News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by tossandthrow on Sunday May 25, 2025 @01:14PM (#44089204)
It is.

And this is the case in all western countries.

It is just being realized in different ways.

Fundamentalle there are 3 ways to cope

1. reduce pensions

2. Raise taxes

3. Decrease amount of benefit receivers.

Denmark choose number 3

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by CubsFan1060 on Sunday May 25, 2025 @01:21PM (#44089249)
Wouldn't the fourth way be via increasing either birth rate or immigration?
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by telotortium on Sunday May 25, 2025 @02:15PM (#44089705)
There's not enough immigrants that actually are of financial benefit to Denmark. Only European immigrants are a large financial benefit throughout their lifespan, and Middle Eastern immigrants are a financial detriment even in their prime working years[0]. That is apart from the cultural effects of having a large portion of your population consist of non-Danish, and especially non-European immigrants, which might have its own detrimental effect on the birth rate.

[0] Figure 2.7 of the Danish Government report "Økonomisk Analyse: Indvandreres nettobidrag til de offentlige finanser i 2018" - https://fm.dk/udgivelser/2021/oktober/oekonomisk-analyse-ind...

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by mmooss on Sunday May 25, 2025 @03:24PM (#44090292)
It turns out that economic productivity is not tied to ethnicity or where you are from - fundamentally racist notions - but to how productive you are.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by nine_k on Sunday May 25, 2025 @03:48PM (#44090477)
It's not about race, it's about culture and education. For instance, Chinese immigrants are usually an economic boost anywhere they go, due to the can-do attitude and respect for education and business activity in the Chinese culture in general.

Also the Chinese immigrants in question, like many others, usually immigrate seeking a better life, it's a strong self-selection filter. Middle Eastern immigrants of last 10-15 years in Europe are refugees, displaced by wars; they did not choose Denmark (or other Western European countries) because they planned to integrate and to prosper there, they ran there to merely stay alive. They need a lot of help adapting. Even if they are very willing to work, they may lack the knowledge required for gainful employment, and there are only so many dish-washing and trash-disposal jobs.

Those who adapt can make it big; consider people like Freddie Mercury or Nassim Taleb.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by selimthegrim on Sunday May 25, 2025 @05:38PM (#44091419)
Freddie Mercury wasn't of Middle Eastern background.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by telotortium on Sunday May 25, 2025 @07:44PM (#44092389)
And Taleb is a Christian Arab, which are genetically distinct from the majority Muslim Arab population.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by selimthegrim on Monday May 26, 2025 @09:08AM (#44097106)
Citation needed, this might not be true for non-Maronites (like Taleb) and outside Lebanon.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by nine_k on Sunday May 25, 2025 @11:00PM (#44093555)
The sultanate of Zanzibar is technically closer to Africa than to the Arabian peninsula, it was a remnant of the Omani empire, with very thick Middle Eastern influence, and obviously Muslim culture.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by selimthegrim on Monday May 26, 2025 @09:09AM (#44097112)
His parents were of Indian Parsi background.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by mmooss on Sunday May 25, 2025 @11:44PM (#44093791)
> It's not about race

It is about race, and here is a commenter saying it explicitly, while you know others resort to dog whistles and other workarounds.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44091194

The problem with immigration isn't immigrants, it's racists. Immigration has never caused me any problem at all - it's added a lot to my life and my communities, in fact - and I've lived around many immigrants.

> Chinese immigrants are usually an economic boost

Chinese immigrants were hated and discriminated against for much of US history, going back over a century. You could hardly pick a worse example for your claim.

The US is built by uneducated immigrants - including from China - who came to the land of freedom and opportunity. China was a land of extreme poverty and illiteracy for much of US history (something Western countries had a hand in causing, and I'm very glad for people there that they have so much more prosperity now).

(However, the most prosperous Chinese people are in the democratic areas, Taiwan and, until recently, Hong Kong. It's freedom and democracy, not culture and language that matter. Give people freedom and they prosper.)

It's all just stuff fabricated by racists to rationalize their prejudices. Look at the horrors Europe has inflicted on itself and the world due to these prejudices and rationalizations - the most destructive events in human history. Enough.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by ryan93 on Monday May 26, 2025 @08:45AM (#44096953)
no white person of means in europe EVER lives around muslim "refugees".
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by mmooss on Tuesday May 27, 2025 @10:21AM (#44107294)
More racism on their part - that's the problem, as I said. I also very much doubt that is true, but generally people do generally segregate by economic means, and first generation immigrants understandably tend to live in their own communities, everywhere. Where else do you find people to talk to, who understand you; where else do you even find dinner or some decent proper tea?

Racism is the problem.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by decimalenough on Sunday May 25, 2025 @03:54PM (#44090525)
Middle Eastern immigrants are not (usually, relatively, on average) unproductive because of their skin color. They're unproductive because they suffer from a large language barrier, tend to have large families that use more government subsidies, are often traumatized by the conditions they escaped, have qualifications that are not recognized in Denmark and have to work menial jobs instead, face racism when they apply for jobs they are qualified for, etc.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by LightBug1 on Sunday May 25, 2025 @04:11PM (#44090655)
You mean, like any/many immigrant waves?

And then their children turn out to be some of the most productive and contributory to a nation (in my experience), even despite some of the headwinds.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by Bassilisk on Sunday May 25, 2025 @05:33PM (#44091368)
Perhaps in the US due to pre-selection, but in Europe the 2nd generation of those MENA migrants frequently becomes an even bigger burden to the host countries due to the former turning to criminal activities or radicalization.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by LightBug1 on Sunday May 25, 2025 @06:59PM (#44092059)
"frequently" ... about as useful as my "in my experience", lol

Sorry, I don't buy that argument re: second generation. I've lived and seen it. Perhaps my lived experience isn't representative but I don't see second generation citizens turning to crime or radicalisation in huge numbers. I see them at work, and looking after their families. I fear the brush you are using is so broad as to, sorry, be useless.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by ryan93 on Monday May 26, 2025 @08:46AM (#44096959)
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by LightBug1 on Wednesday May 28, 2025 @04:46AM (#44113969)
https://archive.ph/rQAVF#selection-3415.8-3439.190

"The study has faced criticism over its methodology, as it only studied rape convictions in Sweden. Experts point to the fact that just a small proportion of rapes in the country are reported to the authorities. Jerzy Sarnecki, a criminologist at Stockholm University, dismissed the study as “meaningless” as it only examined figures for convicted rape. “They’ve only looked at convicted people, and they make up a fraction of all rapists,” he told Swedish broadcaster SVT."

Even ignoring the above, I can think of many reasons, statistical and otherwise for the apparent difference. Perhaps you should try using your brain matter to do the same rather than just posting random links.

I repeat: I don't see second generation citizens turning to crime or radicalisation in huge numbers.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by mmooss on Tuesday May 27, 2025 @10:25AM (#44107323)
Agreed. And the idea that you can call people criminals based on their ethnic heritage is plain racism - they are individuals who will themselves succeed or fail, be good or bad, just like individuals whose parents already lived in the country. Some of those people do bad things like promote hate and racial discrimination, but we can't say that about all of them; it's their individual choice and action.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by arandomusername on Sunday May 25, 2025 @05:14PM (#44091194)
This is false. The study includes descendants and the trend is the same. Those descendants wouldn't suffer a language barrier, aren't traumatized by the "conditions" (neither are majority of immigrants from those regions, as they often go back for holidays etc), will have qualifcations from Denmark.

It's culture and race does also play a part in it. It's not right to treat anyone differently because of their race, but let's not ignore the reality that skin isn't the only difference between races.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by frotaur on Sunday May 25, 2025 @06:08PM (#44091658)
Why would you associate this difference with race rather than culture? Seems like culture differences would be a much better answer to your premise.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by arandomusername on Sunday May 25, 2025 @07:50PM (#44092424)
I think it's both. I think race plays part in it because the trend follows with the descendants who often absorb (parts) of the culture. There's also not that much in their culture that would explain it, to me. In my experience they are often hard workers. It's very taboo to say, but there is difference between races.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by mmooss on Sunday May 25, 2025 @11:46PM (#44093805)
Brazen racism on Hacker News. In the next breath, they'll say DEI is unnecessary because there is no racism.

The problem with immigration is not the immigrants, it's the racists. They create the pain and horrors and the social tension.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by account42 on Monday May 26, 2025 @11:37AM (#44098437)
Shouting louder won't change reality.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by arandomusername on Monday May 26, 2025 @02:55PM (#44100426)
Is it racist to say that there's difference between races?

