News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by cletus on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @07:53AM (#27289290)
I look forward to USB 4.1a Type C.2 Phase iii.b Gen 3E and the 482646282 different cable capability combinations that all plug in and have no distinction of those capabilities whatsoever. I also look forward to all the necessary and helpful posts telling me how the identical ports on my laptop are in fact diffferent despite their identical appearance.

But at least everything uses the same plug, so that’s nice.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by skybrian on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @03:03PM (#27294688)
It actually is sort of nice, because "works" isn't binary. It's nice to be able to charge a laptop with what you have, even if it doesn't charge quite as fast. You can transfer data over a cable at lower speeds even if it doesn't run at top speed.

Using the "right" cable is performance optimization. This isn't like the old days when plugging things in the wrong way might damage your machine.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by alerighi on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @03:56PM (#27295322)
Not using the proper cable could lead also to fires, for example. We are talking about a significant amount of current. If you don't use a cable rated for that current, the cable or the connector will overheat, and possibly start a fire.

And it's not a remote possibility. It happened to me with a fast charging phone power supply and the phone, and the cable was the one provided by the manufacturer! The type-C connector at the phone side was red hot and started to melt, probably caused by a bad connection caused by dirt in the phone connector. Fortunately I was there, and smelled the burnt plastic and disconnected the cable, but what if that happened at night?

And it's not something trivial that power supplies and phones can detect, there is not a way to determinate the voltage drop in the cable built into the standard (basically all they needed to do was to add a voltage sensing pin on the connector, to be shorted with VCC at the load side, so the power supply could sense the voltage at the other side and determinate if there too much drop, but as far as I know it doesn't have it).

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by zlsa on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @05:02PM (#27296061)
It should be impossible for any set of non-damaged, non-defective, spec-compliant set of USB-C cables and peripherals to cause fires. The specifications are very carefully designed to prevent any combination of cables and devices from causing damage.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by Animats on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @06:22PM (#27296848)
It should be impossible for any set of non-damaged, non-defective, spec-compliant set of USB-C cables and peripherals to cause fires.

Then there's the crap offered for sale on Alibaba which somebody will resell on Amazon and which will show up on a checkout rack at the gas station. USB-C has very tight tolerances and unusual material requirements. Dirt or water can create a conductive path all too easily with USB-C pin spacing.

"Decreasing the risk of fire in USB-C connectors" is worth watching.[1] It's an ad for a plastic material, but covers the problems.

[1] https://youtu.be/jYqDh9q5H6I

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by jiofih on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @06:56PM (#27297188)
I’ve never heard of USB-C causing a fire. The control ICs should cut the current the moment anything is out of spec. Do you have any examples of that?
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by mike_d on Thursday May 27, 2021 @03:06AM (#27300237)
https://www.reddit.com/r/Android/comments/7j3k38/anker_usbc_...

https://wccftech.com/macbook-survives-disables-all-usb-ports...

Researchers even developed an exploit for some USB-C fast chargers that forces it to deliver max power and try to catch the connected device on fire: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Es2SqubYSfo

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by baybal2 on Thursday May 27, 2021 @04:04AM (#27300495)
The problem is the gazillion of proprietary fast charging standards.

Some of them were designed for chargers with attached cable, and not disconnectable one.

Many charger ICs emulate the fast charging signalling to trick phones into charging faster, but they of course have no way to check if wiring is ok on micro-usb.

So you can end up with 5A-10A going over flimsy wires/contact pads. Or if they use type-c, they can end up using fake 5A cables. Or in case of VOOC, they don't check if the cable is an actual VOOC cable, which goes over 5A.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by ChuckNorris89 on Thursday May 27, 2021 @06:33AM (#27301253)
>Or in case of VOOC, they don't check if the cable is an actual VOOC cable, which goes over 5A

Actually they do. My OnePlus wich uses the same VOOC tech will not charge at full power with its fast charger if I don't use the cable from the box.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by baybal2 on Thursday May 27, 2021 @07:23AM (#27301655)
Do you use A to C cable, or C to C?

VooC A to C has a fifth pin mapped to CC pin on C side.

Rogue VooC C to C chargers just send VooC signalling directly on CC.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by ChuckNorris89 on Thursday May 27, 2021 @07:42AM (#27301812)
Mine is A to C.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by TheSpiceIsLife on Thursday May 27, 2021 @03:38AM (#27300384)
The comment two above yours is not enough?

Red hot metal and smoking plastic.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by worewood on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @08:14PM (#27297801)
Yeah but there will always be crap for Alibaba for anything you can think of. The solution would be banning charging altogether and adopt only proprietary standards.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by Animats on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @10:30PM (#27298681)
No, the solution for the US would be to refuse imports of any power device that lacks UL/CSA approval.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by spookthesunset on Thursday May 27, 2021 @11:29AM (#27304262)
I don’t even think that is required. I think what might be required is simply making it more explicit when a device is or is not UL listed. I shouldn’t have to search Amazon’s “questions” thing on a product listing to see if it is UL listed.

Of course I suppose products that actually are UL listed on Amazon will already mention the fact somewhere in their description.

That being said I’ve had more issues with low voltage crap letting the magic smoke out than mains powered devices.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by sneak on Thursday May 27, 2021 @02:48AM (#27300153)
What about the 96% of human beings that buy their electronics outside of the USA?
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by afiori on Thursday May 27, 2021 @06:01AM (#27301079)
they have their own corresponding government entities enact the corresponding regulations
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by rhinoceraptor on Thursday May 27, 2021 @02:25AM (#27299995)
The solution is obvious, they just need to be constructed of prefabulated amulite.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by Animats on Thursday May 27, 2021 @01:38PM (#27305809)
That's not entirely a joke. "Halogen-free polyamides are explicitly recommended by the USB-IF in the USB 3.1 specification."[1] Most common plastics do not have a high enough resistance to surface tracking, where, as the connector wears, a conductive path appears across the surface due to dirt and moisture.

[1] https://www.dsm.com/content/dam/dsm/electrical-electronics/e...

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by balefrost on Thursday May 27, 2021 @02:53PM (#27306692)
...as long as you have the necessary hydrocoptic marzlevanes. You don't want side fumbling.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by koube on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @05:10PM (#27296146)
The Nintendo Switch can be bricked if you use the wrong cable, although my understanding is that it's not built to the USB-C spec: https://www.reddit.com/r/NintendoSwitch/comments/87vmud/the_...

Either way, this is an incredibly common device that can be damaged by incompatible hardware where it's difficult to determine compatibility without bricking the device.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by fouric on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @05:24PM (#27296301)
> it's difficult to determine compatibility without bricking the device

This is the problem! This is what everybody talking about the specs doesn't get - it's difficult to (1) tell which spec a device claims to support and (2) verify that it actually supports it (see: a lot of cheap devices on Amazon) and also (3) in real life many devices do not support the specs (i.e. this isn't a theoretical problem).

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by vokep on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @05:44PM (#27296494)
Unless I'm mistaken, there is a license to call a port a USB port, though goods are commonly sold without that. In theory the solution is simple: only buy products that have the actual USB logo and ensure certification, and the USB-IF should retain the right to significantly fine any manufacturer advertising being to spec and using the logo who is in fact not.

In practice, people aren't going to stop buying nintendo switches, unfortunately.

Still, its not entirely necessary to support all specs or have that be entirely clear, what does need to be clear is if you can expect safety specs to be followed. If I plug in my nintendo switch to a charger thinking it'll charge at lightspeed but it takes hours, oh well. If I plug it in and it destroys the device then that should be pretty much an unforgivable problem. Personally I'd be happy to abstain from buying such a device due to that, though also personally I did buy one, expecting no issues, and only found out months later when seeing it mentioned somewhere online. Ideally research is done on every product to ensure things like this aren't the case, but again in practice, that doesn't always happen.

I'm not sure what the fix is, other than outright making USB not so universal by requiring a license for any and all vendors using the design, if the license is cheap enough, maybe that could work? I don't know the legalities so much but maybe a free license could be required for any implementation, which would only have the spec of "make sure it doesn't brick charger or device, and make sure it doesn't catch on fire"

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by dotancohen on Thursday May 27, 2021 @05:55AM (#27301038)
> only buy products that have the actual USB logo

I just took my Samsung A50 out of the case, no USB logo anywhere on the device. There's the Samsung logo, some recycling logo and a CE logo, and that's it.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by TheSpiceIsLife on Thursday May 27, 2021 @03:48AM (#27300432)
One solution could be to require different connectors for different protocols and power delivery.

I'm beginning to suspect The Great Filter is Jony Ive's minimalist design influence: any sufficiently advanced culture will annihilate itself before it discovers interstellar travel when someone connects two devices together that aren't compatible with the equivalent of a One True Connector™ USB cable.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by sgtnoodle on Friday May 28, 2021 @02:39AM (#27312392)
I like to imagine there's an alien species zipping around in FTL space ships, and the only difference from us is they picked one endianness and ran with it.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by chimeracoder on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @05:38PM (#27296440)
> Either way, this is an incredibly common device that can be damaged by incompatible hardware where it's difficult to determine compatibility without bricking the device.

