But that's unnecessary. If developers build more luxury housing, that'll reduce the price of existing housing, such that it becomes affordable.
Again, in principle, if you just keep building, the market would eventually sort this out. Of course, in the process, you'll overbuild housing proportionally to the investment demand. Once the investment demand leaves, the market will crash, which isn't necessarily a great plan either. And we are talking about a lot of finite resources being misallocated in the meantime, while the market forces figure this out.
If you'd like to resolve this problem faster than the market would naturally sort it out, and harness market forces to do so rather than naively fighting them, it makes sense to cut out the excess, artificial investment demand in the meantime. Sure, it would be better to have not created that problem in the first place, but, here we are.
When markets work they are very good at finding prices. But when they fail you get this sort of thing.
There needs to be a lot of planned intervention in the housing sector. Entities with a lot of capital need to build the houses that people need to live in where they need to live in them and then let them live in them.
The market will not do that.
People who are pro-market forces (such as myself) believe strongly that if you were allowed to build apartment buildings in neighborhoods like this that enough capital absolutely would be raised to raise supply. After all, you could take the current house I rent now and put in two walls for under 50k and start renting it out as a duplex two families but that is currently illegal. Hard to blame the market forces for this.
Though as a maximalist on this I'm still upset this is the best compromise we can get since the lot of this house is definitely big enough for more than just 2/4 units.
The house I live in is rented which means it actually wouldnt be eligible since the owner must live in the house for 3 years after turning it into a duplex.
Maybe this will incentivize owners of houses like this to sell to people who are willing to divide it in two? I hope so! But not sure.
Ha, did not know about the three year ownership requirement, classic CA NIMBYism. Still progress.
If you took government control out of the market prices would plummet. Any plank will do, supply, financial backing or interest rates and the whole thing comes crashing down. That’s the real problem, how to cause a 20% “correction” and not 80%.
My house is 8 hours from Vancouver, 8 hours from Calgary, 5 hours from Banff, it’s a town of 10,000 people, it was built in 1904 and is 2500 sqft. It’s been modestly renovated and is worth $950,000. The market is insane.
If so, revelstoke like Vancouver is actually pretty hemmed in by water and mountains. There isn’t an infinite amount of easy to build on land like the on the prairies.
Quality of life in revelstoke is probably amazing! Small town, ski hill, mountains, biking, snowmobiling, fishing, lakes, rivers, airport, and lots of jobs
Demand will always exceed supply in desirable locations, that is part of what makes them desirable. Would you spend 30% of you and your wife’s income to secure a plot in such a paradise? 40%? 50%? Lots of people will take the bet and risk. If you lose and go bankrupt well then you move to the easily affordable town in the equivalent of the fly over states. Odds are the million dollar mortgage will get inflated away you just have to tread water while interest rates are historically low until you can juice your income or hourly rate up enough to make the million dollars you are in debt seem trivial.
Oh it’s already inflated away 30% in less than a year. It was 30% of my income.
What is happening in Dallas which has no zoning rules? (Or am I thinking of Austin Texas?)
I do not know, but it would be useful for this debate
Houston is booming I hear.
They're cheaper because they can still expand outward more than SF, LA, NY, etc before hitting inconvenient geography. Lots of other places that benefit from this too, of course, not just Texas.
So I guess it works.
In any case, all three have rampant HOAs which serve the same purpose as zoning.
I was defending a "planned intervention".
If the last few decades have taught us anything, it'd that location (and every social category that location encodes) matters to people more than luxury, or rather a desirable location is the biggest luxury.
This is why a 3 BD fixer-upper in Palo Alto will cost more than a luxury 5 bedroom house in East San Jose.
To have any effect on housing prices I desirable places, you'd have to build gobs more housing in the highly desirable places, but those are usually the places most opposed to new housing development. And if you build a little bit more, because location dominates all, the existing housing would be as expensive as the new luxury housing in that location, because there is always a higher demand/supply ratio to live in Palo Alto than for East San Jose.
By the same token, building luxury housing in less desirable places won't change things unless you somehow make those places more desirable, but that takes a lot more than new luxury apartments. You usually have to change the kind of people that inhabit that location.
We absolutely need to build more housing of all categories everywhere, but it won't have much effect on housing costs until we address transportation, public education, and crime, the massive factors that affect housing costs.
Targeting stuff that isn't currently residential would be a much easier starting point.
IMO, but more controversially, it goes even further: in the long run, especially with fast transportation and digital communications, it's hard to see certain places ever getting "affordable" given today's wealth distributions. Some locations are going to be in higher demand due to non-human-development related factors (weather, scenery, etc). Others due more to development factors: NYC is more in-demand than if it was an empty bunch of land because we've already done a bunch of development there. (That latter case is especially interesting because it shows how development can both increase supply AND demand, it's not solely something that affects supply.) So if some places are inherently going to be more in-demand than others, and you build more when the market price is currently $X, prices won't fall very quickly at all as you get the people who otherwise want to live there, but couldn't do $X but would do it for $X-1, $X-2, etc, now re-interested in the area!
Agreed, and human development is a major part of that. NYC is a cultural center of the world, which is a result of its human development, and that has a tremendous currency and gravity over and above Manhattan's physical grid.
Not really: Say there's one free acre of land in town. You could build one mansion on it, or a highrise with 100 apartments.
Building the mansion isn't going to move the needle on any existing housing at all, as it's just one unit.
Locally, when I see people complain about luxury housing being built, it's because the developer is building high-spec townhomes and selling them for $800k+. Instead of lower-spec townhomes at $500k. The developer can't fit appreciably more homes in the same footprint (they're all 3-4 stories tall here - reducing size likely means one fewer stories). And the market will bear $800k+, so that's what we get.
The real answer is build even more homes. Or allow high-rises on the same lots.
In theory, the family that buys the $800k townhome came from somewhere. The smaller house they vacated is now open for somebody else (who in turn moved out of a studio flat that's now open, and on down).
A developer will, indeed. More profit. But an acre is small enough that it could just as well be a rich individual buyer, in which case they'll build what they like.
There's a half-acre plot for sale nearby for nearly $2M, I'm curious if it ends up being bought by an IPO millionaire to build a small mansion or by some developer to put up two-story apartments. Could go either way.
Local to me, redevelopment of a lot with an existing SFH tends to be another SFH because of zoning (unfortunately - many of the lots would be perfect for a nice duplex or very small apartment block).
Larger lots tend to be bought by corporate developers, both because they have the resources to develop it fully and also because they frequently have to battle NIMBYs for a while to get re-zoning approved (I tend to side with the developers, except when they buy parkland to develop, but that’s a whole other discussion).
And do they want to live in that mansion surrounded by multi-unit buildings built by developers buying the nearby acres? Also seems unlikely.
Or, they didn’t sell it and are just seeking rent on it, now. For this effect to really work, the number of home-owners should equal the number of homes.
Right now, there are many, many fewer home-owners than homes.
That's fine, it still provides housing for someone. And there are people who actually prefer to rent, so it's good to have rental units available.
Problematic is when they hold on to it and keep it empty, thus occupying space but providing housing for no one.
