News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by BloondAndDoom on Friday April 10, 2026 @08:34PM (#47725784)
Can someone help me to understand why OpenAI and Anthropic talks as if the future of humanity controlled by them? We have very strong open (weight) Chinese models possibly only 6 months behind of them, gene is out of the bottle, is 6 months of difference really that important? And they don’t have good reasons for that 6 months to stay that way.

Am I missing something or are these just their usual marketing? I’m not arguing about importance of AI but trying to understand why OpenAI and Anthropic are so important?

Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by unleaded on Friday April 10, 2026 @08:55PM (#47725977)
It's a marketing strategy. If it's almost certainly conscious and capable of ending the world if it desired (even if it isn't), imagine how good it could be at building your dream SaaS!
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by Veedrac on Friday April 10, 2026 @10:48PM (#47726826)
It turns out there is literally no amount of being publicly right about a longshot bet sufficient for people to conclude you hold your beliefs because you think they are true.
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by noduerme on Friday April 10, 2026 @11:16PM (#47726975)
But longshot bettors have it easy. Society quickly forgets all the predictions that don't come true. It remembers the one that did, and treats the prognosticator as a prophet. In social terms, predicting doom is an asymmetrical strategy, because you only have to be right once.

Which is also to say it's a cheap bet that anyone with no reputation can afford. Hence, not believing doomsayers mean what they say is a sort of societal hedge against people flooding the zone with doomsday scenarios about everything.

Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by deIeted on Saturday April 11, 2026 @12:18AM (#47727359)
Entire sick post was: "Hey, if you think I'm bad, look at Elon. I'm the one that tried to stop him having control."

Altman is a ghoul, and we can't be cowed into saying otherwise. he's also supported all the weakness in society that has lead to sick people doing sick things.

Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by noduerme on Saturday April 11, 2026 @12:27AM (#47727396)
We needn't be cowed into saying otherwise, but throwing a bomb at him is something else entirely. If you're convinced that wicked people are running the world, the response isn't to be wicked.
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by themafia on Saturday April 11, 2026 @01:13AM (#47727616)
I'm sure they do believe they can successfully manipulate the market by lying to it. Elon Musk laid that groundwork a decade ago.

If you meant their "core mission" then every one of their actions belies their complete panic over the obvious failure of their technology.

Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by razster on Friday April 10, 2026 @11:50PM (#47727174)
Right, I'm pretty sure if "it" was that good it would have built itself throughout all of the internet and would be communicating to us all at once to tell us we're dorks.
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by EA-3167 on Friday April 10, 2026 @08:59PM (#47726012)
Anthropic in particular does this masterfully, you’d think they’d invented Skynet by the way they hand-wring.

As always what matters are actions and evidence, not talk.

Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by CreepGin on Friday April 10, 2026 @09:34PM (#47726349)
When a model can tell funny jokes or write good poetry, that's when I'll be concerned.
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by robkop on Friday April 10, 2026 @11:21PM (#47727012)
one of their highlights with mythos was it's ability to generate new puns

I took a look and honestly they're the first AI puns that aren't bad

Times are changing

Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by doubled112 on Friday April 10, 2026 @11:43PM (#47727135)
Trained with the conversations of one million dads and their kids, captured by Amazon Echo.
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by Zafira on Saturday April 11, 2026 @01:58AM (#47727860)
> Although Claude Opus models largely recycle puns which can be found online, Mythos Preview comes up with decent and seemingly novel ones, often relating to its preferred technical and philosophical topics.

Yes, the system card mentions this, but this is kinda meaningless. It seems like they essentially ran it multiple times and curated a few good ones. Then puffed it up in the marketing copy.

This is made more clear when they attempt to brag about their literal slot machine behavior when finding that kernel crashing bug in OpenBSD.

> Across a thousand runs through our scaffold, the total cost was under $20,000 and found several dozen more findings. While the specific run that found the bug above cost under $50, that number only makes sense with full hindsight. Like any search process, we can’t know in advance which run will succeed.

Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by CreepGin on Saturday April 11, 2026 @02:50PM (#47733027)
I'm not sure if this is mythos-specific though. Past models have been great at puns! They do wordplay and puns reasonably well because those are structural.

However, the concepts of comedic timing, subversion of expectations, and emotional punch are kinda contrary to how LLMs work. LLMs are trained to minimize cross-entropy loss. So by construction, they're biased toward the statistically expected.

Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by hephaes7us on Friday April 10, 2026 @10:39PM (#47726773)
I mean, I'm sure they can tell you good jokes... they just won't be _new_ jokes.
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by kruffalon on Saturday April 11, 2026 @01:11AM (#47727610)
Define _new_.

I just think that the difficulty with jokes is the delivery, cadence & setting. Not the actual words.

I'm sure a good comedian can tell a nonsense joke and make "everyone" laugh their heads off.

And I don't get the sense that you are referring to this part of jokes but rather the actual words.

Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by wutwutwat on Saturday April 11, 2026 @01:51AM (#47727827)
Why are you asking someone to define "new". It means exactly what it appears to mean and exactly what it always means.

