News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by seanmcdirmid on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @02:18PM (#31086787)
We really should follow Japan on this:

(a) National zoning

(b) A culture that abhors second hand housing (so structures don't appreciate like land does). Housing that depreciates is no longer a sound investment.

(c) Liberal definition on minimal standard housing to rent (central heating not required, toilets can be shared, no personal shower or even a shower at all in the building you are renting a room in, small spaces are OK).

Maybe not this one:

(d) Not very open to immigration at all, have a decreasing population.

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by admax88qqq on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @02:25PM (#31086888)
> A culture that abhors second hand housing (so structures don't appreciate like land does). Housing that depreciates is no longer a sound investment

That sounds tremendously wasteful. All housing will have to be built new now?

> (d) Not very open to immigration at all, have a decreasing population.

This is probably the biggest reason housing is depreciating in Japan, especially outside of Tokyo.

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by onlyrealcuzzo on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @03:25PM (#31087707)
> That sounds tremendously wasteful. All housing will have to be built new now?

It is if you're building concrete houses common in much of the world.

If you're building houses that are common houses in Japan, it's not nearly as bad.

When you think of a house as something that not only you will live in - but also will be the vast majority of your net worth that you pass down to your children - then building houses the Western way makes more sense.

When a house is just something you live in - you think of it more like renters do.

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by seanmcdirmid on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @02:31PM (#31086994)
> That sounds tremendously wasteful. All housing will have to be built new now?

Well ya. You don't build to have your home last for more than 30-40 years, which can save some materials. We should get better at recycling and renewing building material, maybe the Japanese counteract things that way?

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by jjav on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @04:22PM (#31088498)
> You don't build to have your home last for more than 30-40 years, which can save some materials.

I'm very skeptical it would save any non-trivial amount in materials. What would you leave out?

Housing in the USA is already very cheaply built, 2x4s and drywall and the cheapest hardware they builder can get. Such houses easily last over a 100 years barring some disaster.

To build a house that crumbles to unlivable in 30 years, you'd have to intentionally design it to do that. Which sounds terrible from an environmental waste perspective.

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by bombcar on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @09:32PM (#31091721)
They “last” 100 years with pretty Constance maintenance - and the average house isn’t that old so the jury is still out on some of it.

In many places tear down and rebuild is cheaper than remodeling, especially when energy costs are taken into account.

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by jjav on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @04:07PM (#31102275)
> They “last” 100 years with pretty Constance maintenance

It's no surprise to anyone that a house needs some maintenance, that's a given. If someone lives in it and keeps up with basic maintenance, it'll last many generations.

> the average house isn’t that old so the jury is still out on some of it

I suspect the average house will never be that old, simply because a lot more houses are getting built all the time bringing down the average.

But plenty of 100+ year old houses, even here in California where most construction is more recent.

> In many places tear down and rebuild is cheaper than remodeling

Remodeling is a whole different topic. Yes, remodeling a house to be much larger or much nicer (or both) can be very expensive.

But on the topic of simply living in the same house in the same configuration as it was originally built, for 100+ years (multiple generations surely), there's no need to remodel. Only maintenance.

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by yokoprime on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @03:15PM (#31087555)
Is this satire, are you really advocating building houses with an expected life-span of 40 years? So if i buy a new house when im 30, i should expect to have to buy new if i live to be more than 70 and I havent moved.

If we assume your idea of close to perfectly recyclable houses comes true, i think people would have to really dial down their expectations and standards. No more drywall, particle boards everywhere. Tiles.. forget it, kitchen counters made by reclaimed wood etc

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by seanmcdirmid on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @03:48PM (#31088046)
> Is this satire, are you really advocating building houses with an expected life-span of 40 years?

I'm really not sure. On the one hand, I agree it is wasteful. On the other hand, I personally like living in a new home.

> No more drywall, particle boards everywhere. Tiles.. forget it, kitchen counters made by reclaimed wood etc

The average kitchen where I live is renovated every 10 years, so the drywall, much of the electrical and plumbing, the floor, tile backsplash, etc...is redone. Bathrooms are also on a 10 year schedule. You can let the reno slide, of course, or perhaps you can do a higher quality reno and hope it lasts longer than a decade. (I'm looking at a kitchen reno right now and my house was built in 2016...the builders just made too many mistakes, but $150k to redo the kitchen...ugh)

In Japan, they don't do the reno every 10 years, they just rebuild the house every 30. How is that much different?

