News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by clpm4j on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @02:27PM (#31086929)
Eliminating a subset of buyers, i.e. slightly decreasing demand, is an easy and obvious action to take. Will it have a significant and long lasting effect? Very likely not. But when examining the supply-demand equation, it's painfully obvious to say "foreigners who don't live here should not be allowed to buy residential housing". It's way, way easier than incentivizing developers to build affordable housing and dealing with all of the in-place bureaucracies and regulations and all of the hard stuff that comes along with constructing new neighborhoods and large residential buildings.
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by xapata on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @02:57PM (#31087343)
> incentivizing developers to build affordable housing

But that's unnecessary. If developers build more luxury housing, that'll reduce the price of existing housing, such that it becomes affordable.

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by jerf on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @03:17PM (#31087586)
There's a path dependency problem. In principle, had you just been building housing like that all along, investing in housing is not appealing as you shouldn't see significant gains in general. However, now that it is appealing, the investment itself pushes up demand, which pushes up the appeal of investing because now prices are going up, which pushes up demand, etc.

Again, in principle, if you just keep building, the market would eventually sort this out. Of course, in the process, you'll overbuild housing proportionally to the investment demand. Once the investment demand leaves, the market will crash, which isn't necessarily a great plan either. And we are talking about a lot of finite resources being misallocated in the meantime, while the market forces figure this out.

If you'd like to resolve this problem faster than the market would naturally sort it out, and harness market forces to do so rather than naively fighting them, it makes sense to cut out the excess, artificial investment demand in the meantime. Sure, it would be better to have not created that problem in the first place, but, here we are.

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by worik on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @03:52PM (#31088100)
Market forces are not magic, nor the only method of economic planning.

When markets work they are very good at finding prices. But when they fail you get this sort of thing.

There needs to be a lot of planned intervention in the housing sector. Entities with a lot of capital need to build the houses that people need to live in where they need to live in them and then let them live in them.

The market will not do that.

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by handmodel on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @06:13PM (#31090003)
I live in Los Angeles and am lucky enough to rent on a street that is single family houses. It is illegal to build a duplex here, or a structure above 2 stories, even though each house must be 2500 sqft still.

People who are pro-market forces (such as myself) believe strongly that if you were allowed to build apartment buildings in neighborhoods like this that enough capital absolutely would be raised to raise supply. After all, you could take the current house I rent now and put in two walls for under 50k and start renting it out as a duplex two families but that is currently illegal. Hard to blame the market forces for this.

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by bhewes on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @09:22PM (#31091644)
SB 9 pasted in Sept of last year that allows for duplexes on single unit lots. Here is the info for LA County https://planning.lacounty.gov/view/sb_9
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by handmodel on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @05:25PM (#31103217)
I am very happy about SB9!

Though as a maximalist on this I'm still upset this is the best compromise we can get since the lot of this house is definitely big enough for more than just 2/4 units.

The house I live in is rented which means it actually wouldnt be eligible since the owner must live in the house for 3 years after turning it into a duplex.

Maybe this will incentivize owners of houses like this to sell to people who are willing to divide it in two? I hope so! But not sure.

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by bhewes on Thursday April 21, 2022 @10:22PM (#31117530)
I agree. I lived in Houston and their are a lot of infill Townhomes. I think LA would be great for townhomes vs high rises or those terrible downtown DaVinci Apartments between the 101 and 110.

Ha, did not know about the three year ownership requirement, classic CA NIMBYism. Still progress.

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by _3u10 on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @06:43PM (#31090351)
Vancouver and Toronto isn’t a housing market in any real sense of the word. Supply is fixed by government, interest rates are fixed by government, etc.

If you took government control out of the market prices would plummet. Any plank will do, supply, financial backing or interest rates and the whole thing comes crashing down. That’s the real problem, how to cause a 20% “correction” and not 80%.

My house is 8 hours from Vancouver, 8 hours from Calgary, 5 hours from Banff, it’s a town of 10,000 people, it was built in 1904 and is 2500 sqft. It’s been modestly renovated and is worth $950,000. The market is insane.

