News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An Update on Mozilla's Terms of Use for Firefox by brookst on Saturday March 01, 2025 @09:15AM (#43219419)
It’s a weird term, but I’m not sure how “for the purpose of doing as you request” is terrible. To me that means that when you type a url, they have the right to do a DNS lookup for it.

Is there some interpretation where “for the purpose of doing as you request” means any purpose they want?

Re:An Update on Mozilla's Terms of Use for Firefox by Wilduck on Saturday March 01, 2025 @10:05AM (#43219927)
The problem is that I'm not requesting Mozilla do anything. Firefox isn't a "service" it's a web browser. When I input a seach query, _I_ am acting on my behalf, not Mozilla.

I don't want any language where they get to insert themselves into that chain of behavior. Curl doesn't need a TOS, why does Firefox?

Re:An Update on Mozilla's Terms of Use for Firefox by skydhash on Saturday March 01, 2025 @11:22AM (#43220818)
Very much this. The browser already have all the features to do what I want it to do. Why does Mozilla insists of being a middleman? It's my computer, Firefox code, and someone's server.
Re:An Update on Mozilla's Terms of Use for Firefox by cassianoleal on Saturday March 01, 2025 @04:53PM (#43224110)
I agree. The very fact that they added a Terms of Service is weird. I don't want Firefox to be a service in any way. It's a tool.

When I drill a hole in my wall, DeWalt don't tell anyone who I am, how large a hole it is, what material I drilled into or even the fact that I actually drilled anything. They don't know any of that, and neither should Mozilla know when my local copy of the browser makes a DNS, HTTP or any other request.

Re:An Update on Mozilla's Terms of Use for Firefox by account42 on Monday March 03, 2025 @11:58AM (#43243832)
And they should use the system DNS services for that, not their own partners.