At least the most useless, overpaid person in SV is finally gone and no longer collecting her $7M salary.
Not like money has ever been a problem at Mozilla - they're sitting on over $1.5B in assets, $500M or so in cash alone. That's despite a plunging market share...
Every home network needs a MITM proxy too.
I have been running one for long time now. I depend on it so much that I cannot imagine using the internet without it. It is much smaller and easier to compile than a graphical browser.
Others will have different opinions but I personally remain skeptical that TLS provides internet users with more value than it provides so-called "tech" companies that profit from data collection, surveillance and online advertising services, and the CDNs that collaborate with them. While it can be used to protect a computer owners' data from eavesdroppers as it transits across the open internet, e.g., during "e-commerce", in practice TLS is used to conceal data exfiltration from the computer owner for commercial purposes by so-called "tech" companies. Not to mention the issue of "Certificate Authorities".
IMO, this is analogous to the situation with Javascript. It has the potential to provide value to www users, e.g., as a language computer owners can use to extend and control a graphical browser,^1 but in practice it provides the most value to so-called tech "companies" that are using it to control _someone else's_ browser to allow unauthorised and/or concealed data collection and surveillance.
1. https://raw.githubusercontent.com/bambax/hntitles/refs/heads...
I agree completely.
Google pushed HTTPS because it ensures that they are the only ones who can spy on users.
I think TLS can be helpful (for both sides of a communication), but the browser should not require it, and most servers also should not require it (but should allow it, if you deliberately choose to connect with TLS). HSTS is especially bad (I managed to disable it on my computer by using a hex editor so that the browser would no longer recognize the Strict-Transport-Security header).
Certificates can be helpful if you actually know which ones you specifically trust for a specific purpose (rather than being automatic), and if they will tell you information about a business (although as far as I know, Let's Encrypt does not do this and only verifies the domain name). However, sometimes if a certificate is changed or superseded, due to expiry, or change in ownership, etc, and it does not prevent the server operator from sending you malware; it only prevents spies from doing so. If a domain name is sold to someone else, that does not prevent cookies and other stuff from being sent, or from them adding malware, etc; however, it would be possible for end users to know the certificate to trust and avoid this problem (if a browser can be programmed to do this).
Client certificates could be helpful for authentication too, but this is rare with HTTPS (but it is commonly used with Gemini protocol). But, it does prevent someone who takes over the domain name from being able to use your information to log in, since a private key is required in order to use a client certificate.
Furthermore, the browser really should allow unencrypted proxies for encrypted connections, in order that if you deliberately want MITM then you do not need to encrypt and decrypt the data multiple times.
> IMO, this is analogous to the situation with Javascript. It has the potential to provide value to www users, e.g., as a language computer owners can use to extend and control a graphical browser ...
Yes, as well as other programming languages (if a browser supports it, which most don't).
(I disable JavaScripts on my computer, except for the scripts that I wrote by myself. I did write scripts to replace GitHub's UI (in much less lines of code than GitHub uses themself), and other things.)
Once retrieved, I load the DNS data into the memmory of the "MITM proxy". This eliminates the need for DNS queries to be immediately proceeding associated HTTP requests for web pages, etc., or within some DNS cache duration period.
When I use other sources of DNS data^1, I eliminate the need for remote DNS queries altogether.
1. For example, I extract DNS data from Common Crawl data.
Indeed, it does not seem like DoH was implemented to improve life for computer users but, at least for me, it can be useful. It can also be useful for example to computer users who use remote DNS servers where their ISP is hijacking port 53.
1. Test: https://defo.ie
This doomsday scenario thinking really doesn’t help the discussion.
JFC, it's funny they try to call this out as some kind of a "weird" definition when that's just... what selling is.
<completely unambiguous definition of selling follows>
50 states, plus Federal laws, and all the other countries of the world and internal jurisdictions is how many possible variations? And before you say "Yeah, but they all mean mostly the same thing", remember it's lawyers we're dealing with, who will happily charge large sums of money arguing over misplaced punctuation and legislators who will happily take bribes from those same lawyers.
