Agree it will become a battleground though, because the ability for people to use the internet as a tool (in fact, their tool’s tool) will absolutely shift the paradigm, undesirably for most of the Internet, I think.
We got hit from human verifiers manually war dailing us, this is with account creation, email verify and captcha. I can only imagine how much worse it'll be for us (and Twilio) to do these verifications.
so charge for access. If the value the site provides is high, surely these mobs will pay for it! It will also remove the mis-incentives of advertising driven revenues, which has been the ill of the internet (despite it being the primary revenue source).
And if a bot misbehaves by consuming inordinate amounts of resources, rate limiting them with increasing timeouts or limits.
We put a captcha there, because without it, bots submit thousands of spam contact us forms.
Just my 2 cents, obviously lawmakers and jurisdiction may see these issues differently.
I suppose there will be a need for reliable human verification soon, though, and unfortunately I can't see any feasible technical solution that doesn't involve a hardware device. However, a purely legal solution might work well enough, too.
Well, spam is not a technical problem either. It's a social problem and one day in a distant future society will go after spammers and other bad actors and the problem will be mostly gone.
as for a solution its the same for any automated thing u dont want. (bots / scrapers). you can implement some measures but are unlikely to 'defeat' the problem entirely.
as a server operator you can try to distinguish stuff and the users will just find ways around your detection of if its an automation or not.
Human identity verification is the ultimate captcha, and the only one AGI can never beat.
This is both inevitable already, and not a problem.
No trouble at all. Barely an inconvenience.
I would maybe go in the direction to say that the wording “I’m not a robot” has fallen out of time.
The entire distinction here is that as a website operator you wish to serve me ads. Otherwise, an agent under my control, or my personal use of your website, should make no difference to you.
I do hope this eventually leads to per-visit micropayments as an alternative to ads.
Cloudflare, Google, and friends are in unique position to do this.
While this is sometimes the case, it’s not always so.
For example Fediverse nodes and self-hosted sites frequently block crawlers. This isn’t due to ads, rather because it costs real money to serve the site and crawlers are often considered parasitic.
Another example would be where a commerce site doesn’t want competitors bulk-scraping their catalog.
In all these cases you can for sure make reasonable “information wants to be free” arguments as to why these hopes can’t be realized, but do be clear that it’s a separate argument from ad revenue.
I think it’s interesting to split revenue into marginal distribution/serving costs, and up-front content creation costs. The former can easily be federated in an API-centric model, but figuring out how to compensate content creators is much harder; it’s an unsolved problem currently, and this will only get harder as training on content becomes more valuable (yet still fair use).
I find ads so aesthetically irksome that I have lost out on a lot of money across the past few decades by never placing any ads on any site or web app I've released, simply because I'd find it hypocritical to expose others to something I try so hard to avoid ever seeing and because I want to provide the best and most visually appealing possible experience to users.
It’s kind of funny to remember that complaining about the “signal to noise ratio” in a comment section use to be a sort of nerd catchphrase thing.
Was this a bad thing though? Just because today's is bigger, doesn't make it better. There are so many things out there doing the same thing just run by different people. The amount of unique stuff does not match the bigger. Would love to see something like $(unique($internet) | wc -l)
Hard for me to see how it’s ethical to force your customers to do tons of menial data entry when the orders are sitting right there in json.
There are some very real and obvious downsides to this approach, of course. Primarily, the risk of privacy and anonymity. That said, I feel like the average person doesn't seem to care about those traits in the social media era.
That, to me, seems like it could be the foundation of a new web. Something like:
* User-agent sends request for such-and-such a URL.
* Server says "okay, that'll be 5 tokens for our computational resources please".
* User decides, either automatically or not, whether to pay the 5 tokens. If they do, they submit a request with the tokens attached.
* Server responds.
People have been trying to get this sort of thing to work for years, but there's never been an incentive to make such a fundamental change to the way the internet operates. Maybe we're approaching the point where there is one.
The problem is Sam Altman saw this coming a long time ago and is an investor (co-owner?) of this project.
I believe we will see a world where things are a lot more agentic and where applicable, a human will need to be verified for certain operations.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Estonian_identity_card
Cloudflare deployed the "hand out tokens to anonymously pass captchas" to throw Tor users a bone.
I want to able to automate mundane tasks but I should still be confirming everything my bot does and be liable for its actions.
IMO it's not worth solving anyways. Why do sites have CAPTCHA?
- To prevent spam, use rate limiting, proof-of-work, or micropayments. To prevent fake accounts, use identity.
- To get ad revenue, use micropayments (web ads are already circumvented by uBlock and co).