(Slightly higher because it is mathematically impossible for anyone to move if there are no empty homes, and they sometimes have to sit vacant while being renovated or are in the process of being sold)
(I say this sitting in the middle of the LA metropolis between two almost undeveloped hillsides of ~10 acres each, haha; and a thousand more people in this neighborhood would be significant for us (maybe? dunno the actual pop count) but nothing to LA as a whole, AFAIK)
However, once that high end market pressure has been abated, then there a real and hard limits to the amount of high end housing that can/will be available to low income customers. Instead of being available cheaply, this high-end housing stock will end up being used as a vacation house or a short the rental, neither of which actually help reduce local demand for housing.
There are many markets the the number you can sell far exceeds the available land to build.
I fail to see how lower demand for high end housing makes it more economical to build mid-range housing? The price for that housing will be lower and land to buiody it on will be taken up by lower density high end housing.
High end housing construction is better than no construction, but please don't pretend it is sufficient to solve the need for other types of construction.
Developers today build low density single family homes often due to zoning. If the law says you can build 3000 sqft on a given lot, the most profitable thing to build is probably single family. But if they were allowed 30,000 sqft or 300,000 sqft then you’re almost surely going to get multi family instead. At that point high end and mid range condos will likely both be profitable, but developer returns would be better for the former (if they can find buyers). So as high end buyers become more scarce, more developers will transition to mid range
If you mean classic "free" market failure, then I would disagree. The housing market is replete with constraints that are imposed by government. I think it is more accurate to say that it is a classic regulatory failure (at least in some jurisdictions).
Depends how big the "area" is that you're thinking about. The effect of increasing housing supply is well-studied. Demand can only grow as fast as the population does. If one area experiences increasing demand, then another area will have decreasing demand, comparatively.
(AFAIK) Venice is pretty much entirely shit house -> excellent house development, with some multi-unit (townhouses). DTLA is shit building -> modern condos / luxury apts.
AFAIK in both places a secondary effect of all development is that each area becomes more desirable. I guess, sure, if one stopped becoming more desirable the pull from the other would change demand between the two, but, a) they're not, they're both developing, b) (anecdotally) that's a drop in the bucket compared to the overall demand, and c) they have sufficiently different appeals that the demand isn't coming from the same people.
There's no such thing as unlimited demand for luxury housing. Build enough and the rent will fall for the existing housing stock.
Moving requires finding a home somewhere that they can afford. The fact that they’ve been subjected to rising rents rather than a financial windfall like nearby homeowners… makes that far more difficult for them
If they couldn’t afford to buy then they got to take advantage of a locale they desired at a lower price, another benefit of renting.
(While it would be nice if anyone could live — and own — anywhere they like without worrying about price or competing demand from the billions of other humans around, that’s so far away from reality it’s not worth discussing.)
According to this reasoning, if Ferrari builds more cars, Fiats will get less expensive.
I don’t think that’s how it’s supposed to work.
We treat that weird situation as obvious undersupply in the car market, but somehow expect it with houses. Why should old, used houses sell for more than their purchase price?
2 scenarios come to mind:
1. Ferrari decrease their sale prices, thus they are more affordable for all, thus exerting price pressure on Fiat.
2. People somehow have a bucket more money and now buy Ferraris. But with all this money sloshing around, Fiat might as well up their prices because it'd make little difference on the end customers purchase decision.
In either case, the Ferrari and the Fiat are closer on price but the price pressure on Fiat varies. Curious to know your thoughts?
Lets build shitty buildings that will last for decades. Affordable housing is and will always be a horrible idea. Build and build until you get a surplus and suddenly tons of housing is affordable.
This is like saying food banks are a horrible idea, and we should just focus on job growth so everyone can afford to buy their own food. It comes across as really tone deaf to ignore that some people need help now and that even though it isn’t a complete solution, feeding one person today or getting one person off the street into newly constructed affordable housing makes a real difference to them.
The quality of the building is determined by building codes
Building codes set the lower bounds of acceptable quality of a building, which is good but not all-encompassing (and for a good reason).
This is not an easy problem - and as soon as you try and alert people to the fact that you're going to fix it the market will respond and the problem will occur.
This issue isn't that the laws will move too quickly but that the open intent to pass those laws will spook the market and cause a panic - which is actually a lot worse if you want to deflate the market because any aide or support you'd want to provide is going to come in well after the market has already responded.
And, to return to my main point above... when that happens people with a lot of free capital sitting around are going to be able to game the system and make a bunch of money off of it. So wealth inequality will increase and it's likely a lot of folks will be in an absolutely terrible spot.
Most people aren’t selling. So they haven’t lost.
And how would you limit the effect if housing dropped for the many other reasons prices drop?? You don’t.
This is the big problem the government has: it is very difficult to unwind this mess through policy without triggering a cascade. Likely it will come eventually, they just want to ensure it’s not their party in office when the shoe finally drops.
Not quite true. It would be truer if they have no debt.
But having a large debt, and negative equity, makes a family very vulnerable economically.
folks who gamble with money have to accept the risk part of the equation, whatever vessel that may be. if somebody invested in tech stocks few months ago they are now probably crying in the corner.
And also don't forget that whenever "everybody loses some money" the people at the top are in a great position to grab an even bigger slice of the pie.
Whether or not you feel for the pain these people would go through, you're going to feel pain when it ripples out the rest of the economy.
I do think it would have been better if they hadn’t announced it was limited to 2 years but that’s not practical.
I’m a huge proponent of the “build more supply” side. But that takes time. And in addition, there is a huge 2 year gap of supply creation that didn’t happen because of the pandemic.
This may help ease some of that pandemic related imbalance.
I'm dubious that Canada's policy will achieve that, as I understand it they exempt purchases by foreign students which is already a major avenue for foreign investment property purchases. If they limited resident aliens to a single piece of property which they also lived in, that would be something but my understanding is that they don't.
It's amazing to me how resistant people are to the idea that housing is expensive because there aren't enough homes for people to live in. It's always a search for exotic explanations like foreign buyers and mysterious empty apartments.
I imagine there are enough homes in both America and Canada (they are two of the largest countries after all). But it's all about location. Very few can even afford to move out to the middle of nowhere just to own land. And not many people that can are willing to turn their potentially short commute to work into a 90+ minute trek everyday.
Even with an increase in work from home, there's the whole entertainment aspect of living in the city that makes it a hard sell. When I mean middle of nowhere, I mean a small "town" whose businesses amount to a liquor store, some off brand shopping market, a burger joint, and a 20 year outdated public library. Anything else you need is in the suburbs 30 miles out, and Downtown will be another 30-40 after that.
You will quickly bore of any ventures in town and seek a drive to the city where there's actual events going on. If you're a recluse you can make it work, but I can understand millenial aged people not jiving with that style
But that's difficult because cities have all these veto points. It takes forever to get new construction going, right? Exactly. That's why we aren't building enough, because in the current regulatory environment we can't. That's what people talk about when they talk about NIMBYism as the cause of the housing crisis.
The not so radical solution is to make it easier to build new homes where people want to live.
The jobs left quickly enough that our physical infrastructure couldn't keep up. That implies that jobs are more fluid than building and that therefore that's probably the easier approach to getting jobs and housing in balance.