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by liketochill on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @08:55PM (#31091463)
Revelstoke?

If so, revelstoke like Vancouver is actually pretty hemmed in by water and mountains. There isn’t an infinite amount of easy to build on land like the on the prairies.

Quality of life in revelstoke is probably amazing! Small town, ski hill, mountains, biking, snowmobiling, fishing, lakes, rivers, airport, and lots of jobs

Demand will always exceed supply in desirable locations, that is part of what makes them desirable. Would you spend 30% of you and your wife’s income to secure a plot in such a paradise? 40%? 50%? Lots of people will take the bet and risk. If you lose and go bankrupt well then you move to the easily affordable town in the equivalent of the fly over states. Odds are the million dollar mortgage will get inflated away you just have to tread water while interest rates are historically low until you can juice your income or hourly rate up enough to make the million dollars you are in debt seem trivial.

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by _3u10 on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @12:58AM (#31092971)
Better than revvy :)

Oh it’s already inflated away 30% in less than a year. It was 30% of my income.

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by worik on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @08:47PM (#31091412)
Everybody blaming zoning.

What is happening in Dallas which has no zoning rules? (Or am I thinking of Austin Texas?)

I do not know, but it would be useful for this debate

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by bombcar on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @09:11PM (#31091563)
Houston is usually the one they point to, but is the equivalent of zoning in other ways such as covenants, etc.

Houston is booming I hear.

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by majormajor on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @09:28PM (#31091689)
Right, cities in Texas aren't cheaper because they don't have zoning (they either explicitly do, as well as HOAs in new developments and all sorts of other NIMBYism, or they do in indirect ways like you mention).

They're cheaper because they can still expand outward more than SF, LA, NY, etc before hitting inconvenient geography. Lots of other places that benefit from this too, of course, not just Texas.

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by xapata on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @03:17AM (#31093763)
The housing crisis 15 years ago shrank the building industry and it hasn't recovered, yet. Further, construction has historically used a significant amount of immigrant labor, and immigration has shrank recently, increasing costs.
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by GFischer on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @04:04PM (#31102234)
I have coworkers in Dallas, and they bought for relatively cheap (about 1/3 of what is being mentioned for other places in the USA in this thread).

So I guess it works.

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by throwaway0a5e on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @06:34AM (#31094922)
You're probably thinking of Houston and Austin.

In any case, all three have rampant HOAs which serve the same purpose as zoning.

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by jefftk on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @04:19PM (#31088462)
The market ("people who would stand to earn a lot of money") would be happy to do that, but it's not allowed to (zoning: height limits, parking requirements, lot coverage, maximum floor area...)
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by jerf on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @10:52AM (#31097795)
I feel like you saw the word "market" and just knee-jerked a standard anti-market cant, instead of reading what I actually said.

I was defending a "planned intervention".

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by danans on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @07:55PM (#31090961)
> If developers build more luxury housing, that'll reduce the price of existing housing, such that it becomes affordable.

If the last few decades have taught us anything, it'd that location (and every social category that location encodes) matters to people more than luxury, or rather a desirable location is the biggest luxury.

This is why a 3 BD fixer-upper in Palo Alto will cost more than a luxury 5 bedroom house in East San Jose.

To have any effect on housing prices I desirable places, you'd have to build gobs more housing in the highly desirable places, but those are usually the places most opposed to new housing development. And if you build a little bit more, because location dominates all, the existing housing would be as expensive as the new luxury housing in that location, because there is always a higher demand/supply ratio to live in Palo Alto than for East San Jose.

By the same token, building luxury housing in less desirable places won't change things unless you somehow make those places more desirable, but that takes a lot more than new luxury apartments. You usually have to change the kind of people that inhabit that location.

We absolutely need to build more housing of all categories everywhere, but it won't have much effect on housing costs until we address transportation, public education, and crime, the massive factors that affect housing costs.

