News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by neither_color on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @02:03PM (#27293939)
And every time I buy a new device and think I'll be able to use my existing USB-C cables I'm met with a new standard. Bought a new external GPU enclosure? My macbook charging cable wont work I need a 40gbps thunderbolt THREE(not 2) cable. Bought a new Oculus Quest? Neither my egpu or macbook cables work I need an $80 LINK cable.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by grlass on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @02:06PM (#27293978)
I wonder if the the committee have looked at integrating colour or some other indicator into the standard so that cable/port capabilities are clear visually.

Though ofc the design challenge is for users to feel comfortable that putting red into blue won't break anything, it just might not give the expected features.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by bogidon on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @04:07PM (#27295427)
From the actual spec[1]:

> All EPR cables shall be Electronically Marked and include EPR-specific information in the eMarker as defined by the USB PD specification. As defined in the USB PD specification, EPR cables are marked as 50 V and 5 A capable. All EPR cables shall be visibly identified with EPR cable identification icons as defined by the USB-IF. This is required so that end users will be able to confirm visually that the cable supports up to as high of PDP = 240W as defined in the USB PD specification."

Both are important. I also wish devices had some UI to easily show the capabilities of a connected cable to the user. I could not find actual visual representations of the the "identification icons".

[1]: (page 143) https://usb.org/document-library/usb-type-cr-cable-and-conne...

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by ctoth on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @04:27PM (#27295659)
Can confirm, sucks if you're blind.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by gord288 on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @06:20PM (#27296833)
Some kind of Braille markings, or similar, really should be a standard part of the spec.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by ohazi on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @02:16PM (#27294080)
Indicator recommendations are routinely ignored. There are already color codes for type-A ports, and there's the "lightning bolt" indicator for Thunderbolt USB-C ports, but PC manufacturers ignore them when they want their laptops to have a certain look and feel (e.g. gaming laptops want red or green everything, Apple wants aluminum everything, etc.).

Cable manufacturers are going to do whatever is cheapest.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by SiVal on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @03:39PM (#27295085)
Since the design philosophy behind USB-C is "it must always seem as though it should work", I think we'll need something like the old "tube testers" a few of us still remember.

Decades ago, when your TV was behaving badly, you would take the back off (unplug first!), pull the vacuum tubes out, and take them in a bag to the nearest convenience store. They had a "tube tester" the size of a washing machine. You'd plug each tube into a connector, one at a time, press the "test" button, and the needle on the dial would show good/poor/fail. The body of the tester was a cabinet containing replacement tubes you could buy (and which you could even test right there).

We might need to start using USB-C cable testers. Plug in a new cable, get a good/poor/fail analysis of each potential USB-C feature, then you mark your cable yourself with some labeling scheme.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by lazide on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @04:01PM (#27295372)
God damnit - TAKE MY MONEY!

I've been having to implement tons of my own testing because no cable ever works the way you think it will. I've got a giant pile of thick super beefy USB-C cables which only transmit data at USB 2.0 speeds. Which per the USB standards committee is apparently Working As Intended, but that is definitely not ok.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by tingletech on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @08:19PM (#27297832)
I remember some drugstores had these when I was growing up. My grandpa had two of them in his garage; where he had bought the machine and the stores' collection of tubes, when they were falling out of fasion.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by watersb on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @09:18PM (#27298246)
Excellent idea.

I remember going through the tube testing ritual with my Mom. Good times. It was really interesting to me, how my Mom could take things apart and figure things out.

(She taught me that the inside of a TV was dangerous, and kept the screwdrivers up where I couldn't reach them.)

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by ktkoffroth on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @08:14PM (#27297792)
I'm down to work on this idea.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by grlass on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @02:24PM (#27294214)
Yeah, it's a bit of tragedy.

Resistor style stripes on cables would be fun, a stripe for each feature such as bandwidth, power, etc; perhaps already suggested (and ignored). Though complement for ports would be trickier.

Embossing symbols in the style of thunderbolt might be the way to go, even if the standard is not fully adopted.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by Dylan16807 on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @04:09PM (#27295444)
> each feature such as bandwidth, power, etc;

Honestly that's about all you need.

Even just a bandwidth indicator would be suitable 90% of the time.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by spicybright on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @02:37PM (#27294378)
Ha, I love the color idea.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by omega3 on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @03:24PM (#27294934)
This is terrible for colorblind people.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by salawat on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @08:03PM (#27297704)
For accessibility, assign specific texture patterns on the outside of the insulation for different capabilities. Then you can tell the capabilities by running the cable through your hands.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by watersb on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @09:27PM (#27298313)
I actually have started down this path for my own cables -- the nylon braided ones are lower power etc.

My first attempt was different colors for each device, but was too tedious.

Three categories - low power, high power slow USB2, and 100W Thunderbolt.

- Low power: generic cables from wherever

- High power slow: cables that came with reputable charger (the vendor's cable, like Apple or Samsung; my favorite 3rd party charger is https://www.ravpower.com/products/rp-pc112-gan-tech-61w-wall...)