Increasing density in places that are already built up is much harder. You have to remove the people and things that are already there. If you do something wrong, there are many people in the area who can be negatively affected.
Building permitting regulations are written using the ashes of fires that started from a single house and burned down an entire city.
And often the density of “rural” areas is comparable to the big cities as even in rural areas most of the population is in small cities.
I'm not going to pretend there isn't some literal gatekeeping going on here that make this more difficult than necessary. But I'm also not exactly surprised that in cities as already densely packed as Los Angeles that there aren't exactly acres or hectacres of land just sitting around to be built "where people want to live". That's how we ended up with tiny studio apartments everywhere that still cost way too much.
Part of it is simply physical limitation. Land (unlike so many arbiturary policies nowadays) is a finite resource. Made more finite when the pareto principle kicks in.
I live in Manhattan. LA is far from densely packed.
It’s idiotically packed, seemingly to maximise time spent in traffic and minimise the number of bars, restaurants and essentials within walking distance of the average resident. But visit Tokyo or Paris if you want to see true density.
Depends on what you consider "LA". the "LA county" that extends from Lancaster to Long Beach (some 90 sq Mi) is extremely sparse. But good luck convincing someone doing business downtown to go all the way out to Lancaster to buy homes.
The "City of Los Angeles" that makes up the 10 square miles of Downtown and some immediately surrounding suburbs is densely packed IMO. There's not exactly acres of fields waiting to be tilled for living quarters, and it's not like there already isn't skyscrapers of studio apartments to reside in (that ofc is still way too expensive).
Maybe not to NY levels, but it's not a competition and I don't see that as a positive personally. especially when we can both admit which city has superior public transportation. I avoid driving downtown at all costs, but there's not really any good alternatives when I do need to do business there.
I question which issue between the two of land and transportation would take longer to resolve. I feel they've both been mutli-decade crusades at this point.
Also, https://noparkinghere.com/
And I wonder how much space is lawns
But there are acres and acres of single family homes in both urban areas that could become mid rise apartments.
The developing world has even denser examples [1], e.g. the #2 entry of Manila is about twice as dense as Paris.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_world_cities_by_popula...
2. They make more land all the time. Look at a map of Boston in 1800. In fact, look at an old map of almost any city near a large body of water and compare it to today and you'll find a lot more land being used.
At a great environmental cost. Thankfully society is a bit more careful about environment destruction than in the days where all garbage was dumped on the shoreline to create landfill and build on it.
https://estuarypress.com/hrma-photo-post/filling-the-san-fra...
https://priceonomics.com/what-parts-of-san-francisco-are-bui...
It is true that many cities have filled in shorelines to create more buildable/usable surface.
It is not true that cities do this all the time.
You mean, if we had the density of Manhattan or Shanghai, our housing would be as cheap as Manhattan or Shanghai? I'm not sure people would like that (given that those places are more expensive in general). The best example in the states is Houston, but it is horrible sprawl (so housing isn't being built exactly where people want to live, but continues to build outward). Tokyo is the best example internationally, but they have special conditions (housing depreciates since second-hand houses are not popular, decreasing population, liberal definitions on what is needed to call something a home).
But yes, the implication of a housing abundance agenda is that places will change. I think it's generally underrated exactly how much the cities we know today changed during the 20th century as they grew in population.
That said, you don't really need a lot of high rises to drastically increase density. Even row houses and low rise apartments make a pretty large difference and would be more than enough to meet demand for most cities that are experiencing a crunch.
I would think it might to some degree, but there would be several cut-off points, as living conditions change with more density, and people who previously wanted to move to a place might not like how a place changes as density increases.
With a highway, you can add as many lanes as you want, and the experience of driving on it isn't changed much.
Yes, plenty of people are discouraged from moving to a hot city due to the lack of supply. Increasing supply then moves discouraged demand into actual demand. Otherwise why do dense cities (like Shanghai, NYC, Manila) still experience housing shortages?
If the place is desirable, demand increases to catch up to the new supply, bringing us to the same place where we are now. Even if we built a lot of housing in a desirable place, enough that we hit a cut-off point: in a hundred years or so, we might have just had more children to soak up that supply (like what happens with agriculture surplus). Things go until an equilibrium is reached (where prices are high enough that demand is discouraged, or the place becomes undesirable to really reduce demand).
It's possible (and likely) that housing in Shanghai, NYC, and Manila just have not reached a supply-demand equilibrium yet, because housing policy still constrains supply. There's nothing requires that demand is effectively infinite in these cities, or that demand will keep growing as more housing is built.
Let's say unfilled demand for housing in San Francisco sits at 100,000 units right now (making up numbers; they don't matter). If we could magically build those 100,000 units tomorrow, yes, I do expect we will induce some more demand, because home/rent prices will drop. So let's say we build another 100,000 units. Maybe we get some more demand, because home/rent prices drop more. So we do it again, but not forever.
Because my feeling here is that the main driver of more demand in SF would be drops in home/rent prices. Those prices can't drop to zero; they will always have a cost, and it seems unlikely to me that the cost will drop low enough -- no matter how many units are built, within the physical constraints of the space -- such that there will still always be unmet demand. And home prices will still always be propped up by housing policy to some extent; the city would never implement unrestricted housing development with no hurdles. But maybe the "equilibrium" price can be something significantly less ridiculous than it is today.
Equilibriums are not hypothetical. The fact that increasing supply can induce more demand is well known in many areas (expressways being just one). Cities take off, and building booms don't reduce prices like a recession or bust will.
> the city would never implement unrestricted housing development with no hurdles.
Not many people would like to live in such a city (who wants to live in Houston?), so that on its own would limit demand.
> But maybe the "equilibrium" price can be something significantly less ridiculous than it is today.
Sure. Perhaps a lot more WFH will eventually eliminate or reduce critical mass feedback loops that lead to these problems in the first place (e.g. why live in Seattle when you can live in Toledo?).
5 stories. Perfect height.
* Let everyone shop at the couple of good supermarkets and hope the supermarket can keep the shelves stocked and deal with the crowds.
* Get those other supermarkets to start stocking stuff other than sardines.
The right answer is probably a blend of those.
Which further creates a spiraling effect where even recluses will feel obligated to move to the city just for anything that you can't / is very difficult to get from a town. Turns out it isn't that fun when the majority of your neighborhood doesn't share your generation or interests. Especially for young people still looking to find someone to settle down with.
The NIMBY housing policies and restrictions on building new housing are a massive part of sprawl, and with it the huge amount of excessive carbon emissions from commuting in single passenger cars.
A dense city is about the best organization of people for the environment. To get things you need, you travel the furthest distance. You centralize utilities and infrastructure. You preserve natural habitats. You reduce the effective footprint, actual and resource-wise, of the average person by huge amounts. It maximizes the effectiveness of public transport, and makes private transport less valuable. It makes transport modes like bikes, ebikes, scooters, or even walking viable. And people generally seem to prefer it.
Of course it's America, the incentives are completely messed up. The carbon tax exists as the one policy that everyone agrees would have helped reduce fossil fuel use to help avert global warming.