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by majormajor on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @09:24PM (#31091652)
Even if you had no zoning or "organized" NIMBY restrictions, it would be extremely slow to build denser in the most popular "full" residential places: any new construction there requires someone else to sell and leave for that construction to take place. You aren't going to be able to build a hundred-unit tower like you could if the land was empty or was just a vacant old structure.

Targeting stuff that isn't currently residential would be a much easier starting point.

IMO, but more controversially, it goes even further: in the long run, especially with fast transportation and digital communications, it's hard to see certain places ever getting "affordable" given today's wealth distributions. Some locations are going to be in higher demand due to non-human-development related factors (weather, scenery, etc). Others due more to development factors: NYC is more in-demand than if it was an empty bunch of land because we've already done a bunch of development there. (That latter case is especially interesting because it shows how development can both increase supply AND demand, it's not solely something that affects supply.) So if some places are inherently going to be more in-demand than others, and you build more when the market price is currently $X, prices won't fall very quickly at all as you get the people who otherwise want to live there, but couldn't do $X but would do it for $X-1, $X-2, etc, now re-interested in the area!

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by danans on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @11:49PM (#31092601)
> Others due more to development factors: NYC is more in-demand than if it was an empty bunch of land because we've already done a bunch of development there.

Agreed, and human development is a major part of that. NYC is a cultural center of the world, which is a result of its human development, and that has a tremendous currency and gravity over and above Manhattan's physical grid.

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by jjav on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @03:29PM (#31087778)
> If developers build more luxury housing, that'll reduce the price of existing housing, such that it becomes affordable.

Not really: Say there's one free acre of land in town. You could build one mansion on it, or a highrise with 100 apartments.

Building the mansion isn't going to move the needle on any existing housing at all, as it's just one unit.

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by alistairSH on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @05:15PM (#31089304)
Except, in a competitive/expensive market, the developer will pick the high-rise (almost) every time when allowed by law.

Locally, when I see people complain about luxury housing being built, it's because the developer is building high-spec townhomes and selling them for $800k+. Instead of lower-spec townhomes at $500k. The developer can't fit appreciably more homes in the same footprint (they're all 3-4 stories tall here - reducing size likely means one fewer stories). And the market will bear $800k+, so that's what we get.

The real answer is build even more homes. Or allow high-rises on the same lots.

In theory, the family that buys the $800k townhome came from somewhere. The smaller house they vacated is now open for somebody else (who in turn moved out of a studio flat that's now open, and on down).

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by jjav on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @07:40PM (#31090832)
> Except, in a competitive/expensive market, the developer will pick the high-rise (almost) every time when allowed by law.

A developer will, indeed. More profit. But an acre is small enough that it could just as well be a rich individual buyer, in which case they'll build what they like.

There's a half-acre plot for sale nearby for nearly $2M, I'm curious if it ends up being bought by an IPO millionaire to build a small mansion or by some developer to put up two-story apartments. Could go either way.

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by alistairSH on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @09:19PM (#31091624)
That’s fair.

Local to me, redevelopment of a lot with an existing SFH tends to be another SFH because of zoning (unfortunately - many of the lots would be perfect for a nice duplex or very small apartment block).

Larger lots tend to be bought by corporate developers, both because they have the resources to develop it fully and also because they frequently have to battle NIMBYs for a while to get re-zoning approved (I tend to side with the developers, except when they buy parkland to develop, but that’s a whole other discussion).

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by icambron on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @09:19PM (#31091623)
I mean, it could; rich people do what they like. But would it statistical aggregate? I really doubt it.

And do they want to live in that mansion surrounded by multi-unit buildings built by developers buying the nearby acres? Also seems unlikely.

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by bombcar on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @09:13PM (#31091571)
In many markets there’s no choice - it has to be a single family home.
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by jachee on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @07:19PM (#31090665)
> The smaller house they vacated is now open for somebody else

Or, they didn’t sell it and are just seeking rent on it, now. For this effect to really work, the number of home-owners should equal the number of homes.

Right now, there are many, many fewer home-owners than homes.

