It's only confusing because of FUD from governments who know damn well we've entered a world-wide inflationary death spiral driven by the debt created to perpetuate the idea of infinite growth, even in the face of the system repeatedly trying to correct by popping bubbles. Turns out that reinflating the very bubbles that just popped is exactly the wrong strategy.
Also, in the US we are facing the fact that the vast majority of emergency debt created to combat economic shocks from COVID was embezzled by corporations and fraudsters.
Record profits across the board for corporations, highest CEO pay ratios ever recorded, massive housing bubble; the monied class is making off with their spoils and cashing the stock market in. Meanwhile they are sticking it to consumers with inflation (even shrinkflation) and then complaining about worker shortages!
> Meanwhile they are sticking it to consumers
That's a lot to parse, but I'll give it a try.
"Record profits across the board for corporations" - Record profits is exactly what you would expect with lingering low interest rates + lowered rates from COVID response + unleashed demand post-COVID. This was by design, because profitable companies don't fire everyone and create a recesssion from unemployment. Or tank the stock market and thus housing market and thus create a recession.
And you're a quarter out of date. Profits and margins have been compressing in Q1 2022 and look to continue.
"Highest CEO pay ratios ever recorded" - Exactly what you'd expect with a roaring stock market, given equity-biased compensation. That will correct, as it always does.
And furthermore, talent compensation is already increasing and on every HR department's priority list. [0]
"Massive housing bubble" - Low interest rates + stimulus + lack of supply + sudden demand spike = price spike. Fed rate hikes will cool this off fairly quickly.
"The monied class..." - You mean, everyone?
"... making off with their spoils and cashing the stock market in..." - Reallocating and diversifying assets?
"Meanwhile they are sticking it to the consumers with inflation..." - Who is "they"? Some generalized bourgeoisie who control the means of production and arbitrarily set prices?
See earlier point (and google for statistics) and margin compression for what's actually happening: companies are passing along less than all of their own cost increases.
[0] https://www.pwc.com/us/en/library/pulse-survey/executive-vie... (I hate big-4 management consulting pablum, but it's a quick distillation)
> "The monied class..." - You mean, everyone?
Are you asserting that you believe the parent is using "The monied class..." to mean everyone? Which doesn't seem to be the case.
Or are you asserting everyone belongs in "The monied class", if so, that seems so overly broad as to be a bit ridiculous?
Are we talking about the hyper-wealthy? Business owners? Business managers? Investors in general? It's unclear.
There are a lot of complicated things going on and being generically angry at people with "more" money is uninformative and unproductive.
As near as I can tell, the parent's policy prescriptions amount to (1) we should allow asset bubbles to pop harder, (2) we should have created less(?) or more strictly controlled(method undefined?) COVID emergency debt, and (3) we should implement price controls for consumer goods(?).
[1] At $300 billion supposed net "worth", Elon Musk could retire ($3 million a pop) literally 100,000 times over. Or, he could retire, not making another cent, and live one hundred thousand times better than the average person. If his wealth only grew at par with inflation, he could literally spend $100k a year for three million years.
The fact that this much money is earmarked for this person, or any person really, is only possible because the enormous pyramid schemes they are able to set up which are paid into by speculative investors.
In my frank and honest opinion, there are NO words you can say, NO ideas you could have, NO labor that you could undertake, and NO buttons that you can push that morally justify the tax on humanity's subsequent activities that funnel that much wealth to you. Hands down. And with that money you have zero goddamn problems that justify you offering policy input that personally benefits you. We should shun such money addicts, not lionize them.
The power to make something happen. Like "Long range electric cars should be a thing, now" or "Reusable rockets should be a thing, now." Even and especially when most other people think it's impossible and disagree with you.
Or you can just build a gold-plated swimming pool and ensure your descendants never have to work.
Is that productive? Eh. Versus what? It certainly allows for more risk-taking than government, minimum-cost bidding projects would target. DARPA et al. aside.
It's certainly not fair.
But from a fairness of opportunity perspective, there are certainly more egregiously-born examples who have objectively produced less to show for it than Musk. Or than Ted Turner, to use another random positive example. (E.g. Barbara Hutton for a negative example)
Hacker News is a forum for entrepeneurs. The idea that successful entrepeneurship results in valuable companies shouldn't be foreign. Nor the knowledge that societies that confiscate the fruits of successful entrepeneurship, will soon not have any entrepeneurship at all.
Maybe the consequences of that in terms of individual wealth ownership are unpalatable to you, but the alternative would result in an option that is net significantly worse for society.
I don't accept this framing. That framing is what I thought 20 years ago. It's been the root of a major realignment of my thinking in realizing that these people more accurately have been successful at creating large organizations of people that instead do that fruit production, fight to keep themselves on top of that organization and channel the majority of the profits of those organizations to themselves. How else could you explain the massive, some would call obscene increase of CEO pay ratios over the past four decades? Are CEOs 10x or 100x more productive or good at making decisions than four decades ago? Do they do 10x or 100x more work? It's completely implausible. CEOs continue to be compensated insanely well, even when they make bad decisions and their companies go under.
The real answer is such titans have been more successful at changing the culture to make it acceptable to channel a larger and larger portion of their organization's profit to themselves. It's all mathematically impossible that these people could have done anything to produce so much more "entreprenurial" fruits themselves. Rather, they are the ones confiscating those fruits from their employees and their companies and are benefiting from the casino-like nature of speculative investment markets fueled ultimately by money created out of thin air by debt.
And on top of that, they tell us that they are being stolen from! Gaslighting horseshit.
The alternative? Surely there are more than two ways of organizing society: (i) one with successful entrepreneurship but large wealth inequality, and (ii) presumably one without successful entrepreneurship along with various other characteristics that make that society clearly "net" worse than it would be in (i).
For example, I could imagine a tax regime which resulted in a cap on individual wealth at, say, 1% of GDP. Or 5%. Or 0.1%. Or ...
It's not clear to me that there's an unambiguous demarcation between only two types of societies, and one which is observed across all possible policy or economic schemes.
