Prior to the Industrial Revolution, there was relatively little policing of the natural environment. Aside from property laws, once you were out in nature you could basically do what you wanted. That worked tolerably well, because the scale of what a single person could do to that shared environment was relatively limited.
But with industrialization came massive force multipliers. A single company could cause absolutely devastating pollution to the environment. They could reap all of the rewards while foisting all of the externalities onto everyone else.
I believe we're now in an era where we have to think of the information environment that we live in as a precious commons shared by us all. We still absolutely must have freedom of speech—everyone should have an inalienable right to visit and participate in that information environment. At the same time, no one should have an unbounded right to cause large-scale pollution that environment in ways that harm others, which is exactly what disinformation is.
Good laws are rarely all or nothing. We need legislation that balances individual rights and collective rights.
And I have a driving licence, but have had no need to drive since moving to Berlin.
Sometimes these things can be done without internet, but not always, and the current trend is moving more things online-only.
That should be (more of) a cause for concern, imho.
https://www.dancarlin.com/product/hardcore-history-48-prophe...
Got a source for this?
Biden Campaign Disinformation Retrospective:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Biden_Campaign_Disinforma...
Disinformation at the Wikimedia Foundation:
https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=File:Disinformati...
These are public, as was the fact that there were multiple "Disinformation" hires. However, the meetings between the Wikimedia Foundation and the DHS specifically (as opposed to government agencies generally) were not mentioned in public communications, to my knowledge.
Embezzling information is a form of disinformation too.
This comment is a lot more pithy if you're just absolutely clueless about history...
> to cause large-scale pollution
Be Exxon and have expensive lawyers and you'll be fine.
https://darrp.noaa.gov/oil-spills/exxon-valdez
https://corporate.exxonmobil.com/News/Newsroom/News-releases...
p.s.
Looked at from another angle, I guess I'm proposing a thought experiment:
Imagine if only billionaires, celebrities, or "papers of record" were permitted to opine. Would we be discussing the problem of disinformation and how to institutionally address it using police powers?
What about a private sector solution?
We consider Michelin stars to be indicative of exceptional food. You can still get amazing food outside of their reviewed restaurants, but to be included in their list you need to pass a pretty thorough anonymous inspection over time.
It could be at an individual reporter level or a publication level and reviewed using a set of public, transparent criteria.
It would be far from perfect, but a bottom up review is definitely better than any top down censorship.
In general, even if it works, it risks becoming captured by the same interests as direct government censorship.
It already is.
>At least 51 senior officials worked with Facebook, Microsoft, Amazon, Apple or Google.
https://www.forbes.com/sites/ericfan/2022/03/07/beltway-big-...
It's also the wrong direction, as those are going from Big Tech to the government.
Although my comment may not be sufficient to prove anything, there's a lot to explore with this topic. For instance, here's an example in the other direction:
>more than 80 former Schumer staffers have gone on to subsequently work at the Big Tech firms. And Schumer's two daughters have also both worked directly for Big Tech—one for Amazon, and one for Facebook subsidiary Instagram.
https://www.newsweek.com/why-chuck-schumer-trying-stop-antit...
This article is only about the one direction, but you can be sure the revolving door goes both ways in big-tech. Just look at all the ex-NATO officers currently wor
While I believe the Democratic party has a lot less work to do than the Republican party in terms of reform, entrenching itself into a grass roots power exchange system is not a good look.
Back when I was at university, 18 years ago, they told me their filters were blocking a thousand messages per day per student.
At my current workplace, scammers guessed my email address in the first month.
"Aliases" is a solution to neither of these situations.
The study Republicans cite only displayed a bias in the default training of a new email account that had never trained the spam filter:
> "Shahzad said while the spam filters demonstrated political biases in their 'default behavior' with newly created accounts, the trend shifted dramatically once they simulated having users put in their preferences by marking some messages as spam and others as not," the Post article said. [1]
In other words, Republican email messages are more likely to use spammy phrases. Once a user starts marking any messages as "mark as spam" or "move to inbox", the bias dissipates.
This is not anywhere close to a good example of rent seeking.
[1] https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2022/10/republicans-sue-... (money shot in last 4 paragraphs)
This is a prime example of the private sector working, while Republicans crying fowl without knowing or caring that they are destroying the private sector solution.
Reminder that Google's response to the Republican claims is to RTFM when sending email marketing:
> Google denied the allegations, saying the spam filtering is based on actions taken by users. "As we have repeatedly said, we simply don't filter emails based on political affiliation," Google said in a statement provided to Ars. "Gmail's spam filters reflect users' actions. We provide training and guidelines to campaigns, we recently launched an FEC-approved pilot for political senders, and we continue to work to maximize email deliverability while minimizing unwanted spam." [1]
GMail isn't biased towards/away from Republicans. The users receiving those messages are training the spam filter to dislike their messages.
Getting regulators involved in this case is increasing nanny-state actions from the party that claims to hate the nanny-state.
[1] https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2022/10/republicans-sue-...
i think this highlights an interesting dynamic we’re seeing pretty often lately, groups are trying to force their beliefs and the recipients are saying “i’m not at all interested.”
it really seems reminiscent to what i’ve read about the 60s-90s religious groups where these groups were trying to force their personal religious beliefs onto society.
these groups are now suing to use government force to force companies to force their views onto all of us.
again:
> GMail isn't biased towards/away from Republicans. The users receiving those messages are training the spam filter to dislike their messages.
We have some prototypes: moderation systems (HN), peer review (science publications), Wikipedia, and perhaps even TikTok?
All of those systems have their virtues and problems.
big *anything* companies
The private sector has over and again shown that it is not the right lever to use when trying to solve public commons / ecological problems. The private sector is what gave us Dickensian hellholes full of child coal miners, the North Atlantic cod collapse, the Bhopal disaster, etc.
Private enterprises are structurally incentivized to externalize their costs in order to compete with other private enterprises. They are about as good at preserving a shared public space (physical, ecological, or informational) as any of the hippos are in Hungry Hungry Hippos.
I'm not anti-market in general. I think within the bounds of a well-structured regulated market, they have shown an incredible ability to increase efficiency and allow goods and labor to flow around and organize.
But that only works when the market participants are playing a game with rules and enforcement. If you just get a bunch of people together all trying to win without regulation, you get a quarterback carrying an assault rifle onto the field.
> We consider Michelin stars to be indicative of exceptional food.
Yes, but we do not rely on Michelin to make sure we don't each roaches or get food poisoning. We rely on regulation for that. Michelin ratings don't scale to the level needed for food safety. It's a niche, luxury product.
> It could be at an individual reporter level or a publication level and reviewed using a set of public, transparent criteria.
Reporting without enforcement is pointless. There were many many reports showing clearly that the North Atlantic cod population was going to collapse. The fisherman didn't care. They just wanted to get what they could out of the water for as long as they could.
Very few companies have been able to do this well and to scale to modern volumes. It’s too easy to do it cheaply and/or cave to commercial interests.
This is contradictory.
> We need legislation that balances individual rights and collective rights.
Maybe something like, you can't force someone to stop and pay attention to you if they don't want to? Or maybe letting people sue anyone who spreads damaging lies about them?
As to your second point, what about social networks not showing content that they believe to be objectionable. Does that count as “not forcing someone to stop and pay attention to you if they don’t want to?”
"Contradictory" presumes that a given property is Boolean and thus if it isn't one value, it must be the other.
Very few useful properties outside of the artificial worlds of logic and computing are Boolean. Most properties we are trying to design systems for out in the real world continuously varying and often multi-dimensional.
That's why optimizing them requires difficult trade-offs.
Especially with topics like the pandemic I see no authority that could help here and maybe that isn't so bad in the grand scheme of things.
"Information" and "misinformation" is not. The problem of "truth" is a philosophical one - how do you know that a particular claim is, indeed, true? Very few things in the world are directly provable. Even judges and juries get it wrong a lot, even when human lives - apparently the most valued things in society - are at stake.
Your model has a fatal flaw in its assumption that "the truth" is something obvious that we all agree upon. It's not - it's subjective and complicated.
We also have centuries (even millennia) of experience studying the truth. Yet the problem of truth is still as hard as always. I don't see how could any amount of experience solve such fundamental problems.
The problem is differentiating between "information" and "misinformation" - which is exactly the issue of truth and lies, isn't it?
Otherwise, if you ignore the truthfulness of information, and judge only by the effects, you're walking a slippery slope towards censoring truth because "it's harmful".
What about nutrient pollution? It requires a bit of philosophical nuance to conclude that nitrogen runoff, say, is a pollutant.
No, this is absolutely, deeply, profoundly false.
The entire history of the ecological movement is about conservationists working incredibly hard to create the notion of "pollution" as a concept, persuade people to believe it, build technology to detect it, generate data based on that, prove that it actually causes harm, and get people to care.
Really, please do learn more about the history of ecology and conservation and you will realize that the truth is anything but what you just said.