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by jjav on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @07:35PM (#31090785)
> Or, they didn’t sell it and are just seeking rent on it, now.

That's fine, it still provides housing for someone. And there are people who actually prefer to rent, so it's good to have rental units available.

Problematic is when they hold on to it and keep it empty, thus occupying space but providing housing for no one.

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by seoaeu on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @10:38PM (#31092171)
No, the number of homes has to be slighter higher than the number of residents. If a renter is living in a home then it isn’t going to waste!

(Slightly higher because it is mathematically impossible for anyone to move if there are no empty homes, and they sometimes have to sit vacant while being renovated or are in the process of being sold)

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by paxys on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @03:34PM (#31087863)
That isn't a matter of incentives but zoning laws.
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by RangerScience on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @06:33PM (#31090245)
Are there any places that have these kinds of housing pressure where there are a significant number of free acres of land in town?

(I say this sitting in the middle of the LA metropolis between two almost undeveloped hillsides of ~10 acres each, haha; and a thousand more people in this neighborhood would be significant for us (maybe? dunno the actual pop count) but nothing to LA as a whole, AFAIK)

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by frenchy on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @05:09PM (#31089211)
As long as land prices are high, a highrise should net a lot more profit though, would it not?
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by nine_k on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @04:55PM (#31088987)
I wonder why NYC has so few mansions, and so many high-rises.
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by undersuit on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @06:15PM (#31090022)
The high rises in NYC are mansions.
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by nine_k on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @06:52PM (#31090435)
Occupied by one extended family?
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by shkkmo on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @04:56PM (#31089013)
Up to a point, this is true when the affordable housing has had it's cost bid up by high end customers because of a scarcity of high end housing.

However, once that high end market pressure has been abated, then there a real and hard limits to the amount of high end housing that can/will be available to low income customers. Instead of being available cheaply, this high-end housing stock will end up being used as a vacation house or a short the rental, neither of which actually help reduce local demand for housing.

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by xapata on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @06:35PM (#31090272)
Suppliers will build more until the market clears. If prices are rising, that's a signal to suppliers to keep building. They won't stop until prices fall.
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by seoaeu on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @10:58PM (#31092324)
We’re not anywhere close to this in any of the high cost markets. But once we do get to that point another thing will happen: the lower demand for high end housing (there’s only so many vacation homes and short term rentals you can sell) will make it economical to build new mid-range housing
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by shkkmo on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @01:24AM (#31093141)
> there’s only so many vacation homes and short term rentals you can sell)

There are many markets the the number you can sell far exceeds the available land to build.

I fail to see how lower demand for high end housing makes it more economical to build mid-range housing? The price for that housing will be lower and land to buiody it on will be taken up by lower density high end housing.

High end housing construction is better than no construction, but please don't pretend it is sufficient to solve the need for other types of construction.

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by seoaeu on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @10:15AM (#31097261)
The amount to housing you can fit in a given metro absent zoning is basically unlimited. Manhattan has a population density of 75,000 people/square mile, and could be much higher without “air rights” limiting construction or the abnormally high percentage of commercial real estate. Many of the cities that are supposedly out of land have population densities an order of magnitude lower.

Developers today build low density single family homes often due to zoning. If the law says you can build 3000 sqft on a given lot, the most profitable thing to build is probably single family. But if they were allowed 30,000 sqft or 300,000 sqft then you’re almost surely going to get multi family instead. At that point high end and mid range condos will likely both be profitable, but developer returns would be better for the former (if they can find buyers). So as high end buyers become more scarce, more developers will transition to mid range

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by heavyset_go on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @05:58PM (#31089838)
There are housing insecure people who need housing now and not some nebulous time in the future when the market could, theoretically, correct itself. Markets are notorious for remaining irrational in the face of obvious market forces that should, theoretically, influence them. While we wait for housing to trickle down, people will go without homes, possibly for decades. It's a classic market failure, and doubling down on "markets but more this time" might not exactly help, either.
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by gwright on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @09:36PM (#31091751)
> It's a classic market failure

If you mean classic "free" market failure, then I would disagree. The housing market is replete with constraints that are imposed by government. I think it is more accurate to say that it is a classic regulatory failure (at least in some jurisdictions).