10% of households own 90% of the stocks held by households. Close to half hold none at all.
Things will cost more. That’s hardly surprising. Energy is really important.
You can't just assume the price spike in December is the same thing that we're seeing in March or June.
The CPI data took years to catch up because consumers are quite price sensitive and detecting and responding to increased demand is a delicate process.
Of course prices went up.
Plus at best there was a big slowdown, but there was no serious shutdown, many people still worked and got COVID, eg. people who would have otherwise worked at the port. (Though even a serious lockdown doesn't help much. (We saw this in China.)) And mask wearing was so far from ideal that it was not able to seriously decrease the transmission of the disease.
Aaand of course the boosters could have been much much better (containing new variants): https://www.slowboring.com/p/were-getting-an-omicron-optimiz...
What's true is the shut/lock/slow part made no sense after we got the vaccines, and it's also quite obvious that there was just not enough stockpile of basically anything to do a ~1 month lockdown to stop the spread of the disease. (And the moment the first international plane landed it would have started again.)
The way you worded that somehow makes me think you aren't talking about the OPEC+ deal from 2020 that drastically reduced oil supply. Because strangely, not a coincidence, domestic production has been up since that deal expired.
I don't disagree that oil prices drive inflation since almost everything needs transportation, especially in the US where even domestic goods have to travel huge distances. But a "war on domestic production" is not evidence based.
Closest thing that could be serious considered a war was OPEC+, which I understand why Trump did it, prices were plummeting and we wouldn't want the entire sector to crash.
When looking at TIPS and inflation expectations it looks like it's not quite self reinforcing yet.
This is what people seem to forget. Trade involves two items, so you gotta look at both sides of the trade (in this case credit+dollars vs goods). Dollar supply has increased dramatically since 2020, credit near free, while the supply of goods has decreased. Obviously that's a recipe for inflation.
Had dollars+credit decreased with the supply of goods instead, people selling goods would have trouble demanding more dollars. For hyperbole, if only 1 dollar existed, no one could sell something for more than 1 dollar, no matter the supply of goods. People might still try to demand more than 1 dollar for their goods, but trade with dollars would cease to happen until they reduced their demands to <= 1 dollar.
> This is what people seem to forget. Trade involves two items, so you gotta look at both sides of the trade (in this case credit+dollars vs goods). Dollar supply has increased dramatically since 2020, credit near free, while the supply of goods has decreased. Obviously that's a recipe for inflation.
I don't think anyone forgets this. The standard model says supply constrained + generous fiscal/monetary policy = inflation.
The parent post mentioned "money printing coming home to roost. Lots of folks say that isn’t what it is." I too seem to have encountered people saying the money printing is a non-factor, and it's just supply chain problems. In reality, both are factors.
There is this from Dalio who suggests money printer go brrr policies sank the Dutch and Brits: https://youtu.be/xguam0TKMw8
While all the fancy math is great for drawing geometric shapes, human intuition and basic arithmetic run the economy; human intuition for quantity has been evolving for millions of years whereas our fancy languages are only 5,000 years old (so says historians). We annotate our arithmetic operators differently for calculus and the rest of higher level math, but at the end of the day with only 13% of the adult public possessing an “advanced degree” most people make pretty basic arithmetical decisions.
Smart people used their education to get ahead but the rest of the world has caught up and caught on as <50% believe in higher powers now; elites are just people, not specials to be kowtowed by.
So what’s happened is again elites tried to form concrete agency habits into the masses (like religion did) but the masses agency does not concretely conform to rigid mathematical objects and the elites are now out of touch; either by stubbornness or age, they can’t handle they’re the ones losing ground all this time.
So they tinker with official math to keep us in line: https://www.nytimes.com/1997/02/27/business/job-insecurity-o...
So in the end economic policy was always politically motivated power consolidation for the elites, and the public, probably thanks to the meta awareness of our communities the internet provides, has caught onto the big picture game. Like Assange said; only the highly numerate will be able to see. I like to think it’s because such minds are not as swayed by cable group think.
So here we are saving like the Fed said and emotionally normalizing to a recession coming because that’s what we talk about, and so we’ll create a self fulfilling prophecy of it because like the number say, only 13% have an advanced degree; the masses will go along with Jerome Powell and the cable news channels telling them; stop spending, save, because a recession is coming. And stopping that simple arithmetic spending at scale will trigger a recession.
Subs will get cut to services. Services die off. What’s left is the new “real economy”, and off we go again. Conveniently not giving a toss about general public who got hurt while the elites look smart for getting us to believe they saw the future, and ignore that listening to them really just modified our economics behavior to make it all true.
What can the average _not_a_billionaire_ investor do to weather this out (not knowing exactly what _this_ is)?
In my example I have most of my money on Index funds (with a 60/20/20 split between US markets, China markets, and sector specific ETFs) plus an emergency fund that lasts me about 12 months and I (unfortunately now) earn in Euros.
[1] - https://www.blackrock.com/us/individual/literature/investor-... [2] - https://www.treasurydirect.gov/indiv/research/indepth/ibonds...
My conclusion is that long term it's probably good to be in stocks. The problem is that stocks might go down a lot before recovering, years from now. And of course you cannot time it.
They're already pulling back this year though:
I've been using AVLV and AVUV, but they've been down since I bought them in May.
In short, a lot of what’s happening comes back to the debate we had during the early part of the pandemic... one side said shutting down the world would have major consequences down the line and we’re seeing that now.
No one seemed to understand that those kinds of things were going to have much more drastic effects for everyday people as well. This same thing goes for the stock market, sure I don't have a ton of money it it, but I do keep putting money in my 401k and so do a lot of other people that are depending on it for their retirement, when the stock market takes hits it effects me just as much as the "elite".
It would have been irresponsible to risk chicken with something that might have had MERS lethality.
Eventually we put tighter bounds on those quantities, and could make more informed decisions. But yes, all stages of the pandemic were unfortunately people talking past each other, without being actually curious about the pros/cons of various approaches.