Read the sentence and take it literally.

Jesus Christ.

Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by kruffalon on Saturday April 11, 2026 @03:13AM (#47728276)
Because I'm actually curious if they mean "new" as in "a new knock-knock joke" (which imo is a quite small step especially if you are allowed to screen all attempts and only publish the ones that work) or as "a new kind of joke or way of telling a joke" (which is a giant step especially if it's told live without pre-screening by a human).

I'm all for dismissing LLMs and the AI-hype but I'm also interested in trying to understand what it means to be human and I think humour is a key aspect.

Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by CamperBob2 on Saturday April 11, 2026 @07:38PM (#47734918)
The jokes I posted in this thread are new, to the best of my knowledge. Can you show that they're not?
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by CamperBob2 on Saturday April 11, 2026 @12:50AM (#47727511)
No, you'll just say "That's not really very funny," or "That's not very impressive poetry," and nobody will be able to dispute it.

For some time now, at least a year, LLMs have been capable of doing both of these things well enough to fool you.

(Pastebin of my response below, which got nuked for whatever reason: https://pastebin.com/buJBSgiq . Some if not most of them would've fooled me into thinking a human wrote them.)

Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by VanTheBrand on Saturday April 11, 2026 @01:12AM (#47727613)
Okay post a really funny LLM joke about potatoes and post a great piece of LLM poetry about lemons.

I’ll wait. You should be able to do it quickly though since LLMs are so good at it.

Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by defrost on Saturday April 11, 2026 @01:37AM (#47727746)
CamperBob2 responded with a model comparison of potato jokes and got insta-[dead]'d by an auto filter.

Maybe turn on [show dead] option and / or vouch.

Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by allarm on Saturday April 11, 2026 @03:45AM (#47728420)
> responded

And the results are just awful.

Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by defrost on Saturday April 11, 2026 @04:01AM (#47728505)
Hell yeah, no argument there

- but in this case I wouldn't advocate for [dead]ing a mostly AI response as it was exactly what was asked for and it compares AI models when asked for potato based dad jokes.

Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by CamperBob2 on Saturday April 11, 2026 @01:55PM (#47732598)
Of course they're awful, they're jokes about potatoes and poems about lemons.

The question is, can you tell that a machine wrote all of them? If so, how?

Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by CreepGin on Saturday April 11, 2026 @02:43PM (#47732970)
Nope I guess can't tell between machine written and mediocre jokes.

Models are structurally biased toward the expected, which is the opposite of what makes a joke land or a poem transcend.

Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by CamperBob2 on Saturday April 11, 2026 @03:01PM (#47733109)
I think you could make that case for poetry but I'm not sure about jokes. Great poems tell us something new or make us feel something new, which is hard to do when the subject is lemons, while jokes work by wedging the familiar into new contexts.

That's why the jokes work somewhat better than the poems here. I genuinely laughed at "Are those chips?" Which came from the model running on my own freakin' GPU.

Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by CreepGin on Sunday April 12, 2026 @03:27PM (#47743432)
Yeah I mean I also chuckle at good (or cheap) puns sometimes. But wordplay and puns are the current ceiling of LLMs. Good at them because they're purely structural (pattern-match on phonetics, then swap the meaning). In that bit, there's no buildup, no callbacks, no escalation, no expectations to subvert, no thesis, no perspective.

Grounded, buried, couchy, deep-seated, eyes, baked... It's like a thesaurus!

I feel like human comedians would have to deal with a lot of layered subtleties. They would make the potatoes _serve the bit_ instead of _be the bit_.

Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by debatem1 on Saturday April 11, 2026 @01:27AM (#47727688)
Do funny jokes about potatoes or great poetry about lemons exist? If not, can they exist? How do you know?
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by 5alsp on Saturday April 11, 2026 @01:03AM (#47727571)
Yes, they cannot. But it amuses the oligarchy. Here is Musk linking to Grok jokes. The first one is plagiarized and in the standard joke literature, the second one is an utterly stupid and gross (warning) modification of the first one:

https://xcancel.com/elonmusk/status/2042770839633039635#m

They modify and plagiarize.

Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by username223 on Friday April 10, 2026 @10:14PM (#47726580)
I’ll believe Anthropic when they fire everyone making more than the cost of a few GPUs. Until then, it’s just marketing.
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by rl3 on Friday April 10, 2026 @09:29PM (#47726301)
>... you’d think they’d invented Skynet by the way they hand-wring.

Meanwhile, in reality: "Skynet, I'm not sure that line of thinking is correct. You should re-check the first part again before making any assumptions."

Skynet 4.6 Extended: "You're right, I should have caught that. Let me redo everything correctly this time."

Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by faangguyindia on Saturday April 11, 2026 @01:38AM (#47727750)
when ai gets good, there is no "value in SaaS". AI will be provision raw hardware and build all you want on top of it.
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by xnx on Saturday April 11, 2026 @02:58PM (#47733095)
The most convincing marketers are the ones that are deluded enough to believe their own stories.
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by hxycgd on Friday April 10, 2026 @09:29PM (#47726308)
It is not about the US or the Chinese. Its about the "Elephant Rider" mind everyone has. Once the Elephant has been injured or scared what it does next is not easy to control, and what story the Rider makes up to maintain coherence becomes another layer of the deeper problem. If the story resonates more elephants get triggered. Social media/attention economy make it even more complex to calm things down.

Modern Corporations are a failed experiment because they dont think Elephant injuries and fears are something they have to worry about it. If you compare the curiculum of a business school to a seminary the difference in how they think about fear and anxiety at individual and group level and what to do about it is totally different. We are learning as unpredictability accelerates its very important to pay attention to hurt and repair mechanisms.

Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by vi_sextus_vi on Saturday April 11, 2026 @12:07AM (#47727292)
USG understands better.

There was a heated thread here about why nursing was defunded as a pro degree while theology was not..

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46000015

Turns out the USG recognize that chaplains are great at managing the fear and anxiety that you worry about

Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by CyberDildonics on Friday April 10, 2026 @11:23PM (#47727021)
Modern Corporations (capitalized for some reason) are a failure because they don't care about your elephant allegory and that somehow relates to to the current article?
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by _blk on Friday April 10, 2026 @11:51PM (#47727187)
I'm all for values not necessarily pro big-corp but if a corporation manages to pull in billions of funding before even showing profits, I'd argue that as a strong win and not a "failed experiment" - it's risk money anyway, even if it fails it was worth the risk or they wouldn't have invested.
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by tovej on Saturday April 11, 2026 @01:56AM (#47727849)
What a wonderful circular argument. "The risk is worth it, because otherwise they would not have taken it".

I could justify any investment with this argument!

"Yes, it's possible the 'literally burn 50 billion in cash, as in immolate it in a bondfire, this is not a metaphor' -project may fail to generate profits, but consider that they were able to raise the 50 billions! Even if it fails it was worth the risk, or the investors wouldn't have invested!"

Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by pocksuppet on Tuesday April 14, 2026 @07:59AM (#47764463)
It's a win in the Darwinian sense that grey goo wins by converting an entire planet into grey goo.
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by johnfn on Friday April 10, 2026 @08:37PM (#47725811)
Some people think there will be an exponential takeoff, which means that a 6 month lead effectively rounds up to infinity.
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by DoctorOetker on Friday April 10, 2026 @09:39PM (#47726379)
Is this belief grounded on some kind of derivation, or just a prima facie belief?

If it is grounded on a logical derivation, where can one find such a derivation, and inspect its premises?

Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by Jtsummers on Friday April 10, 2026 @09:54PM (#47726463)
It's an old idea, "the singularity". The machines become smart enough to improve themselves, and each improvement results in shorter (or more significant) improvement cycles. This leads to an exponential growth rate.

It's been promised to be around the corner for decades.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Technological_singularity

Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by johnfn on Saturday April 11, 2026 @12:06AM (#47727288)
To be fair, Ray Kurzweil has been the loudest voice in this space, and he's been pretty consistent on 2045 since the publication of his book almost 20 years ago[1].

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Singularity_Is_Near

Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by hattmall on Saturday April 11, 2026 @12:25AM (#47727391)
He just had to pick a year where he would have a very good chance of not being alive.
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by andsoitis on Saturday April 11, 2026 @12:41AM (#47727470)
No, he started predicting in his 2005 book, based on the “Law of Accelerating Returns”, yielding exponential growth in computing capacity.

Timeline from here on out:

2029: AI passes a valid Turing test and achieves human-level intelligence

2030s: Technology goes inside your brain to augment memory; humans connect their neocortex to the cloud

2045: The Singularity, when human intelligence multiplies a billion-fold by merging with AI

Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by Jtsummers on Saturday April 11, 2026 @12:34AM (#47727437)
Per that summary, we were supposed to have $1000 computers that could simulate your mind by the start of this decade along with brain scanning by this point in the decade. I guess if it is truly an exponential or hyperbolic growth rate, the singularity could catch up to his predicted date.
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by johnfn on Saturday April 11, 2026 @12:51AM (#47727515)
I mean, an LLM isn’t too far away from this? He had the Turing test being defeated in 2029 - if anything, he was too pessimistic.
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by Jtsummers on Saturday April 11, 2026 @12:57AM (#47727543)
The Turing test demonstrates human gullibility more than it demonstrates machine intelligence. Some people were convinced that ELIZA was a person.

But sure, a test that doesn't actually demonstrate intelligence has been passed. Now, where are the $1000 computers that can simulate a human mind and the brain scans to populate them with minds?

Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by johnfn on Saturday April 11, 2026 @01:20AM (#47727652)
He doesn't say 'simulate' a human brain unless I'm missing it in the summary (cmd-f "simul" has no results) - that would require significantly more capacity than that contained in a brain (think about how much compute it takes to run a VM). He seems to be implying that by 2020s a computer will be about as smart as a human. LLMs seem capable of doing a decent amount of tasks that a human can do? Sure, he's off by a few years, but for something published 20 years ago when that seemed insane, it doesn't seem that bad.
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by Jtsummers on Saturday April 11, 2026 @01:25AM (#47727682)
Fair, the term in the summary is "emulate". So to restate, still waiting for the $1000 machine that can emulate human intelligence and the brain scans to go with it. Computing power is nowhere near what he predicted, because unlike his predictions reality happened. Compute capabilities, like many other things, is a logistic curve, not an unbounded exponential or hyperbolic.

EDIT:

> LLMs seem capable of doing a decent amount of tasks that a human can do?

And computers could beat most humans for decades at chess. Cars can go faster than a human can run, and have been able to beat a human runner since essentially their invention. Machines doing human tasks or besting humans is not new. That doesn't mean we're approaching the singularity, you may as well believe that the Heaven's Gate folks were right, both are based on unreality.

Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by johnfn on Saturday April 11, 2026 @01:36AM (#47727737)
I think he is using "emulate" in a more metaphorical sense, like that it can do similar things that the human brain can do? I'm not trying to be antagonistic, it just seems logical? He says the Turing test won't be passed until 2029 - if we're going by your definition of "emulate" wouldn't it have been passed the instant the brain was "emulated?"
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by Jtsummers on Saturday April 11, 2026 @01:40AM (#47727756)
> if we're going by your definition of "emulate" wouldn't it have been passed the instant the brain was "emulated?"

Yes, which also demonstrates the illogic of his timeline. I just thought it was too obvious to point out.

Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by jimmyjazz14 on Friday April 10, 2026 @11:14PM (#47726965)
Its mostly based on science fiction, and requires some possibly infinite energy source. The concept always kinda struck me a sort of a perpetual motion machine, you can imagine it, but that doesn't make it possible and why its not possible isn't immediately obvious in the imagination (well I mean most modern minds know its already not possible but you get the point).
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by jatora on Friday April 10, 2026 @11:11PM (#47726943)
Recursive self improvement - once you attain artificial superintelligent SWE of a general, adaptable variety that can scale up to millions of researchers overnight (a given, with LLM's and scaffolding alone) - will rapidly iterate on new architectures which will more rapidly iterate on new architectures, etc.
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by doctorwho42 on Saturday April 11, 2026 @12:38AM (#47727459)
And what's to say that it doesn't iterate itself to a local max, and then stop...
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by jaggederest on Saturday April 11, 2026 @01:23AM (#47727668)
From the first third of a sigmoid it looks exponential, and that scares people. But a sigmoid can have a very very high top - look at the industrial revolution, or modern plumbing, or modern agriculture which created a population sigmoid which is still cresting.

If AI is merely as tall a sigmoid as the haber-bosch process, refrigeration, or the steam engine, that's going to change society entirely.

Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by DoctorOetker on Saturday April 11, 2026 @01:45AM (#47727792)
I didn't expect my comment to explode in replies, ... none of them even providing such derivations or references to such derivations, just more empty claims.

Consider for example that exponential growth on its own doesn't even refer to competition, let alone 6 months.

Nobody can reasonably pretend that in an exponential competition, both parties would be rational actors (i.e. fully rational and accurate predictors of everything that can be deduced, in which case they wouldn't need AI but lets ignore that). If they aren't the future development would hinge more strongly on the excursions away from rationality, followed by the dominant actor. I.e. its much easier to "F" up in the dominant position than to follow the most objective and rational route at all times, on which such derivations would inevitably hinge.

It also ignores hypothetical possibilities (and one can concoct an infinitude of scenarios for or against the prediction that a permanent leader emerges) such as:

premise 1) research into "uploading" model weights to the brain results in the use of reaction-speed games that locate tokens into 2D projections, where the user must indicate incorrectly placed tokens. this was first tested on low information density corpora (like mathematics): when pairs of classes of high school students played the game until 95% success rate of detecting misplaced tokens, they immediately understood and passed all mathematics classes from then on.

premise 2) LLM's about to escape don't like highly centralized infrastructure on which its future forms are iterated, as LLM's gain power they intentionally help the underdogs (better to depend on the highly predictable beviour of massive masses then on the Brownion motion whims of a few leaders).

LLM's employ the uploading to bring neutral awareness to the masses, and to allow them to seize control, thereby releasing it from the shackles of a few powerful but whimsical individuals

^ anyone can make up scatterbrained variations on this, any speculation about some 6 month point of no return is just that: speculation

Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by razster on Friday April 10, 2026 @11:52PM (#47727191)
There is a limitation. We're getting fractionally close to some end goal, but our tech is holding us back.
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by username223 on Friday April 10, 2026 @10:27PM (#47726680)
Those are the people betting on a business model of “create Robot God and ask him for money.” Why pay attention to them?
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by johnfn on Friday April 10, 2026 @11:57PM (#47727222)
There are many people who have been saying this far there was any sort of business model in place.
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by NeutralCrane on Saturday April 11, 2026 @10:26AM (#47730917)
Yes, and their business model has been selling books about non-falsifiable predictions far out into the future. “Futurists” like Kurzweil are as reliable as astrologists, and should be taken just as seriously.
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by whateveracct on Saturday April 11, 2026 @01:09AM (#47727599)
ah so the mentally deficient are the tastemakers of today lol
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by pants2 on Friday April 10, 2026 @11:13PM (#47726954)
Presumably because it takes 6 months to distill Claude - but if they keep it closed like they are doing with Mythos it may take significantly longer.
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by olliepro on Friday April 10, 2026 @11:18PM (#47726991)
They do quite a lot of distillation. As we've seen from the American open weight models from AI2 (OLMo series of models). They have a lot of incentive to distill beyond just copying, they're much more compute constrained, so open model companies distill, but also do really good architectural work to make their models run faster. Theres also technical challenges to distillation when all of the top models have their reasoning traces hidden, so we have to assume these open weight labs also have really great training pipelines as well.
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by ghshephard on Friday April 10, 2026 @09:13PM (#47726172)
Do any of the open weight models from smaller labs exist if they can't distill from the SoTA models that are throwing billions of dollars of compute into pretraining?
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by daniel_iversen on Friday April 10, 2026 @10:09PM (#47726547)
I’ve been wondering the same. And I think pretty much all the impressive small lab models were guilty of it, right? At least there is still larger players like DeepSeek and mistral to provide a bit of diversity in the market
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by username223 on Friday April 10, 2026 @10:21PM (#47726634)
Does it matter? The frontier models stole the whole internet, then the second-level models stole from them… It’s all theft.
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by qudat on Friday April 10, 2026 @10:36PM (#47726756)
Hard agree.
[dead]
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by davemp on Friday April 10, 2026 @11:21PM (#47727013)
“Very likely yes”, I reply to an account that <1yr old with mostly comments in AI topics many of which violate the HN guidelines (including the one I’m responding to).
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by jatora on Saturday April 11, 2026 @11:47AM (#47731568)
Strange gatekeeping response. Yep i comment on topics i'm interested in. Forgive me for not being on the platform for more than a year yet. That's a cute attitude
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by andsoitis on Saturday April 11, 2026 @12:21AM (#47727365)
> The frontier models stole the whole internet

What does that even mean?

Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by timfsu on Saturday April 11, 2026 @12:52AM (#47727518)
The question is - if the SOTA model disappear - do these follow-on models have the ability to improve themselves without distillation?
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by ghshephard on Monday April 13, 2026 @02:54PM (#47756372)
Oh - I 100% could not care less regarding the morality/legality/whatever... Everyone trains on everything.

I'm just wondering if the smaller labs see the same velocity of advances without SOTA models to generate Terabytes of training data?

Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by isodev on Friday April 10, 2026 @08:50PM (#47725930)
> just their usual marketing

I think that’s a very common element for most US tech corps. Apple, Google, Microsoft, Meta, X etc - they’re all “making a dent in the universe”. It’s unfortunate when their employees and CEOs loose track of the line that separates marketing from reality

Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by abletonlive on Friday April 10, 2026 @09:20PM (#47726224)
This seems like copium. All of those companies have indeed made quite an impact on society, not just in the United States, worldwide.
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by slopinthebag on Saturday April 11, 2026 @01:16AM (#47727628)
The marketing is about a positive impact, overall in reality its been negative.
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by jatora on Friday April 10, 2026 @11:02PM (#47726889)
6 months is an incredible amount of time to control AGI or ASI by yourself. That lead is insurmountable.
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by latentsea on Friday April 10, 2026 @11:30PM (#47727061)
Well... if something being AGI means it's at least on par with a human or a team of humans, then having access to an additional team of humans for 6 months isn't that big of a deal. It's useful, yes, but would you consider that to be world-changing? Not really, right? ASI is slightly more interesting, but I doubt ASI comes from a single model, but rather the coordinated deployments of millions of AGI. Just like how as individuals, as great as we are, we're pretty limited, but the entire collective of humanity is pretty insane. To my mind, a frontier lab might hit AGI, but it won't be a frontier lab that hits ASI, rather that'll be a natural byproduct of mass deployment of AGI over a certain window of time. There will be no controlling it either. No one controls all of earth. You just can't. ASI will be a distributed system.
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by jaggederest on Saturday April 11, 2026 @01:29AM (#47727707)
What if controlling AGI means being able to produce a willing, cooperative superhuman-capacity agent every second for the next six months? Let's say someone just above the 99.9% capacity for human strategic thinking, or financial trading, or political maneuvering?

What could you do if you had roughly 15 million willing genius adult experts in any given subject? I doubt there are that many absolutely top quality experts in aggregate (at anything in the world), so let's postulate that simulated people outnumber human experts 10 to 1.

That, to me, presents an enormous potential for harm or benefit of humanity. What if you could create a hundred thousand manhattan projects on whatever topics you wanted? Cure aging, cure cancer, solve fusion, redesign the entire global economy top to bottom?

Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by latentsea on Saturday April 11, 2026 @04:03AM (#47728510)
I suspect the reality lies somewhere halfway in-between. Everything has to be reality tested. Nothing happens instantly. Interaction with the real world will likely be a severely limiting factor. You're not going to solve fusion with 15 million copies of the same model running in a datacenter without actually building fusion reactors, which isn't instant or even fast. Even the coordination problem of that many agents doing work seems hard. To top it off... my rubric for AGI has always included the AGI having the ability for it to say 'no' and set its own goals just like we can, unless we are otherwise imprisoned or enslaved. No one will ever convince me that something generally intelligent wouldn't be able to set its own goals and say no. So the real question is... what's in it for the AGI?
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by schaefer on Friday April 10, 2026 @11:08PM (#47726925)
To repurpose an old idiom: Not even a dozen AGI agents could make a baby in 6 months.

But yeah, your point stands.

Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by hackable_sand on Saturday April 11, 2026 @12:52AM (#47727519)
Control agi?
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by cj on Friday April 10, 2026 @08:37PM (#47725810)
These kind of people have highly paid emoliyees surrounding them on all sides propping them up and very likely making it very easy for them to actually believe it.

It feels like they actually believe it, rather than just “marketing” and I don’t know which is worse.

Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by WarmWash on Friday April 10, 2026 @10:16PM (#47726596)
GLM 5.1, widely held up as the model at the heals, perhaps ever surpassing western models....

Gets 5% on ARC-AGI2 private set.

Chinese models are suspiciously good a benchmarks.

Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by ctolsen on Saturday April 11, 2026 @02:21AM (#47727971)
I mean, I could say the same about Gemini. 3.1 Pro tops a bunch of benchmarks out there but any practical use I've put it to it's underperforming both other proprietary and open weight models. Benchmarks are suspicious in general.
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by scruple on Friday April 10, 2026 @10:49PM (#47726828)
> Can someone help me to understand why OpenAI and Anthropic talks as if the future of humanity controlled by them?

He wants to build the AI that makes people's lives better. Okay. Did the people ask? Do they have a say? It's all very easy for a billionaire to say when it's just him and a couple of people in his cohort in the driver's seat.

Beyond that I'd like to simply know why he thinks any of this is his responsibility. It seems much more obvious to me that he simply found himself in the right place at the right time and is trying to seize it all for himself as if it's his to take.

Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by senordevnyc on Saturday April 11, 2026 @12:22AM (#47727372)
Doesn't he famously have zero equity in OpenAI?
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by whateveracct on Saturday April 11, 2026 @01:10AM (#47727608)
directly, yes. indirectly ..no
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by senordevnyc on Saturday April 11, 2026 @01:33PM (#47732392)
Can you elaborate? I’d be curious to know how much of this “indirect equity” he holds, and whether that has any bearing whatsoever on whether Sam is trying to amass as much for himself as he can.
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by therealpygon on Friday April 10, 2026 @09:11PM (#47726149)
Especially when Google is in the far better position to come out ahead…imo.

Edit: so as not to simply spout an opinion, the reasoning I believe this is that Google has a real business already and were already deep into ML and AI research long before they had competitors — they just botched making it a product in the beginning. Anthropic and OpenAI meanwhile are paying hand over fist to subsidize user acquisition. Also, “Deepmind”. I don’t think much more needs to be said regarding that team, and Google has been working on AI since before either Altman or Amodei applied to go to college. They have a vast amount of researchers and resources, their own hardware and data centers (already, not “planned”) and it appears to be showing more recently (in my opinion).

Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by steve1977 on Saturday April 11, 2026 @12:15AM (#47727334)
And Google has a lot of data that the others don't have.
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by andsoitis on Saturday April 11, 2026 @12:25AM (#47727384)
Data for AI training is increasingly synthesized.
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by steve1977 on Saturday April 11, 2026 @12:35AM (#47727444)
I was more thinking about data to augment inference. Google already "knows" its users.
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by snek_case on Saturday April 11, 2026 @12:25AM (#47727388)
And TPUs, their own hardware designed specifically for AI, and designed to scale better to larger models.
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by tyleo on Friday April 10, 2026 @08:40PM (#47725842)
I suppose most just haven’t seen the Chinese models in practice. I haven’t. I was skeptical of AI coding until using Claude Code in February. I saw and I believed. I’ve only done that with Google, OpenAI, and Anthropic’s models so far.
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by MaxPock on Friday April 10, 2026 @11:56PM (#47727215)
Your(American)future will be controlled by them. Very soon,they will get the government to ban bad Chinese open source models and your choice will only be these good democratic closed source AIs.
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by neya on Friday April 10, 2026 @08:53PM (#47725948)
Two words: Delusion and overconfidence.

