News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by zlsa on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @05:02PM (#27296061)
It should be impossible for any set of non-damaged, non-defective, spec-compliant set of USB-C cables and peripherals to cause fires. The specifications are very carefully designed to prevent any combination of cables and devices from causing damage.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by Animats on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @06:22PM (#27296848)
It should be impossible for any set of non-damaged, non-defective, spec-compliant set of USB-C cables and peripherals to cause fires.

Then there's the crap offered for sale on Alibaba which somebody will resell on Amazon and which will show up on a checkout rack at the gas station. USB-C has very tight tolerances and unusual material requirements. Dirt or water can create a conductive path all too easily with USB-C pin spacing.

"Decreasing the risk of fire in USB-C connectors" is worth watching.[1] It's an ad for a plastic material, but covers the problems.

[1] https://youtu.be/jYqDh9q5H6I

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by jiofih on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @06:56PM (#27297188)
I’ve never heard of USB-C causing a fire. The control ICs should cut the current the moment anything is out of spec. Do you have any examples of that?
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by mike_d on Thursday May 27, 2021 @03:06AM (#27300237)
https://www.reddit.com/r/Android/comments/7j3k38/anker_usbc_...

https://wccftech.com/macbook-survives-disables-all-usb-ports...

Researchers even developed an exploit for some USB-C fast chargers that forces it to deliver max power and try to catch the connected device on fire: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Es2SqubYSfo

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by baybal2 on Thursday May 27, 2021 @04:04AM (#27300495)
The problem is the gazillion of proprietary fast charging standards.

Some of them were designed for chargers with attached cable, and not disconnectable one.

Many charger ICs emulate the fast charging signalling to trick phones into charging faster, but they of course have no way to check if wiring is ok on micro-usb.

So you can end up with 5A-10A going over flimsy wires/contact pads. Or if they use type-c, they can end up using fake 5A cables. Or in case of VOOC, they don't check if the cable is an actual VOOC cable, which goes over 5A.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by ChuckNorris89 on Thursday May 27, 2021 @06:33AM (#27301253)
>Or in case of VOOC, they don't check if the cable is an actual VOOC cable, which goes over 5A

Actually they do. My OnePlus wich uses the same VOOC tech will not charge at full power with its fast charger if I don't use the cable from the box.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by baybal2 on Thursday May 27, 2021 @07:23AM (#27301655)
Do you use A to C cable, or C to C?

VooC A to C has a fifth pin mapped to CC pin on C side.

Rogue VooC C to C chargers just send VooC signalling directly on CC.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by ChuckNorris89 on Thursday May 27, 2021 @07:42AM (#27301812)
Mine is A to C.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by TheSpiceIsLife on Thursday May 27, 2021 @03:38AM (#27300384)
The comment two above yours is not enough?

Red hot metal and smoking plastic.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by worewood on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @08:14PM (#27297801)
Yeah but there will always be crap for Alibaba for anything you can think of. The solution would be banning charging altogether and adopt only proprietary standards.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by Animats on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @10:30PM (#27298681)
No, the solution for the US would be to refuse imports of any power device that lacks UL/CSA approval.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by spookthesunset on Thursday May 27, 2021 @11:29AM (#27304262)
I don’t even think that is required. I think what might be required is simply making it more explicit when a device is or is not UL listed. I shouldn’t have to search Amazon’s “questions” thing on a product listing to see if it is UL listed.

Of course I suppose products that actually are UL listed on Amazon will already mention the fact somewhere in their description.

That being said I’ve had more issues with low voltage crap letting the magic smoke out than mains powered devices.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by sneak on Thursday May 27, 2021 @02:48AM (#27300153)
What about the 96% of human beings that buy their electronics outside of the USA?
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by afiori on Thursday May 27, 2021 @06:01AM (#27301079)
they have their own corresponding government entities enact the corresponding regulations
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by rhinoceraptor on Thursday May 27, 2021 @02:25AM (#27299995)
The solution is obvious, they just need to be constructed of prefabulated amulite.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by Animats on Thursday May 27, 2021 @01:38PM (#27305809)
That's not entirely a joke. "Halogen-free polyamides are explicitly recommended by the USB-IF in the USB 3.1 specification."[1] Most common plastics do not have a high enough resistance to surface tracking, where, as the connector wears, a conductive path appears across the surface due to dirt and moisture.

[1] https://www.dsm.com/content/dam/dsm/electrical-electronics/e...

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by balefrost on Thursday May 27, 2021 @02:53PM (#27306692)
...as long as you have the necessary hydrocoptic marzlevanes. You don't want side fumbling.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by koube on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @05:10PM (#27296146)
The Nintendo Switch can be bricked if you use the wrong cable, although my understanding is that it's not built to the USB-C spec: https://www.reddit.com/r/NintendoSwitch/comments/87vmud/the_...