DEI is important, specially Diversity. In order to have diversity, you need to have different cultures. Mass immigration erodes diversity. Diversity exists by having different nations with different cultures, not one culture everywhere.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by mmooss on Sunday May 25, 2025 @11:45PM (#44093800)
> They're unproductive because they suffer from a large language barrier,

Immigrants everywhere come with a language barrier. If you live in the US, very probably your ancestors did. It's the same with every first generation from everywhere.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by decimalenough on Monday May 26, 2025 @01:19AM (#44094207)
The barriers are not all the same. Somebody moving from Norway or Sweden will have a much easier time picking up Danish. And European immigrants are highly likely to speak English, meaning they can communicate with Danes who speak English (virtually all of them) from day one.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by mmooss on Tuesday May 27, 2025 @10:22AM (#44107305)
You're really struggling to find problems. English is spoken all over the world - people all over the world learn it, in China, India ... places with completely unrelated languages.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by Scarblac on Sunday May 25, 2025 @06:35PM (#44091856)
It's because the ME immigrants that make it to Denmark are traumatized refugees from war zones, with education that isn't recognized so they can often only do minimum wage work if they work at all. That's not racist, that's a result of laws and treaties.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by account42 on Monday May 26, 2025 @11:38AM (#44098456)
There are no refugees coming from ME to Denmark. Refugees go to nearby countries, people who travel halfway around the world are economic migrants.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by Scarblac on Monday May 26, 2025 @12:28PM (#44098923)
Syrians are the second largest group of asylum seekers in Denmark, after Ukrainians. They're almost exclusively war refugees.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by mmooss on Tuesday May 27, 2025 @10:27AM (#44107337)
> Refugees go to nearby countries

They actually go lots of places. How are there so many refugees in the US (a good thing)? Canada and Mexico aren't places producing a lot of them.

It's a major issue of international law, as people who are anti-immigrants try to insist refugees stay in nearby countries.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by niemandhier on Sunday May 25, 2025 @03:07PM (#44090145)
I can only give you the rundown for Germany, but I guess it’s similar in Denmark:

Basically the state spends to much money on humans in general. A young qualified immigrant might have a less negative impact than a slightly older German person, but both of them will be money sinks in the long run.

Statistically immigrants in Germany are less qualified than the general population, so they’ll have an even more negative impact.

The only valid solution is to reduce the spending per person, both birthrate and immigration will only delay the problem.

Denmark should be in a slightly better position than Germany since their health system is cheaper.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by n_ary on Sunday May 25, 2025 @04:53PM (#44091010)
> Statistically immigrants in Germany are less qualified than the general population, so they’ll have an even more negative impact.

I need to see some data backing this. Also regardless of stats, many war refugees(the net negatives as told by media) are actually highly qualified but the asylum process and qualification recognition process is eternal. On top of the trauma and uncertainty, they also need to learn a new language, find a new community, patiently go through all the dystopian meetings, cope with their loss of loved ones.

In reality, it is possible for them to be net positive because if things were faster, they would often out qualify the average locals and this also has some effects on wage and market(over supply, constant demand and all the economics).

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by niemandhier on Sunday May 25, 2025 @05:26PM (#44091297)
You are right regarding the insufficient opportunities for highly qualified people.

Regarding your other point: https://home-affairs.ec.europa.eu/whats-new/publications/oec...

The liked pdf there gives a good overview.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by arandomusername on Sunday May 25, 2025 @05:23PM (#44091270)
Most immigrants are not war refugees but economical refugees.

> they would often out qualify the average locals

That's definitely not true, which is why they want to immigrate to those countries in the first place.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by ryan93 on Monday May 26, 2025 @08:50AM (#44096982)
"refugees" from syria or iraq or wherever would quickly out qualify danes???
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by SoftTalker on Sunday May 25, 2025 @01:32PM (#44089343)
Immigration only works if the immigrants adopt and support the social norms and outcomes that you desire. If the immigrants have no desire to work, pay taxes, and support the elderly then you won't want them.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by mmooss on Sunday May 25, 2025 @03:29PM (#44090330)
Immigration works and has worked for generations, and for generations people have slandered immigrants. Let's try to be more intelligent that broad stereotypes.

> If the immigrants have no desire to work, pay taxes, and support the elderly then you won't want them.

What does it have to do with immigration? You could say the same about anyone, regardless of where they are born.

One thing you can say about immigrants, especially undocumented ones, is that they have the drive to drop everything in their old lives, go a long way to a strange place - where people often express hate and abuse - where the language is different, the culture confusing, and the future uncertain.

Those people have more drive than the great majority of the people born in the country, many of whom can't get off their sofas or away from their computers.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by arandomusername on Sunday May 25, 2025 @05:19PM (#44091232)
Immigration only works if the cultures are very similar so that they can assimilate, or the immigration levels are very low.

In Denmark, immigration from culturally similar countries are usually net-positive, while others are net negative (financially).

There's a reason people are choosing to vote for parties that are (publicly) anti-immigration

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by mmooss on Sunday May 25, 2025 @11:41PM (#44093776)
> Immigration only works if the cultures are very similar so that they can assimilate, or the immigration levels are very low.

People just make this stuff up, any rationalization for hatred. It's not hard to see how immigration has worked, how Europe integrates with itself (a continent that fought endless wars before the proto-EU was born), and how the US is a country of immigrants. Rather than repeat it all, see:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44092557

Excerpt, from Ben Franklin:

"... Why should Pennsylvania, founded by the English, become a Colony of Aliens, who will shortly be so numerous as to Germanize us instead of our Anglifying them, and will never adopt our Language or Customs, any more than they can acquire our Complexion. ..."

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by arandomusername on Monday May 26, 2025 @02:52PM (#44100405)
It's very easy to see how immigration hasn't worked. Visit London, Brussels or Paris. Compare that to cities that have low immigration rates, like Warsaw.

Europe integrated itself because European countries have very similar culture, and are same/similar race.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by mmooss on Tuesday May 27, 2025 @10:19AM (#44107274)
You're comparing London, Brussels and Paris to Warsaw? I think most people would consider the former three to be much 'better' cities and greater successes - Paris and London are considered two of the greatest cities in the world! Right there with New York, also a home for immigrants from all over.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by arandomusername on Tuesday May 27, 2025 @03:25PM (#44109958)
Have you been to any of those cities in the last 5-10 years?

Paris and London used to be great cities. Not anymore, they are just living off their formal glory.

It feels like your image of London/Paris is based of movies and tv shows.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by mmooss on Wednesday May 28, 2025 @12:38AM (#44112789)
Yes, I have. You are living in an Internet disinformation unreality - just like the nonsense the right wing craps out about how horrible and dangerous NY is. As empirical data, look up real estate prices and tourism to the three cities, and see how Warsaw compares. Remember, people in Europe can easily go to Paris or Warsaw; going to London is a bit harder.

And that is with massive disinformation campaigns against immmigrants and 'liberal' cities.

(No offense to Warsaw - maybe only NY and Tokyo measure up to London and Paris.)

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by grunder_advice on Sunday May 25, 2025 @01:48PM (#44089471)
Getting immigrants who work is a non-issue. I never heard of immigrants from India, China, Africa or Latin America who don't work so long as they entered the country legally. The issue you are alluding to has to do with genuine refugees and illegal economic migrants, who are not filtered at the border depending on their employability within the local market. But the cultural shift is still inevitable. A foreigner is not a local, and it is neither fair nor ethical to expect a foreigner to transform themselves into a local.

I think, if you are concerned with the cultural shift, you can give immigrants temporary term VISAs and make it clear their stay is going to be strictly temporary. That was supposed to be how the Gastarbeiter system works. Thing is, when you have already on boarded a foreign worker and have had them working for you for 2 years already, you don't want to let them go and replace them with a fresh foreign worker who you have to retrain.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by bananalychee on Sunday May 25, 2025 @02:09PM (#44089649)
Assimilation as most people understand it does not necessitate an immigrant become completely indistinguishable from a native citizen. There are some baseline expectations that are not always met right now, such as learning the official language of one's host country, and sometimes its social standards. Most countries simply lack the necessary coercive incentives to make that happen systematically. I would argue that most Western cultures have become too individualistic at the expense of societal health, fueling the notion that assimilation is inherently unethical.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by Loic on Sunday May 25, 2025 @02:54PM (#44090026)
I fundamentally agree with your comment. But for Denmark, it is very difficult to learn Danish. I lived there 3 years, took courses and was at end able to do my daily stuff in English, but a part of the society simply does not want a foreigner to speak Danish. You are forced to use English.