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by ghaff on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @06:16PM (#31090036)
I have never seen that in the US. Any significant remodels are on the order of decades. My house is 200 years old.
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by seanmcdirmid on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @08:44PM (#31091388)
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by bombcar on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @09:34PM (#31091735)
Median duration of home ownership is 13 years - only need them to do one remodel and we basically hit the proposed numbers.

Being in a 200 year old house already puts you WAY into the far outliers - the median US house is 37 years old.

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by BlargMcLarg on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @02:54PM (#31087303)
(b) is the biggest one. It doesn't make second hand unlivable, it just stops putting a premium on things which clearly aren't premium (unlike say Europe). It also makes it easier to tear things down in case of future needs, whereas Europe tends to "lock" itself in, creating a market which is very inflexible.

>(c)

Keep in mind 1LDKs (living room, dining room, kitchen) come with everything you'd expect a full apartment to come with, and are still very cheap in Tokyo compared to most metropolises and big cities. Many DKs also come with personal shower, small kitchen and toilet. Their spaces are generally on par with what you'd get in bigger European cities, for an equal or lower price. Not bad considering it is Tokyo.

>(d)

I mean, between the US and Japan, Japan isn't that much more difficult to immigrate to, unless you expect to get by with just English. Decreasing population also isn't a problem considering population numbers are getting far too big for comfort among developed countries.

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by seanmcdirmid on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @03:31PM (#31087802)
The USA is about 12% immigrants, Japan is around 2%. I mean, it is definitely no China, but it has the lowest immigration rate of the all the developed countries.
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by BlargMcLarg on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @03:52PM (#31088099)
That's not what I was pointing to. Check the visa requirements for various visas for the US, Japan and other developed countries. They follow similar thought patterns: skilled workers with demonstrated experience and/or knowledge, who won't be a burden on the state. The biggest boon being most skilled workers from developed countries already know English at an okay level, and most developed countries accommodate non-native language speakers better than Japan does when it comes to immigration.
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by yokoprime on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @03:07PM (#31087470)
> (b) is the biggest one. It doesn't make second hand unlivable, it just stops putting a premium on things which clearly aren't premium (unlike say Europe). It also makes it easier to tear things down in case of future needs, whereas Europe tends to "lock" itself in, creating a market which is very inflexible

Could you elaborate on what this paragraph means? How do we "lock" ourselves in here in Europe? I can go out _today_ buy a rundown house and tear it down. If the cost of renovating it exceeds the cost of building new, it's financially sound to do. Unless i'm buying some historically important building there are zero restrictions.

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by BlargMcLarg on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @03:24PM (#31087691)
If you can buy a rundown house, yes. Now place yourself in the shoes of the generation who can't reasonable buy a rundown house in a place close to work, and are expected to commute to work. They are dependent on laws and profit margins for anything to happen.

When the profit margins say "building apartments isn't profitable" and the laws say "well whatever", nothing's gonna get torn down for apartments. Turns out when you build things to last and the mentality is that a 30yo house should still be in good shape, there's not a lot of profits to be gained tearing it down and building an apartment complex compared to renovating it a little and selling it to some upper middle class family with more dough to spend.

And yes, there are ways around this, e.g. turning that SFH into a sharehouse. Why that isn't happening more is a whole different story.

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by nine_k on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @05:54PM (#31089794)
USA is a "salad bowl", it expects immigrants and varied cultures. Basically, coming from anywhere in the world, with some getting used to, you can blend in.

Japan is much more homogeneous culturally, and as an immigrant you will always be a stranger. Even if people will be nice and polite towards you, they likely won't be able to treat you as they would treat a Japanese, because you'd miss the cultural context which builds up from early childhood on.

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by usefulcat on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @02:42PM (#31087171)
> A culture that abhors second hand housing (so structures don't appreciate like land does). Housing that depreciates is no longer a sound investment.