Seems safest to assume that if it can be tracked, it will be. And traded too.
If it's as innocent as "Firefox has to send HTTP packets to arbitrary web servers to achieve the fundamental function of loading a page" and that web server is considered 3rd party by CCPA, then everyone would understand... this is either poor communication or they are hiding something else (which everyone should rightly assume in this day and age).
Just tell us already Mozilla!
> In order to make Firefox commercially viable, there are a number of places where we collect and share some data with our partners, including our optional ads on New Tab and providing sponsored suggestions in the search bar.
And remember, they’re citing CCPA’s definition as meaning “… in exchange for ‘monetary’ or ‘other valuable considerations’”. This is exactly what people mean by “selling”.
It’s not the innocent thing you’re contemplating, about a browser doing its job. It’s specifically about things like serving ads, making that browser “commercially viable”.
Mozilla is stopping claiming they’re never selling your data because they’ve been selling your data for the last few years.
Mozilla is helping perpetuate the illusion that online advertising necessarily includes collecting and selling data about the users who are shown the ads.
See for example,
https://www.adexchanger.com/privacy/mozilla-acquires-anonym-...
"That shared mission is predicated on the notion that advertising and privacy are not – or at least don’t have to be – mutually exclusive."
And it goes into detail on the investment and technology in that area.
> Mozilla collects technical and interaction data, such as the position, size, views and clicks on New Tab content or ads, to understand how people are interacting with our content and to personalize future content, including sponsored content. This data may be shared with our advertising partners on a de-identified or aggregated basis.
There's a lot of tracking data that does leave the user's computer, and Mozilla is trying to justify it by assuring us it's sufficiently anonymized and aggregated—assurances they would not need to make if the data wasn't changing hands.
It's also silly to suggest that targeting advertising without tracking users needs to be "pioneered". It's obvious that Mozilla could have the browser download this month's list of sponsored search keywords and have the browser check search strings against that list, without going off-device. There's no innovation required to implement that. All the attempted innovation is focused on how to exfiltrate data in a form that they can get away with selling.
It's meaningless data to you: It doesn't say what you click on, just where and how big the ads are, and how many times you click. It doesn't identify you or reveal anything about you, except that you clicked on some unknown ads.
> It's also silly to suggest that targeting advertising without tracking users needs to be "pioneered". It's obvious that Mozilla could have the browser download this month's list of sponsored search keywords and have the browser check search strings against that list, without going off-device.
These are the words of someone who hasn't done it. Look at the article; what advertisers want and what the privacy-destroying competition does is much more sophisticated than what you describe. For example,
Anonym also has technology that allows ad platforms and advertisers to securely share encrypted impression and conversion data within a trusted execution environment for attribution, causal lift measurement and lookalike modeling. (A trusted execution environment is the secure area of a main processor where code can be run safely and in isolation.)
To be fair, the major ad platforms have long offered attribution and measurement solutions, Mudd said. “But they required the data to come into their system,” he added. “In this world, that doesn’t have to happen.”
I'm not sure what you mean by "meaningless data to you". Obviously, the data Mozilla is collecting, aggregating, and selling is meaningful to the buyers. And you're straight up lying about the extent of the data, directly contradicting Mozilla's Privacy Notice.
> Look at the article; what advertisers want and what the privacy-destroying competition does is much more sophisticated than what you describe.
Obviously? What I was describing was how it's possible to target an advertisement without doing any user tracking. What the advertisers want to do and are doing is tracking users as much as they can get away with. And that includes the ad tracking company Mozilla bought.
You are going too far in your 'pile on Mozilla' performance.
I decide whats meaningless to me. Not you. Not mozilla.
At what point does user data stop being user data? I don't think aggregation is enough in some of these discussions, but maybe I'm wrong.
If that's true then it sounds to me like there's some liability to sue for in California courts against Mozilla. I wonder if EFF would be interested
What is collected by telemetry is documented here for desktop [1].
[1] https://firefox-source-docs.mozilla.org/toolkit/components/t...
If they can't stop abusing their users, I will look for another browser, goddamnit.