My girlfriend asked me once in a Restaurant (Cafe Norden in Kopenhagen) why I was ordering in English. Then, I spent the complete evening ordering everything in Danish, to always receive answers in English. And this nearly everywhere (not my bakery, the girls there could not speak a word of English, this was an exception). This was in the early 2000's. This never happened to me in all the other countries I have been living in. A Danish colleague simply told me that he does not like to listen to broken Danish, better switch to English.

Still have a lot of friends in Denmark, integration there is not easy, even for highly qualified people from the EU.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by SoftTalker on Sunday May 25, 2025 @03:07PM (#44090149)
Danes are by and large all English speakers, probably the last generation who would have much difficulty with conversational English are all 70+ years old now. And while Danes are generally very polite and friendly with foreigners, there is a level of personal closeness (part of the "hygge" concept) that you will rarely penetrate if you are not a lifelong close friend or family member. This is another part of why real integration into Danish culture is nearly impossible for a foreigner.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by Lyngbakr on Sunday May 25, 2025 @03:20PM (#44090258)
I had a similar experience in the Netherlands. We could have a 30 second exchange in their perfect English or a laboured 2 minute conversation in my abysmal Dutch. I struggled to improve because everyone would immediately switch to English.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by theodric on Sunday May 25, 2025 @03:18PM (#44090228)
I observed over my 11 years in the Netherlands that the friendliness and quality of service I received was greater when I spoke English and much diminished when I spoke Dutch. The Netherlands is, similar to Denmark, a place where people would seemingly prefer to speak English than listen to an accent on their native language.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by bananalychee on Sunday May 25, 2025 @09:05PM (#44092896)
I commend you for your efforts and I'm sure they were appreciated even by those who switched to English with you. It sounds like you were in the infamous long awkward intermediate stage of language learning. Depending on the cadence of your language classes, three years may not be a long time. Intensive language programs with daily lessons and drills are exponentially more effective than typical language-learning programs spread out across short sessions sprinkled throughout the week/month. In my opinion, it makes a lot more sense to place newcomers in intensive learning programs on arrival than to accept they will not be functional outside of ethnic enclaves, and wait decades for their children and grandchildren to finally integrate, as other commenters suggest. It's not an easy process and we can't expect everyone to have the intrinsic motivation to do it all on their own, which is why incentives are needed.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by yborg on Sunday May 25, 2025 @02:47PM (#44089960)
Without establishing a hermetic environment a la the Amish, assimilation happens automatically in the next generation if a nation has basic structures in place like public education to some minimum standard and basic anti-discrimination laws to allow economic advancement. Children absorb the culture that surrounds them, often to their parents' dismay.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by mmooss on Sunday May 25, 2025 @03:34PM (#44090364)
The data I saw is that by the third generation, only a few percent speak the language of their grandparents' country, and most marry outside their nationality.

In the US, Italians, Irish, and Germans, as just a few examples, all were treated as unassmilated aliens. People say the same things, generation after generation about newcomers. If you moved to a country with a different language and culture, you might make an effort to learn the language but you would still think, read, etc. in your native language. Your kids would know both languages; their kids would of course speak the language of their surroundings.

What solves these problems is a fundamental belief in freedom for all. People don't need to speak your language to be your equal and be just as human, with the same rights as you.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by brewdad on Sunday May 25, 2025 @04:13PM (#44090681)
This was certainly true of my Polish ancestors. My great grandfather arrived at age 19. He never really became fluent in English but could get by when he needed to. My grandfather spoke both Polish and English but only spoke English at home once he had school aged children. My father really only knew the Polish swear words and I know a handful of Polish phrases that only get used amongst family at Thanksgiving or Christmas. Don’t ask me to write them down. I’ve only ever heard them verbally.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by Detrytus on Sunday May 25, 2025 @06:00PM (#44091594)
Italians, Irish, Germans in US are bad examples, because Americans and Western Europeans are basically one and the same culture, the only significant difference being the language spoken. I suppose integrating Chinese or Indian people might take much longer.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by mmooss on Sunday May 25, 2025 @08:12PM (#44092557)
In fact, they were seen as very different cultures and the exact same things were said about them. Only in hindsight do people say what you are saying (and in hindsight they will say the same about today's immigrants). In fact, the world has never been smaller or more homogenous - people in countries all over the world dress like us, are exposed to our culture a great many already speak English. Before you spread damaging misinformation - there are few evils inflicted by and on humanity than those based on these prejudices - shouldn't you know what you are saying? Shouldn't we talk great care?

Here's Benjamin Franklin (Palatine refers to the Holy Roman Empire or Germanic regions, depending on the source):

"[W]hy should the Palatine Boors be suffered to swarm into our Settlements, and by herding together establish their Language and Manners to the Exclusion of ours? Why should Pennsylvania, founded by the English, become a Colony of Aliens, who will shortly be so numerous as to Germanize us instead of our Anglifying them, and will never adopt our Language or Customs, any more than they can acquire our Complexion.

Which leads me to add one Remark: That the Number of purely white People in the World is proportionably very small. All Africa is black or tawny. Asia chiefly tawny. America (exclusive of the new Comers) wholly so. And in Europe, the Spaniards, Italians, French, Russians and Swedes, are generally of what we call a swarthy Complexion; as are the Germans also, the Saxons only excepted, who with the English, make the principal Body of White People on the Face of the Earth. I could wish their Numbers were increased. And while we are, as I may call it, Scouring our Planet, by clearing America of Woods, and so making this Side of our Globe reflect a brighter Light to the Eyes of Inhabitants in Mars or Venus, why should we in the Sight of Superior Beings, darken its People? why increase the Sons of Africa, by Planting them in America, where we have so fair an Opportunity, by excluding all Blacks and Tawneys, of increasing the lovely White and Red? But perhaps I am partial to the Complexion of my Country, for such Kind of Partiality is natural to Mankind."

https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2008/02/swarthy...

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by decimalenough on Sunday May 25, 2025 @03:59PM (#44090572)
It often takes three generations. The first generation came willingly and thus have an incentive to put up with shit; the second generation did not, find people hating on them anyway, and understandably react by pulling back and doubling down on their heritage.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by GLdRH on Sunday May 25, 2025 @03:05PM (#44090123)
If only that were true.

You can look at any country in western europe to see how it's not.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by stefan_ on Sunday May 25, 2025 @03:02PM (#44090100)
Mhm, the current generation of kids of Turkish immigrants in Germany all seem to believe they are actually displaced Turks. I suppose thats what you encourage with double passport and voting for authoritarians at "home". (of course they are totally out of place in Turkey, that part of assimilation is unavoidable)
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by theodric on Sunday May 25, 2025 @03:22PM (#44090270)
This is not borne out by the anecdata I have collected over the last 22 years as a foreign invader living in and observing Europe. Moroccans in the Netherlands, Albanians in Switzerland, even Irish Travellers in Ireland-- despite being integrated from primary school onward, all seem to be somewhat apart from the host culture even after several generations.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by selimthegrim on Sunday May 25, 2025 @05:40PM (#44091432)
Travellers aren't foreign.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by theodric on Monday May 26, 2025 @03:39AM (#44094963)
And yet they remain a distinct cultural group with different traditions and modes of living, despite integration at a school level. Apparently they've even diverged genetically[1] from the main population.

[1] https://www.pure.ed.ac.uk/ws/portalfiles/portal/35314239/sre...

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by soerxpso on Sunday May 25, 2025 @03:00PM (#44090083)
> you can give immigrants temporary term VISAs and make it clear their stay is going to be strictly temporary

In practice that rarely goes as intended. The first political party to say, "We changed our minds, you can all have citizenship," gets to secure power with an influx of loyal voters.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by Pamar on Sunday May 25, 2025 @05:35PM (#44091388)
Maybe I misunderstand your point but... if these people are not citizens (i.e. they need a VISA) how could they actually vote for whatever party proposing this?
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by babyent on Monday May 26, 2025 @05:18AM (#44095532)
He says the party will lock in a loyal block after doing such an act.

Before: 5 million illegals or immigrants.

Party A passes law making them all citizens.

After: Party A always wins because large portion of the new 5 million vote for Party A

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by Pamar on Wednesday May 28, 2025 @01:49AM (#44113076)
Well, if a party has enough votes to pass such a law, it means that the majority of the society has no problems with that.

Conversely, if this hypothetical party had a secret agenda to pass the law when they get elected, but they kept this a secret until then... first of all they will probably lose of voters in the next election. Also, they might find out that former immigrants do not automatically reward this behaviour in terms of votes.

