Whoa. Think about it, there are constantly people thumping their chests and posting their theories about how things are under and over-valued, and pretty much everything else (like the world ending). If you think that because some people made a winning bet with their money that timing the market in general is a good strategy, I'd suggest you never play poker seriously.
2014: All this pump is fake. Sell!
2018: All this pump is fake. Sell!
2022: All this pump is fake. Sell! See, you can time the market.
> Gold and crypto protect against inflation.
No insurance policy pays when the house is already on fire.
> Bonds should be 20-40 percent of a portfolio.
If you believed in inflation north of 3%, why the hell would you own bonds?
> Apple and MSFT and the rest of big tech are safe havens.
Megacap tech is still up tremendously from the 2020 lows. Not saying they're going higher, but they've weathered the recent storm pretty well.
> It's always a good time to buy a home, as supply is at a generational low and will remain like that for a decade, we will become like Canada so you shouldn't wait to buy.
This was good advice if you were planning to live in your home you could have locked in rates at generational lows. Sure you were paying up for the house, but your mortgage payments would have been absurdly low. And yes, I'm almost positive over a 15-30 year period you'd be able to recoup your principle.
Inflation protected bonds earning nearly 10%?
My casual observation that I'll probably forget about in a few years and maybe remember the next time a real downturn (I'm too young to have ever paid attention to the economy, economic news, etc. during a downturn) happens is that, most likely, everyone gets scared of the uncertainty and dumps their assets in to cash so they're ready to pay off any debts they have. What happens next is unknown.
> Quite obviously a lot of people correctly timed the market's trends starting around the end of 2021
How many incorrectly timed the markets in 2020? In 2019? Etc.
I felt real smart when I sold my BTC at the ~$18k peak way back when. I even told myself I'd wait til it dropped to $2k before I bought more. Seemed smart back then. Not so smart now. Granted, I still made money, but I left a lot on the table.
I'm the even bigger dummy. I held through that $18k peak and crash in 2018, and still held through the $68k peak and crash last year. Still holding, but could have made way more if I had sold even a piece of it when it hit my target ($54k) instead of waiting for the $100k everyone kept promising was definitely going to happen based on previous cycles. Oops.
Why not sell now? Wouldn’t you still make a decent profit?
Key lesson -- if a shill has good information, take the information. But make your own decision at the end of day. How it fits into your mid/long term goals etc.
But it didn't even get that far. Dropped almost immediately after getting to its ATH, which usually doesn't happen. The world had to shit the bed and take it down with it before that.
Based on what?
I saw some of the same predictions as GP, they were all about the start, not the middle or end.
Then they take the half they got right, and do the same thing again. After a few iterations, their pool of marks is smaller...but they also believe that the scammer is never wrong. (I believe the scammer then tells them they need to put a large sum down—which the scammer will, of course, handle for them...and then absconds with it.)
You're focusing on the ones who got it right, ignoring the ones who got it wrong, and calling it smarts. It's very unlikely to be so. The market as a whole should always be treated no differently than the scammer's entire initial pool of marks.
(Excellent book, by the way)
Show me the person who can consistently time the market.
The data is pretty clear on this one: even the professional investors that did better than the index in one period, were not able to do the same in the following period.
Buy and hold, there is nothing better. Try to be smart and you will lose.
> Whether they sold in November or August, they correctly timed. Buy and hold investors made the wrong move by holding. It was obvious then to many.
In a decade or so I strongly believe my investment will be up significantly from those November numbers. I won't care what happens right now, it literally doesn't effect my plans to withdraw the cash when I retire.
Surely at any time somebody correctly timed the market.
No new value created, just people playing musical chairs until the music eventually stopped.
I feel your pain, I was deep in it too and my gut was telling me the way forward. But I ended up listening to the shills, mostly because I'm relatively young and wanted to lean towards more exposure than less.
It just feels like there is about to be an asset wipeout across the spectrum - like a forest fire clearing out the forest for new growth.
Don't run to the exits because that's an even worse outcome unless your holding leveraged stock bets.