This seems to go beyond "can't stop" to "are actively plotting a course to continue." I've seen a lot of missteps from Mozilla over the years, but I never thought I'd see them selling my data. From seeing the news yesterday to today, I know now I have to stop recommending Firefox, and figure out a browser that I can trust.
* Blink (Google): Used in everything, from Chrome, Edge, Opera, Qt-Toolkit, Electron.
* Gecko (Mozilla): Firefox. And Waterfox? I assume Gecko is still hard to integrate.
* WebKit and WebKitGtk (Apple and Gtk): Safari, Epiphany and Gtk-Toolkit. Easy to integrate. And the only engine where I’m aware that actually two side actively cooperate in development.
Epiphany is small and nice, but they need a lot more developers. And I think they should use ffmpeg, gstreamer seems to be a source of issues for many years. But again, they need us, every helper capable of C++ is welcome.Ladybird an another new engine, implemented in C++. But it is in alpha-state, only for developers. Everyone else who tries to show us a new browser means “use that Google thing with another name on it”.
(It is very usable already in combination with Tauri as alternative to Electron + Chromium)
* Librewolf, Palemoon, Falkon.
Palemoon is based on an outdated fork of Gecko.
Falkon uses QtWebEngine, which is Blink.
I honestly think we need to shift our trusted computing base off of C/C++. There's no way a ragtag bunch of volunteers puts enough effort into security when every minor mistake is a disaster :-(
I use Firefox. I hate ads. I don't love that Mozilla engages in some level of affiliate deals to pay the bills, but it's the only viable alternative to Google controlling the entire web and doing much worse tracking/advertising at this point, unless Mozilla can figure out some other revenue stream.
Chromium-based "privacy-focused" browsers can only exist as long as they're not popular enough to move the needle on Google's ad business. Firefox derivatives can only exist as long as Mozilla can pay the bills, which they almost certainly can't do if nobody uses Firefox (no reason for Google to pay for search priority for an audience of zero, and no affiliate deals for an audience of zero).
The more people use Firefox forks, the sooner Google controls everything. You might personally benefit in the short term, with "complete" privacy, so I can understand why some might choose that option, but you need to accept that you're contributing to Google's dominance by doing so.
Pretty sure that community project will get overwhelmingly big donations from all over.
Software don't need AI-hyping 6 million dollar swallowing CEO's
Mozilla could have added years ago a donation or subscription to fund the development of Firefox, but they don't want that. Mozilla wants all the money for its charitable activities instead.
There will be a time when they have no money anymore, but it's only their fault.
Charitable is a really nice wording tbh:
https://foundation.mozilla.org/en/campaigns/
https://foundation.mozilla.org/en/what-we-fund/programs/
They have the AI virus, i don't see Firefox once mentioned on that page, it's as absurd.
Although their $7 mil CEO could have found a way to handle this while not running afoul of the IRS, but she decided to play with a bunch of dead-end commercial endeavors instead. So that's on them.
Describing Mozilla's derailment as "charitable activities" is like describing the Mexican cartels as "self-help groups".
Never forget their "We need more than deplatforming".
They were doing fine as a business under Eich, whatever you think of him. They make over $500M just from their search box - and frankly, that is way more than you need to make a fantastic browser. And Thunderbird.
Baker took home over $7M a year for the past six years, and though she stepped down as CEO, we don't know if they even cut her pay, or what the other top tier salaries are [1]. Mozilla is a "open" company, but they announced that they will "not be disclosing salaries" after Baker stepped down.
Kagi makes a browser with 35 employees and ~200K inn sales. And I know, they are not building from scratch - but neither is FF at this point. It is ridiculous to suggest that Mozilla will go under if they don't become spyware.
Well do it, i had Firefox on all my machines for about 15 years, change to librewolf took like 20 minutes on all machines...and it even feels more responsive, and i dont have have to install uBlock manually and other settings by hand, like disable those experiments mozilla can install:
https://librewolf.net/#main-features
And if you de-install firefox on windows you can even tell them why you did it ;)
Now people will read even more carefully their privacy policy https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/privacy/firefox/#notice and may find things like:
> Firefox also shows its own search suggestions based on information stored on your local device (including recent search terms, open tabs, and previously visited URLs). These suggestions may include sponsored suggestions from Mozilla’s partners [...] or relevant URLs that are popular in your country.
