News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by bsimpson on Monday April 13, 2026 @11:18AM (#47753269)
Do this one next:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gonzales_v._Raich

The Supreme Court somehow held that the feds can regulate what you do in your own home (in this case, growing marijuana for personal use) because it could have a butterfly effect on the interstate price. (Constitutionally, the feds can only regulate _interstate_ commerce.)

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by tdb7893 on Monday April 13, 2026 @11:53AM (#47753890)
I think much more likely is that it will just be made legal federally sometime in the next decade. Marijuana legalization has majorities across ideologies (https://news.gallup.com/poll/514007/grassroots-support-legal...) and even though the inability to create federal law on something so popular seems like a good case study on how the US system doesn't always do a good job representing it's actual people, it seems to be at a critical mass where it can't be ignored for much longer. Even my parents' friends who are conservative have started doing weed.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by cogman10 on Monday April 13, 2026 @12:14PM (#47754245)
I think the issue is this isn't seen by politicians as a motivating vote driver. It is, however, a motivation for someone to go out and vote against a politician.

That's ultimately what keeps things like MJ illegal. There are just far too many people that will get upset about it if it were made federally legal.

My state, Idaho, has one such politician that is constantly bringing up and trying to find ways to keep the wacky tabacy out of the state. Including trying to amend the state constitution for it. He does this because he's mormon and the mormons are scared of the devil's lettuce.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by sir0010010 on Monday April 13, 2026 @12:52PM (#47754814)
I personally would be okay with having it legal if smoking could still be banned in multifamily complexes. I don't care if my neighbors are using edibles, but since I know that legalized weed means more smoke coming from my neighbors' balconies, I will always vote "No" when marijuana legalization is on the ballot in my location.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by pattilupone on Monday April 13, 2026 @01:02PM (#47754956)
Can smoking tobacco be banned in multifamily complexes currently? I'd think the policy would be the same.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by ryoshoe on Monday April 13, 2026 @01:10PM (#47755055)
HOAs tend to manage this kind of thing
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by hedgedoops2 on Monday April 13, 2026 @01:56PM (#47755643)
Lol, yes, subsidiarity.

HOAs, the lowest level of US government.

[dead]
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by refulgentis on Monday April 13, 2026 @02:30PM (#47756098)
You've made about a dozen comments in this thread and they've escalated from "HOAs are unconstitutional" to "I'd rather shoot my fellow citizens than be drafted if weed isn't legal" to "driving high is fine, I've done it for decades." Each one a little more unhinged than the last, which is an accomplishment given where it started.

It reads less like a coherent political philosophy and more like someone who's been hitting the sacrament a little too hard this morning.

I smoke your "sacrament" daily, and cigarettes, and I'm terrified that people will think you're representative of either of those classes, or even a minority of them.

Most people in this thread broadly agree with you that marijuana should be legal. You're somehow picking fights with your own allies because they had the audacity to say they don't like the smell, or that driving impaired is bad. You're not defending freedom, you're being contrarian and hostile to anyone who doesn't arrive at your exact position with your exact intensity.

And the driving thing isn't a matter of opinion. "I've done it for decades and never caused an accident" is the exact argument every drunk driver makes right up until they do. Your anecdotal survival is not evidence of safety.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by dfdsjsdklfjs on Monday April 13, 2026 @05:57PM (#47758382)
> You've made about a dozen comments in this thread and they've escalated from "HOAs are unconstitutional"

A factual statement.

> to "I'd rather shoot my fellow citizens than be drafted if weed isn't legal"

1) When you have illegalized my lifestyle and want to have me and my friends thrown in prison, you don't get to call yourself "fellow citizen" anymore. I keep no company with tyrants.

2) When you censor my legitimate post through flagging, you don't get to call yourself "fellow citizen" anymore. I keep no company with censors.

3) You never had any right to send me off to any of your bullshit imperial wars in the first place.

> to "driving high is fine, I've done it for decades."

Another factual statement. Two, actually.

> Each one a little more unhinged than the last, which is an accomplishment given where it started.

Why do you hate facts?

> It reads less like a coherent political philosophy and more like someone who's been hitting the sacrament a little too hard this morning.

Apologies for not delivering a complete and well articulated political philosophy in the first 5 posts of my brand new throwaway account. Had I done so, presumably it would have caused you, after 30 seconds of deep reflection, to immediately abandon decades of government propaganda and bow in submission before my obviously superior logic. Clearly the fault is mine.

Fortunately I have made a number of additional posts which you may now reference in your diligent efforts to explore and understand my viewpoint.

Many have downvoted and even flagged a few posts, as you did, but on the balance a larger number have agreed with my "unhinged" postings thus far. It seems there are lots of us wingnuts out here I guess.

> I smoke your "sacrament" daily

Sacrament--not "sacrament"--as in it's a sacred herb that has comforted and helped mankind in countless ways, medicinal and non medicinal, since it was first cultivated tens of thousands of years ago. It may be humanity's oldest cultivated plant. You don't have to worship it, but you should show some respect.

> I'm terrified that people will think you're representative of either of those classes, or even a minority of them.

It seems you live a life of fear. I don't recommend that.

> Most people in this thread broadly agree with you that marijuana should be legal.

Judging by the upvotes, yes, people do seem to broadly agree with me, though it's certainly not unanimous. Doesn't matter who agrees with me, however. I'm going to do what I want to do anyway and nobody is going to stop me.

> You're somehow picking fights with your own allies

People who want to put me in a cage aren't allies. Sorry.

> And the driving thing isn't a matter of opinion.

Not a matter of your opinion, anyhow.

Your ignorant opinion, the product of a lifetime of government brainwashing, is irrelevant to me and the millions of other weed smokers who are smoking and driving daily with no trouble, completely unbeknowst to you.

> Your anecdotal survival is not evidence of safety.

1) The plural of anecdote is "data." Learn this fact.

2) My personal experience is in fact quite relevant to my own choices, because as a person of astoundingly high intellect living in a corrupt, broken, and collapsing society of lying sociopaths, I've learned to trust my own experience above all others. Especially yours.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by jhbadger on Tuesday April 14, 2026 @01:24PM (#47768499)
Every apartment that I've lived in in the US has as part of the lease that you can't smoke (tobacco or anything else) in it. Same for hotel rooms.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by dfdsjsdklfjs on Monday April 13, 2026 @02:03PM (#47755741)
So you're OK if it's legal, as long as it's not legal.

You're OK with people being thrown in prison, because you don't like the smell.

And you wonder why people call you a selfish nation full of selfish people.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by bonesss on Monday April 13, 2026 @02:56PM (#47756396)
VOCs and carcinogens are a health hazard. Asthma, kids development, allergies, and occasional migraine trigger.

It’s not random we call it ‘dank’ or ‘skunk’ and if it’s good it should piss off your neighbours.

It’s 2026. Dry flower vapes get you higher, with less product, and sparing the lungs. They have a smell more in line with popcorn than a cigarette. They come in everything from one-hitter to portable-volcano. Fans exist too.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by jrflowers on Monday April 13, 2026 @03:20PM (#47756691)
> VOCs and carcinogens are a health hazard. Asthma, kids development, allergies, and occasional migraine trigger.

This is the foundational reasoning for making perfume, air fresheners, deodorant, and scented cleaning supplies illegal to possess or use.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by TylerE on Monday April 13, 2026 @04:38PM (#47757511)
Frankly, as an asthmatic I'd be 100% onboard with everything. There are plenty of scent free deodorants that work just fine, btw.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by jrflowers on Monday April 13, 2026 @09:14PM (#47760042)
Fair enough. Banning VOCs and carcinogens would also make barbecues illegal, or really the Maillard reaction in general though.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by TylerE on Monday April 13, 2026 @09:31PM (#47760175)
There’s a difference between something inherent to a process, and something added for basically for marketing reasons that has minimal/no positive effect in actual functionality.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by MisterTea on Monday April 13, 2026 @04:32PM (#47757453)
> Dry flower vapes get you higher, with less product, and sparing the lungs.