This is 100% Nintendo's fault for using the USB-C connector type but not actually bothering to adhere to the USB-C specification.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by mortenjorck on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @09:35PM (#27298366)
Exactly. If you're going to base your interconnect on an industry standard, you have two options as far as I'm concerned:

A) Follow the spec

B) Make your off-spec interconnect physically incompatible with standard devices

Going off-spec with a compatible and physically indistinguishable connector is an "attractive nuisance," to use the tort term.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by mjevans on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @07:44PM (#27297575)
It would be OK if they didn't claim to be complaint, and FAILED SAFELY when used with complaint devices.

The issue is that they're both not compliant AND fail in a non-safe bad way.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by chimeracoder on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @08:10PM (#27297764)
IMO the issue is that they fail unsafe, whether or not they claim compliance.

Nintendo doesn't claim compliance, but if they're using the connector shape, it should comply with the spec for power delivery (which is honestly not even hard to do).

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by notatoad on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @08:39PM (#27297986)
again though, this is bad but not a flaw in usb-c. a manufacturer created a device that violates the spec.

MicroUSB devices can also be bricked by using non-conforming cables and power adapters, but fortunately devices like that are rare because the spec has existed long enough that all the bad devices have been flushed out of the market. manufacturers having made stupid decisions in the past does not mean we shouldn't make USB-C better now.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by tremon on Thursday May 27, 2021 @05:11AM (#27300818)
It absolutely is a flaw in usb-c that a large manufacturer can create a device that violates the spec and not face serious repercussions.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by evilduck on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @09:10PM (#27298180)
Is this actually a current problem? I haven't heard of this issue occurring at all in recent years beyond "better safe than sorry" warnings against it when people still ask, and even the original claims didn't seem especially widespread.

While it's anecdotal, I've been charging Switches in my household with all sorts of USB-C sources for a couple years now as well (20W Apple chargers, 18W Anker bricks, a MacBook Air, external battery packs, 12v car adapters, etc) and they're all still working.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by II2II on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @07:27PM (#27297437)
> It should be impossible for any set of non-damaged, non-defective, spec-compliant set of USB-C cables and peripherals to cause fires.

That is a fairly significant list of conditions. As an example, I have encountered significant heating in a damaged power cable on the original power supply of a laptop from a reputable vendor. It's easy to argue the owner should immediately replace the damaged power supply, yet many people will continue to use problematic hardware until it no longer functions. It is also the case that many companies will manufacture components down to a price (or, in the case of this vendor, for aesthetics) rather than make something that is robust.

I find it a bit disconcerting that we're talking about delivering 240 W over a cable that consumers are unlikely to differentiate from a 15 W cable (i.e. USB-C specification) or even from a 2.5 W cable (e.g a USB cable they would have used fifteen years ago).

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by Dylan16807 on Thursday May 27, 2021 @12:01AM (#27299248)
> That is a fairly significant list of conditions.

It is, but it's a list of things that could fail even if there was only one kind of cable. The added risk from having a bunch of different kinds of cable with varying capability is quite small.

> I find it a bit disconcerting that we're talking about delivering 240 W over a cable that consumers are unlikely to differentiate from a 15 W cable (i.e. USB-C specification) or even from a 2.5 W cable (e.g a USB cable they would have used fifteen years ago).

All these voltages are low enough that you can expect any cable to support them. What really matters is the amps, and the difference is much smaller there. Specially marked cables support 5 amps. All other USB C cables support 3 amps. Old USB cables will vary, but it's been standard fare to push 2.4 amps over them for a long time.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by iainmerrick on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @09:42PM (#27298397)
I find it a bit disconcerting that we're talking about delivering 240 W over a cable that consumers are unlikely to differentiate from a 15 W cable (i.e. USB-C specification) or even from a 2.5 W cable (e.g a USB cable they would have used fifteen years ago).

Yes, exactly! It’s foolhardy.

And maybe unnecessary -- haven’t Apple just shown that you can get amazing performance with very low power requirements? And shouldn’t we all be trying to minimize power usage, to try to reduce CO2 emissions, mining of rare and toxic elements, plastic waste, etc etc etc?

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by lovemenot on Thursday May 27, 2021 @05:22AM (#27300881)
What you say about efficiency is right, but it's complicated.

There are many domestic devices on 110 / 220v AC using less than 250W. They are native DC, but source AC because they must.

These devices are not likely to go away soon. In fact they'll proliferate so long as the developing world is still developing.

We can also expect proliferation of domestic battery and solar: both DC sources. A standardised domestic micro-grid of DC sources and consuming devices could be a boon to efficiency and reduction of single-purpose conversion devices such as power bricks and inverters.

As an example, every type of e-bicycle currently has a different proprietary adapter. Just as mobile phones once did. Most e-bikes charge at around 40v.

With 250W USB available we will likely see a switch to USB by e-bile manufacturers, resulting in more common lower cost equipment and better interoperability.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by dTal on Thursday May 27, 2021 @09:03AM (#27302559)
It's a sensible vision, but USB-C is absolutely the wrong tech for it (which, from experience, means it's the tech that will get adopted). The connectors are fiddly and expensive and fragile and unreliable and require a bunch of silicon logic to work. You can't mess about with power delivery stuff, it needs to be robust and cheap. A domestic DC power plug standard should have a single voltage standard, three pins (+,-,G), and be able to tolerate being stepped on without causing shorts.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by lovemenot on Thursday May 27, 2021 @10:34AM (#27303644)
I don't doubt you are technically right.

USB-C is presumably not the final word in USB connectors. Let's hope for both vision and better implementation.

What's wrong with having multiple set voltages? If it's the necessity of semiconductors, is that really so terrible in this day and age?

On a separate note, I hope they'd have properly managed EMI in this standard. USB has so many makers of varying quality, I can imagine cheap, badly-shielded cables and connectors playing merry hell with noise.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by hyperdimension on Friday May 28, 2021 @10:46AM (#27315953)
> a laptop from a reputable vendor

Why are comments here always so deliberately vague? I'd like to know which manufacturer. It seems like an important detail.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by NovemberWhiskey on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @05:48PM (#27296525)
Yeah the problem is that there's nothing to stop product designers from specifying the connectors even though the device doesn't logically support the implied standards.

Some people here talked about the Switch; but it's a general problem. For example: I have an external USB drive that has a Type A USB 3 host socket on the back of it (???). It came with a cable with a Type A USB 3 plug on one end and a USB C plug on the other end.

Now that's a combination of connectors you will definitely see elsewhere. I have such a cable that came with my PS5 for charging its controllers - but I know for a fact that it's not interchangeable with the one for my external drive.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by dzhiurgis on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @06:00PM (#27296647)
But what does universal shape of connector has to do with?

Power negotiation applies to USB-A just as it does with USB-C... (I think)

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by chx on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @06:31PM (#27296946)
> Power negotiation applies to USB-A

Nope it doesn't.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by dzhiurgis on Thursday May 27, 2021 @05:58PM (#27309085)
Which is why there's more fires with usb-a
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by chx on Friday May 28, 2021 @07:20AM (#27314043)
nah, there's more fires with USB A because it's more widespread, simple as that. There are plenty C cables from your favorite online dollar store (amazon, aliexpress, jd etc) which are a serious fire hazard.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by Workaccount2 on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @05:22PM (#27296272)
>The specifications are very carefully designed

I need assurance though that my cables were carefully designed.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by notatoad on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @08:41PM (#27298008)
buy your cables from reputable manufacturers...
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by dragontamer on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @03:59PM (#27295352)
> We are talking about a significant amount of current.

Are we?

I'm not sure how they deliver more power in this specification. But traditionally, the additional power (from 5W to 20W to 100W) was through additional *voltage*, not current.

> And it's not something trivial that power supplies and phones can detect, there is not a way to determinate the voltage drop in the cable built into the standard (basically all they needed to do was to add a voltage sensing pin on the connector, to be shorted with VCC at the load side, so the power supply could sense the voltage at the other side and determinate if there too much drop, but as far as I know it doesn't have it).

Surely we just set a current-limit, written into the specification. Then we choose AWG wires / connectors as appropriate to support that current.

Voltage can't go up arbitrarily, but voltage can safely be increased to ~48V or so in most applications. After 48V, humans start to get shocked / hurt, so that's probably the reasonable limit.