> Mozilla processes [...] how many searches you perform, how many sponsored suggestions you see and whether you interact with them.
> Mozilla collects technical and interaction data, such as the position, size, views and clicks on New Tab content or ads, to understand how people are interacting with our content [...] This data may be shared with our advertising partners on a de-identified or aggregated basis.
> we share data across Mozilla-controlled affiliates and subsidiaries. We [...] disclose personal data as part of a corporate transaction, such as a merger, acquisition, sale of assets or similar transaction
> [...] retain personal data for more than 25 months, but actual retention periods may vary depending on the type of data and the purpose(s) for which it was collected
[Definitions]
> Technical data : Device type, operating system, IP address, ISP
> Settings: Enhanced Tracking Protection settings, cookie settings, permissions (location, camera, microphone), toolbar customization.
> Location : Country code, city.
> Precise Location: Your precise location (within a few feet or meters).
> Interaction data : How many tabs you have open or what you’ve clicked on. Click counts, impression data, attribution data, how many searches performed, time on page, ad and sponsored tile clicks.
> Browsing data: [...] websites and URLs you’ve visited. [...] (travel, shopping, social media), top level domains (example.com) or specific web pages visited.
> Firefox also shows its own search suggestions based on information stored on your local device
That data stays on your computer ...
> Mozilla processes [...] how many searches you perform, how many sponsored suggestions you see and whether you interact with them.
That description contains no user content: number of searches, number of ads, whether you interact says nothing about you - it doesn't say what you click on or see, just that you clicked.
> position, size, views and clicks on New Tab content or ads
Again, there is no content mentioned, just number of clicks and not what you click on.
> [Definitions]
This section defines terms; it doesn't say they are doing anything.
Advertiser: "Show this to users who like Candles."
Mozilla: "OK"
That's pretty standard and can be used to track people on the advertiser's side still, depending on how the ad itself is served and how clicks on the ad are processed.
If not, when it queries to find out which ads to serve, what data does is sent with that query (or prior to that query)?
https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/advertising/
https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/foundation/annualreport/2024/a...
Advertising is, unfortunately, necessary to funding most of the web, and targeting is necessary to advertising. As a result, users are surveiled and tracked heavily.
But imagine if the targeting could be done without surveillance and tracking - then users could largely use the web in private. It would be revolutionary. That's what Firefox has figured out and is investing more in:
https://www.adexchanger.com/privacy/mozilla-acquires-anonym-...
Mozilla might be doing very sketchy things with your data, but it's also very plausible that they are doing a reasonable job at anonymization of data but in a way that is still technically classified as selling personal data (in aggregate form).
Per: https://thecpra.org/#1798.145(a)(6)
> Exemptions: > (6) Collect, use, retain, sell, share, or disclose consumers’ personal information that is deidentified or aggregate consumer information.
I understand that people who have a vested interest in eroding any possibility of online privacy and data protection would want us to believe these laws are vague and overreaching - but that doesn’t mean they actually are vague and overreaching.
The definition requires Mozilla to do it "in exchange for “monetary” or “other valuable consideration.”". What consideration is Mozilla receiving and from who?
With Mozilla, for example, displaying sponsored links using Firefox Suggest ( https://blog.mozilla.org/en/products/firefox/firefox-news/fi... ) means collecting and sharing personal data (like search keywords, browsing history or bookmarks). This data sharing, with another company, could either be the raw data or the processed data. In either case, it is a problematic issue for any privacy conscious and politically aware user because either party or multiple parties will (or can) create profiles from the data. "Anonymous" data collection doesn't have any meaning here because with enough data points from a particular user, you can reasonably identify a user (either to track them digitally or to even to identify their personhood in real life, for legal or political reasons). This is easier to do so if you also combine it with data from multiple sources. (Which is what the US NSA programs with US BigTech are doing, and why these companies are so valuable today - Data is the new oil).