This may be subjective as I have tried just about every dry vape out there and each time the high is underwhelming. For me, the traditional bong hit is king.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by toast0 on Monday April 13, 2026 @02:12PM (#47755849)
I don't think it's unreasonable to desire to be free from the noxious odors of others.

> The right to waft my smells in any direction ends where your nose begins.

- Abraham Lincoln or Ben Franklin or Mark Twain or someone

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by sir0010010 on Monday April 13, 2026 @03:00PM (#47756443)
It's not just because marijuana "smells bad". Secondhand marijuana smoke contains many of the same toxic chemicals as secondhand cigarette smoke and likely is similarly deleterious to your health [1]. I also believe everyone should have the right to be able to open their windows and have clean air come through. Smoking on balconies denies people this right. Edibles only effect the user and therefore should be permitted.

[1] https://www.cdc.gov/cannabis/health-effects/secondhand-smoke...

[dead]
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by stale2002 on Monday April 13, 2026 @03:43PM (#47756933)
It doesn't have to be criminally illegal. Instead it could simply be civil. The apartment complex, which you do not own, would be the ones setting the rules here.

And you, of your own free choice, would have the choice to either follow the rules or go live somewhere else. The person you are responding to doesn't have an issue with you smoking in your own purchased home. Instead this was about apartment complexes.

And it wouldn't even have to be a law applied to you. It could be applied to the apartment complex. Apartment complexes already have to follow lots of laws. So they could simply be required to have this as a rule.

And then you, could make your libertarian choice to live there or not. Its not your apartment complex after all. And since its someone else property, they would absolutely have the free to make you not do this in their own property.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by dfdsjsdklfjs on Monday April 13, 2026 @06:54PM (#47759003)
If the apartment owner wants to set his own rules that's fine. It is completely in accord with the principles of free association that a landlord can decide who he wants in his building. When it's forced by government decree to be one way or the other however then it becomes tyranny.

Why shouldn't there be an apartment block that is nothing but weed smokers, and others that are cigarette smokers, some that are both, and some that are neither, in accordance with each tenant and landlord's personal desires? That's what freedom looks like.

If laws were made for instance that a landlord couldn't change from one status to the other (smoking<>non-smoking or vice versa) without a significant notice period, to give people time to move if needed, that would be completely fair.

Strongarming people into a one size fits all mold isn't freedom, regardless of what wishy washy reasoning is given to justify it.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by stale2002 on Monday April 13, 2026 @11:52PM (#47761046)
> When it's forced by government decree

You aren't being forced to do anything that you didn't agree to. You aren't the apartment owner, you instead just signed the contract and have to follow the apartment rules.

I don't see why you get to complain about what someone else is doing with their own property. Its their property. What laws apply to them are none of your business as you simply signed the contract.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by safety1st on Monday April 13, 2026 @02:28PM (#47756066)
Oh good grief. This is such an uninformed and unnecessarily belligerent take.

We can and do have public nuisance laws which kick in when an individual is impinging upon the health, safety, comfort etc. of other people. This exists in jurisdictions all over the world for all kinds of things, the penalties are usually minor and applied only to repeat offenders. It is completely reasonable for someone to support the idea of these applying to marijuana use, in fact, in most jurisdictions where marijuana is legal, they probably already do. Yes, repeatedly stink up your neighbor's apartment and you may get a warning followed by a fine, deal with it. Your parent is not a Nazi and is not throwing stoners in prison. Perhaps go touch grass instead of smoking it now and then.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by dfdsjsdklfjs on Monday April 13, 2026 @05:29PM (#47758060)
The irony of being called "belligerent" when there is infamously a declared war (The War On Drugs) against me and my kind!

Just like all other American wars, it is neverending, and nothing more than a way to funnel money and power into certain people's pockets at the expense of others, while destroying as many innocent lives as possible in the process.

I don't care what apartment dwelling city people do. City issues are for you to work out among yourselves. I'm out in the country far from anyone and I still have to worry about being thrown in prison. The danger is no less here and it has nothing to do with the smell. That's just one of many excuses weed haters use to persecute us. Satisfy one objection and immediately another will be raised.

It never ends and will never end, until the evil ones have achieved their end goal of exterminating this plant and its keepers from the planet forever. Since that will never happen, then it will just be a neverending struggle until the end of time, I guess, with many lives being destroyed in the process.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by asadotzler on Monday April 13, 2026 @04:45PM (#47757591)
Until we start throwing cigar, pipe, and cigarette smokers in prison for smoking where I can smell it, I'm totally okay smelling some pot. The playing field needs to be leveled.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by throwaway173738 on Monday April 13, 2026 @04:49PM (#47757639)
I don’t want my toddler exposed to secondhand pot smoke. Unfortunately it’s more common than secondhand cigarette smoke in my experience. I wouldn’t get upset on my own behalf but he’s too young to choose and it’s my responsibility to act in his behalf as much as I can.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by dfdsjsdklfjs on Monday April 13, 2026 @07:08PM (#47759156)
Good news! Secondhand pot smoke won't hurt your toddler. Nor will firsthand pot smoke.

In fact it will only help him, because if nothing else it will enable him to grow up in tomorrow' world where that's just one of countless other normal smells one might encounter in the world that some might see as objectionable, but that nobody has a right to put others in prison for.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by DangitBobby on Monday April 13, 2026 @11:21PM (#47760861)
Yep it's more distinctive, more intrusive, spreads further, smells worse.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by IAmBroom on Tuesday April 14, 2026 @10:49AM (#47766390)
But is it more unhealthy? The rest are simply adult "preferences".
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by throwaway173738 on Tuesday April 14, 2026 @11:43PM (#47774451)
Are you arguing that my toddler should be okay with it? The point is that it’s not about what I am okay with it’s about my being responsible for my son and what his adult self might want. We had opinions about the positive health effects of cigarettes in the 1940’s and 1950’s that turned out to be wrong. There’s a possibility you’re wrong about pot smoking too.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by dragonwriter on Tuesday April 14, 2026 @01:36PM (#47768656)
Government tobacco smoking bans in indoor spaces accessible to the public (or outdoor spaces near the entrances to such spaces) are not uncommon in the US, nor are private contractual (via leases for rental properties and sometimes CC&Rs that bind property owners) bans for non-public spaces.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by heavyset_go on Monday April 13, 2026 @08:24PM (#47759704)
Voting to put people in prison because of smells is certainly a take.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by DangitBobby on Monday April 13, 2026 @11:20PM (#47760853)
I get that fucking smell everywhere now even while it's still illegal.
[dead]
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by LEDThereBeLight on Tuesday April 14, 2026 @09:43AM (#47765566)
Give me a break.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by dragonwriter on Tuesday April 14, 2026 @01:28PM (#47768548)
Not all bans are criminal, and tobacco smoke has problems beyond odor.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by dragonwriter on Tuesday April 14, 2026 @01:28PM (#47768541)
Smoking (even of tobacco) can generally be banned in the CC&Rs of properties (multifamily complexes is the case where this makes the most sense) and by the landlord in any rented property, multifamily or subject to CC&Rs or not.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by socalgal2 on Monday April 13, 2026 @02:01PM (#47755713)
You should argue with him he's acting like Satan. The mormons (I used to be one) say that Satan wanted to force everyone to be good, Jesus wanted each person to have free will and choose.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by spiritplumber on Tuesday April 14, 2026 @06:16AM (#47763626)
that's actually a pretty cool take!

here's mine if you have a use for it. https://archiveofourown.org/works/65636176?view_full_work=tr...

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by limagnolia on Monday April 13, 2026 @02:33PM (#47756133)
Mormons voted strongly to legalize MJ in Utah. Maybe your politician is just an odd man out?

edit: Well, I should note the Utah vote was only for "medical" MJ.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by cogman10 on Monday April 13, 2026 @03:06PM (#47756530)
It got through via a ballot initiative. It wouldn't have been passed by the legislators in UT without that.