But it's been awhile since the political class has had to deal with an actual existential science problem... so that muscle wasn't very strong.
Not all countries are experiencing high inflation at the moment.
Which suggests that persistently high inflation is caused by the same thing it's always caused: (local) money printing.
Not some abstract worries about excessive (?) debt or 'fraudsters' etc or so.
And I think it's a great example that most of the actual drivers of economic outcomes are unmeasurable. What we actually measure and react to are themselves second order effects of those primary drivers.
Which is why we can compare two situations with similar (second order) metrics (but different primary drivers) and be puzzled by different macro outcomes.
However, nominal variables are also subject to feedback loops.
If they printed enough money, they could generate all the inflation they wanted (or live in economic utopia.)
Basically, keep using newly printed money to buy up assets around the world. At some point you either own the globe, or you'll get the inflation you wanted.
With boomers retiring and deaths and disability due to covid taking workers out of the pool, along with suppression of immigration, there's a large overhang of jobs compared to workers. This is giving average workers negotiating power which is creating wage growth.
That is what the Fed and the business pages are really most concerned about and the sternest warnings from the Fed are about the labor market. Not the headline CPI numbers.
The fact that the "man on the street" now believes that inflation is purely a monetary phenomenon, though, means that every time wage inflation rears its head that people will clamor for the Fed to punish the economy.
The Fed is going to have to crash the economy to create a recession and thereby cause deflation. There will almost certainly be detonations elsewhere in the economy (commercial and residential real estate most likely) that will further cause deflation. High CPI will be transitory because this Fed doesn't care about tanking the economy. Billionaires also don't care about tanking the economy, the past 20 years have taught them they always wind up even more on top than before.
What will be interesting though is to see what happens when they've had enough of pain and start to support the economy again, then inflation will probably come roaring back, since its causes are now the structural conditions of the wage market. Then there will be renewed calls to tank the economy again and people will object to the Fed doing anything to try to support the economy with exactly the same rhetoric here. In the near term future (~10 years) any time the inflation numbers tick up the stock market may crash on its own now.
I suspect we're now in for a decade or more of stagnation, although alternating periods of inflation and recession should average out. I might be wrong though if the billionaires decide it is too painful and want the Fed to turn the money spigot back on. But as a lot of this comment section shows, the managerial class has now been taught to really deeply hate the Fed doing that, and believes it to be the root cause of all that is ill.
But enter covid money printing actually reaching normal people (even if alot of it got soaked up too), plus the elites using the money to buy things normal people want instead of rich people nonsense (buying housing as "safe" investment during covid), plus all the money that was going towards servicing student loans getting spend in the economy, plus normal people using their power to get more wages due to worker shortages and here we are.
Yes. I think we had something like monetary inflation but it was all captured by the upper 1% and 0.1%. The policies suppressed wages down the Ginni Coefficient ladder and actually contained inflation. This produced low interest rates due to low CPI inflation expectations. But it would up producing what economists call asset bubbles rather than inflation. This has also built up over the past 30-40 years ever since Volker in 1980, it goes way beyond the post-2008 recovery and the pandemic.
We're now seeing the point where this has all become unsustainable, and the masses are clamoring (rightly) to get a share of it. Either we're going to allow that inflation to run downhill now and re-price via inflating wages and suck up the smaller pain of inflation, or I think we're going to have to inflict truly severe economic pain of multiple deep recessions. Given how much people now deeply hate inflation, now that wage inflation has reached the baristas and food service people, it looks like we're going to choose recession.
I would at least expect that to be less inflationary than that same amount of money ending up in consumers’ hands and being rapidly spent without an offsetting increase in production.
When the government opens up the feeding trough, it should expect pigs to show up. I agree that it probably can’t be blocked up front, but fraud needs to be prosecuted aggressively after the fact.
Yes, the brokerage accounts of rich people have less velocity than the bank accounts of poor people. This makes it more scandalous, not less. People who didn't need the money took ten times as much, because they could, and now they are pointing accusing fingers at the little people. Again.
It would be an easily explainable problem if the US and only the US printed a ton of money and got overheated market.
The problem is that virtually every country printed a ton of money during the pandemic. So the demand overheated globally.
On the supply side we have:
a) Chinese factories working intermittently due to COVID restrictions
b) Russia who cannot participate freely in the gas market anymore and their threat to cutoff Europe during winter
c) The supply chains are experiencing full scale bullwhip effects working overtime to satisfy demand that is not there anymore.
These incur huge import costs to any country.
So even if the US had printed zero additional dollars the past two years, we would still be experiencing inflation due to the vast raises of the cost of our imports.
- Someone wants a car and ask the car dealer
- car dealer orders 3 just in case because shortage
- distributor orders 6 for the same reason
- factory makes 12 because parts are short in stock
Result: cars in demand 1, cars in stock 12. No more just in time production and huge demand imbalance.
[1]https://web.archive.org/web/20220627205956/https://www.washi...
If anything you don’t want demand destruction if we are anticipating such a drastic increase in supply.
It’s just a basket of goods.
The question of how many people can afford this basket is a different question.
And that question’s name is demand.
To get the prices back to the original we need to bring down by 10% the *global* demand.
That means that the US needs to cut 50% their oil consumption (demand) if they are to act alone.
These are not realistic things.
That's like saying that by pointing my fan to blow onto the road, I can move the cars.
In theory and all else being equal, yes. In practice, cars have drivers that steer to stay on the road.
Similarly, other countries around the globe have their own central banks that regulate their local money supply to achieve their own goals.
But 600k in the bank is still not the norm for Americans, only a small percentage of them. Most are really struggling right now.
I guess that a lot of people are on the fence about whether they should short stocks since "everything is going down" or just sit on their cash reserves, eat the inflation and hope to buy in again once the bottom has been reached.
Granted I think this recession is likely going to be significantly worse and longer than that one. I'm still taking advantage of the the 25% discount on stocks and buying, though.