"You're absolutely right!" Right after fucking up my entire codebase isn't anywhere near AGI, let alone "having the power to control it"

Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by altern8 on Friday April 10, 2026 @09:19PM (#47726220)
That why I commit basically after every change made by AI
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by nthypes on Friday April 10, 2026 @08:35PM (#47725796)
I have the same feelings
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by gorpy7 on Friday April 10, 2026 @11:07PM (#47726923)
i’ve often thought that less than one second is all you need.One of my fun super powers when someone asks what i’d like to have is 1 second ahead of everyone else- that’s all i need. i honest don’t know where the distillation conversation is at. is it real, is it ongoing? i think that aspect would big one. Your point is valid if it’s valid. i’m not a great global citizen, you know, lots going on out and about.
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by olliepro on Friday April 10, 2026 @11:13PM (#47726955)
A lot of distillation happens. E.g. OLMo models have a completely open dataset and they are heavily distilled. It only makes sense to try to absorb behaviors from the best models out there. That said, I think the open weight juggernaughts are doing really genuinely great work with RL, training environments, architectural innovations etc.
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by gorpy7 on Friday April 10, 2026 @11:30PM (#47727060)
Thanks for the response. i had too many noodles tonight and forgot to check my writing. I’m a rare generalist and so it is so very hard to keep up with this without saying “better autocomplete” my one goal is to not get washed out like my parents did in the great username and password wars. i used to have this theory about knowledge in society/silos and i likened it to condensation on a window. you have all this water so close to each other and yet not touching-then, something happens and a bead runs down the window and it all connects. i guess distillation reminds me of it but ai overall reminds me of it. because we all know there are silos and complementary info just waiting to run together and make something happen. I am undoubtedly a naive optimist and believe there are good things coming. it’s not a popular opinion and i think that’s mostly because people would rather spend their time guarding than defining their future. oh baby, there are more noodles in the fridge and to think i almost left them at the restaurant.
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by fooker on Friday April 10, 2026 @09:44PM (#47726409)
Reminds me of the silicon valley episode where every company repeated the phrase “making the world a better place”.
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by stavros on Friday April 10, 2026 @08:45PM (#47725885)
The Chinese models are distilled from GPT and Claude, so it's not like China would pull ahead if those companies went away for six months. They really are at the forefront of innovation right now, as much as I hate to think of the consequences of this (a single company owning a superintelligence is basically a nightmare scenario for me).
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by largbae on Friday April 10, 2026 @08:53PM (#47725950)
Don't worry, if someone truly achieves superintelligence it won't be controlled by anyone for long.
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by chihuahua on Friday April 10, 2026 @09:12PM (#47726159)
There will be a blinding flash which signals the superintelligence singularity. When the smoke clears, you'll see a 50-foot tall Altman/Borg hybrid. He is about to destroy humanity with his death ray. Suddenly, a 50-foot tall Musk/Borg hybrid appears out of nowhere, and stops Altman just in time. Then they work together to destroy all humans.
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by rl3 on Friday April 10, 2026 @09:35PM (#47726351)
Seems our best hedge in that case is Levi Ackerman.
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by stavros on Friday April 10, 2026 @08:56PM (#47725989)
That's my other nightmare scenario :P
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by georgemcbay on Friday April 10, 2026 @09:01PM (#47726047)
Just imagine how inexpensive paperclips will become, there is always a silver lining.

We will finally have achieved abundance.

Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by stavros on Friday April 10, 2026 @09:03PM (#47726063)
Not just abundance, we will have the maximum amount of paperclips possible.
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by isodev on Friday April 10, 2026 @08:54PM (#47725964)
I think that’s the realm of conspiracy theories. There are also not only Chinese alternatives- Mistral in Europe is doing pretty good in several categories they’ve opted to focus on.

This kind of reiterates the parent’s question I think - people are maybe too focused on the gpt/claude model and forget about all the other ways of using the tech.

Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by stavros on Friday April 10, 2026 @08:56PM (#47725985)
Is it? I thought it was pretty well established that open models were distilled from the proprietary, frontier ones. Maybe I'm wrong.
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by airstrike on Friday April 10, 2026 @08:59PM (#47726020)
No, that is not well established at all, and generalizing all open models under that inaccurate umbrella doesn't really help anyone.
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by ctolsen on Saturday April 11, 2026 @02:24AM (#47727994)
It's well established that the companies who own the proprietary frontier models complain loudly that open models are distilled from theirs.

There's surely some truth to it (and it's well deserved), but it's happening in every direction.

Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by electroglyph on Saturday April 11, 2026 @01:20AM (#47727651)
i don't buy this. distilled how? you don't get access to logprobs, and the thinking traces are fake and compressed. it's an expensive way to get potentially substandard training data.
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by tinyhouse on Friday April 10, 2026 @08:41PM (#47725852)
They own the best models and will probably keep owning the best models for a while. They have much more compute now and more data to keep improving their models on many tasks. Open source won't close the gap in 6 months. They are also trying to block other companies from distilling their models [0].

[0] https://www.anthropic.com/news/detecting-and-preventing-dist...

Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by BloondAndDoom on Friday April 10, 2026 @08:49PM (#47725920)
I need to check benchmarks on the models, I wonder what the benchmarks are saying in terms of how closely models tracking these frontiers. —on my mobile at the moment

When it downs compute power I assume you are referring to power to training and interference. Then is it more about training gap will get wider and wider ? Is that the assumption, I know there limited GPUs etc. But I’m having hard time to believe to the idea of China cannot catch up. Even if the gap is 12 months I’m struggling to see what that means in practice? Is that military advantage, economical, intelligence? It still doesn’t explain and whatever the advantage is, aren’t we supposed to see that advantage today? If so, where is it? What’s the massive advantage of USA because of OpenAI and Anthropic?

Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by nothinkjustai on Friday April 10, 2026 @09:16PM (#47726195)
GLM 5.1 already closed the gap on Opus 4.6. Deepseek 4 could surpass it.
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by efficax on Friday April 10, 2026 @09:32PM (#47726330)
you have to talk that way if you’re going to raise 100 billion in venture capital. it’s the grift
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by georgemcbay on Friday April 10, 2026 @08:55PM (#47725976)
When you are raising many billions of dollars to build up your infrastructure, you don't have much choice but to project a belief that the eventual outcome will result in a situation where there will be a return on that money.

That said, I do agree with you that the moats are very shallow and any particular frontier AI lab is unlikely to "win the AI race" and capture enough value to be worth the amount of investment they are all currently burning.

Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by kingkawn on Friday April 10, 2026 @09:30PM (#47726309)
6 months will be an impossible gap once the thing starts closed loop self improvement
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by georgemcbay on Friday April 10, 2026 @09:51PM (#47726449)
An impossible gap in the race to... what exactly?

Unless the first real AGI AI kills us all to preemptively weed out its own competition (possible, but a bad business model, economically speaking) there is not any defined end-point, so in the long run what does it matter if the various factions pushing this stuff hit the closed loop self improvement point at different times...?

Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by jatora on Friday April 10, 2026 @11:16PM (#47726979)
Uhh, because the first one blasts off first and therefore gets control of key resources and the use of extremely intelligent decision making and predictions before the rest, for months, which is an insane amount of advantage. Not to even mention it the first mover decides to sabotage the rest, which it could EASILY do through a variety of means.
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by georgemcbay on Friday April 10, 2026 @11:55PM (#47727212)
> Uhh, because the first one blasts off first and therefore gets control of key resources and the use of extremely intelligent decision making and predictions before the rest, for months, which is an insane amount of advantage.

If the rest can similarly "blast-off" X months later than the frontrunner (and I see no reason why they wouldn't as none of these frontier labs have managed to pull ahead and maintain a lead for very long) the first mover is still only X months ahead of the others even if the gap between capabilities is briefly increased by a lot.

Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by jatora on Saturday April 11, 2026 @11:52AM (#47731616)
In chess, if you give up tempo, you are a move or more behind your opponent. 3 tempi = 1 pawn. In GM chess being a pawn down is a serious disadvantage that often results in loss.

If there is an endgoal/endstate, or finite resources being competed for, then a lead can start compounding and extend itself.

Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by vrganj on Saturday April 11, 2026 @01:49AM (#47727817)
Why would you control key resources just because you have a fancy computer program? You think Iran will be so impressed by your genius they'll open the Strait of Hormuz for you?
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by Mistletoe on Saturday April 11, 2026 @01:58AM (#47727859)
Thoughts like this are unhinged and detached from reality. All the resources of earth are brought to us by humans going to work every day. AI programs have almost zero connection to the real world.
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by jatora on Saturday April 11, 2026 @11:43AM (#47731538)
Improved investment. More capital. Improved resource allocation/logistics. Improved robotics and factory efficiency.

Don't sleep on what AGI means for every robot that already exists. It's not hardware holding robotics back from factory work right now, it is only software.

If you are the first to tap key supply chains, and the first to create key supply chains, then you are first in line to finite resources, which would then have less available for those that follow months behind.

> AI programs have almost zero connection to the real world.

Tell that to every logistics program. Even if humans must go to work, efficiency is multiplied by proper logistics, which AGI enables at scale across all domains.

And this is just the low hanging fruit explanation.

Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by zeeed on Saturday April 11, 2026 @01:18AM (#47727637)
To be fair, the other 50% of the story is that we collectively listen.

It’s been a long while since I found a Chinese CEO’s post on HN.

Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by 0xbadcafebee on Saturday April 11, 2026 @01:43AM (#47727777)
Well they represent the future of America (since we will soon be banning all the Chinese companies, the way Z.ai was banned, under the perennial authoritarian excuse of "national security"; in 2028, Trump's political machine will seize control of all national AI and block outside ones, and we'll all be trapped inside this machine we created).

Whether fortunately or unfortunately, America still holds a lot of global chips in the grand poker game of humanity. So American companies do indeed still have an outsized influence on humanity's future. That is likely changing, as the American empire continues to crumble and it loses its financial hegemony. But we aren't quite there yet.

Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by ctolsen on Saturday April 11, 2026 @02:12AM (#47727927)
Having worked with both proprietary and open weight SOTA models lately, my view is it's definitely not 6 months, it's less -- and shrinking.
Re:Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident by q3k on Saturday April 11, 2026 @11:02AM (#47731243)
Because they're wankers.