This seems more like a problem of convincing people of truth than problem of the contept of pollution. We have built technology to detect it - we have no such technology to detect truth. So pollution is measurable, truth is not.
> Really, please do learn more about the history of ecology and conservation and you will realize that the truth is anything but what you just said.
No, I don't think me having an epiphany of "Gasp! That person on the internet was RIGHT, I was completely WRONG! Pollution is a harder problem than truth!" is going to happen, no matter how much history of ecology I learn. It's a cute sentiment, though.
It was a major concern during the Constitutional Convention that:
> In Massts. it had been fully confirmed by experience that they are daily misled into the most baneful measures and opinions by the false reports circulated by designing men.
What's different is we're coming out of a time when a very small class of people had near-total functional control (or so they thought) over mainstream media, so there were huge swaths of people they really had no experience of. Now these people are @ing them on Twitter. And seeing these people out there makes them very, very uncomfortable.
The arguments you're making are not new arguments. They're the exact same arguments made by authoritarian regimes for millenia. From the article:
> In a March meeting, Laura Dehmlow, an FBI official, warned that the threat of subversive information on social media could undermine support for the U.S. government.
The problem is dissent. Much of the government is run and controlled by a class of people whose beliefs and values are becoming increasingly divorced from other segments of the population. And rather than re-adjusting their policies and goals in line with a democratic consensus, they want to stay their course and tighten control of speech and even thought in the name of social order and harmony. None of this is new at all.
200 years ago, everyone had about the same power to reach people. Oh, sure, it was easier the richer you were, but the difference was not dramatic and wealth inequality was not as dramatic a factor. Then in the 20th to early 21st centuries, broadcast television and media consolidation put a lot of one-way power into the hands of a very small set of hands. Now everyone is on the same playing field once again.
"These people" have brought us a mass convergence of social panics (some recent, others remixed):
- Anti-government zealotry (a la sovereign citizens, accelerationists, Ruby Ridge, Timothy McVeigh, Turner Diaries readers, Amon Bundy militia, 3 Percenters, Boogaloo Boys, neo-nazis)
- traditional family advocates / anti LGBTQ+
- sexual slavery/trafficking
- anti police-violence (both the pro-police and anti-police movements)
- local community book burning
- "abortion is genocide"
- "white genocide"
- 2020 election fraud
- anti "Jews control the [elite organization]" (millennias old)
- Pizzagate / adrenachrome / HollyWeird / "cabal of [elite people] who [some secret sex or slavery acts]" / QAnon
- Obama birtherism
- numerous things with the Clintons including "the Clinton Kill Count", "HER EMAILS!!!", and Benghazi
- numerous things with Donald Trump (too many to name)
- George Soros (theories about uses of dark money)
- The Koch brothers (theories about uses of dark money)Everyone is not on the same level now. Some are willing to make incredibly outlandish claims about stolen elections, and make personal threats to others, they are fine with that and they have enough power to make it hard to stop them or counter their reach.
Would client-side uBlock work?
ycombinator.com##:xpath(//a[@href="user?id=d23"]/parent::span[@class="comhead"]):style(background: linear-gradient(to right, darkorange, gold, #f6f6ef, 50%, #f6f6ef) !important)
If you want to gray out someone's comments, go up two more levels (/../..) in the xpath selector and try opacity: 20% for the style. Up one more level and visibility: collapse will cause them to disappear entirely (with some confusion because their child comments become children of something else).We already have laws which provide penalties for 8+ categories of illegal speech: {Obscenity, Fighting words, Defamation, Child pornography, Perjury, Blackmail, Incitement to imminent lawless action, True threats, fraud, conspiracy to commit a felony, etc}.
My assessment is the tools of the law (police departments, prosecutors, courts, and tort litigation) don't move at the scale of internet posters/commenters.
How long did it take for Alex Jones to build a theory about the Newtown School Shooting kids' parents/families/investigators? He probably just remixed some 4Chan theory in a few minutes then went onto his show unscripted.
How long (and how many resources) did it take the plaintiffs and their lawyers to gather evidence, do discovery, fight AJones's legal motions to delay the case? Literally years. The first case was finally settled 10 years after the shooting.
The law doesn't move fast enough because of the Bullshit Asymmetry Principle[1]. New laws are unlikely to solve that problem. IMHO only very consistent prosecution of people that do violate the law would dissuade law breakers.
I might agree that the arrest typically happens quickly (if it happens at all) in violent crimes, but it is extremely slow for white collar crimes.
[The Ministry of Truth] was startlingly different from any other object in sight. It was an enormous pyramidal structure of glittering white concrete, soaring up, terrace after terrace, 300 metres into the air. From where Winston stood it was just possible to read, picked out on its white face in elegant lettering, the three slogans of the Party:
WAR IS PEACE
FREEDOM IS SLAVERY
IGNORANCE IS STRENGTH
https://bookanalysis.com/1984/ministry-of-truth/You seem to be presupposing a 1984 outcome. Where is the evidence of that?
Evidence of what? Future outcomes?
From past research into the history of the Industrial Revolution where it comes to pollution, I've seen that there were many court cases brought up to oppose industrial pollution from factories on farmers and others' land. What happened in these cases is that contrary to all past legal precedent of landowners' property rights, the rulings went in favor of industry because it was seen to be in the collective good to see progress and that superseded the individual rights of the landowners to not have their land damaged by pollution.
The lesson I see from the Industrial Revolution isn't one of dangerous force multipliers, but that ignoring individual rights always comes back to bite you.
> We need legislation that balances individual rights and collective rights.
I think we all (or most of us) agree that individual rights exist.
But what is this collective rights you're mentioning? How are rights possessed by a group that aren't possessed by individuals? And if so, which rights and which groups?
And if collective rights exist and if they're ever in conflict with individual rights, why not just automatically side with the the smallest minority of all, the individual?
Do I have the right to kill all of the fish in a lake? Presumably not because there are other people who fish in that lake who would be harmed. If there happen to be no other people who want to fish in it right now do I then have the right? Why not? What individual right would I be stepping on?
One way to think of collective rights is that they are simply the rights of at least one individual we can reasonably assume does or will exist but cannot directly point to right now. Yes, the "reasonable assume" part requires judgement.
A simple answer about legality might be: "You can kill all of the fish in a lake that you own just as you can kill all of the fish in your fish tank, but not your neighbor's fish tank".
The legal cases in the Industrial Revolution that cropped up were the equivalent of a factory owner dumping poison in a farmer's lake and a judge merely saying to the farmer, "That's progress, sucks to be you". A strict adherence to property rights could have prevented many environmental problems.
PS: I'm obviously not familiar with your life experience and background, but for some reason it doesn't seem like you've encountered much in the way of libertarian style arguments on this before. I'm not here to do the proselytization thing (and I don't even think I'm a libertarian), but for the sake of enhancing your own arguments, I'd highly recommend looking into some libertarian-style environmentalist discussions on Reddit, looking into searches like "free-market environmentalism", or looking into libertarian-esque environmental think tanks like https://www.perc.org/ to gain a better understanding of what you're arguing against.
> One way to think of collective rights is that they are simply the rights of at least one individual we can reasonably assume does or will exist but cannot directly point to right now. Yes, the "reasonable assume" part requires judgement.
If you can come up with a better definition, I'd be open to hear it and noodle it over, but it sounds like there's no objective standard.
I'm sure your intentions are good here, but a hypothetical imaginary person's rights could always end up trumping an actual person's rights. Think about what happened in much of history. There was no objective code of laws and if there was some judge like a king or tribe leader or high priest or something, he just based his decisions on whatever he felt might have been reasonable. It was always seen as a great civilizational progress for humanity to try and codify all laws into a legal system that could be objectively understood. Not sure that what you're arguing for, based on how you described it, is anything but a step backwards.
It's subject to the biases of those who decide what is and isn't disinformation and its subject to changes in these biases over time. The damage it does is also hard to measure, especially when weighed against the damage caused by giving anyone or group of people the authority to decide what others can say and believe. It's easy to apply such ideas to obviously stupid conspiracy theories and fringe claims, but it's also very easy to start spreading the scope of what gets claimed as disinformation over time.
We could look at the entire pandemic as just one very evident example of these tendencies happening. We can also look at a number of authoritarian countries that have taken advantage of the western media obsession with "misinformation/disinformation" of the last few years and used it as a cover for passing their own clearly authoritarian speech-repressing laws in the name of "fighting misinformation". Freer countries are also never immune to going down the same road, their governments DO NOT need more tools for making it easier.
Truly bad information and grossly ignorant opinions are not only not anything new in all of human history, they are if anything today less extreme and less common than they've ever been. The proliferation of better thinking has moved best in exactly those countries where free speech has been best protected. It's in places where it has been repressed that the opposite tends to happen more easily.
It's sad to me that educated, intelligent people can use sophistry to try building moats around their personal biases in defense of speech controls and then claim that they're working towards the protection of people's minds, or any sort of common good. History has shown that such attempts at controlling speech almost invariably produce the opposite and that giving power over speech to any authority does so especially. Grotesque.