Also I suspect we're in for some terrible shit in the next 5-15 years with the way the environment is heading (the physical environment, i.e. lack of water, topsoil, ocean acidification, etc), but I also suspect we're in for at least one more solid bull run before that happens.
I've lived through crypto winters before that have lasted 2+ years. If I had bought a little bitcoin every week during that time I would easily be retired now. I plan to do the same during this downturn, but focused more on stocks (also getting a small amount of crypto). I didn't have the spare cash back in 2008 during the Great Recession, or I would have done extremely well for myself then too.
If for some reason the stock market stays fucked for decades, then I am acquiring other assets too, like precious metals. Also guns and ammo and goods to barter with might not be a bad idea in that case.
Problem is that bitcoin is a ponzi and doesn't have any revenue/profits but just FOMO.
If you bought tulips at the bottom and sold at the top...
Thanks for being casually insulting. I know Hacker News is full of those comments so I'm used to it, but I'm not sure how you expected me to respond to your comment there, or what benefit it would add.
Your comment comes off to me as if I said something like "Oh look, I just got a pet mouse!" and you responded "Mice are crappy pets. It's going to bite you and give you the plague."
For the record, I said buy every week (as in DCA, or just buy no matter the price, all the way up until now), and I'd be retired now. That's not 'buy at the bottom, sell at the top'. It's currently $20,000, and that's not "at the top", the top was ~$69,000 in Nov 2021, so now is nowhere near the top right now.
First crypto winter I held bitcoin through, the price was hovering around $200 every week for two years, so I could and should have been buying more that entire time, instead of checking the price every couple of months to see if anything changed and buying nothing.
But I probably could have accumulated at least 40 coins potentially based on my income then, with a few sacrifices (by that I mean less going out to eat and buying a bunch of random video games that I'd often play once or twice and never again...still a problem I have today, it just makes up a smaller percent of my paycheck now). I was excited in bitcoin even then, but I was also a lot poorer, making about 15-20% what I'm making now, and I also wasn't prioritizing it as much as I could have been.
Even still, I'm not dumping all my earnings into this stuff. I put far more into my 401k/stocks than I do crypto.
If you DCAd on tulips and sold at the top you'd be set for generations.
You are talking with too much feelings. I understand. But it's ponzi all the way down.
> I put far more into my 401k/stocks than I do crypto.
Every single $1 you put is every single $1 into a ponzi. I'm sorry. I wish I too had generational wealth and did fancy art fulltime.
If you want something more real life and high risk/return, check out TQQQ & HFEA. I do those.
This is a crazy hack, in countries like India where a home/rent-income is a defacto investment, being in debt is cleverest way you can can have your investments subsidised by the economy(general public).
One of the biggest things you can learn as an adult is to be comfortable with manageable levels of debt.
https://www.stlouisfed.org/publications/regional-economist/2...
The poor are getting worse off, with wages not rising nearly fast enough to keep pace with inflation (not to mention being basically sacrificed to keep the great money machine running during COVID).
And they're already starting to do something about it: the unionization push is accelerating (I saw several weeks ago a figure that at the beginning of the year, there were zero unionized Starbucks, and at the time of that posting, they had just unionized the 150th), and if inflation continues at this rate—or higher—without some significant changes in wages, etc, we might start to see bigger problems before long.
This is truly such an exxagerated strawman. It’s such a minuscule number of people, and they’re definitely not 28. Plus, the sky high salaries are for senior engineers, not juniors.
A FAANG engineer that joined just out of school (~22 years old) and spent 6 years getting regular promotions, awards, maybe a move into management, etc. and all of their initial stock awards vested could very well have 600k saved over that time. Doubly so if they're married and their spouse is in the same situation.
[0] https://www.levels.fyi/company/Facebook/salaries/Software-En...
I still disagree, there’s so much in income/other taxes that are applied. They spend on exorbitant rents and overpriced goods. Most such people are not frugal by any stretch.
If you could link any survey/study/statistics on the number of such 600k saving individuals, I’d love to see it. Until then, it’s a strawman.
FAANG don’t even employ enough people for this to make a dent on anything other than housing prices in FAANG commute localities.
That shows to me that capitalism is broken if success means inflation. We should be able to swim in cash reserves and safety and not be penalized for it.
Then take comfort in that armchair analysis being wrong. If it were true, if FAANG employees’ pay were driving inflation, we’d expect to see local inflation correlate with FAANG employment.
It does not. In fact, almost the opposite is true, with inflation in the interior outpacing that on the coasts [1][2]. (Shipping.)
[1] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-11-11/inflation...
[2] https://www.jec.senate.gov/public/index.cfm/republicans/anal...
Or in other words, the rest of the country catching up to the big cities
No idea if this is the truth of course
Internal migration is too slow and too small to explain the interior’s price shocks. Also, it’s not like the coasts are withering away. Real GDP growth in California and New York was better than the national trend in Q1 2022; the interior saw the worst of the real economic shock [1].
[1] https://www.bea.gov/news/2022/gross-domestic-product-state-1...
As anyone who paid any attention to the housing market in the past 2yr knows, if you have 10 houses and 11 buyers...
>the interior saw the worst of the real economic shock
That places that have economies that are more dependent on physical goods, services that cannot be performed remotely and high volume low margin types of business (which are heavily affected by supply chain stuff and commodity prices) should not surprise anyone.
Where I'm located(east coast LCOL area), we still compete with ~15 bidders for every house, and they're still reliably selling within 2-3 days for 10% over asking, all cash, with inspections waived.
Obviously part of this is a supply issue, but, I have a strong suspicion the rise of remote work is a contributor to price increases near us. We live a short distance(~1-2 hrs) from several major metros, and with the flexibility to go into the office only a few days a month, It's feasible to take a much higher paying job in somewhere like NYC and commute. Local wages for engineers here are/were also much lower than what was offered for typical remote roles, so I'm sure that's causing an additional upward pressure
I keep getting YouTube adds for the same kind of things I have seen on TV. Tide pods, dish soap, toilet paper etc alongside Door Dash’s attempt to recruit workers. They would definitely make less money without door dash but not enough to matter. Much like how startups keep splurging on Super Bowl commercials but the Super Bowl would still make lots of money without them.
