You got 50 years, but many people haven't. There are so many people out there in the prime of their careers right now, I genuinely worry about them and what this does for their livelihood.
If I could pick an age for this all to happen, it would be when I was 16, just starting to get into computers. I think I would enjoy the hell out of the new world, getting in on the ground floor at the very start of my journey. But my 2nd pick would be my current age, at the tail end of my career. I get to see this crazy transformation, but I've already reaped most of the rewards of everything I learned that is potentially becoming quickly obsolete.
I really don't envy those mid-career, who have put tons of work into their craft but have yet to reap the majority of the rewards (which tend to be stacked later in career rather than evenly spread out.)
You've worked hard and build a knowledge-base that was extremely lucrative; That's becoming less and less true. The "democratization" of software is a great thing for people who wanted to get into it, but found it too difficult. It's a horrible thing for those who made a living on it being difficult.
And I'm not even advocating that we should halt progress. This is how humanity has always evolved technology. Jobs exist where technology can't replace them, until it does. Software had a good run, I just wish it'd been longer.
Nearly everything will (eventually) be impacted.
Therapists? People are using LLMs for “free” help.
Physical trainers? Just upload a video of your workout for tuning advice and other exercises you can focus on.
Appliance/vehicle repair? Just DIY it with an LLM.
Teachers? Just teach yourself with and LLM.
I could go on.
To be clear, I’m not saying LLMs are better at this. But just saying LLMs are impacting nearly every field.
More workers competing means lower pay. Less good paying jobs means less customers. Less customers means less jobs. This is an over simplification, but is one possible future.
I'd be happier if my prediction turns out wrong.
But never mind that. Get money or die. Every rat for herself.
Nothing makes sense or is computable when human labor/knowledge has little to no value. It's a bit like an economic event horizon
Actually makes everything a lot simpler, economically.
Economics is the study of how to equitably distribute scarce resources. When everyone's contributions are equally meaningless (because hey, we made this do-everything bot that will do your job, no matter how much you were worth in the before-time) then the whole convoluted, often inequitable distribution scheme is paved over with the brutal 'your share = [resources] / [number of people]' equation.
Ownership is a social construct, backed by the rule of law. If we rapidly take away the ability for the masses to be able to afford to own things, there isn't any magic preventing them from deciding to not honor that particular construct anymore.
The bigger question is, if that does come to pass, will the AI overlords still have enough power to enforce their ownership claims the old fashioned way -- with violence?
I'm afraid this is going to get very ugly.
200 years ago, in the US, 85% of the labor force was employed in the farming industry. 100 years ago, it was 40%, and now it is 1.5%, almost a rounding error.
We are far better fed, spend almost none of our time as a society farming compared to what used to be almost all of our time. There are few people left who have any serious knowledge of how to grow food.
Yes, the period of transition will be faster. And the transition will happen to a different class of workers. And, yes, our current food,in many ways, is mostly crap.
The future will be quite different
The real danger for teachers is society deciding people don’t need to be educated. Although that would be a problem for all of us actually.
Sure, in THEORY we can do all these things, but I suspect this fear is somewhat borne out of the same error that mashes us estimate a task will take 6 hours and then it takes a week.
We systematically underestimate the human effort needed. How many non-technical, non-interested people are going to be looking up DIY for fixing their car, buying the needed equipment, developing the skill, etc, really?
While they’re doing that, they’ll somehow also have time to produce their own movies, write their own indie games, etc, etc.
Fast food is available; people still go to restaurants. I can sketch on a piece of paper, but I still buy art. It’s technically not difficult to build a chair, but I still buy furniture, etc.
It’s going to have a massive impact for sure, but we have to temper our expectations and ground them in real, practical limits.
Definitely some interesting years ahead. Fingers crossed.
Done right, that accreditation could be objectively superior to brand names like Harvard, etc.
And the results are poor because the LLM does not have a face and is not reading your facial expressions or hearing the tone of your voice. We communicate with more than just the words we speak.
> Physical trainers? Just upload a video of your workout
...lol
> Appliance/vehicle repair? Just DIY it with an LLM.
"Officer you can't arrest me and impound my car, I did what the LLM told me to do. It's not my fault that a wheel fell off and my exhaust is an eerie green color!"
> Teachers? Just teach yourself with an LLM.
See above about therapy, there is more to teaching than spitting out words.
> I could go on.
You could, but at what point will you get to the few lines of work that are genuinely going to disappear because of this technology? Taxi drivers are the most obvious, and least discussed, example -- self driving cars will eliminate that entire profession over the next few decades.