How is that any different from violence inspired by correct facts?
Following the logic you're laying out, I don't think it's the defense of truth you're advocating for; it's social harmony and stability. Basically the ideals favored in the Chinese model -- which censors true things and false things equally, depending on their social impact.
> Following the logic you're laying out, I don't think it's the defense of truth you're advocating for; it's social harmony and stability. Basically the ideals favored in the Chinese model -- which censors true things and false things equally, depending on their social impact.
This is a straw man. The original comment made no such argument. From the comment you're responding to:
> ... I desperately do not want further injury or violence to occur spurned by incorrect speech on the facts of reality.
Now, "truth" is an interesting thing. Ricky Gervais decided that the founders of Christianity were the lying liars, perhaps because their stories were not concretely, verifiably true in every historical detail, and therefore Ricky concluded that Christianity is a fabric of lies made up to make people feel better or control us or something.
Unfortunately it's Ricky who's got the short end of the Truth. Because Truth is more than just facts that are printed in a newspaper about the daily police blotter. Once you accept that there are higher, more important Truths than what you'll find in Wikipedia, we'll all be a lot better off. And we can better evaluate those lower-order facts and figures for what they really are.
The truth of Wikipedia is epistemic, as is the truth of theology, and as such it’s possible to evaluate them in different epistemic systems and draw different conclusions.
But capital-t Truth is capitalized to indicate that it is an ontological rather epistemological signifier, i.e. a name referring to a personal entity.
So technically speaking God is not a higher or lower truth, in the sense of the verity of a proposition, as you can’t compare a person with a fact.
If we start conflating epistemology with ontology, then... God help us! We’ll end up calling night day, and figuratively literally :)
Only if the action is justifiable in the first place. Let’s say someone wants to kill gay people (or people who are against vaccines, or people who want to raise taxes); does it really matter whether he kills an actual gay person or whether he kills a straight person who he mistakenly thinks is gay?
An adversarial person can flood people with rethoric of issues, corruption, crime, against all established political powers and institutions, and position themselves as the solution to all those ilks.
They can do that by flooding the public square of free opinions (the internet), with disinformation, fake data, lies of omissions, lack of contextualization, attacking all others personally, ridiculing them, etc.
All they have to do is put doubt in people's mind, keep the focus on others, and appeal to emotions of more and more people slowly.
They can do that because they are free to do it.
Then they can gain the political power from it, and slowly replace institutional power with loyalists working for them.
Once they've managed to get enough loyalist in place through this method, they can remove the right to free speech and take over as a fascist or dictator, or other more authoritarian measures.
Then they can continue the same speech they've always been pushing as propaganda, even denying the removal, bans, jailing, and all that of their opposition, and voila.
This is a pretty straightforward playbook. It's played out many times before.
You can call it a soft-coup:
> populists who seek the centralization of power but do so under the pretense of improving democracy
At least to me, it's very obvious our system is susceptible to this kind of adversarial attack. I don't know the solution, you don't want to prevent this attack but enable another one in doing so, but it's a huge threat vector and I'd hope we recognize it and do something to mitigate it.
>An adversarial person can flood people with rethoric of issues, corruption, crime, against all established political powers and institutions, and position themselves as the solution to all those ilks.
Appealing to emotions and attempting to label your opponents as corrupt and soft on crime is as old as politics itself. Convincing people to vote for you is not a soft-coup.
The platforms should be the ones who should decide how their algorithms promote information and shouldn't be pressured or controlled by whoever the current party is in power at that moment. The benchmark should be - would you want a Trump DHS with the power to change their censorship policies however they liked?
If online speech should be regulated by the government, pass legislation, don't backdoor it in a risky and unilateral manner through law enforcement.
From my understanding of political history, it used to be more common to talk about your policies and what you plan to do to win votes, and something related to Newt Gingrich started a new trend of being more on the attack/discrediting towards others, and it escalated from there.
But the important part isn't that piece, but what followed in what I said, it's the second stratagem to put loyalists in place that is the key to performing a soft-coup. Something you cannot do when moderates abound, it requires focusing on strong cult-like minority, that are really loyal, and slowly replacing key government roles with people you pick for their loyalty to you and not their qualifications.
It's that second part that's all the difference here.
> If online speech should be regulated by the government, pass legislation, don't backdoor it in a risky and unilateral manner through law enforcement.
I don't disagree, to be clear, I'm not saying this in favor of the DHS program, I don't know what the right defensive measures against this would be, that also wouldn't cause other bigger risks, but I think it's a vector for attack we currently are vulnerable too and I'd like to see it delt with.
Still, in any case, just to be extra clear, this isn't the issue I'm calling out, the adversarial attack is in-combination with the setting up of loyalists and the overthrow.
That a campaign can be won by crude measures of appeal to emotions and discrediting of your opponents is a bit sad, but it isn't as much a problem if it is just a method for election.
The problem I see is afterwards, are the checks in place to make sure that you cannot instate loyalists, and change the rules themselves to entrench yourself. It's this second part that is the soft-coup.
> They can do that by flooding the public square of free opinions (the internet), with disinformation, fake data, lies of omissions, lack of contextualization, attacking all others personally, ridiculing them, etc.
> They can do that because they are free to do it.
> Then they can gain the political power from it, and slowly replace institutional power with loyalists working for them.
> Once they've managed to get enough loyalist in place through this method, they can remove the right to free speech and take over as a fascist or dictator, or other more authoritarian measures.
This is more or less what the woke left has done to a lot of cultural institutions, with universities requiring political loyalty oaths. They just don't rely on a strongman to enforce their will the way populist movements do since wokeness is a distinctly professional-managerical class movement. But they've systematically taken control of most places of cultural power in the US.
Prudent actions are rooted in truth. Where there is not prudence there is no justice. Strength and action in the absence of justice is tyranny.
So that the harmony and stability of society can continue; and the truth of the matter can be adjudicated (defense or offense) in a thorough and thoughtful manner.
Why should we leave this battle to be taken up in the public square and threads like this?
If a pizza parlor was actually a pedo ring or a politician was actually sacrificing babies (both real examples of widely spread and believed misinfo right now) the violence induced against the perpetrators would be vigilantism but still considered morally defensible to most people due to failure to take action from the authorities.
It seem perfectly sensible to say that we apparently have a big problem due to people literally shooting up pizza parlors over disinformation, and that if someone was shooting up a pizza parlor over correct information the situation would be different and warrant different responses.
This is a perfect example of why this is a bad idea. Thank you for being the example. No one shot up a pizza parlor due to disinformation. A single concerned citizen brought a gun to a pizza shot to ascertain if there was a pedo ring being operated in it, after confirming there was not, he handed over his gun and not a single shot was fired.
But you honestly believe that to be the case, either because it benefits your argument or because someone lied to you or because you misinterpreted something you read. But you now believe this is the truth and everyone who disagrees with that "truth" should be censored.
This is a perfect example of disinformation. According to a contemporaneous report by the New York Times, the “concerned citizen” (which of course is a strange thing to call a criminal, but leaving that aside) illegally discharged an AR platform rifle inside the building, in order to destroy a lock.
Think about why a person would want you to believe that the shooter’s actions were perfectly normal or why they would want you to believe you misremembered the event.
> On December 4, 2016, Edgar Maddison Welch, a 28-year-old man from Salisbury, North Carolina, arrived at Comet Ping Pong and fired three shots from an AR-15 style rifle that struck the restaurant's walls, a desk, and a door.
There's a whole section on Wikipedia:
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pizzagate_conspiracy_theory
Your response is exactly why people are getting away with proposing draconian measures like this. You need to stop ingesting and spreading disinformation.
Surely even if you think that was fine, it would have been better than fine if the guy did that same thing to a pizzeria actually was a pedo ring? My comment was only saying that violence induced by outright lies has a relevant difference than violence which is a reaction to things that actually happened. Those seem clearly different even if you think censorship is not a viable or correct solution to "violence induced by misinfo".
To my knowledge it was never the Republican Party's position is that pizzeria was a pedophile ring was it? What should being of a particular political party have to do with it, that event was based on 100% confirmed fake news. There are no conservative or liberal policies seem involved in that story at all?
If it’s unrelated to your politics, yes. What’s the point of you stating your opinion otherwise? Do you realize this can be construed as interference? Would you like Americans commenting on your political issues?
For example, when Americans went nuts and tried to remove/deface historical statues, here in Finland local Leftist party's youth group suggested removing a statue of Mannerheim. Mannerheim was a war leader during the Finnish Civil War and led the Finnish defense against Russia during WW2.
He's literally one of the primary reasons those Leftist youth organization chucklefucks' parents didn't grow up behind the Iron Curtain, yet they wanted his statue removed. They definitely got the idea from the US.
I propose many people pretending to be arbiters of truth refuse to acklowledge facts and citations before them.
The mainstream media inspires wars... they don't get held to account do they? Why the sudden focus on arbitrary standards and funny how they always get applied to those that vary outside the approved overton window.
