And I definitely don't want this:
> You give Mozilla the rights necessary to operate Firefox. This includes processing your data as we describe in the Firefox Privacy Notice. It also includes a nonexclusive, royalty-free, worldwide license for the purpose of doing as you request with the content you input in Firefox. This does not give Mozilla any ownership in that content. [0]
[0] https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/about/legal/terms/firefox/#you...
Why is my browser serving me advertising in the first place? Because Mozilla is an advertising company now.
I don’t use Firefox and this whole thing is distasteful, but I’m not sure how they’re supposed to cover operating expenses without indirect monetization, or what for of indirect other than ads would work.
Speak for yourself.
Give me a browser that clearly and unambiguously does not sell my usage of it in any way, and I will give you a monthly subscription.
There's a third way: screw revenue, dump all staff not related to browser development and documentation (MDN) and look for government grants to fund that.
Especially the EU may be a target for a well-written proposal, given the political atmosphere it would make sense to have at least one browser engine that is not fundamentally tied to the US and its plethora of bullshit like NSLs.
I would, if they offered a payment-only access to Firefox with no added services and no telemetry whatsoever. I'd pay 50€ a year for that.
Is there some interpretation where “for the purpose of doing as you request” means any purpose they want?
I don't want any language where they get to insert themselves into that chain of behavior. Curl doesn't need a TOS, why does Firefox?
When I drill a hole in my wall, DeWalt don't tell anyone who I am, how large a hole it is, what material I drilled into or even the fact that I actually drilled anything. They don't know any of that, and neither should Mozilla know when my local copy of the browser makes a DNS, HTTP or any other request.
Why do you imply that Firefox showing ads is acceptable ?
Because it isn't acceptable.
The first thing I've done (for years now) when configuring Firefox is to turn off many of the defaults. Advertisements, pocket, search engine, online spell checker, translator, blah blah blah.
They're beholden to who gives them money, which is not us.
FF exists off of good will and the search deal. The more people stop using the browser the less they’re going to pull in from the deal.
Yet the second one, which I think would be very much considered close to harmless from my perspective (compared to an alternative of "an ad is shown to everyone across the world"), would, I think, still fit into this metric of your data being sold.
Though maybe I'm misinterpreting what the CCPA's breadth would be.
I have been a bit disillusioned by FF for some time, and would like for them to figure out some version of a business model in order to survive, and so we can know the contours of that business model. Trying to play "we do not do business things at all" with them constantly shipping weird ad-ful features and stuff like Pocket... let's see if we can make this honest!