It could simply be a consequence of the parameters of nature not offering humans unlimited energy and resources.
If we continue along competitive models for allocation to the end, we're right back where humans started before forming societies except in an articicial darwinistic model which I'd say people are increasingly rejecting, so we need to start thinking a bit more about more equitable allocation systems than we currently have. Right now, I'd say the general population is pretty fed up with existing allocation systems.
Competition is a very strong motivator for progress. Even if you didn’t embed it formally within a society, I bet it would very quickly arise and build upon itself.
Yes, I do not see a problem with capitalism coexisting with a wealth transfer mechanism to constantly “reset” the game a little bit to prevent extreme disparities. Well, other than the fact that humans would have to allow it to occur.
According to https://www.thebalance.com/who-owns-the-u-s-national-debt-33...:
“The public holds over $22 trillion of the national debt. 3 Foreign governments hold a large portion of the public debt, while the rest is owned by U.S. banks and investors, the Federal Reserve, state and local governments, mutual funds, pensions funds, insurance companies, and holders of savings bonds.”
This is amazing. A very few seem to realise that it says the public buys and holds a promise on a future productive capacity of that same public. It's as if I paid another person for the privilege of promising myself to behave and work for that person overtime in the future.
I don’t see how the holdings of it matter, that’s completely different to the bonds being sold on the open market, which the fed was buying
We are not in a hyper inflationary environment. Hyperinflation is when monthly inflation rate is above 50%, or more than 12,800% per year.
* We're seeing June numbers. Gas prices lately have plunged relative to where they were
* supply problems are moderating
The one thing the fed should be worried about is another unexpected supply shock -either a COVID wave that affects Asia etc, or natural disaster that drastically affects energy. Then, the economy is in a deep bind and the fed has their hands tied.
It seems like that is only true if you're in a niche (like skilled tech) or if you're <$20/hr. I see tons of openings for shit jobs (low wage and/or bad environment).
Even being in tech and making under the national average for devs, I don't see many good jobs posted that fit with my experience. I'd like to switch industries, but that would generally require a significant pay cut and other downsides with things like working construction, warehouse, driving a truck, etc.
This is evidence of a strong job market.
Which will then further increase inflation (somewhat).
Amazon, Walmart, Publix are paying pickers $30/hr
Buckey's, Loves, all paying over $20hr with benefits
Becoming an electrician is currently at the top of my list. There should be considerable future work with all the various popular changes (EV chargers, solar panels, old homes being updated, new home and office construction, etc).
Have they? Where, and by how much?
I'm still seeing ~$5/gal gas around here...
But remember, California $6/ga gas is Texas $4/ga gas.
We're almost certainly below the natural rate of unemployment, meaning even a declining CPI isn't enough for the Fed to stop hiking
Gold and crypto protect against inflation.
Bonds should be 20-40 percent of a portfolio.
Apple and MSFT and the rest of big tech are safe havens.
It's always a good time to buy a home, as supply is at a generational low and will remain like that for a decade, we will become like Canada so you shouldn't wait to buy.
My favorite one is, you can't time the markets. Quite obviously a lot of people correctly timed the market's trends starting around the end of 2021, and the reasoning was pretty sound. I'm kicking myself today for dismissing them.
Whoa. Think about it, there are constantly people thumping their chests and posting their theories about how things are under and over-valued, and pretty much everything else (like the world ending). If you think that because some people made a winning bet with their money that timing the market in general is a good strategy, I'd suggest you never play poker seriously.
2014: All this pump is fake. Sell!
2018: All this pump is fake. Sell!
2022: All this pump is fake. Sell! See, you can time the market.
> Gold and crypto protect against inflation.
No insurance policy pays when the house is already on fire.
> Bonds should be 20-40 percent of a portfolio.
If you believed in inflation north of 3%, why the hell would you own bonds?
> Apple and MSFT and the rest of big tech are safe havens.
Megacap tech is still up tremendously from the 2020 lows. Not saying they're going higher, but they've weathered the recent storm pretty well.
> It's always a good time to buy a home, as supply is at a generational low and will remain like that for a decade, we will become like Canada so you shouldn't wait to buy.
This was good advice if you were planning to live in your home you could have locked in rates at generational lows. Sure you were paying up for the house, but your mortgage payments would have been absurdly low. And yes, I'm almost positive over a 15-30 year period you'd be able to recoup your principle.
Inflation protected bonds earning nearly 10%?
My casual observation that I'll probably forget about in a few years and maybe remember the next time a real downturn (I'm too young to have ever paid attention to the economy, economic news, etc. during a downturn) happens is that, most likely, everyone gets scared of the uncertainty and dumps their assets in to cash so they're ready to pay off any debts they have. What happens next is unknown.
> Quite obviously a lot of people correctly timed the market's trends starting around the end of 2021
How many incorrectly timed the markets in 2020? In 2019? Etc.
I felt real smart when I sold my BTC at the ~$18k peak way back when. I even told myself I'd wait til it dropped to $2k before I bought more. Seemed smart back then. Not so smart now. Granted, I still made money, but I left a lot on the table.
I'm the even bigger dummy. I held through that $18k peak and crash in 2018, and still held through the $68k peak and crash last year. Still holding, but could have made way more if I had sold even a piece of it when it hit my target ($54k) instead of waiting for the $100k everyone kept promising was definitely going to happen based on previous cycles. Oops.
Why not sell now? Wouldn’t you still make a decent profit?
Key lesson -- if a shill has good information, take the information. But make your own decision at the end of day. How it fits into your mid/long term goals etc.
But it didn't even get that far. Dropped almost immediately after getting to its ATH, which usually doesn't happen. The world had to shit the bed and take it down with it before that.
Based on what?
I saw some of the same predictions as GP, they were all about the start, not the middle or end.