Pizzagate was not that: half the people repeating it were doing it as a meme, were in on the joke. People spread it even knowing it is not true.
I don't know what your point about journalists are: it's literally journalists deliberately spreading damaging misinfo like Alex Jones that need to be held accountable here. The DHS isn't able to go after grandma at Thanksgiving dinner for saying Clinton drinks baby blood.
But how come only the right needs to stop misinformation? Not a day goes by that an article from the left MSM comes out spouting wildly incorrect information (for instance, recently with the SIG SCX SPEAR). The left has increased division and hate in this country and now we’re seeing the result.
Wow this is scary, and kinda borderline needs to be reported to the FBI. Why is shooting up a pizza parlor acceptable when the information is “correct”? This is cult behavior.
I can empathize with the people who are deceived. The person who attacked Pelosi has now had his life ruined by lies; the lies induced him to commit violence against an innocent person. That's a thing that is sad on top of Mr. Pelosi who was almost murdered thanks to the lies. It is a pretty sad situation that people lying without consequences resulted in that outcome for both of them.
If he knew the truth and committed the crime then either 1) it was justified vigilantism or 2) it was a wrong action that he did of his own volition. Either way is is less bad than an wrong action that he was tricked into.
But how come you used an example from the left? How come you weren’t neutral and used an example from both sides? Now you looked biased and are guilty of spreading the same misinformation you’re claiming was spread in the Pelosi instance. You will cause violence against republicans with your comments, so you are now just as guilty.
Furthermore, speaking of misinformation, Pelosi’s attacker was a hardcore liberal, then suddenly became a hardcore Trumpist? And the evidence supporting this was viewed by a handful of police officers and we just have to trust them that someone can make this radical of a change from receiving misinformation? Parts of this story still don’t add up, and looks very convenient to happen right now before midterms. On top of an 82 year old surviving a hammer attack.
The flip side is much as Voltaire is supposed to have said: "Truly, whoever is able to make you absurd is able to make you unjust" or "Those who can make you believe absurdities can make you commit atrocities." Violence inspired by incorrect facts is violence automatically out of accord with worthwhile values.
If you are interested in accurate and correct information, it is procedurally discovered in a competitive information environment with multiple interested actors; not decreed by the President and his employees.
Now what do we do about Truth in this age of disestablishmentarianism? There is no one Religion of the State, and therefore there is no one Truth, there is a Plurality of Truths. That seems to present an existential problem for arbiters of Truth within the borders of the State, doesn't it.
Also you adjust the algorithms of your content feeds away from "maximize engagement," because that tends toward feeding people lots of videos that confirm their biases (no matter what those biases are).
That is not an arms race one wins.
Consider how education is done. We do it in classrooms, not in the street. Controlled environment where noise can be down-filtered.
How do we handle it if the problem is we need to educate everyone?
(I do agree with changing incentives off "maximize engagement". How, I do not know; it is the nature of capitalism in the interest economy to chase that brass ring.
May problems, no obvious solutions...)
This does not invalidate their point.
What you're pointing out are risks, are those risks worth being free?
Most people would say yes.
We had the luxury, for decades, of a de-facto mechanism of tamping the noise in the SNR culturally: the press was free, but only some people could afford it (and, at least over the airwaves, the press wasn't even technically free, as the AM / FM bands were considered shared natural resources that were parceled up by the FCC; break their rules, and your privilege of throwing signal through America's finite bandwidth was curtailed by law).
This is no longer the case. The modern, dominant, massively-distributed, massively-parallel peer-to-peer communications media doesn't follow any of those old rules. IP addresses are a constrained resource, but not enough to actually care. Anyone who can get a peering agreement with an internet carrier can communicate. As a result, we are freer than ever to speak our minds to every corner of the Earth at near lightspeed... But a lot of old assumptions that were implicitly baked into the question of how mass communication technology was used no longer apply.
It is not guaranteed that democratic society survives in this new normal. That is the interesting question. So when people assert, unexplored, that you just "inform" people by "adding signal," it's worth raising the question of how that signal cuts through the noise. In the old days, it'd cut through because various broadcast comms organs, from NBC down to individual stations, refused to carry the noise (either by their own standards or by implicit threat of loss of broadcast license). What makes it cut through now? It isn't whether it's true (we have observed how easily people can be deceived if someone spends enough money to culture-jam them with an alternate narrative of reality). It isn't whether it's important (we've observed people turn to triviality to disengage from painful reality going on outside their window).
We should think hard about these aspects of the new normal.
Since time immemorial people have wanted to control others and the primary way of doing so is violence and speech. This has ALWAYS been the case.
This is nothing more than yet another person wanting to control other people. Whoopdeedoo, welcome to the human condition.
What makes the US so unique is that its laws were put into place by those WHO WERE CONTROLLED and thus it was important to them that the usual mechanisms for control were subverted, hence free speech.
And it took a mere 200+ years, a blink of an eye, for society to transform to the point that the debates are now discussing doing away with free speech to better control the information people have access to.
Because ... you know ... literal democracy will fall if we don't give access to control mechanisms to control information that people can see. We'll paper over that democracy has become the strongest super power in the world with those very same tenets in place.
> What makes the US so unique is that its laws were put into place by those WHO WERE CONTROLLED
Americans (and I'm including myself here) tend to have a belief in exceptionalism that isn't well-grounded in their own history.
The first thing the Continental Army did after overthrowing the existing power structure was march on western Pennsylvania to put down a tax rebellion. We definitely traded one structure of large-scale control for another. And the nation that came out of that war, while "no longer controlled," still practiced slavery, a practice that was only ended by a second violent upheaval (resulting in a government far more federalized, i.e. centralized, than the one that it replaced... America had tried the experiment of state-level government self-determination and found it extremely wanting).
The United States is, depending on how you slice the concept, two major political-philosophical upheavals away from its roots (the Civil War and the New Deal). We are the same country in terms of continuity but not stasis. A 1776-era revolutionary wouldn't have recognized the America of 1960, let alone today.
> We'll paper over that democracy has become the strongest super power in the world with those very same tenets in place.
Hard disagree, because as I explained, freedom of the press was previously implicitly curtailed by cost of press, exclusivity, and limited reach. This new paradigm is new. It remains to be seen how democracy survives boiling in this pot. It may very well survive! I have not seen a strong argument that doesn't appeal to the past that the survival is likely, let alone guaranteed, and appeals to the past don't work because the Internet is a discontinuity; we have not communicated with each other in this way before.
You're wanting some extreme changes and arguing that democracy will fall otherwise.
good luck with that.
My perception is I'm observing extreme changes and hoping democracy does not fail. I grasp for reassurance and all people seem able to give me is "Well, it hasn't failed so far," which is the way people talked about housing prices before the crash.
I am guessing, since we are on HN and you hold this set of views, that you, like me, are part of the modern "clergy" class. Most of HN is, as well as much of silicon valley. The discourse has so far been controlled to your benefit by people who are your peers, and you are looking at the uncertain future of your own status and thinking that the entirety of democracy is falling. The reality is that our position as arbiters of speech is a distortion of the democratic system, and the immune system of democracy, speech, is coming to fix that.
This distortion affects your definition of "signal" and "noise." It is a lot easier for us to see things that benefit the cathedral as signal, and things that don't as noise.
Most people can tell the signal from the noise just fine. The problem is that for tech folks, the signal we want them to receive isn't always the signal that they want to receive. It often isn't noise or disinformation, just signal that is inconvenient for us.
If you look at provably false conspiracy theories (eg flat earth or chemtrails) and cults, there are very few people who believe them despite the noise level they put out and the amount that YouTube promotes them. In comparison, something like 70% people believe one or two conspiracy theories that are hard to disprove (eg things about the JFK assassination, aliens, or the CIA). It turns out that this is mostly harmless - the worst that happens is that it leads to distrust of government, which happens to have earned a lot of distrust.
If you look at other inconvenient things that big tech has suppressed, like the news about Hunter Biden's laptop, you will find that this is important signal that may have swung the election, not misinformation. The problem is that it would have swung the election the wrong way, so the cathedral (in this case, the FBI, Google, Facebook, and Twitter) kept it off the modern airwaves, proclaiming it to be "noise." Unfortunately, this was signal for most people - a later survey said that a decent fraction of Biden voters would have voted differently if they had known about it - and our collective filters caught it because it was inconvenient for us.
People are not bad critical thinkers: they can figure out what is relevant signal for them. After getting out of school, they understand how to think critically well enough to find the information that is relevant and not false. It just isn't leading them to the information that we think should be relevant to them.
Democracy is fine. In fact, it may be healthier when the censorship regime that we have collectively imposed is gone. The control we have over it is going away, and that is a good thing.
I don't know how to square that view with the observation that in the United States, an attack on Congress was perpetrated as a direct result of a runaway lie regarding the integrity of the election process. That's not free speech protecting democracy; that's a mob riled up by unchecked lies directly, physically attacking the mechanisms of their representative democracy.