I don't disagree. But I think people will still use it. We've seen how people Googled stuff to get help in this area, and it's 100x easier with LLMs.
>> Physical trainers?
> ... lol
I disagree here. I think LLMs are decent at getting someone dumb to working out, like me, from zero to establishing a decent workout plan, and making adjustments as you go, if you give it enough context on your health, and how things are working for you.
Again, I'm not saying LLMs are better at it, but I think it's arguable that people will figure out that they can use an LLM to get started pretty easily, where they used to go to physical trainers.
> "Officer you can't arrest me and impound my car, I did what the LLM told me to do. It's not my fault that a wheel fell off and my exhaust is an eerie green color!"
I was already doing a lot of my own home/vehicle work via YouTube. Now I almost never taking my vehicle into the shop (for what I think are relatively small repairs that aren't safety hazards, like fan repairs, electronics, etc.).
Additionally, I now upload repair estimates to an LLM, and have it push back on things that I can either do myself, or do somewhere else and save a lot. And this has, indeed, kept me from spending as much for vehicle repairs (cutting into their margins).
Similarly, I've uploaded pics/videos of appliances bugging out on me, and have been able to fix many things myself. I used to already do this to an extent with YouTube, but would still have to figure a lot of things out myself. Being able to upload pics/videos changes things quite a bit.
>> Teachers?
> See above about therapy, there is more to teaching than spitting out words.
Again, agree mostly on this one. But the value of higher education has already been in question for a while, and I think LLMs are only pushing this further.
I don't think teachers/professors will get replaced (anytime soon), but I have kids and know parents of kids that are using LLMs to help them in ways that they used to rely on teachers for.
> You could, but at what point will you get to the few lines of work that are genuinely going to disappear because of this technology?
I'm not necessarily talking about full replacement. Agree that this is very possible/likely with taxi drivers. And I do think some fields will also get replaced, some that we may not even consider now (would we have thought 15 years ago that taxi drivers would get replaced in our lifetime?).
But my point is that LLMs are going to, at the very least, have an impact on many non-digital fields.
The results are more 5* reviews than 1*: https://apps.apple.com/us/app/feeling-great/id6450066153
I think this is a very good template for what sort of skills will survive the LLM-apocalypse and what won't. LLMs are the great homogenizer. Any type of knowledge work where there is a broadly-accepted set of best practices for how to do it is gonna get outsourced to an AI.
But AI is terrible at doing anything unique, personalized, and based on your own desires, because it doesn't have your desires. It's building on a corpus of shared knowledge, but there is a large set of knowledge that is unshared, and it can't do anything for that. A large portion of business, for example, is secrets and lies, and an LLM isn't going to be able to help you much with that. At its best it can set up the frameworks and tools to help you keep secrets and tell lies.
And then a large portion of life is personal preferences, the things that make you unique and distinct from every other human, and an LLM can't help you with that either. There is a reason I don't have a nanny raise my kids, even though we could afford it. If I did that, it would be the nanny raising my kids, which defeats a lot of the point of having kids in the first place. LLMs have the same problem.
I keep trying to nudge them to be relevant with specific examples of a few shows I had watched that were very popular at the time but now considered "old/boring/not remastered" so don't make it into the Best X Shows of XXs lists that emphasize modern tastes. But the recommendations were either the same things I already knew about, or were just wrong/irrelevant for various reasons.
Recently I stumbled onto a Reddit post from years ago with a similar request to mine, and both the question itself and top answers were a goldmine of suggestions that were never recommended and I hadn't heard of. I knew within seconds of looking at the IMDB that they would be exactly what I wanted, so it's not like the AI recs are failing just because of idiosyncratic taste. They just don't seem to search from a deep enough info source, have been RLed into conformity, or some other disconnect between intent and execution.
Or — more disturbingly — what if LLMs lock us into our current state of development forever? This is all we will ever be; nothing will fundamentally change from here on out.
Cars are too expensive to not repair, but the complexity of car repair is way too high. Even with an incredibly specific and accurate video, even one made lovingly by a knowledgeable mechanic, most repairs are beyond most people’s physical skills.
I do mostly agree with your thesis, still. Being closer to education than many other fields, though, I remain unconvinced that AI will handle children well.
College, on the other hand? For many reasons, colleges should be an existential crisis right now. Nothing about college makes sense from cost to how AI-cheating changes things, to job prospects for most majors.
Good luck replacing elementary / high school teachers with LLM's. Their job is about so much more than just teaching.