The other big environmental issue we face (well that we aren't facing up to) is the sixth mass extinction, which is primarily coming from sprawl. And the simple solution to that is to property tax the shit out of land in the exurbs and suburbs so that urban organization of housing is cheaper than suburban and rural, which is currently the opposite.
The externality to sprawl is the illusion that land is infinite. It most certainly is not. The real abundant supply in modern human architecture is going vertical, or even subterranean.
To get back to liberal cities where housing supply is being restricted, this is DIRECTLY causing environmental impacts, and has been for decades. It's not just a racial issue, it is very much an environmental one.
You can't really tax people money they don't have. Maybe it'd work in suburbs, but generally (at least in american cities) the more rural areas consist of
1. Farmland owners who likely contribute resources and get tax deductions anyway 2. mid-low income homeowners far from the city who's property cost as a whole pales in comparison to the cities. Either because of mass emmigration (which can be "White Flight" at worst, or simply dwindling resources/income at best in an evolving world) or simply happening to own/inherit land before costs went out of control.
There's not much to squeeze out of these people to begin with. And not exactly any alternative land to offer them that wouldn't be to their massive benefit (Again, this land isn't exactly valuable to begin with, comparatively speaking). Housing struggles to keep up as is and can't really afford this altruistic effort to try and consolidate everyone into a densely packed area.
But a long term phase-in over a decade, which also is difficult to sustain over successive administrations and controls of congress, would be ideal. Obviously American governance is too incompetent to achieve that.
The carbon tax is for the current largest environmental threat: global warming.
But the sixth mass extinction will probably be the next big environmental issue once GW mitigations come into play. And the key to that is a big land tax to change incentives. And the same issues arise: how to avoid shock pricing and instead phase in over an economically adaptable timeframe.
It even has the same technological potential solutions but lack of supply: vertical farms and artificial meat have the potential to eliminate huge swathes of land that are currently used for 1) grazing and 2) crops that feed grazing animals.
Vertical farming and artificial meat should be getting massive research subsidies right now. Every research university should have substantial grants pursuing these. Because the habitats that we can reclaim back to nature and hopefully avert a total collapse of the "species web" is very important.
I feel we are constantly playing russian roulette with extinctions. Was this species so important that everything collapses? No. Well, how about this one? This one?
I mean, insect populations are dropping. Insects. Very concerning.
Sprawl is only bad in big cities. In a city of 250k, it's not really a big deal.
The waste of time, energy and the resulting pollution are mind blowing.
I recently had a recruiter try to convince me to move back to the midwest by throwing numbers about how median housing prices were over $500k less in my hometown then where I am now on the west coast. I don't need a house with my lifestyle right now, but I'll probably just move back if/when that changes. I enjoy living in a west coast city but not at the cost of 500k-1mil additional housing costs for a smaller place with less land. I'd be just as content moving back and using some of that extra money to travel or fund a long-term sabbatical.
It is cheaper for sure, but it's not quite as I expected. Most of the desirable homes have doubled or tripled since 2020. They are still under a $1 million and usually have quite a bit more land, but most medium size cities have seen huge increases in housing costs and rent.
They are about 0.5% of my neighborhood and are built by all sorts of people, but always for the same reason: Housing is an asset class. In some places, its expected return is always positive even without rental income.
You should buy in those places. If you leave it empty, you get an appreciating asset, and the demand for homes to live in remains the same.
And then, there are places like Kharian, where there is huge demand for the idea of housing, but the living is mostly done elsewhere. See: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_fOYJ3_ZppM
At least in my area, developers spend over half of the expense of the home on land (including the legal/political costs of getting it up zoned) and “horizontal development” (utilities, impact fees, permit costs, roads, environmental mitigation, drainage, etc.)
If just breaking ground costs you $400k per lot, then it doesn’t make a ton of sense to build 1500 square foot starter homes that will sell for $600k instead of 3500 square foot McMansions that will go for $1.2mn
Like, there is no need to rail against people not changing their mind two years before you might reasonably expect them too. Besides, it would behoove you to reserve your judgement here and let results speak for themselves lest you fall into the same behavior you decry.
Good shout on the whole "build more houses to have more houses" thing though.
EDIT it's been three years and not two
https://www.scmp.com/economy/china-economy/article/3012312/c...
I have to wonder if it is ever possible to build enough in the places everyone wants to live for it to become cheap?
Manhattan is extremely dense and yet, incredible expensive. More expensive than nearly every less-dense area. So density isn't helping drive cost down.
It shouldn't be. That is describing the demand side of the equation.
That’s it.
> reject the idea that houses have to be appreciating assets
Particularly this. This is the outlook in the UK and it so problematic because normal people want this "property empire". Its become a source of content creation on YouTube or boasting on social media platforms. So fustrating
(a) National zoning
(b) A culture that abhors second hand housing (so structures don't appreciate like land does). Housing that depreciates is no longer a sound investment.
(c) Liberal definition on minimal standard housing to rent (central heating not required, toilets can be shared, no personal shower or even a shower at all in the building you are renting a room in, small spaces are OK).
Maybe not this one:
(d) Not very open to immigration at all, have a decreasing population.
That sounds tremendously wasteful. All housing will have to be built new now?
> (d) Not very open to immigration at all, have a decreasing population.
This is probably the biggest reason housing is depreciating in Japan, especially outside of Tokyo.
It is if you're building concrete houses common in much of the world.
If you're building houses that are common houses in Japan, it's not nearly as bad.
When you think of a house as something that not only you will live in - but also will be the vast majority of your net worth that you pass down to your children - then building houses the Western way makes more sense.
When a house is just something you live in - you think of it more like renters do.
Well ya. You don't build to have your home last for more than 30-40 years, which can save some materials. We should get better at recycling and renewing building material, maybe the Japanese counteract things that way?
I'm very skeptical it would save any non-trivial amount in materials. What would you leave out?
Housing in the USA is already very cheaply built, 2x4s and drywall and the cheapest hardware they builder can get. Such houses easily last over a 100 years barring some disaster.
To build a house that crumbles to unlivable in 30 years, you'd have to intentionally design it to do that. Which sounds terrible from an environmental waste perspective.
In many places tear down and rebuild is cheaper than remodeling, especially when energy costs are taken into account.
It's no surprise to anyone that a house needs some maintenance, that's a given. If someone lives in it and keeps up with basic maintenance, it'll last many generations.
> the average house isn’t that old so the jury is still out on some of it
I suspect the average house will never be that old, simply because a lot more houses are getting built all the time bringing down the average.
But plenty of 100+ year old houses, even here in California where most construction is more recent.
> In many places tear down and rebuild is cheaper than remodeling
Remodeling is a whole different topic. Yes, remodeling a house to be much larger or much nicer (or both) can be very expensive.
But on the topic of simply living in the same house in the same configuration as it was originally built, for 100+ years (multiple generations surely), there's no need to remodel. Only maintenance.
If we assume your idea of close to perfectly recyclable houses comes true, i think people would have to really dial down their expectations and standards. No more drywall, particle boards everywhere. Tiles.. forget it, kitchen counters made by reclaimed wood etc
I'm really not sure. On the one hand, I agree it is wasteful. On the other hand, I personally like living in a new home.