-----

And I'm pretty sure you can sense the voltage drop across a cable. USB-3 delivers 5V by default, and then you send protocol commands to increase your voltage to 12V or whatever. If you detect that the power-supply is only supplying 11V (after the 12V command), then its either a PSU-error or a cable-error. And I'm not sure if it even matters which is which (either way, you're not getting enough power, so your device needs to probably shut off)

You can then disconnect / reset your device and maybe stick to 5V default specs.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by maxerickson on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @05:12PM (#27296179)
It's 5 amps at 48 volts, defined in https://usb.org/document-library/usb-power-delivery

That level of power delivery is negotiated after the devices are connected. The cable also has to advertise that it is capable of that power delivery.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by dangerlibrary on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @04:20PM (#27295567)
> Voltage can't go up arbitrarily, but voltage can safely be increased to ~48V or so in most applications. After 48V, humans start to get shocked / hurt, so that's probably the reasonable limit.

Car batteries in ICE cars are nominally 12v. Grab both terminals and tell me it doesn't hurt.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by StrictDabbler on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @04:28PM (#27295675)
Ok, done. Many many many times.

12v can't exceed the resistance of human skin so it doesn't matter how much current capacity it has. You can hold onto those terminals all day.

It's settled science. If you doubt it, tests of this are all over YouTube. It's just true.

Now your tongue, perhaps...

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by swader999 on Thursday May 27, 2021 @02:55AM (#27300185)
So my cat doesn't have to worry?
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by amluto on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @06:00PM (#27296652)
If t you short a car battery, you might not get electrocuted, but the results are unlikely to be pretty.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by wearywanderer on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @06:46PM (#27297103)
You can't short a car battery by touching the terminals with your dry unbroken skin, anymore than you can short a AA battery by touching both ends.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by stordoff on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @08:07PM (#27297741)
You aren't shorting the battery in this case. There's still a significant resistance (your body, particularly the skin contact resistance) between the terminals.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by dandelany on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @04:29PM (#27295679)
...it doesn't hurt. Dry skin isn't conductive enough to pass any significant current at 12V. But if you inserted electrodes into your fingers so the electricity conducted through your wet inner bits, you can be killed by a lot less than 12V across the heart.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by martyvis on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @04:31PM (#27295711)
I have never felt anything holding 12V DC in my hands. Putting your tongue across 9V "transistor" battery terminals is another thing though.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by dragontamer on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @04:37PM (#27295770)
I've left a 9V battery in my pocket once and it touched a penny. I definitely felt that, lol.

But yeah, 9V and 12V don't hurt your skin at all. The worst you'll get typically is when you accidentally short it with some metal, and something becomes burning hot really quickly.

But this "burning hot" issue can happen even with 1.5V NiMH batteries or 3.3V Li-Ion batteries (even hot enough to start a fire in your pocket! Like all those vaping accidents).

That's not "shock" or "electricity", that's literally heat from some other thing messing up the battery pack. So its not really the same.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by sjruckle on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @04:27PM (#27295647)
I've done this. It doesn't hurt. In fact I didn't feel anything besides the battery terminals.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by ChrisMarshallNY on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @05:52PM (#27296575)
When I was a kid, we had this massive high-voltage transformer that produced about 2,000 volts, at some sick amperage.

We used it to make jacob's ladders. That was fun.

Until I touched the two bars.

I woke up on the other side of the room, smelling burning...me.

That wasn't fun...

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by Tempest1981 on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @08:02PM (#27297696)
I learned this recently:

> If you receive a shock, if can affect the rhythm of your heart and cause problems later. We’re taught to go and get an ECG after receiving a shock. Like jump in the car and go to the doctor or hospital, and have someone else drive you. If you’ve received a shock - go get checked out. -jaidan

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27259589

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by Taniwha on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @08:24PM (#27297877)
yup, always work around high voltages with your left hand (the one closes to your heart) in your pocket, to discourage unwanted currents from passing through the heart
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by orthoxerox on Thursday May 27, 2021 @04:16AM (#27300557)
As the old joke goes, experienced electricians touch even their wife's breasts with only one hand, just in case.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by tempestn on Thursday May 27, 2021 @02:27AM (#27300019)
The main reason being that you don't want to be working with both hands, since then current can travel in one and out the other, directly across your chest.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by Dylan16807 on Thursday May 27, 2021 @12:06AM (#27299290)
I saw that too but I wouldn't spread it as a fact without a better source.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by Tempest1981 on Thursday May 27, 2021 @08:00AM (#27301956)
I found this, but it's more than a mild shock:

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2658458/

Bing's answer-mode points here:

https://healthcare.utah.edu/the-scope/shows.php?shows=0_esno...

Always hard to know how cautious to be, with so many variables.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by maxerickson on Thursday May 27, 2021 @12:22PM (#27304850)
I recently had some industrial training that made the same point. The recommendation there was to immediately hook up an AED.

You can go into tachycardia or bradycardia (fast and slow heartbeats), so feeling sort of okay isn't the end of it.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by OJFord on Friday May 28, 2021 @10:37AM (#27315823)
Hadn't heard of this, and initial results had no clear link to electricity:

https://wonders.physics.wisc.edu/jacobs-ladder/

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by dTal on Thursday May 27, 2021 @09:08AM (#27302621)
Good god, you were lucky to live!
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by ChrisMarshallNY on Thursday May 27, 2021 @12:14PM (#27304749)
You have no idea...

That was nowhere near the stupidest thing I've done...

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by throaway46546 on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @04:57PM (#27296011)
It just tingles a bit if anything.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by beervirus on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @06:29PM (#27296928)
It doesn’t tingle.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by contriban on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @04:11PM (#27295469)
From what I understand, the cable has to advertise the supported power output, it’s not like a raw power outlet that will start a fire if you use a random thin cable. A 5W USB cable will probably never receive 240W, even by mistake.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by unparagoned on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @05:56PM (#27296609)
When I last worked with USB, there were all sorts of resistors over the pins telling you about its capabilities. I'm pretty sure usb-c has that as well. Your device should check the spec of the cable and inly draw the amount if power its rated for
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by freeone3000 on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @08:14PM (#27297793)
There's a microcontroller in the cable negotiating the power transfer rate, data transfer rate, and other capabities.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by x0 on Thursday May 27, 2021 @08:31AM (#27302224)
Is a resistor really enough to determine if a 5W cable gets 240W?
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by spookthesunset on Thursday May 27, 2021 @12:16PM (#27304783)
Current is often measured by putting a small value resistor of a precisely known value and measuring its voltage drop.

I = V/R

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by dTal on Thursday May 27, 2021 @08:49AM (#27302424)
I have also had my phone's USB-C port spontaneously self-destruct, effectively ruining the phone. As you say, burning smells and melted plastic, and I shudder to think if I hadn't been there to power it off and yank the battery.

And just this past weekend, a close friend of mine had their Galaxy S6 drain completely to 0 in a minute or two, and then claim water damage in the boot screen (which tests resistance across the port). The phone wasn't wet.

Both times, the phone wasn't even plugged in. I am beginning to look very askance at USB-C ports.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by modeless on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @04:59PM (#27296028)
> Not using the proper cable could lead also to fires, for example

Only if the cable or device is defective or damaged. Which is true of every type of charging cable or connector.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by tom_mellior on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @09:01PM (#27298132)
> defective or damaged. Which is true of every type of charging cable or connector.

Yes, that's my experience with USB-C as well.

(Seriously, my Dell laptop and Dell dock connected by a Dell cable can't keep up a reliable connection. People are saying that the spec is fine, but a spec that's this hard to implement well is maybe not fine.)

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by andrewmunsell on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @03:13PM (#27294802)
Explaining to my aunt or uncle or grandparents that, no, the cable and charger they bought isn't the right one for their phone/laptop/whatever even though it fits isn't ideal. Sure, it might just charge slowly (cue family tech support call), but it could also just show "not charging" on OS X for example, which is just confusing for most people.

It's a real problem, even if tech savvy people are fine with lower charge speeds because we know that the charger/cable/device combo only supports PD profile whatever.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by chrisacky on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @03:49PM (#27295206)
Even I have this problem. I bbought an amp reader and throw out anything reporting below 0.4ma/h. So many devices come bundles with poor cables my house is riddled with cables that I just never want to use for charging.

I'm actually TERRIFIED of pluggin anything in to my kids Switch other than Nintendo's official cable, incase I brick i t.

Does anyone know if they've patched this? I have some Dell laptop charger USB-Cs which I use alot, and I've had to caution everything in the family to never plug the Switch into it despite it fitting and despite every room in the house having such a charger...

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by whelming_wave on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @05:13PM (#27296192)
The Switch cable situation is always going to be a bit finicky, because their port is on the extreme edge of the spec's tolerances - it gets shorted because it's actually possible to cross the power into the wrong terminal, IIRC, with some wiggling. Safest to go with the official stuff, which people haven't reported issues with.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by MinorTom on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @04:52PM (#27295948)
The Switches USB-C implementation is genuinely broken, so this isn't the fault of the connector. A spec-compliant charger, cable and connector will never brick anything (or catch on fire, for that matter)
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by berdario on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @07:55PM (#27297654)
I think I've used:

- a pixel charger - macbook charger - HP charger

and the Switch works fine with all of them.