- To prevent cheating in games, use skill-based matchmaking or friend-group-only matchmaking (e.g. only match with friends, friends of friends, etc. assuming people don't friend cheaters), and make eSport players record themselves during competition if they're not in-person.
What other reasons are there? (I'm genuinely interested and it may reveal upcoming problems -> opportunities for new software.)
I think you may think passing the Turing test is more difficult and meaningful than it is. Computers have been able to pass the Turing test for longer than genAI has been around. Even Turing thought it wasn't a useful test in reality. He meant it as a thought experiment.
It would be a bit more difficult if you were dealing with an LLM agent tasked with faking a turing test as opposed to a naieve LLM just responding as usual, but even there the LLM will reveal itself by the things that it plain can't do.
The intent (it was just a thought experiment) of a Turing test, was that if you can't tell it's not AGI, then it is AGI, which is semi-reasonable, as long as it's not the village idiot administering the test! It was never intended to be "if it can fool some people, some of the time, then it's AGI".
Obviously as time goes on, and chatbots/AI progress then it'll become harder and harder to distinguish. Eventually we'll have AGI and AGI+ - capable of everything that we can do, including things such as emotional responses, but it'll still be detectable as an alien unless we get to the point of actually emulating a human being in considerable detail as opposed to building an artificial brain with most or all of the same functionality (if not the flavor).
I often interact with the web all day and don't write any text a human could evaluate.
However, I'd have to guess that given a reasonable amount of data an LLM vs human interacting with websites would be fairly easy to spot since the LLM would be more purposeful - it'd be trying to fulfill a task, while a human may be curious, distracted by ads, put off by slow response times, etc, etc.
I don't think it's a very interesting question whether LLMs can sometimes generate output indistinguishable from humans, since that is exactly what they were trained to do - to mimic human-generated training samples. Apropos a Turing test, the question would be can I tell this is not a human, even given a reasonable amount of time to probe it in any way I care ... but I think there is an unspoken assumption that the person administering the test is qualified to do so (else the result isn't about AGI-ability, but rather test administrator ability).
Even before modern LLMs, some scrape-detectors would look for instant clicks, no random mouse moves, etc., and some scrapers would incorporate random delays, random mouse movements, etc.
The original Turing test is a social game, like the Mafia party game. It's not a game people try to play very often. It's unclear if any bot could win competing against skilled human opponents who have actually practiced and know some tricks for detecting bots.
The game is much harder if the human player is trying to pretend to be a machine.
Even if they lie, you could ask them 20 times and they d reply the lie, without feeling annoyed: FAIL.
LLMs cannot pass the Turing test, it's easy to see they're not human. They always enjoy questions ! And they never ask any !
The turning test wasn't meant to be bulletproof, or even quantifiable. It was a thought experiment.
I do agree (and I think there is a general consensus) that passing the Turing test is less meaningful than it may seem, it used to be considered an AGI-complete task and this is now clearly not the case.
But I think it’s important to get the attribution right, LLMs were the tech that unexpectedly passed the Turing test.
From my experience, AI has significantly improved since, and I expect that ChatGPT o3 or Claude 4 Opus would pass a 30 minute test.
> In the test, a human evaluator judges a text transcript of a natural-language conversation between a human and a machine. The evaluator tries to identify the machine, and the machine passes if the evaluator cannot reliably tell them apart. The results would not depend on the machine's ability to answer questions correctly, only on how closely its answers resembled those of a human.
Based on this, I would agree with the OP in many contexts. So, yeah, 'basically', is a load bearing word here but seems reasonably correct in the context of distinguishing human vs bot in any scalable and automated way.
Didn’t realize plexiglass existed in the 1930s!
I'm certainly not a monetization expert. But don't most consumers recoil in horror at subscriptions? At least enough to offset the idea they can be used for everything?
Not sure why this isn’t getting more attention - super helpful and way better than I expected!
The third has also been written by many a bot for at least fifteen years.
Of course people can fake it, just as they fake other kinds of ID, but it would at least mean that officially sanctioned agents from OpenAI/etc would need to identify themselves.
https://web.archive.org/web/20140417093510/https://www.googl...
“Correction, May 19 [2021]: At 5:22 in the video, there is an incorrect statement on Google’s use of reCaptcha V2 data. While Google have used V2 tests to help improve Google Maps, according to an email from Waymo (Google’s self-driving car project), the company isn’t using this image data to train their autonomous cars.”
The sign up form only serves to link saved state to an account so a user could access game history later, there are no gated features. No clue what they could possibly gain from doing this, other than to just get email providers to all mark my domain as spam (which they successfully did).
The site can't make any money, and had only about 1 legit visitor a week, so I just put a cloudflare captcha in front of it and called it a day.