> No more drywall, particle boards everywhere. Tiles.. forget it, kitchen counters made by reclaimed wood etc
The average kitchen where I live is renovated every 10 years, so the drywall, much of the electrical and plumbing, the floor, tile backsplash, etc...is redone. Bathrooms are also on a 10 year schedule. You can let the reno slide, of course, or perhaps you can do a higher quality reno and hope it lasts longer than a decade. (I'm looking at a kitchen reno right now and my house was built in 2016...the builders just made too many mistakes, but $150k to redo the kitchen...ugh)
In Japan, they don't do the reno every 10 years, they just rebuild the house every 30. How is that much different?
Being in a 200 year old house already puts you WAY into the far outliers - the median US house is 37 years old.
>(c)
Keep in mind 1LDKs (living room, dining room, kitchen) come with everything you'd expect a full apartment to come with, and are still very cheap in Tokyo compared to most metropolises and big cities. Many DKs also come with personal shower, small kitchen and toilet. Their spaces are generally on par with what you'd get in bigger European cities, for an equal or lower price. Not bad considering it is Tokyo.
>(d)
I mean, between the US and Japan, Japan isn't that much more difficult to immigrate to, unless you expect to get by with just English. Decreasing population also isn't a problem considering population numbers are getting far too big for comfort among developed countries.
Could you elaborate on what this paragraph means? How do we "lock" ourselves in here in Europe? I can go out _today_ buy a rundown house and tear it down. If the cost of renovating it exceeds the cost of building new, it's financially sound to do. Unless i'm buying some historically important building there are zero restrictions.
When the profit margins say "building apartments isn't profitable" and the laws say "well whatever", nothing's gonna get torn down for apartments. Turns out when you build things to last and the mentality is that a 30yo house should still be in good shape, there's not a lot of profits to be gained tearing it down and building an apartment complex compared to renovating it a little and selling it to some upper middle class family with more dough to spend.
And yes, there are ways around this, e.g. turning that SFH into a sharehouse. Why that isn't happening more is a whole different story.
Japan is much more homogeneous culturally, and as an immigrant you will always be a stranger. Even if people will be nice and polite towards you, they likely won't be able to treat you as they would treat a Japanese, because you'd miss the cultural context which builds up from early childhood on.
If you want a house that depreciates faster, manufactured homes are an option. It's not at all obvious to me though that a structure that depreciates faster will necessarily be more affordable than a traditional house that has been properly maintained. Even if it is, building a new home every N years will almost certainly consume more resources over the medium to long term.
I don't want to live in the same place my whole life and I don't want every Canadian city to look and feel the same.
It will also make sure that you get enough leeway to build in all the corruption you want. Or at least all the NIMBYism you want.
"Yeah, to build in this region you have to pay this huge tax unless you fill out this form and we approve."
Any time you build an intelligent (read: complex) system you rely on the goodwill of the people that build it and maintain it to do what you want the system to do. This in turn gives those people great opportunities to take advantage of others.
A national dividend that pays out land value taxes democratizes access to land for all citizens of that nation and thereby makes it pointless to have exclusive access over specific plots of land for the sake of rent seeking. It only makes sense to own a plot of land if you want to "work" that land or rephrased, when society collectively agrees that you should have this plot of land.
Ya: a land value tax is just a property tax that ignores improvements (charing based on what could be built rather than what is built). But it would totally destroy the low income housing market (since property owners of old run down low-end rentals would be seriously penalized for not building new luxury apartments).
In the USA, not really. Today's new luxury apartment is tomorrow's old but affordable housing. Given the expense in building something, there isn't much cost difference to developers in building low-income units or high-income units, and if they go with the latter they will lose their shirts (Not to mention the low-income tenants of those houses would have to pay land use taxes similar to their richer neighbors).
> For example empty lots or parking lots are low value and would be turned into housing,
There really aren't many of those left in the cities people want to live in. Undergound parking and multi-level parking garages are already a thing in dense locations where property values alone mean turning something into a parking lot is bad use (unless you are saving up the parking lots to create something rand like Vulcan's South Lake Union project in Seattle).
I'm still all for it, but we would probably have to sink a lot more money into public housing to prevent a bloody revolution from occurring.
It should not be illegal for such housing to exist.
I think a dormitory or barracks style housing is perfectly acceptable as a solution but putting the burden of supplying bathrooms on private businesses or implicitly requiring people shit in buckets in their one and only room is not.
I might feel that a gigabit fiber connection is necessary to maintain basic human dignity ;-) but I don't think that should be enforced via law. One should be able to opt out for something more afforable.
> I'm reasonably sure we can meet housing needs and still maintain basic human dignity.
The proof of your hope would be in the pudding, and right now we have no pudding.
For the person living in it, yes. For other people living in the area, bringing in a large number of people who are just one step above living in a tent, may have impacts on the neighborhood that they don't want. Much of the resistance to building more housing is this at various different levels.
Why yes, indeed, it is!
The problem is that your primary residence is a tax-advantaged vehicle in Canada (infinite tax-free capital gains). So the optimal choice is always to buy as much real estate as you possibly can. People also use their children to hold deeds when they want to expand into second and third homes. The tax advantaged status drives the Canadian housing bubble
People are regularly talking about "housing cannot be both a good investment and affordable". In Canada, it is a 'good investment' by tax law.
Look at how much real estate prices have diverged from rent in Toronto. It is mind-boggling. The gap's growth accelerated with COVID-era quantitative easing.
I think most people would agree that measures can be taken on both the supply and demand sides. It’s a rather extraordinary claim to suggest that root causes don’t exist on the demand side, and that the issue can only be addressed from supply side. That’s an opinion on a debatable topic stated as fact, and it may be a popular opinion among the HN crowd, but that doesn’t make it more of a fact.
If foreign buyers are using Canadian housing as an investment vehicle and to park assets, that additional demand decreases supply for Canadian citizens who require housing for shelter.
Of course, they can (and should) directly address the supply side as well. But there’s the possibility that foreign buyers’ demand will continue to outpace supply, leading to ghost cities like there are China, with 65M+ empty homes. Canada is under no obligation to perpetuate that.
If you have a lot of money in places like China and Russia or if you have money from graft, it could all be taken away quickly. So these people are very willing to buy something real in a "safer" country, even if it has a negative ROI.
This is not the only problem with housing in general, but it is a contributing factor that does not provide value for people that are looking to actually live somewhere.
I don't think people from Russia or China can do this anymore. At least the Russians can no longer do it in the West. As for the mainland Chinese, the CCP has blocked capital flight and they have even blocked cryptocurrency. This happened two years ago ie. unless they already got their money out of China two years earlier, they can't buy anything in Canada
EDIT it happened three years ago and not two years
https://www.scmp.com/economy/china-economy/article/3012312/c...
Alternatively, provide a dedicated asset class for that, so they can put their money in something other than housing
These are contributing factors, but the energy that drives the bubble is capital, and bubbles have a way of becoming self-perpetuating. When a bubble becomes critical, you can't "build out of it", unless you think you can actually produce 10% more houses in a year, every year!