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by digisign on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @11:25PM (#31092477)
Unhindered housing markets haven't been allowed to exist for fifty years. Homes for people of limited means, outlawed for almost a century.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Single_room_occupancy

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by RangerScience on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @03:08PM (#31087479)
That (first) either assumes demand remains constant, or requires measuring actual cost vs theoretical cost instead of simply actual; and second, assumes that there aren't complex interdependencies - ie, more luxury housing can make an area more desirable and increase demand more than it increases supply - arguably that's the goal, since otherwise you're literally building places people want to live in less than what's already available.
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by xapata on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @03:15PM (#31087545)
> more luxury housing can make an area more desirable

Depends how big the "area" is that you're thinking about. The effect of increasing housing supply is well-studied. Demand can only grow as fast as the population does. If one area experiences increasing demand, then another area will have decreasing demand, comparatively.

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by RangerScience on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @06:29PM (#31090198)
Hmm. I guess that makes sense if you're looking comparatively within an area. I'm talking about an area as a whole; in particularly, I'm thinking of Venice CA and the DTLA arts district, as two distinct areas.

(AFAIK) Venice is pretty much entirely shit house -> excellent house development, with some multi-unit (townhouses). DTLA is shit building -> modern condos / luxury apts.

AFAIK in both places a secondary effect of all development is that each area becomes more desirable. I guess, sure, if one stopped becoming more desirable the pull from the other would change demand between the two, but, a) they're not, they're both developing, b) (anecdotally) that's a drop in the bucket compared to the overall demand, and c) they have sufficiently different appeals that the demand isn't coming from the same people.

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by xapata on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @06:41PM (#31090330)
What's causing the increased demand: births, immigration, or increased wealth? The pair of Venice and Downtown LA are not closed system. If people are immigrating to those places, then they've left somewhere else, which experiences a declining demand for housing.
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by nradov on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @03:55PM (#31088124)
That relationship doesn't hold in ski resort areas. Wealthy people have increasingly bought up vacation homes even as the population remains flat. Those vacation homes are vacant much of the year. There are usually geographic and infrastructure constraints which make it impossible to build significant amounts of new housing within practical commuting distance. So long time local residents are effectively being forced out.
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by xapata on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @06:30PM (#31090219)
I have little sympathy for people that are "forced" to sell their homes for a large capital gain. They can move to where it's cheap and live large. Maybe my perspective as an immigrant is unusual, but I'm a big fan of the freedom to migrate. That includes the freedom to buy housing at market price.
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by nradov on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @06:34PM (#31090262)
Most of the people being forced out are renters.
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by xapata on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @06:48PM (#31090391)
Then it's even easier to move. If the polity doesn't want to zone for more housing, they've chosen to expel people who can't pay more than $X for rent. They'll feel the pain when there's no one around to make their coffee anymore.

There's no such thing as unlimited demand for luxury housing. Build enough and the rent will fall for the existing housing stock.

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by seoaeu on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @10:50PM (#31092261)
> Then it's even easier to move.

Moving requires finding a home somewhere that they can afford. The fact that they’ve been subjected to rising rents rather than a financial windfall like nearby homeowners… makes that far more difficult for them

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by upvotepartytime on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @12:30AM (#31092831)
They could have bought. Instead they took advantage of the optionality afforded to a renter that can up stakes and move at will, without being tied to a mortgage.

If they couldn’t afford to buy then they got to take advantage of a locale they desired at a lower price, another benefit of renting.

(While it would be nice if anyone could live — and own — anywhere they like without worrying about price or competing demand from the billions of other humans around, that’s so far away from reality it’s not worth discussing.)