> With Mozilla, for example, displaying sponsored links using Firefox Suggest ( https://blog.mozilla.org/en/products/firefox/firefox-news/fi... ) means collecting and sharing personal data (like search keywords, browsing history or bookmarks).
That article says it's only opt-in, so you are safe:
As always, we believe people should be in control of their web experience, so Firefox Suggest will be a customizable feature.
We’ll begin offering smarter contextual suggestions to a percentage of people in the U.S. as an opt-in experience.
"They" in this context is Mozilla the organization, not Firefox the process in memory. For Mozilla to collect information, information has to leave my computer and end up on Mozilla's computer.
Funny, I never opt-in to that garbage - and yet Firefox keeps trying to auto-recommend things to me. It does this even in the Firefox Quantum mobile browser.
I don't think Mozilla is being 100% honest.
If it's what I'm thinking, they do it without data about you ever leaving your computer. Look up how it's done - it's game-changing tech for privacy.
"we work with partners, service providers, suppliers and contractors"
But they won't disclose which partners and what Mozilla gets in exchange. Which is opaque, and probably intentionally so.
You can scroll down to the types of data and lawful bases they list for these data exchanges.
[1] https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/privacy/firefox/#how-is-your-d...
But anyway, if anyone thinks FF or any other browser can survive without such commercial deals needs to get ready to use Safari or other minor browser
What monetary or other valuable consideration does HN get from you when HN serves up someone's profile page to you?
Yet the second one, which I think would be very much considered close to harmless from my perspective (compared to an alternative of "an ad is shown to everyone across the world"), would, I think, still fit into this metric of your data being sold.
Though maybe I'm misinterpreting what the CCPA's breadth would be.
I have been a bit disillusioned by FF for some time, and would like for them to figure out some version of a business model in order to survive, and so we can know the contours of that business model. Trying to play "we do not do business things at all" with them constantly shipping weird ad-ful features and stuff like Pocket... let's see if we can make this honest!
And I definitely don't want this:
> You give Mozilla the rights necessary to operate Firefox. This includes processing your data as we describe in the Firefox Privacy Notice. It also includes a nonexclusive, royalty-free, worldwide license for the purpose of doing as you request with the content you input in Firefox. This does not give Mozilla any ownership in that content. [0]
[0] https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/about/legal/terms/firefox/#you...
Why is my browser serving me advertising in the first place? Because Mozilla is an advertising company now.
I don’t use Firefox and this whole thing is distasteful, but I’m not sure how they’re supposed to cover operating expenses without indirect monetization, or what for of indirect other than ads would work.
Speak for yourself.
Give me a browser that clearly and unambiguously does not sell my usage of it in any way, and I will give you a monthly subscription.
There's a third way: screw revenue, dump all staff not related to browser development and documentation (MDN) and look for government grants to fund that.
Especially the EU may be a target for a well-written proposal, given the political atmosphere it would make sense to have at least one browser engine that is not fundamentally tied to the US and its plethora of bullshit like NSLs.
I would, if they offered a payment-only access to Firefox with no added services and no telemetry whatsoever. I'd pay 50€ a year for that.
Is there some interpretation where “for the purpose of doing as you request” means any purpose they want?
I don't want any language where they get to insert themselves into that chain of behavior. Curl doesn't need a TOS, why does Firefox?
When I drill a hole in my wall, DeWalt don't tell anyone who I am, how large a hole it is, what material I drilled into or even the fact that I actually drilled anything. They don't know any of that, and neither should Mozilla know when my local copy of the browser makes a DNS, HTTP or any other request.
Why do you imply that Firefox showing ads is acceptable ?
Because it isn't acceptable.
The first thing I've done (for years now) when configuring Firefox is to turn off many of the defaults. Advertisements, pocket, search engine, online spell checker, translator, blah blah blah.
They're beholden to who gives them money, which is not us.
FF exists off of good will and the search deal. The more people stop using the browser the less they’re going to pull in from the deal.
Firefox exists off of google and their antitrust deal.
If you sell the information how many customers you have and how many shoes you've sold last month, are you selling your customer's personal data?
