News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Leaked Documents Outline DHS’s Plans to Police Disinforma... by perihelions on Monday October 31, 2022 @03:06PM (#33411051)
- "and I desperately do not want further injury or violence to occur spurned by incorrect speech on the facts of reality"

How is that any different from violence inspired by correct facts?

Following the logic you're laying out, I don't think it's the defense of truth you're advocating for; it's social harmony and stability. Basically the ideals favored in the Chinese model -- which censors true things and false things equally, depending on their social impact.

Re:Leaked Documents Outline DHS’s Plans to Police Disinforma... by drtz on Monday October 31, 2022 @03:27PM (#33411421)
Do you truly see no difference between a lie that leads to someone getting harmed and a truth that leads to the same outcome? Your argument seems disingenuous.

> Following the logic you're laying out, I don't think it's the defense of truth you're advocating for; it's social harmony and stability. Basically the ideals favored in the Chinese model -- which censors true things and false things equally, depending on their social impact.

This is a straw man. The original comment made no such argument. From the comment you're responding to:

> ... I desperately do not want further injury or violence to occur spurned by incorrect speech on the facts of reality.

Re:Leaked Documents Outline DHS’s Plans to Police Disinforma... by GoblinSlayer on Monday October 31, 2022 @03:47PM (#33411799)
Some religious people say if there's no god, they will go kill all people. Is such truth worth the price?
Re:Leaked Documents Outline DHS’s Plans to Police Disinforma... by Arrath on Monday October 31, 2022 @04:08PM (#33412181)
Yes? Civil society cannot allow itself to be held hostage by the threats of an unhinged fringe.
Re:Leaked Documents Outline DHS’s Plans to Police Disinforma... by YeahNO on Monday October 31, 2022 @04:26PM (#33412485)
If they have to believe in a mythical deity that dispenses "justice" post-death in order to quell their urges to commit murder, they probably should be treated for mental illness or otherwise removed from society, as they are a ticking time bomb.
Re:Leaked Documents Outline DHS’s Plans to Police Disinforma... by ben_w on Monday October 31, 2022 @04:01PM (#33412062)
If they are sincere, it's very useful to allow them to identify themselves by publicly announcing this in advance. Much easier to stop them before they get going if you know who they are.
Re:Leaked Documents Outline DHS’s Plans to Police Disinforma... by tekknik on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @09:32AM (#33420956)
There needs to be some evidence for this. You can’t just claim some religious people want to kill everybody. Link please or this is a blatant lie.
Re:Leaked Documents Outline DHS’s Plans to Police Disinforma... by Eleison23 on Monday October 31, 2022 @03:56PM (#33411946)
The Index Librorum Prohibitorum was not a bad idea. It was scorned and mocked in the 20th century because it had become so unwieldy and impractical, based on the widespread use of the printing press and other media such as film, television, and music.

Now, "truth" is an interesting thing. Ricky Gervais decided that the founders of Christianity were the lying liars, perhaps because their stories were not concretely, verifiably true in every historical detail, and therefore Ricky concluded that Christianity is a fabric of lies made up to make people feel better or control us or something.

Unfortunately it's Ricky who's got the short end of the Truth. Because Truth is more than just facts that are printed in a newspaper about the daily police blotter. Once you accept that there are higher, more important Truths than what you'll find in Wikipedia, we'll all be a lot better off. And we can better evaluate those lower-order facts and figures for what they really are.

Re:Leaked Documents Outline DHS’s Plans to Police Disinforma... by MonkeyClub on Monday October 31, 2022 @05:25PM (#33413437)
Ok you’re espousing a view that’s fringe on HN and of course you were downvoted (not by me), but I’d just like to raise a technical point:

The truth of Wikipedia is epistemic, as is the truth of theology, and as such it’s possible to evaluate them in different epistemic systems and draw different conclusions.