If you want a house that depreciates faster, manufactured homes are an option. It's not at all obvious to me though that a structure that depreciates faster will necessarily be more affordable than a traditional house that has been properly maintained. Even if it is, building a new home every N years will almost certainly consume more resources over the medium to long term.

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by 3pt14159 on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @02:24PM (#31086872)
Or we could, you know, intelligently tax property nationally and tie it to a national dividend that directly goes to landed immigrants and citizens in the form of a basic income. It will make sure that the poor and lower middle class don't get hosed and simultaneously make property a less attractive investment for foreigners or would-be mansion builders.

I don't want to live in the same place my whole life and I don't want every Canadian city to look and feel the same.

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by Aerroon on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @02:33PM (#31087014)
>It will make sure that the poor and lower middle class don't get hosed and simultaneously make property a less attractive investment for foreigners or would-be mansion builders.

It will also make sure that you get enough leeway to build in all the corruption you want. Or at least all the NIMBYism you want.

"Yeah, to build in this region you have to pay this huge tax unless you fill out this form and we approve."

Any time you build an intelligent (read: complex) system you rely on the goodwill of the people that build it and maintain it to do what you want the system to do. This in turn gives those people great opportunities to take advantage of others.

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by rcpt on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @04:23PM (#31088529)
You're talking about "impact fees" which are dumb for that reason. OP is more about land value tax
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by imtringued on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @05:13PM (#31089275)
That is actually a good idea but you shouldn't tax the improvement to the land. If someone constructs a building that building should be privately owned just like a car would be privately owned.

A national dividend that pays out land value taxes democratizes access to land for all citizens of that nation and thereby makes it pointless to have exclusive access over specific plots of land for the sake of rent seeking. It only makes sense to own a plot of land if you want to "work" that land or rephrased, when society collectively agrees that you should have this plot of land.

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by seanmcdirmid on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @02:30PM (#31086969)
Property taxes should be doing that already, maybe we just need a national property tax? I'm all for basic income as a form of wealth re-distribution (as long as the money does't come from nowhere and stoke inflation).
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by zip1234 on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @02:40PM (#31087143)
Land value tax would prevent people from buying land without a plan to make it useful. IE ending land speculation and encouraging productive uses of land.
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by seanmcdirmid on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @03:55PM (#31088139)
> Land value tax would prevent people from buying land without a plan to make it useful.

Ya: a land value tax is just a property tax that ignores improvements (charing based on what could be built rather than what is built). But it would totally destroy the low income housing market (since property owners of old run down low-end rentals would be seriously penalized for not building new luxury apartments).

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by zip1234 on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @05:03PM (#31089118)
1. There is a difference between luxury apartments and new apartments. 2. More likely the most egregious wasted land uses will be destroyed and not something already being used fairly productively. For example empty lots or parking lots are low value and would be turned into housing, driving down prices far before any existing building would be affected
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by seanmcdirmid on Wednesday April 20, 2022 @12:10AM (#31092719)
> 1. There is a difference between luxury apartments and new apartments.

In the USA, not really. Today's new luxury apartment is tomorrow's old but affordable housing. Given the expense in building something, there isn't much cost difference to developers in building low-income units or high-income units, and if they go with the latter they will lose their shirts (Not to mention the low-income tenants of those houses would have to pay land use taxes similar to their richer neighbors).

> For example empty lots or parking lots are low value and would be turned into housing,

There really aren't many of those left in the cities people want to live in. Undergound parking and multi-level parking garages are already a thing in dense locations where property values alone mean turning something into a parking lot is bad use (unless you are saving up the parking lots to create something rand like Vulcan's South Lake Union project in Seattle).

I'm still all for it, but we would probably have to sink a lot more money into public housing to prevent a bloody revolution from occurring.

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by idiotsecant on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @02:23PM (#31086866)
In what sane universe is not requiring toilets and showers a solution to housing issues? I'm reasonably sure we can meet housing needs and still maintain basic human dignity.
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by andrewmutz on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @02:28PM (#31086947)
Not all housing need to go to a 4-person family. In my late teens and early 20s I shared a bathroom and a bedroom and never felt my dignity impinged. At that age it was much more important for it to be cheap than for it to be good.