That's why the guy in my state, C. Scott Grow, has also been fighting to make ballot initiatives harder. He's terrified that an MJ initiative would make it's way in that way.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by rhcom2 on Monday April 13, 2026 @03:08PM (#47756544)
Republicans in Utah are also trying to remove the power from ballot initiatives because they're upset the Utahans passed an anti-gerrymandering initiative.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by mothballed on Monday April 13, 2026 @03:31PM (#47756806)
Yaeh this is a thing states do. South Dakota went in cahoots with the courts to cancel the ballot initiative to legalize weed, and California went in cahoots with the courts to sabotage prop 8 (the banning of gay marriage).
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by smcin on Tuesday April 14, 2026 @08:01AM (#47764485)
California Proposition 8 (gay marriage ban) was unconstitutional though, it was always likely to be struck down by the SC.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by mothballed on Tuesday April 14, 2026 @10:26AM (#47766086)
That's not why it was "struck down" by SCOTUS. It was struck down because California intentionally did not defend the case in SCOTUS, leaving the proponents (i.e., those representing the majority vote) to defend it in SCOTUS. Then SCOTUS determined the prop 8 voters didn't have standing to defend prop 8, essentially defaulting the decision through a perverse chickenshit technicality and remanding it back to the lower courts.

SCOTUS did not find gay marriage bans unconstitutional in that case. Only the 9th circuit did, and California intentionally stopped defending it at the 9th circuit because the 9th circuit is and was pro gay marriage.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by jrflowers on Monday April 13, 2026 @03:15PM (#47756637)
> C. Scott Grow

Reverse nominal determinism

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by sdenton4 on Monday April 13, 2026 @04:12PM (#47757228)
Grow, Scott, grow!
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by ribosometronome on Monday April 13, 2026 @11:32PM (#47760930)
> isn't seen by politicians as a motivating vote driver ... It got through via a ballot initiative

Those two seem a little at odds. People are going to vote against it, but not when it's specifically on the ballot?

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by cogman10 on Tuesday April 14, 2026 @12:09AM (#47761130)
It's not.

If 90% of party A supporters support the issue, and 70% of party B supporters support and issue and the election is close to 50/50 with B in power. B putting forward the issue can make them lose the next election because that 30% will either withhold their vote or vote for the other party.

But if that same issue is a ballot measure, then the 90% of A voters and 70% of B voters will overwhelmingly pass it.

This is what I mean by a motivating issue. Nobody will withhold their vote if MJ stays illegal. But there are certainly people (mostly religious) that absolutely will withhold their vote if a politician makes it legal. Even if that's a super popular move.

That's why pretty popular things aren't done. It's also why unpopular things can be easily done. If nobody withholds their vote because of the "send the kids to the mines" act (because they are happy about the mandatory Bible study), then a politician can get away with really horrible things so long as they make the core of their voters happy. After all, you aren't going to let the other guy win now are you.

It's what's broken about parties and FPTP elections.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by lokar on Monday April 13, 2026 @03:30PM (#47756791)
This gets at something I think a lot of people don't really understand. They see polls that show strong support for policy X, and then complain that politicians don't enact it. What they fail to consider is that while a strong majority may be in favor of the policy, it's not the top (or top 3) priority, and they will support candidates that have the opposite position on X, if they support their top priority.

This is situation where well thought out (and moderately constrained) referendum process can help achieve the majority desire for a policy that would not otherwise be considered important enough to drive the selection of representatives.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by jasonwatkinspdx on Monday April 13, 2026 @04:46PM (#47757600)
Yeah, that's essentially what happened here in Oregon.

And the 2nd chapter of it is after the ballot measure passed, the state liquor commission drug its heels for a couple years, because most of their executives are far more conservative than the median voter here (a side effect of a lot of them being Salem locals vs Portland, but anyhow).

Eventually the state legislature got fed up with the obstructionism and passed a "ok, we're just doing it how CO did, stop stalling" bill.

And here we are. The sky didn't fall.

There's a lotta ways ballot measures can go into stupidity, but this is an instance where it helped force the bureaucracy to align with the majority voter position.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by cucumber3732842 on Tuesday April 14, 2026 @06:14AM (#47763618)
>(a side effect of a lot of them being Salem locals vs Portland, but anyhow).

Because their industry is in bed with government so their priority #1 is coordinating with the people of that industry. The actual "value producing" activity of buying, distributing, selling liquor and managing those relationships is a sideshow.

You see this in every deeply regulated industry.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by throwaway173738 on Monday April 13, 2026 @04:46PM (#47757605)
Also it doesn’t matter if there’s majority support for a lot of things because most people don’t vote. If you want to get a policy enacted make sure you and your friends vote in elections regularly.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by chii on Monday April 13, 2026 @11:46PM (#47761009)
> They see polls that show strong support for policy X

i would imagine those polls are full of selection bias - even if the poller is trying to be as neutral as possible. People who would agree to participate in polls tend to have strong(er) feelings than those who don't.

> referendum process

instead of referendums, there should be a representative vote by the elected politician, but with an option for the voter to submit their own vote (provided they pass a cursory examination that certifies they have read and understood the bill they're voting for).

E.g., a senator or an elected politician has N number of votes for a bill, where N is the number of people he/she represents. If those people don't want to participate in a bill voting process, the politician will vote on behalf of them (like they do now, supposedly).

However, an individual voter who wishes to, can certify their understanding of said bill, and rescind the representative vote for his electorate and vote himself directly on the bill. The politician will now have N-1 votes on that same bill.

This means for issues of importance, the individual can choose to participate. For issues that they don't care about, but have a vague sense of direction, they have their votes delegated to the politician that they elected once every X years.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by alphawhisky on Tuesday April 14, 2026 @09:07AM (#47765176)
Or because mormons are fucking batshit crazy. Are they gonna ban coffee in the state next? Idiots.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by bsimpson on Monday April 13, 2026 @12:18PM (#47754316)
I don't even smoke - it just offends me deeply to see the Supreme Court rule in a direction that's so blatantly against the Constitution.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by pdonis on Monday April 13, 2026 @12:20PM (#47754347)
That's been going on for a long, long time.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by dmitrygr on Monday April 13, 2026 @12:05PM (#47754099)
You’re probably right, though I dread the possibility. I cannot stand the smell, and one of the best things about moving from California to Texas was avoiding that pervasive smell being everywhere. Negative externalities of personal behavior really need to be handled better in our society. If you want pot to be legal, fine, but only inside your own personal enclosed house.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by barbazoo on Monday April 13, 2026 @12:11PM (#47754193)
That's only one of many ways to consume it, many people vape, have edibles or drinks and you just don't notice.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by embedding-shape on Monday April 13, 2026 @01:08PM (#47755043)
Even as a daily weed smoker myself though, it's hard not to acknowledge that a more liberal marijuana stance in a geographic location does lead to that smell being more commonly encountered when in public and out and about.

Personally I don't mind, almost the opposite, but for people who don't like the smell, obviously they feel differently. Good thing we can have different policies in different places, and people can generally, one way or another, move themselves to other places. Could be easier, but could also be way worse.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by dfdsjsdklfjs on Monday April 13, 2026 @02:05PM (#47755766)
As a daily weed smoker, I live out in the middle of the woods, but even that isn't enough to stop the Way Better Than Thou types from wanting me thrown in prison and/or excommunicated. There is no escaping these violent, self-righteous, arrogant busybodies.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by embedding-shape on Monday April 13, 2026 @03:40PM (#47756903)
Meanwhile, I smoke weed in my office, but I have a air purifier (rated for double the air flow capacity of the room) and not even my wife who works in the room next door can smell anything, and she actively despises the smell.