But capital-t Truth is capitalized to indicate that it is an ontological rather epistemological signifier, i.e. a name referring to a personal entity.

So technically speaking God is not a higher or lower truth, in the sense of the verity of a proposition, as you can’t compare a person with a fact.

If we start conflating epistemology with ontology, then... God help us! We’ll end up calling night day, and figuratively literally :)

Re:Leaked Documents Outline DHS’s Plans to Police Disinforma... by GaylordTuring on Monday October 31, 2022 @04:06PM (#33412153)
> Do you truly see no difference between a lie that leads to someone getting harmed and a truth that leads to the same outcome?

Only if the action is justifiable in the first place. Let’s say someone wants to kill gay people (or people who are against vaccines, or people who want to raise taxes); does it really matter whether he kills an actual gay person or whether he kills a straight person who he mistakenly thinks is gay?

Re:Leaked Documents Outline DHS’s Plans to Police Disinforma... by didibus on Monday October 31, 2022 @03:37PM (#33411586)
There's a problem of adversarial attack right now.

An adversarial person can flood people with rethoric of issues, corruption, crime, against all established political powers and institutions, and position themselves as the solution to all those ilks.

They can do that by flooding the public square of free opinions (the internet), with disinformation, fake data, lies of omissions, lack of contextualization, attacking all others personally, ridiculing them, etc.

All they have to do is put doubt in people's mind, keep the focus on others, and appeal to emotions of more and more people slowly.

They can do that because they are free to do it.

Then they can gain the political power from it, and slowly replace institutional power with loyalists working for them.

Once they've managed to get enough loyalist in place through this method, they can remove the right to free speech and take over as a fascist or dictator, or other more authoritarian measures.

Then they can continue the same speech they've always been pushing as propaganda, even denying the removal, bans, jailing, and all that of their opposition, and voila.

This is a pretty straightforward playbook. It's played out many times before.

You can call it a soft-coup:

> populists who seek the centralization of power but do so under the pretense of improving democracy

At least to me, it's very obvious our system is susceptible to this kind of adversarial attack. I don't know the solution, you don't want to prevent this attack but enable another one in doing so, but it's a huge threat vector and I'd hope we recognize it and do something to mitigate it.

Re:Leaked Documents Outline DHS’s Plans to Police Disinforma... by GoblinSlayer on Monday October 31, 2022 @04:14PM (#33412272)
I'm afraid entire political system runs on populism. It gives them free pass to any idea they want to push.
Re:Leaked Documents Outline DHS’s Plans to Police Disinforma... by JacobThreeThree on Monday October 31, 2022 @05:11PM (#33413222)
>There's a problem of adversarial attack right now.

>An adversarial person can flood people with rethoric of issues, corruption, crime, against all established political powers and institutions, and position themselves as the solution to all those ilks.

Appealing to emotions and attempting to label your opponents as corrupt and soft on crime is as old as politics itself. Convincing people to vote for you is not a soft-coup.

The platforms should be the ones who should decide how their algorithms promote information and shouldn't be pressured or controlled by whoever the current party is in power at that moment. The benchmark should be - would you want a Trump DHS with the power to change their censorship policies however they liked?

If online speech should be regulated by the government, pass legislation, don't backdoor it in a risky and unilateral manner through law enforcement.

Re:Leaked Documents Outline DHS’s Plans to Police Disinforma... by didibus on Monday October 31, 2022 @10:17PM (#33416150)
> attempting to label your opponents as corrupt and soft on crime is as old as politics itself. Convincing people to vote for you is not a soft-coup.

From my understanding of political history, it used to be more common to talk about your policies and what you plan to do to win votes, and something related to Newt Gingrich started a new trend of being more on the attack/discrediting towards others, and it escalated from there.

But the important part isn't that piece, but what followed in what I said, it's the second stratagem to put loyalists in place that is the key to performing a soft-coup. Something you cannot do when moderates abound, it requires focusing on strong cult-like minority, that are really loyal, and slowly replacing key government roles with people you pick for their loyalty to you and not their qualifications.