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by bombcar on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @09:15PM (#31091588)
I’m starting to feel we may be nearing a local maximum on housing, as more and more arguments seem to take for granted that it can never go down …
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by michaelmrose on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @04:12PM (#31088366)
Alternatively you end up with more empty housing poor to middling people can't afford while a bigger portion of society has the life sucked out of them by housing costs work 2nd jobs spend less time with their kids or on self improvement. Save less. Crash harder during down turns etc.
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by xapata on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @06:54PM (#31090449)
Speculators will eventually mark to market and sell or rent their empty houses. It might take a while, but it's a big country. Housing is illiquid on a small scale, but is a fairly efficient market on the national level. Except for the zoning rules, of course. That's the nice thing about living in the US or a Schengen country. It's easy to move to where the economy is better.
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by rbanffy on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @10:02PM (#31091919)
> If developers build more luxury housing

According to this reasoning, if Ferrari builds more cars, Fiats will get less expensive.

I don’t think that’s how it’s supposed to work.

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by YokoZar on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @10:10PM (#31091975)
The vast majority of affordable cars are used cars. Used cars are cheaper when there's tons of new cars, and they get more expensive when new car production slows - prices jumped so much in the past two years that some used cars were sold for more than they were originally purchased for.

We treat that weird situation as obvious undersupply in the car market, but somehow expect it with houses. Why should old, used houses sell for more than their purchase price?

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by mrexroad on Thursday April 21, 2022 @12:07PM (#31111308)
The mental model of buying something new/used doesn’t apply same as cars. Unlike a car, the structure is simply an improvement that’s factored into the price of what you’re purchasing — the rights to the physical space itself. Sometimes a lot of the “value” is locked up in the structure, and sometimes the structure is barely functional and most of the value is in the land. At some point that ratio of the land:improvements values reaches a point where the “used” structure is relatively worthless and gets replaced, the ratio rebalances.
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by xapata on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @10:23PM (#31092063)
People forget that houses depreciate. It's the land that appreciates.
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by seoaeu on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @10:54PM (#31092287)
This isn’t true in all markets. Higher labor costs (for instance, caused by higher rents…) makes it more expensive to construct new homes. That makes any existing homes more valuable, potentially even accounting for depreciation
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by rbanffy on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @09:57AM (#31097020)
The cost of replacing a house appreciates, but a new house has higher value than an old one.
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by cycrutchfield on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @10:08PM (#31091957)
If Ferrari sold 10 million cars per year, you don’t think that would have a downward pricing impact on other cars?
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by _carbyau_ on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @03:01AM (#31093668)
Basically, not sure how to interpret "sold 10 million cars".

2 scenarios come to mind:

1. Ferrari decrease their sale prices, thus they are more affordable for all, thus exerting price pressure on Fiat.

2. People somehow have a bucket more money and now buy Ferraris. But with all this money sloshing around, Fiat might as well up their prices because it'd make little difference on the end customers purchase decision.

In either case, the Ferrari and the Fiat are closer on price but the price pressure on Fiat varies. Curious to know your thoughts?

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by tick_tock_tick on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @03:22PM (#31087649)
> build affordable housing

Lets build shitty buildings that will last for decades. Affordable housing is and will always be a horrible idea. Build and build until you get a surplus and suddenly tons of housing is affordable.

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by hgomersall on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @05:09PM (#31089209)
Affordable doesn't mean shit, it means not optimised to gouge as much cash as possible from the buyer, and also probably means coming with a price control covenant. Many council houses in the UK were historically built to very high spec.
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by seoaeu on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @11:07PM (#31092380)
> Affordable housing is and will always be a horrible idea.

This is like saying food banks are a horrible idea, and we should just focus on job growth so everyone can afford to buy their own food. It comes across as really tone deaf to ignore that some people need help now and that even though it isn’t a complete solution, feeding one person today or getting one person off the street into newly constructed affordable housing makes a real difference to them.