Believe me, if I was observing free speech bringing truth to power and undermining, for example, the lobbying infrastructure, or the massive consolidation of power in megacorporations, I'd be thrilled. The cathedral needs to be corrected if not taken down. But that's not what I'm seeing. I think I'm mostly observing the rich and powerful using their ability to buy content on the various free channels of speech to rile mobs with lies. They're trying to cut the structural constraints on their piece of the cathedral and turn it into, if you will, a High Tower.
I'm not thinking about Biden's laptop; I agree with your assessment of that. The amplification of lies about the structure of US elections threatens to undermine the democratic process, and if it crumbles now it's most likely to be replaced with a fascist autocracy.
Censorious actions are, to my eye, attacks on individuals; especially when power is transferred/controlled/manipulated under the guise of "positive" group think.
Many cliches apply, sweeping under the rug, kicking the can down the road, turning a blind eye.
Well-intentioned good faith conversations about integrity, accountability and forthrightness are in vogue :)
That's not how humans treat argumentation
curiouser and curiouser
Is it? Are there more assaults in countries with more freedom of expression?
From what I understand, the US is fairly unique in history for pioneering peaceful transfer of power without violence.
Elections are a form of revolution each term.
In most of world history, this type of transfer of power was incredible bloody.
Also, from what I see on the news, the US isn't at all unique when it comes to political violence, and in general it's much more rare and less extreme than what I see elsewhere. It wasn't long ago that Ireland had horrific bloody political conflict, the likes of which we've never seen in this country other than the civil war.
The US inherited much of its political culture from that of England (not to say that the US didn't innovate heavily and positively on top of that heritage).
Would you say that England / the UK has had less of a history of peaceful transferring of power since American independence, or since the US Civil War?
You can say that the UK has faced violent opposition to its rule in Northern Ireland, but it would seem more reasonable to equate that to attacks like 9/11 in the US.
USA is actually doing pretty well at 246 years old. There are certainly monarchies that lived longer, but 246 is above average for regimes. For instance, the current french regime has only been around for 64 years[1]
These trade offs have no objectivity. They're done on a whim with the exact thinking that the OP is succumbing to.
So, anytime someone makes an argument for supression of speech "for the good of the people", I am instantly cynical of their motives or their gullibility or both.
This also happens because if there's an explicit or implicit ban on addressing those topics and retaining a place in polite society, then only people crazy enough to disregard polite society will address those topics.
What topics would those be?
Historically, I might suggest the song "God Save the Queen" by the Sex Pistols, or the book "Lady Chatterly's Lover", or poem "The Love That Dares to Speak Its Name", given the effect they had on "polite society".
I don’t see what is so hard to understand here. We already have the legal clarity , they just needs to be implemented diligently.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shouting_fire_in_a_crowded_the...
The history of Free Speech in the US is pretty interesting. The kinds of things that are acceptable today would get you thrown in prison 100 years ago (for example, handing out anti war pamphlets) and are more akin to the kinds of things Americans look down on other countries for criminalizing.
Edit: See here for a more nuanced perspective: https://www.mentalfloss.com/article/627134/is-it-illegal-to-...
Shouting “Bomb!” or “Gun!” in public would put you in a similar situation. In May 2018, for example, officials had to evacuate part of Daytona Beach International Airport after a man ran naked through the building screaming about a bomb in the women’s bathroom. There was no bomb, but he was charged with “false report of a bomb,” “criminal mischief,” and “exposure of sexual organs,” among other things. In that case, no self-respecting lawyer would advise him to claim his actions were protected by the First Amendment.
>The line between what is permissible and not subject to control and what may be made impermissible and subject to regulation is the line between ideas and overt acts.
>The example usually given by those who would punish speech is the case of one who falsely shouts fire in a crowded theatre.
>This is, however, a classic case where speech is brigaded with action. See Speiser v. Randall, 357 U.S. 513, 536—537, 78 S.Ct. 1332, 1346, 2 L.Ed.2d 1460 (Douglas, J., concurring.) They are indeed inseparable and a prosecution can be launched for the overt acts actually caused. Apart from rare instances of that kind, speech is, I think, immune from prosecution. Certainly there is no constitutional line between advocacy of abstract ideas as in Yates and advocacy of political action as in Scales. The quality of advocacy turns on the depth of the conviction; and government has no power to invade that sanctuary of belief and conscience.
In other words, the court rejected the applicability of the analogy to the case at hand. They didn’t draw the conclusion that deliberately causing stampedes in theaters is protected by the First Amendment.
https://scholarship.law.wm.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1...
The replacement standard instead excludes protection for speech that is both "directed to" and "likely to" "incite or produce imminent lawless action," and these things are construed quite narrowly.
So: it's a bad analogy that was never the actual legal test, doesn't match the current test, and references an overturned case. But that doesn't mean it's actually legal to knowingly falsely shout "fire" in a crowded theater intending to cause a panicked stampede (though note there's more detail about intent and knowledge given there, and there would be other questions).
To a certain extent, trying to stop people referencing this really doesn't matter, though. If you got all the country's internet commentators to talk about "incitement to imminent lawless action" instead, they'd be in all likelihood deploying that phrase in the same places they currently use "fire in a crowded theater" or "clear and present danger." Eliminating this one analogy isn't really going to move the needle on people's understanding of what the First Amendment protects, but the phrase is both enduringly popular and a bugbear of the kind of people who care about this stuff, so the arguments and corrections will continue.
If someone *falsely* yells FIRE without a real FIRE in a crowded town hall that causes a stampede resulting in death or injury - I guess it is ground for bringing criminal charges against the original yeller.
But my point is since it is clearly defined legally do we have to really over analyze it to the point of inducing paralysis?
What really caused conflicts and damage are the situations the "lies" cannot be falsified (just in current population due the the limit of intelligence, no necessary for smart people in future generations), and the yeller is not a typical liar but belong to a special specie (majority of politicians who have good skill in elections) that totally believe their lies so there's no legal ground base to charge them. There have been already a lot of damaging consequences and seems continue to have more because of this.
Do we have reverse yellers yelling "NO FIRE" to balance the ongoing damages? The are very few for some important issues. There's no way to counter balance.
Why? It's not because there are less people know the truth. In real world it's not a clear cut model that information can be passed back and forth independently between a yeller and audience. The misinformation exists because there are eager misinformation consumers. There are a very large portion of people need the yelling of "FIRE" and hence there are more "FIRE" yellers. This is another discrepancy between your model and real world.
- If it is damaging yet done repeatedly obviously it is wrong. Things may not be clear the first time but soon becomes clearer. And if the yeller claim to not know the consequences they better not say something until they collect and analyze more data.
Lies by governments amplified by mass media are always going to be way more damaging than lies by crackpots on social media.
Then read between the lines and recognize the public in general has moved away from recognition/acceptance of the rules as written and now all the mobs are demanding speech they don't like be restricted by powers on high.
Agreed that's unacceptable, but maybe we could criminalize aggravated assault instead? https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySectio...
Why is that? The intuitive answer is that the information we are operating on is not the cause of the attack. The idea that we need to police information to the point where crazy people do not get ideas is a nonstarter.
Presumably because you believe they are merely a thorn and not an existential threat.
I suspect many people might be willing to commit a felony if you could convince them they were, with certainty, saving their family, friends, and country.
I believe my prior comment stands perfectly fine on its own without your attempts to clarify it.
Your remark seems to hand-wave all responsibility onto "crazy people" (whoever those are) instead of admitting that there is a severe problem with how members of this country fail to communicate with each other. It's really important to talk about this issue. It matters for the future of this country, far more than just about anything else does.
It is the responsibility of the listener to police their own information intake. Anything else leads down a well greased slippery slope ending in the maws of dragons.
The solution to the misinformation is education, critical thinking, and depolarization; not criminalization. It's a slower process but it's the right one. The more a government gives up on educating and trusting the people it represents, and tends towards instead treating them like little children who can't possibly make decisions on their own, the more that population will be become just that— incapable of making decisions on their own. We don't want that to be the case; that's dangerous.
1.Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis signs a law punishing student 'indoctrination' at public universities and threatens budget cuts
https://www.businessinsider.com/desantis-signs-law-to-punish...
2. CRT taught in just one university course is a major talking point. Another attack on schools
Etc
1% of Harvard faculty identifies as conservative: https://www.thecrimson.com/article/2022/7/13/faculty-survey-...
77% of students say professors espouse liberal ideas: https://freebeacon.com/campus/campus-conformity-college-stud...
Other miscellaneous statistics: https://www.aei.org/articles/are-colleges-and-universities-t...
My own anecdote from my time as an undergrad at UConn: my ethics professor once said, verbatim, that anyone who supported a pro-life stance was, flat out, wrong. I watched conservative speakers come to campus and the associate vice president said that “even the thought of an individual coming to campus with [conservative views] can be concerning and even hurtful” [1]. This was after an “event review process” was stood up, ostensibly with the intent to moderate content that could be discussed at the university, following a right-wing speaker’s talk breaking out into violence after being called a Nazi and having his property stolen [2].