I do not find this scenario particularly realistic.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by tristramb on Sunday May 25, 2025 @02:20PM (#44089736)
Have you any figures that indicate that is an issue?
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by Ray20 on Sunday May 25, 2025 @03:53PM (#44090520)
No one knows how to increase the birth rate. And all the studies show that immigration increases the budget deficit, not reduces it (at least in that way in which it is being implemented now).
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by AdrianB1 on Sunday May 25, 2025 @04:05PM (#44090614)
Actually the factors inhibiting birth rate are well known, but the actions to take are not something states wants to take. In Europe you cannot even talk about it, usually, unless you talk to younger family members and ask them why they don't want kids at or or just 1 or 2 max. There are economic, education and legal aspects that are clear for anyone that looked not farther than 50 years ago when having 3-4 kids was not exceptional.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by vbezhenar on Sunday May 25, 2025 @04:20PM (#44090727)
Everyone knows. Stop contraception, stop woman education, stop abortions, reduce woman rights to 1800. Remove children rights, make environment where children are productive and bring profits to their parents, so they have financial incentive to create children.

No one wants to implement it.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by geodel on Sunday May 25, 2025 @06:39PM (#44091885)
You are right. Since that is not happening the next best thing is to juice the oldies. At least more countries have started doing that.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by const_cast on Sunday May 25, 2025 @05:50PM (#44091519)
Right, if anyone here has taken a human geography course this is the obvious answer. This is why birthrate was so high for so long. As nations developed and gained rights for women, it went lower and lower and lower.

And it makes complete sense. The reality is having a child kind of sucks for a woman, and I, nor anyone else, can blame a large portion of women for just saying "eh... no". I would probably say no, too, although it's hard to tell, because I'm not a woman.

Having children was once a boon, because conditions were shit. Now it's a burden. So, people will treat it as a burden.

Either make it less burdensome or revert women. Nobody wants to do the latter, so we must do the former. We have to invest in children, because children are a Nation's investment.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by streptomycin on Sunday May 25, 2025 @10:09PM (#44093298)
Here is a chart of Saudi Arabia's fertility rate, which has dropped from 7 to 2 over the past 40 years: https://www.consultancy-me.com/illustrations/news/detail/202...
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by AngryData on Monday May 26, 2025 @03:16AM (#44094830)
Not having to work as much to live seems like a decent way to increase birthrates. Having kids is/would be much easier if parents were at home more often and able to care for kids instead of contracting out childcare to daycare centers because you cannot afford to not have both parents working full time. But it comes at the cost of not growing as fast and being less attractive to capital investors/owners who are reaping by far the highest percentage of profits currently.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by mr_toad on Sunday May 25, 2025 @01:26PM (#44089292)
The people who would actually benefit from that the most are the people who are too old to have children and are strongly opposed to immigration.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by impossiblefork on Sunday May 25, 2025 @01:32PM (#44089346)
Improve the birth rate, yes, but you probably can't do that unless you deal with the resource situation as well.

So you can reduce pensions, improve the situation for the youth, take efforts to get an improved birth rate, making use of the resources lost to pensioners, and then maybe you can raise the pension later on once you realize things are stable.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by lostlogin on Sunday May 25, 2025 @01:25PM (#44089279)
That’s collecting more taxes, 2, isn’t it?
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by JackYoustra on Sunday May 25, 2025 @01:26PM (#44089300)
technically true but people usually associate that with rate increases
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by lostlogin on Sunday May 25, 2025 @04:56PM (#44091039)
I’m not sure that’s always true.

The centre right often argue for less taxation ‘to grow businesses’. The argument being that the economy grows and that’s how the money is recouped. At least that’s what’s happened here in New Zealand.

Looking past ones next pay day does seem universally difficult.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by nicolashahn on Sunday May 25, 2025 @01:59PM (#44089578)
Raising the birth rate is extremely difficult and immigration will destroy a country's culture if not managed properly.

For an interesting case study, compare Japan (who refuses to allow mass immigration and is at risk of going extinct) and the UK (who has embraced it and is on the way to becoming Muslim-majority). It'll be interesting to see in 50 years which one has had better outcomes.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by mariusor on Sunday May 25, 2025 @02:07PM (#44089639)
According to Wikipedia[1] you are quite off base as Muslims form only 6.5% of the population as opposed to Christians (46.2%) and a-religious (37.2%).

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Religion_in_the_United_Kingdom

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by nicolashahn on Sunday May 25, 2025 @02:14PM (#44089698)
I said "on the way to".

> Between 2001 and 2009, the Muslim population increased almost 10 times faster than the non-Muslim population.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Islam_in_the_United_Kingdom?wp...

Granted 2009 was a while ago but they're still the fastest growing population in the UK by a lot.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by dtech on Sunday May 25, 2025 @02:30PM (#44089833)
This is using the same flawed logic that has had people shouting about overpopulation since the 70's: assuming current* population growth rate will continue indefinitely

* well, not even current. 15+ year old

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by nicolashahn on Sunday May 25, 2025 @03:14PM (#44090197)
The difference is that this is a change in the demographics of a population, not the overall growth, which is limited by resources available. The growth of Islam isn't constrained by anything other than the cultural practices that lead to them having more children than the rest of the population and the tolerance of the country for immigration. These things could definitely shift to balance the scales but there's no guarantee that happens and there have absolutely been many times in history where a native population has been displaced by the growth of an immigrant group.

Stepping back a bit, Pew expects Islam to overtake Christianity as the dominant world religion in a few decades: https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2017/04/06/why-musli...

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by mariusor on Sunday May 25, 2025 @03:54PM (#44090529)
Nicholas, is it clear that at any point in the near future, let's say two generations (30-40 years) the Muslim population will not be a majority in the UK? I don't understand why you continue arguing.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by gambiting on Sunday May 25, 2025 @02:53PM (#44090017)
Ah, it's the same argument that my mum uses to say that if we don't do something about "the gays" then straight people will disappear, after all "there are a lot more of them than there used to be".
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by ak_111 on Sunday May 25, 2025 @02:28PM (#44089811)
You are not making your point any favour. It is right that everyone is calling you out for your xenophonbic BS.

If it grew 10x between 2001 and 2009 (starting from a very small base), then between 2009 and 2023 it grew by only 0.3x (see graph below).

So rate of growth went from 10x to 0.3x in around a decade, this is a hugely significant deceleration. It actually implies muslim community as portion of population is heading lower.

https://new.islamchannel.tv/wp-content/uploads/2024/04/63860...

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by nicolashahn on Sunday May 25, 2025 @02:58PM (#44090058)
You're not comparing the same stats. The original stat was growth rate compared to the rest of the country. Islam's overall growth rate has been fairly steady for decades, although admittedly it has slowed, but at a rate that could conceivably stop above Christianity, which your chart shows is decreasing about as rapidly as Islam is rising. I think it's reasonable to project that it may settle below Islam eventually. Realistically, there will be continued backlash by native English and that may temper immigration, though even if immigration stops, the birth rate of Muslims in the UK is still much higher than native population.

However - if we're including atheist then clearly that'll be the majority position.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by logicchains on Sunday May 25, 2025 @02:15PM (#44089704)
He said "on its way" so you'd want to be looking at the rate of change in the ratio, not the current ratio.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by fakedang on Sunday May 25, 2025 @02:21PM (#44089752)
Any data on the birthrates of the younger generations being born today?
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by nicolashahn on Sunday May 25, 2025 @04:14PM (#44090687)
I found this article from 2017:

https://www.pewresearch.org/religion/2017/11/29/europes-grow...

The most recent birth rate stats I can find is 2005-2010 where Muslims have a birth rate of 3.0 while the rest of the country is at 1.8. Estimates say it's more like 2.5 now, but the current overall UK birth rate is only 1.57 from a quick Google.

https://assets.pewresearch.org/wp-content/uploads/sites/11/2...

The same article also states that the average age for Muslims is much lower than non-Muslims as of 2016, 28 vs 41 for the UK.

https://www.pewresearch.org/wp-content/uploads/sites/7/2017/...

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by fakedang on Monday May 26, 2025 @12:58AM (#44094097)
Yes I know the stats hover around roughly that, which is why I requested you to post those numbers as proof for anyone questioning it. There's also the very concerning fact that the last census conducted was before the immigration boom period (2010 or 2011 iirc), so literally everyone is working on outdated data.

Maybe not in one generation, but in 2-3 generations, the UK will definitely turn Islamic, especially given the exodus of other communities. The irony is that the well-off British are settling in the UAE en masse, a distinctly Islamic country, and driving property prices up there. It's not that much of a concern since local housing is distinctly separated from expat housing.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by mariusor on Sunday May 25, 2025 @02:32PM (#44089848)
Yes, I'm sure those 6.5% can out breed the rest of the UK tens of times over. Please stop trying to justify misinformation.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by fakedang on Monday May 26, 2025 @12:53AM (#44094068)
Actually, OP has given information that proves exactly that. Maybe not in one generation, but Lebanon was in a similar situation where the Muslim population, which was firmly a minority in the 1940s, outbred the Christian population and is currently more than the latter.

