News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An Update on Mozilla's Terms of Use for Firefox by mmooss on Saturday March 01, 2025 @02:32AM (#43216880)
> According to CA and other states Mozilla is collecting and selling your data.

The definition requires Mozilla to do it "in exchange for “monetary” or “other valuable consideration.”". What consideration is Mozilla receiving and from who?

Re:An Update on Mozilla's Terms of Use for Firefox by thisislife2 on Saturday March 01, 2025 @03:18AM (#43217206)
Personally, any application that even collects personal data is problematic for me. Personal data of a user has a value, and a large repository of personal data, of millions of users, makes the company valuable too. Any data collected can be monetised, if not immediately (as part of the company's business model) or in the future (when the company is sold).

With Mozilla, for example, displaying sponsored links using Firefox Suggest ( https://blog.mozilla.org/en/products/firefox/firefox-news/fi... ) means collecting and sharing personal data (like search keywords, browsing history or bookmarks). This data sharing, with another company, could either be the raw data or the processed data. In either case, it is a problematic issue for any privacy conscious and politically aware user because either party or multiple parties will (or can) create profiles from the data. "Anonymous" data collection doesn't have any meaning here because with enough data points from a particular user, you can reasonably identify a user (either to track them digitally or to even to identify their personhood in real life, for legal or political reasons). This is easier to do so if you also combine it with data from multiple sources. (Which is what the US NSA programs with US BigTech are doing, and why these companies are so valuable today - Data is the new oil).

Re:An Update on Mozilla's Terms of Use for Firefox by mmooss on Saturday March 01, 2025 @03:39AM (#43217322)
I'm not sure you and they agree on the meaning of collect: If you input personal data into Firefox - e.g., an email you type in a Gmail - then they 'collect' it. Unless you use Firefox only for anonymous purposes, some data must pass through Firefox.

> With Mozilla, for example, displaying sponsored links using Firefox Suggest ( https://blog.mozilla.org/en/products/firefox/firefox-news/fi... ) means collecting and sharing personal data (like search keywords, browsing history or bookmarks).

That article says it's only opt-in, so you are safe:

As always, we believe people should be in control of their web experience, so Firefox Suggest will be a customizable feature.

We’ll begin offering smarter contextual suggestions to a percentage of people in the U.S. as an opt-in experience.

Re:An Update on Mozilla's Terms of Use for Firefox by wtallis on Saturday March 01, 2025 @04:03AM (#43217469)
> I'm not sure you and they agree on the meaning of collect: If you input personal data into Firefox - e.g., an email you type in a Gmail - then they 'collect' it.

"They" in this context is Mozilla the organization, not Firefox the process in memory. For Mozilla to collect information, information has to leave my computer and end up on Mozilla's computer.

Re:An Update on Mozilla's Terms of Use for Firefox by lightedman on Saturday March 01, 2025 @09:31AM (#43219549)
"That article says it's only opt-in, so you are safe:"

Funny, I never opt-in to that garbage - and yet Firefox keeps trying to auto-recommend things to me. It does this even in the Firefox Quantum mobile browser.

I don't think Mozilla is being 100% honest.

Re:An Update on Mozilla's Terms of Use for Firefox by mmooss on Sunday March 02, 2025 @04:32AM (#43228824)
> Firefox keeps trying to auto-recommend things to me

If it's what I'm thinking, they do it without data about you ever leaving your computer. Look up how it's done - it's game-changing tech for privacy.

Re:An Update on Mozilla's Terms of Use for Firefox by Rygian on Saturday March 01, 2025 @04:55AM (#43217743)
From their privacy policy [1]:

"we work with partners, service providers, suppliers and contractors"

But they won't disclose which partners and what Mozilla gets in exchange. Which is opaque, and probably intentionally so.

You can scroll down to the types of data and lawful bases they list for these data exchanges.

[1] https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/privacy/firefox/#how-is-your-d...