My wife has a deep expertise in modern therapy* and I saw her use ChatGPT. The difference is between "I want to fetch better products" vs "modify this index to use embeddings with model XXX"
*people's mental model of therapy comes from the movies, books or TV shows. Modern therapy doesn't look like an episode of Sopranos
Is this the limited of UI/UX(like no visual input to the model), or it's flawed in the core ?
The first one can be fixed.
What is the common thread?
These roles depend on some combination of physical skill, human connection, trust, judgment and accountability, and such jobs are out of reach of AI.
Arguably, software has times that require physical presence, human connection, trust, judgment, and accountability.
Depends on what the software does and it is application.
If its a tiny video game, journaling app or camera app that requires little human interaction: Then it isn't important.
If it is infrastructure-level, critical and time-sensitive and deals with highly regulatory industries such as finance, crypto, healthcare, legal, manufacturing and has a chance of risk to the human then that software will continue to be used and pay will remain high.
Then they will be able to do more and more, and 1 nurse will be able to do the job of 4-5 2020 nurses.
Until that nurse is a dude from Mexico [where im from/based] giving instructions to all the robots.
There are some professions where human touch is in demand (this is not about capability, but about user experience in sense of human interface)
The same way I [as an Xenial] prefer to use the self-checkout in the supermarket to avoid contact with the cashier lady or the person that bags items [here in Mex].
I imagine when I'm older I will prefer the robot to help me go to take a dump and clean me, instead of a nurse...
Of course the elderly and frail and people too afraid to touch something lest they break it will still call an expert, and original build and installations will need those trained, but I could see vast swaths of less technically skilled people opting for a go at routine repairs which could really hollow out the demand.
And where do they get the money to pay for this when all of the knowledge work is gone?
None of these end up really being out of reach of AI if Anthropic can justify this valuation. They're just slower to roll out.
If predictions about robotics are accurate, things will get even more difficult in the next ten years as humanoid robots mature.
Depends on timeframe. The economy depends on white collar workers spending money to pay for salaries of blue collar workers. The largestt tax-base is the middle class (white collar workers and blue collar workers).
Having 30% of white collar workers out of a job in a week is going to have the impact of riots in the streets, looting and a destabilisation (if not outright coupe attempts) of Governments. Might even be a partial collapse of some civilisations.
Having 30% of white collar workers lose their jobs over the next 10 years is manageable. We'll all be miserable, but the structure of civilisations and governments will remain intact.
LLMs are hugely suited to code because it's token heavy and the compiler is the RLHF verifier.
The LLMs are still very bad at concepts.
What we see in code does not translate to other, arbitrary domains.
Legal - yes, due to text heavy content with tons of great examples as well.
Everything else ... not really. At least not LLMs as we understand them today.
I'm not the only one that had that idea, they're advertising these things as features now.
I don't know what's next, but keep in mind that today's LLM's are the worst they'll ever be.
That's like saying in 2011: "today's Google search is the worst it will ever be."
Enshitification is coming my friend. We're just now starting to see the kinds of refusals that LLMs will ultimately end up with to protect IP owners and the status quo. We'll look back at this time and marvel that LLMs used to be able to reverse engineer software, or able to create derivative IP works.
I wonder if we are seeing them maxing out llm model capabilities now...
6.1 made a lot of assumptions and would "just do it." For many professionals that was a bad thing. For mnay users it was a good thing.
6.2 on the other hand does what it's told, and uses less flowery language.
I think they're focusing more on the enterprise.
But I wasn't talking about subjective experience I was talking about benchmarks like artificial analysis for coding agents, where it gets slightly lower score than 6.1 (frontier code 2.0 it gets a 2 point drop).
It was 100% different though, and it was a bit jarring. It was kind of like having one of your coworkers replaced with a similar, but different, pod-person. I'm getting used to that feeling though.
The one thing I think we can all agree is certain is that it will be different in a few months.
I kind of wish they had LTS versions of some models, so you could build processes and tooling around them with certainty that they'd be exactly the same in 5 years.
They are going to be 'better than what they are today' but I don't see obvious unlocks.
We need more abstractions on top of them.
Two examples of the lengths people went to for performance - 1) the networking hardware, terminals and everything were special airline flavors that sent data in 6 bits rather than 8, just to squeeze more data onto the wire. Is you look over someone's shoulder at an airline booking screen even now you'll see an all caps look - that's why. All caps means less bits.
The second was a little before my time but the geniuses who maintained the assembler code were very close to the hardware. Some used programming tricks to account for the rotational speed of the DASD, so the software would be ready to pull bits off the hard drive just as those bits rotated around and arrived at the read heads. Insane optimisations.