OTOH, if you try to use one of those for the docking station, the docking station will refuse to work

I heard that it's because it supports only a lower amount of Watts than what the Macbook charger can provide, for example... (60W or 85W) While other chargers, like the pixelbook's (45W) work just fine

But I agree that it's unnerving: I connected a disposable switch to the cables that I didn't trust, before trusting to use my main Switch with them

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by megamegaman on Thursday May 27, 2021 @02:03AM (#27299874)
I understand that simply charging is fine, while video output is the riskier action because of unofficial docks that use a Switch-incompatible voltage for signalling. The wrong voltage can burn out a specific chip and require resoldering.

For what it's worth I sold the official charger/dock that came with my Switch more than a year ago and have been using only third-party chargers/cables plus a Covert Dock since then. No issues :)

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by cheschire on Thursday May 27, 2021 @05:39AM (#27300962)
I bricked my switch on a multi-device charging station. Had to mail it into nintendo and they replaced the whole motherboard. Surprisingly the entire repair process cost less than a replacement switch motherboard on ifixit.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by robotnikman on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @04:07PM (#27295430)
I use an HP laptop USB C charger with my switch sometimes, if that anecdote helps.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by nuodag on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @06:27PM (#27296895)
I spend years explaining to my family that its not a catastrophe if they can't find their phone charger, it's micro USB, see, just take this one from the drawer, it doesn't matter if it says Samsung or Sony, if it fits it will work.

They were right being mistrusting apparently.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by texaswhizzle on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @06:51PM (#27297142)
How is this any different than buying the wrong cable in the past? You used to have to choose USB2, USB3, USB3.x, micro USB, mini USB, DisplayPort, Mini DisplayPort, HDMI, mini HDMI, VGA, DVI, thunderbolt, and more.

I think people are either too young to remember this disaster, or have just outright forgotten.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by aduitsis on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @10:08PM (#27298560)
Allow me to say it's slightly different, because you could basically tell the difference by just looking at the connector carefully. The knowledge that if it connects, it'll 99.9% work is too ingrained in all of us. Usb-c breaks that norm.

Now you have to carefully see what the packaging says, which can range from inadvertently unclear to downright misleading. And to add to that, you don't know what to look for in the first place if you don't have prior experience with thunderbolt/usb-c. Example, I didn't know that a cable must explicitly mention DP in order to connect to an external monitor. Because it was the first time I had an external monitor that can use usb-c.

Not really complaining, usb-c is very very nice. Just pointing the minor annoyance of learning its warts.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by andrewmunsell on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @07:31PM (#27297470)
The issue is more the ubiquity-- when everything from my phone, to Nintendo Switch, to headphones, to flashlight, to laptop use the same cord for power and data, it's a bigger problem than the low spec HDMI cable you plug in once.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by throwaway894345 on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @03:15PM (#27294815)
Meh, I would rather know that what I have is going to work correctly. Now we're going to have many more calls to customer service complaining that our devices aren't charging/transferring-data at the advertised rates and every rep is going to start by telling us to use only the cable that was provided with our device. I, a technical person, don't enjoy dealing with this stuff, and it's going to be hell for my non-technical family and friends (who will naturally come to me with their problems).

That it won't damage their device is certainly wonderful, but I definitely think the cons outweigh the pros.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by shalmanese on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @03:32PM (#27295018)
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by MrSourz on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @05:49PM (#27296533)
A good example happened to me yesterday. I brought my MacBook and charger to my partner’s family’s place along with my USB-C SSD that has some files I thought I might need on it; however, I managed to forget the USB-C charging cable for my computer. I ended up using the USB-C cable that came with my SSD. It’s not charging at full speed, but it’s working!
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by endymi0n on Thursday May 27, 2021 @03:01AM (#27300210)
Spot on. It all is a massive step forward from the times when my mom asked me which cable to plug in where and identical (but fully different) PS/2 connectors for mouse and keyboard were still a thing.

The fact that power doesn‘t just go through a data cable, but actually in all kinds of voltages, useful power levels and in _both directions_ is nothing short of awesome. Fun fact: Didn‘t really find the charching port on my new USB-C power bank until I realized it‘s the same as the output port...

The fact that even degradation is graceful is great. I don‘t always have the 90W brick with me when I‘m on the road with the MacBook, but more than one time I‘ve not regretted at least having a lightweight USB cable in my backpack in order to use a phone charger over night. Granted, I can‘t play games on it in that configuration, but hey, it‘ll still hold up nicely over many hours and I can still work.

Good times!

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by drewzero1 on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @06:10PM (#27296733)
"Works" may be a spectrum, but "works optimally" is binary.

There is so much variation in the USB spec that a data transfer or a battery charge could take a few minutes or a few hours depending on which cable and which port/adapter you use, with no foolproof way to make sure you're putting together the right equipment, because regardless, it still "works", just not very well.

Don't get me wrong, it's great that it "works". I just wish it was clearer what I need to make it work optimally, aside from just using the one brick and cable that came with my device (assuming I was so lucky).

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by wearywanderer on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @03:36PM (#27295067)
I can count the number of times I have ever had to charge my laptop with somebody else's cable on one hand. And I've been using laptops exclusively since 2006.

My current laptop (an XPS 9310) has USB-C for charging. But I would be very reticent to ever charge it with somebody else's cable, and without a 'usb condom' I wouldn't even consider charging from some random public cable (e.g. airport charging kiosks.) USB charging for laptops has the same "untrusted cable" problems as USB charging for cellphones.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by MisterTea on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @03:46PM (#27295169)
> It actually is sort of nice, because "works" isn't binary.

Spoken like a true gaslit tech user.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by aboringusername on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @08:12AM (#27289467)
We should give anyone involved in the USB-IF a test:

Here are 10 different cables, you must accurately describe each of their features in detail (USB speeds, charging speeds/power delivery, video out? What version of Display Port does it support?). Make one mistake and you'll be executed.

Obviously I don't advocate for that but it's damn annoying you can have one cable do so many different things and not know by looking at it. At least USB 3 was often times blue to offer a distinction.

These days I plug in a cable and prey it functions as advertised (sometimes it's 50/50).

Awful mess.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by SAI_Peregrinus on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @09:52AM (#27290488)
The issue isn't the number of things supported, it's that there are optionally-supported things. If every cable needed to support everything, and every host port needed to support every valid device type, it'd be fine. But instead you get cables that don't properly work with alternate modes, host ports that don't implement DisplayPort, etc. It's cheaper, but ridiculously frustrating.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by cletus on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @12:42PM (#27292775)
Sorry but not true. To get full bandwidth really limits how long the cable can be. Like I don't think you'll find 40Gbps cables longer than about 0.5m.

This is more expensive too (eg there are generally chips in the plugs at either end to handle attenuation).

But there's obviously a use case for cables longer than that.

It is true that we have cables that support data but not power and power but not data or data at different bandwidths and so on. It's a mess. But it's not a case of simply choosing not to support optional features.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by danhor on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @03:17PM (#27294833)
The Apple Thunderbolt 3 Pro Cable (2 m) is one of the only cables that can support everything usb-c over such a long distance [1]. But that costs 129$, which just wouldn't work for smartphone charging for which cables (usb-c 2.0 & 60w, the least you can do while still being spec-compliant) cost 7$. I think I haven't seen such a clear & easy to grasp demonstration of tradeoffs anywhere else.

[1] For the longest time, this was the only cable to do it all. I think more are available now, but they're still very much non-affordable.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by SAI_Peregrinus on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @04:42PM (#27295845)
No, it's a matter of expense. It's possible to embed a redriver in the cable every 0.5m, and thus get longer cables at full speed. They're just very, very expensive.

There are three alternatives: one cable type that does everything and is easy to use (but gets expensive quickly as it gets longer), multiple cable types that each do somewhat different things but use identical connectors, or multiple cable types that each do somewhat different things and use different connectors. The USB-IF went with the "multiple cable types, identical connectors" option, which is cheap but extremely confusing. The "multiple cable types, multiple connectors" is what USB was created to avoid. So the only remaining option to remove confusion is to have expensive cables.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by jsight on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @01:53PM (#27293825)
> These days I plug in a cable and prey it functions as advertised (sometimes it's 50/50).

Are you preying on the folks at USB-IF?

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by grawprog on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @01:50PM (#27293789)
I haven't had to delve into the world of trying to find an appropriate USB-C cable until fairly recently. I didn't actually understand the situation thinking a replacement USB-C cable should just work.

Oh hell no and none of the packaging actually explains what features a cable supports, none of them actually explain what the cable is actually compatible with. The little android logo doesn't mean shit. Sure, you might be able to slowly charge your phone with a particular cable, but it doesn't mean it'll do anything else it's supposed to do.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by neither_color on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @02:03PM (#27293939)
And every time I buy a new device and think I'll be able to use my existing USB-C cables I'm met with a new standard. Bought a new external GPU enclosure? My macbook charging cable wont work I need a 40gbps thunderbolt THREE(not 2) cable. Bought a new Oculus Quest? Neither my egpu or macbook cables work I need an $80 LINK cable.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by grlass on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @02:06PM (#27293978)
I wonder if the the committee have looked at integrating colour or some other indicator into the standard so that cable/port capabilities are clear visually.