Then they take the half they got right, and do the same thing again. After a few iterations, their pool of marks is smaller...but they also believe that the scammer is never wrong. (I believe the scammer then tells them they need to put a large sum down—which the scammer will, of course, handle for them...and then absconds with it.)
You're focusing on the ones who got it right, ignoring the ones who got it wrong, and calling it smarts. It's very unlikely to be so. The market as a whole should always be treated no differently than the scammer's entire initial pool of marks.
(Excellent book, by the way)
Show me the person who can consistently time the market.
The data is pretty clear on this one: even the professional investors that did better than the index in one period, were not able to do the same in the following period.
Buy and hold, there is nothing better. Try to be smart and you will lose.
> Whether they sold in November or August, they correctly timed. Buy and hold investors made the wrong move by holding. It was obvious then to many.
In a decade or so I strongly believe my investment will be up significantly from those November numbers. I won't care what happens right now, it literally doesn't effect my plans to withdraw the cash when I retire.
Surely at any time somebody correctly timed the market.
No new value created, just people playing musical chairs until the music eventually stopped.
I feel your pain, I was deep in it too and my gut was telling me the way forward. But I ended up listening to the shills, mostly because I'm relatively young and wanted to lean towards more exposure than less.
It just feels like there is about to be an asset wipeout across the spectrum - like a forest fire clearing out the forest for new growth.
Don't run to the exits because that's an even worse outcome unless your holding leveraged stock bets.
That's generally expected when interest rates rise. Most assets have value now because they ought generate returns in the future -- but you can get interest between now and in the future, and if you can get a lot of that interest now, why would you spend so much on what is still a long way off?
Other countries have their own alternatives. For instance, here in Brazil we have the NTN-B, a federal government bond which can be bought by anyone and currently returns the inflation plus 6% (see https://www.tesourodireto.com.br/titulos/precos-e-taxas.htm which calls it "Tesouro IPCA", with IPCA being our main inflation index). And it doesn't have any "only 10k per year" limit.
But if you get your mortgage now, you don't have to worry about those future increases. IIRC, most American mortgages are fixed rate.
Yes, everything that goes wrong with the house is now your responsibility. Yes, you will pay property taxes. Landlords are not in the business of renting at a loss in cities just yet. Occupancy rates are still high.
For anyone that is not currently a home-owner, I'm afraid you're correct.
It would also wipe out a lot of people's savings.
I think interest rates will stabilize in the near future. I don't think they can continue to go up without demolishing the economy.
Interesting username, btw!
"Interesting username, btw!"
Ha! Thanks. You should see the @mentions I get on IG. Turns out a lot of people are often mad at the bank...
Edit: Ah, wow I can't read. I need a cup of coffee :)
Sadly, this one hasn't been disproven yet (I hope it will be soon). All we've seen is record home cancellations which may or may not be a leading indicator [0]
[0] https://www.cnbc.com/2022/07/11/homebuyers-are-canceling-dea...
You mean when some of the Fed officials sold? Sound reasoning, indeed.
What is generally meant by this is that you cannot know the future so you cannot know when is the most optimal time to buy or sell.
Now, you can react to trend (eg your “trends starting around the end of 2021”) and sell, for instance. But when are you going to buy again (ie can you know when the bottom is?).
But herein lies the trap. While any particular crypto currency may have limited supply, there is theoretically an infinite amount of crypto currency (people can and do create new ones out of thin air when an existing one has run its course). To top it off, these are not productive assets.
In practice, crypto is very prone to hype cycles.
Assets aren’t inflationary or deflationary. Prices are. Prices, denominated in crypto, have inflated through the moon this year as the value of the currencies crashed.
There are plenty of things in the world with naturally or artificially fixed supply. Anyone pitching them as deflationary is talking tripe.
real estate has a lot of lag though so you are probably paying above market price for homes today
For me, Tesla was the flashing red sign, it's market cap was something close to that of the entire auto industry combined. I had a big expense coming up this year, so I went ahead and sold a bunch of stock in January.
'You can't time the market' would preclude both, but I think GP is talking about scenario 2 and you are talking about scenario 1.
Exactly. My favorite one was about Cloudflare stock. Look at the responses in [0] when it was more than $210 per share, For Bitcoin reaching >$60K 'This isn't even close to what will be the all time high.' [1] and I suggested many to run away from the market [2] and one said 'Stock market up 1% today on both this news and decades-high inflation.' which that obviously didn't age well.
So as you can see, it looks like so far I (and many others) were able to time the market and predict the 2022 crash, especially in crypto. [3]
[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29355360
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26840880
If I predict this coin flip will be heads, and I flip it, and it is heads… does that mean I can predict coin flips? What if I do it three times in a row?
What if I do it 10 times in a row? [1]
We have loads of information available to us which is correlated with stock market performance.
With enough information about the coin's motion while it is in the air, one might be able to predict a coin flip pretty accurately too.
The other three citations are basic speculation from Apr 2021, and 6-7 months ago. Not sure how this counts as “timing” the market.
"Inflation is always and everywhere a monetary phenomenon, in the sense that it is and can be produced only by a more rapid increase in the quantity of money than in output." - Milton Friedman
When a government bond is first sold, the buyer gives the government money.
Then when the Fed buys it back, it creates news money for the purchase.
Post-2008, the fed did their quantitative easing by buying non-treasury bond like mortgage debt, etc.
It’s new money because the original money received for the bond doesn’t disappear.
Yes within that transaction it’s neutral (seller gives up $1M bond for $1M cash). But overall, new money has been injected.
I emphasize that this isn't a great interpretation because the root of the problem lies with Congress's inability to balance a budget, not the Fed. If our budget were balanced, then the Fed would instead raise interest rates by selling more bonds, which destroys more money. Because we're already issuing so many new bonds already, the Fed doesn't have to sell as many.
If the fed buys with new money, it expands the supply, whatever they buy.
If someone issues debt and exchanges existing money for bonds, there is no change to the money supply.