It's that second part that's all the difference here.

> If online speech should be regulated by the government, pass legislation, don't backdoor it in a risky and unilateral manner through law enforcement.

I don't disagree, to be clear, I'm not saying this in favor of the DHS program, I don't know what the right defensive measures against this would be, that also wouldn't cause other bigger risks, but I think it's a vector for attack we currently are vulnerable too and I'd like to see it delt with.

Re:Leaked Documents Outline DHS’s Plans to Police Disinforma... by nradov on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @01:45AM (#33417417)
Your understanding of political history is very limited and simply wrong. Look deeper at the history of 19th century campaigns. There was plenty of attacking and discrediting going on, often using language that would shock modern readers.
Re:Leaked Documents Outline DHS’s Plans to Police Disinforma... by didibus on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @05:36PM (#33427869)
Thanks, I went and read about it, it's interesting. It is unclear how it stopped exactly and why it changed, apart from making ballot booths, but it does seem to be making a comeback.

Still, in any case, just to be extra clear, this isn't the issue I'm calling out, the adversarial attack is in-combination with the setting up of loyalists and the overthrow.

That a campaign can be won by crude measures of appeal to emotions and discrediting of your opponents is a bit sad, but it isn't as much a problem if it is just a method for election.

The problem I see is afterwards, are the checks in place to make sure that you cannot instate loyalists, and change the rules themselves to entrench yourself. It's this second part that is the soft-coup.

Re:Leaked Documents Outline DHS’s Plans to Police Disinforma... by iaml on Monday October 31, 2022 @05:23PM (#33413407)
I think it’s effective because the message is simple and scaled in coordinated fashion. To effectively answer to such an attack you need to massively distribute among the users refutals to every part of the attack message, with reputable sources and it needs to be brief enough so people don’t lose interest halfway. It could take a form of browser extension or a separate site with a dialogue tree of sorts where one participant is propaganda bot and the other the site user. Then users need to publicly post these (i guess you can ask fellas for help?).
Re:Leaked Documents Outline DHS’s Plans to Police Disinforma... by soundnote on Saturday November 05, 2022 @11:00AM (#33482097)
> An adversarial person can flood people with rethoric of issues, corruption, crime, against all established political powers and institutions, and position themselves as the solution to all those ilks.

> They can do that by flooding the public square of free opinions (the internet), with disinformation, fake data, lies of omissions, lack of contextualization, attacking all others personally, ridiculing them, etc.

> They can do that because they are free to do it.

> Then they can gain the political power from it, and slowly replace institutional power with loyalists working for them.

> Once they've managed to get enough loyalist in place through this method, they can remove the right to free speech and take over as a fascist or dictator, or other more authoritarian measures.

This is more or less what the woke left has done to a lot of cultural institutions, with universities requiring political loyalty oaths. They just don't rely on a strongman to enforce their will the way populist movements do since wokeness is a distinctly professional-managerical class movement. But they've systematically taken control of most places of cultural power in the US.

Re:Leaked Documents Outline DHS’s Plans to Police Disinforma... by pfisherman on Monday October 31, 2022 @03:34PM (#33411523)
I think the word / concept you are looking for is justice.

Prudent actions are rooted in truth. Where there is not prudence there is no justice. Strength and action in the absence of justice is tyranny.

Re:Leaked Documents Outline DHS’s Plans to Police Disinforma... by usernomdeguerre on Monday October 31, 2022 @03:32PM (#33411497)
I think this is an insightful comment, but i'm not sure its merely the Chinese model at play. It's also the purpose of courts and lawmaking.

So that the harmony and stability of society can continue; and the truth of the matter can be adjudicated (defense or offense) in a thorough and thoughtful manner.

Why should we leave this battle to be taken up in the public square and threads like this?