Sometimes you just need to find the right equipment :)

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by asadotzler on Monday April 13, 2026 @04:49PM (#47757638)
See also, cigarettes, cigars, and pipe smoking. I find those smells about 10x as offensive as smoked weed. I don't see the HN crowd coming out against tobacco despite these two being roughly equivalent in use. And that 20 ft from the door thing is a joke when it's on the sidewalk you have to walk through to reach the bus stop or your car. At least the pot smell doesn't stick to my clothes until they're washed like the tobacco smell.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by nullc on Monday April 13, 2026 @07:14PM (#47759192)
I dunno, I think it should be legalized and operation of a car or other heavy machinery while intoxicated should result in a swift and brutal public execution. Win/win. :D

But maybe I'm just a little jaded after having lived in a legalized area and almost being run down by hotboxed cars more than once.

Functionally in many places where the usage is unlawful, harmless use in people's private homes has very low risk of prosecution while dangerous or disruptive public use is still curtailed. I find it easy to sympathize with people who consider that a better tradeoff.

I strongly agree with de-federalizing any such decisions though-- your comment on freedom to move is a great one. I recently relocated to a place where it wasn't legal from one where it was, any when evaluating differential freedoms in making that decision the subject came up and I decided I probably actually preferred the restriction due to the collateral harms (although I strongly chaff at any restrictions on private activities or maintenance of your own body). I wouldn't say it was a major factor in the decision to move (other policy/economic/environmental/security matters were drivers) but for me it wasn't a reason to not make that move.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by ChoGGi on Tuesday April 14, 2026 @09:45AM (#47765592)
I live in Canada, I smell it maybe a dozen times a year? Certainly less than I smell tobacco smoke (that smell is nasty).

Could depend on where I live and hangout though.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by caycep on Monday April 13, 2026 @12:13PM (#47754233)
I mean, there are plenty of neighborhoods in CA that don't have that smell...
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by 0x457 on Monday April 13, 2026 @01:11PM (#47755072)
There just no smell like this in any neighborhood outside of college campuses and area close to those.

You might get a whiff here and there, but you're going to encounter a lot of smells you don't like here and there.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by realo on Monday April 13, 2026 @12:21PM (#47754357)
THC is perfectly legal here (Quebec, Canada) and believe me, there is no smell on the streets!

What is actually disgusting and happens often in the streets is the smell of ordinary cigarette smoke.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by FuriouslyAdrift on Monday April 13, 2026 @01:29PM (#47755304)
It's not legal where I am at all and I get hotboxed on my morning drive to work every day...
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by declan_roberts on Monday April 13, 2026 @01:41PM (#47755442)
The fact that so many people think it's fine to get high and drive is baffling to me.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by dlev_pika on Monday April 13, 2026 @01:53PM (#47755610)
It’s ok if you do it where you arrive at taps forehead
[dead]
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by FuriouslyAdrift on Monday April 13, 2026 @02:07PM (#47755799)
It's still illegal in all 50 states and a DUI or DWI.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by dfdsjsdklfjs on Monday April 13, 2026 @02:15PM (#47755884)
And your point is?
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by lovich on Monday April 13, 2026 @02:41PM (#47756232)
It still negatively affects your ability to drive. You shouldn’t be taking anything that negatively affects reaction time or attention and drive.

I’m pro legalization but definitely not pro reckless behavior like that

[dead]
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by lovich on Monday April 13, 2026 @07:53PM (#47759491)
If you think consuming thc doesn’t effect your driving ability then you should probably lay off it for a while because you’ve become retarded.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by dfdsjsdklfjs on Monday April 13, 2026 @07:59PM (#47759524)
Why do you hate facts?
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by lovich on Tuesday April 14, 2026 @10:24AM (#47766064)
I don’t, you’re fundamentally incorrect.
[dead]
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by lovich on Tuesday April 14, 2026 @11:21AM (#47766841)
Kk, this is just a clanker. Or someone so high they can’t handle reality.

Have a good day.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by z500 on Monday April 13, 2026 @12:47PM (#47754723)
This might be controversial, but smelling either in public makes me happy! Now the stale smell of tobacco-infused clothing, that is awful.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by declan_roberts on Monday April 13, 2026 @01:40PM (#47755432)
It's legal in many states here. In SF it's absolutely everywhere and disgusting. Austin smells like tobacco and it's much better to my nose.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by dfdsjsdklfjs on Monday April 13, 2026 @02:16PM (#47755897)
What you smell as "disgusting" smells amazing to me.

Some of these perfumes that people drench themselves with smell disgusting to me. But I don't look for them to be thrown in prison or taxed for it.

If you like the smell of tobacco (and I do also) then you'd better band together with weed smokers regardless of whether you like weed or not, before the Karens succeed in making it all illegal and banned along with anything else that helps one escape from the prison they are building.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by asadotzler on Monday April 13, 2026 @04:54PM (#47757690)
Your nose is literally a special flower. What smells good to it may not to another and vice versa. I far prefer the smell of pot smoke on the sidewalk to the smell of tobacco smoke. You youngsters missed the years of indoor workplace smoking and smoke breaks with 20 smokers surrounding the office entry door. It's just another smell to you. But for those of us who lived through the bad days of smoking, it's a toxic soup, a smoke inferno hell pit we're not thrilled about revisiting right outside of our favorite restaurant. A little bit of grass burning, no big deal. A cigarette and my meal's ruined.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by arrowsmith on Wednesday April 15, 2026 @02:10PM (#47782949)
It’s illegal in London but you wouldn’t know it from the smell. That city stinks of weed.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by kjkjadksj on Monday April 13, 2026 @12:33PM (#47754539)
Oh no, the thought of catching a whiff! No one must smoke in texas, since you know, everyone follows the law. Smoking weed only started in general with legalization. It was mythical beforehand.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by squigz on Monday April 13, 2026 @12:46PM (#47754719)
> but only inside your own personal enclosed house.

Isn't it usually illegal to smoke things like cigarettes inside rented homes, legality aside? And don't most people rent? That seems like a whole can to deal with.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by Brian_K_White on Monday April 13, 2026 @12:49PM (#47754769)
Some people say the same about the smell or noise of babies. It's not a very strong argument for getting ones way in controlling others.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by jonnycoder on Monday April 13, 2026 @01:08PM (#47755032)
Are you ok with ciggarete smoke then if you are ok with marijuana smoke?
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by dfdsjsdklfjs on Monday April 13, 2026 @02:15PM (#47755878)
Yep. Why wouldn't I be? I'm not a brainwashed Karen. "Freedom" isn't just a word that I use--it actually means something to me.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by dmitrygr on Monday April 13, 2026 @04:24PM (#47757349)
>> Are you ok with ciggarete smoke then if you are ok with marijuana smoke?

> Yep. Why wouldn't I be? I'm not a brainwashed Karen.

