop, as it's cheaper to simply rent an automated vehicle to get to your destination. This means a lot less waste, as you have far less vehicles sitting around being utilized maybe one or two hours a day. Folks aren't going to be interested in daily 8 hour drives if the wear and tear on the vehicle is going to force them to buy a new car every 3-5 years, on top of the fuel cost (even electricity). Same goes for if you're renting, since you won't want to pay a small fortune on your daily commute.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by harambae on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @09:43AM (#35525021)
This seems much closer to the reality. With LiDAR's, imaging radar's, a host of other sensors, more custom calibration and crazy high development costs, these autonomous vehicles are going to be the price of a Lamborghini for a long time. The idea that A/V's like this will clog streets across America because every worker will keep 2 in their garage is unlikely.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by anshumankmr on Monday April 10, 2023 @10:53PM (#35520173)
>replaced with a relentless driving machine that never tires or gets frustrated and has no fear of death.

Listen, and understand. That car is out there. It can’t be bargained with. It can’t be reasoned with. It doesn’t feel pity, or remorse, or fear. And it absolutely will not stop, ever, until you ̶a̶r̶e̶ ̶d̶e̶a̶d̶ reach your destination.

Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by kortilla on Monday April 10, 2023 @11:14PM (#35520314)
Congestion tax will solve that in a hurry
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by dusted on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @05:21AM (#35522694)
While I immensely enjoy driving "the human way", I think a total-ai roadsystem would be much more efficient and do away with the clogging.. A lot of clogging comes from humans being terrible at merging and driving in general.
Re:Dashcam Footage Shows Driverless Cars Clogging San Francisco by mrjin on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @09:07AM (#35524580)
If the current approach does not change, we'll never ever see that day.