To make that analogy fair for the scope of what Mozilla's doing, the shoe store would have to be selling data about what color shirts people are wearing when they visit the shoe store.
Firefox is installed on my computer, not on a VPS owned by Mozilla. I'm not browsing Mozilla website. Why are they entitled to record and share everything I do?
But I think the sense Mozilla are referring to is the more obvious and over-the-top things like selling your name, phone number, email, postal address, your Amazon purchasing history, or to ramp it up more, your passwords, your credit card info etc.
> (1) “Sell,” “selling,” “sale,” or “sold,” means selling, renting, releasing, disclosing, disseminating, making available, transferring, or otherwise communicating orally, in writing, or by electronic or other means, a consumer’s personal information by the business to a third party for monetary or other valuable consideration.
Most people would view a sale as Mozilla getting cash back for the data. But that "other valuable consideration" (which the AG declined to clarify or create a factor-based approach for deciding) makes Mozilla vulnerable to lawyers.
The same parasites that claimed that embedding a chatbot on your website violates the California wiretapping laws and have been extracting cash from sites will figure out a way to do the same to Mozilla. see the wave of CIPA chatbot lawsuits.
For instance, suppose Mozilla partners with a search engine and could be claimed to get a discount or some other consideration for letting that search partner use search terms to improve the search engine. Something that isn't advertising related at all. That's probably a sale under CPRA.
If a search engine partner wants to use search terms to improve their search engine, they only have to look at their own logs. They don't need Mozilla to collect, aggregate, and sell them any data to accomplish that. Mozilla doesn't need to worry about selling data if they never possess that data in the first place.
Your complaint about "other valuable consideration" is just a complaint that the law isn't crippled by stupid loopholes.
That's not the law. The search engine partner using those logs is probably valuable consideration and hence a sale. Mozilla doesn't even need to keep the data; just an api passthrough will qualify.
It's not a sale when the search engine doesn't get those logs from Mozilla. When a user sends a search query to Google using a Mozilla browser, it's Google's privacy policy that applies, not Mozilla's.
> Mozilla doesn't even need to keep the data; just an api passthrough will qualify.
There is no API passthrough in this scenario. Search queries go to the search engine directly without being relayed through Mozilla servers. Anything that does hit Mozilla's servers is entirely optional and unrelated to the purpose of satisfying the user's request for search results.
You don't need to speculate about how this could all be due to innocent ordinary operation of a web browser when Mozilla has already disclosed that they're voluntarily tracking users in ways that are not necessary for the operation of a web browser.
I feel like the people who understand Mozilla's true principles have long since moved on by this point, and the crowd of those unaware still use Firefox as a daily driver, for better or worse. That crowd might have just moved to Chrome without Firefox as an option anymore.
Although, as I understand it Firefox and Chrome will be closer to each other in terms of 3rd-party data selling from now on with this ToS change.
Where to?
https://assets.mozilla.net/annualreport/2024/mozilla-fdn-202...
It became all about the authoritarianism of wokeness. They wasted so much money in ridiculous tangents and became extremely partisan and censorious.
It's still the best browser due to extensions and customization but it's sad to see these news making it not that better than chrome when it comes to privacy.
Absolutely. That would have allowed Firefox to fall to better stewardship.
Like sorry, if your selling point is "privacy" then you can't show ads on the new tab page. Debian was onto something when they called this software "IceWeasel".
> selling, renting, releasing, disclosing, disseminating, making available, transferring, or otherwise communicating orally, in writing, or by electronic or other means, a consumer’s personal information
Mozilla doesn't need my personal information at all to set a default search engine.
Under a loose interpretation, which is what they expressed concern about.
This is the kind of clarification we need, the same way we need actual laws so that companies can't play with the definition of "purchase" to refer to what are actually rentals.
THANK YOU California for this definition of selling data, which is accurate, and representative of what people think of when discussions of selling data come up.
> In order to make Firefox commercially viable, there are a number of places where we collect and share some data with our partners
Ok, so that’s pretty straightforward. According to CA and other states Mozilla is collecting and selling your data. Which is exactly what everyone is upset about and means exactly what everyone thought it meant.