It should not be illegal for such housing to exist.

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by evilduck on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @02:39PM (#31087116)
I think you're speaking past each other. The comment mentioned no access to shower facilities at all. Go search Youtube for tiny apartments in Japan or Tokyo and you'll quickly find rooms for rent where bathrooms and personal or communal showers simply don't exist, residents must walk to nearby businesses or public facilities like libraries during business hours just to relieve themselves. This is not a desirable housing situation either.

I think a dormitory or barracks style housing is perfectly acceptable as a solution but putting the burden of supplying bathrooms on private businesses or implicitly requiring people shit in buckets in their one and only room is not.

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by hpkuarg on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @02:28PM (#31086938)
For example, it would be nice to be able to build a dormitory- or barracks-style high-density, low-creature comforts housing, where multiple rooms may share a common bathroom and a kitchen, in areas with high homelessness to give those folks a place to call home. This is not currently legal in many jurisdictions due to building code limitations.

I might feel that a gigabit fiber connection is necessary to maintain basic human dignity ;-) but I don't think that should be enforced via law. One should be able to opt out for something more afforable.

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by lwkl on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @02:40PM (#31087133)
What is more affordable than Gigabit Fiber? Fiber infrastructure is cheaper to build than copper after all.
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by hpkuarg on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @02:51PM (#31087268)
Well, that's another whole issue that relates to policy. From what I've gathered, there's an ungodly amount of red tape involved in trying to be an upstart ISP at the residential level. So much so that one of the richest companies on the planet has only made inroads in like ten cities.
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by seanmcdirmid on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @02:32PM (#31087011)
A $250/month room with a shared toilet is better than living in a tent somewhere. Also, the need for showers can be mitigated with public bath houses, we used to have more of those...again...it makes lower end housing more viable, but most people will probably want their own toilet and shower and will pay for it.

> I'm reasonably sure we can meet housing needs and still maintain basic human dignity.

The proof of your hope would be in the pudding, and right now we have no pudding.

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by troupe on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @09:27PM (#31091682)
> A $250/month room with a shared toilet is better than living in a tent somewhere.

For the person living in it, yes. For other people living in the area, bringing in a large number of people who are just one step above living in a tent, may have impacts on the neighborhood that they don't want. Much of the resistance to building more housing is this at various different levels.

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by bombcar on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @09:36PM (#31091754)
NIMBY just is “keep out the poors” for the most part.
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by oneoff786 on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @02:29PM (#31086951)
One with a public bathhouse culture
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by oneoff786 on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @02:30PM (#31086967)
e) a land value tax
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by rcpt on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @04:25PM (#31088547)
That solves a) through d) to.
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by jjtheblunt on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @02:39PM (#31087118)
what does abhors second hand housing imply?
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by homonculus1 on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @02:26PM (#31086912)
Great plan, for a favela
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by seanmcdirmid on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @02:42PM (#31087165)
Tokyo is the farthest possible away you can get from a favela.
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by homonculus1 on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @03:09PM (#31087486)
>[homogenous Japanese population] is the farthest possible away you can get from [unrestricted immigration from the southern hemisphere].

Why yes, indeed, it is!

Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by imtringued on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @05:22PM (#31089400)
This is an absurd argument considering that American zoning has been exceptionally successful at segregating black people into their own separate communities. You have homogenous American neighborhoods and cities. When you are blaming someone else in this way you are not only admitting defeat but you are also an asshole.
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by homonculus1 on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @05:56PM (#31089826)
American neighborhoods are homogeneous, and you can see the result when you walk between them.
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by glogla on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @03:49PM (#31088053)
Ah, racism. Long time no see.
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by 8note on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @04:48PM (#31088882)
I'd certainly be interested in how racism within japan affects the housing market there, especially considering the racial bent behind this Canadian policy
Re:Canada bans foreign home buyers for two years by kevin_thibedeau on Tuesday April 19, 2022 @07:06PM (#31090548)
"Long time no see" is a racist mockery of Chinese immigrant broken English.