- Thuderbolt: I buy from https://eshop.macsales.com/shop/Thunderbolt

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by madsbuch on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @02:45PM (#27294475)
Or! We could go one step further, and change the connector to make sure that people use them correctly. Wouldn't that be clever!?
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by samatman on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @04:00PM (#27295367)
I don't actually want this. I would rather have the problems that come with incompatible cables than the problems which come with incompatible ports.

In particular, if my Thunderbolt ports didn't support bog-standard USB, that would suck. I would need special ports which weren't as powerful, or even more dongles, or both.

As it stands, things are.. fine, actually. I have one TB cable that works on everything, and a small handful of USB-C cables which work on most things. and a USB-C-or-Thunderbolt-and-I-don't-know-or-care to DisplayPort which stays plugged into my monitor. and a USB-C-or-Thunderbolt-etc to microHDMI for my camera.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by 8note on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @04:05PM (#27295406)
I think that doesn't make a lot of sense.

You'd need a cross product of different cable shapes for all the different available features, since the cable could support any number of them.

On top of that, the connector has mechanical constraints to handle, and some of these connector shapes will be suboptimal and undertested

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by Klinky on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @03:55PM (#27295295)
People already incorrectly buy USB A when they should have bought USB C or visa versa. Changing the physical form-factor doesn't solve this problem.

"I thought I needed a USB cable"?

Also it's a huge waste if say an HDMI 2.1 cable cannot be used on an HDMI 2.0/1.4 device. People would complain about that too.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by wearywanderer on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @03:58PM (#27295336)
> People already incorrectly buy USB A when they should have bought USB C or visa versa. Changing the physical form-factor doesn't solve this problem.

At least the nature of the problem is immediately apparent to such people the moment they attempt to plug the cable in. If the cable won't fit, they know there is nothing wrong with their computer; they didn't misconfigure anything or click the wrong button. The problem is unambiguous.

Some USB-C cables not working with some USB-C sockets leaves users feeling gaslit.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by Klinky on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @04:06PM (#27295421)
Except people have damaged ports forcing incorrect form factors. Also we've had tons of other standards where cables vary with performance. HDMI, DisplayPort, IDE, USB1/2/3.

You'll get people complaining about the cable not working with their new device, and then people complaining it didn't work with their old device.

Eventually USB-C will be so capable and ubiquitous, this will be a non-factor. I don't miss the days of trying to track down the right barrel connector, micro-HDMI cable or proprietary and fragile network dongle adapter. Those weren't easier days.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by wearywanderer on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @04:09PM (#27295443)
I would love to see somebody attempt to damage a micro-USB or USB-C port by forcing a USB-A plug into it. Not going to happen, sorry. They may as well try to force a NEMA-5 plug into a VGA port. It's nonsensical.

At a certain point on the usability continuum, user error becomes so severe that only dementia can explain it. But USB-C incompatibilities are so far from that point that arguing otherwise seems like bad faith. These USB-C incompatibilities can bite technically inclined people with sound, sober and healthy minds.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by Klinky on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @04:33PM (#27295729)
What is your suggested solution? Every potential configuration USB-C can offer needs its own physically different cable? We're going to need a dozen different form factors now. How do you do that at scale economically?

How does it help when someone inevitably buys the USB-C cable with shape y when they need USB-C cable with shape x? It physically doesn't fit, great, but they still have the wrong cable and their device still doesn't work, not even in a degraded fashion. They still have to take it back to the store.

Typically these issues bite people who bought cheap junky cables that weren't USB-IF certified off Amazon by sorting for lowest price. If it's not working, check that your cable is certified for what your intended use case is. This applies to everything, not just USB-C.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by wearywanderer on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @05:12PM (#27296174)
They could, at the very least, enforce color coding. Colorblind people would still be left high and dry, but with the status quo everybody is up shit creek.

> How does it help when someone inevitably buys the USB-C cable with shape y when they need USB-C cable with shape x? [...] They still have to take it back to the store.

It helps because they know they have to go back to the store, and aren't left wondering if the problem is actually with themselves somehow using their computer wrong. As I mentioned earlier: "Some USB-C cables not working with some USB-C sockets leaves users feeling gaslit."

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by Klinky on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @05:25PM (#27296318)
USB3 did have blue color coding on the plastic interior of the connector. That doesn't exist on USB-C. You'd have to color-code the metallic connector or the connector housing. Forcing a color-coding scheme on the connector housing would clash with branding, so you'd likely end up with companies ignoring the color coding.

People will also ignore the color coding even if it existed. Counterfeiters would add the color to add legitimacy to their incompatible products. Color coding would not physically prevent you from plugging the cable in.

The people who feel gaslit over a USB-C cable not working would probably also feel gaslit over buying the "wrong USB C cable", because they bought a "USB C cable" and "USB C should just work, why do I have to remember which of 12 different connectors my computer uses, I thought the point of USB C was a unified connector".