Though ofc the design challenge is for users to feel comfortable that putting red into blue won't break anything, it just might not give the expected features.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by bogidon on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @04:07PM (#27295427)
From the actual spec[1]:

> All EPR cables shall be Electronically Marked and include EPR-specific information in the eMarker as defined by the USB PD specification. As defined in the USB PD specification, EPR cables are marked as 50 V and 5 A capable. All EPR cables shall be visibly identified with EPR cable identification icons as defined by the USB-IF. This is required so that end users will be able to confirm visually that the cable supports up to as high of PDP = 240W as defined in the USB PD specification."

Both are important. I also wish devices had some UI to easily show the capabilities of a connected cable to the user. I could not find actual visual representations of the the "identification icons".

[1]: (page 143) https://usb.org/document-library/usb-type-cr-cable-and-conne...

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by ctoth on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @04:27PM (#27295659)
Can confirm, sucks if you're blind.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by gord288 on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @06:20PM (#27296833)
Some kind of Braille markings, or similar, really should be a standard part of the spec.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by ohazi on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @02:16PM (#27294080)
Indicator recommendations are routinely ignored. There are already color codes for type-A ports, and there's the "lightning bolt" indicator for Thunderbolt USB-C ports, but PC manufacturers ignore them when they want their laptops to have a certain look and feel (e.g. gaming laptops want red or green everything, Apple wants aluminum everything, etc.).

Cable manufacturers are going to do whatever is cheapest.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by SiVal on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @03:39PM (#27295085)
Since the design philosophy behind USB-C is "it must always seem as though it should work", I think we'll need something like the old "tube testers" a few of us still remember.

Decades ago, when your TV was behaving badly, you would take the back off (unplug first!), pull the vacuum tubes out, and take them in a bag to the nearest convenience store. They had a "tube tester" the size of a washing machine. You'd plug each tube into a connector, one at a time, press the "test" button, and the needle on the dial would show good/poor/fail. The body of the tester was a cabinet containing replacement tubes you could buy (and which you could even test right there).

We might need to start using USB-C cable testers. Plug in a new cable, get a good/poor/fail analysis of each potential USB-C feature, then you mark your cable yourself with some labeling scheme.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by lazide on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @04:01PM (#27295372)
God damnit - TAKE MY MONEY!

I've been having to implement tons of my own testing because no cable ever works the way you think it will. I've got a giant pile of thick super beefy USB-C cables which only transmit data at USB 2.0 speeds. Which per the USB standards committee is apparently Working As Intended, but that is definitely not ok.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by tingletech on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @08:19PM (#27297832)
I remember some drugstores had these when I was growing up. My grandpa had two of them in his garage; where he had bought the machine and the stores' collection of tubes, when they were falling out of fasion.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by watersb on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @09:18PM (#27298246)
Excellent idea.

I remember going through the tube testing ritual with my Mom. Good times. It was really interesting to me, how my Mom could take things apart and figure things out.

(She taught me that the inside of a TV was dangerous, and kept the screwdrivers up where I couldn't reach them.)

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by ktkoffroth on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @08:14PM (#27297792)
I'm down to work on this idea.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by grlass on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @02:24PM (#27294214)
Yeah, it's a bit of tragedy.

Resistor style stripes on cables would be fun, a stripe for each feature such as bandwidth, power, etc; perhaps already suggested (and ignored). Though complement for ports would be trickier.

Embossing symbols in the style of thunderbolt might be the way to go, even if the standard is not fully adopted.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by Dylan16807 on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @04:09PM (#27295444)
> each feature such as bandwidth, power, etc;

Honestly that's about all you need.

Even just a bandwidth indicator would be suitable 90% of the time.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by spicybright on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @02:37PM (#27294378)
Ha, I love the color idea.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by omega3 on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @03:24PM (#27294934)
This is terrible for colorblind people.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by salawat on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @08:03PM (#27297704)
For accessibility, assign specific texture patterns on the outside of the insulation for different capabilities. Then you can tell the capabilities by running the cable through your hands.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by watersb on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @09:27PM (#27298313)
I actually have started down this path for my own cables -- the nylon braided ones are lower power etc.

My first attempt was different colors for each device, but was too tedious.

Three categories - low power, high power slow USB2, and 100W Thunderbolt.

- Low power: generic cables from wherever

- High power slow: cables that came with reputable charger (the vendor's cable, like Apple or Samsung; my favorite 3rd party charger is https://www.ravpower.com/products/rp-pc112-gan-tech-61w-wall...)

- Thuderbolt: I buy from https://eshop.macsales.com/shop/Thunderbolt

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by madsbuch on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @02:45PM (#27294475)
Or! We could go one step further, and change the connector to make sure that people use them correctly. Wouldn't that be clever!?
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by samatman on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @04:00PM (#27295367)
I don't actually want this. I would rather have the problems that come with incompatible cables than the problems which come with incompatible ports.

In particular, if my Thunderbolt ports didn't support bog-standard USB, that would suck. I would need special ports which weren't as powerful, or even more dongles, or both.

As it stands, things are.. fine, actually. I have one TB cable that works on everything, and a small handful of USB-C cables which work on most things. and a USB-C-or-Thunderbolt-and-I-don't-know-or-care to DisplayPort which stays plugged into my monitor. and a USB-C-or-Thunderbolt-etc to microHDMI for my camera.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by 8note on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @04:05PM (#27295406)
I think that doesn't make a lot of sense.

You'd need a cross product of different cable shapes for all the different available features, since the cable could support any number of them.

On top of that, the connector has mechanical constraints to handle, and some of these connector shapes will be suboptimal and undertested

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by Klinky on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @03:55PM (#27295295)
People already incorrectly buy USB A when they should have bought USB C or visa versa. Changing the physical form-factor doesn't solve this problem.

"I thought I needed a USB cable"?

Also it's a huge waste if say an HDMI 2.1 cable cannot be used on an HDMI 2.0/1.4 device. People would complain about that too.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by wearywanderer on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @03:58PM (#27295336)
> People already incorrectly buy USB A when they should have bought USB C or visa versa. Changing the physical form-factor doesn't solve this problem.

At least the nature of the problem is immediately apparent to such people the moment they attempt to plug the cable in. If the cable won't fit, they know there is nothing wrong with their computer; they didn't misconfigure anything or click the wrong button. The problem is unambiguous.

Some USB-C cables not working with some USB-C sockets leaves users feeling gaslit.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by Klinky on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @04:06PM (#27295421)
Except people have damaged ports forcing incorrect form factors. Also we've had tons of other standards where cables vary with performance. HDMI, DisplayPort, IDE, USB1/2/3.

You'll get people complaining about the cable not working with their new device, and then people complaining it didn't work with their old device.

Eventually USB-C will be so capable and ubiquitous, this will be a non-factor. I don't miss the days of trying to track down the right barrel connector, micro-HDMI cable or proprietary and fragile network dongle adapter. Those weren't easier days.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by wearywanderer on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @04:09PM (#27295443)
I would love to see somebody attempt to damage a micro-USB or USB-C port by forcing a USB-A plug into it. Not going to happen, sorry. They may as well try to force a NEMA-5 plug into a VGA port. It's nonsensical.

At a certain point on the usability continuum, user error becomes so severe that only dementia can explain it. But USB-C incompatibilities are so far from that point that arguing otherwise seems like bad faith. These USB-C incompatibilities can bite technically inclined people with sound, sober and healthy minds.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by Klinky on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @04:33PM (#27295729)
What is your suggested solution? Every potential configuration USB-C can offer needs its own physically different cable? We're going to need a dozen different form factors now. How do you do that at scale economically?

How does it help when someone inevitably buys the USB-C cable with shape y when they need USB-C cable with shape x? It physically doesn't fit, great, but they still have the wrong cable and their device still doesn't work, not even in a degraded fashion. They still have to take it back to the store.

Typically these issues bite people who bought cheap junky cables that weren't USB-IF certified off Amazon by sorting for lowest price. If it's not working, check that your cable is certified for what your intended use case is. This applies to everything, not just USB-C.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by wearywanderer on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @05:12PM (#27296174)
They could, at the very least, enforce color coding. Colorblind people would still be left high and dry, but with the status quo everybody is up shit creek.

> How does it help when someone inevitably buys the USB-C cable with shape y when they need USB-C cable with shape x? [...] They still have to take it back to the store.

It helps because they know they have to go back to the store, and aren't left wondering if the problem is actually with themselves somehow using their computer wrong. As I mentioned earlier: "Some USB-C cables not working with some USB-C sockets leaves users feeling gaslit."