https://www.cdc.gov/tobacco/secondhand-smoke/health.html

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by dmitrygr on Monday April 13, 2026 @04:23PM (#47757338)
babies -> needed for civilization to continue

weed -> possibly negative effect on civilization ( https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2424288/) , certainly not a requirement.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by kelnos on Monday April 13, 2026 @10:41PM (#47760628)
If you truly think that "having babies" and "smoking weed" can be compared in any meaningful sense like this, I'm not sure what to tell you.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by Brian_K_White on Wednesday April 15, 2026 @08:49PM (#47787341)
I truly think "it's not a very strong argument". If only I had said those exact words in order to communicate clearly.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by dfxm12 on Monday April 13, 2026 @04:09PM (#47757190)
It's been popular (with over 50% popular support) for the last decade though. The major opponents are the alcohol industry, big pharma and the prison industrial complex. Their lobbying efforts are too powerful. We (the people) don't stand a chance.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by swiftcoder on Monday April 13, 2026 @11:23AM (#47753346)
I'd imagine one wants to litigate Wickard v. Filburn in its entirety, rather than just the downstream Gonzales v. Raich
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by mothballed on Monday April 13, 2026 @11:29AM (#47753443)
That would also invalidate the civil rights act, as the (similar) 19th century CRA was already struck down because the 14th amendment binds against discrimination by public not private actors. The reason why the modern CRAs weren't also struck is because they rested on the laurels of Wickard v Filburn declaring the CRA (this time) is about regulating "interstate" commerce.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by bombcar on Monday April 13, 2026 @11:31AM (#47753474)
fixing the interstate commerce clause is one of those things that needs to be done eventually, but will likely never be done - even if just to "fix" it so everything remains the same but is based on simpler allocation of powers than through a "loophole".
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by gbacon on Monday April 13, 2026 @12:34PM (#47754568)
John Roberts will find a way to screw it up.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by drak0n1c on Monday April 13, 2026 @12:27PM (#47754457)
That would be an improvement in the same spirit, as the modern CRAs are also unconstitutionally limiting over what one chooses to do with their own property. The scope should be limited to government-involved services and facilities, as those must serve all possible taxpayers. We live in a more connected, option-saturated information age where even bigots more often than not understand the utility of at least doing business politely and making nuanced exceptions. Egregious offenses are corrected by social pressure and business competition. The current regime of ambulance-chasing liabilities inserted into every organizational, contracting, and hiring process harms far more people of every race and sex than it helps.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by BobaFloutist on Monday April 13, 2026 @02:05PM (#47755769)
>Egregious offenses are corrected by social pressure and business competition.

This doesn't work when bigots are willing to pay a premium for discriminatory services.

Also, do you feel the same way about the FHA and Title VII? Those also involve regulating what you can choose to do with your private property, but I don't want to assume that you don't consider housing and employment to be distinct from, say, hotels and grocery stores.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by hellojesus on Tuesday April 14, 2026 @01:06PM (#47768308)
I think it should be repealed. It's legally baseless. How hard would it possibly be to get anti discriminatory Ammendments into the constitution? Surely at least 2/3 of reps are not that unfit.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by gbacon on Monday April 13, 2026 @12:33PM (#47754546)
You have identified a root perversion. Roscoe Filburn’s wheat did not leave Ohio or even his farm. He didn’t offer it for sale; the wheat was for his own use. It was deemed to “affect interstate commerce” and thus within the scope of the interstate commerce clause. With that, a provision intended to remove power of states to tax each other’s goods and services and promote a free trade zone instead became a mechanism to nitpick and micromanage every last little detail, ossify existing practice, protect large players, give loopholes to the politically connected, and enable mass regulatory capture. It cannot be overturned quickly enough.

https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/317/111/

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by laughing_man on Monday April 13, 2026 @01:14PM (#47755105)
I don't see SCOTUS ever overturning Wickard, sadly. Too many federal programs and regulations would lose their legal basis if that happened.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by gbacon on Monday April 13, 2026 @02:18PM (#47755930)
You’re almost certainly correct. Kagan, Sotomayor, and Jackson would argue this consequentualist line. Thomas, Alito, and Gorsuch could be persuaded by textualist or originalist arguments and are the most likely overturn votes. Kavanaugh was a key man on standing up and defending the so-called PATRIOT Act during the George W. Bush administration, so no way he knocks out this pillar.

ACB talked a strong originalist game during her confirmation but since shown it’s not her core philosophy. Although Roberts appears inclined to rein in the administrative state, he’s aligned chaotic neutral and thinks himself too clever.

Already down 4-3 and having to persuade both Barrett and Roberts to join a ruling overturning parts of Wickard, another Dobbs seems wildly unlikely even though both precedents were poorly reasoned. At best, they agree to some marginal or technical reduction in scope. It seems equally likely that she sides with the four, in which case, what does Roberts do? He may need to make it 6-3 to control who writes the opinion. Such strong numbers would be unfavorable enough on the surface that he might persuade her back to an even more tepid limitation. The concurring opinions that it would induce from Thomas, Alito, and Gorsuch would be entertaining reading, at least.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by PaulDavisThe1st on Monday April 13, 2026 @03:31PM (#47756801)
Please suggest one, but ideally three, things that you think that overturning Wickard would lead to that would cause K, S & J to vote against doing so?
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by giantg2 on Tuesday April 14, 2026 @11:25AM (#47766881)
The federal civil rights act of 1964 is probably a good one. The clean air act is another. Probably others like consumer protection laws, healthcare regulations, safety laws (OSHA), etc. These are all based on the expanded powers from wickard v fillburn. If portions of these were challenged and overturned, I believe those justices would not view that as a good thing.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by hellojesus on Tuesday April 14, 2026 @01:03PM (#47768267)
Isn't OSHA already unconstitutional under current implementation due to competing intelligible principles?

I agree they won't do it, but they absolutely should.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by hellojesus on Tuesday April 14, 2026 @01:01PM (#47768235)
There's no way Roberts would vote to overturn this given his history of pretending a penalty directly remitted to the IRS for not carrying health insurance was not a tax for the whole ACA fiasco.

But Filburn must needs be overturned. The sovereignty of states depends on it.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by wahern on Monday April 13, 2026 @02:27PM (#47756054)
In Gonzales, O'Connor dissented and Scalia, who was too afraid of pulling the rug out from under the administrative state, issued a concurrence. So, surprises do happen.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by laughing_man on Monday April 13, 2026 @03:12PM (#47756591)
Drugs were always a weird exception to what was otherwise pretty consistent jurisprudence on Scalia's part.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by wahern on Monday April 13, 2026 @11:26PM (#47760891)
I was prepared to excuse his vote as an exceptional situation until Sebelius, when rather than revisit and fix his mistake in Gonzales he chose to embrace the affirmative mandate vs passive prohibition distinction nonsense, a deux ex machina fit for one purpose and one purpose only. Fool me once....

There's a good argument to be made that it was just good luck for Scalia's intellectual legacy that he died before the conservative supermajority on the court got rolling, because he was already well on his way to replacing principles with expediency: https://www.scotusblog.com/2026/03/justice-scalias-uncertain... Like the old saying goes, it's easy to criticize, much more difficult to offer constructive, durable solutions.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by PaulDavisThe1st on Monday April 13, 2026 @03:29PM (#47756786)
I call BS. Wickard is about, effectively, "police power" based on a broad interpretation of the scope of federal/interstate commerce.

As noted by other commenters, the concept of federal control of interstate commerce was intended to prevent states from interfering with trade between themselves and other states, and to create some "higher" authority for aspects of commerce that truly transcended state borders and control.

Most of what has happened in terms of programs and regulations fits very comfortably into that understanding. What doesn't, which I don't think is a lot, should probably go away anyway.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by laughing_man on Monday April 13, 2026 @10:31PM (#47760566)
If you can use the commerce clause to prevent a guy growing wheat on his own property and feeding that crop in its entirety to his animals, there literally isn't an activity the federal government can't regulate.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by socalgal2 on Tuesday April 14, 2026 @04:57AM (#47763037)
Correct. I'm suprised sexual orientation hasn't been regulated by the same stupid logic. Clearly if you're not making babies you're effecting all kinds of interstate commerce.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by tyre on Monday April 13, 2026 @11:42AM (#47753659)
Another case based on interstate commerce: the US ban on racial segregation. The example given, iirc, was restaurant competition across state lines.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by tt24 on Monday April 13, 2026 @11:46AM (#47753738)
The interstate commerce clause is just craziness. It touches everything and gives justification to regulate nearly anything.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by mothballed on Monday April 13, 2026 @11:50AM (#47753800)
You could just as easily stuff most of those things under the "general welfare" clause if you do the same rigamarole of years and years of precedent hand-waving. We live in a post constitutional state. The constitution is just something worked to backwards so the guys who function as our priests/gods point to the document because that's the only way to feign some sort of legitimacy to our government.