I'm out of the area now so I didn't know what the state of the art is, presumably there's not any IBM assembler still lurking but it certainly wouldn't surprise me.
The changes taking place now are not unexpected, and not unwelcome, but long overdue.
For anyone who nabbed the outsized returns while they existed, be thankful you got them at all, and hopefully you saved some of it. Due to geographic barriers to movement, 96% of humanity never had the opportunity to work in tech and profit off the supply/demand gap. LLMs arbitraged that gap, and now we can diffuse these capabilities throughout the entire world at extremely low cost.
AI is a giant compression and de-duplication algorithm on white collar labor, and it was needed. We've had an over-production of white collar elites problem for a while now resulting in policy errors in most developed economies who completely ignored building in the real world.
Don't worry, humanity still has more than a few problems to solve. There's infinite jobs to be done. The nature of humanity is that our expectations always grow to exceed our current capabilities. And with AI, you don't need to sit in a classroom for 6 years to get up to speed on the next job to be done.
If the US government allows it, of course. It just banned my country from buying data center nvidia chips.
>Don't worry, humanity still has more than a few problems to solve. There's infinite jobs to be done. The nature of humanity is that our expectations always grow to exceed our current capabilities. And with AI, you don't need to sit in a classroom for 6 years to get up to speed on the next job to be done.
You sound like someone who's overly cocksure that you've figured it all out. By It I mean, how to organize society. What Policy Errors would not have been made, in your scenario?
- The entire west relocating all key assets like factories, mines and production to the developing world/China
- Neglecting to build homes in basically all western countries for the past 18 years
- Virtue signaling going green by pushing energy production offshore to less regulated countries and then importing it back at even higher net carbon costs (more a Europe problem)
- Getting overly hysterical during Covid due to work from home being viable for the white collar class, requiring massive stimulus that mostly just caused inflation and inflated asset values
- Decades of under investment in hard infrastructure and instead investment in legal red tape and white collar bureaucracy
- An entire generation over-educated in digital building vs. physical building, such that much of the know how isn't even here anymore
- Post-financial crisis, inflating global asset values via artificially low/negative/0% interest rates to protect laptop class home values and 401ks over the real economy
- Over fetishization of credentialism/higher education -> government guarantees of college loans to any borrower regardless of ability to repay -> runaway inflation in the cost of US higher education
Want more?
A million Americans died.
Other than that, yeah, spot-on rant.
As you get older, I recommend traveling more internationally, you begin to get a more accurate picture of your relative stature.
While you and the rest of HN are busy exciting yourselves with the online bolshevik revival, it would be wise to first examine where you sit objectively relative to the rest of humanity (based on the analytics, if you're on this site you're in the top 2% to 0.001%).
If we're going to normalize seizing the property of individuals to pay for your fully automated luxury socialist dreams, unfortunately we won't be able keep the line drawn at just billionaires, or at just millionaires. The math doesn't math without taking your stuff too.
Under what historical precedent did we draw the line of “elites” at only the 3 richest dudes?
Sorry, we’re going to have to take your stuff too. There’s not enough Elon Musks to pay for what you want.
I'm already taxed. I just want them to be taxed as much as I am, not way less :)
I don't hate taxes, society or mankind (unlike some people on this site).
But I get it, you dislike the fact taking risk to build companies means you make capital gains vs. income (what you mostly get taking zero financial risk and working an adult daycare corporate job). And you don't want to try to create/market/sell something new that society finds valuable, you just want other people to take those risks and pay for you to live comfortably.
The problem: the 400 richest Americans pay about $40B in tax per year collectively (federal only, not including state). So how much should they pay instead? Double? Triple? 10X?
Even if they paid 10X as much it wouldn't solve the yearly deficit on the current government programs we have (we run a $2T yearly deficit).
Sorry, we're going to have to take some of your stuff too.
Just say you're a misanthropist, it's OK.
But of course, what does an old crusty fart like me know and what could I have possibly learned over 50+ years of coding that could be at all relevant today? IKR?
You hate this? That's on you. But doing the same thing over and over and expecting a different result is insanity. However, if you saved up before you were outed as an imposter, I can see that working out in the long run. IDIC and all that.
But the concern is overall jobs disappearing not “people Now have to be competent”
I live in a society and if there is suddenly only 2 jobs for every 10 it’s going to be a problem.
I also have empathy so I feel for people who will not be able to feed or house themselves because ai decreased then number of jobs.
you’ve still not answered what happens when or a solution to there being 1/5 the jobs available. Those people don’t vanish
Only time will tell, but I reject your pessimism on this. And I say that as a major cynic and pessimist on human nature. Shun! Shun! Shun the unbeliever in p(doom)!