My own experience has been that “liberal indoctrination” correctly captures the magnitude of this effect.
1: https://www.dailywire.com/news/uconn-acts-uc-berkeley-offers...
2: https://www.cnn.com/2017/11/29/us/lucian-wintrich-uconn-spee...
Universities have always been hotbeds for change, research, vanguard and protest against the standard. I'm not surprised there's so little conservatism there; it's an environment that attracts open-mindedness, not people who shy away from deep analytical reconsideration. For the latter, there's churches.
Alternate explaination: being educated increases the probability you'll become liberal
2.Anecdotes have no meaningful value and even if it did prove it.
This is essentially conceding the point the above commenter is making: American universities influences graduates to become more liberal.
However, naravara started the comment with:
> What if bots and nations state actors can flood the platform…
Which is much easier to deal with.
Most platforms I think let you follow specific accounts, and noise from other accounts shouldn't matter (unless it's enough to DDOS the system).
When the other party is acting in bad faith all it takes is some money and time to subvert platforms with paid shills that all network with each other and mix disinfo into seemingly normal content streams. This allows the shills to build credibility.
Good luck dealing with that. You can reply with all the well-reasoned arguments you want but when 500 of the shill's friends bury your reply (and mass-report you) no one will see your message so correctness becomes a moot point... not that people have enough free time to read and consider every well-reasoned argument when they come across an issue to begin with. If you tried that you'd need more than 24 hours in a day.
Those who would give up essential liberty to purchase a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety.Would religion be policed for making unproven claims? Would there be any allies of political favorables who could correct the record with their version of the truth? Is inconvenient information disinformation, as in, will they define disinformation as any information disruptive to the status quo as able to be proven without revealing state secrets, classified information, or restricted media like the "collateral damage" video, whether true or false?
Despite CNN and MSNBC being broadcast in Russia and China, their news is all but forbidden in the US. How damaged and fragile is the US mindset that it can't exist in the presence of other ideas?
On another note, that's one for the warhawks and their pro-war lobby. Aid doesn't mean bandages and medicine, you know.
If the loved one of a politician was severely injured because of a drunk driver should alcohol be banned? What if the person injured isn't related to a politician?
I certainly don't trust governments, whether they lean left or right, as they all have heavy biases and big money influencing decision making.
It would certainly reduce the chance people would say unsubstantiated and harmful things if it was enforced.
Btw we aren't discussing what an unreasonable person might do with that information, just whether or not a reasonable person might believe what has been said or understand it a certain way.
We can definitely solve for the egregious cases though and we can solve those before getting too hung up on the tough ones in the middle.
And just to be clear. You are always permitted to say true things. It's only when you say false things that we need these curbs. What I'm really talking about is curbing "false speech".
Bad example. We do limit the consumption of Alcohol and also Driving because of the possibility of Drunk Drivers.
Or cars. Or roads. Or hammers. Or any other ingredient in the process.
Useful tools like speech and hammers are equally useful for anyone and for any purpose. Fire, electricity, sharp saw blades, the wheel, money, intelligence, good looks, encryption, math, can all be used for good or bad, and there is no way to change that and seperate the utility into only utility for good.
It's misguided to try to address the misuse of a tool by controlling the tool instead of the weilder.
It just becomes a little easier to pick on something like alcohol or guns because you can say they "obviously duh" aren't useful tools or necessities like vehicles or electricity, so it's ok to act like they are somehow less inanimate or neutral or useful than other random equally special purpose things, and easier to evoke emotional reactions about them whether from puritanism or fear, than say, paint thinner or construction tools. And most people will buy that more than any academic arguments, and numbers matter more than academic reason.
So we control speech. And on private platforms, which is all platforms, they can. And only the worst a*holes and the dopiest hippies complain about it.
I think the significance of the fact that it was a politician's relative is that it suggests that this is part of a larger pattern. I think it would be similar if you had a politician calling for violence against an ethnic group that resulted in actual violence; that seems like a good reason for restrictions to me.
Now, I am also a believer in your first point. The cure _must not_ be worse than the poison. And I don't know what the right solution is. But we need one because we are not equipped to deal with this. Just a couple days ago a single individual bought one of the biggest speech platforms in the world and proceeded to post a defamatory conspiracy theory from a "fake news" outlet about a political target. The way the world is set up right now I think things can really go sideways. And while I am sure most people here prides themselves on their ability to discern the truth, remember that the electorate is not comprised of hacker news users. Thanks
Why didn’t we have that conversation after the Dallas police shooting shortly after Obama talking about police violence? Or the mass riots spurred on by democrat politicians? Or the Jan 6th riots following trumps speech (actually, he got deplatformed everywhere following that). Or the congressional baseball shooting following Bernie Sander’s calling Republicans hateful for not passing healthcare bills?
Obviously this attack is unacceptable, but if these other instances didn’t move people to curtail speech, the fact that this relatively minor event does tells me this is more about pushing an agenda and putting politicians ahead of freedoms.
As far as I’m concerned in the conversation about the limits of free speech, Pelosi is nobody special. Would we curtail speech because some random person in Ohio got assaulted for saying mean words? Of course not, so why would we do it for some powerful politician, who’s used speech in just as inciting ways as well no less?
To put it plainly: should we curtail freedoms because somebody attacked Pelosi? The answer to that is the same as the answer to “should we curtail freedoms because speech makes people mad sometimes”. The way we’ve answered that as a society in all other instances is “no”, so the answer remains the same.
But in any case, we can't limit freedom of speech because of implications of "unreasonable" implications of speech. Simply saying you hate Pelosi, isn't grounds for any reasonable person to think you try to kill her with a hammer. But if someone said, "we need to kill her" then that is much more prosecutable IMO.
Unfortunately what probably works best to avoid these sorts of incidents is critical thinking and common sense. I do think the echo chambers on the internet create less of this - so these sorts of things will happen more frequently.
Would you be so kind as to elaborate which speech and which figures you believe are at fault?
Linux is not a cult. It's a holy war spreading across the Universe like unquenchable fire.
Conspiracy is already illegal, despite going against free speech, so making updates to conspiracy laws to handle these cases is the best path forward
People can speak up, but it turns out that there's now too much noise and nobody can distinguish the source of the speech, the context of the speech, the trustworthiness of the speech, and the occurrence of the speech (how many people are saying the same thing versus parroting what they were told).
Not only that, but the cost to speak is so low now, that bad actors have a field day, and I include bad faith people looking to just amass political fame, power, following, etc.
Mix that in with our new shortened attention span, and people no longer engage with the speech, instead it becomes like advertisement, if you've seen the same message a lot you'll subconsciously have taken it as a truth. It becomes which opinion have you seen most becomes your opinion, and everyone does this, so the truth becomes a matter of who can parrot their message as often, as loudly and to as many people.
This also means that catchy speech will win over non-catchy speech, because everything is more like a marketing game. Appealing to emotions is attention grabbing, controversy is attention grabbing, so all speech of that form becomes the winning speech in terms of getting viewer and heard.
That's why I think all reasonable people are doomed here, this mechanism of social conversation lends itself automatically to destabilizing opinions winning over stable reasonable but boring and not attention grabbing perspectives.
Before the internet, there were more filtering happening in a layered approach, publications and journalist were there to filter out the noise, the low quality, the unsubstantiated, the agenda driven, and all those.
Speaking up about injustices involved having to physically mobilize yourself to a public square, which takes a lot of effort from the speaker, again allowing a filtering out of bad actors and bad faith individual since the effort demanded had a cost, only people really motivated by great injustice would have the will to go through with protesting.
I don't think it was ideal before either, as publications as a filter had their own bias to what they'd filter out. But at least even what they let through, since there wasn't an abundance of it, the listeners could have a deeper think about it, and didn't believe it to be true just because they keep hearing about it over and over.
Hopefully we can find a way to improve on both. I think we need to put more contextualizing and filters over the internet speech, nothing that removes or bans speech, but allows to manage all the noise.
Algorithms are already in place doing this, except they filter based on corporate profit making, which often involves around engagement and attention grabbing. Again this is extra counterproductive, worse than a simple unfiltered approach with everything chronological.
I'm not sure how best to implement improvements, but I feel strongly it is needed, because even I can no longer make sense of all the noise in the internet, and it feels more and more like I actually can't tell what's real or not anymore, even though I'm in an ocean of information.
I just don't see any practical solution that doesn't involve some type of restriction on disinformation.
Debate is how you get educated. Nothing else can suffice.
I guess I just don't understand why saying "[individual X] is a criminal" is restricted but I can say "everyone in [group Y] is a criminal" without repercussion. Why does the broadening of the statement make it allowable? It seems just as easy to disprove and just as damaging to society.
What are we supposed to when this disinformation censorship is corrupted by such people?