Re:Leaked Documents Outline DHS’s Plans to Police Disinforma... by buscoquadnary on Monday October 31, 2022 @03:35PM (#33411546)
Truth is truth, the defining feature of truth is it's independence of any view point. To suggest it can be adjudicated is to imply that there is no longer truth and only the power of the weak over the strong.
Re:Leaked Documents Outline DHS’s Plans to Police Disinforma... by usernomdeguerre on Monday October 31, 2022 @03:44PM (#33411738)
Truth may be truth, but marshaling it out of the past and into the present courtroom is a lossy operation no matter what we philosophically believe.
Re:Leaked Documents Outline DHS’s Plans to Police Disinforma... by esrauch on Monday October 31, 2022 @03:16PM (#33411202)
Violence inspired by disinformation is so drastically different than violence inspired by correct information though.

If a pizza parlor was actually a pedo ring or a politician was actually sacrificing babies (both real examples of widely spread and believed misinfo right now) the violence induced against the perpetrators would be vigilantism but still considered morally defensible to most people due to failure to take action from the authorities.

It seem perfectly sensible to say that we apparently have a big problem due to people literally shooting up pizza parlors over disinformation, and that if someone was shooting up a pizza parlor over correct information the situation would be different and warrant different responses.

Re:Leaked Documents Outline DHS’s Plans to Police Disinforma... by vxNsr on Monday October 31, 2022 @03:39PM (#33411625)
> It seem perfectly sensible to say that we apparently have a big problem due to people literally shooting up pizza parlors over disinformation

This is a perfect example of why this is a bad idea. Thank you for being the example. No one shot up a pizza parlor due to disinformation. A single concerned citizen brought a gun to a pizza shot to ascertain if there was a pedo ring being operated in it, after confirming there was not, he handed over his gun and not a single shot was fired.

But you honestly believe that to be the case, either because it benefits your argument or because someone lied to you or because you misinterpreted something you read. But you now believe this is the truth and everyone who disagrees with that "truth" should be censored.

Re:Leaked Documents Outline DHS’s Plans to Police Disinforma... by singleshot_ on Monday October 31, 2022 @03:53PM (#33411899)
> not a single shot was fired

This is a perfect example of disinformation. According to a contemporaneous report by the New York Times, the “concerned citizen” (which of course is a strange thing to call a criminal, but leaving that aside) illegally discharged an AR platform rifle inside the building, in order to destroy a lock.

Think about why a person would want you to believe that the shooter’s actions were perfectly normal or why they would want you to believe you misremembered the event.

Re:Leaked Documents Outline DHS’s Plans to Police Disinforma... by gaganyaan on Monday October 31, 2022 @04:11PM (#33412228)
What? There were shots fired:

> On December 4, 2016, Edgar Maddison Welch, a 28-year-old man from Salisbury, North Carolina, arrived at Comet Ping Pong and fired three shots from an AR-15 style rifle that struck the restaurant's walls, a desk, and a door.

There's a whole section on Wikipedia:

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pizzagate_conspiracy_theory

Your response is exactly why people are getting away with proposing draconian measures like this. You need to stop ingesting and spreading disinformation.

Re:Leaked Documents Outline DHS’s Plans to Police Disinforma... by etchalon on Monday October 31, 2022 @05:06PM (#33413126)
Your comment is such a perfect example of the ouroboros of misinformation, it's hard to believe it exists.
Re:Leaked Documents Outline DHS’s Plans to Police Disinforma... by esrauch on Monday October 31, 2022 @05:20PM (#33413362)
I don't understand your point; you think it's just fine that people deliberately slandered and lied about a pizza place to the extent that someone believed it, went in with an AR and fired rounds and that's all fine because no one died?

Surely even if you think that was fine, it would have been better than fine if the guy did that same thing to a pizzeria actually was a pedo ring? My comment was only saying that violence induced by outright lies has a relevant difference than violence which is a reaction to things that actually happened. Those seem clearly different even if you think censorship is not a viable or correct solution to "violence induced by misinfo".