This is just a tautological advice. It is equivalent to saying "be successful, then you will be successful".
Also, have you seen the batch of CS majors coming from non-top-tier universities? I don't see how they will be able to compete with LLMs.
So whenever someone says "We are laying off SWE's because AI", I have no idea what they're talking about. Just the idea of taking on the mental load of getting rid of engineers to direct more agents shipping complex features makes my hands sweaty. I am so glad I am still able to hand off the technical direction, architectural care, follow-up, unblocking decisions etc. to a real accountable human.
So yea, the sunset on this career seems far too pre-emptive.
So a company that can't/won't grow, lays people off and blames AI? Checks out I guess.
For them, keeping their level of ambition and dropping staff in favor of AI makes perfect sense.
A huge supermajority of users of those products couldn't care less if there are never any features added. They want a product that just works, that's understandable.
To use the Netflix example: why does a company that ships DVDs need to add streaming to their website?
Your comment seems to say that the higher cost of devs is worthwhile because it will allow a company to keep a lead, but how many products out there are just things like kanban boards, todo lists, and crud applications? Is any product ever completed and how much value really exists above the line at which most people are satisfied.
LOL, so true. I feel like as people at my (medium size, ~5000 employee) company start to really understand how much more software we can build, they're going to ask for things they've only dreamed about in the past. Just glorified CRUD, but that's what drives businesses these days.
Personally having been remote for ~8 years it would be difficult to go back to in person or hybrid, this said I am not sure how I could prove I am trustworthy besides "trust me bro" unless I am using somebody in my network as a reference...
If you hired a security guard to watch your house, would you be okay with that person watching a neighbor's house for a few hours each night because they had free time from watching your house?
People use things like responsiveness, turnaround times on requests, comparing timesheets to actual work delivered, and shared resources like updates to a common document to form an opinion about your availability.
I'm sure sales teams have the same issue. How do I know a sales rep on the road is actually making sales calls and not simply at a bar, day drinking? They have solved it by tying incentives to actual results and use CRMs to capture updates from sales reps to figure out if those reps are doing actual work or not.
Maybe remote software work needs to go the same way - tie pay to actual meetings attended and contributed to, tickets closed, issues raised which proved prescient in hindsight, and so on.
LLMs can help this sort of usefulness tracking. E.g., Give an LLM a meeting transcript and ask it to work out how much saimiam contributed to the meeting.
What's your product? You kind of need to provide that context - if your team is building some CRUD or calculator app that's a little different to a global engineering team working on products at massive scale.
> don't see a bright future for this profession
Then I'd apply the same logic to every STEM field. I'd rather have a CS degree and understand the tools that are supposed to be building the future.
I don't see a future where everything is AI yet people stop being educated in how AI and software works?
I did Mechanical Engineering years ago and we've had programs to do FEA and CFD analysis for a while now - yet we still have to learn how to do those by hand.
Put it this way - I don't think people who understand AI and software are going to be worse off in the future than those who don't.
I don't think it's relevant here. The point is that there were several work streams that kept several engineers busy full time that now are done by AI almost with little supervision. We do the same amount of work with less people and the software we ship is better on all relevant metrics. If the demand for software stays the same, we'll need less people for the same output.
> I'd rather have a CS degree and understand the tools that are supposed to be building the future.
Sure, we'll always need some experts. But it'll be a riskier career compared to what it was.
I think what you call supervision, I call care. Yes a company could always not care and ship stuff but you’re just kind of trundling towards failure.
I believe in modern parlance some people call it “slop” but that’s a bit of a flattening of what happens. Again, maybe you have a simpler product and doesn’t need a level of care across all dimensions.
It’s just not true for us, AI has made us more ambitious but also has rapidly upsized how much each member has to care.
It so is.
This could be another variation of "I don't need software engineers anymore for my business!" (it's a vibe-coded e-commerce site).
Went from a groups of team of 40 -> 20 and experienced the exact same thing. This was long before AI and agentic workflows though.
It was more a symptom of how much busy work / non-work was required to get anything done.
And if those “You are accountable for every line of code” directive holds here, they’re accountable for way more than they can comprehend. A huge win for the leafs in the org chart.
Leave each person you interact pleased that they interacted with you, better off in some way.
Now it seems like it's the sunset of this way of making a living. I think people who manage to move up the food chain a bit will succeed but its hard to advise any junior in the industry exactly what that looks like.