Treasury bonds are considered M4 money. It's not as liquid as M1, but so long as if you don't want to liquidate it, it isn't much different from M1.
>If someone issues debt and exchanges existing money for bonds, there is no change to the money supply.
I'm not sure what you mean by this. Issuing debt is creating money. This is true for commercial banks as well. When a bank issues lends you $10k to buy a car, that's money that had never existed before. You receive $10k from the bank. Meanwhile, the bank's depositors are still entitled to withdrawal the full amount they deposited in the bank.
But that monetary inflation multiplier is stable if the money supply is stable.
When the fed buys up assets using new dollars that expands the money supply, which can then be multiplied through lending.
QT is the processes of reducing money supply so is paying off the loans. If more people pay off the loan than new people taking up loans due to higher interest rates, the money supply falls.
You can plot other assets too, such as gold https://totalrealreturns.com/s/GLD
The solution to that is raising interest rates. Possibly a massive rate hike. Look for the Fed to do a full percentage point or more next time. The party is over. They're trying to be gentle so as not to destroy the housing market like last time. But housing is going to drop, no question.
Recall that until the late 1970's the thought that inflation could persist through a recession seemed absurd.
Nobody is ready for that scenario because they think it's impossible. But then again, how many predicted the situation we find ourselves in right now?
We're heading for a consumer debt crisis. Outside of the tech bubble, average people are in a dire situation.
> What if the rate hikes keep coming fast and furious and the CPI keeps rising even faster?
Same thing that happened with the housing crisis in 2008. Consumers are going to default, and instead of the banks sharing the risk in the market they helped over inflate, Wall Street's going to get bailed out, because entering a deflationary environment is absolutely off the table.
Stagflation? Of course it's possible, that was the 1970's. The question is if the Fed is willing to do the unpopular thing needed to stop it. And then the follow-on is weather congress is willing to address the federal budget and pay down the debt (obviously not since they already missed the chance to do it before rates rise) painful as that will be.
As long as we're all fucked together (including rich people and wall street) I think we'll be OK in the end. It's the trying to play favorites that is probably causing the most damage.
The beatings will continue until CPI improves.
It’s like showing up to a job site with all the tools in the world and worrying that you’ll need a tool that doesn’t exist. Do not fall into paralysis by analysis.
*You can't buy fire insurance when your house is on fire. Insurance prices also skyrocket when everyone is freaking out about the need to buy insurance.*
And guess what you do when inflation hits hard and you need to pay for things? You sell your gold. It's happening in Sri Lanka[0], I'm sure its also happening else where across the developing and even in the developed world.
Gold is still up 15% since before the pandemic in USD, in every other currency its up even more.
If you're buying now you're buying as a hedge against whatever inflation will come in the future.
Even in 1975 when inflation was at 9% gold prices collapsed by 30%!!!
Unfortunately, you need to time markets to some extend to get the full benefit of any hedge since you necessarily only profit when someone else is willing to buy at a higher price.
[0]: https://theprint.in/world/sri-lankans-selling-gold-amid-econ... [1]: https://www.nytimes.com/1975/12/31/archives/gold-rush-in-us-...
>the value of their home has increased significantly
This causes their property taxes to go up, too, adding to the pressure.
> The main losers seem to be renters
Home ownership rates are decreasing; and you really forgot people on fixed incomes or no incomes (living on the street).
"gold" or actual physical metal gold? What I hear is that getting gold or silver metal delivered is almost impossible.
I think a lot of problems are being aggravated by the failure of the "market makers" and market reports that are more to influence than inform.
See also the Nickel market.
What do you mean? That inflation fears caused consumers to clear out the retail channel, or that "investment" gold is often something that just sits in a bank vault and can't reasonably delivered except to a specialist?
western media tend to omit that it's the west against Russia, not the world
People repeat these gold lines like it's the 19th C. Today its a shiny metal sold by ponzi schemers to paranoids.
Gold tends to be (but is not guaranteed to be) a hedge against monetary inflation but not against supply crunch driven inflation. Prices are going up because prices are actually going up.
Pandemic, probably yes. Ukraine? Probably not. The supply problem is over-optimized supply chains, which means "we build everything in China, and they're not producing." I just got a time estimate of 52 weeks for a 1200A distribution panel, and things like breakers >600A have similar restrictions.
All of this compounds up and down the chain. But luckily, a lot of suits on Wall Street are making tons of money, so everything will be fine, right?
Look at risk assets, and consider whether that supports your assertion.
~ But luckily, a lot of suits on Wall Street are making tons of money forcing the global economy into this put-all-your-eggs-in-the-Chinese-manufacturing-basket strategy, so never mind any potential risks to the larger global economy outside Wall Street in the second or third decade of the twenty-first century; those suits on Wall Street are making tons of money and that's the main thing, so everything will be fine, right?
And sure, it was -- for a while. And for those suits on Wall Street, it probably still is: They've made their [m|b]illions. (Not sure what you mean by "risk assets", but I do know this: If they're really risks, you and I will probably be on the hook for them, rather than those suits on Wall Street.)
> I doubt this is monetary inflation. It's price inflation due to a supply crunch brought on by the pandemic shutdowns
Take a look at M2 money supply [0]. Pumping huge amounts of fiscal stimulus into the global economy caused this. Inflation has been driven by poor policy decisions.
> Then throw in other factors like housing undersupply in developed countries
There has been a housing stock shortage for over a decade, that's not new, so it's hard to argue that's a proximate cause [1].
> continuing depletion of "easy" oil
There's plenty of oil available [2]. New technology (hydraulic fracturing, horizontal drilling, etc.) allows for accessing reserves that were too expensive previously. There has been structural underinvestment in O&G thanks to misguided green/ESG policy.
> Chinese threats against Taiwan
How does this drive inflation? If anything, China has reduced inflationary pressures by decimating economic activity with Covid lockdowns.