I don't have a horse in this game - I'm Muslim after all. But I've experienced London pre-immigration boom and post-immigration boom and I definitely prefer the former, like some of my Muslim peers. The fabric of London has already been destroyed, especially when given the fact that London natives have been priced out of their own homes. Given what I've seen firsthand, and what's preached in the mosques of the UK by unleashed and unhinged Imams, the UK is on track to become a Muslim country in 2 or 3 generations.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by vbezhenar on Sunday May 25, 2025 @04:23PM (#44090754)
How many children were born in Muslim families in 2024 and how many children were born in Christian families in UK?
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by teamonkey on Sunday May 25, 2025 @02:10PM (#44089664)
UK is in no conceivable way “on the way to becoming Muslim-majority”.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Religion_in_the_United_Kingdom

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by danw1979 on Sunday May 25, 2025 @02:14PM (#44089693)
Way to undermine your point by using a completely made up statistic.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by heyheyhouhou on Sunday May 25, 2025 @02:06PM (#44089631)
it is 6% muslim majority?
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by BenFranklin100 on Sunday May 25, 2025 @02:14PM (#44089695)
It’s not. But a xenophobic far right is approaching a majority.
[dead]
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by heyheyhouhou on Sunday May 25, 2025 @02:44PM (#44089931)
yes, I read it, still is 6%.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by nicolashahn on Sunday May 25, 2025 @02:58PM (#44090066)
Please work on your reading comprehension then
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by maleldil on Sunday May 25, 2025 @03:08PM (#44090152)
If you're going to be xenophobic, at least make your point more explicitly. For example, you could use a current statistic instead of something from 16 years ago.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by bugglebeetle on Sunday May 25, 2025 @02:05PM (#44089621)
In 50 years, Japan will have a Chinese majority, so…
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by erklik on Sunday May 25, 2025 @05:55PM (#44091555)
> Raising the birth rate is extremely difficult

> the UK (who has embraced it and is on the way to becoming Muslim-majority)

.. Seems like we've found a fix for ;) I wonder what's the difference between Muslims in the UK vs Japanese folks.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by cbeach on Sunday May 25, 2025 @01:30PM (#44089332)
Raising immigration rates to solve an aging population is a Ponzi solution.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by jaoane on Sunday May 25, 2025 @02:47PM (#44089963)
The pension system has always been a ponzi. Only now we are faced to realise it because the pyramid was flipped violently.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by risyachka on Sunday May 25, 2025 @03:23PM (#44090282)
In the modern economy system there is no way around it.

The more old people there is the more taxes you need.

More taxes - economy must grow. And it can’t grow if working population is shrinking

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by pfdietz on Sunday May 25, 2025 @01:36PM (#44089370)
The total fertility rate (number of children per woman) seems stubborn against attempts to raise it.

I suggest instead altering the male/female ratio, so a stable or growing population can be maintained at lower TFR. Technically, filter sperm to remove those with Y chromosomes before artificial insemination.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by mattlondon on Sunday May 25, 2025 @03:26PM (#44090305)
At least in the UK the cost of childcare is a major factor putting people off.

People simply can't afford to send a kid to pre-school childcare because it's 2 or 3 thousand GBP per month. So you have to stay at home to look after them, but then you can't afford the rent/mortgage and/or food because you're not working. Woe betide you if you earn over 1 penny over 100K GBP because then you get zero help with costs.

They need to provide more government funded (i.e. universally free non-means-tested) pre-schooling like they do for 5-18 year olds.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by nicolashahn on Sunday May 25, 2025 @01:55PM (#44089531)
I feel like there really hasn't been sincere data-backed methods with proper resources behind them, for example governments giving out minor cash benefits to parents of a few thousand dollars when that's a drop in the bucket compared to the total cost of raising a kid and is not going to convince anyone who wasn't already going to have kids.

Also, that's a wild solution. You'd have to do away with monogamy which would cause some pretty insane societal shifts. However, as a straight guy I can see the appeal lol.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by pfdietz on Sunday May 25, 2025 @01:59PM (#44089569)
The issue with low TFR seems to be difficulty of forming relationships, not failure to have children once relationships are formed.

I'm imagining it becoming a social norm for single women to have (at least) a single child. Perhaps they'd team up to make raising them easier, forming loose family-like units. Romantic attachments would be optional.

One consequence of such a situation would be an incentive toward private positive eugenics. Women would prefer semen from top quality donors.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by amanaplanacanal on Sunday May 25, 2025 @01:46PM (#44089459)
As Jan and Dean put it in Surf City: "two girls for every boy".
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by AdrianB1 on Sunday May 25, 2025 @04:12PM (#44090661)
Without a major and unrealistic cultural change, 2 girls to share one boy (polygamy) is not going to happen.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by const_cast on Sunday May 25, 2025 @05:54PM (#44091547)
No no, not like that. Well, maybe, but no. Most men are useless from a reproductive standpoint because they're not the bottleneck. Women are the bottleneck. More women means no more bottleneck, means more children per person.

Also sexual selection is a thing and I think we were really never meant to have this many men. Men seem good for being really successful or otherwise dying, not much in the middle.

But also, all this talk is purely from a reproductive standpoint. Human societies also need to consider fairness and rights.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by AdrianB1 on Monday May 26, 2025 @12:43PM (#44099064)
All you said is correct, but all you said points towards polygamy.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by pfdietz on Sunday May 25, 2025 @10:19PM (#44093355)
If TFR stays well below 2, there's going to be major change sooner or later. The question becomes which change. Maybe the Amish will take over the world? Or maybe some solution we find really weird will be adopted by some other minority and they'll dominate.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by pfdietz on Sunday May 25, 2025 @03:26PM (#44090307)
Or more. The prevalence of males seems to be an unfortunate consequence of evolution. There's an evolutionary equilibrium of nearly an equal chance of a male or female offspring, even though the ability of the species to reproduce would be higher with mostly female offspring.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by adrianN on Tuesday May 27, 2025 @01:52AM (#44104240)
I wouldn’t be surprised if historically there were more women than men due to accidents involving mammoths or clubs meeting skulls.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by staticman2 on Wednesday May 28, 2025 @12:14PM (#44117632)
I love this as a science fiction thought experiment but altering the male/ female ratio will never happen.

If someone tried to implement it- aside from the obvious problem of authoritarianism- the resulting male minority would live life in romantic "easy mode" so people who want the best for their kids would want male children and rebel against a system more likely to give them female children who would find romantic prospects difficult.

I suppose if someone invented a way to alter sexuality to allow straight women to opt into becoming gay the romance problem could be mitigated, but I'm guessing that this is impossible given the human brain is only so neuroplastic in adult years.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by constantcrying on Sunday May 25, 2025 @01:28PM (#44089312)
You have to grow your economy at a rate that allows you to pay for the additional pensioners.

Birthrates seem very hard to change and even if change would happen it is much too slow.

Germany did the experiment on immigration and has not seen GDP growth for half a decade. There the system is failing far worse in some ways, but in Germany employees are paying directly for the pension plans, so the state just raises the employee contributions.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by trueismywork on Sunday May 25, 2025 @02:19PM (#44089728)
Because Germany does nothing to attract and keep employable immigrants. They only want to keep immigrants which completely tow the line of only speaking German, which inevitably attracts mostly bottom of the barrel. Significant portion of highly qualified workforce in Germany is umemployable because of refusal to conduct business in anything other than German.

Also, the beaurcracy is the real culprit for growth.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by lo_zamoyski on Sunday May 25, 2025 @07:16PM (#44092198)
Yes and no.

The elephant in the room that is getting some attention is demographic collapse. It’s been politicized, unfortunately, and seized on by strange people, but the fact remains that we’ve stuck our heads in the sand here. The seriousness of demographic collapse cannot be overstated. Social and economic collapse are inevitable unless something (morally licit, of course) is done to boost birth rates to above replacement rates, or kept at replacement levels. Once we reach a point of no return, it will be impossible to reverse course.