I don't know what the solution to the problem is, but I fear where it's heading. If people cannot get housing, anarchy and revolution are in the making. Then it's heads on pikes, French Revolution style.
some do, others just want to safely park capital away from their own government reach (China/Russia/various *stans/corrupted countries).
In a closed system with two economies, yes, true. But in reality, many nations either run a trade deficit (exports < imports), or a trade surplus (exports > imports)
https://www.scmp.com/economy/china-economy/article/3158048/c...
They are conservatives, this "foreign buyer ban" bandaid is put in place by liberals. NDP and Greens offer nothing different. A quadri-partisan consensus on ignoring the root cause.
I do think there's another major cause - cheap money. It's fuelling a lot of the meteoric price growth and making the housing market even more of a wild speculative one, where all that matters is the carrying costs and not any underlying fundamentals. This one is more of a worldwide problem, and a small country like Canada cannot use monetary policy to bludgeon the housing market back into reality without bludgeoning the rest of the economy with it.
The operative word is *could*. If there's market demand for it, you could and you absolutely should do it. If there isn't, you (the builder) won't build it, and you (the tenant) won't move in.
If you focus urban planning on the big picture and allow the market to determine how many parking spots a building needs, or whether a single family neighbourhood makes any sense next to subway stops, the housing crisis will literally solve itself with private money. Instead, we keep floundering while entire generations of our under-30s struggle in precarious housing, because we are unwilling to adopt a different approach. 3/4 of discussions about 'housing affordability' at my city's council meetings are about money pits and bandaids such as airBnB bans and 'affordable housing' (can we build 30,000 units of it with taxpayer money? Didn't think so, let's move on).
If you ignore the blah-blah and focus on actions, we the voters don't really want to solve this problem. If we did, we'd act on the obvious solution.
Not really, if the municipality is in fact willing to centrally plan a city down to the micro-management level, and a different level of government wants to prevent it from happening. Some overriding is gonna have to happen here.
>Negative externalities are a very real thing
Indeed. Example: artificially embalming swathes of single-family neighbourhoods in time, right next to recently built public transit we're sinking billions into building. So let's not be selective about negative externalities and consider the ones created or exacerbated by NIMBY-driven urban planning, too.
>allowing developers to have arbitrarily many of them at arbitrarily bad levels is not the only alternative to complete and total central planning. Believe it or not there are reasonable middle grounds that allow some influence on developments from central planning to limit negative externalities while also listening to market forces. My beliefs align somewhere in this middle ground.
Sure. I too am somewhere between allowing toxic smelters next door to kindergartens and Soviet-style central planning where government owns all and builds all. Everyone's gonna align themselves somewhere in this middle ground between two contrived and straw-man extremes, all NIMBYs included. The whole debate is about where in this middle ground we ought to be. Forgive my skepticism, it's just that I've heard this middle-ground line often. And often, this is simply a rhetorical cop-out and a prelude to killing off any meaningful changes that allow for building the types of housing people want in places where they want it.
I never said some overriding isn't going to have to happen. I never said the municipality should be able to plan down to the micromanagement level. All I said was that a blanket allowance for all buildings of a certain size on any street with a bus route regardless of the route reaching the building or not was absurd.
I criticized a specific recommendation of a panel that suggested we completely override municipal planning and not allow them to address any concerns with any buildings on a street with a bus route as long as those buildings were 6 to 11 stories tall. I pointed out how it allowed for certain absurdities and was not a sound policy recommendation.
>Indeed. Example: artificially embalming swathes of single-family neighbourhoods in time, right next to recently built public transit we're sinking billions into building. So let's not be selective about negative externalities and consider the ones created or exacerbated by NIMBY-driven urban planning, too.
What you call artificial embalming others might call a status quo. It has its own negative externalities, I agree. I want more development than many people I know and don't think the status quo is sacrosanct. I also don't think the status quo is a state like any other that doesn't deserve any special consideration. I think it represents a way of life that people bought into and became part of a community with. Parts of that are bad: low density forever doesn't work. But there is a certain standard of services provided in the neighbourhood and developments need to be cognizant of that and be coordinated in ways that don't have huge adverse effects on that.
I want smart development that considers the surrounding neighbourhood in reasonable ways. I don't want 50 story condo buildings in crowded school zones without a plan to build new schools. I don't want 50 story condo buildings that aren't on highways or good public transit when traffic studies show nearby intersections are at or near peak capacity. I also don't like it when developers consistently claim buildings in my neighbourhood will end up with 76% of occupants using public transit when after the fact surveys show that number is 39%. Instead of 24% of occupants driving we end up with 61% doing so, an impact of 254% of what was predicted on traffic patterns. I also dislike that we consider each development in isolation and don't do any holistic studies on the impacts, the net result of which is four different developments within two blocks of my house each show that facilities won't be overcrowded and traffic will be "within acceptable limits" if only their development proceeds. Then the province overrides the city and approves all four at once and we get severe overcrowding and overburdened facilities.
There is also the double whammy that property taxes are based on a percentage of property value (which is lower for condos) and the percentage used is also lower for condos. The net result of this is that the municipality gets far less budget per capita and this leads to a decline in services. I'm not sure what a good solution is since we need more density but I have a lot of sympathy for people who don't think it's fair that the services of their neighbourhood are forced into a significant decline.
They also conveniently target people who can't vote, much like big taxes on out-of-province housing purchases that are very popular within Canada.
I don't agree that this is the root cause. The root cause is the artificial demand on housing created though our mass immigration policy. Canada accepts _at least_ 500,000 people per year through various channels, "temporary" foreign workers, international students (many of whom stay), refugees, and of course, normal immigration. And I am low balling that number. It could be closer to 1 million.
When you bring in an entire large city worth of people, it stands to reason that this will cause massive pressure on housing prices. Now sustain that yearly increase for decades, and you have the problem we face today.
There are 9 million people in Canada (a country of around 40M) currently living here on 10 year visa's. - Crazy!
So there you have it. How could you leave that completely out from your argument and only blame zoning laws and nimbyism?
What prevents you from just building more housing in all that extra space you have? Zoning laws and nimbyism.
That's the wrong way to look at the problem. Developers can already build in the hinterlands, but there's virtually no demand to do so because the economic activity is concentrated in the established cities. You also run into the Siberia problem where despite having massive tracts of "free/undeveloped" land in the taiga, actually inhabiting it is very expensive because of how brutal the weather can be. Unless you have something like a literal gold mine or oil well, the expense of heating the buildings and maintaining the equipment is not at all economically viable.
Vancouver may be the most constrained geographically but quite a lot of it looks suburban and could be built up if the political will existed.
Or, Canadians could choose to build nothing but single-family homes, but if they make that choice, they should own it and admit it is the real reason rather than blaming foreigners.
There is plenty of cheap, available housing in the hinterlands of Canada. And yet, nobody wants to move there. Why do you think that is? Prime locations are scarce no matter how much land mass you have.
Canada has a deep labor shortage in its urban areas, with plenty of pent-up demand for growth.
It's certainly true that if we must perpetually conserve each and every single family home in an urban area, then we'll remain housing-constrained. If that's what everyone wants to do, that's their right, but it's necessarily going to result in lower income and living standards for the country.