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by digisign on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @11:33PM (#31092521)
"Affordable housing" is one of the most expensive, bureaucratic forms of construction, not a way to build faster.
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by seoaeu on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @09:49AM (#31096925)
Faster than what? It takes a handful of years for a non-profit or government housing agency to build new affordable housing. At the current pace of market rate construction, it’ll take many many decades before newly built “luxury” housing filters down enough for low income households to afford it. Even if there was a massive YIMBY housing boom we’re still probably looking at 10-20 years before market rents fall enough to be affordable to low income folks
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by digisign on Friday April 22, 2022 @11:42AM (#31123027)
Ignoring the problem is not a solution, as we've seen. Nor are bureaucratic bandaids over a mortal wound. Yes, we need to increase the rate of construction 10x and things will get better after a decade or so.
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by cardamomo on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @03:27PM (#31087751)
I agree with this, minus the "shitty buildings" part. The way to create more affordable housing is to create more housing period. I do feel that they should be homes they people want to live in, though!
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by 8note on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @04:38PM (#31088736)
Luxury and affordable buildings only differ by the rent they charge.

The quality of the building is determined by building codes

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by asiachick on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @05:50PM (#31089748)
Plenty of people in Hong Kong and Japan live comfortably and happily in apartmetns as small as 300-400 sqft where as in many cities in the west such small apartments are not allowed. That's a building code issue. You can't build cheaper housing because of the code. Similarly in many areas house require garages or parking space and front yards of a certain size by law. Again, housing codes dicate whether you can make something cheaper or not.
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by nine_k on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @05:00PM (#31089055)
The size and shape of rooms, hallways, stairways, elevators (if we're talking about high-rises), the quality of installed windows, quality and presence of a centralized HVAC, etc, certainly depend on the "luxury level" of a building.

Building codes set the lower bounds of acceptable quality of a building, which is good but not all-encompassing (and for a good reason).

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by munk-a on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @03:28PM (#31087756)
This may be a healthy long term outcome but a lot of people have a good portion of their value parked in their home - if there is a sudden oversupply how will you cousin the economic and social shock as millions of middle-class folks suddenly lose their wealth while upper class folks mainly invested in the stock market come out the far side with even more wealth?

This is not an easy problem - and as soon as you try and alert people to the fact that you're going to fix it the market will respond and the problem will occur.

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by seunosewa on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @03:31PM (#31087801)
So why bother cutting off foreigners if you want your real estate to keep appreciating in value?
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by munk-a on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @03:42PM (#31087978)
To slow the value gain - I think ideally the government would like to sort of stabilize housing prices in BC & ON for a few years then re-start a slower more reliable growth pace... exploding the housing market fully could cause a value loss - so this is like opening one pressure release valve to slow the build up a bit.
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by seunosewa on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @03:59PM (#31088189)
Liberalizing the housing market is a slow process that will be heavily contested politically and in courts, so it won't lead to an instant explosion of the housing market. The political will to continue liberalizing the housing market will evaporate as soon as housing prices become reasonable as a result of it.
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by munk-a on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @04:56PM (#31089003)
The market can generally move faster than politics - as soon as it becomes common knowledge that the housing market will be opened up you'll see a modest drop in prices, when some legislation is passed you'll see a larger drop in prices... if and when that legislation survives the court you'll see even more of a drop.

This issue isn't that the laws will move too quickly but that the open intent to pass those laws will spook the market and cause a panic - which is actually a lot worse if you want to deflate the market because any aide or support you'd want to provide is going to come in well after the market has already responded.

And, to return to my main point above... when that happens people with a lot of free capital sitting around are going to be able to game the system and make a bunch of money off of it. So wealth inequality will increase and it's likely a lot of folks will be in an absolutely terrible spot.

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by seunosewa on Thursday April 21, 2022 @05:50PM (#31115620)
Making it easy to construct new buildings - let's call it liberalization - isn't a binary thing. You can do it a little bit, a lot, or anywhere in-between. If you want home prices to go down, you do it a lot. If you want to stabilize things just a little bit, you do it a little. For this reason, "we don't want the prices to fall too much" doesn't work as a reason to choose banning foreigners over liberalization.
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by megablast on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @03:49PM (#31088056)
People dont lose anything until they sell.