Critical thinking skills should be taught and practiced at all levels of education. An online course available for everyone for free would nice too.
> what are we supposed to do for the next 30 or 40 years
Everything else we've been doing. Calling out bullshit when we see it, explaining why it's wrong and how it's being used to manipulate people.
> What are we supposed to do when this disinformation education is corrupted by people who themselves have already fallen victim to disinformation because they haven't been educated properly?
Isn't this is a risk with teaching anything anywhere? The good news is that it'll be a lot easier for students to catch issues with how they're being educated when they can think for themselves and are trained in how to catch bad arguments.
I do believe that free speech is so incredibly beneficial that it's always worth having, even if that means accepting cults, celebrities, politicians etc preying on the weak.
This sort of thing assumes that bad actors don't exist and will never get into power... only it turns out bad actors do exist and... gasp they already control many of the reins of power, why would you support giving ceding more control?
If they're that influential, then what chance do laws limiting free speech have at curtailing their efforts? The solution seems to be pass laws that only effect the average citizen and ignore the obvious differences in scale with these flagged "problem cases."
> the loved one of a politician was severely injured because of someone who believes the incorrect speech of influential figures
Is there actual evidence of that? I mean, which exact "influential figures" lead to this crime? What writing of theirs were the most provocative to this individual? What should we be considering when examining this situation? Is there anything other than vague accusations?
> So what's to be done about the actual, real harm being done, while also protecting free speech? I don't want to assume that assaulting people is just the cost of free speech.
It seems to me that's exactly what you're doing.. and you've not made the connection between free speech and generalized harm in anything but a casual way. This makes people exceptionally uneasy, you're suggesting that a defined right should be curtailed simply because there's an implication in one particular notable situation.
And why is this _one_ newsworthy situation being used to spark this debate? Doesn't this raise questions of inappropriate "influence" itself? Again, we know nothing about this individual, yet all kinds of motivations are being ascribed to his actions all in service of suggesting that "a little too much free speech" might be responsible here.
This entire line of thinking makes my uneasy.
Trust in the facts of reality can only really be established as a chain - this is how the sciences work. That’s why independent experimental verification of results is so important. In the information ecosystem, fact checkers perform this function. We should establish structural means of support for these functions.
At first glance, it looks like you've just re-defined the problem from "platforms should decide which posts are true" to "fact checkers should decide which posts are true", but actually I think you might be onto something.
Platforms could use their existing user-reporting features, and measures of audience size, to inform fact checkers about which posts are the most controversial; then different fact checkers could (reactively) investigate the claims and offer rulings that would appear as a banner over the relevant post.
The missing pieces of the puzzle are that individual users should be able to opt in to one or more fact checker, and platforms should give users a default set of fact checkers, and the fact checkers should be funded by a 1% tax on platforms' revenue (split in proportion to the popularity of those fact checkers among users).
This could actually be a valuable and viable system, and maybe the sciences could also benefit from a system like this for flagging suspect papers and paying for researchers to attempt to reproduce results. It could even be gamified, with researchers winning "points" for correctly guessing which studies have non-reproducible results (as long as these points didn't have financial incentives attached which could corrupt them).
To the former, I imagine this was brought up as an example. Whether you think it's the strongest example seems immaterial unless you're saying there is no example at all in the history of the world?
To the latter, that seems to be the exact purpose of courts and lawmaking, no? To take the murky uncertainty of life and create a reasonable line of evidence that binds two points together. That we, in American society, have decided not to draw the line between those two points to see if they intersect the same victim is our choice. Unless you believe no ones words are influential in any context?
So we're to argue with your imagination?
> Whether you think it's the strongest example seems immaterial unless you're saying there is no example at all in the history of the world?
I'm saying you're implying things without any proof. I think you should have proof before you consider depriving people of their rights.
> To the latter, that seems to be the exact purpose of courts and lawmaking, no?
Precisely. If you break the law, you are charged with a crime. If you were incited to do so, that person will be charged with a crime. So.. what reason is there to restrain free speech?
> Unless you believe no ones words are influential in any context?
I don't believe prior restraint will solve your problem, and other than these vague assertions, you've provided no concrete argument as to how they will.
To be clear, not my imagination as i'm not the original poster. Nor anyone's imagination since the act of violence did, in fact, occur. A poor choice of words, on my part.
And the open question, still, is "was the violence precipitated by too much free speech? Is there literally any evidence of that?"
This whole thread is based on this assumption, and people are happy to argue a point because they "imagine" the evidence for it exists. If this is actually the case, this is absolutely stunning.
And this would include those currently in power, no? Who want to further their ability to put their narrative of choice forward - regardless of how truthful - while suppressing any counter-narratives, even if true.
More speech.
"More speech" is too simplistic to work in the modern world.
As with all other laws, my personal preference is the maximum possible liberty that doesn't allow people the liberty to remove other people's liberty.
Unfortunately, that's a soundbite and not a well-defined policy position, and I don't know how to generate the latter from the former.
Trivially true, but this doesn't go deep enough. Changes that come about as a result of collective discussion and decision are of a different character than changes that are the predictable result of preexisting feedback loops. For example, once upon a time a single breadwinner on minimum wage could support a family. For some time after that was no longer true, two breadwinners on minimum wage could support a family. That's no longer the case now, but we never had big debate to decide that. It wasn't "disinformation" that caused our soaring inequality; indeed it could be argued that we would have noticed it happening had there been more information allowed to reach the public consciousness.
The USFCS (United States Fact Checking Service) has flagged this as malinformation, and limited your ability to comment for the next 72 hours.
If you believe this is in error, please win the next election, so that you gain control of the censorship bureau and show us how to do it right.
At a fundamental level, one must ask why people are attacking 5G towers, storming the Capitol, and calling for violence against politicians: they believe their voices are not being heard. Censorship and banishment to alt-tech platforms only reinforces that belief.
To use the words of Scalia in "R.A.V. v. City of St. Paul", I believe the government "has sufficient means at its disposal to prevent such behavior without adding the First Amendment to the fire" [2].
[1] - https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2021/oct/18/colin-powell...
[2] - [PDF] https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/505/377/case.pdf
There is a part of the US population that feels deprived of all but the last box currently: big tech censorship of their ideas, beliefs in a stolen election, and belief in a rigged justice system (thanks in no small part to Merrick Garland's actions). It doesn't matter if they are right. All that matters is how they feel about it. If you combine that with the rising cost of food and shelter, you get the recipe for a violent revolution.
"I think it's coming out" what does this mean? You've seen rumors and assume they are true or that evidence is coming soon?
I don't believe a motive has been established in the Paul Pelosi case?
https://www.foxnews.com/politics/paul-pelosi-attack-suspect-...
https://www.cbsnews.com/news/paul-pelosi-attack-suspect-targ...
Let alone the screaming that he was gonna smash Nancy's kneecaps, etc. How does that fit into the whole thing with the hitlist, do you think?
It was ridiculous on the face of it, the fact that the attacker bonked a hippie chick in SF and did some nudity stuff with her doesn't mean he wasn't a conservative attacking the targets that conservatives have railed against for a decade. He literally posted about the pizzagate hoax lol.
It was a ridiculous circumstantial theory spun by some conservative website to deflect blame for their violence as usual, and even Fox admits the guy had a list of targets to attack next.
Meanwhile it's literally a microcosm of the disinformation problem, you have people actually taking this whole idea seriously when literally a few minutes thought shows it's not reasonable at all. But it was a politically advantageous theory to push.
So you could be spreading misinformation right now as well.
One major news article I read mentioned he was a hemp craftsman living in Berkeley, somehow I doubt he's an alt right Qanon type if that's the case
The only other info I could readily find was from ZeroHedge, though, so I don't want to take it as the gospel truth just yet
This person was mentally unstable/disturbed. I'm not sure we should frame our world, an freedoms, around the craziest of us all, otherwise our society will eventually look no different than an insane asylum.
I do believe there are memetic "contagions", but I also believe that a better solution is proper mental healthcare for those in need, like this person was.
People in general are just stupid, but no one seems to have the self-reflection necessary to recognize it.
Think about it like this.
You can look back in history and see actions and behaviors that make absolutely no sense. Those people were just stupid. Salem witch trials, the internment of the Japanese, concrete examples of mass hysteria, ad nauseum.
The question is, what are we doing that will look obviously stupid to people 100 years from now? "omg, they drill holes in their teeth and put metal in it?!?!".
The point is, these "memetics" have always existed in some form, what do you think local superstition is? To argue that this is only a problem for those in healthcare is extremely naive. Perfectly healthy, normal people, have on many occasions participated in various mass hysteria events or believed incorrect things. Blowing smoke up ones ass was literally a medical procedure.
The scary part about social media isn't about the social part, it's about the technology. Never in history has it been possible to manipulate so many people so easily.
This isn't a fight about people, it's a fight about control of the masses.
Why do people cling to this notion of censorship being a good thing? I feel like it's an attempt at a power grab with "won't someone please think of the children!" as the justification to the masses.