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by wearywanderer on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @06:53PM (#27297166)
> The people who feel gaslit over a USB-C cable not working would probably also feel gaslit over buying the "wrong USB C cable",

They might feel deceived or mislead by the packaging, but they won't have to wonder if they are somehow using their computer wrong. Particularly for people who lack confidence with computers, this means a lot.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by Klinky on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @08:11PM (#27297769)
While I can understand the desire to make it easier for non-savvy computer users, I don't think it's worth destroying the technical gains USB-C brings with it. Again, we've had non-savvy users hook stuff up wrong or destroy things even when ports had differentiated shapes. A software solution to identify the incompatibility and notify the user seems more practical than redesigning the connector for every evolution of USB-C.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by 8note on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @04:06PM (#27295420)
If at first the cable doesn't fit, apply more force.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by IgorPartola on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @06:16PM (#27296784)
Better: add a color band to the connector. One line for low power, two for medium, three for high.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by Klinky on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @09:52PM (#27298459)
The problem is you have:

Power: 18W, 30W, 45W, 60W, 100W, 240W

Data: No Data, 480Mbps, 5Gbps, 10Gbps, 20Gbps, 40Gbps

You also have a potential variety of modes that could influence your ability to achieve those speeds with certain devices.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by Dylan16807 on Thursday May 27, 2021 @12:14AM (#27299329)
That sounds like two markings, not too hard.

Also there are no power ratings below 60W, and I don't think "no data" is a valid cable.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by Klinky on Thursday May 27, 2021 @01:43AM (#27299775)
USB-PD supports 5, 9, 15 or 20v at between 0 - 5 amps. Higher power typically needs a thicker gauge wire.

There are definitely "charge-only" cables being marketed.

Two markings with each having multiple variations. You will have a dozen plus combinations, that will only get more complex.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by Dylan16807 on Thursday May 27, 2021 @04:01PM (#27307546)
> USB-PD supports 5, 9, 15 or 20v at between 0 - 5 amps. Higher power typically needs a thicker gauge wire.

Every voltage below 20 maxes out at 3 amps. As far as cables go, 60 is the minimum watts supported.

> There are definitely "charge-only" cables being marketed.

Are they valid though?

> Two markings with each having multiple variations. You will have a dozen plus combinations, that will only get more complex.

I don't really care how many combos there are. I won't need most of them. Most of the time I just want speed or power, sometimes I want both, and it's always a minimum requirement rather than anything specific.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by Klinky on Thursday May 27, 2021 @07:05PM (#27309711)
>Every voltage below 20 maxes out at 3 amps. As far as cables go, 60 is the minimum watts supported.

Perhaps for PD 2.0/3.0 but there is also legacy USB PD 1.0 and USB-C BC. During that era I believe 1.5A was minimum.

>Are they valid though?

Probably not, looks like USB 2.0 data is minimum required.

>I don't really care how many combos there are. I won't need most of them.

Just because you don't need specific combinations, doesn't mean you won't have to wade through all possible combinations to find the cable you're looking for.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by endgame on Thursday May 27, 2021 @02:46AM (#27300134)
By the time the relevant committees have worked over that idea, there will be fifteen bands in colours that you need tetrachromic vision to differentiate between.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by IgorPartola on Thursday May 27, 2021 @09:34AM (#27302885)
Can’t do color as people are color blind. Need to do it by number of bands.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by jquery on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @03:10PM (#27294771)
Didn’t Europe ban this?
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by mamurphy on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @03:36PM (#27295058)
jquery was downvoted but I recall articles like this (https://www.theverge.com/2020/1/17/21070848/eu-apple-europea...) with the EU trying to ban any "non-standard" connector.

Maybe non-standard connectors are actually a feature, not a bug, because everything having the same connector but not the same functionality will lead to confusion as described above.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by 8note on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @04:22PM (#27295603)
I don't think it was ever true that the connectors on the two devices determine whether they're compatible.

You can find all sorts of different connectors on a cable to connect two devices together, but you still only knew that devices are/are not compatible by trying to plug them in

At least with the current setup, you are unlikely to burn out the devices by trying a cable.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by dr_orpheus on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @02:12PM (#27294041)
This does seem like it would be helpful. They started coloring the USB-A ports blue for those that were compatible with USB 3 high speed data. I think the challenge may be to get people to understand it more than being afraid to plug blue in to black. I know quite a few people just assumed the color choice was a design choice and if the cable fits, plug it in.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by Rebelgecko on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @02:28PM (#27294277)
My Oculus Quest works fine with a 3meter AmazonBasics USB cable that I got for like $15. I think the only advantage of the official link cable is that it gets you 5m without needing to add an extender to a 3m cable
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by neither_color on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @04:55PM (#27295974)
It works but it if you run a high bandwidth game like Flight Simulator you might hit some performance limits, you can check your cable speed in the quest desktop app.
Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by snailmailman on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @07:17PM (#27297333)
I’m not the same user but I haven’t had any problems with my cheap usb cable. Only that the cheaper cable I got is shorter.

I haven’t done the speed test in a while but last I checked I think it was 3Gbps? Not quite the theoretical max for the port/cable but easily enough for the few hundred megabit video feed.

Re:USB-C is about to go from 100W to 240W, enough to power b... by ianlevesque on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @02:38PM (#27294386)
Yeah the Quest even added USB 2 support.