Most people aren’t selling. So they haven’t lost.

And how would you limit the effect if housing dropped for the many other reasons prices drop?? You don’t.

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by jdkenney on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @04:29PM (#31088618)
Many people would be forced to sell though if there was a price drop, because the high prices necessitated having a very high borrowing rate (95% borrowed), and commonly at renewal (typically 5 years in Canada) mortgage terms require the borrower to pay the difference between the market value and the borrowed amount to ensure they are not more than 95% leveraged still.

This is the big problem the government has: it is very difficult to unwind this mess through policy without triggering a cascade. Likely it will come eventually, they just want to ensure it’s not their party in office when the shoe finally drops.

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by worik on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @03:55PM (#31088132)
> People dont lose anything until they sell.

Not quite true. It would be truer if they have no debt.

But having a large debt, and negative equity, makes a family very vulnerable economically.

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by dmoy on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @03:59PM (#31088191)
What percentage of pensions and 401ks are tied up in mortgage backed securities, etc?
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by saiya-jin on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @04:17PM (#31088432)
thats a view of an owner who wants to get as rich as his property will allow him, and hopefully even more. fuck everybody else. exactly how we get into this situation.

folks who gamble with money have to accept the risk part of the equation, whatever vessel that may be. if somebody invested in tech stocks few months ago they are now probably crying in the corner.

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by munk-a on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @04:53PM (#31088954)
The majority of Canadians are in this situation - you can be extremely unsympathetic towards them and tell them that their investment was unwise - that's perfectly fair... but do realize that the vast majority of Canadians will suddenly find themselves either worth a lot less than they thought they would be or underwater in debt and homeless.

And also don't forget that whenever "everybody loses some money" the people at the top are in a great position to grab an even bigger slice of the pie.

Whether or not you feel for the pain these people would go through, you're going to feel pain when it ripples out the rest of the economy.

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by heavyset_go on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @06:04PM (#31089905)
The difference between 'luxury' housing and affordable housing is the facade, marketing and price, not quality.
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by imtringued on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @05:02PM (#31089096)
Yeah, let the building plague begin.
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by thawaya3113 on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @12:09AM (#31092710)
This is also, obviously, not intended to be a long term solution as evidenced by the fact that it’s limited to 2 years.

I do think it would have been better if they hadn’t announced it was limited to 2 years but that’s not practical.

I’m a huge proponent of the “build more supply” side. But that takes time. And in addition, there is a huge 2 year gap of supply creation that didn’t happen because of the pandemic.

This may help ease some of that pandemic related imbalance.

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by majani on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @10:06AM (#31097144)
The next question to that is why does zoning exist in the first place? Zoning exists because of how hard it is to scale up infrastructure to match demand. And we decided to entrust governments with infrastructure, yet they are not nimble enough to handle these scaling issues
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by handmodel on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @06:09PM (#31089960)
I'm actually happy they did it only because it will get people (at least the subset of people who follow casually and do care) to acknowledge that foreign buyers are not the root cause once a couple years pass and the data will be apparent.
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by Eliezer on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @06:16PM (#31090046)
That's a very cheerful take about people's ability to update about politics after a law fails to give them a promised result. I wish I lived in the territory corresponding to your map.
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by nullc on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @02:40PM (#31087128)
A key point is that people buying for investment are less sensitive to driving the prices up-- so long as they're sustained. If you have enough wealth that you would be buying multiple properties anyways, buying fewer more expensive places just lowers your transaction costs. As such, they likely have an outsized effect on driving up prices.

I'm dubious that Canada's policy will achieve that, as I understand it they exempt purchases by foreign students which is already a major avenue for foreign investment property purchases. If they limited resident aliens to a single piece of property which they also lived in, that would be something but my understanding is that they don't.

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by munk-a on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @03:45PM (#31088023)
In theory BC at least has a residency tax on vacant homes - but that just increases the cost of making the investment and shifts the numbers... it doesn't necessarily make the investment a losing strategy unless you're right on the border.