Funny how in the first hundred years in Canada, we didn't have any issue with housing costs, despite accepting vast amounts of refugees. I'm not saying it's not making the problem worse, but to SOLELY pin it on them is IMO willful ignorance.
if we banned all immigrants, of any kind, tomorrow, would Canada's housing prices collapse? I'd suspect not: credit is still cheap, and every day canadians still want homes.
https://www.canada.ca/en/employment-social-development/progr...
There are Twitter accounts dedicated to calling out multi-million dollar homes in Vancouver and Toronto, owned by "students".
https://www.scmp.com/economy/china-economy/article/3012312/c...
Separately, Canada's population growth rate is the lowest it's been in over a hundred years, and it isn't close. The lower trend continues for decades and decades. The last time the population growth rate was increasing was in the 1950s. So this is a very strange argument to make.
Talk about distorting statistics in bad faith to further xenophobia…
The 10 year visa is a non resident visa that allows temporary enter into Canada during that period.
It doesn’t let people work, and just because someone has the Visa doesn’t mean they’re currently living in Canada
Canada's population has increased around 4 million over the past ten years, so I don't know if that velocity of closer to million tracks.
> When you bring in an entire large city worth of people, it stands to reason that this will cause massive pressure on housing prices. Now sustain that yearly increase for decades, and you have the problem we face today.
You make it sound like those people enter Canada and then just sit there doing nothing. Which is wrong.
As long as they're LEGALLY in Canada, I don't see a problem.
They're studying/taking up jobs or whatever, and they're also spending the money that they make in Canada, in Canada. This helps the existing Canadians as well. And some of them start their own businesses. That's how the economy develops. Money should keep rolling.
> There are 9 million people in Canada (a country of around 40M) currently living here on 10 year visa's. - Crazy!
What's so crazy about that? You should check the numbers for USA.
As for the 10 year visa part. From what I know, Canada grants B1/B2 visa with a 10 year validity for businesspeople and tourists. It does not mean they can enter and stay for 10 years. They can enter, stay for sometime (they have to state how long they intend to stay at the time of entry), and then they leave. Or atleast, the vast majority of them do. They have better things to do back home.
By the way, you might also want to look into Canadians emigrating to USA. Not that there's anything wrong with it. Just saying that it happens.
However, these kinds of price spikes still happen in lots of places that have neither a ton of immigration or constraints on building, so it's not clear to me that either one is really a singular root cause.
You can believe that if you want to.
Any level-headed analysis of the situation, however, points to multiple factors at play, here -- dark actors with huge pools of dark money to park somewhere (that just so happens to be mildly appreciating on average) being one of them. A system which promotes and protects de-facto anonymization of luxury assets at scale being another. Truncating the root cause analysis simply to "supply" is simplistic at best.
Until we liberalize zoning, legalize building, and reject the idea that houses have to be appreciating assets, the issue will continue.
As much as one may want to believe that this is the right fix in the long term -- even under the best of conditions, it will take years, more like decades to pan out. Meanwhile the housing market needs relief now.
It's also a very broad statement: I never see any construction when I visit SF, but in Montreal everything is under construction all the time. There are a dozen new condo developments within a few blocks of where I live, and yet the prices of homes still rose something like 20% last year.
There isn't usually one The Root Cause for economic issues, so blanket statements about policies being "boogeyman politics" are the kinds of unlikely sentiments that I'd like to see backed up by significant evidence.
The major problem is that the vast majority of the U.S. which is not underwater in debts, has the majority of their wealth in their houses. So if building more housing led to a secular reduction in housing prices, people would get poorer.
Which means that it will never happen, because people who own housing in those areas and therefore control the entire political processs, will not accede to shooting themselves in the foot even if they are YIMBYs.
What this means then, is that the only housing that will be allowed to be built, or the only housing that will not in turn make the people of the area poorer, will be “luxury” housing, which does not lower their property values because it compensates for the drop in housing value due to greater supply by adding “amenities”, allowing them to maintain their existing house values.
The escape route for this is low income housing. Creating cheaper housing for people who couldn’t afford to buy their houses anyways, and therefore even though it leads to lower cost housing, it doesn’t lead to a drop in their house values (if anything, it may lead to an increase in their house values since it reduces virgin land that could have otherwise been used to build non low income housing that would compete with their houses).
You're conspicuously avoiding low interest rates and 30-year mortgages from that list.
When people can borrow against their entire life's earnings to buy a home, the price of a home will trend towards that of a person's entire life's earnings.
Limiting maximum mortgage terms to 9 years would do more to bring down the price of homes than dealing with anything else you've listed.
My guess is that it would increase by ~2.6 million.
But it would certainly level the playing field between the average person and 'the landlord with capital'.
So if we are so concerned about keeping the average Joe up with that landlord, why don't we go ahead and do it? [1] It's not like it's hard to run the printing presses!
[1] Unfortunately, we do do it, except instead of just handing this money out, we wrap it up in decades of indentured mortgage payments, instead. The net result is the same, with the addition of a colossal wealth transfer from borrowers to lenders.
Many companies and people buy homes currently for investment rentals. They’re competing with homebuyers. Strictly speaking I would expect the share of homes owned by landlords to rise even if prices fall.
It has the same inflationary effect on the economy. Under fractional reserve banking, loans inject money into the economy, increasing prices. The lower interest rates are, and the longer mortgage terms are, the more such money gets injected.
My guess is most homes on the market would be bought by private equity firms and retirement funds. There are a lot of confounding factors; just changing mortgage terms is not sufficient.
Or at least not bolstering the mortgage market. Fannie and Freddie practically caused the extreme leverage mortgage phenom in the US.
The idea that houses are appreciating assets doesn't come from some fundamental law or ideology. It comes from recognizing reality. There is only so much land where people want to live, and population tends to increase (we are talking about urban and suburban areas, of course), so the demand and price increase. It's pretty simple, really.
NIMBYism, zoning laws, permitting, those are always familiar and convenient boogiemen for people who don't want to do actual analysis of market factors. But, what you are really wanting to argue against is private property ownership.
If I wanted to turn my single family house into a duplex, or just tear it down and build bigger, to far closer to the property line, I'd be completely unable to do so, because the zone is R1, the minimum offset to the edge of the property is enough to part 2 F-150s lined front to back. The maximum legal usable square footage, across all levels, of the house must not exceed 40% of the square footage of the lot. Most of my property must, by regulation, be lawn, and the taller I build, the more lawn I need. There's houses with this zoning structure right next door to supermarkets.
So how is asking to be allowed to redevelop your own lot being against private property ownership? If land is so plentiful nobody wants to build taller, the land will remain very low density. But the idea of having a lot that, if razed, would be worth a million dollars, but where building a duplex is illegal is not, in any way, going against private ownership.
To answer that: consider, would me being allowed to build a joint pig farm and jet engine testing facility 10 feet from your bedroom window be compatible with your property rights?
Externalities exist. Changes in the usage-- which includes density-- of the surrounding property can have a real effect on the existing residents. Debate over zoning is just a debate over the thresholds.
This isn't to say that existing policies in any particular place are well informed. But the basic concept of setting out the characteristics of neighboring properties, particularly to the extent that these rules were done in advance of your ownership and were clearly established, not only doesn't conflict with private property rights but can help protect them.