Re:Leaked Documents Outline DHS’s Plans to Police Disinforma... by tekknik on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @09:46AM (#33421172)
You’re excusing violence cause by your party, but demanding change for the other party. Both parties need to stop the violence. Having actually fought in a war, violence is never acceptable unless someone is trying to take your life.
Re:Leaked Documents Outline DHS’s Plans to Police Disinforma... by esrauch on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @06:12AM (#33433538)
I'm excusing no violence, and whichever side you think is 'my party' you are incorrect, I am not either an American Republican or Democrat.
Re:Leaked Documents Outline DHS’s Plans to Police Disinforma... by tekknik on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @09:39AM (#33435566)
Ah the good ole “not an American” getting involved in American politics.
Re:Leaked Documents Outline DHS’s Plans to Police Disinforma... by esrauch on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @08:53PM (#33445189)
No one can comment on the mere idea of violence based on lies without having picked a side and defending a specific political agenda now?

To my knowledge it was never the Republican Party's position is that pizzeria was a pedophile ring was it? What should being of a particular political party have to do with it, that event was based on 100% confirmed fake news. There are no conservative or liberal policies seem involved in that story at all?

Re:Leaked Documents Outline DHS’s Plans to Police Disinforma... by tekknik on Thursday November 03, 2022 @10:25AM (#33451480)
> No one can comment on the mere idea of violence based on lies without having picked a side and defending a specific political agenda now?

If it’s unrelated to your politics, yes. What’s the point of you stating your opinion otherwise? Do you realize this can be construed as interference? Would you like Americans commenting on your political issues?

Re:Leaked Documents Outline DHS’s Plans to Police Disinforma... by soundnote on Saturday November 05, 2022 @10:55AM (#33482049)
In fairness, American political culture does leak and infect the rest of the English-speaking cultural sphere, so we do have an interest in it.

For example, when Americans went nuts and tried to remove/deface historical statues, here in Finland local Leftist party's youth group suggested removing a statue of Mannerheim. Mannerheim was a war leader during the Finnish Civil War and led the Finnish defense against Russia during WW2.

He's literally one of the primary reasons those Leftist youth organization chucklefucks' parents didn't grow up behind the Iron Curtain, yet they wanted his statue removed. They definitely got the idea from the US.

Re:Leaked Documents Outline DHS’s Plans to Police Disinforma... by arminiusreturns on Monday October 31, 2022 @05:45PM (#33413702)
Go read about the Franklin scandal, or the Dutroux scandal before you spout things you are sure aren't happening (in particular the X-witness reports). Elm house, Kinkora in UK. Epstein-Maxwell-Wexner-Mossad, etc, need I go on?

I propose many people pretending to be arbiters of truth refuse to acklowledge facts and citations before them.

The mainstream media inspires wars... they don't get held to account do they? Why the sudden focus on arbitrary standards and funny how they always get applied to those that vary outside the approved overton window.

Re:Leaked Documents Outline DHS’s Plans to Police Disinforma... by esrauch on Monday October 31, 2022 @06:16PM (#33414072)
Obviously pedophilia exists in the world. There obviously should be authorities whose job it is to investigate such things. People absolutely need to be able raise suspicions to authorities for due investigation.

Pizzagate was not that: half the people repeating it were doing it as a meme, were in on the joke. People spread it even knowing it is not true.

I don't know what your point about journalists are: it's literally journalists deliberately spreading damaging misinfo like Alex Jones that need to be held accountable here. The DHS isn't able to go after grandma at Thanksgiving dinner for saying Clinton drinks baby blood.

Re:Leaked Documents Outline DHS’s Plans to Police Disinforma... by tekknik on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @09:41AM (#33421107)
> I don't know what your point about journalists are: it's literally journalists deliberately spreading damaging misinfo like Alex Jones that need to be held accountable here. The DHS isn't able to go after grandma at Thanksgiving dinner for saying Clinton drinks baby blood.