Ultimately none of us signed the constitution and all of those people that did are dead. It is a religious artifact used by the whig -god people to argue they are right. Not something followed with faith to the historical context nor literal contract.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by Windchaser on Monday April 13, 2026 @12:21PM (#47754361)
General Welfare Clause only applies to taxing and spending, though, not just general regulation (e.g., making drugs illegal or banning segregation).
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by gbacon on Monday April 13, 2026 @12:47PM (#47754729)
For what purpose could the enumeration of particular powers be inserted, if these and all others were meant to be included in the preceding general power? Nothing is more natural nor common than first to use a general phrase, and then to explain and qualify it by a recital of particulars … But what would have been thought of that assembly, if, attaching themselves to these general expressions, and disregarding the specifications which ascertain and limit their import, they had exercised an unlimited power of providing for the common defense and general welfare? I appeal to the objectors themselves, whether they would in that case have employed the same reasoning in justification of Congress as they now make use of against the convention. How difficult it is for error to escape its own condemnation!

Federalist No. 41 https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/fed41.asp

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by seanw444 on Monday April 13, 2026 @12:43PM (#47754680)
I agree, from the other side of the aisle. The Constitution is merely a well-guarded piece of toilet paper now. Culture matters way more than legal documents in preserving a nation, and our culture has waned too significantly. I believe we've entered the "Byzantine" phase of America.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by cogman10 on Monday April 13, 2026 @12:21PM (#47754351)
A lot of stuff does have interstate implications. Especially now that most corporations operate in an interstate fashion.

That said, I agree that it's overused. I personally think that the 9th amendment should be used in a lot of cases, like civil rights, instead of the interstate commerce law.

The supreme court, however, has basically decided that the 9th amendment doesn't really exist.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by Der_Einzige on Monday April 13, 2026 @11:46AM (#47753728)
I wouldn't be surprised if this one unironically goes given that Uber/Lyft are fully doing "women only" ride shares now.

Gen Z / Alpha have embraced X-"realism" and fully accept essentialism/reject "intersectionality". They're far more conservative/prudish than millennials, even at their young age.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by esseph on Monday April 13, 2026 @12:10PM (#47754182)
[delayed]
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by DennisP on Monday April 13, 2026 @12:34PM (#47754571)
I think there's a selection effect there that makes it an unrepresentative sample.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by esseph on Monday April 13, 2026 @02:04PM (#47755752)
First, Gen Alpha is in their teens, so it's kind of hard to say what is happening there or will happen.

Second, there is a growing divide between gen Z males that are skewing conservative in some ways. Their church/religious attendance is up, but overall attendance is still down.

Gen Z females that are the most liberal demographic in history.

The split is both political/social.

(US analysis)

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by fennecbutt on Monday April 13, 2026 @03:29PM (#47756790)
>Their church/religious attendance is up

This was debunked, at least in the UK. Not sure about the US but I'll bet it's the same sham (church sponsored) statistics.

I think more of each generation is coming to realise that religion is an outmoded parasite.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by dfdsjsdklfjs on Monday April 13, 2026 @07:12PM (#47759186)
The church certainly is, but religion isn't and will never be.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by kelnos on Tuesday April 14, 2026 @12:08AM (#47761128)
At this point I don't see any difference between the two. Modern religions are shaped (warped, really) by the larger organizations that control them.

Sure, the concept of "spiritual/non-scientific belief" isn't a parasite in and of itself, but even if the existing organized religions ceased to hold their sway, and people treated religion as a personal thing without centralized authorities, I still don't see an end to (for example) people trying to get their religious beliefs enshrined in law. That's parasite behavior.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday April 14, 2026 @04:02AM (#47762689)
> Another case based on interstate commerce: the US ban on racial segregation.

Specifically the federal ban on private segregation. The states would still be able to ban it.

Moreover, is that the sort of thing you even want as an ordinary statute dangling precariously off of the commerce clause instead of making it a constitutional amendment to begin with?

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by jmyeet on Monday April 13, 2026 @11:38AM (#47753588)
I looked at the actual decision [1] and didn't see Filburn mentioned once. I find that odd. Filburn [2] was a controversial and far-reaching decision that said that the Federal government's ability to regulate interstate commerce extended to people growing wheat on their own property for their own use. The rationale was that by growing wheat you weren't participating in the interstate wheat market. That seems like a wild interpretation to me but it's Supreme Court precedent at this point.

So I found this footnote:

> The government does not challenge the district court’s Commerce Clause analysis on appeal. Accordingly, any such argument is forfeited, and we do not address it.

That's interesting. Here's a legal analysis that does bring up the Commerce Clause and Filburn [3]. I really wonder why the government didn't raise this issue.

I knew just from the headline this was going to be a 5th Circuit decision, and it was. This is the same circuit that is perfectly fine to override "state's rights" for other issues.

[1]:https://www.ca5.uscourts.gov/opinions/pub/24/24-10760-CV0.pd...

[2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wickard_v._Filburn

[3]: https://www.yalejreg.com/nc/reviving-the-commerce-clause-one...

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by bee_rider on Monday April 13, 2026 @12:01PM (#47754028)
That seems like a pretty over-reaching interpretation. It makes sense in the context (needing to support federal economic control during WW2). But in some sense the economy is a dynamic system that touches and is touched by almost every decision we make. I made a pot of coffee this morning, should the federal government have the ability to decide whether or not I’m damaging the cafe market by not supporting my local cafe?
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by gbear605 on Monday April 13, 2026 @11:41AM (#47753646)
It's possible that the government thought that if they did try to challenge the Commerce Clause analysis, then the Supreme Court could have struck down Filburn. They'd much rather lose narrowly on this specific case than have Filburn reversed entirely.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by mothballed on Monday April 13, 2026 @11:46AM (#47753722)
SCOTUS did a pretty hilarious soft "strike down" of Wickard where they basically determined the gun free school zone act (GFSZA) violated interstate commerce clause. So congress just added "in interstate commerce" to the GFSZA and now it does the exact same thing even if there was no interstate commerce involved, and nothing involved ever crossed state lines or actually entered interstate commerce.

So SCOTUS basically solved this by saying the law had to say "in interstate commerce" but it is basically just there as a talisman to ward away challenges, a distinction without any difference as it becomes a tautology.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by nullc on Monday April 13, 2026 @07:40PM (#47759388)
I don't agree that requiring a talisman is irrelevant-- ineptly drafted laws will lack them and fail more easily. The legislative effort to add it may not happen later, especially once judicial review has spoken negatively of the underlying constitutionality of the law.

It also is not of no effect-- it's an element of defense and people have escaped GFSZ act because the government failed to satisfy interstate commerce (and internet search suggests the some courts have taken it to mean that the presence of the gun in the school zone itself must have impacted interstate commerce, rather than just the gun's past purchase did). Every element the prosecution must prove at any level increases the marginal cost of prosecution and makes it less likely to be imposed on more marginal cases.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by pdonis on Monday April 13, 2026 @12:19PM (#47754337)
In Wickard v. Filburn, back in 1942, they said the same thing for wheat.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by thaumasiotes on Monday April 13, 2026 @01:42PM (#47755462)
You say that like interstate commerce regulation was more egregious for wheat than it was for marijuana.

But Raich is significantly more egregious: the theory on which the government won Wickard v. Filburn, that private consumption of wheat could affect the interstate market for wheat, doesn't even apply, because there can be no interstate market in a substance that is illegal to trade.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by ianferrel on Monday April 13, 2026 @02:36PM (#47756155)
>there can be no interstate market in a substance that is illegal to trade.