There’s a lot working against healthy demographics. We have decades of alarmist, misanthropic, Malthusian propaganda from types like Paul Ehrlich. We have now a hyperindividualistic culture - politically, socially, and economically - that is hostile both functionally as well as in sentiment toward the healthy function of family, and secondarily the community life it produces, as well as mental health). The logic of consumerism does not sit well with family life, because family life is not something that can be monetized. Consumerism relies on maximizing spending of the atomized individual, and in order for that to work, one must maximize the work done by that individual. Family life interferes with the regime of constant spending and the reign of total work. (Ironically, this makes the celebrated careerism of feminism an expression of this all consuming capitalist drive. It stigmatizes motherhood with demeaning labels like “stay-at-home mom” and celebrates the very office jobs that are the stuff of comedies.) Today, we understand everything with reference to the individual, even anachronistically reinterpreting history according to its alienating categories. Some governments have enacted pro-natalist policies, but they’re typically weak, superficial, and ineffective. We’re addicted to patterns of life formed over the last 70 years that we don’t want to let go of. Governments need to take much more serious measures that drastically favor, prioritize, and protect the family, through and through. Good luck doing that in our democratic societies. Addicts typically change only after they’ve experienced a crisis and hit rock bottom, and by then, it may be too late.

Immigration, of course, is no solution. The belief that immigration can fix the problem is itself rooted in the logic of hyperindividualism, where atomized individuals can be replaced by other atomized individuals to achieve net conservation or even gain according to the numbers. Cultural realities are totally ignored. The rate of immigration that a country can successfully absorb is not enough to outpace demographic decline. Exceeding that rate undermines the whole point of using immigration to compensate for demographic decline in the first place, since mass migrations are always harmful to host populations. You’re basically talking the collapse of the host populace and the formation of new ones in its place. Furthermore, immigration drains the populations of other countries, ones that are likely also facing demographic issues, which basically makes richer countries parasitic and callous about the continuity and futures of other peoples, until there are no more populations to drain of people anymore.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by babyent on Monday May 26, 2025 @05:13AM (#44095498)
Please only educated immigrants who will need to assimilate to the culture.

I’m an immigrant, and I think at least where I live in USA we need to stop immigration from any random place or of people who refuse to assimilate.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by mmooss on Sunday May 25, 2025 @03:24PM (#44090284)
That omits the essential fact that economies tend to grow - quite a bit over your lifetime. 2% compounded annual growth over 50 years will result in the economy being 2.7x its starting size.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by SpicyLemonZest on Sunday May 25, 2025 @03:38PM (#44090395)
Economic growth in the abstract doesn't help much, because a retiree is only on the consumer side of the equation. 2% compounded annual growth over 50 years will result in the average worker consuming a lot more stuff, and they're not going to be happy if they have to throw that all out and embrace a 1970s-era standard of living when they retire.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by mmooss on Sunday May 25, 2025 @03:48PM (#44090485)
> Economic growth in the abstract doesn't help much

True, but economic growth is very real.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by tossandthrow on Monday May 26, 2025 @03:49PM (#44100992)
Why?

And established elsewhere is this post, people apparently don't want to live like we did 50 years ago, so economic growth has merely been translated into inflated expectations.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by mmooss on Tuesday May 27, 2025 @10:28AM (#44107347)
> economic growth has merely been translated into inflated expectations

It's been translated into far better services too.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by hmmokidk on Sunday May 25, 2025 @02:16PM (#44089710)
Can also just raise taxes on the super rich
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by bombcar on Sunday May 25, 2025 @02:31PM (#44089834)
A 99.9% wealth tax on US billionaires would cover the annual deficit for about 1.5 years.

The scale of the problem is absolutely mind-blowing.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by layer8 on Sunday May 25, 2025 @03:59PM (#44090567)
I’d say that “super rich” starts well below billionaires.

Not saying that the math would work out without problems then.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by AdrianB1 on Sunday May 25, 2025 @04:15PM (#44090692)
My grandpa went to prison (in Romania) in the 1950-es for being part of bourgeoise class because he fixed and ran a broken mill. He was a war refugee (from Romania to Romania) without any money, land or any other resources, but in Communist Romania running a mill would tag you as "super rich". I guess this is what you wanted to say there, correct?
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by layer8 on Sunday May 25, 2025 @04:27PM (#44090792)
I consider myself reasonably well-off but am unlikely to become even a millionaire in my life (inflation-adjusted). I’d say millionaire = rich, 10-20 million or more = super rich. See also https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-net-worth_individual.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by bethekidyouwant on Sunday May 25, 2025 @09:33PM (#44093073)
10% of Americans are millionaires you just need to own a home
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by layer8 on Sunday May 25, 2025 @10:00PM (#44093244)
Then 10% of Americans are rich, I guess.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by bombcar on Monday May 26, 2025 @08:03AM (#44096612)
If we assume the wealthy own the stock market, it’s $52 trillion - enough to pay off the debt and leave $16 trillion left over - which would cover about ten years (assuming the debt service has been removed by the payoff).

Whether nationalizing the entire US market would be worth it is left to the reader.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by FirmwareBurner on Sunday May 25, 2025 @02:41PM (#44089911)
US annual deficit/debt is a meaningless number since it just prints as much money as it needs being the world reserve currency. It's a looney toons number.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by IndubitableCoil on Sunday May 25, 2025 @02:52PM (#44090004)
This really isn't true. I am not deficit doomer, but you can't say its meaningless. The US paid $881 billion on interest on its debt last year. This is on par with the DoD. Yes, it's still only around a tenth of the US's total budget, but it is not hard to imagine the debt going up by 10 times. With the same interest rates, we then the US will pay as much in interest as the rest of the budget combined. If the US just needs to "print as much money as it needs", there is a certain point at which it will become hyperinflationary.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by gambiting on Sunday May 25, 2025 @02:55PM (#44090038)
It's worth noting that it pays that interest back to itself. The risk of becoming hyperinflationary is real, but US can continue ignoring the problem pretty much indefinitely as long as other countries do their trading in US dollar.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by HDThoreaun on Monday May 26, 2025 @12:35PM (#44098990)
Other countries dump the dollar as soon the US makes credible plans to print money in order to sustain the deficit.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by Ray20 on Sunday May 25, 2025 @04:03PM (#44090600)
You can, but it won't help. Commie, as always, do not understand the basics of mathematics.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by Buttons840 on Sunday May 25, 2025 @04:13PM (#44090678)
The top 1% pay like 25% of all taxes. If we want to increase tax revenue 25%, we can just double the taxes on the top 1%. This might cause some of the top 1% to suffer the extreme suffering of being in the top 2%.

What part of the math am I not understanding?

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by Ray20 on Sunday May 25, 2025 @04:36PM (#44090869)
>The top 1% pay like 25% of all taxes. If we want to increase tax revenue 25%, we can just double the taxes on the top 1%.

Just look at the countries that have already done this. What share of taxes does their top 1% pay, and does that consistent with your model? Or does the reality show exactly the opposite result?

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by Buttons840 on Sunday May 25, 2025 @04:52PM (#44091003)
You'll have to tell me. It's time to make your argument, because it's not obvious.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by namdnay on Sunday May 25, 2025 @01:16PM (#44089216)
The trap is the worse the imbalance gets, the harder (1) gets electorally
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by tossandthrow on Sunday May 25, 2025 @01:18PM (#44089233)
Number 1 is likely the outcome of passivity - inflation will eat away the value of the pension.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by namdnay on Sunday May 25, 2025 @01:22PM (#44089261)
In many countries pensions are indexed on inflation… so there is no natural erosion unfortunately
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by WinstonSmith84 on Sunday May 25, 2025 @01:43PM (#44089437)
Typically EU countries implement the 3 options together - option 1. btw is meant to make the pension irrelevant. It can't happen from one day to the next, but there is a shift happening where people contribute more and more towards private pension funds. It's easy to see that at some point, there will be the equivalent of the US 401K in Europe.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by distances on Sunday May 25, 2025 @03:07PM (#44090138)
> It's easy to see that at some point, there will be the equivalent of the US 401K in Europe.

* In some European countries. Many countries, however, have no meaningful avenues whatsoever for tax efficient pension saving. My own "pension fund" is just a regular broker account where I invest after income taxes, and where I have to pay capital gains as usual.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by tossandthrow on Sunday May 25, 2025 @03:17PM (#44090226)
Denmark does have ratepension, which is exactly that.