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by Klinky on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @05:25PM (#27296318)
USB3 did have blue color coding on the plastic interior of the connector. That doesn't exist on USB-C. You'd have to color-code the metallic connector or the connector housing. Forcing a color-coding scheme on the connector housing would clash with branding, so you'd likely end up with companies ignoring the color coding.

People will also ignore the color coding even if it existed. Counterfeiters would add the color to add legitimacy to their incompatible products. Color coding would not physically prevent you from plugging the cable in.

The people who feel gaslit over a USB-C cable not working would probably also feel gaslit over buying the "wrong USB C cable", because they bought a "USB C cable" and "USB C should just work, why do I have to remember which of 12 different connectors my computer uses, I thought the point of USB C was a unified connector".

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by wearywanderer on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @06:53PM (#27297166)
> The people who feel gaslit over a USB-C cable not working would probably also feel gaslit over buying the "wrong USB C cable",

They might feel deceived or mislead by the packaging, but they won't have to wonder if they are somehow using their computer wrong. Particularly for people who lack confidence with computers, this means a lot.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by Klinky on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @08:11PM (#27297769)
While I can understand the desire to make it easier for non-savvy computer users, I don't think it's worth destroying the technical gains USB-C brings with it. Again, we've had non-savvy users hook stuff up wrong or destroy things even when ports had differentiated shapes. A software solution to identify the incompatibility and notify the user seems more practical than redesigning the connector for every evolution of USB-C.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by 8note on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @04:06PM (#27295420)
If at first the cable doesn't fit, apply more force.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by IgorPartola on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @06:16PM (#27296784)
Better: add a color band to the connector. One line for low power, two for medium, three for high.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by Klinky on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @09:52PM (#27298459)
The problem is you have:

Power: 18W, 30W, 45W, 60W, 100W, 240W

Data: No Data, 480Mbps, 5Gbps, 10Gbps, 20Gbps, 40Gbps

You also have a potential variety of modes that could influence your ability to achieve those speeds with certain devices.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by Dylan16807 on Thursday May 27, 2021 @12:14AM (#27299329)
That sounds like two markings, not too hard.

Also there are no power ratings below 60W, and I don't think "no data" is a valid cable.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by Klinky on Thursday May 27, 2021 @01:43AM (#27299775)
USB-PD supports 5, 9, 15 or 20v at between 0 - 5 amps. Higher power typically needs a thicker gauge wire.

There are definitely "charge-only" cables being marketed.

Two markings with each having multiple variations. You will have a dozen plus combinations, that will only get more complex.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by Dylan16807 on Thursday May 27, 2021 @04:01PM (#27307546)
> USB-PD supports 5, 9, 15 or 20v at between 0 - 5 amps. Higher power typically needs a thicker gauge wire.

Every voltage below 20 maxes out at 3 amps. As far as cables go, 60 is the minimum watts supported.

> There are definitely "charge-only" cables being marketed.

Are they valid though?

> Two markings with each having multiple variations. You will have a dozen plus combinations, that will only get more complex.

I don't really care how many combos there are. I won't need most of them. Most of the time I just want speed or power, sometimes I want both, and it's always a minimum requirement rather than anything specific.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by Klinky on Thursday May 27, 2021 @07:05PM (#27309711)
>Every voltage below 20 maxes out at 3 amps. As far as cables go, 60 is the minimum watts supported.

Perhaps for PD 2.0/3.0 but there is also legacy USB PD 1.0 and USB-C BC. During that era I believe 1.5A was minimum.

>Are they valid though?

Probably not, looks like USB 2.0 data is minimum required.

>I don't really care how many combos there are. I won't need most of them.

Just because you don't need specific combinations, doesn't mean you won't have to wade through all possible combinations to find the cable you're looking for.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by endgame on Thursday May 27, 2021 @02:46AM (#27300134)
By the time the relevant committees have worked over that idea, there will be fifteen bands in colours that you need tetrachromic vision to differentiate between.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by IgorPartola on Thursday May 27, 2021 @09:34AM (#27302885)
Can’t do color as people are color blind. Need to do it by number of bands.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by jquery on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @03:10PM (#27294771)
Didn’t Europe ban this?
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by mamurphy on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @03:36PM (#27295058)
jquery was downvoted but I recall articles like this (https://www.theverge.com/2020/1/17/21070848/eu-apple-europea...) with the EU trying to ban any "non-standard" connector.

Maybe non-standard connectors are actually a feature, not a bug, because everything having the same connector but not the same functionality will lead to confusion as described above.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by 8note on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @04:22PM (#27295603)
I don't think it was ever true that the connectors on the two devices determine whether they're compatible.

You can find all sorts of different connectors on a cable to connect two devices together, but you still only knew that devices are/are not compatible by trying to plug them in

At least with the current setup, you are unlikely to burn out the devices by trying a cable.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by dr_orpheus on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @02:12PM (#27294041)
This does seem like it would be helpful. They started coloring the USB-A ports blue for those that were compatible with USB 3 high speed data. I think the challenge may be to get people to understand it more than being afraid to plug blue in to black. I know quite a few people just assumed the color choice was a design choice and if the cable fits, plug it in.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by Rebelgecko on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @02:28PM (#27294277)
My Oculus Quest works fine with a 3meter AmazonBasics USB cable that I got for like $15. I think the only advantage of the official link cable is that it gets you 5m without needing to add an extender to a 3m cable
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by neither_color on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @04:55PM (#27295974)
It works but it if you run a high bandwidth game like Flight Simulator you might hit some performance limits, you can check your cable speed in the quest desktop app.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by snailmailman on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @07:17PM (#27297333)
I’m not the same user but I haven’t had any problems with my cheap usb cable. Only that the cheaper cable I got is shorter.

I haven’t done the speed test in a while but last I checked I think it was 3Gbps? Not quite the theoretical max for the port/cable but easily enough for the few hundred megabit video feed.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by ianlevesque on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @02:38PM (#27294386)
Yeah the Quest even added USB 2 support.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by qubitcoder on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @04:37PM (#27295769)
Welcome to the world of USB-C! My general approach, and recommendations to others, is to purchase only Thunderbolt 3 cables.

Yes, they're more expensive. But they'll essentially handle everything you throw at them, and behave as expected (due to the large protocol support [0,1]).

Of course, this won't always be the case. But it's generally a safe assumption for now.

[0] https://www.intel.com/content/www/us/en/products/docs/io/thu...

[1] https://thunderbolttechnology.net/sites/default/files/Thunde...

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by selectodude on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @04:51PM (#27295933)
Spending $65 on a 6 foot cable as a "fix" for that doesn't seem like much of a fix at all.

https://www.monoprice.com/product?p_id=24721

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by Reason077 on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @05:44PM (#27296485)
> "My general approach, and recommendations to others, is to purchase only Thunderbolt 3 cables ... they'll essentially handle everything you throw at them"

Is this really true? My Thunderbolt monitor (LG Ultrafine 4K) came with two cables: Thunderbolt 3 (for connecting to Thunderbolt laptops) and USB-C (for connecting to iPads etc which don't support Thunderbolt). Why would two different cables be needed if the Thunderbolt 3 one can do it all?

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by Dylan16807 on Thursday May 27, 2021 @12:18AM (#27299348)
Some active thunderbolt cables don't properly support USB. A good one can do it all, as far as I'm aware.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by Reason077 on Thursday May 27, 2021 @05:29AM (#27300912)
The cables designed for Thunderbolt 3 + 100W charging don't seem to be capable of the fastest USB speeds in my experience. That includes Apple's expensive Thunderbolt cable. They fall back to slower speeds when used as a USB-C cable.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by vmception on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @03:00PM (#27294659)
Try finding any accessory that has USBC

Its been over 5 years already

If your phone is about to die because yiu checked out of a hotel in the morning and your flight is at night and you are just cruising around in a car, you will not be able to stop anywhere and get a USBC car charger.

So anyway LPT: get USBC accessories on Amazon in advance and dont rely on them to have any particular feature of quality control.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by vel0city on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @03:23PM (#27294914)
I've seen USB-C cables for sale at most gas station convenience stores, both C to C and C to A. I've seen lots with car 12V to USB-C as well. They're not rare around me.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by flyinghamster on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @08:09AM (#27289436)
USB-C sure turned into a mess, didn't it? So far, I only have two such devices (a cell phone and a set of headphones), and there's no problem charging either. But even there, we already have proprietary extensions (Qualcomm quick charging, for instance), and then there's Thunderbolt, and now this.