> Gold tends to be (but is not guaranteed to be) a hedge against monetary inflation
Gold has been a great hedge against inflation in the long run. When measured in gold, a soldier today earns a similar salary to a Roman soldier 2000 years ago [3]. However, gold is not a good hedge against inflation in the short term. When inflation goes up, interest rates go up. When interest rates go up, the opportunity cost of owning gold increases. It should be noted that interest rates have steadily declined throughout history.
[0] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/M2REAL
[1] https://smile.amazon.com/Shut-Out-Shortage-Recession-Univers...
[2] https://bettermeetsreality.com/how-much-oil-is-left-in-the-w...
[3] https://www.mining.com/what-a-roman-centurions-pay-says-abou...
Core PCE jumping [1]. Core is elevated. But between that and headline is a lot of energy price volatility.
[1] https://www.bea.gov/data/personal-consumption-expenditures-p...
The price of money is contained in the interest rate. There are loads of models for turning credit spreads and duration curves into a Fed-neutral level, but I have my doubts.
We have no metric for the part of inflation caused by monetary policy. If we did, central banking would be solved. Instead, we have various measures that include some confounding variables and exclude others. Core PCE excludes most volatile, non-monetary contributors to prices. If core PCE spikes, it’s hard to argue the cause isn’t systemic and widespread, i.e. monetary or something with similar breadth. CPI spiking, on the other hand, has more explanations which must be rejected before we can conclude monetary origins.
Many many different areas are experiencing "perfect storms" to cause huge disruptions and shortages:
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-07-11/thirteen-...
That’s what it means to go from a 2% inflation rate to a 9% inflation rate.
The inflation rate is literally the slope of that chart. It’s a price chart, not an inflation chart.
> Also notice how that chart only goes in one direction - up and to the right. There are very brief periods in which it reverses, only to return to trend with a vengeance.
Yes, because deflation is generally considered a bad thing.
Up and to the right does not imply that CPI increases are accelerating, which I agree is the problem. You can have a perfectly healthy economy with linear, constant inflation, that's been the case for most of history. Some small, relatively consistent amount seems to be good for a society, it encourages reinvestment rather than hoarding. Straight lines are good, parabolas are dangerous, they usually turn into hyperbolas as an economy collapses.
Is it going up and to the right faster and faster? Here's a chart of the month-to-month delta of that chart since May 2020:
https://i.imgur.com/Id8tGSE.png
It's noisy like all real data, but a linear fit says y = 0.0028x - 123.44, R² = 0.476. That suggests that CPI is going up and to the right about 1.5 points per month, equal to 0.5% monthly or 6.2% annually, but that each month the rate of increase gets larger by 0.0028 points. That's what we need to bring back to 0.
the assumption that stocks hedge inflation has clearly been borne out of false over the past year
Inflation is not a tax as commonly assumed. This is why people who are dumping revenue-generating assets and bonds and are content with 'losing' 8%/year by being in cash, because they aren't really losing anything.
You only get 'taxed' by inflation if your consumption habits or preferences are aligned in such a way as to match the components of the CPI, which for the wealthy/rich they aren't. The rich don't need millions of dollars of food, healthcare, or gasoline. If you already own a home, then your hedging needs are already mostly fulfilled.
For someone who has much less money, then inflation is more like a tax, because your will be spending a lager % of your income on essentials, such as food and gas, which are tracked by the CPI.
There are no short-term hedges to inflation outside the money markets. (And even they are highly imperfect.) Real assets broadly hedge against inflation in the long term, almost by definition.
I've heard this quite a bit but I don't think it's true.
The FED is raising rates purposefully, knowing this will cause a negative turn in the economy possibly (and likely) leading to a recession.
Their goal is (perhaps indirectly but still intended) to cause a (controlled?) recession by raising interest rates.
It doesn't make sense they would they seek to undo a recession that they induced. Eventually they will once inflation is back down but the FED can (and should) keep raising rates until inflation comes back down.
I wouldn't be surprised to see interest rates at 6, 7 or even 8% if inflation continues at its current level or continues to rise.
I remember some particularly catastrophising conspiracists claiming it would, but I don't remember giving the idea credibility.
Right now the gold market is pricing in a Volcker-style freakout by central banks.
If Powell pivots, this will surely reverse.
It could also that in prices will not behave as you'd expect due to large-scale, persistent, quantitative easing: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32083245
The published CPI might not be that important - any small trader who cares about gold probably doesn't care too much about inflation. It isn't like the amount of money printing is a secret, when I care to check I measure the gold price vs the monetary aggregates.
And any big trader probably has better data available than the government statistics.
Government data is the gold standard.
Traders spend money trying to predict what the government numbers will be. It can be difficult to emulate, since it involves talking to real people, but there are brokers out there for consumer spending data.
Since the dollar is really a petrodollar now what you’ve been seeing in oil prices has been the hedge against inflation.
The Fed will not become accommodative before the inflation is beaten. The Fed will keep increasing rates, recession be damned. They won't do the mistake that the '70s Fed did.
This by itself is not surprising. The fed has a target of 2% inflation which means that even in the best case, CPI will by an exponential that gains 2% per year.
https://www.tradingview.com/chart/?symbol=NASDAQ%3ATSLA
Remember how gold was going to protect you from hyperinflation?
Something nasty is brewing in the economy. It will be obvious when it hits but until then it will be confusing as hell.
The bond and eurodollar markets have been signally for about a year now that the nasty thing will be a recession that will force the Fed back into accommodative mode as early as this year.
The funny thing is that both can be true. Inflation can soar and the economy can crater. The Fed can be accommodative while inflation runs hot. It has happened before. If it happened again, it's hard to imagine a scenario that would cause greater confusion.
> On a monthly basis, headline CPI rose 1.3% and core CPI was up 0.7%, compared to respective estimates of 1.1% and 0.5%.
Here's the number to pay attention to. CPI increases are accelerating. Have a gander at this chart:
https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/CPIAUCSL
Also notice how that chart only goes in one direction - up and to the right. There are very brief periods in which it reverses, only to return to trend with a vengeance.