If I wanted to turn my single family house into a duplex, or just tear it down and build bigger, to far closer to the property line, I'd be completely unable to do so, because the zone is R1, the minimum offset to the edge of the property is enough to part 2 F-150s lined front to back. The maximum legal usable square footage, across all levels, of the house must not exceed 40% of the square footage of the lot. Most of my property must, by regulation, be lawn, and the taller I build, the more lawn I need. There's houses with this zoning structure right next door to supermarkets.
So how is asking to be allowed to redevelop your own lot being against private property ownership? If land is so plentiful nobody wants to build taller, the land will remain very low density. But the idea of having a lot that, if razed, would be worth a million dollars, but where building a duplex is illegal is not, in any way, going against private ownership.
To answer that: consider, would me being allowed to build a joint pig farm and jet engine testing facility 10 feet from your bedroom window be compatible with your property rights?
Externalities exist. Changes in the usage-- which includes density-- of the surrounding property can have a real effect on the existing residents. Debate over zoning is just a debate over the thresholds.
This isn't to say that existing policies in any particular place are well informed. But the basic concept of setting out the characteristics of neighboring properties, particularly to the extent that these rules were done in advance of your ownership and were clearly established, not only doesn't conflict with private property rights but can help protect them.
> one is a different type of use instead of just a more dense one
Differences in density are differences in use! perhaps insubstantial ones--- ones that don't meaningfully impinge any existing residents property right, and if so they shouldn't rightfully be restricted by zoning. And obviously they are-- I'm not attempting to defend existing practices-- only arguing that the conflict is not fundamental and that people arguing over them can all be making reasonable arguments over the right thresholds.
you CAN. But that takes a while. There's always something under construction in Califnornia and a good portion of that is trying to build more apartments and housing. The time to make those don't keep up with the influx of people emmigrating to LA or otherwise leaving the parents' homes to seek their own lifestyle.
It's honestly a more feasible solution to try and convince certain companies to build in a city that is otherwise "vacant". Make it a place where people will work around, have the existing land and homes appreciate in value. That's why Amazon and Apple had such aggressive bid wars from cities to try and get them to make new campuses in their respective city areas.
We have a shortage of dense housing because it is illegal to build dense housing in the places it should exist, and where it is legal, community review processes quickly shut it down
It's a a long and expensive process and I wouldn't be surprised if some deals fell through something because the minimum expenses exceeded what some potential clients expected.
In which dense cities in Canada (or the USA) did this work, resulting in a desirable dense city with cheap housing?
You could argue that you can just keep building up and up until you cross the threshold of demand affecting the price, but without a market incentive to do that, it's wishful thinking at best. "Well the government could fund it" you could say, and indeed it can. But speaking of economic research, everytime the government has done such a thing, it causes widespread economic depression of the local area.
Housing does not suffer from induced demand like road capacity does. This is easy to disprove by reading those studies. Sure, building nicer better neighborhoods does make them more desirable but it doesn't follow that they have to be more expensive, as long as you build enough homes for people to live in. Taken to its conclusion the induced demand argument against density is an argument against improving quality of life in general, and pretty nihilistic.
[1] https://ideas.repec.org/p/fer/wpaper/146.html
[2] https://www.dropbox.com/s/oplls6utgf7z6ih/Pennington_JMP.pdf...
[3] https://docs.wixstatic.com/ugd/7fc2bf_ee1737c3c9d4468881bf14...
They issue more permits for new housing units in a year than the entire state of California does, even though California has more than double the population. (or for an East Coast comparison - they issue around 9x the housing permits that NYC does, even though the population is <50% larger).
There have been many articles written on this topic by many publications that you can find, but here's one citation: https://www.ft.com/content/023562e2-54a6-11e6-befd-2fc0c26b3...
Tokyo metro area is 14,034 km2.
Meanwhile LA is 14% parking lots or so I’ve heard.
Tokyo, with its reasonable zoning, seems to have figured out how to build densely without being absurdly expensive. The key here is that the "market" is indeed allowed to figure it out, and not as restricted by NIMBYism.
The best thing the government can do right now is to get out of the way in regards to building more units.
Houses are not appreciating assets, in general. They are durable goods but tend to degrade if not maintained. Land is often an appreciating asset for the reasons you mentioned. And of course the "NIMBYism, zoning laws, permitting" play a part in that, by restricting the land available for various desired uses. Removing these factors would help, though of course it wouldn't completely negate the tendency for land prices to rise, especially in densely populated areas.
> But, what you are really wanting to argue against is private property ownership.
Removing private property ownership wouldn't make more land available, or cause it to be used more efficiently. Quite the opposite in fact.
The idea that houses are appreciating assets doesn't come from some fundamental law or ideology. It comes from recognizing reality. There is only so much land where people want to live, and population tends to increase (we are talking about urban and suburban areas, of course), so the demand and price increase. It's pretty simple, really.
NIMBYism, zoning laws, permitting, those are always familiar and convenient boogiemen for people who don't want to do actual analysis of market factors. But, what you are really wanting to argue against is private property ownership.