Either way, this is an incredibly common device that can be damaged by incompatible hardware where it's difficult to determine compatibility without bricking the device.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by fouric on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @05:24PM (#27296301)
> it's difficult to determine compatibility without bricking the device

This is the problem! This is what everybody talking about the specs doesn't get - it's difficult to (1) tell which spec a device claims to support and (2) verify that it actually supports it (see: a lot of cheap devices on Amazon) and also (3) in real life many devices do not support the specs (i.e. this isn't a theoretical problem).

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by vokep on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @05:44PM (#27296494)
Unless I'm mistaken, there is a license to call a port a USB port, though goods are commonly sold without that. In theory the solution is simple: only buy products that have the actual USB logo and ensure certification, and the USB-IF should retain the right to significantly fine any manufacturer advertising being to spec and using the logo who is in fact not.

In practice, people aren't going to stop buying nintendo switches, unfortunately.

Still, its not entirely necessary to support all specs or have that be entirely clear, what does need to be clear is if you can expect safety specs to be followed. If I plug in my nintendo switch to a charger thinking it'll charge at lightspeed but it takes hours, oh well. If I plug it in and it destroys the device then that should be pretty much an unforgivable problem. Personally I'd be happy to abstain from buying such a device due to that, though also personally I did buy one, expecting no issues, and only found out months later when seeing it mentioned somewhere online. Ideally research is done on every product to ensure things like this aren't the case, but again in practice, that doesn't always happen.

I'm not sure what the fix is, other than outright making USB not so universal by requiring a license for any and all vendors using the design, if the license is cheap enough, maybe that could work? I don't know the legalities so much but maybe a free license could be required for any implementation, which would only have the spec of "make sure it doesn't brick charger or device, and make sure it doesn't catch on fire"

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by dotancohen on Thursday May 27, 2021 @05:55AM (#27301038)
> only buy products that have the actual USB logo

I just took my Samsung A50 out of the case, no USB logo anywhere on the device. There's the Samsung logo, some recycling logo and a CE logo, and that's it.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by TheSpiceIsLife on Thursday May 27, 2021 @03:48AM (#27300432)
One solution could be to require different connectors for different protocols and power delivery.

I'm beginning to suspect The Great Filter is Jony Ive's minimalist design influence: any sufficiently advanced culture will annihilate itself before it discovers interstellar travel when someone connects two devices together that aren't compatible with the equivalent of a One True Connector™ USB cable.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by sgtnoodle on Friday May 28, 2021 @02:39AM (#27312392)
I like to imagine there's an alien species zipping around in FTL space ships, and the only difference from us is they picked one endianness and ran with it.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by chimeracoder on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @05:38PM (#27296440)
> Either way, this is an incredibly common device that can be damaged by incompatible hardware where it's difficult to determine compatibility without bricking the device.

This is 100% Nintendo's fault for using the USB-C connector type but not actually bothering to adhere to the USB-C specification.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by mortenjorck on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @09:35PM (#27298366)
Exactly. If you're going to base your interconnect on an industry standard, you have two options as far as I'm concerned:

A) Follow the spec

B) Make your off-spec interconnect physically incompatible with standard devices

Going off-spec with a compatible and physically indistinguishable connector is an "attractive nuisance," to use the tort term.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by mjevans on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @07:44PM (#27297575)
It would be OK if they didn't claim to be complaint, and FAILED SAFELY when used with complaint devices.

The issue is that they're both not compliant AND fail in a non-safe bad way.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by chimeracoder on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @08:10PM (#27297764)
IMO the issue is that they fail unsafe, whether or not they claim compliance.

Nintendo doesn't claim compliance, but if they're using the connector shape, it should comply with the spec for power delivery (which is honestly not even hard to do).

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by notatoad on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @08:39PM (#27297986)
again though, this is bad but not a flaw in usb-c. a manufacturer created a device that violates the spec.

MicroUSB devices can also be bricked by using non-conforming cables and power adapters, but fortunately devices like that are rare because the spec has existed long enough that all the bad devices have been flushed out of the market. manufacturers having made stupid decisions in the past does not mean we shouldn't make USB-C better now.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by tremon on Thursday May 27, 2021 @05:11AM (#27300818)
It absolutely is a flaw in usb-c that a large manufacturer can create a device that violates the spec and not face serious repercussions.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by evilduck on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @09:10PM (#27298180)
Is this actually a current problem? I haven't heard of this issue occurring at all in recent years beyond "better safe than sorry" warnings against it when people still ask, and even the original claims didn't seem especially widespread.

While it's anecdotal, I've been charging Switches in my household with all sorts of USB-C sources for a couple years now as well (20W Apple chargers, 18W Anker bricks, a MacBook Air, external battery packs, 12v car adapters, etc) and they're all still working.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by II2II on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @07:27PM (#27297437)
> It should be impossible for any set of non-damaged, non-defective, spec-compliant set of USB-C cables and peripherals to cause fires.

That is a fairly significant list of conditions. As an example, I have encountered significant heating in a damaged power cable on the original power supply of a laptop from a reputable vendor. It's easy to argue the owner should immediately replace the damaged power supply, yet many people will continue to use problematic hardware until it no longer functions. It is also the case that many companies will manufacture components down to a price (or, in the case of this vendor, for aesthetics) rather than make something that is robust.