I'm not enthusiastic about wading into the world of "every port looks identical but isn't" that USB-C has given us. I have to keep my cell phone charger cable with the charger at all times, because it's my only cable compatible with Qualcomm quick charging. Naturally, there's no visible indication of this.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by ak217 on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @01:39PM (#27293622)
I don't know, the flipside is that Thunderbolt delivers genuinely cutting-edge interconnect capabilities. I can run two 4K60 displays and a dozen peripheral devices, and charge my laptop, all via a single cable off of my $100 Thunderbolt 3 dock. There is no other technology that comes close to this capability at this price point.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by asdff on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @01:46PM (#27293723)
At the same time, I have no idea if the cable I have is a thunderbolt or usb-c cable. There is no standard marking.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by the_pwner224 on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @02:22PM (#27294182)
Thunderbolt cables generally have a lightning bolt mark, and are expensive and short and thick+inflexible. And because of that, you likely don't have any except for the one coming out of a thunderbolt dock or external GPU enclosure etc.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by asdff on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @02:51PM (#27294539)
My apple cable I believe is thunderbolt but I'm not sure. It's white with no marking.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by djrogers on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @03:09PM (#27294754)
If there's no lightning bolt marking, it's just a charge & USB 2.0 cable, not thunderbolt. Genuine Apple Thunderbolt cables are marked, and the one you got with your MacBook for charging isn't one.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by Yizahi on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @05:33PM (#27296399)
Does it have frayed rubber isolation around connectors and randomly along the cable? If yes, then it is a genuine Apple (tm) cable. If it has solid isolation ad looks good then it's probably a Chinese knockoff. :)
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by mirthflat83 on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @09:27PM (#27298309)
You either have a fake cable or a USB 2.0 charging cable
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by lajamerr on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @01:59PM (#27293894)
You might not know in advance which is a problem but it seems pretty trivial issue. Just test it and see if it works, if it doesn't return it and get a different one. Then repeat the process until you get the one you need.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by asdff on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @02:52PM (#27294560)
Or you could look at the cable from the getgo and read a simple marking and not have to do this song and dance.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by polutropos on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @02:13PM (#27294053)
Your Thunderbolt cables don't have the lightening bolt logo on them? I didn't think it was a 'requirement' but every TB cable I've seen always has the thunderbolt icon.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by asdff on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @02:51PM (#27294546)
Not my apple one.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by djrogers on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @03:10PM (#27294767)
Then it's either not genuine Apple or it's not Thunderbolt. This is what an Apple Thunderbolt cable looks like:

https://www.apple.com/shop/product/MD862LL/A/apple-thunderbo...

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by pix64 on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @06:33PM (#27296966)
That's not a USB-C cable. The discussion is about USB-C cables capable of thunderbolt. Not the older, dedicated thunderbolt cables.

Correct link: https://www.apple.com/shop/product/MQ4H2AM/A/thunderbolt-3-u...

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by djrogers on Saturday June 05, 2021 @07:23PM (#27409261)
Good catch - still has a lightning bolt on it though.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by notSupplied on Friday May 28, 2021 @05:48PM (#27320928)
Which made me realize…a lightning bolt symbol could just as easily be interpreted by laymen as “charging only”!

What a mess…

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by monocularvision on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @09:12PM (#27298196)
So…. with a lightning bolt then.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by SamBam on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @04:00PM (#27295362)
The standard MacBook charger that comes with any Apple laptop is not thunderbolt.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by mgkimsal on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @02:03PM (#27293933)
do those screens need to be 'thunderbolt' as well? or can they just take a usb-c connection (but ... not be thunderbolt?)

I have a 2019 MBP 15". Every 'dock' I've looked at seemed to indicate that "you will see mirrored screens on multiple displays" - which is not what I'd want.

Perhaps all of this is because I'm 'only' using a 2 year old MBP, and this is somehow all Apple's fault?

Would love to know what specific $100 thunderbolt 3 dock you have. It seems to be a confusing mess of half-information whenever I go to shop for stuff.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by danhor on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @03:25PM (#27294951)
> and this is somehow all Apple's fault?

Unfortunately yes. Apple (or MacOS specifically) doesn't support DisplayPort MST, which allows using multiple displays over a single DisplayPort connector. Since non-thunderbolt usb-c video is just DisplayPort, that means many usb-c docks with multiple display outputs don't work. Now why MacOS supports multiple video outputs over Thunderbolt and doesn't support MST is beyond me, but everything else does.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by ak217 on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @02:57PM (#27294622)
No, the displays don't need a Thunderbolt controller (and I do get 3 separate displays - mirroring would be pretty useless, I agree).

I use this dock: https://www.amazon.com/Lenovo-Thinkpad-Thunderbolt-Dock-40AC...

After updating the dock to the latest firmware, I can run two 4k60 displays, although it requires a specific configuration: one display on one of the DisplayPort lanes, and one on an active USB-C to DisplayPort cable hooked up to the dock's unpowered Thunderbolt port.

I've done this setup multiple times with this dock model, and it has worked with every Thunderbolt 3 MBP I've used.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by 7ewis on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @01:27PM (#27293461)
It's not _terrible_, but could definitely be improved.

I'm fairly content with my current situation. My phone has 'WARP' charge, which fully charges it in less than half an hour, however it can also charge (at a slower rate):

* Earphones

* Shaver

* Handheld Fan

* MacBook

I rarely connect my devices to a display, but that is supported with my cable too. The only device I use semi-regularly that isn't USB C is my Bose QC35s, but they last ~20hrs so usually last a few weeks due to my low usage.

On the other hand, my Mac charger can charge my phone (and obviously Mac) but none of the other devices...

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by sonograph on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @09:34AM (#27290282)
After only reading the headlines promising the bright future of USB-C, I am very disappointed now that I carry three USB-C in my backpack for different use-cases.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by yurishimo on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @12:53PM (#27292953)
Can you explain the differences between them? I don't have many USB-C devices (Switch and MacBook) but wouldn't you be able to use the most "fully featured" cable for every scenario?
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by ev1 on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @02:34PM (#27294334)
The most "fully featured" cable with a USB-C tip is often like <0.5m long.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by texasbigdata on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @09:29PM (#27298324)
And $40+. Buying a long one for a music recording interface (that sweet sweet I/O) was super painful.

I guess it's cheaper now but in what world is a $50 cable to power an accessory reasonable in any way.

Source: https://www.sweetwater.com/c1225--Thunderbolt_Cables

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by ev1 on Thursday May 27, 2021 @03:43PM (#27307310)
It's kind of funny when (pre-covid) at the office people would point out my dock TB/USBC connector and how thick it was.

It carries probably 100W+ for power, multiple 4K displays, ethernet, half a dozen USB3 ports... I'd rather it not be the thickness of a 5W charging cable.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by notatoad on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @09:00PM (#27298121)
which perfectly ecapsulates the "problem" with usb-c: everybody wants a cable with all the features, but only wants to pay for the cheapest cable. and then gets frustrated when their $3 cable doesn't support thunderbolt and high-power modes.

you can get 3-metre thunderbolt cables if you want, you just have to pay a lot for them. all the problems with USB-C can be solved by spending more money. if you want to go the cheap route and buy cables that don't support all the various modes, then you're going to end up with a bunch of cables that don't support some modes and have to keep track of which ones those are.

if you regularly use devices that need higher-spec cables, it's probably worth keeping one good high-spec USB-C cable in your bag, instead of three terrible ones.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by danhor on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @03:19PM (#27294858)
Quick Charging 3.0 is more-or-less a hack and shouldn't be done on usb-c (unfortunately, cheap manufacturers still do). Quick Charging 4.0 is just USB-PD, so a different name but compatible.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by rini17 on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @12:34PM (#27292634)
Are there cheap devices that measure USB cables? So that user plugs the cable into it (both ends) and it will list what protocols/bandwidth does it support. And electrical resistance of course.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by _Microft on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @12:47PM (#27292863)
Maybe with an attached labelling machine to print the results in a way that could easily be affixed to the cable? ;) Oh, and please with an integrated wirecutter that automatically destroys cables if their results are too bad?
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by pantalaimon on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @02:54PM (#27294584)
Heh I had a cursed micro-USB cable at the office that only carried power, no data - had fun debugging why my board did not work.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by vel0city on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @03:28PM (#27294973)
Sometimes those are useful. I've got a Canon camera which can charge by MicroUSB, but if it detects any data it doesn't engage the charger and does data only. So having a power only cable is the only way to charge it without taking the battery out and putting that on a charger.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by ectopod on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @03:28PM (#27294979)
My micro-USB charging cable is worse than that. It appears to transfer data but it always flips a few bits. Quite surprisingly, no part of the protocol stack catches this. The cable quietly delivers slightly broken files.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by xsmasher on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @07:48PM (#27297612)
I've seen a lot that are JUST good enough for android debugger to connect, but then drop as soon as data is sent.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by xsmasher on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @07:47PM (#27297605)
It seems that half of the micro-USB cables I get only work for charging, not for data. When I find one that does reliably connect I label it and then hide it where even I can't find it.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by Dylan16807 on Thursday May 27, 2021 @12:31AM (#27299421)
A 5-pack of reasonable quality micro-USB cables is less than $10, FYI.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by rini17 on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @05:06PM (#27296100)
These charge-only cables are supplied as standard with cheap chargers.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by Dagonfly on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @01:40PM (#27293631)
https://www.chargerlab.com/category/power-z/

These read out the e-marker and tell you the supported power delivery and USB data speeds.