There is in fact an interstate market in many substances that are illegal to trade because laws against things do not make those things fail to exist.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by PaulDavisThe1st on Monday April 13, 2026 @03:42PM (#47756917)
No market that the federal government can recognize, tax or regulate
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by lmm on Monday April 13, 2026 @10:29PM (#47760553)
Illegal commerce is still subject to taxation and regulation, famously so in the case of Al Capone.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by IAmBroom on Tuesday April 14, 2026 @11:01AM (#47766552)
Legally subject to. Practically, untaxed.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by zdragnar on Tuesday April 14, 2026 @10:45AM (#47766337)
By making it illegal, it has already been regulated. The IRS also requires reporting and taxing all income, even that which was unlawfully gained.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by gowld on Monday April 13, 2026 @03:08PM (#47756543)
The reason marijuana is Federally illegal in the first place is because the commerce clause is interpreted to allow it.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by 999900000999 on Monday April 13, 2026 @12:23PM (#47754392)
The problem is if you say the government can’t regulate MJ, then all drug regulations fall apart.

On one hand you should have a right to buy whatever you want at 21( which should be the minimum enlistment age), but I’d be concerned about Billy selling homemade GPLs or whatever.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by dylan604 on Monday April 13, 2026 @12:28PM (#47754469)
> The problem is if you say the government can’t regulate MJ, then all drug regulations fall apart.

No, that's not what's being said. If you grow your own plant for personal use, there's no need for the federal government to be involved. If you grow that plant and then try to sell it, then there's some commerce which does fall under some regulation (we'll leave the interstate nuances aside). Having the fed being allowed to say you cannot grow in your house is one step away from saying you are only allowed to perform missionary position (no other positions are allowed) between the hours of 7-8pm, but not at all on Sunday.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by 999900000999 on Monday April 13, 2026 @12:40PM (#47754650)
Okay. So if you decide to visit a friends house does him sharing still count as personal use ?

In many communities you have a guy who cooks plates of food and sells them. While technically this is illegal with out a permit, it’s usually tolerated.

I’m all for the legalization of everything for adults, but it’s a very complex issue. Education is the way here, not punishment

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by semiquaver on Monday April 13, 2026 @01:17PM (#47755149)
No one argues these things are not able to be regulated. Instead, per the 10th amendment, it must be left to state law since Congress does not have unlimited power and may only legislate where power has been granted to them by the constitution.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by kjkjadksj on Monday April 13, 2026 @12:36PM (#47754595)
And before people say you are being hyperbolic, the government still regulates sex positions. Sodomy is illegal in 12 US states.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by randallsquared on Monday April 13, 2026 @01:24PM (#47755233)
Not the federal government, however.

There are specific prohibitions on certain categories of state laws, like granting titles of nobility, creating non-gold/silver currencies, etc. The federal government cannot constitutionally regulate sex positions, because anything not explicitly covered in the Constitution is reserved to the states, or the people. In that broad grant, however, the states individually can make or avoid making law on any topic.

As others have mentioned, the Supreme Court has frequently worked around the Constitution for reasons that made sense to them at the time, including the original ruling that this one overturns.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by BobaFloutist on Monday April 13, 2026 @02:17PM (#47755913)
>The federal government cannot constitutionally regulate sex positions, because anything not explicitly covered in the Constitution is reserved to the states, or the people.

That being said, there's probably not a constitutional way to enforce laws regulating sex positions. Even if you don't agree that such laws are clearly discriminatory in intent (let alone impact), the privacy violations necessary to prove guilt "Beyond a reasonable doubt" almost certainly violate the Fourth Amendment, and any theory of harm would implicitly (if not explicitly) rest on religion.

This is all assuming you don't accept Griswold as a reasonable constitutional argument that pretty obviously would extend to the kinds of sex people have.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by dylan604 on Monday April 13, 2026 @03:25PM (#47756732)
> That being said, there's probably not a constitutional way to enforce laws regulating sex positions.

Right, but until someone gets arrested for this, nobody has standing to challenge the constitutionality of the law itself. It is one of those unenforceable laws. Even biblical law required witnesses (never just one) before being able to prove adultery.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by dcrazy on Monday April 13, 2026 @07:21PM (#47759253)
See also Griswold v. Connecticut.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by MichaelDickens on Monday April 13, 2026 @12:30PM (#47754501)
I believe the original idea of the Constitution was that most things would be regulated at the state level.

This is pretty much already the case with marijuana, where it's illegal at the federal level, but in practice if it's legal in your state then it's legal.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by kelnos on Tuesday April 14, 2026 @12:14AM (#47761159)
"Pretty much" is doing quite a bit of work there. The feds ignoring marijuana use in states that have legalized or decriminalized it is the DoJ actively deciding not to prosecute MJ cases. They could absolutely send the FBI or whatever into a state with legalized marijuana and raid dispensaries and arrest people if they wanted to.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by hellojesus on Tuesday April 14, 2026 @01:10PM (#47768344)
I'm convinced they don't do exactly that because they know it would ultimately result in the Supreme Court overturning Filburn.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by davidw on Monday April 13, 2026 @12:29PM (#47754475)
> I’d be concerned about Billy selling homemade GPLs or whatever.

Would it be better with a BSD license?

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by gbacon on Monday April 13, 2026 @12:36PM (#47754602)
Been samplin’ a little bit of Grandpa’s attribution clause, have we?
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by torstenvl on Monday April 13, 2026 @12:58PM (#47754900)
The word "interstate" does not exist in the text of the Constitution.

There's arguably some merit to your position, but the argument that some case law is invalid because it doesn't meet the definition of a term defined in other case law is circular and incoherent.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by codexb on Monday April 13, 2026 @01:01PM (#47754953)
It uses the phrase “regulate commerce between the states” which effectively has the same meaning.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by torstenvl on Monday April 13, 2026 @02:19PM (#47755943)
No. It absolutely does not use that language, and it baffles me as to what would cause you to say that it does.

Please endeavor to say only true things. The truth matters.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by bsimpson on Monday April 13, 2026 @03:19PM (#47756682)
You're working awfully hard to be pedantic without comparing the actual language:

> to regulate Commerce with foreign Nations, and among the several States, and with the Indian Tribes"

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commerce_Clause

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by torstenvl on Monday April 13, 2026 @03:46PM (#47756961)
It's morally repugnant that you think expecting people not to lie is "pedantic."
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by kelnos on Tuesday April 14, 2026 @12:10AM (#47761134)
A paraphrase isn't a lie. The actual quoted passage from the constitution does indeed amount to a regulation of interstate commerce.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by torstenvl on Sunday April 19, 2026 @08:38PM (#47829077)
Quotation marks don't indicate a paraphrase. Are you confused or just pathologically disingenuous?
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by codexb on Monday April 13, 2026 @01:01PM (#47754938)
The controlling case is Wickard v Filburn (1942).

A farmer was told he could only grow X acres of feed on his own land; feed that he had no intention of selling and was being fed entirely to his own livestock on the same land.

This seems to overturn that in part, but until Wickard is overturned, and the interstate commerce clause reigned in, there will be weird side effects of it like this.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by semiquaver on Monday April 13, 2026 @01:05PM (#47755014)
Circuit courts may not overrule Supreme Court precedent. Accordingly, this decision purports to rest on the “Necessary and Proper” clause, avoiding Wickard (decided on commerce clause grounds)
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by wahern on Monday April 13, 2026 @02:23PM (#47755983)
In particular, Necessary and Proper as it relates to the taxing power, which the challenged statute relied upon, having been passed decades before the scope of Commerce Clause powers began their expansion, let alone Wickard v. Filburn.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by HWR_14 on Monday April 13, 2026 @03:09PM (#47756562)
How does the supreme court revisit precedents if the circuit court doesn't readdress the issue?
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by pdonis on Monday April 13, 2026 @03:52PM (#47757015)
The party that wants the precedent reversed loses in the lower court (because the lower court is bound by current Supreme Court precedent) and appeals to the Supreme Court. The canonical historical example is Brown v. Board of Education, which was appealed to the Supreme Court explicitly to ask them to reverse Plessy v. Ferguson, which lower courts had relied on as precedent.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by PaulDavisThe1st on Monday April 13, 2026 @03:25PM (#47756739)
Somebody has to bring a new case that presents a novel legal theory/presentation that isn't clearly addressed by the ruling that forms the precedent.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by djoldman on Monday April 13, 2026 @03:49PM (#47756992)
Additionally, one can argue that the state of the world has changed enough that assumptions made by the USC at the time of precedence require reversal.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by sdenton4 on Monday April 13, 2026 @04:19PM (#47757301)
The court is stacked with so called originalists - history stopped in the eighteenth century.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by franga2000 on Tuesday April 14, 2026 @02:18AM (#47761899)
idk, they wouldn't have given the president nearly absolute immunity back then..
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by IAmBroom on Tuesday April 14, 2026 @10:56AM (#47766488)
Yes, they are insincere "originalists". This is known.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by PaulDavisThe1st on Monday April 13, 2026 @04:03PM (#47757138)
only in a new case ....
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by gowld on Monday April 13, 2026 @03:04PM (#47756499)
> Circuit courts may not overrule Supreme Court precedent.