Twitter is a prime example of this, before Elon the mantra was "meh private company can do what it wants" the second the people that followed that mantra perceived their tribe as losing power over the platform that changed so fast that people got whiplash now twitter is a threat to everything from the foundation of democracy to national security.
> In a March meeting, Laura Dehmlow, an FBI official, warned that the threat of subversive information on social media could undermine support for the U.S. government.
As the people running the US government - particularly the democratically unaccountable set - become increasingly divorced in their values and beliefs from a a large segment of the population, they become increasingly obsessed with control of the Other, which by its very nature appears subversive.
This doesn't end well for any of us.
It's interesting to see people see the exact same arguments people have made for centuries, always in service of the existing status structure. "Misinformation" and "disinformation" aren't new. Twitter didn't radically change the world. If anything, we have returned to the pre-20th century environment, where rumors and conspiracies led to mobs, riots, and all kinds of civil unrest. It was a major concern of people in the Constitutional Convention that "designing men" would use misinformation to rile up the people to take over the government.
> In Massts. it had been fully confirmed by experience that they are daily misled into the most baneful measures and opinions by the false reports circulated by designing men.
Truly, there is nothing new under the sun.
What's "different" now in the so-called Information Age is that the brief era of a small class of people having near total control over what is published has ended. And they really, really don't like it.
There's no particular guarantee that the past can be used to predict the present here. Lies go around the world before truth gets its boots on, and now everybody can spread a lie with cross-continental reach.
So no, I don't think we're returning to the past. I think we're entering a new future, one with uncharted territory. The past gives us no particular guarantees that people are capable of handling this level of noise, let alone focused culture jamming and intentional exploitation of the new speed and reach of communication.
Again, the reach is not new! Nor is the speed - it’s just before only the Right People could do it, excepting maybe AM radio.
Before that, the reach was still as far as people spoke your language - it just took longer and people relied more on hearing what you said from someone else, until the invention of the printing press. Information still spread rapidly and if anything, people were more likely to take action due to the greater level of social cohesion in most times.
People have always had a burning desire for “news”, and the primary source for millennia was rumor.
People organized a nationwide attack on the US Capitol in 2021. It was a tiny fraction of the population that wanted to participate (much less participated), but they organized and came in from everywhere. What would that organization have looked like in Roman times?
Which is why our government selection is spread both over time and geography to prevent that.
Unfortunately there are people that want to move the federal government closer to direct democracy that would tear down both the time (2, 4 and 6 year term cycles) and geographic (Electoral College)
When in reality we need to be expanding these checks on power, not removing them
Even if the actual enforcers of speech law were honest, they would never be allowed to enforce the law where it is most needed, namely government itself. Wars are usually supported with lies. [1] [2] Will speech laws be used to punish government officials who lie the country into war? I think not. Instead, such laws will be used to protect powerful people, especially people in government. For example, in Citizen's United, a case that Democrats still criticize, the government was prosecuting the members of a small non-profit with felonies for publishing a 90-minute documentary critical of then Senator Hillary Clinton. [3]
[1] https://militaryhistorynow.com/2015/07/15/damned-lies-nine-w... [2] https://www.europereloaded.com/false-flags-and-the-american-... [3] https://www.oyez.org/cases/2008/08-205
I don't know how the parent can compare an instance of a crazy person to government sending people in war that kill hundreds of thousands of people. Because these lives are no media personalities?
To me this is nothing one should base an opinion on. Information needs to be free of course and if government gets their hand on some platforms, these will become unreliable sources with far more and significant disinformation than we have seen before.
There is nothing exceptional about social media except that it has taken so long to apply the sane principles of civil society. People who threatened the founding fathers with physical violence probably earned themselves a horsewhipping or a duel.
People who resent society must find a way to express their resentment by democratic action, not through threats and violence.
The founding fathers were not senseless followers of written words. They did not relinquish critical thinking by signing a constitution. The constitution was not a declaration of the end of critical thinking, education, and progress.
Violence is a destructive cultural anti-pattern.
I would assume that there were quite a few more consequences for threats than there are today. I would also assume that there was quite a bit of tarring and feathering of people who held deeply unpopular beliefs, because this did happen.
It seems likely that there is more to the story than is represented in this summary. Truly "new" news is rarely completely accurate and accurately complete.
For one, stop making up stuff like the above. Are you in the attackers head? No? Then be responsible and make a claim like that. Otherwise, I’m glad there’s no fact gestapo to stop you from running your fingers; keep typing; be as irresponsible as you’d like; make the mistakes everyone makes; eventually realize people are and must be responsible for their own actions no matter what people say (in both senses).
That’s exactly it - the cost of free speech.
And why should we pay that cost? Because the alternative is far worse.
The problem everyone ignored is who decides what speech is “ok” and which is not? Clearly someone would have to. And when that someone uses that power to silence “disinformation” that is in reality legitimate opposition? Well now you’re screwed.
I’ve lived in countries where speech is highly regulated and it’s basically used to control political opposition. Posting the wrong thing on Facebook can get you jail time.
> On a third hand, the loved one of a politician was severely injured because of someone who believes the incorrect speech of influential figures and I desperately do not want further injury or violence to occur spurned by incorrect speech on the facts of reality.
Terrible things, but I wonder how someone can come to the conclusion that it is a better solution to police the information than actually strengthen people's ability to detect arbitrary BS by themselves. Policing disinformation does not scale (Brandolini's law), while teaching people to think does. Why aren't logical fallacies a part of every school's curriculum? Is it because the "official" disinformation would suffer from that too?
Before we start to police disinformation, don't we need a court-proof definition of the term disinformation? I tried to look up the definition of truth, only to learn that there is no commonly accepted philosohical definition of that. So most likely, any definition of disinformation that is used to depress certain information will be BS too.
Free speech has reasonable limits. Slander/Libel is necessary. Death threats, bomb threats, incitement to suicide or genocide. All completely reasonable exceptions nobody will argue against. All of these are IRL physical damages or at least threat of.
So do you go further to amoleriate or prevent psychological damage? This is really the biggest part of the controversy.
So what happens when you create hate speech laws? If you define what isn't allowed to be said. For example N-word isn't allowed tobe said. You actually are going to receive the opposite effect. In order to hurt, people now know what to say; if they don't want to break the law but still hurt you invent new words.
Civilized people who aren't looking to hurt don't care, they simply avoid those words without the law. So you end up with a cat and mouse game where you say you cant use the N word but I sure can invent the same destructive word which isn't the n word. The law is utterly pointless.
So you don't define the words. You just say 'anything that offends' or "anything which incites hatred"
But now even the civilized people are at a loss here. What the law ends up being is a direct method to silence your political opponents. E-word used to be the term for the inuit up in the north. It's now considered a slur. Why? Because it is similar to words that mean snow in other languages that dont matter? But what happened was the inuit used this 'slur' to silence their political opponents. It was orchestrated by the same people who wrote this: https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/north/dear-qallunaat-white-pe...
To anyone you can see the problem with hate speech but better yet that isnt the whole story. We now have compelled speech. Hate speech avoids words, but compelled speech... that's next level. The government under force of law are telling you what you must say. This is to avoid offending people. It's remarkable how bad this has been.
The primary battlefield has been a bunch of overworked doctors have been getting fired from our public healthcare and going into private clinics for more money and less work. All because they were accused of not using the right pronoun. No wonder they don't really try to defend themselves. So what happened? You break your arm or whatever emergency. You'll be in the ER for >15 hours and very likely not be able to see a doctor.
The real argument for free speech is that policing speech is not practical.
Oooh you really lost me here. It feels like you’ve fallen hook line and sinker for the news emotional storyline.
Deranged individuals exist regardless of current rhetoric. Never give up free speech in an attempt to cure society of deranged individuals. It won’t work.
Also, “the facts of reality”. You believe this exists in the political realm?
IMO, the solution is to teach and reward critical thinking and questioning authority instead of blind obedience and defering to others who know best.
All policing disinformation does is make people afraid of questioning what they are told - and that will still hold true once the authority they follow changes to one you disaprove of.
If you cultivate a strong culture of ultimate responsibility, people will learn to think twice.
If everyone took ultimate responsibility for their own actions, then the cult leader / dictator / influencer would just be a person shouting in a room.
On one hand, I love free speech and think it is good. The innovation capable from people being ably to publish their views, congregate freely, etc. is a foundational good I believe in.
On the other hand, I'm aware that certain influential figures explicitly manipulate their speech in order to primarily amass personal power regardless of any second-order effects. E.g. cults are horrible, even though people are freely congregating, they just feel like they can't leave because of the emotional abuse these influential figures are heaping via their speech.
On a third hand, the loved one of a politician was severely injured because of someone who believes the incorrect speech of influential figures and I desperately do not want further injury or violence to occur spurned by incorrect speech on the facts of reality.
So what's to be done about the actual, real harm being done, while also protecting free speech? I don't want to assume that assaulting people is just the cost of free speech. That just seems so wrong to me.