People with good private pensions can decide to retire 5 years before they officially retire.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by robaato on Sunday May 25, 2025 @03:05PM (#44090124)
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by Ray20 on Sunday May 25, 2025 @04:08PM (#44090635)
It turns out you won't have a problem funding your pension system if you literally pump out millions of dollars' worth of oil per person.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by rad_gruchalski on Sunday May 25, 2025 @03:13PM (#44090187)
Not everyone sits on a bazillion tons of natural gas and oil. Also, there are 5.5 million people in Norway. Though, Denmark is almost the same population, they have no bazillion tons of oil and natural gas. See the problem?
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by CamperBob2 on Sunday May 25, 2025 @03:25PM (#44090300)
You forgot step -1: Use time machine constructed in step 3.5 to seed nearby oceans with phytoplankton and other organic carbon reservoirs
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by keybored on Sunday May 25, 2025 @05:40PM (#44091441)
Norway is also going to raise the retirement age.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by dyauspitr on Sunday May 25, 2025 @01:35PM (#44089366)
4. Stop spending 90% of healthcare costs on 5% of chronic problem beneficiaries.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by tossandthrow on Sunday May 25, 2025 @01:40PM (#44089414)
That is increasing tax.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by dyauspitr on Sunday May 25, 2025 @06:04PM (#44091623)
How? Less tax but 5% of people get worse healthcare.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by lostlogin on Sunday May 25, 2025 @01:24PM (#44089270)
2 has some options. Increase the number of (young) immigrants. Increase the birthrate (has anywhere managed this?).
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by tossandthrow on Sunday May 25, 2025 @01:25PM (#44089280)
Birthrates are problematic as it usually take 20 to 25 years before they pay taxes. And in that time they require a lot of expenses.

They talk abiut the squeeze, if Birthrates increase too suddenly - workers would both have to pay for the elderly and the kids.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by spacebanana7 on Sunday May 25, 2025 @01:40PM (#44089419)
This is the real demographic death trap, and why Taiwan and South Korea are probably past the point of no return.

If one generation has a fertility rate of 1 child per woman, the next must have 4 children per woman to undo the demographic change.

The people in the “corrective” generation must support their own two elderly parents plus four of their own children. It becomes practically impossible.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by lostlogin on Sunday May 25, 2025 @02:03PM (#44089604)
> The people in the “corrective” generation must support their own two elderly parents plus four of their own children. It becomes practically impossible.

The country and the individual has the same problem. But it also goes a generation further.

There was a link on HN recently which I can’t find. It discussed how we are in an unusual time, where kids can often meet their great grandparents. Previously people died younger, so couldn’t. Now people are having kids at an age where it will be unlikely for them to meet their great grandchildren.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by gambiting on Sunday May 25, 2025 @03:01PM (#44090087)
>>Previously people died younger, so couldn’t

I'm not sure that's true - people died younger, sure, but they also had kids much earlier. Even assuming 18 for first child(and it often was earlier than 18), you'd be a great grandparent at the age of 54 - and people have commonly lived that long even in antiquity.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by lostlogin on Sunday May 25, 2025 @03:22PM (#44090273)
Have a look at the graph here - ‘Life expectancy by world region, from 1770 to 2018’

The average lifespans was only 40-something until the 1850-1950 range.

I’m sure plenty lived longer, but the average was terrible.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Life_expectancy

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by messe on Sunday May 25, 2025 @03:32PM (#44090356)
Those figures are heavily skewed by high infant mortality rates.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by rightbyte on Sunday May 25, 2025 @04:53PM (#44091011)
Read the "other measures" part of the article.

"While the most common age of death in adulthood among modern hunter-gatherers (often taken as a guide to the likely most favourable Paleolithic demographic experience) is estimated to average 72 years,[169] the number dying at that age is dwarfed by those (over a fifth of all infants) dying in the first year of life, and only around a quarter usually survive to the higher age."

Etc.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by bethekidyouwant on Sunday May 25, 2025 @09:42PM (#44093129)
Yeah, I don’t know why people actually believe everyone died at 40 clearly that that’s not true. You’ve met a 40-year-old, right? Here’s a popular one include all the abortions as deaths and you’ll see that the average age that we live now is also 40
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by gambiting on Monday May 26, 2025 @01:00AM (#44094101)
Why would you include abortions too? My wife had a miscarriage at 3 months in, should we include that in stats too?
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by dtech on Sunday May 25, 2025 @02:40PM (#44089902)
Getting to a fertility rate of 2.1 will at least mean the problem will end at some point and the population will be stable, altough it will take the better half of a century.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by gambiting on Sunday May 25, 2025 @02:58PM (#44090062)
This is a nice explanation from Kurzgesagt showing precisely why South Korea is completely screwed long term, and why it's impossible to course correct through birth rate alone:

https://youtu.be/Ufmu1WD2TSk?si=3mMFke_Rj6b3jWld

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by spacebanana7 on Sunday May 25, 2025 @01:34PM (#44089361)
Israel is the only developed country which has a sustained positive fertility rate.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by lazyasciiart on Sunday May 25, 2025 @01:41PM (#44089430)
But that’s not an example of a solution - the birth rate is driven by orthodox citizens who don’t participate in mainstream society, so they aren’t going to pay taxes or care for the elderly (outside their own family).
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by spacebanana7 on Sunday May 25, 2025 @01:44PM (#44089445)
Yeah it’s a pessimistic data point because it’s challenging to replicate Israel’s unique circumstances and also it’s not clear this solution is even good for Israel.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by ImHereToVote on Sunday May 25, 2025 @02:28PM (#44089813)
Seems like the US taxpayer should subsidize all countries as much as they subsidize Israel. That would fix it.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by ido on Sunday May 25, 2025 @03:08PM (#44090153)
US economic aid to Israel ended in 2007 (18 years ago).

The US since then only provides Israel with military aid (most of which is only allowed to be spent buying US-made goods). It’s more of a subsidy for the US military-industrial complex.

Also despite the military aid Israel still spends a much greater share of GDP on its military than most or all other developed countries (so the US isn't subsidising Israel’s unusually high birth rate).

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by arandomusername on Sunday May 25, 2025 @05:35PM (#44091387)
> It’s more of a subsidy for the US military-industrial complex.

That's a funny way to twist it. US is providing aid to Israel. Billions a year.

US also provides indirect aid, through protection or aid to neighbouring countries (e.g Jordan and Egypt) as bribes so they play nice with Israel.

And who knows, with the way the Iran thing is panning out, you might be paying a lot more if US decides to bomb Iran on Israel's request

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by ido on Sunday May 25, 2025 @05:51PM (#44091523)
And how does this explain Israel's abnormal birth rate (what ImHereToVote suggested in the parent comment)? I claim it's unrelated and is mostly to do with cultural and religious norms.

If the US starts sending proportional military aid to South Korea (fertility rate of 0.75 vs Israel's 2.83) it will not "fix it".

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by arandomusername on Sunday May 25, 2025 @07:52PM (#44092440)
I went a bit off-topic, just wanted to comment on the extra aid they receive. I do agree that it's not because of the US aid.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by ido on Monday May 26, 2025 @01:15AM (#44094177)
I agree my reply was flippant because I was annoyed by the original comment, and I apologise for that.

The US provides and provided a ton of assistance to Israel but there’s a tendency online for people (probably mostly Americans?) to assign credit to literally everything that happens in Israel to US aid.

Israel exists outside of US-Israel politics and not everything (like birthrates) that happens there is because of the US. The US also supported/aided a lot of other countries that didn’t experience the same economic/industrial/technological development that Israel has in the last 30-40 years - some of it really is because of Israelis’ efforts and not just because of Americans’.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by lostlogin on Sunday May 25, 2025 @09:24PM (#44093028)
> US economic aid to Israel ended in 2007 (18 years ago). The US since then only provides Israel with military aid (most of which is only allowed to be spent buying US-made goods).

That’s one hell of a disclaimer on the statement.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by dvfjsdhgfv on Sunday May 25, 2025 @02:05PM (#44089626)
> Increase the number of (young) immigrants

Increase the number of (young female) immigrants

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by grunder_advice on Sunday May 25, 2025 @01:56PM (#44089547)
Mormons and Amish have above replacement fertility rates. Millionaires in western countries also have above replacement fertility rates.

To me it seems rather obvious: you need both the will and the means to raise 3+ children.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by arrowsmith on Sunday May 25, 2025 @02:51PM (#44089997)
I’m not sure it’s about having the “means”, since birth rates were far higher in the past when everybody was much poorer.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by Spivak on Sunday May 25, 2025 @03:28PM (#44090322)
You can solve the means problem by making everyone wealthier or by lowering everyone's expectations. The problem is that "how much it costs to raise children" is dependent on your environment. One group's normal is another's neglectful parenting.

The catch-22 is that the people you presumably want to be having more children— educated working professionals— have some of the highest social standards for child rearing.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by logicchains on Sunday May 25, 2025 @02:16PM (#44089719)
Shouldn't it be the will or the means, not the will and the means, giving how relatively poor the Amish are in financial terms?
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by bombcar on Sunday May 25, 2025 @02:32PM (#44089853)
The Amish have the means because their means are not measured in normal dollar amounts. Most of what they have is traded and transacted outside of the dollar economy.