That's a Supreme Court opinion that only applies if the new case reaches their docket and gets reaffirmed.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by bell-cot on Monday April 13, 2026 @03:07PM (#47756537)
There's a lot of context (behind Wickard v Filburn) which would obviously not apply to anyone distilling for personal consumption:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wickard_v._Filburn

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by laughing_man on Monday April 13, 2026 @01:10PM (#47755057)
If they reversed Gonzales v. Raich they'd be under a lot of pressure to reverse Wickard v. Fulburn, which would have such wide ramifications I just don't see the court doing it no matter how warranted.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by john01dav on Monday April 13, 2026 @01:39PM (#47755416)
I suspect that if that ruling was made, then many other drugs being made at home for personal use might become legalized, at least unless states decide to go and ban it too. Note that I am not taking a position here on if that's desirable.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by bsimpson on Monday April 13, 2026 @01:59PM (#47755692)
That's arguing around the point.

If the law is broken, fix the law. Don't pervert logic to pretend that the existing law dictates what you want is correct.

If Roe v Wade is based on faulty logic, cool - overturn it. But it then becomes Congress's responsibility to replace it with the correct version.

The federal government isn't supposed to police people's personal behavior. "Federal" comes from "federation" as in, the group of states in the union. It's the job of the legislature to write the laws, the job of the judiciary to interpret the laws, and the job of the states to do these things for areas that don't rise to the level enumerated in the Constitution.

When you get it twisted, you end up with this tug-of-war where corrupt politicians try to put biased judges on the bench to mold the rules to their whims without actually having to pass them.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by gowld on Monday April 13, 2026 @03:10PM (#47756573)
> If the law is broken, fix the law

If you follow that argument to its conclusion, you end up at: fixing the law requires amending the Constitution, and if the law for amending the constitution is broken, the remedy is revolution. Most participants prefer the current practice instead.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by DangitBobby on Monday April 13, 2026 @11:25PM (#47760888)
Maybe we could get enough support behind an amendment to amend the amendment process.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by abigail95 on Monday April 13, 2026 @05:46PM (#47758245)
If anyone considers that outcome to be strange - that's how most things are supposed to be regulated. It's doubly specified in the wording of the constitution and 10A.

If one takes the opinion interstate commerce means buying, selling and transporting.

It's also how the current system works. Most drug convictions are based on state law. Federal drug prosecutions are 2% of the total. Every state has its version of controlled substances act.

Nothing much would change at all.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by Tangurena2 on Monday April 13, 2026 @01:41PM (#47755445)
Many American treaties (with other nations) prohibit both/either parties from decriminalizing marijuana among other drugs.

Links:

discusses some of the treaties:

https://www2.nycbar.org/pdf/InternationalDrugControlTreaties...

History of illegalization of pot:

https://www.congress.gov/crs-product/R44782

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by bsimpson on Monday April 13, 2026 @01:44PM (#47755489)
It's not about decriminalizing marijuana - it's about the absurd assertion that the federal government can regulate what you do personally because "yadda yadda yadda…interstate commerce!"
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by tavavex on Monday April 13, 2026 @05:48PM (#47758276)
These treaties are ancient and mostly irrelevant, especially outside the topic of hard drugs. Unless you're doing harm to the other nations, no one will do anything.

This paper is all the way from 2012. Since its publication, many countries have pushed the limits to far greater lengths than what it talks about. Canada remains a signatory to all the old 60s-80s treaties about drugs, but can you guess what the consequences were when we legalized cannabis in spite of all of them? No one cares about these.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by 15155 on Tuesday April 14, 2026 @06:41AM (#47763829)
Treaties can't legally do an end-run around the limits prescribed to the government in the Constitution.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by andrewmg on Monday April 13, 2026 @01:45PM (#47755494)
Our companion case in the Sixth Circuit tees up the issue:

https://www.buckeyeinstitute.org/issues/detail/ream-v-us-dep...

See the opening brief.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by nullc on Monday April 13, 2026 @03:32PM (#47756814)
Thank you for your work here. Overcoming the argument that a threat of prosecution doesn't create standing is a huge advancement for the cause of freedom-- in light of Babbitt the state never should have been arguing otherwise nor should the lower court have ruled that way but they were and that line of argument is protecting a lot of facially unconstitutional law.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by webdoodle on Monday April 13, 2026 @01:45PM (#47755505)
The entire 10th amendment is basically being ignored because interstate commerce policies and rulings. For that matter, the 1st, 4th and 5th aren't being upheld either.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by nradov on Monday April 13, 2026 @01:51PM (#47755582)
Yes, regardless of that specific case I'm hoping to see a series of Supreme Court decisions that will eviscerate federal government power over internal state affairs and restore the original intent of the 10th Amendment. Long live federalism.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by threecheese on Monday April 13, 2026 @01:57PM (#47755655)
We’ve already seen states try and regulate outside their borders; TX with abortion as one example. How does a weaker federal government protect against this, or do you believe it should not? And how does this not devolve into 50 fiefdoms?
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by carefulfungi on Tuesday April 14, 2026 @08:37AM (#47764858)
It will be an interesting next decade or two on this topic. The federal government increased its power in part to coerce States to end Jim Crow, to broaden personal liberty (like with Roe v. Wade), establish a social safety net, and set minimum environmental protection standards. If we keep seeing federal power being used to compel a reduction in liberalism among the States, the sides supporting "state rights" seem likely to switch.

Adding to that, if the supreme court continues to make realistic federal administration harder by tearing down executive rule making authority and requiring more explicit Congressional rule making (which can't scale in our current system), we'll continue to see less stable and predictable federal regulatory actions - which might further compel the states to step in...

But where will States raise the taxes to make this happen? While the federal government seems willing to do less (in terms of classic liberalism policies), it certainly isn't reducing its spending.

And how will States defend themselves from federal intrusion if they do start to claim more of their power - will we see armed stand-offs between national and state forces?

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by saltyoldman on Monday April 13, 2026 @02:02PM (#47755732)
nah, 3d printed firearms next.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by bilekas on Tuesday April 14, 2026 @02:34AM (#47762014)
That's really strange.. I grow tomatoes at home. Surely that would apply too?
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by vel0city on Tuesday April 14, 2026 @10:36AM (#47766213)
Yes, it would. But there isn't currently a law limiting the amount of tomatoes one can grow especially for personal consumption. In 1938, the Agricultural Adjustment Act was passed. This law tried to control the prices of food by determining quotas for production. Filburn was allowed to grow ~11 acres of wheat. He went and grew 23 acres of wheat, setting aside the overproduction for personal consumption while taking that ~11 acres to market.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by dragonwriter on Tuesday April 14, 2026 @01:33PM (#47768621)
Gonzales v. Raich (2005) is a pretty straightforward application of the precedent of Wickard v. Filburn, 317 U.S. 111 (1942) [0] rather than a novel, out-of-the-blue new interpretation of the Constitution.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wickard_v._Filburn