But how come only the right needs to stop misinformation? Not a day goes by that an article from the left MSM comes out spouting wildly incorrect information (for instance, recently with the SIG SCX SPEAR). The left has increased division and hate in this country and now we’re seeing the result.

Re:Leaked Documents Outline DHS’s Plans to Police Disinforma... by tekknik on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @09:38AM (#33421056)
> and that if someone was shooting up a pizza parlor over correct information the situation would be different and warrant different responses.

Wow this is scary, and kinda borderline needs to be reported to the FBI. Why is shooting up a pizza parlor acceptable when the information is “correct”? This is cult behavior.

Re:Leaked Documents Outline DHS’s Plans to Police Disinforma... by esrauch on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @06:17AM (#33433568)
I did not say it is "correct" to shoot up a pizza parlor. I am saying that scenario of "people knowingly lie, other people are misled, other people cause violence" is an even worse situation for society than "people know the truth, people cause violence". The second one is already horrible, the first one is especially horrible.

I can empathize with the people who are deceived. The person who attacked Pelosi has now had his life ruined by lies; the lies induced him to commit violence against an innocent person. That's a thing that is sad on top of Mr. Pelosi who was almost murdered thanks to the lies. It is a pretty sad situation that people lying without consequences resulted in that outcome for both of them.

If he knew the truth and committed the crime then either 1) it was justified vigilantism or 2) it was a wrong action that he did of his own volition. Either way is is less bad than an wrong action that he was tricked into.

Re:Leaked Documents Outline DHS’s Plans to Police Disinforma... by tekknik on Thursday November 03, 2022 @10:31AM (#33451578)
Good.

But how come you used an example from the left? How come you weren’t neutral and used an example from both sides? Now you looked biased and are guilty of spreading the same misinformation you’re claiming was spread in the Pelosi instance. You will cause violence against republicans with your comments, so you are now just as guilty.

Furthermore, speaking of misinformation, Pelosi’s attacker was a hardcore liberal, then suddenly became a hardcore Trumpist? And the evidence supporting this was viewed by a handful of police officers and we just have to trust them that someone can make this radical of a change from receiving misinformation? Parts of this story still don’t add up, and looks very convenient to happen right now before midterms. On top of an 82 year old surviving a hammer attack.

Re:Leaked Documents Outline DHS’s Plans to Police Disinforma... by raxxorraxor on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @06:05AM (#33433488)
It is never morally defensible if you do not have conclusive evidence. Of course what would be considered conclusive is subjective, but that is a matter of education as there can be objective standards. These will never be approached by vigilantism though.
Re:Leaked Documents Outline DHS’s Plans to Police Disinforma... by nonethewiser on Monday October 31, 2022 @03:17PM (#33411210)
I wonder which model the federal government prefers.
Re:Leaked Documents Outline DHS’s Plans to Police Disinforma... by emeraldd on Monday October 31, 2022 @03:28PM (#33411437)
Realistically, the federal government (and by definition any government) is made up of people with their own self-interests. They will favor the style of "censorship" that keeps them in power.
Re:Leaked Documents Outline DHS’s Plans to Police Disinforma... by wwweston on Monday October 31, 2022 @04:02PM (#33412069)
Violence is better avoided. Most people also believe violence is situationally justified in service of other values, and this is an arena in which the truth of the situation matters very much. This is why we have court proceedings where we aspire to reach conclusions of correct facts before we allow the state to apply law and sentencing that may do violence to property, liberty, or person.

The flip side is much as Voltaire is supposed to have said: "Truly, whoever is able to make you absurd is able to make you unjust" or "Those who can make you believe absurdities can make you commit atrocities." Violence inspired by incorrect facts is violence automatically out of accord with worthwhile values.