The irony that their product comparison table has 30+ rows should not be missed!

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by jerf on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @01:20PM (#27293356)
How much information about the cable is exposed to a computer's interface, even if nothing is plugged in on the other side? Could this just be a computer program, albeit one that may only work with certain controllers?
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by chmod775 on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @12:54PM (#27292967)
I haven't had dealings with these new USB cables yet. Can anyone enlighten me what is happening here?

In older USB cables you used to have four, five, or nine pins that were directly connected via copper wire to the pins on the other end. With the exception of charging-only cables that didn't connect the data pins.

Is the issue just that the new cables tend to only connect a subset of the 24 USB-C pins?

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by georgyo on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @01:02PM (#27293093)
USB-C cables can have all sorts of logic embedded in the cable, including inline resistors to signal capabilities.

However, when it comes to power delivery. For both old style USB and newer USB-C, the thickness of the copper matters for how much amps the wire can carry.

IE apple has a 30W charger that comes with a different thickness than their 61W charger. And using the 30W cable with the 61W charger.

https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT201700#usbc

> For the best charging experience, you should use the USB-C charge cable that comes with your Mac notebook. If you use a higher wattage USB-C cable, your Mac will still charge normally. USB-C cables rated for 29W or 30W will work with any USB-C power adapter, but won't provide enough power when connected to a power adapter that is more than 61W, such as the 96W USB-C Power Adapter.

The best part is that the cables look nearly identical with some very small print on the cable that says they are different.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by crispyambulance on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @01:42PM (#27293669)

  > The best part is that the cables look nearly identical with some very small print on the cable that says they are different.
If you're lucky, that is.

One would think that after nearly 2 decades of USB cable confusion the standards bodies and vendors would make an effort to make the cable identification easy, but no.

I suspect it's because they actually want consumers to end up buying lots cables and the churn it causes.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by consp on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @01:12PM (#27293250)
As a solution by anecdote:

My (by now) ancient laptop simply won't charge (or boot if cold) if the wattage of the psu is insufficient. This will easily solve that problem as you find out when the battery runs out of juice. I noticed this as it originally came with a 45 watt charger but after a processor upgrade the required power would be at least 60 watt.

Note that it will charge the battery when off with any charger, it is just slower.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by numpad0 on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @12:56PM (#27293004)
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by unwind on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @12:48PM (#27292879)
That's a great idea, really!

I guess it is not completely trivial though, and would probably end up costing a fair bit due to the max bandwidth etc.

Just measuring resistance accurately enough for short cables for all conductors sounds hard.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by rini17 on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @05:35PM (#27296418)
In ideal world it would be part of spec of USB host that it can test cable and report to user. That would not be expensive at all.

Resistance is most important for power connection. To determine if voltage drop is acceptable does not need high accuracy.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by wsinks on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @12:42PM (#27292786)
Wow, the tool that I didn't realize I wanted. Let me know if you find one. I don't have an inexpensive one.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by jessikat on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @01:16PM (#27293305)
At least USB-A receptacles were coloured... did we really need to descend into hell for a slightly slimmer reversible plug that wears out even faster than USB-A cables?
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by Causality1 on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @01:27PM (#27293455)
Not to mention they're significantly thicker and wider than the micro-b socket they replaced, so many tiny products will continue shipping with micro-b indefinitely.

Also I've destroyed probably half a dozen of them by accidentally stepping on or rolling my chair over the connector and smushing it flat.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by mixmastamyk on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @03:45PM (#27295162)
The little ones broke too often.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by eldaisfish on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @08:28AM (#27289625)
there's also the very real danger of identical ports bricking devices. See the nintendo switch issue where some users have bricked their devices due to nintendo's implementation of USB C. This limits the chargers you can use and nintendo may well deny a warranty claim if a third-party charger was used.

Not the best source - https://old.reddit.com/r/NintendoSwitch/comments/87vmud/the_...

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by Dylan16807 on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @08:30AM (#27289636)
Not true, the bricking was from was blatantly broken chargers putting 9 volts onto low-voltage signal pins.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by eldaisfish on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @08:37AM (#27289714)
that's one explanation but there is another that is relevant to this thread - Nintendo diverging from the USB C standard implementation. End of the day, standards exist for a reason and nintendo diverged from the standard

https://arstechnica.com/gaming/2019/08/heres-why-nintendo-sw...

If the port fails open—meaning pins just don't make electrical contact—there's usually no real harm done. But if they fail short—meaning pins are bridged electrically to pins they have no business connecting to—you may easily overvolt a pin. Remember that 6V absolute maximum rating on the Configuration Channel of the Switch's USB-C PD chip? Well, it's only 0.5mm away from the VBus (main power line), which carries 15V.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by jl6 on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @08:18AM (#27289526)
Is there a possible outcome where cable components become cheap enough that every USB-C cable is a universal cable that does everything?
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by Dylan16807 on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @08:24AM (#27289589)
Not if you want cables that are longer than two feet. There's a tradeoff between speed and distance.

And that's after you solve the problem of people trying to cut out a couple pennies of copper. And the people that want thinner cables just for charging.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by izacus on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @02:30PM (#27294301)
No, since Thunderbolt needs active cables with amplifiers very quickly, which is driving the cost of TB3 cables well over 50$ for distances that a standard 15$ USB3.1 easily beats.

Physics is a problem here.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by sokoloff on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @08:22AM (#27289561)
As long as there’s a penny to be made by shaving component costs, probably not.

I have USB micro cables that “work” to charge phones or for data but will give voltage throttling errors if used to power an RPi3 or later. This is presumably from using wires internally of too small gauge. I can’t see things like that stopping.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by izacus on Thursday May 27, 2021 @03:23AM (#27300317)
It's not pennies - 0.5m of TB3 cable is 50$. 2m of TB3 cable is 130$. 2m of USB3.1 cable is 15$. Massive difference, don't you think?
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by sokoloff on Thursday May 27, 2021 @09:54AM (#27303151)
By pennies, I meant if someone can sell a substandard (but "mostly works") cable of any variety and have the parts cost $0.10/meter less, the market will ensure that happens.

Was comparing TB2.995 vs TB3, not TB vs USB.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by kalleboo on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @02:03PM (#27293935)
No, because they will keep adding features at the high end as the previous high end features get cheaper and new high end features become possible
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by chippiewill on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @08:21AM (#27289551)
No because vendors will keep putting custom things into their cables to support magic XYZ feature.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by dheera on Thursday May 27, 2021 @02:59AM (#27300198)
> won’t need to be equipped with an ugly barrel jack

Please bring the barrel jacks back. They were virtually unbreakable. I break about a USB-C cable a week because the connectors are super weak and supported only by 2 dots of solder on a PCB instead of a solid cutout on the housing.

USB-C should have at least standardized the shape of the rubberized housing around the connector, made a matching inset shape on the equipment, and have that take the brunt of all mechanical stress, just like an IEC power cable, which you can drop bricks on and they won't break.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by KingOfCoders on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @01:41PM (#27293653)
I know design and all this, but I would prefer red, blue, green plugs and corresponding colors on my laptop to make it easier what I can plugin where - with my desktop I which has around 10 USB ports I always struggle to find the right one.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by mekster on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @09:44PM (#27298419)
Will people ever stop complaining?

If it started making physically different cables or sockets to add new features, people whine how nothing is compatible anymore and if it stopped adding new features to stay compatible, you call the standard dead and not forward thought.

Instead it's gradually upgrading the standard with the same physical socket, so that at least some compatibilities are kept and it's still moving forward.

Can it be better than that?

A bit of confusion on which version you need is better than not being able to plug it in at all.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by jayd16 on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @03:49PM (#27295205)
I'd much rather have this and all the fallback than "well it could work but they put a little nub on the port so it doesn't fit."
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by yoz-y on Thursday May 27, 2021 @05:42AM (#27300973)
Meh, I know it's a bummer and have had problems with this too. However, HDMI, DP, USB-A all have this problem to some extent. (E.g.: my graphics card does not work at-all (as in not even let the computer to boot) if an older HDMI cable is plugged in.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by gspr on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @03:52PM (#27295253)
Ooh! Will some of them unexpectedly fry the host, the client, or both, unless you spend hours perusing through spreadsheets curated by some random hero on the internet too?
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by CyberDildonics on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @04:23PM (#27295612)
Don't forget super speed, super speed+ and super speed+ 2x2
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by asddubs on Thursday May 27, 2021 @02:55AM (#27300188)
if only we could go back in time and warn ourselves about usb type-c. the future seemed so bright
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by Hypx_ on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @08:56PM (#27298104)
We're frankly headed towards a USB type-D standard, where we intentionally create different ports for different uses. A dedicated power connector should never a data connector, and there should be a way to differentiate A/V ports from periphery ports. The mess we are in now doesn't really work as intended.