I find it a bit disconcerting that we're talking about delivering 240 W over a cable that consumers are unlikely to differentiate from a 15 W cable (i.e. USB-C specification) or even from a 2.5 W cable (e.g a USB cable they would have used fifteen years ago).

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by Dylan16807 on Thursday May 27, 2021 @12:01AM (#27299248)
> That is a fairly significant list of conditions.

It is, but it's a list of things that could fail even if there was only one kind of cable. The added risk from having a bunch of different kinds of cable with varying capability is quite small.

> I find it a bit disconcerting that we're talking about delivering 240 W over a cable that consumers are unlikely to differentiate from a 15 W cable (i.e. USB-C specification) or even from a 2.5 W cable (e.g a USB cable they would have used fifteen years ago).

All these voltages are low enough that you can expect any cable to support them. What really matters is the amps, and the difference is much smaller there. Specially marked cables support 5 amps. All other USB C cables support 3 amps. Old USB cables will vary, but it's been standard fare to push 2.4 amps over them for a long time.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by iainmerrick on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @09:42PM (#27298397)
I find it a bit disconcerting that we're talking about delivering 240 W over a cable that consumers are unlikely to differentiate from a 15 W cable (i.e. USB-C specification) or even from a 2.5 W cable (e.g a USB cable they would have used fifteen years ago).

Yes, exactly! It’s foolhardy.

And maybe unnecessary -- haven’t Apple just shown that you can get amazing performance with very low power requirements? And shouldn’t we all be trying to minimize power usage, to try to reduce CO2 emissions, mining of rare and toxic elements, plastic waste, etc etc etc?

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by lovemenot on Thursday May 27, 2021 @05:22AM (#27300881)
What you say about efficiency is right, but it's complicated.

There are many domestic devices on 110 / 220v AC using less than 250W. They are native DC, but source AC because they must.

These devices are not likely to go away soon. In fact they'll proliferate so long as the developing world is still developing.

We can also expect proliferation of domestic battery and solar: both DC sources. A standardised domestic micro-grid of DC sources and consuming devices could be a boon to efficiency and reduction of single-purpose conversion devices such as power bricks and inverters.

As an example, every type of e-bicycle currently has a different proprietary adapter. Just as mobile phones once did. Most e-bikes charge at around 40v.

With 250W USB available we will likely see a switch to USB by e-bile manufacturers, resulting in more common lower cost equipment and better interoperability.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by dTal on Thursday May 27, 2021 @09:03AM (#27302559)
It's a sensible vision, but USB-C is absolutely the wrong tech for it (which, from experience, means it's the tech that will get adopted). The connectors are fiddly and expensive and fragile and unreliable and require a bunch of silicon logic to work. You can't mess about with power delivery stuff, it needs to be robust and cheap. A domestic DC power plug standard should have a single voltage standard, three pins (+,-,G), and be able to tolerate being stepped on without causing shorts.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by lovemenot on Thursday May 27, 2021 @10:34AM (#27303644)
I don't doubt you are technically right.

USB-C is presumably not the final word in USB connectors. Let's hope for both vision and better implementation.

What's wrong with having multiple set voltages? If it's the necessity of semiconductors, is that really so terrible in this day and age?

On a separate note, I hope they'd have properly managed EMI in this standard. USB has so many makers of varying quality, I can imagine cheap, badly-shielded cables and connectors playing merry hell with noise.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by hyperdimension on Friday May 28, 2021 @10:46AM (#27315953)
> a laptop from a reputable vendor

Why are comments here always so deliberately vague? I'd like to know which manufacturer. It seems like an important detail.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by NovemberWhiskey on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @05:48PM (#27296525)
Yeah the problem is that there's nothing to stop product designers from specifying the connectors even though the device doesn't logically support the implied standards.

Some people here talked about the Switch; but it's a general problem. For example: I have an external USB drive that has a Type A USB 3 host socket on the back of it (???). It came with a cable with a Type A USB 3 plug on one end and a USB C plug on the other end.

Now that's a combination of connectors you will definitely see elsewhere. I have such a cable that came with my PS5 for charging its controllers - but I know for a fact that it's not interchangeable with the one for my external drive.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by dzhiurgis on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @06:00PM (#27296647)
But what does universal shape of connector has to do with?

Power negotiation applies to USB-A just as it does with USB-C... (I think)

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by chx on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @06:31PM (#27296946)
> Power negotiation applies to USB-A

Nope it doesn't.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by dzhiurgis on Thursday May 27, 2021 @05:58PM (#27309085)
Which is why there's more fires with usb-a
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by chx on Friday May 28, 2021 @07:20AM (#27314043)
nah, there's more fires with USB A because it's more widespread, simple as that. There are plenty C cables from your favorite online dollar store (amazon, aliexpress, jd etc) which are a serious fire hazard.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by Workaccount2 on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @05:22PM (#27296272)
>The specifications are very carefully designed

I need assurance though that my cables were carefully designed.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by notatoad on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @08:41PM (#27298008)
buy your cables from reputable manufacturers...