> one is a different type of use instead of just a more dense one
Differences in density are differences in use! perhaps insubstantial ones--- ones that don't meaningfully impinge any existing residents property right, and if so they shouldn't rightfully be restricted by zoning. And obviously they are-- I'm not attempting to defend existing practices-- only arguing that the conflict is not fundamental and that people arguing over them can all be making reasonable arguments over the right thresholds.
you CAN. But that takes a while. There's always something under construction in Califnornia and a good portion of that is trying to build more apartments and housing. The time to make those don't keep up with the influx of people emmigrating to LA or otherwise leaving the parents' homes to seek their own lifestyle.
It's honestly a more feasible solution to try and convince certain companies to build in a city that is otherwise "vacant". Make it a place where people will work around, have the existing land and homes appreciate in value. That's why Amazon and Apple had such aggressive bid wars from cities to try and get them to make new campuses in their respective city areas.
We have a shortage of dense housing because it is illegal to build dense housing in the places it should exist, and where it is legal, community review processes quickly shut it down
It's a a long and expensive process and I wouldn't be surprised if some deals fell through something because the minimum expenses exceeded what some potential clients expected.
In which dense cities in Canada (or the USA) did this work, resulting in a desirable dense city with cheap housing?
You could argue that you can just keep building up and up until you cross the threshold of demand affecting the price, but without a market incentive to do that, it's wishful thinking at best. "Well the government could fund it" you could say, and indeed it can. But speaking of economic research, everytime the government has done such a thing, it causes widespread economic depression of the local area.
Housing does not suffer from induced demand like road capacity does. This is easy to disprove by reading those studies. Sure, building nicer better neighborhoods does make them more desirable but it doesn't follow that they have to be more expensive, as long as you build enough homes for people to live in. Taken to its conclusion the induced demand argument against density is an argument against improving quality of life in general, and pretty nihilistic.
[1] https://ideas.repec.org/p/fer/wpaper/146.html
[2] https://www.dropbox.com/s/oplls6utgf7z6ih/Pennington_JMP.pdf...
[3] https://docs.wixstatic.com/ugd/7fc2bf_ee1737c3c9d4468881bf14...
They issue more permits for new housing units in a year than the entire state of California does, even though California has more than double the population. (or for an East Coast comparison - they issue around 9x the housing permits that NYC does, even though the population is <50% larger).
There have been many articles written on this topic by many publications that you can find, but here's one citation: https://www.ft.com/content/023562e2-54a6-11e6-befd-2fc0c26b3...
Tokyo metro area is 14,034 km2.
Meanwhile LA is 14% parking lots or so I’ve heard.
Tokyo, with its reasonable zoning, seems to have figured out how to build densely without being absurdly expensive. The key here is that the "market" is indeed allowed to figure it out, and not as restricted by NIMBYism.
The best thing the government can do right now is to get out of the way in regards to building more units.
Houses are not appreciating assets, in general. They are durable goods but tend to degrade if not maintained. Land is often an appreciating asset for the reasons you mentioned. And of course the "NIMBYism, zoning laws, permitting" play a part in that, by restricting the land available for various desired uses. Removing these factors would help, though of course it wouldn't completely negate the tendency for land prices to rise, especially in densely populated areas.
> But, what you are really wanting to argue against is private property ownership.
Removing private property ownership wouldn't make more land available, or cause it to be used more efficiently. Quite the opposite in fact.
Even if all those things are done the issue will still continue.
There is a limited amount of land at desirable locations with desirable properties.
You can increase density-- sure-- but after densifying more than some threshold of land it won't help because the extremely high density housing is itself extremely unattractive to many people, so building more density only helps to the extent that there are people who want that with unmet housing needs.
The fundamental natural of housing is the root cause, restrictive policy is an exacerbating factor.
To use an extreme example, you can easily go find big tracts of land in Montana for under $1000 an acre where no one would prevent you from building a gosh darn arcology if you wanted to. Yet the existence of cheap land someplace else doesn't magically make the issue of housing costs solved. People don't want to live in that someplace else, they want to live in particular places and there always is and always will be a finite amount of land in those particular places.
However, in places like Vancouver people are buying up property as a place to park money and they remain unoccupied. Policies like additional taxes on unoccupied or secondary residences. Seem like one good way of adding supply.
Otherwise you're stuck crafting clever anti-investment legislation which may or may not work and may or may not create weird distortions due to some unforeseen consequence of how the regulations are worded.
Until the policy is fixed, additional foreign investment is pointless and only serves to drive speculative price increases. It makes sense to deter it.
In theory as countries apply similar policies across the world, the surplus countries driving these capital flows will be forced to either invest in developing countries that could actually use the funds, or park the cash domestically. That will force countries like China and Germany to deal with their issues internally instead of exporting them.
If they were targeting mainland Chinese investors, it's too late. China already stopped capital flight out of their country two years ago. They even banned crypto, so getting money out of China is both difficult and expensive for both Chinese citizens and even expats. The former is understandable since it's an authoritarian country, but expats? That's a new one unless countries in the Middle East do the same thing.
Zoning could be more liberal, but it would still be massive stakeholders that would build new homes and rent them out to get a decent ROI.
I am all for increasing density in places where there is high demand for housing. But a lot of people are living in this libertarian fantasy that all you have to do is liberalize zoning and you will magically get a perfect high density city like Singapore (which ironically has some of the strictest zoning in the world) and not a sea of slums (which actually happens in the real world when you combine high demand with no zoning).
I think cities should increase density when they see high demand for housing. But they should do it smartly by providing services and infrastructure for more citizens when allowing higher density buildings.
The most important service for high density living and the first pain point a city hits when population increases is transport. So if you want higher supply of housing, the most important thing to do first and foremost is to vote for all mass transit initiatives and try to convince your city leaders to put in more mass transit. Once the mass transit is there it will be far easier to put in apartment buildings and increase density without choking the city in traffic.
SF has notoriously strict zoning.
Communist until you get rich
Feminist until you get married
Atheist until the plane starts falling
Critisizing NIMBYism until you own the house.
I laugh when I see people have BLM signs on their property because those are the exact people who don't want to care about it.
In the USA, all it takes is a email, or phone call, from practically anywhere in the world and they own it.
At minimum we (USA) need to start with citizenship as a prerequisite. Oh yea, stop corporation for buying up precious stock too.
(Until we have more stock--the last thing we should allow is foreigners with funds buying our land. I have found it infuriating since I found out about how easy it is to buy here. Other countries do not let wealthy Americans buy land so dam easy.)
That's foreign money coming in to USA.
Technically, that's a good thing for the country as a whole.
Foreign investors jump into the housing market because the current system ensures that the supply of housing is limited so it is an attractive way to park your wealth.
But that is not the root cause.
The root cause is the system that is geared to keep houses always appreciating via supply constraints: aggressive zoning, discretionary permitting, NIMBYism.
Until we liberalize zoning, legalize building, and reject the idea that houses have to be appreciating assets, the issue will continue.
As it is often the case, politicians go for the headline with the highest electoral ROI, rather than tackle the real issues.