That's generally expected when interest rates rise. Most assets have value now because they ought generate returns in the future -- but you can get interest between now and in the future, and if you can get a lot of that interest now, why would you spend so much on what is still a long way off?
Other countries have their own alternatives. For instance, here in Brazil we have the NTN-B, a federal government bond which can be bought by anyone and currently returns the inflation plus 6% (see https://www.tesourodireto.com.br/titulos/precos-e-taxas.htm which calls it "Tesouro IPCA", with IPCA being our main inflation index). And it doesn't have any "only 10k per year" limit.
But if you get your mortgage now, you don't have to worry about those future increases. IIRC, most American mortgages are fixed rate.
Yes, everything that goes wrong with the house is now your responsibility. Yes, you will pay property taxes. Landlords are not in the business of renting at a loss in cities just yet. Occupancy rates are still high.
For anyone that is not currently a home-owner, I'm afraid you're correct.
It would also wipe out a lot of people's savings.
I think interest rates will stabilize in the near future. I don't think they can continue to go up without demolishing the economy.
Interesting username, btw!
"Interesting username, btw!"
Ha! Thanks. You should see the @mentions I get on IG. Turns out a lot of people are often mad at the bank...
Edit: Ah, wow I can't read. I need a cup of coffee :)
Sadly, this one hasn't been disproven yet (I hope it will be soon). All we've seen is record home cancellations which may or may not be a leading indicator [0]
[0] https://www.cnbc.com/2022/07/11/homebuyers-are-canceling-dea...
You mean when some of the Fed officials sold? Sound reasoning, indeed.
What is generally meant by this is that you cannot know the future so you cannot know when is the most optimal time to buy or sell.
Now, you can react to trend (eg your “trends starting around the end of 2021”) and sell, for instance. But when are you going to buy again (ie can you know when the bottom is?).
But herein lies the trap. While any particular crypto currency may have limited supply, there is theoretically an infinite amount of crypto currency (people can and do create new ones out of thin air when an existing one has run its course). To top it off, these are not productive assets.
In practice, crypto is very prone to hype cycles.
Assets aren’t inflationary or deflationary. Prices are. Prices, denominated in crypto, have inflated through the moon this year as the value of the currencies crashed.
There are plenty of things in the world with naturally or artificially fixed supply. Anyone pitching them as deflationary is talking tripe.
real estate has a lot of lag though so you are probably paying above market price for homes today
For me, Tesla was the flashing red sign, it's market cap was something close to that of the entire auto industry combined. I had a big expense coming up this year, so I went ahead and sold a bunch of stock in January.
'You can't time the market' would preclude both, but I think GP is talking about scenario 2 and you are talking about scenario 1.
Exactly. My favorite one was about Cloudflare stock. Look at the responses in [0] when it was more than $210 per share, For Bitcoin reaching >$60K 'This isn't even close to what will be the all time high.' [1] and I suggested many to run away from the market [2] and one said 'Stock market up 1% today on both this news and decades-high inflation.' which that obviously didn't age well.
So as you can see, it looks like so far I (and many others) were able to time the market and predict the 2022 crash, especially in crypto. [3]
[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29355360
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26840880
If I predict this coin flip will be heads, and I flip it, and it is heads… does that mean I can predict coin flips? What if I do it three times in a row?
What if I do it 10 times in a row? [1]
We have loads of information available to us which is correlated with stock market performance.
With enough information about the coin's motion while it is in the air, one might be able to predict a coin flip pretty accurately too.
The other three citations are basic speculation from Apr 2021, and 6-7 months ago. Not sure how this counts as “timing” the market.
Gold and crypto protect against inflation.
Bonds should be 20-40 percent of a portfolio.
Apple and MSFT and the rest of big tech are safe havens.
It's always a good time to buy a home, as supply is at a generational low and will remain like that for a decade, we will become like Canada so you shouldn't wait to buy.
My favorite one is, you can't time the markets. Quite obviously a lot of people correctly timed the market's trends starting around the end of 2021, and the reasoning was pretty sound. I'm kicking myself today for dismissing them.