Proof of work? Bots are infinitely patient and scale horizontally, your users do not. Doesn't work.
Micropayments: No such scheme exists.
Anyways, I wonder if there is a service that unions all those official auth methods for countries so there would be a global solution for website login. Certainly there would still be countries left in the dark, like USA :(
I suggest you go ahead and make these; you'll make a boatload of money!
After all, Anubis looks to be a successful project to me.
When users are given the choice between Ad-supported free, Ad-subsidized lower payment, and No-ads full payment. Ad-supported free dominates by far, with ad subsidized second, and full payment last.
Consumers consistently vote for the ad-model, even if it means they become the product being sold.
Any viable micropayments system that wants to even have a remote chance of toppling ads has to have near zero cognitive setup cost, absolutely zero maintenance, and work out of the box on major browsers. I need to be able to push a native button on my browser that says "Pay $0.001" and know that it will work every time without my lifting a finger to keep it working. The minute you have to log in to this account, or verify that E-mail, or re-authenticate with the bank, or authorize this, or upload that, it's no longer viable.
HN is a huge echo chamber of opinions of highly-compensated tech workers, and it seems most of their friends are also tech workers. They don't realize how cheap a lot of the general public is.
The other option is everything just keeps moving more and more into these walled gardens like Instagram where everyone uses the mobile app and watches ads, because the web versions of those apps just keep getting worse and worse by comparison.
I will bet $1000 on even odds that I am able to discern a model from a human given a 2 hour window to chat with both, and assuming the human acts in good faith
Any takers?
I could tell in 1 minute.
These situations will commonly be characterized by: a hundred billion dollar company's computer systems abusing the computer systems of another hundred billion dollar company. There are literally existing laws which have things to say about this.
There are legitimate technical problems in this domain when it comes to adversarial AI access. That's something we'll need to solve for. But that doesn't characterize the vast majority of situations in this domain. The vast majority of situations will be solved by businessmen and lawyers, not engineers.
So I think maybe that is a partial answer: anti-AI barriers being simply too expensive for AI spamfarms to deal with, you know, once the bottomless VC money disappears?
It's back to encryption: make the cracking inordinately expensive.
Otherwise we are headed for de-anonymization of the internet.
2. Even pre current LLMs, paying (or otherwise incentivizing) humans to solve CAPTCHAs on behalf of someone else (now like an AI?) was a thing.
3. It depends on the value of the resource trying to be accessed - regardless of whether generating the captchas costs $0 - i.e. if the resource being accessed by AI is "worth" $1, then paying an AI $0.95 to access it would still be worth it. (Made up numbers, my point being whether A is greater than B.)
4. However, maybe solutions like cloudflare can solve (much?) of this, except for incentivizing humans to solve a captcha posed to an AI.
Bot: one press of the trigger => automatic firing of bullets
And then there's Worldcoin, which is universally hated here.
When we do that, it opens up solutions which are far more privacy conscious and resistant to abuse. (For example, being blocked from signing up for new accounts because somebody in the federal government doesn't like an op-ed you wrote.)
If your site is not monetized by ads then having an LLM access things on the user's behalf should not be a major concern it seems. Unless you want it to be painful for users for some reason.
There's likely a correlate with AI here: If I run OpenTable, I wouldn't want my relationship with my customers to always be proxied through OpenAI or Siri. Even the App Store is something software businesses hate, because it obfuscates their ability to deal directly with their customers (for better or worse). Extremely few businesses would choose to do business through these proxies, unless they absolutely have to; and given the extreme competition in the AI space right now, it feels unlikely to me that these businesses feel pressure to be forced to deal with OpenAI/etc.
[1] https://www.cnbc.com/2025/07/28/jpmorgan-fintech-middlemen-p...
LLM models are much harder to drive than any website to serve, so you do not expect mob of bots.
Also keep in mind that this no interaction captchas use behavioral data that are collected in background. Plus you usually have sensitivity levels configured. depending on your use case you might want user proof not being a bot or it might be good enough to just not provide evidence for being one.
bypassing this no interaction captcha can be also purchased as a service, they basically (AFAIK) reuse someone else session for captcha bypass.
As a user I want the agent to be my full proxy. As a website operator I don’t want a mob of bots draining my resources.
Perhaps a good analogy is Mint and the bank account scraping they had to do in the 2010s, because no bank offered APIs with scoped permissions. Lots of customers complained, and after Plaid made it big business, eventually they relented and built the scalable solution.
The technical solution here is probably some combination of offering MCP endpoints for your actions, and some direct blob store access for static content. (Maybe even figuring out how to bill content loading to the consumer so agents foot the bill.)