In fact, they may majority be of subsistence in which case the entire dollar value of all of their stuff is simply the land.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by risyachka on Sunday May 25, 2025 @03:35PM (#44090376)
4. They must attract skilled immigrants in significant numbers.

Most don't want to so they have to compensate via taxes and higher pension age.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by littlestymaar on Sunday May 25, 2025 @01:21PM (#44089251)
You are missing the most important one:

- increase productivity more than how much the workforce/receivers grow.

And if AI/robots eventually deliver, we're soon going to need a discussion about lowering the retirement age to 55 or even 50 if we don't want 30% unemployment anyway.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by carlosjobim on Sunday May 25, 2025 @03:54PM (#44090532)
Productivity has already increased several times over while the working age population has decreased. Working the young population into extermination is the current paradigm and is giving the current results, which is all according to plan.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by tossandthrow on Sunday May 25, 2025 @01:26PM (#44089297)
That would be raising taxes.

- indifferent to how much automation you have, people still need to pay for it, for money they don't earn.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by StackRanker3000 on Sunday May 25, 2025 @01:48PM (#44089469)
Automation and increased productivity can also lower the cost of necessities such as food and health care, meaning retired people could theoretically get by with less.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by tossandthrow on Sunday May 25, 2025 @01:59PM (#44089579)
No.

A part of necessities are access to assets.

In the model you propose, inequality in itself will make those more expensive.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by littlestymaar on Sunday May 25, 2025 @01:34PM (#44089358)
When people refer to “raise taxes” they usually talk about raising the rates, but you don't need to raise rates, if the GDP increase then the amount collected through taxes increases even if you don't change the rate.

And as such, it feels like labelling that “raise taxes” is disingenuous.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by tossandthrow on Sunday May 25, 2025 @01:38PM (#44089382)
Exactly, another way to increase taxes is also by increasing gdp.

Indeed the normal Understanding is not only about increasing rates - look at Switzerland eg.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by littlestymaar on Monday May 26, 2025 @02:46AM (#44094661)
I'd you really wanted to fit this square peg into your artificial triangle hole, I'd argue that in practice this is closer to “lowering benefits” than to “raise taxes” since the purchasing power of the retired would decline compare to the population average.

But again, there's no basis to chose just your three items in particular.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by tossandthrow on Tuesday May 27, 2025 @04:52PM (#44110581)
This is not fitting anything into anywhere. This is how economists think about.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by littlestymaar on Wednesday May 28, 2025 @02:50AM (#44113303)
Economists working on pensions think about productivity a lot, and they don't bundle that in your “raise taxes” category.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by lostlogin on Sunday May 25, 2025 @01:27PM (#44089303)
The money made and saved isn’t going to go to governments and the population though. As it stands, a couple of billionaires will become richer.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by littlestymaar on Sunday May 25, 2025 @02:47PM (#44089955)
That's a political decision though, and they try to hide it behind this kind of false trilemma.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by jxjnskkzxxhx on Sunday May 25, 2025 @01:52PM (#44089508)
What does "reduce pensions" mean? Pensions are people's property. You can take pensions like you can confiscate property, a la communism.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by rsynnott on Sunday May 25, 2025 @02:10PM (#44089662)
In this case you're talking about state pensions, which are a form of social welfare.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by nicolashahn on Sunday May 25, 2025 @01:56PM (#44089545)
So close! Pensions are actually property taken from the younger generation and given to retirees.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by pmg101 on Sunday May 25, 2025 @02:14PM (#44089696)
I think this is just the word "pension" being overloaded, meaning both

1. A state provided welfare benefit Or 2. A privately held long term savings/investment account

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by m4rtink on Sunday May 25, 2025 @02:30PM (#44089828)
Isn't it essentially a thanks/appreciation for what the people built once they retire ? Without theire work, there would be nothing for the younger people to use and benefit from.

Would not be very motivational if you work hard your whole life and then you are considered a useless burden once you retire.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by bee_rider on Sunday May 25, 2025 @02:39PM (#44089896)
I’ll take the thanks/appreciation in the form of wages instead, thanks!
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by jonathanstrange on Sunday May 25, 2025 @03:05PM (#44090122)
Those retirees have been paying into the pension system their whole life.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by mattlondon on Sunday May 25, 2025 @03:12PM (#44090178)
So have younger people too, just their life has not been as long (yet).

The way it usually works is taxation from the current working generation pays for the current retirees. You are not paying into your own account for later (that is a private pension)

FWIW in the UK there are more children in poverty (so their parents too) than retirees who are in poverty. Kids don't vote though...

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by jonathanstrange on Sunday May 25, 2025 @03:42PM (#44090421)
IMHO it's a matter of basic justice. If you're forced to pay an amount for pension funds that you cannot even chose and have no control over for your whole work life, then you better should get a an adequate pension when it's time. As for the example from the UK (not comparable to Denmark), I don't see why someone who worked their ass off their whole life should be poor because some parents are too poor to have children. That seems to be a different problem.

What's annoying about these debates is that the people who'd e.g. like to see pension cuts are either young and will change their mind later, or they are so rich that none of this matters to them anyway and the latter shouldn't even have a voice in this debate.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by mattlondon on Monday May 26, 2025 @04:11AM (#44095154)
> I don't see why someone who worked their ass off their whole life should be poor because some parents are too poor to have children.

The issue is the "triple lock" (state pension rises by either rate of inflation, average earnings increases, or 2.5%).

While laudable in intent, recently this has led to situations where pensioners are getting bumper increases linked to high inflation, while the younger working age people are getting stagnant wages while inflation shoots up.

This is is why pensioners are on average getting wealthier than the working population. Let that settle in for a moment: pensioners are getting more wealthy than the working population that is financing the pensioner's increase in wealth.

This is universally accepted as unsustainable and deeply unfair on an intergenerational basis as the pensioners - who generally tend to own their own homes and also get various benefits like free transport and extra money for heating costs etc as well as benefiting from more generous policies/working conditions of the past like free university education and final-salary private pensions or purchasing government-built social housing at steeply-discounted rates - continue to get more and more well-off while the people financing their retirement are struggling with soaring costs, zero-hour contracts, stagnant wages and all the rest. Yet pensioners complain that they paid their taxes so they deserve to cripple the current workers who also pay their taxes.

Trouble is that it is a political landmine since pensioners are a big part of the vote so no one has the balls to abolish (or at least reform) the triple lock.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by budding2141 on Sunday May 25, 2025 @03:17PM (#44090222)
Yeah, but they paid a vastly lower percentage of their paycheck than people nowadays do (at least here in western EU)
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by Ray20 on Sunday May 25, 2025 @04:13PM (#44090677)
Another reason not to repeat their mistake.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by jonathanstrange on Monday May 26, 2025 @04:32AM (#44095274)
It's not a choice. You're forced to pay for the pension system in Denmark and most other countries if you're employed. The only thing governments have to do is to use that money for actual pension funds instead of embezzling it, and to calculate the contributions on a reasonable basis with reasonable extrapolations about inflation, i.e., to properly finance these funds now and not abuse them for other purposes.

It's mysterious why they haven't done that despite the fact that the demographic problems were known to occur up to 40 years ago. But you see the same thing with housing prices and rents, forthcoming problems were already obvious 20 years ago in every country, yet only few have tried to deal with them in time. Maybe someone else can explain where this inertia comes from, I always found it strange.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by Ray20 on Monday May 26, 2025 @08:29AM (#44096822)
>It's mysterious why they haven't done that despite the fact that the demographic problems were known to occur up to 40 years ago.

Because it goes against their personal interests.

Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by carlosjobim on Sunday May 25, 2025 @03:57PM (#44090552)
It's much worse than that, it is indebted servitude being done to the younger generation.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by jxjnskkzxxhx on Sunday May 25, 2025 @04:23PM (#44090757)
Its not "so close" - the pensions that I'm familiar with are exactly what I described. They're basically a special tax treatment for my assets.
Re:Denmark to raise retirement age to 70 by jltsiren on Sunday May 25, 2025 @05:45PM (#44091478)
And capital gains are actually property taken from the workers and given to capitalists. In both cases, the recipients have magic tokens that legally entitle them to some of the value created by other people.

I don't know how this works in other countries. In Finland, it was established decades ago that pensions based on past contributions are constitutionally protected private property. Because people made explicit pension contributions and because the government promised that the future pension would be based on the individual contributions, the government can't alter the deal substantially without a constitutional amendment. If the contributions had been general taxes, or if the promised pension had been independent of the actual contributions, ordinary legislative process would have been enough.